Blue Ocean Strategy
     ―The Peaceful Strategy‖
In business, we were always taught to fight an enemy
 (competitor) over a given piece of land (market)
Signs of fierce competition/
market unattractiveness                       ―Me-too‖            Supply
                                              Products              >
                                              (commoditized)      Demand
                        Zero-sum                                                   Price
                         Game                                                      Wars
                        (fighting over the
                        same customers)
                                                    Red Ocean
                                                         of
                                                 Bloody Competition               Shrinking
                           Rising
                                                                                   Profit
                           Churn
                                                                                  Margins
                           Rate               Declining             Slowing
                                               Brand/               Growth/
                                              Customer              Mature
                                               Loyalty              Markets

   ...and our language of strategy is deeply imbued with its roots in military:
   ―Chief executive officers sitting in the corporate headquarters think about
   what their customer-facing people at the front lines are doing, and how to
   capture a larger share of their markets‖
                            It is a ―winner/loser‖ thinking
   3
Companies have achieved substantially higher
 returns from investments in Blue Oceans (in %)




                     Red Oceans                                                  Blue Oceans
                     Market-Competing Business Launches                          Market-Creating Business Launches




* 10-year study of business lunches from 108 companies in different industries
 by: W. Chan Kim & Renée Mauborgne
  5
Value Innovation is the cornerstone of BOS,
  placing equal emphasis on value and innovation
                                                                                                                 Sony Walkman was the result of
The simultaneous pursuit of differentiation and low cost                                                         two already existing technologies




                                                 Cost
       Eliminate
                                                                                         Cost

        Reduce                                                                                                          Boom box


                                                Value
                                              Innovation

          Raise
                                                                                                                       Radio transistor
                                                                                    Buyer Value

         Create
                                                Value

                                                                                                                   Sony Walkman

        • Value creation: Something that incrementally improves value, but is not sufficient to make your organization stand out in
        the market place.
        • Innovation: Tends to be technology driven, market pioneering or futuristic, often shooting beyond what customers are
        ready to accept.
        • Value Innovation: Creating a leap in value for customers and your company, thereby opening up new and uncontested
        market space. It goes beyond value creation.
  7
Maximizing opportunities and minimizing risks in
  formulating and executing Blue Ocean Strategy
The six principles of BOS
             Formulation Principles          Formulation Risks


         Reconstruct market boundaries          Search Risk


        Focus on the big picture, not the
                                               Planning Risk
                   numbers


         Reach beyond existing demand            Scale Risk


        Get the strategic sequence right    Business Model Risk



              Execution Principles            Execution Risks


           Overcome key organization
                                            Organizational Risk
                   hurdles


          Build execution into strategy      Management Risk

  9
What about one simple picture that tells you the
  whole story and helps you avoid the ―math‖ things
The strategy canvas
                     Formula 1       1-star hotels      2-star hotels
  9
                                                                                       Sleep well at the best price !
  8
                                                                                               ERRC grid
  7
                                                                              Eliminate                           Raise
  6
                                                                         Eating facilities             Bed quality
  5
                                                                         Architecture                  Hygiene
  4
                                                                         Appealing lounges              Room quietness
  3

  2

  1
                                                                                Reduce                           Create
  0
                                                                          Room size (replaced          Automatic check-in
                                                                         closets with shelves)          machines
                                                                          Room amenities
                                                                         (desks, stationary,
                                                                         decoration)
                                                                          Receptionists
                                                                         (except during peak
                                                                         times)

                                                                        Result:
 What does the strategy canvas tell you?:                               • Captured large share of the budget hotel business
 • Graphical representation of strategy                                 • Expanded the market to include noncustomers such as
                                                                        truck drivers who previously slept in their trucks and
 • Big picture view
                                                                        business people who needed a few hours of rest
 • Landscape scanning (the most important factors of competition)
 • Relative positioning vs. competitors

