Sex, Genes and Sequence
Sex chromosomes – most interesting part of genome
Origins, evolution, future of X and Y
Epigenetics and environmental sex
Origins, evolution of sex genes
Jenny Graves
LA Trobe University, ANU, U Canberra
Sex chromosomes are weird
X
1669 genes
Many different functions
Many sex, intelligence genes
Brains-and-balls genes
Y
Only 27 genes specific to Y
Many copies, pseudogenes
Male-specific functions
Sex and spermatogenesis
PAR
Shared by X and Y
Contains 24 genes
Smart,
Sexy X
Wimpy Y
• Problems at meiosis
• Dosage problems
• Sex-linked diseases
• Sex-reversal syndromes
Why so weird?
• so they work optimally?
• evolutionary accident?
XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX
X Y
Dumb
Sex chromosomes –> trouble
• the Y self-destructs!
X Y
proto-XY
XY evolution
Once the X and Y were an ordinary pair
One partner acquires a male-determining gene
Other male-advantage genes accumulate
- recombination suppressed
Y degraded by deletion, mutation
And degraded and degraded
And can even disappear
The Y is a degraded X
Evidence: XY homology; independent Y dropouts
Self-destruction of the Y
High variation
• frequent mutation, deletion, insertion
in testis
Inefficient selection and drift
• no recombination, no repair
Rate of loss is ~10 genes/MY
Y will self-destruct in 4.6 mY
How the Y chromosome determines sex
female male
X X X Y
TDF
testis
hormones
=SRY
Y genes are degraded X genes
TSPY
Spermatogenesis?
RBMY
Spermatogenesis
Y
SRY
Sex determination
RBMX
Mental retardation?
X
SOX3
Mental retardation
spermatogenesis
TSPX
Cell cycle?
Most Y genes have copies on X
Brains-and-balls genes –> sex and fertility genes
X-Y shared dosage-sensitive genes in added region
Mammals
Fish
450
Tetrapods
Amphibians
410
Monotremes
166
Amniotes
Birds and
Reptiles
310
Placental
mammals
Marsupials
148
Vertebrate relationships
Human
mice
105
Mammals
Amniotes
Tetrapods
Fish
Amphibians
Reptiles and birds Monotremes Marsupials Placentals
450
410
310
166
148
XY
Origin of human sex chromosomes
Human
Mouse
105
X
?
Elephant
???
Mammals
Y
X
Origin of human XY
Elephant
XX
A
Kangaroo Human
Map orthologues
of human X genes
Y
Chicken Platypus Kangaroo Elephant Human
X64
1q
A
X
A
X
Origin of human XY
Male Female
Z Z Z W
Bird sex
W is a degraded Z
Chicken
Emu
XY and ZW chromosomes
follow the same evolutionary rules
X Y W Z
humans
mice
kangaroos
ratite birds
carinate birds
male female
Z Z Z W
What is the bird sex-determining gene?
No SRY
Dose-dependent sex determination
DMRT1 on Z but not W
Need two doses to make enough male-determining product
Knockdown –> ZZ female
Platypus sex chromosomes
X1 Y1 X2 Y2 X3 Y3 X4 Y4 X5 Y5
Female: 26 pairsMale: 21 pairs + 10
Homology to chick ZW
No homology to human XY
No SRY
AMH Sex determining?
Mammals
Amniotes
Tetrapods
Fish
Amphibians
Reptiles and birds Monotremes Marsupials Placentals
450
410
310
166
148
XYXYTSD,XY,ZW
XY ZW
XYXYXYXYXY
Origin of human sex chromosomes
ZW?
SRY
XY and ZW chromosomes
follow the same evolutionary rules
X Y W Z
humans
mice
kangaroos
ratite birds
carinate birds
boid snakes
colubrid snakes
vipers
Snake sex chromosomes
Vicoso et al, PLoS Biol 2013
Coverage for male ZZ (blue) and female ZW (red)
Assembled against Anolis macrochromosomes 1-6
Conserved Z
Boids show no ZW differentiation
Colubrids and viperids show extreme ZW differentiation
Snakes are ZZ male / ZW female
Snake Z = chicken 2
SOX3
4
2
5
TSD turtle Birds Platypus Kangaroo HumanSnakes
1
DMRT1
SOX3
4
ZW
2
1
DMRT1
SOX3
SRY
X Y
4
3,7,10
SOX3
SRY
X Y
5
1
3
SOX3
6
15, 18
DMRT1
X Y X Y X Y X Y X Y
?
