In this article we introduce and apply the GOV typology in order to analyze various e-Government tools, websites and interactive methods of the
EU-project “Open Government in Europe”. In many ways these so-called ‘Good Practices’ (GP) are state of the art examples of open data, egovernment
tools and innovative relationships between governments and active citizens in Europe. Rich though the examples may be, comparing and
evaluating them is not easy, while learning from them or using a specific example in one’s own situation is quite difficult. The proposed indicator
GOV, while allowing for three distinct GOV strata, hugely improves the options for meaningful comparison between Good Practices and learning
from them. Furthermore, with the GOV typology we observe a difference between the patterning of Good Practices, mainly found in GOV 1.0 and
GOV 2.0 strata, and the subset of selected ‘Best Practices’, which tend to clustering in the GOV 2.0 and GOV 3.0 strata. Thirdly, due to the GOV
indicator we have a better understanding of the workings of the Good Practices, especially the options of interaction between given GOV strata. The
Dutch GOV 2.0 case “Research on Civic Initiatives, DIY’s & Liability” illustrates such behavior, resulting in additional GOV examples, with clear
indications of push and pull strategies due to attitudes of governments and citizens and thus providing a solid argument for interaction.
ENoLL President Tuija Hirvikoski presented the European Network of Living Lab's vision on global opportunities through Living Labs at Cantillon 2017 event that was hosted in Ireland. Content of the presentation:
- strategy of Living Labs, how Living Labs work, ENoLL memberhsip and the 11th wave
- OI2 (open innovation)
- OpenLivingLab Days 2017
- LLs as Local Open Innovation
Ecosystems
- Living Lab examples (Finland - Laurea UAS)
The document discusses lessons learned from the OurSpace project, which aimed to create a cross-border eParticipation platform for youth political deliberation. An evaluation methodology was developed using 4 levels and 11 indicator categories to measure the project's objectives and results. The methodology included questionnaires, interviews, data analysis and focus groups. Results showed that while the platform facilitated relevant political discussions for youth, decision maker participation was limited. Technical features were satisfactory but could be enhanced to better support networking and community aspects. Promotion through diverse channels helped engage users.
The document provides information about a workshop on Living Lab methodology hosted by Botnia Living Lab. It discusses the agenda, which includes an introduction to Botnia Living Lab and the FormIT methodology. Participants will work in groups to discuss key Living Lab principles and present their discussions. The document also provides background on Botnia Living Lab and its approach, including the FormIT methodology, which involves three cycles of user involvement: concept design, prototype design, and innovation design. It lists several of Botnia's projects and describes the key principles and benefits of the Living Lab approach.
The document provides an overview of Living Labs for user-driven open innovation. It defines Living Labs as user-driven open innovation ecosystems based on business-citizens-government partnerships that enable users to actively participate in the research, development and innovation process. Living Labs have benefits for users, SMEs, larger companies, and research. The European Commission supports Living Labs through programs like i2010, CIP, and FP6/FP7. Projects are developing collaboration environments and tools to support user-driven innovation.
The document discusses four key European projects focused on eParticipation: DEMO-Net, MOMENTUM, the European eParticipation Study, and PEP-NET. DEMO-Net is a 4-year network of excellence project to strengthen research on eParticipation. MOMENTUM is a 30-month project to monitor, coordinate, and promote EU eParticipation projects. The European eParticipation Study is a 12-month project to identify roles for and barriers to eParticipation in Europe. PEP-NET is a 30-month thematic network to create a pan-European network on local and regional eParticipation.
ENoLL President Tuija Hirvikoski presented the European Network of Living Lab's vision on global opportunities through Living Labs at Cantillon 2017 event that was hosted in Ireland. Content of the presentation:
- strategy of Living Labs, how Living Labs work, ENoLL memberhsip and the 11th wave
- OI2 (open innovation)
- OpenLivingLab Days 2017
- LLs as Local Open Innovation
Ecosystems
- Living Lab examples (Finland - Laurea UAS)
The document discusses lessons learned from the OurSpace project, which aimed to create a cross-border eParticipation platform for youth political deliberation. An evaluation methodology was developed using 4 levels and 11 indicator categories to measure the project's objectives and results. The methodology included questionnaires, interviews, data analysis and focus groups. Results showed that while the platform facilitated relevant political discussions for youth, decision maker participation was limited. Technical features were satisfactory but could be enhanced to better support networking and community aspects. Promotion through diverse channels helped engage users.