  11
Path 1: Look Across Alternative Industries
                           Southwest          Other airlines        Car
10
 9
                                                                                               The pioneer of the budget airline business model
 8
 7                                                                                                  Eliminate                       Raise
 6
                                                                                               Meals                      Speed
 5
 4                                                                                             Lounges                    Friendly service
 3                                                                                             Seating choice
 2
                                                                                               Hub connectivity
 1
 0
                                                                                                     Reduce                        Create
                                                                                               Price versus               Frequent point-to-
                                                                                               average airlines            point departures



                                                                                               Other areas of cost saving:
                                                                                               • Moved from central to secondary airports
                                                                                               • Used one type of planes (Boeing 737)
* The insight into Southwest‘s success is that they looked at the car (alternative) as their   • Adopted simple pricing (all inclusive, no change fees)
competitor and not the other airlines in their industry

           Substitutes: Different forms but offer the same functionality or core utility. e.g.: Tea and Coffee
           Alternatives: Different forms and functions but give the same purpose. e.g.: Restaurants and Cinemas share the same
           purpose (―Enjoy a night out‖)
13
Path 3: Look Across the Chain of Buyers



                                               By launching NovoPen (the first user-friendly insulin delivery
                                           3
                                               solution), Novo Nordisk shifted its industry focus from doctors
                                               to patients
                                               Result: 70% of its total turnover comes from diabetes care!




    1                                                                                                            2

• Historically, the insulin industry focused on doctors                                                          • Meanwhile diabetics (users) were left with the
(influencers) who wanted purer insulin for their                                                                 complex and unpleasant task of handling
patients                                                                                                         syringes, needles and administering their doses.
• By 1980s advances in purification technology had
improved dramatically (Little progress could be made
further in this direction)

            The chain of buyers: purchasers, users and influencers.


 15
Path 5: Look Across Functional or Emotional
   Appeal to Buyers
Functional:                            Emotional:
• Simple                               • Pricey
• Low cost                             • Extras
• Low price                            • Feelings




                                                          ―No-nonsense‖ haircutting service




              Commodity   Experience




                                         • Hot towel
                                         • Shoulder rubbing
                                         • Tea/coffee
                                         • 1-hour, $27-$45
                                                                                       • Automatic wash & dry
                                       Result:                                         • ―one-use‖ towel & comb
                                       • From 1 outlet in in Japan (1996) to 560       • 10-mintue, $9
                                       shops in Far East (2010)                        • Traffic light system (no
                                       • Capital: $8.5m                                reservation desk)
   17
Answering these challenging questions can open
 up new and uncontested market space
                                                                                                          Step 3 : Identify desirable value
                Step 1 : Identify paths                       Step 2 : Think about
                                                                                                          factors


Alternative     Which are some substitute and alternative Why do buyers trade across them?
                                                                                                          What are the most important value factors?
Industries      industries to your industry?


                                                              Why do customers trade up for the higher
Strategic       What are the main strategic groups in                                                     What are the most attractive value factors?
                                                              group, and why do they trade down for the
Group           your industry?
                                                              lower one?


                What is the chain of buyers in your           Which buyer group does your industry        What factors can you create to unlock new
Buyer Group
                industry?                                     focus on?                                   value for a different buyer group?


Scope of
                                                              Are there any pain points that can be
Product or      What happens before, during or after                                                      What factors can be created to offer a total
                                                              eliminated through a complementary
Service         using your product?                                                                       solution buyers seek?
                                                              product or service offering?
Offering


                                                                                                          What factors can be stripped to create a
Functional or
                Is your industry functionally or emotionally                                              fundamentally simpler offering?
Emotional                                                    Can you flip this orientation?
                oriented?                                                                                 What factors can add emotion to your
Appeal
                                                                                                          functional products/services?


                What are some irreversible trends with a      How will these trends impact your           Given this, what new factors can be created to
Time
                clear trajectory that impact your industry?   business?                                   open up unprecedented customer utility?



