CO-CREATION’S
                      5 GUIDING
                      PRINCIPLES

FRONTEER
STRATEGY
INNOVATION.
CO-CREATION.
BRAND DEVELOPMENT.
A White Paper by
       Martijn Pater, Fronteer Strategy

       Amsterdam, May 2009




FRONTEER
STRATEGY
INNOVATION.
CO-CREATION.
BRAND DEVELOPMENT.
Co-creation’s
             5 Guiding Principles

OR .... WHAT IS SUCCESSFUL CO-CREATION MADE OF?


In this white paper, we identify different types of co-creation
 (suitable for different types of challenges), present 5 guiding
  principles for success, discuss the value of co-creation and
  present a number of inspiring cases from around the world.



                               3
Co-creation -
                      what is it?




FRONTEER
STRATEGY
INNOVATION.
CO-CREATION.
BRAND DEVELOPMENT.         4
We define co-creation as the
 practice of collaborative product
or service development: developers
and stake-holders working together.




                 5
Co-creation -
                     where does it come from?




FRONTEER
STRATEGY
INNOVATION.
CO-CREATION.
BRAND DEVELOPMENT.              6
Customers want more
                                                 involvement with their products




     Traditional business
processes have changed




                              An enormous
                                 amount of
                            knowledge has
                                   become
                                accessible       Co-creation is part of the
                                                 Open Innovation trends
                                                  going on since the 50‘s

  FRONTEER
  STRATEGY
  INNOVATION.
  CO-CREATION.
  BRAND DEVELOPMENT.                         7
Because of these trends,
                         companies face
                      challenging questions




FRONTEER
STRATEGY
INNOVATION.
CO-CREATION.
BRAND DEVELOPMENT.              8
How to innovate
                                                                                 from the core?




                                How to get - or stay -
                          connected with customers?


How should I deal with the risk of
commoditisation?



                                                             Where can I find
                                                             future growth?




     FRONTEER
     STRATEGY
     INNOVATION.
     CO-CREATION.
     BRAND DEVELOPMENT.                                  9
But markets change and
                        new rules apply...




FRONTEER
STRATEGY
INNOVATION.
CO-CREATION.
BRAND DEVELOPMENT.             10
99,995% of the people
                                      don’t work at your
                                          company...

                                    They might have some
                                       good ideas...

                                    Why not capture them?




But opening up can be scary
- most companies hesitate to
  share ideas and strategies


                               11
Co-creation -
                     how does it work?




FRONTEER
STRATEGY
INNOVATION.
CO-CREATION.
BRAND DEVELOPMENT.           12
There is always 1 initiator
 - either company or just a
single person - that decides
    to start the initiative




                                       Contributors will be joining
                                        along the process, but the
                                      initiator determines who can
                                    join and under what conditions
 FRONTEER
 STRATEGY
 INNOVATION.
 CO-CREATION.
 BRAND DEVELOPMENT.            13
1% Creators

                                                             10% Synthesisers
   If you open up, keep in
      mind the ‘1% rule’
                                            100% Consumers




                                    Only 1% of people in any
                                    community generates the
                                  majority of the creative output

FRONTEER
STRATEGY
INNOVATION.
CO-CREATION.
BRAND DEVELOPMENT.           14
Co-creation is more than a
tool, it’s a program of change
           It can be used to...




                                       ... tackle your toughest strategic challenges
                                       ... get a fresh perspective on your business
                                       ... develop breakthrough new ideas
                                       ... unlock the world outside and bring it inside
                                       ... connect with partners, customers, consumers
                                       ... bring excitement to the floor

  FRONTEER
                                       ... work with the 1% most creative people
  STRATEGY
  INNOVATION.
  CO-CREATION.
  BRAND DEVELOPMENT.              15
4 Types of Co-creation
                         There are many ways to go about
                     Co-creation, and which to choose depends
                      on the challenge and objectives at hand.




FRONTEER
STRATEGY
INNOVATION.
CO-CREATION.
BRAND DEVELOPMENT.                      16
The 4 types of co-creation
are based on 2 dimensions:




                                         Ownership
                                   who owns the challenge &
                                        the outcome?

