Man Haron Monis' violent siege in Sydney raises questions about how a person with his criminal history was released on bail and able to carry out the attack. While his actions were driven by delusion and narcissism, they still meet the definition of terrorism. The Islamic State has actively encouraged "lone wolf" attacks in Western countries by troubled, alienated individuals. They view damaged people as weapons to enact violence without being formally connected or following orders. This poses challenges for detection without established patterns of terrorist planning and networks. Increased community engagement and intelligence sharing between security agencies will be important to address the threat of future lone wolf attacks.

1. 3/01/2015 11:08 pmDamaged goods as weapons | The Monthly
Page 1 of 6http://www.themonthly.com.au/blog/greg-barton/2014/22/2014/1419202929/damaged-goods-weapons
Damaged goods as weapons
To those mourning the loss of a loved one, a friend or colleague, determining whether the
callous violence of Man Haron Monis was an act of terrorism or merely the all-too-familiar
crime of murder-suicide can bring little solace.
Unfortunately, at times during this past week the terrorism question appeared to be cast in
terms of a classic left–right divide. This question is too important to be occluded by petty
politics. If we are to do our best to reduce the likelihood of such incidents re-occurring, we
need to grapple with the question of who Monis was and what the motivations behind his
actions were.
The matter of why Monis was released on bail after being charged with a number of violent
offences, including as an accessory to the murder of his ex-wife, Noleen Hayson Pal, is one
of the most troubling questions arising from this tragedy. It is made all the more poignant
by the fact that Pal had told police that Monis had threatened to kill her and she was in fear
of her life. Police took this threat seriously enough to lay charges of intimidation but he
challenged this and in May 2012 was acquitted.
Monis had also been charged with more than 40 cases of sexual assault against women

2. 3/01/2015 11:08 pmDamaged goods as weapons | The Monthly
Page 2 of 6http://www.themonthly.com.au/blog/greg-barton/2014/22/2014/1419202929/damaged-goods-weapons
who had come to his “spiritual healing clinic”.
The victims of Monis’ abusive behaviour were not limited, however, to those who walked
through his door, seeking help. In September 2013, he was convicted on 12 counts of
misusing the postal service to cause offence after sending abusive letters between 2007
and 2009 to the grieving families of soldiers who had fought and died in Afghanistan. After
his conviction, he chained himself to the railing on the steps outside the court and
proclaimed: “This pen is my gun and these words are my bullets, I fight by these weapons
against oppression to promote peace.”
The Friday before Monday’s siege, Monis had lost a High Court appeal to overturn that
conviction.
For years, Monis had terrorised in the name of justice while seeking to present himself as a
freedom fighter and peace activist. He had a long history of extremist religious views and
strong political opinions expressed in a way intended to offend, to hurt and to draw
attention to himself. At times, he championed the Shia group Hezbollah and once
registered the business phone number “1300-4-JIHAD”. One of his first actions on
Monday after ordering the cafe doors be locked was to force his hostages at gunpoint to
hold a black banner in the front window of the Lindt cafe. The words on the banner were
simply the Muslim creed of faith, but the colour and style of the banner were intended to
imply a link with Jihadi terrorist groups, and in particular with the Islamic State (IS)
movement. Any ambiguity about this disappeared when he demanded, through frightened
hostages forced to make phone calls to multiple media outlets, that he be brought an IS
flag (with the same words but distinctive calligraphy), and that the prime minister
acknowledge he was conducting the siege in the name of IS.
The man who for years had hubristically, and, it appears, completely without foundation,
described himself as an Islamic cleric had only days before the siege proclaimed on his
website, since taken down, that he had turned his back on his Iranian Shia heritage (“I
used to be a Rafidi [one who rejects], but not any more. Now I am a Muslim, Alhamdu
Lillah”) and had embraced both Sunni Islam and the Islamic State, swearing allegiance to
the latter’s leader Abu Bakr al-Baghdadi.
Almost all of Monis’ actions can be explained in terms of delusion, anger and narcissism.

3. 3/01/2015 11:08 pmDamaged goods as weapons | The Monthly
Page 3 of 6http://www.themonthly.com.au/blog/greg-barton/2014/22/2014/1419202929/damaged-goods-weapons
Just as in the case of Norwegian far-right lone wolf Anders Behring Breivik who in 2011
killed eight people, this does not mean that Man Haron Monis was not a terrorist.
Since September, IS has been calling on thousands of followers in countries all around the
world, including Australia, to, in effect “attack the Crusaders whatever you are with
whatever you have”. The first official statement came on 21 September, when in a
rambling but evocative audio message IS spokesman Sheik al-Adnani declared:
If you can kill a disbelieving American or European – especially the spiteful and
filthy French – or an Australian, or a Canadian, or any other disbeliever from the
disbelievers waging war, including the citizens of the countries that entered into a
coalition against the Islamic State, then rely upon Allah, and kill him in any
manner or way however it may be. Do not ask for anyone's advice and do not seek
anyone's verdict . . . If you are not able to find an IED or a bullet, then single out
the disbelieving American, Frenchman, or any of their allies. Smash his head with
a rock, or slaughter him with a knife, or run him over with your car, or throw him
down from a high place, or choke him, or poison him.
In mid October the fourth issue of the official IS magazine, Dabiq, repeated this call for
lone wolf attacks in the west:
Every Muslim should get out of his house, find a crusader, and kill him. It is
important that the killing becomes attributed to patrons of the Islamic State who
have obeyed its leadership. This can easily be done with anonymity. Otherwise,
crusader media makes such attacks appear to be random killings. Secrecy should
be followed when planning and executing any attack. The smaller the numbers of
those involved and the less the discussion beforehand, the more likely it will be
carried out without problems. One should not complicate the attacks by involving
other parties, purchasing complex materials, or communicating with weak-hearted
individuals.
IS represents one of the most dangerous manifestations yet of jihadi terrorism. This latest
iteration of a movement that has been evolving for more than three decades differs from
al-Qaeda and other affiliates that pre-date it: it is indiscriminate in its recruitment.
Whereas al-Qaeda and most modern terrorist movements have been discerning about