 19
To maximize the size of your BO, reach beyond
  existing demand by focusing on noncustomers
The three tiers of noncustomers

                                                                                                           Unexplored
                                                                       Refusing
                           Soon-to-be                                                                These have not been targeted or
                    They are already part of the current       They either do not use or cannot      thought of as potential customers
                    market and minimally use the               afford to use the current market      by any company in the industry
        Your
                    product/service until something            offerings because they find the       and are assumed to belong to
       Current                                                                                       other markets. e.g. until recently
                    better comes up. They do not have          offerings unacceptable or beyond
       Market                                                  their means. Their needs are either   tooth whitening was thought to be
                    loyalty, want something better and
                    usually try other alternatives             dealt with through another means or   a service provided exclusively by
                                                               are completely ignored                doctors and not by oral care
                                                                                                     consumer-product companies


       Young
       antisocial   Other males
       males
                                             Girls
                                                           Everyone else




                              Blue Oceans can be created by focusing on the key commonalities in what buyers value, and
                              not their differences through finer customization and segmentation.
  21
Unless your new idea offers exceptional additional
  utility for customers, don‘t go any further
                                                    Buyer Experience Cycle
Buyer Utility
   Map             Purchase        Delivery             Use              Supplement   Maintenance   Disposal


  Utility Levers
  Customer                     Helping customers do things faster or better (time/money)
 Productivity



  Simplicity                                  No physical or intellectual difficulty



 Convenience                                   Easy to obtain, use or dispose of


     Risk                             Reduce financial, physical or credibility risk
  Reductions



  Fun/Image                   Provide a fun experience or particular image for the customer


 Environmental
                                       Contributing to improving the environment
  Friendliness


  23
                                                        Back to Path 4
Target costing addresses the profit side of the
business model to ensure meeting the strategic price
        Red Ocean Pricing                                                                                       Blue Ocean Pricing
                                                          The Strategic Price

                                                                                                                       Strategic
                 Cost
                                                                                                                         Price



                                                           The Target Profit                                            Target
                Profit
                                                                                                                        Profit




                                                                                                                        Target
                Price                                       The Target Cost                                              Cost




                                    Streamlining & Cost                              Partnering
                                        Innovations



• Swatch strategic price was $40 and their                                                • Partnered with over 1500 manufacturers in
Asian competitors‘ around $75 per watch                                                   more than 50 countries to ensure lower material
• Used plastic instead of metal or leather                  Pricing Innovation            cost and faster production
• Reduced the inner parts from 150 to 51
• Replaced screws by ultrasonic welding
                                                                     • Fractional ownership of corporate jets
• Direct labor cost went down from 30% to 10%
                                                                     • Revenue share with IT start-ups in return for providing HP‘s
                                                                     high-end servers
  25
Building a robust business model is important to
  ensure profitability from your Blue Ocean idea
The strategic sequence                                     Buyer utility
                                               Is there exceptional buyer utility in your
                                               business idea?                               No- Rethink
   • Address the revenue side
                                                         Yes
   • Create a leap in value for buyer
   • Net Buyer Value = Buyer Utility - Price
                                                                Price
                                               Is your price easily accessible to the
                                               mass of buyers?
                                                                                            No- Rethink

                                                         Yes


   • Addresses the profit side
                                                                 Cost
   • Create a leap in value for company        Can you attain your cost target to profit
   • Profit = Price - Cost                     at your strategic price?
                                                                                            No- Rethink

                                                         Yes

                                                               Adoption
                                               What are the adoption hurdles in
                                               actualizing your business idea? Are you
                                               addressing them up front?                    No- Rethink

                                                         Yes

                                                          A Commercially
                                                         Viable Blue Ocean
                                                                Idea
  27
Tipping Point Leaders take a shortcut to address
  organizational hurdles
Conventional Wisdom vs. Tipping Point Leadership
   Conventional Wisdom: Theory of organization change rests on transforming the mass. So change
   efforts are focused on moving the mass, requiring steep resources and long time frames.




                                           Mass of Employees

                                                  Company




   Tipping Point Leadership: To change the mass, focus on the extremes – people, acts, and activities
   that exercise a disproportionate influence on performance to achieve a strategic shift fast at low cost.