                                          Openness
                                   who can join the challenge?
  FRONTEER
  STRATEGY
  INNOVATION.
  CO-CREATION.
  BRAND DEVELOPMENT.          17
The 4 types of co-creation


        Anyone              Crowd of                     Community of
        can join             People                      Kindred Spirits

Open-               Crowd of people
ness


        Selection            Club of                       Coalition of
         process             Experts                         Parties



                            Initiator                    Initiator + Contributors

                                             Ownership
                                        18
Crowd of people
For any give challenge there
might be a person ‘out there’
     with a brilliant idea




                                     Threadless enables contributors to send in and
                                       rate t-shirt designs. Profits on sold items are
                                       shared with the designer. Not bad: a full 30%
                                      profit margin selling t-shirts with no R&D cost,
                                       low investments and hardly any employees.




                                19
Community of kindred spirits
                                                   People or groups with a similar
                                                   goal develop something for the
                                                           ‘greater good’




The Linux open source operating system
 software was developed by users and for
users. The software code is free to use and
  owned by nobody. It started with one
   simple e-mail with a request for help.




                                              20
Nokia organises ‘lead user’ and
                                     ‘expert’ co-creation sessions to
                                     develop visionary new products
                                               and services.




      Club of experts
 For specific, time-pressured
challenges when expertise and
breakthrough ideas are needed


                                21
Heineken has successfully developed
 the ‘Beertender’ in co-operation with
Krups. A development period of 10 years
   resulted in the first true packaging
    innovation in beer in a long time.




                                                   Coalition of parties
                                                In certain complex situations
                                               parties with specific skills team
                                                up to share knowledge, ideas
                                                       and investments

                                          22
5 Guiding Principles of
                             Co-creation
                     Successful co-creation initiatives tend to have
                        a number of characteristics in common.




FRONTEER
STRATEGY
INNOVATION.
CO-CREATION.
BRAND DEVELOPMENT.                         23
5 Guiding Principles of Co-creation




                 24
5 Guiding Principles of Co-creation




      Inspire
      participation



                      24
5 Guiding Principles of Co-creation




         Select the very best

      Inspire
      participation



                            24
5 Guiding Principles of Co-creation




             Connect creative minds


         Select the very best

      Inspire
      participation



                            24
5 Guiding Principles of Co-creation



                      Share results


             Connect creative minds


         Select the very best

      Inspire
      participation



                              24
5 Guiding Principles of Co-creation

                              Continue development


                      Share results


             Connect creative minds


         Select the very best

      Inspire
      participation



                              24
Inspire participation
Trigger people to join your
        challenge




                                   Alessi has been inspiring designers
                                   for many years to contribute to the
                                   Alessi brand, in return for exposure
                                            and shared gains.


FRONTEER
STRATEGY
INNOVATION.
CO-CREATION.
BRAND DEVELOPMENT.            25
Select the very best
Find the best ideas and the
        best people




                                    Innocentive is a platform where scientists and
                                       other experts are gathered to solve tough
                                       scientific challenges. Their track record is
                                   impressive: 30% of all problems posed are solved


 FRONTEER
 STRATEGY
 INNOVATION.
 CO-CREATION.
 BRAND DEVELOPMENT.           26
Connect creative minds
 Enable people to work
 together and find that
        ‘spark’




                               Lego developed new generation Mindstorms
                                 products together with lead users of the
                                Mindstorms Developer Program. They have
                              helped Lego improving their product ranges far
                                      beyond Lego’s wildest dreams.




                         27
Share results
 ‘Giving back’ is crucial*




                                           Co-creation was part of many of Apples
                                         successes and also drives the Apple iPhone
                                          App store success. The profits are shared,
                                           70% is for the developer, 30% for Apple.


FRONTEER
STRATEGY
INNOVATION.
CO-CREATION.
BRAND DEVELOPMENT.             28   *Compensation doesn’t have to be monetary, sharing IP is a next step
Continue development
Co-creation only delivers
when it is a longer-term
      engagement




                                    Procter & Gamble set high co-creation
                                 standards: 50% of new products should come
                                 from outside the company. P&G’s Connect &
                                   Develop platform invites external people &
                                       companies to innovate with them.




                            29
4 Areas of Value
                     Return on investments in co-creation
                        can be found in several areas.




FRONTEER
STRATEGY
INNOVATION.
CO-CREATION.
BRAND DEVELOPMENT.                    30
4 Areas of Value in Co-creation
  Generated Value




                                                                    s
                                                               n off
                                                           pi
                                                    r   eS
                                                   u
                                            F   ut
                                        s
                                  n off
                              pi
                           tS                                  Resul
                                                                    ts
                      r  ec                               ture
                    Di                                 Fu
                            R      esults
                    D irect

                                                  Time


                                                   31
Direct results correspond with the
                                                  project goals that have been set: often
                                                    new products and services, which
                                                        generate economic value




 Direct spinoffs cannot be measured in
terms of profit, but create enormous value.
  Unexpected effects can occur like new
    contacts, collaborations and brand
               ambassadors.