The document provides information about a workshop on Living Lab methodology hosted by Botnia Living Lab. It discusses the agenda, which includes an introduction to Botnia Living Lab and the FormIT methodology. Participants will work in groups to discuss key Living Lab principles and present their discussions. The document also provides background on Botnia Living Lab and its approach, including the FormIT methodology, which involves three cycles of user involvement: concept design, prototype design, and innovation design. It lists several of Botnia's projects and describes the key principles and benefits of the Living Lab approach.
The document provides an overview of Living Labs for user-driven open innovation. It defines Living Labs as user-driven open innovation ecosystems based on business-citizens-government partnerships that enable users to actively participate in the research, development and innovation process. Living Labs have benefits for users, SMEs, larger companies, and research. The European Commission supports Living Labs through programs like i2010, CIP, and FP6/FP7. Projects are developing collaboration environments and tools to support user-driven innovation.
The document discusses four key European projects focused on eParticipation: DEMO-Net, MOMENTUM, the European eParticipation Study, and PEP-NET. DEMO-Net is a 4-year network of excellence project to strengthen research on eParticipation. MOMENTUM is a 30-month project to monitor, coordinate, and promote EU eParticipation projects. The European eParticipation Study is a 12-month project to identify roles for and barriers to eParticipation in Europe. PEP-NET is a 30-month thematic network to create a pan-European network on local and regional eParticipation.
The European Network of Living Labs (ENoLL) is the international federation of benchmarked Living Labs in Europe and worldwide. In the following presentation ENoLL presents what it means for cities to be Living Lab and what is the difference between Cities as Living Labs and Urban Living Labs.
to build an Open Data ecosystem in our city.
Promote Open Data and Living Lab approach in our city.
Test new ways of involving citizens in the smart city development.
Learn from other cities experiences.
Contribute to the European Open Data movement.
Pilot Experience: Issy-les-Moulineaux
2nd Period Achievements
- Completed Closed User Group 1 & 2
- Completed Open User Group 1
- Published new datasets on data.issy.com
- Created first apps with our citizen developers
- Organized workshops to promote Open Data
- Contributed
The Urban Living Lab project is an open ecosystem involving students, residents, local communities and businesses around an eco-campus in Saint-Quentin-en-Yvelines and Versailles Grand Parc territories. It supports innovation for sustainable and low carbon development. The project promotes innovation in education, strengthens the local economy, and makes the territories more attractive. It has locations in the two territories to better involve local actors and experiments with innovative projects in transportation, energy efficiency, food supply, and education.
Look through the projects submitted by ENoLL members, choose the one you like best and give your vote: http://bit.ly/2mxoi89
Read through longer descriptions of projects: http://bit.ly/2m0dDjb
The European Network of Living Labs (ENoLL) is a non-profit international association representing over 300 certified Living Labs across Europe. Living Labs are real-life test environments where users and producers co-create innovations through public-private-people partnerships. ENoLL was launched in 2006 and supports the European Innovation Partnership on Active and Healthy Ageing by coordinating a community of Living Labs to develop and test interoperable independent living solutions.
USA CENDI's Strategic Thinking About Openness for 2014 Carolina Rossini
The document discusses open government and open science from an international perspective. It notes that examples of citizen-driven open science are emerging rapidly, but that government policies and institutions have yet to fully embrace openness. It questions how citizen science and open government can best work together to address societal challenges.
The European Network of Living Labs (ENoLL) is a non-profit international association representing over 300 certified Living Labs across Europe. Living Labs are real-life test environments where users and producers co-create innovations. ENoLL was launched in 2006 and supports various EU initiatives related to aging well, smart cities, and future internet technologies by facilitating partnerships between its member Living Labs. ENoLL is committed to the EU Active and Assisted Living Program and plans workshops and projects to promote interoperability and gather evidence on independent living solutions.
This document provides an overview of Living Labs from a European perspective given by Prof. Álvaro de Oliveira, President of the European Network of Living Labs (ENoLL). It defines Living Labs as user-driven open innovation ecosystems where users co-create and test new ideas, products, and services in real-life environments. The ENoLL has grown in waves to now include over 200 Living Labs across Europe. Living Labs address big challenges like sustainability and behavior change through collaborative innovation that engages users, businesses, researchers, and other stakeholders.