       Disproportionate                                                             Disproportionate
       influence Factors                                                            influence Factors



                                                  Company

  29
Tipping Point Leadership in action: How Bill Bratton
turned New York to the safest large city in the US                                                                                              1994 -1996
1 Seeing is believing:                                                2 Redistribute resources to your hot spots:
  • Although the public was complaining about the                       • Bratton did a complete refocus of cops at subway stations as he
  surge in crime in the subway system, the NYC                          found that they were staffed equally even though the majority of
  Police Dept. believed that it only accounted for 3%                   crimes occurred only in a few stations and lines
  of city‘s crime.                                                      • He also allocated more staff to narcotics unit which was
  • Starting by himself, Bratton let the top and middle                 understaffed (5% of the total work force yet handled 30-50% of
  brass ride the subway trains.                                         total crimes, attributable to drug-related crimes)
                                                                        Redirect resources from your cold spots:
                                                                        • Before Bratton, it would take an officer 16 hrs to bring a
  Meet with disgruntled customers:
                                                                        criminal/suspect from downtown to the court.
  • The public was intimidated by the surge in crime in
                                                                        • By using ‗bust buses‘ that were parked outside subway
  Boston‘s Police District 4 (under Bratton), and
                                                                        stations, an officer needed to only escort the suspect up to the
  residents were selling their homes and leaving.
                                                                        street level to the bus
  • But the police force felt there were doing a fine
                                                                        • This cut processing time from 16 hrs to 1 hr, freeing more officers
  job, according the short 911 response times and
                                                                        to patrol the subway and catch criminals
  their record in solving major crimes.
  • To solve the paradox, Bratton arranged a series                     Engage in horse trading:
  of town hall meetings between his officers and the                    • Bratton facilitated a horse trading initiative between 2 police
  neighborhood residents                                                units, one was short of cars but had excess office space and the
                                                                        other vice versa.
4 Leverage your angles and silence your devils:                       3 Zoom in on kingpins:
  • Bratton‘s devils were the courts, who believed that his new         • Bratton zoomed in on the 76 precinct heads as his key
  strategy (focusing on quality-of-life crimes) would overwhelm the     influencers and kingpins
  system with small crimes (prostitution, public drunkenness)           • Each head directly controlled 200-400 police officers, who
  • He built a coalition with his angles (mayor, district               in turn would have ripple effect on 36 thousand police force.
  attorneys, jail managers, public media), by illustrating to them
  that the court system could indeed handle the added crimes and        “Fishbowl” management:
  in the long run they would reduce their caseload.                     • Biweekly crime strategy meetings
  • With this powerful coalition, the courts could no longer oppose     • Each commander‘s performance was publically critiqued
  his strategy                                                          in front of peers and superiors
                                                                        • Made results and responsibilities clear and transparent for
                                                                        everyone
Secure a consigliere:                                                   • The fishbowl was applied to all kingpins
• Bratton appointed John Timoney, a highly respected NYPD
officer, as his number two                                              Atomization (break the challenge into bit-sized atoms):
• Timoney‘s task was to report to Bratton on the likely attitudes       • Each officer was responsible for his/her (block, precinct
of the top NYPD staff on the new strategy, identifying those            or borough), so no one could claim that was out of his/her
who would fight or silently sabotage the new initiative                 hands
                                                                        • Responsibility for executing the new strategy shifted from
                                                                        him to each of the NYPD 36,000 police officers
    31
Are you saying Red Ocean Strategy is no longer
useful?

     Absolutely not. It will always be important to swim successfully
     in the Red Ocean by outcompeting rivals. Red Oceans will
     always matter and will always be a fact of business life. But…




       while Red Ocean Strategy tells you        Blue Ocean Strategy shows
     how take a bigger slice from the market‘s     how to create your own
                      pizza