                                             32
A successful new product introduction
                                                can generate a snowball effect within a
                                                  category, creating future results




      Future spin-off effects are
 unpredictable. Side-effects of certain
 actions are hard to oversee, but  what
we can say is that action taken now will
 have an effect sometime in the future.




                                           33
FRONTEER                           martijn@fronteerstrategy.com
STRATEGY
I N N OVAT I O N.
C O - C R E AT I O N.
B R A N D D E V E L O P M E N T.

Fronteer Strategy - Co-creation's 5 Guiding Principles

  • 1.
    CO-CREATION’S 5 GUIDING PRINCIPLES FRONTEER STRATEGY INNOVATION. CO-CREATION. BRAND DEVELOPMENT.
  • 2.
    A White Paperby Martijn Pater, Fronteer Strategy Amsterdam, May 2009 FRONTEER STRATEGY INNOVATION. CO-CREATION. BRAND DEVELOPMENT.
  • 3.
    Co-creation’s 5 Guiding Principles OR .... WHAT IS SUCCESSFUL CO-CREATION MADE OF? In this white paper, we identify different types of co-creation (suitable for different types of challenges), present 5 guiding principles for success, discuss the value of co-creation and present a number of inspiring cases from around the world. 3
  • 4.
    Co-creation - what is it? FRONTEER STRATEGY INNOVATION. CO-CREATION. BRAND DEVELOPMENT. 4
  • 5.
    We define co-creationas the practice of collaborative product or service development: developers and stake-holders working together. 5
  • 6.
    Co-creation - where does it come from? FRONTEER STRATEGY INNOVATION. CO-CREATION. BRAND DEVELOPMENT. 6
  • 7.
    Customers want more involvement with their products Traditional business processes have changed An enormous amount of knowledge has become accessible Co-creation is part of the Open Innovation trends going on since the 50‘s FRONTEER STRATEGY INNOVATION. CO-CREATION. BRAND DEVELOPMENT. 7
  • 8.
    Because of thesetrends, companies face challenging questions FRONTEER STRATEGY INNOVATION. CO-CREATION. BRAND DEVELOPMENT. 8
  • 9.
    How to innovate from the core? How to get - or stay - connected with customers? How should I deal with the risk of commoditisation? Where can I find future growth? FRONTEER STRATEGY INNOVATION. CO-CREATION. BRAND DEVELOPMENT. 9
  • 10.
    But markets changeand new rules apply... FRONTEER STRATEGY INNOVATION. CO-CREATION. BRAND DEVELOPMENT. 10
  • 11.
    99,995% of thepeople don’t work at your company... They might have some good ideas... Why not capture them? But opening up can be scary - most companies hesitate to share ideas and strategies 11
  • 12.
    Co-creation - how does it work? FRONTEER STRATEGY INNOVATION. CO-CREATION. BRAND DEVELOPMENT. 12
  • 13.
    There is always1 initiator - either company or just a single person - that decides to start the initiative Contributors will be joining along the process, but the initiator determines who can join and under what conditions FRONTEER STRATEGY INNOVATION. CO-CREATION. BRAND DEVELOPMENT. 13
  • 14.
    1% Creators 10% Synthesisers If you open up, keep in mind the ‘1% rule’ 100% Consumers Only 1% of people in any community generates the majority of the creative output FRONTEER STRATEGY INNOVATION. CO-CREATION. BRAND DEVELOPMENT. 14
  • 15.
    Co-creation is morethan a tool, it’s a program of change It can be used to... ... tackle your toughest strategic challenges ... get a fresh perspective on your business ... develop breakthrough new ideas ... unlock the world outside and bring it inside ... connect with partners, customers, consumers ... bring excitement to the floor FRONTEER ... work with the 1% most creative people STRATEGY INNOVATION. CO-CREATION. BRAND DEVELOPMENT. 15
  • 16.
    4 Types ofCo-creation There are many ways to go about Co-creation, and which to choose depends on the challenge and objectives at hand. FRONTEER STRATEGY INNOVATION. CO-CREATION. BRAND DEVELOPMENT. 16
  • 17.
    The 4 typesof co-creation are based on 2 dimensions: Ownership who owns the challenge & the outcome? Openness who can join the challenge? FRONTEER STRATEGY INNOVATION. CO-CREATION. BRAND DEVELOPMENT. 17
  • 18.
    The 4 typesof co-creation Anyone Crowd of Community of can join People Kindred Spirits Open- Crowd of people ness Selection Club of Coalition of process Experts Parties Initiator Initiator + Contributors Ownership 18
  • 19.