Prof. Alvaro Oliveira, CEO of Alfamicro, presenting the case of Lisbon & Human Smart Cities during the ENoLL fringe session "Open Innovation and Living Labs shaping the cities and regions of the future" at the EC Innovation Convention 2014
Implementing transparency and open government projects in GreeceMichael Psallidas
This document discusses challenges and opportunities for implementing transparency and open government projects in Greece. It outlines past open government projects in Greece from 2009-2012 that focused on proof of concepts, skills development, interoperability, and open standards. Current demands for transparency stem from the economic crisis. The Transparency Program aims to establish a new relationship between citizens and government based on accountability. It promotes open data through a multichannel platform and encourages third parties to create applications. Challenges include overcoming issues within institutions and culture, bridging access gaps, and adopting diverse technical solutions. Opportunities exist for both public and private sectors to improve governance and gain business value through openness, feedback, and knowledge-based applications.
The document discusses OpenCoesione, an Italian government initiative that aims to promote transparency around Cohesion Policy funds from the EU. It provides open data on over 800,000 projects funded totaling €80 billion. The goals are to improve decision making, increase civic participation, and encourage analysis of policy impact. It summarizes the types of data available on the OpenCoesione website, how often it is updated, and efforts to promote its use through data journalism and civic monitoring of local projects.
Présentation d'Alain Bravo à la journée "Questions numériques 2011"Fing
The document summarizes the key findings and recommendations from a panel that evaluated the FP7-ICT program. The panel found the ICT program to be relevant and well-implemented, but made recommendations in three areas: 1) Strengthening European ICT research globally by continuing the ICT theme and building partnerships. 2) Exploiting ICT's influence across sectors through coordinated policies and involvement of users/industry. 3) Sharing risks more to increase participation, especially of SMEs, through simplified rules and a two-stage application process.
Modelling and Measuring Sustainable Lifestyle Transition to 2050Patrick Niemann
This webinar presentation summarized findings from the EU-InnovatE project, which models and measures sustainable lifestyle transitions to 2050. The project uses an agent-based model to simulate societies and evaluate the impact of adopting user innovations in different domains like food, energy, living and mobility. Emerging findings show that widespread adoption of various user innovations across these domains has the potential to transition European societies to sustainable consumption levels. Public policies and societal interventions that accelerate innovation adoption can significantly reduce carbon emissions and resource use. The project will continue measuring trends, designing future scenarios, and evaluating pathways to accelerate sustainable entrepreneurship and lifestyle changes.
7th Session: Workshop II on a Roadmap to Future Government
In this session we proceed to presentations and discussion concerning the the development of the new roadmap for digital government. Two projects (Gov3.0 and Big Policy Canvas) will join forces in this exciting endeavor.
Organizers: Maria Wimmer, Professor, Koblentz University, Germany; Francesco Mureddu, Associate Directorr, Lisbon Council, Belgium; Juliane Schmeling Fraunhofer Institut FOKUS, Researcher, Germany; Shoumaya Ben Dhaou, Researcher, United Nations University, PT
Les enjeux politiques de l’open access contre les OligopolesFrancesca Di Donato
This document discusses open access and its role in challenging publisher oligopolies. It defines open access as free online access to scholarly works, and outlines two main open access strategies: self-archiving in repositories ("green road") and publishing in open access journals ("gold road"). The dominance of a few large commercial publishers is addressed, as is the "serials crisis" of rising subscription costs limiting library budgets. The document recommends policies like institutional open access mandates and funder open access policies to promote open access goals of increased access, impact, and innovation.
The European Network of Living Labs (ENoLL) is the international federation of benchmarked Living Labs in Europe and worldwide. In the following presentation ENoLL presents what it means for cities to be Living Lab and what is the difference between Cities as Living Labs and Urban Living Labs.
to build an Open Data ecosystem in our city.
Promote Open Data and Living Lab approach in our city.
Test new ways of involving citizens in the smart city development.
Learn from other cities experiences.
Contribute to the European Open Data movement.