33
Thank you

Flevy.com - Blue Ocean Strategy - The Peaceful Strategy

  • 1.
    Blue Ocean Strategy ―The Peaceful Strategy‖
  • 2.
    In business, wewere always taught to fight an enemy (competitor) over a given piece of land (market) Signs of fierce competition/ market unattractiveness ―Me-too‖ Supply Products > (commoditized) Demand Zero-sum Price Game Wars (fighting over the same customers) Red Ocean of Bloody Competition Shrinking Rising Profit Churn Margins Rate Declining Slowing Brand/ Growth/ Customer Mature Loyalty Markets ...and our language of strategy is deeply imbued with its roots in military: ―Chief executive officers sitting in the corporate headquarters think about what their customer-facing people at the front lines are doing, and how to capture a larger share of their markets‖ It is a ―winner/loser‖ thinking 3
  • 3.
    Companies have achievedsubstantially higher returns from investments in Blue Oceans (in %) Red Oceans Blue Oceans Market-Competing Business Launches Market-Creating Business Launches * 10-year study of business lunches from 108 companies in different industries by: W. Chan Kim & Renée Mauborgne 5
  • 4.
    Value Innovation isthe cornerstone of BOS, placing equal emphasis on value and innovation Sony Walkman was the result of The simultaneous pursuit of differentiation and low cost two already existing technologies Cost Eliminate Cost Reduce Boom box Value Innovation Raise Radio transistor Buyer Value Create Value Sony Walkman • Value creation: Something that incrementally improves value, but is not sufficient to make your organization stand out in the market place. • Innovation: Tends to be technology driven, market pioneering or futuristic, often shooting beyond what customers are ready to accept. • Value Innovation: Creating a leap in value for customers and your company, thereby opening up new and uncontested market space. It goes beyond value creation. 7
  • 5.
    Maximizing opportunities andminimizing risks in formulating and executing Blue Ocean Strategy The six principles of BOS Formulation Principles Formulation Risks Reconstruct market boundaries Search Risk Focus on the big picture, not the Planning Risk numbers Reach beyond existing demand Scale Risk Get the strategic sequence right Business Model Risk Execution Principles Execution Risks Overcome key organization Organizational Risk hurdles Build execution into strategy Management Risk 9
  • 6.
    What about onesimple picture that tells you the whole story and helps you avoid the ―math‖ things The strategy canvas Formula 1 1-star hotels 2-star hotels 9 Sleep well at the best price ! 8 ERRC grid 7 Eliminate Raise 6 Eating facilities Bed quality 5 Architecture Hygiene 4 Appealing lounges  Room quietness 3 2 1 Reduce Create 0  Room size (replaced Automatic check-in closets with shelves) machines  Room amenities (desks, stationary, decoration)  Receptionists (except during peak times) Result: What does the strategy canvas tell you?: • Captured large share of the budget hotel business • Graphical representation of strategy • Expanded the market to include noncustomers such as truck drivers who previously slept in their trucks and • Big picture view business people who needed a few hours of rest • Landscape scanning (the most important factors of competition) • Relative positioning vs. competitors 11
  • 7.
    Path 1: LookAcross Alternative Industries Southwest Other airlines Car 10 9 The pioneer of the budget airline business model 8 7 Eliminate Raise 6 Meals Speed 5 4 Lounges Friendly service 3 Seating choice 2 Hub connectivity 1 0 Reduce Create Price versus Frequent point-to- average airlines point departures Other areas of cost saving: • Moved from central to secondary airports • Used one type of planes (Boeing 737) * The insight into Southwest‘s success is that they looked at the car (alternative) as their • Adopted simple pricing (all inclusive, no change fees) competitor and not the other airlines in their industry Substitutes: Different forms but offer the same functionality or core utility. e.g.: Tea and Coffee Alternatives: Different forms and functions but give the same purpose. e.g.: Restaurants and Cinemas share the same purpose (―Enjoy a night out‖) 13
  • 8.
    Path 3: LookAcross the Chain of Buyers By launching NovoPen (the first user-friendly insulin delivery 3 solution), Novo Nordisk shifted its industry focus from doctors to patients Result: 70% of its total turnover comes from diabetes care! 1 2 • Historically, the insulin industry focused on doctors • Meanwhile diabetics (users) were left with the (influencers) who wanted purer insulin for their complex and unpleasant task of handling patients syringes, needles and administering their doses. • By 1980s advances in purification technology had improved dramatically (Little progress could be made further in this direction) The chain of buyers: purchasers, users and influencers. 15