    Crowd of people Forany give challenge there might be a person ‘out there’ with a brilliant idea Threadless enables contributors to send in and rate t-shirt designs. Profits on sold items are shared with the designer. Not bad: a full 30% profit margin selling t-shirts with no R&D cost, low investments and hardly any employees. 19
  • 20.
    Community of kindredspirits People or groups with a similar goal develop something for the ‘greater good’ The Linux open source operating system software was developed by users and for users. The software code is free to use and owned by nobody. It started with one simple e-mail with a request for help. 20
  • 21.
    Nokia organises ‘leaduser’ and ‘expert’ co-creation sessions to develop visionary new products and services. Club of experts For specific, time-pressured challenges when expertise and breakthrough ideas are needed 21
  • 22.
    Heineken has successfullydeveloped the ‘Beertender’ in co-operation with Krups. A development period of 10 years resulted in the first true packaging innovation in beer in a long time. Coalition of parties In certain complex situations parties with specific skills team up to share knowledge, ideas and investments 22
  • 23.
    5 Guiding Principlesof Co-creation Successful co-creation initiatives tend to have a number of characteristics in common. FRONTEER STRATEGY INNOVATION. CO-CREATION. BRAND DEVELOPMENT. 23
  • 24.
    5 Guiding Principlesof Co-creation 24
  • 25.
    5 Guiding Principlesof Co-creation Inspire participation 24
  • 26.
    5 Guiding Principlesof Co-creation Select the very best Inspire participation 24
  • 27.
    5 Guiding Principlesof Co-creation Connect creative minds Select the very best Inspire participation 24
  • 28.
    5 Guiding Principlesof Co-creation Share results Connect creative minds Select the very best Inspire participation 24
  • 29.
    5 Guiding Principlesof Co-creation Continue development Share results Connect creative minds Select the very best Inspire participation 24
  • 30.
    Inspire participation Trigger peopleto join your challenge Alessi has been inspiring designers for many years to contribute to the Alessi brand, in return for exposure and shared gains. FRONTEER STRATEGY INNOVATION. CO-CREATION. BRAND DEVELOPMENT. 25
  • 31.
    Select the verybest Find the best ideas and the best people Innocentive is a platform where scientists and other experts are gathered to solve tough scientific challenges. Their track record is impressive: 30% of all problems posed are solved FRONTEER STRATEGY INNOVATION. CO-CREATION. BRAND DEVELOPMENT. 26
  • 32.
    Connect creative minds Enable people to work together and find that ‘spark’ Lego developed new generation Mindstorms products together with lead users of the Mindstorms Developer Program. They have helped Lego improving their product ranges far beyond Lego’s wildest dreams. 27
  • 33.
    Share results ‘Givingback’ is crucial* Co-creation was part of many of Apples successes and also drives the Apple iPhone App store success. The profits are shared, 70% is for the developer, 30% for Apple. FRONTEER STRATEGY INNOVATION. CO-CREATION. BRAND DEVELOPMENT. 28 *Compensation doesn’t have to be monetary, sharing IP is a next step
  • 34.
    Continue development Co-creation onlydelivers when it is a longer-term engagement Procter & Gamble set high co-creation standards: 50% of new products should come from outside the company. P&G’s Connect & Develop platform invites external people & companies to innovate with them. 29
  • 35.
    4 Areas ofValue Return on investments in co-creation can be found in several areas. FRONTEER STRATEGY INNOVATION. CO-CREATION. BRAND DEVELOPMENT. 30
  • 36.
    4 Areas ofValue in Co-creation Generated Value s n off pi r eS u F ut s n off pi tS Resul ts r ec ture Di Fu R esults D irect Time 31
  • 37.
    Direct results correspondwith the project goals that have been set: often new products and services, which generate economic value Direct spinoffs cannot be measured in terms of profit, but create enormous value. Unexpected effects can occur like new contacts, collaborations and brand ambassadors. 32
  • 38.
    A successful newproduct introduction can generate a snowball effect within a category, creating future results Future spin-off effects are unpredictable. Side-effects of certain actions are hard to oversee, but  what we can say is that action taken now will have an effect sometime in the future. 33
  • 39.
    FRONTEER martijn@fronteerstrategy.com STRATEGY I N N OVAT I O N. C O - C R E AT I O N. B R A N D D E V E L O P M E N T.