Pilot Experience: Issy-les-Moulineaux
2nd Period Achievements
- Completed Closed User Group 1 & 2
- Completed Open User Group 1
- Published new datasets on data.issy.com
- Created first apps with our citizen developers
- Organized workshops to promote Open Data
- Contributed
The Urban Living Lab project is an open ecosystem involving students, residents, local communities and businesses around an eco-campus in Saint-Quentin-en-Yvelines and Versailles Grand Parc territories. It supports innovation for sustainable and low carbon development. The project promotes innovation in education, strengthens the local economy, and makes the territories more attractive. It has locations in the two territories to better involve local actors and experiments with innovative projects in transportation, energy efficiency, food supply, and education.
Look through the projects submitted by ENoLL members, choose the one you like best and give your vote: http://bit.ly/2mxoi89
Read through longer descriptions of projects: http://bit.ly/2m0dDjb
The European Network of Living Labs (ENoLL) is a non-profit international association representing over 300 certified Living Labs across Europe. Living Labs are real-life test environments where users and producers co-create innovations through public-private-people partnerships. ENoLL was launched in 2006 and supports the European Innovation Partnership on Active and Healthy Ageing by coordinating a community of Living Labs to develop and test interoperable independent living solutions.
USA CENDI's Strategic Thinking About Openness for 2014 Carolina Rossini
The document discusses open government and open science from an international perspective. It notes that examples of citizen-driven open science are emerging rapidly, but that government policies and institutions have yet to fully embrace openness. It questions how citizen science and open government can best work together to address societal challenges.
The European Network of Living Labs (ENoLL) is a non-profit international association representing over 300 certified Living Labs across Europe. Living Labs are real-life test environments where users and producers co-create innovations. ENoLL was launched in 2006 and supports various EU initiatives related to aging well, smart cities, and future internet technologies by facilitating partnerships between its member Living Labs. ENoLL is committed to the EU Active and Assisted Living Program and plans workshops and projects to promote interoperability and gather evidence on independent living solutions.
This document provides an overview of Living Labs from a European perspective given by Prof. Álvaro de Oliveira, President of the European Network of Living Labs (ENoLL). It defines Living Labs as user-driven open innovation ecosystems where users co-create and test new ideas, products, and services in real-life environments. The ENoLL has grown in waves to now include over 200 Living Labs across Europe. Living Labs address big challenges like sustainability and behavior change through collaborative innovation that engages users, businesses, researchers, and other stakeholders.
Prof. Alvaro Oliveira, CEO of Alfamicro, presenting the case of Lisbon & Human Smart Cities during the ENoLL fringe session "Open Innovation and Living Labs shaping the cities and regions of the future" at the EC Innovation Convention 2014
Implementing transparency and open government projects in GreeceMichael Psallidas
This document discusses challenges and opportunities for implementing transparency and open government projects in Greece. It outlines past open government projects in Greece from 2009-2012 that focused on proof of concepts, skills development, interoperability, and open standards. Current demands for transparency stem from the economic crisis. The Transparency Program aims to establish a new relationship between citizens and government based on accountability. It promotes open data through a multichannel platform and encourages third parties to create applications. Challenges include overcoming issues within institutions and culture, bridging access gaps, and adopting diverse technical solutions. Opportunities exist for both public and private sectors to improve governance and gain business value through openness, feedback, and knowledge-based applications.
The document discusses OpenCoesione, an Italian government initiative that aims to promote transparency around Cohesion Policy funds from the EU. It provides open data on over 800,000 projects funded totaling €80 billion. The goals are to improve decision making, increase civic participation, and encourage analysis of policy impact. It summarizes the types of data available on the OpenCoesione website, how often it is updated, and efforts to promote its use through data journalism and civic monitoring of local projects.
Présentation d'Alain Bravo à la journée "Questions numériques 2011"Fing
The document summarizes the key findings and recommendations from a panel that evaluated the FP7-ICT program. The panel found the ICT program to be relevant and well-implemented, but made recommendations in three areas: 1) Strengthening European ICT research globally by continuing the ICT theme and building partnerships. 2) Exploiting ICT's influence across sectors through coordinated policies and involvement of users/industry. 3) Sharing risks more to increase participation, especially of SMEs, through simplified rules and a two-stage application process.