4. 3/01/2015 11:08 pmDamaged goods as weapons | The Monthly
Page 4 of 6http://www.themonthly.com.au/blog/greg-barton/2014/22/2014/1419202929/damaged-goods-weapons
those allowed into their inner circles, and committed to rigorous, lengthy programs of
indoctrination, training and filtering, IS has put the word out among those crossing the
Turkish border into Syria that it will take all-comers. As a result, its ranks have swollen to
more than 15,000 foreign fighters. At the same time, IS is actively seeking out the lost,
lonely and vulnerable, those who might be dismissed as “damaged goods”.
Seasoned al-Qaeda fighters and radicalised former Iraqi officers are holding captive eight
million people in a territory the size of Great Britain. Within this disciplined leadership
elite, one of the nine ministries that governs IS’s day-to-day operations is its media
council. This body produces slick, professionally edited videos and powerful online
publications through which it has been calling for lone wolf attacks around the world. IS
also has a very long tail of foreign fighters and an international network of recruiters and
supporters, most of whom are neither experienced nor professional but are encouraged to
contribute through their own social media postings, and their own acts of terror.
To young men it wants to recruit as fighters or to the others it hopes to persuade to act in
its name, the message is the same: the world has looked down on you and rejected you and
people say that you amount to nothing. But join us and you will be a hero.
We’ve seen this redemptive narrative at work in the example of Mohammad Ali Baryalei,
the former Kings Cross sex club spruiker, and the other young Australians he recruited to
fight in Syria and Iraq. Islamic States’ call for lone-wolf attacks also appears to be what
drove Abdul Numan Haider to violently confront two police officers in the car park outside
Endeavour Hills Police Station on 23 September 2014, the day after Islamic State’s
spokesperson Sheikh Abu Mohammad al-Adnani had issued the first of IS’s many calls to
action.
The IS call to action also seems to be behind the actions of Martin Couture-Rouleau, who
on 20 October lined up his car in a Quebec parking lot and ran down two uniformed
soldiers, killing Warrant Officer Patrice Vincent. Similarly, the actions of Michael Zehaf-
Bibeau in Ottawa two days later, when he shot dead Corporal Nathan Cirillo, a ceremonial
guard on duty at the war memorial, and then attempted to storm Canada’s parliament
seem to be linked to this call to arms. And it seems likely that Zale Thompson in New York,
who attacked four police officers with a hatchet on 23 October, was responding to the same
message. All three attackers were troubled individuals, angry and alienated, who appear to

5. 3/01/2015 11:08 pmDamaged goods as weapons | The Monthly
Page 5 of 6http://www.themonthly.com.au/blog/greg-barton/2014/22/2014/1419202929/damaged-goods-weapons
have found larger purpose in responding to the call of IS.
The bad news keeps on coming and some sort of pattern is emerging. Saturday’s attack in
the French central town of Joue-les-Tours appears to be an IS-inspired lone wolf attack.
Burundi-born French national, 28-year-old Bertrand Nzohabonayo, a convert to Islam
who had posted an IS flag on his Facebook page, was shot dead after attacking two
officers at a police station with a knife, slashing the face of one. Much less clear, however,
are the causes of Sunday’s attack in the eastern French city of Dijon, where a psychiatric
patient drove his small hatchback into a group of pedestrians, injuring 11. What does seem
clear is that the fatal shooting of two NYPD officers sitting in their patrol car in Brooklyn
was not an attack of Islamist terrorism. Posting on Instagram, the shooter,
Ismaaiyl Brinsley, 28, claimed to be avenging the wrongful deaths of African Americans at
the hands of police.
It would appear that Monis was pushed down the levels of an ASIO’s terrorism risk-
assessment matrix because he was unconnected and without broad influence: a deranged
loner not plugged in to any of the known networks. The rapid evolution of IS and its recent
incitement to lone-wolf attacks are forcing us to think differently. It is now clear that IS is
targeting disgruntled loners in its call for action. Unlike most previous terrorist groups, it
is not fussed about filtering out troubled and unstable individuals for its attacks in the
west. It does not need them to follow orders – so long as when they act on their own they
act in the name of IS. In fact, IS is in the business of turning “damaged goods” into
weapons. Sadly, there are no easy ways to meet the threat of lone-wolf terrorism. Without
the conventional patterns of chatter between cell members and within terror networks,
and of long months of preparation, the chances of early detection are greatly reduced.
So what can we do? Firstly, we need to understand the nature of the threat and recognise
that attacks like those seen in Sydney are likely to be repeated. Secondly, we need to
redouble our efforts to work with the communities and groups best positioned to be aware
of individuals who represent a threat and/or are in danger of being radicalised. Haider was
just one of around 70 young men whose passports had been withheld, many at the request
of their families. We need to work with every one of these individuals, with their families,
with community groups, and with those who have returned from fighting abroad, and with
everyone else whose homes have been raided or otherwise cross the path of the authorities.
Such case management interventions might not have stopped last week’s attack but they

6. 3/01/2015 11:08 pmDamaged goods as weapons | The Monthly
Page 6 of 6http://www.themonthly.com.au/blog/greg-barton/2014/22/2014/1419202929/damaged-goods-weapons
could stop future ones.
More than ever we need to work to ensure that interagency co-operation and timely
sharing of intelligence between ASIO, the Australia Federal Police and state police forces is
supported and nurtured at every level. Suddenly, it’s just become a whole lot harder.