DMRT1
SOX3
4
2
ZW
1
Different genome regions became sex
chromosomes in different vertebrates
Sex in frogs
Yoshimoto & Ito, FEBS J 2011
Conclude DMW inhibits DMRT1
2 DMRT1 –> male
2 DMRT1 + DMW –> female
DMW defines new W
Xenopus laevis has ZZ / ZW
Found DMRT1 homologue on W
DMW knockdown –> ZW males
ZW=XY=human Xq
SOX3 is sex determining
Rana rugosa has ZZ / ZW and XY / XX
Miura et al 2010
Sex in Fish
Linkage analysis –> chr 1=XY
Y Positional cloning –>DMRT1 copy
XX female XX+DMY male XY male
Transgenic DMY –> XX male
Matsuda et al, Nature 2002; PNAS 2007
soma testis
Conclude:
2 DMRT1 female
2 DMRT1 + DMY male
DMY defines a new Y
Medaka Oryzias latipes
MALE FEMALE
Z Z
X Y
Z Z
Z W
X X
Z W
A A
A A
A A
A A
Neo-Y
Neo-W
Origin of new sex genes?
from copy
from inactive copy
Sex in other medaka species
O. latipes LG1 DMY
O. curvinotos LG1 DMY
=> Change in expression level or timing
O. dancera LG10 ?
Oda (XY=LG10)
Sox3 on X, Y –> same protein
Overexpression of Sox3 –>male
Olu ( XY=LG12)
Gsdf on X, Y–>same protein
Overexpression of GsdfY –>male
O. luzonensis LG12 ?
Ope (XY=LG12)
Gsdf on X, Y–>same protein
Early expression of GsdfbY –>male
O. pectoralis LG12 ?
A A
A A
X Y
X Y
A A
A A
Z W
Z W
Overexpression of one allele
MALE FEMALE
testis ovary
New sex genes from expression change
testis ovary
Change in timing or tissue of expression
Ectopic expression in testis
–>XX males
SOX3
active in brain, germ-cells
Evolution of SRY
Fusion
expression in gonad
SRY
testis determination
New function
Sato et al Mol Cell Biol 2010; Sutton et al J Clin Invest 2011
Mammals
Amniotes
Tetrapods
Fish
Amphibians
Reptiles and birds Monotremes Marsupials Placentals
450
410
310
166
148
XYXYTSD,XY,ZW
XY ZW
XYXYXYXYXY
Independent recruitment of sex genes
M
Y
DMY
O. latipes
DMW
X. laevis
DMRT1
birds
SRY
SOX3
SOX3
R. rugosa
SOX3
O. dancera
AMH
sea bass
AMH?
DMRT1
tongue sole
Mammals
Temperature Sex Determination - TSD
e.g. Crocodiles and marine turtles
No sex chromosomes
Chick Z
6
6
Dragon lizard Pogona vitticeps
%males
Temperature –>
50
0
GSD TSD
Identification of ZW by CGH
W
Quinn et al
Science ‘07
A dragon with ZW and TSD
GSD–> TSD
ZW –> XY
male female
Z Z Z W
Normal
temperature
female female
Z Z Z W
High
temperature
Sex in dragons
Finding dragon sex determining gene….
dose-dependent
and temperature
-dependent
Microdissected W, screened for W BACs
Sequenced W BAC –> RCC1, OPRD1, syntenic with RSPO1…
Sequenced ZZ male, ZW female, ZZ female at BGI
ZZ ZW ZW
male female pseudomale
dmrt1 dmrt1 dmrt1
Epigenetic sex determination
Half smooth tongue sole
Chen et al Nature, Shao et al Genome Res
AUTOSOMES SEX CHROMOSOMES
methylation
Conclusions
Vertebrate genome is very conserved
Different genome regions became sex chromosomes
New sex genes evolve, often from same autosomal gene
Sex chromosomes specialize, then self-destruct
Sex can be determined or modified by environment

Jenny Graves at SMBE2014: Sex, Genes and Sequence

  • 1.