Modelling and Measuring Sustainable Lifestyle Transition to 2050Patrick Niemann
This webinar presentation summarized findings from the EU-InnovatE project, which models and measures sustainable lifestyle transitions to 2050. The project uses an agent-based model to simulate societies and evaluate the impact of adopting user innovations in different domains like food, energy, living and mobility. Emerging findings show that widespread adoption of various user innovations across these domains has the potential to transition European societies to sustainable consumption levels. Public policies and societal interventions that accelerate innovation adoption can significantly reduce carbon emissions and resource use. The project will continue measuring trends, designing future scenarios, and evaluating pathways to accelerate sustainable entrepreneurship and lifestyle changes.
7th Session: Workshop II on a Roadmap to Future Government
In this session we proceed to presentations and discussion concerning the the development of the new roadmap for digital government. Two projects (Gov3.0 and Big Policy Canvas) will join forces in this exciting endeavor.
Organizers: Maria Wimmer, Professor, Koblentz University, Germany; Francesco Mureddu, Associate Directorr, Lisbon Council, Belgium; Juliane Schmeling Fraunhofer Institut FOKUS, Researcher, Germany; Shoumaya Ben Dhaou, Researcher, United Nations University, PT
Les enjeux politiques de l’open access contre les OligopolesFrancesca Di Donato
This document discusses open access and its role in challenging publisher oligopolies. It defines open access as free online access to scholarly works, and outlines two main open access strategies: self-archiving in repositories ("green road") and publishing in open access journals ("gold road"). The dominance of a few large commercial publishers is addressed, as is the "serials crisis" of rising subscription costs limiting library budgets. The document recommends policies like institutional open access mandates and funder open access policies to promote open access goals of increased access, impact, and innovation.
Proeftraining Social Media Volksuniversiteit HengeloBoth social
Op vrijdag 14 september was het Happy Hour bij de Volksuniversiteit Hengelo. Tijdens het Happy Hour kan je gratis kennismaken met de verschillende trainingen van de volksuniversiteit.
Menno Both verzorgde een proeftraining over social media. Hoe kan je social media nu inzetten als MKB ondernemer? Wat zijn de voordelen voor de MKB ondernemer? Dit kwam tijdens het Happy Hour allemaal voorbij.
English presentation Saxion 22 may 2013Both social
Een Engelse presentatie van Menno Both op het Saxion op 22 mei. Voor een groep internationale studenten gesproken over de voordelen van social media voor marketing.
Social update tijdens Business Meets TwenteBoth social
Tijdens Business Meets Twente gaf Menno Both een social update over korte video's van Vine en Instagram Video. Vine is een nieuw platform waarop gebruikers 6 sec. film kunnen maken.
Op 18 december gaf Menno Both een terugblik op de ontwikkelingen van social media in 2013. De terugblik ging over trends, ontwikkelingen en nieuwe technieken geintroduceerd in 2013 en een vooruitblik naar 2014
Op donderdag 20 februari gaf Menno Both een presentatie bij de netwerkclub tobe. Samen met Tim Fabels van Combidesk verzorgde hij een presentatie over de inzet van social media.
De social update van maart. Vol met een interactieve workshop. Ook een keer een social update bijwonen? Registreer je hier: http://www.bothsocial.nl/social-updates/
Op 7 februari 2013 gaf Menno Both een presentatie over social media in de drukindustrie bij GEA Communicatielogistiek. GEA is expert op het gebied van in- en uitgaande communicatie-
stromen en daarmee dé partij in het begeleiden van media-
transities. GEA realiseert verandering en versterkt het innovatievermogen van organisaties.
Cultuurkwartiertje tijdens culturele zondagBoth social
Tijdens de culturele zondag in Enschede gaf Menno Both invulling aan een van de culturele kwartiertjes in de Villa van Heek. In een kwartier tijd kwamen verschillende onderwerpen m.b.t. social media aan bod. Het kwartiertje smaakte naar meer...
Social media awareness training Europa KinderhulpBoth social
Op 22 maart hield Menno Both van Both Social een Social media awareness training voor Europa Kinderhulp over het gebruik van social media. Daarnaast werden een aantal basis tips gedeeld. Meer informatie over trainingen van Both Social: http://www.bothsocial.nl
Awareness training overheid en social mediaBoth social
Tijdens de bijeenkomst van Both social op 4 september met als thema overheid en social media is er een levendige discussie ontstaan over het gebruik van social media.