  • 9.
    Path 5: LookAcross Functional or Emotional Appeal to Buyers Functional: Emotional: • Simple • Pricey • Low cost • Extras • Low price • Feelings ―No-nonsense‖ haircutting service Commodity Experience • Hot towel • Shoulder rubbing • Tea/coffee • 1-hour, $27-$45 • Automatic wash & dry Result: • ―one-use‖ towel & comb • From 1 outlet in in Japan (1996) to 560 • 10-mintue, $9 shops in Far East (2010) • Traffic light system (no • Capital: $8.5m reservation desk) 17
  • 10.
    Answering these challengingquestions can open up new and uncontested market space Step 3 : Identify desirable value Step 1 : Identify paths Step 2 : Think about factors Alternative Which are some substitute and alternative Why do buyers trade across them? What are the most important value factors? Industries industries to your industry? Why do customers trade up for the higher Strategic What are the main strategic groups in What are the most attractive value factors? group, and why do they trade down for the Group your industry? lower one? What is the chain of buyers in your Which buyer group does your industry What factors can you create to unlock new Buyer Group industry? focus on? value for a different buyer group? Scope of Are there any pain points that can be Product or What happens before, during or after What factors can be created to offer a total eliminated through a complementary Service using your product? solution buyers seek? product or service offering? Offering What factors can be stripped to create a Functional or Is your industry functionally or emotionally fundamentally simpler offering? Emotional Can you flip this orientation? oriented? What factors can add emotion to your Appeal functional products/services? What are some irreversible trends with a How will these trends impact your Given this, what new factors can be created to Time clear trajectory that impact your industry? business? open up unprecedented customer utility? 19
  • 11.
    To maximize thesize of your BO, reach beyond existing demand by focusing on noncustomers The three tiers of noncustomers Unexplored Refusing Soon-to-be These have not been targeted or They are already part of the current They either do not use or cannot thought of as potential customers market and minimally use the afford to use the current market by any company in the industry Your product/service until something offerings because they find the and are assumed to belong to Current other markets. e.g. until recently better comes up. They do not have offerings unacceptable or beyond Market their means. Their needs are either tooth whitening was thought to be loyalty, want something better and usually try other alternatives dealt with through another means or a service provided exclusively by are completely ignored doctors and not by oral care consumer-product companies Young antisocial Other males males Girls Everyone else Blue Oceans can be created by focusing on the key commonalities in what buyers value, and not their differences through finer customization and segmentation. 21
  • 12.
    Unless your newidea offers exceptional additional utility for customers, don‘t go any further Buyer Experience Cycle Buyer Utility Map Purchase Delivery Use Supplement Maintenance Disposal Utility Levers Customer Helping customers do things faster or better (time/money) Productivity Simplicity No physical or intellectual difficulty Convenience Easy to obtain, use or dispose of Risk Reduce financial, physical or credibility risk Reductions Fun/Image Provide a fun experience or particular image for the customer Environmental Contributing to improving the environment Friendliness 23 Back to Path 4
  • 13.
    Target costing addressesthe profit side of the business model to ensure meeting the strategic price Red Ocean Pricing Blue Ocean Pricing The Strategic Price Strategic Cost Price The Target Profit Target Profit Profit Target Price The Target Cost Cost Streamlining & Cost Partnering Innovations • Swatch strategic price was $40 and their • Partnered with over 1500 manufacturers in Asian competitors‘ around $75 per watch more than 50 countries to ensure lower material • Used plastic instead of metal or leather Pricing Innovation cost and faster production • Reduced the inner parts from 150 to 51 • Replaced screws by ultrasonic welding • Fractional ownership of corporate jets • Direct labor cost went down from 30% to 10% • Revenue share with IT start-ups in return for providing HP‘s high-end servers 25
  • 14.