    Sex, Genes andSequence Sex chromosomes – most interesting part of genome Origins, evolution, future of X and Y Epigenetics and environmental sex Origins, evolution of sex genes Jenny Graves LA Trobe University, ANU, U Canberra
  • 2.
    Sex chromosomes areweird X 1669 genes Many different functions Many sex, intelligence genes Brains-and-balls genes Y Only 27 genes specific to Y Many copies, pseudogenes Male-specific functions Sex and spermatogenesis PAR Shared by X and Y Contains 24 genes Smart, Sexy X Wimpy Y
  • 3.
    • Problems atmeiosis • Dosage problems • Sex-linked diseases • Sex-reversal syndromes Why so weird? • so they work optimally? • evolutionary accident? XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX X Y Dumb Sex chromosomes –> trouble • the Y self-destructs!
  • 4.
    X Y proto-XY XY evolution Oncethe X and Y were an ordinary pair One partner acquires a male-determining gene Other male-advantage genes accumulate - recombination suppressed Y degraded by deletion, mutation And degraded and degraded And can even disappear The Y is a degraded X Evidence: XY homology; independent Y dropouts
  • 5.
    Self-destruction of theY High variation • frequent mutation, deletion, insertion in testis Inefficient selection and drift • no recombination, no repair Rate of loss is ~10 genes/MY Y will self-destruct in 4.6 mY
  • 6.
    How the Ychromosome determines sex female male X X X Y TDF testis hormones =SRY
  • 7.
    Y genes aredegraded X genes TSPY Spermatogenesis? RBMY Spermatogenesis Y SRY Sex determination RBMX Mental retardation? X SOX3 Mental retardation spermatogenesis TSPX Cell cycle? Most Y genes have copies on X Brains-and-balls genes –> sex and fertility genes X-Y shared dosage-sensitive genes in added region
  • 8.
  • 9.
    Mammals Amniotes Tetrapods Fish Amphibians Reptiles and birdsMonotremes Marsupials Placentals 450 410 310 166 148 XY Origin of human sex chromosomes Human Mouse 105 X ? Elephant ??? Mammals
  • 10.
    Y X Origin of humanXY Elephant XX A Kangaroo Human Map orthologues of human X genes
  • 11.
    Y Chicken Platypus KangarooElephant Human X64 1q A X A X Origin of human XY
  • 12.
    Male Female Z ZZ W Bird sex W is a degraded Z Chicken Emu
  • 13.
    XY and ZWchromosomes follow the same evolutionary rules X Y W Z humans mice kangaroos ratite birds carinate birds
  • 14.
    male female Z ZZ W What is the bird sex-determining gene? No SRY Dose-dependent sex determination DMRT1 on Z but not W Need two doses to make enough male-determining product Knockdown –> ZZ female
  • 15.
    Platypus sex chromosomes X1Y1 X2 Y2 X3 Y3 X4 Y4 X5 Y5 Female: 26 pairsMale: 21 pairs + 10 Homology to chick ZW No homology to human XY No SRY AMH Sex determining?
  • 16.
    Mammals Amniotes Tetrapods Fish Amphibians Reptiles and birdsMonotremes Marsupials Placentals 450 410 310 166 148 XYXYTSD,XY,ZW XY ZW XYXYXYXYXY Origin of human sex chromosomes ZW? SRY
  • 17.
    XY and ZWchromosomes follow the same evolutionary rules X Y W Z humans mice kangaroos ratite birds carinate birds boid snakes colubrid snakes vipers
  • 18.
    Snake sex chromosomes Vicosoet al, PLoS Biol 2013 Coverage for male ZZ (blue) and female ZW (red) Assembled against Anolis macrochromosomes 1-6 Conserved Z Boids show no ZW differentiation Colubrids and viperids show extreme ZW differentiation Snakes are ZZ male / ZW female Snake Z = chicken 2
  • 19.