Samen met Efthymios Constantinides (Universiteit Twente) gaf Menno Both (Both social) invulling aan de Business & Science meeting van IKT / TKT en de Faculity club op 16 april 2013. Het thema van deze bijeenkomst was, hoe kan het ook anders, "social media."
Report on current policies and regulatory frameworksOles Kulchytskyy
The Report on current policies and regulatory frameworks for social media and content convergence: information disorder, human rights and regulatory implications (D2.1) provides a
comprehensive insight into regulatory and governance initiatives addressing the human rights concerns related to information disorder in social media and a better understanding of the
regulatory and governance implications, including their potential impact on the fragmentation of the single market.
The information is prepared by the team of the COMPACT project (http://compact-media.eu/).
COMPACT is a Coordination and Support Action funded European Commission under framework Horizon 2020.
The objective of the COMPACT project is to increase awareness (including scientific, political, cultural, legal, economic and technical areas) of the latest technological discoveries among key stakeholders in the context of social media and convergence. The project will offer analyses and road maps of related initiatives. In addition, extensive research on policies and regulatory frameworks in media and content will be developed.
Open Data and the transparency of the lists of beneficiaries of EU Regional P...OpenCoesione
This document discusses open data and transparency regarding lists of beneficiaries of EU regional policy funding. It summarizes the results of surveys conducted in 2010-2012 that evaluated how openly and usefully different EU countries and regions published this funding data. The surveys found three main strategies for publishing the data and that over time more regions/countries shifted towards a balanced approach considering both data openness and usability. Open questions remain regarding factors influencing transparency and how to best promote civic engagement with the data.
This document discusses understanding and improving the uptake and utilization of open data. It aims to present the state of open data programs, highlight opportunities in open data adoption, and identify issues and challenges.
The document provides background on the continued interest in open data and the growing adoption by institutions. It summarizes findings from recent surveys that show over 380 open data catalogs globally and over 150 in Europe. The 2013 Open Data Barometer is discussed, which ranks countries' open data readiness, implementation, and impact. The UK ranks as most advanced while few datasets are truly open with accessible licenses and formats.
Issues and challenges to open data uptake include few high-value datasets, lack of access to information laws, and limited training
Report on future policies and regulatory frameworksOles Kulchytskyy
The Report on future policies and regulatory frameworks for social media and content convergence: information disorder, human rights and regulatory implications (D2.3) gives a comprehensive insight into the functioning of the regulatory and governance initiatives addressing the human rights concerns related to information disorder in social media. Moreover, it provides better understanding of the regulatory and governance implications of such efforts, including their potential impact on policy definition, incentives employed, State’s involvement, building societal trust, etc. In addition to the contents planned with the project Grant Agreement and due to the situation with the world COVID-19 pandemic, this particular context and its implications on the topics discussed here is also addressed in the report.
The information is prepared by the team of the COMPACT project (http://compact-media.eu/).
COMPACT is a Coordination and Support Action funded European Commission under framework Horizon 2020.
The objective of the COMPACT project is to increase awareness (including scientific, political, cultural, legal, economic and technical areas) of the latest technological discoveries among key stakeholders in the context of social media and convergence. The project will offer analyses and road maps of related initiatives. In addition, extensive research on policies and regulatory frameworks in media and content will be developed.
Trigger.eu: Cocteau game for policy making - introduction and demoMarco Brambilla
COCTEAU stands for "Co-Creating the European Union".
It's a project supported by the European Union whose objective is to involve citizens to cooperate alongside policy makers, contributing to build a better future.
Open Government Data: What it is, Where it is Going, and the Opportunities fo...OECD Governance
Keynote presentation given by Ryan Androsoff (Digital Government Policy Analyst, OECD) at the 2015 EUROSAI-OLACEFS conference in Quito, Ecuador on 25 June 2015. Focus of the presentation is on Open Government Data and the opportunities for Supreme Audit Institutions presented by open data. Video of the presentation is available at: https://youtu.be/SlBfxmecJhI?t=1h50m19s
For more information on OECD's work relating to Open Government Data please see: http://www.oecd.org/gov/public-innovation/open-government-data.htm
Open data barometer global report - 2nd edition yann le gigan
This document provides an introduction and overview of the Open Data Barometer report. The report analyzes global trends in open data by assessing countries' readiness, implementation, and impact of open data initiatives. It finds that while open data initiatives have spread rapidly, more work is needed to support data-enabled democracy worldwide and ensure data access, skills, and freedoms are distributed equitably. The report evaluates 86 countries across different clusters and provides recommendations for tailoring open data strategies based on countries' varying capacities and needs. It aims to contribute to understanding challenges and opportunities in realizing open data's potential to increase transparency, empower citizens, and inspire innovation.