    Building a robustbusiness model is important to ensure profitability from your Blue Ocean idea The strategic sequence Buyer utility Is there exceptional buyer utility in your business idea? No- Rethink • Address the revenue side Yes • Create a leap in value for buyer • Net Buyer Value = Buyer Utility - Price Price Is your price easily accessible to the mass of buyers? No- Rethink Yes • Addresses the profit side Cost • Create a leap in value for company Can you attain your cost target to profit • Profit = Price - Cost at your strategic price? No- Rethink Yes Adoption What are the adoption hurdles in actualizing your business idea? Are you addressing them up front? No- Rethink Yes A Commercially Viable Blue Ocean Idea 27
  • 15.
    Tipping Point Leaderstake a shortcut to address organizational hurdles Conventional Wisdom vs. Tipping Point Leadership Conventional Wisdom: Theory of organization change rests on transforming the mass. So change efforts are focused on moving the mass, requiring steep resources and long time frames. Mass of Employees Company Tipping Point Leadership: To change the mass, focus on the extremes – people, acts, and activities that exercise a disproportionate influence on performance to achieve a strategic shift fast at low cost. Disproportionate Disproportionate influence Factors influence Factors Company 29
  • 16.
    Tipping Point Leadershipin action: How Bill Bratton turned New York to the safest large city in the US 1994 -1996 1 Seeing is believing: 2 Redistribute resources to your hot spots: • Although the public was complaining about the • Bratton did a complete refocus of cops at subway stations as he surge in crime in the subway system, the NYC found that they were staffed equally even though the majority of Police Dept. believed that it only accounted for 3% crimes occurred only in a few stations and lines of city‘s crime. • He also allocated more staff to narcotics unit which was • Starting by himself, Bratton let the top and middle understaffed (5% of the total work force yet handled 30-50% of brass ride the subway trains. total crimes, attributable to drug-related crimes) Redirect resources from your cold spots: • Before Bratton, it would take an officer 16 hrs to bring a Meet with disgruntled customers: criminal/suspect from downtown to the court. • The public was intimidated by the surge in crime in • By using ‗bust buses‘ that were parked outside subway Boston‘s Police District 4 (under Bratton), and stations, an officer needed to only escort the suspect up to the residents were selling their homes and leaving. street level to the bus • But the police force felt there were doing a fine • This cut processing time from 16 hrs to 1 hr, freeing more officers job, according the short 911 response times and to patrol the subway and catch criminals their record in solving major crimes. • To solve the paradox, Bratton arranged a series Engage in horse trading: of town hall meetings between his officers and the • Bratton facilitated a horse trading initiative between 2 police neighborhood residents units, one was short of cars but had excess office space and the other vice versa. 4 Leverage your angles and silence your devils: 3 Zoom in on kingpins: • Bratton‘s devils were the courts, who believed that his new • Bratton zoomed in on the 76 precinct heads as his key strategy (focusing on quality-of-life crimes) would overwhelm the influencers and kingpins system with small crimes (prostitution, public drunkenness) • Each head directly controlled 200-400 police officers, who • He built a coalition with his angles (mayor, district in turn would have ripple effect on 36 thousand police force. attorneys, jail managers, public media), by illustrating to them that the court system could indeed handle the added crimes and “Fishbowl” management: in the long run they would reduce their caseload. • Biweekly crime strategy meetings • With this powerful coalition, the courts could no longer oppose • Each commander‘s performance was publically critiqued his strategy in front of peers and superiors • Made results and responsibilities clear and transparent for everyone Secure a consigliere: • The fishbowl was applied to all kingpins • Bratton appointed John Timoney, a highly respected NYPD officer, as his number two Atomization (break the challenge into bit-sized atoms): • Timoney‘s task was to report to Bratton on the likely attitudes • Each officer was responsible for his/her (block, precinct of the top NYPD staff on the new strategy, identifying those or borough), so no one could claim that was out of his/her who would fight or silently sabotage the new initiative hands • Responsibility for executing the new strategy shifted from him to each of the NYPD 36,000 police officers 31
  • 17.
    Are you sayingRed Ocean Strategy is no longer useful? Absolutely not. It will always be important to swim successfully in the Red Ocean by outcompeting rivals. Red Oceans will always matter and will always be a fact of business life. But… while Red Ocean Strategy tells you Blue Ocean Strategy shows how take a bigger slice from the market‘s how to create your own pizza 33
  • 18.