    SOX3 4 2 5 TSD turtle BirdsPlatypus Kangaroo HumanSnakes 1 DMRT1 SOX3 4 ZW 2 1 DMRT1 SOX3 SRY X Y 4 3,7,10 SOX3 SRY X Y 5 1 3 SOX3 6 15, 18 DMRT1 X Y X Y X Y X Y X Y ? DMRT1 SOX3 4 2 ZW 1 Different genome regions became sex chromosomes in different vertebrates
  • 20.
    Sex in frogs Yoshimoto& Ito, FEBS J 2011 Conclude DMW inhibits DMRT1 2 DMRT1 –> male 2 DMRT1 + DMW –> female DMW defines new W Xenopus laevis has ZZ / ZW Found DMRT1 homologue on W DMW knockdown –> ZW males ZW=XY=human Xq SOX3 is sex determining Rana rugosa has ZZ / ZW and XY / XX Miura et al 2010
  • 21.
    Sex in Fish Linkageanalysis –> chr 1=XY Y Positional cloning –>DMRT1 copy XX female XX+DMY male XY male Transgenic DMY –> XX male Matsuda et al, Nature 2002; PNAS 2007 soma testis Conclude: 2 DMRT1 female 2 DMRT1 + DMY male DMY defines a new Y Medaka Oryzias latipes
  • 22.
    MALE FEMALE Z Z XY Z Z Z W X X Z W A A A A A A A A Neo-Y Neo-W Origin of new sex genes? from copy from inactive copy
  • 23.
    Sex in othermedaka species O. latipes LG1 DMY O. curvinotos LG1 DMY => Change in expression level or timing O. dancera LG10 ? Oda (XY=LG10) Sox3 on X, Y –> same protein Overexpression of Sox3 –>male Olu ( XY=LG12) Gsdf on X, Y–>same protein Overexpression of GsdfY –>male O. luzonensis LG12 ? Ope (XY=LG12) Gsdf on X, Y–>same protein Early expression of GsdfbY –>male O. pectoralis LG12 ?
  • 24.
    A A A A XY X Y A A A A Z W Z W Overexpression of one allele MALE FEMALE testis ovary New sex genes from expression change testis ovary Change in timing or tissue of expression
  • 25.
    Ectopic expression intestis –>XX males SOX3 active in brain, germ-cells Evolution of SRY Fusion expression in gonad SRY testis determination New function Sato et al Mol Cell Biol 2010; Sutton et al J Clin Invest 2011
  • 26.
    Mammals Amniotes Tetrapods Fish Amphibians Reptiles and birdsMonotremes Marsupials Placentals 450 410 310 166 148 XYXYTSD,XY,ZW XY ZW XYXYXYXYXY Independent recruitment of sex genes M Y DMY O. latipes DMW X. laevis DMRT1 birds SRY SOX3 SOX3 R. rugosa SOX3 O. dancera AMH sea bass AMH? DMRT1 tongue sole Mammals
  • 27.
    Temperature Sex Determination- TSD e.g. Crocodiles and marine turtles No sex chromosomes Chick Z 6 6
  • 28.
    Dragon lizard Pogonavitticeps %males Temperature –> 50 0 GSD TSD Identification of ZW by CGH W Quinn et al Science ‘07 A dragon with ZW and TSD GSD–> TSD ZW –> XY
  • 29.
    male female Z ZZ W Normal temperature female female Z Z Z W High temperature Sex in dragons Finding dragon sex determining gene…. dose-dependent and temperature -dependent Microdissected W, screened for W BACs Sequenced W BAC –> RCC1, OPRD1, syntenic with RSPO1… Sequenced ZZ male, ZW female, ZZ female at BGI
  • 30.
    ZZ ZW ZW malefemale pseudomale dmrt1 dmrt1 dmrt1 Epigenetic sex determination Half smooth tongue sole Chen et al Nature, Shao et al Genome Res AUTOSOMES SEX CHROMOSOMES methylation
  • 31.
    Conclusions Vertebrate genome isvery conserved Different genome regions became sex chromosomes New sex genes evolve, often from same autosomal gene Sex chromosomes specialize, then self-destruct Sex can be determined or modified by environment