The Open Data Barometer aims to uncover the true prevalence and impact of open data initiatives around the world. It analyses global trends, and provides comparative data on countries and regions via an in-depth methodology combining contextual data, technical assessments and secondary indicators to explore multiple dimensions of open data readiness, implementation and impact.
This is the second edition of the Open Data Barometer, completing a two-year pilot of the Barometer methodology and providing data for comparative research. This report is just one expression of the Barometer, for which full data is also available, supporting secondary research into the progression of open data policies and practices across the world.
The Open Data Barometer forms part of the World Wide Web Foundation’s work on common assessment methods for open data.
This document summarizes the Leveraging Big Data to Manage Transport Operations (LeMO) project. The 3-year project, funded by the EU, aims to (1) produce a research roadmap for using big data in transport; (2) involve stakeholders to identify opportunities and barriers; and (3) disseminate findings. It will conduct 7 case studies on topics like rail transport, open data, and logistics. The project aims to enhance sustainability and competitiveness in transport through big data analysis of modes, sectors, technologies, policies, and evaluations. It will provide a framework for a consistent European big data strategy in transport.
Urban data platforms presentation 27 9-2018 by Marcel van OosterhoutRUGGEDISED Project
Trust is a vital factor for the successful adoption and use of urban data platforms. Some key points regarding trust and public vs private platform operators:
- Trust in data quality and security of the platform are major concerns for users that can limit adoption. This is a bigger challenge for private operators who may be perceived as more interested in commercial goals than public interests.
- Public platform operators, like municipalities, may engender more initial trust as they are seen as motivated by serving public/civic goals rather than private profits. However, they still need to demonstrate strong data governance, security practices and responsiveness to build sustained trust.
- Private operators can build trust by being transparent about data practices, security measures, privacy protections and having independent
This document summarizes a session from the imaGIne Conference 2014 on open source and open data for geographic information (GI). The session included presentations on open data policies and economic impacts from the European Commission, contributions to open standards and software, and open data and content as foundations for open educational resources. A panel discussion addressed how open source GI and European open data policy can drive wider use of GI. Key points included the anticipated impacts of revisions to the Public Sector Information Directive, opportunities and challenges around open data and skills gaps in handling large geospatial data. The session provided perspectives from policy, education, and technical viewpoints on enabling open data.
Research Policy Monitoring in the Era of Open Science & Big Data Workshop ReportData4Impact
Workshop on Research Policy Monitoring in the Era of Open Science and Big Data was a two day event, co-organised by OpenAIRE and Data4Impact, with support of Science Europe. The event explored mechanisms for research policy monitoring and indicators, and how to link these to infrastructure and services. The first day was focused on open science indicators as these emerge from national and EU initiatives, while the second day explored more advanced aspects of indicators for innovation and societal impact.
Ukraine has been a member of the Open Government Partnership (OGP) since 2011. Its current action plan has 26 commitments related to access to information, civic engagement, e-government, and anti-corruption. The next plan should focus on implementing and enforcing laws passed. Despite political difficulties, Ukraine has made significant progress passing open government laws. It should participate in peer learning and exchange through OGP working groups and meetings to focus on areas like public procurement and reducing red tape.
Open Government Data Ecosystems: Linking Transparency for Innovation with Tra...Luigi Reggi
Presentation at IFIP EGOV 2016 Conference. September 5, 2016.
Abstract. The rhetoric of open government data (OGD) promises that data transparency will lead to multiple public benefits: economic and social innovation, civic participation, public-private collaboration, and public accountability. In reality much less has been accomplished in practice than advocates have hoped. OGD research to address this gap tends to fall into two streams – one that focuses on data publication and re-use for purposes of innovation, and one that views publication as a stimulus for civic participation and government accountability - with little attention to whether or how these two views interact. In this paper we use an ecosystem perspective to explore this question. Through an exploratory case study we show how two related cycles of influences can flow from open data publication. The first addresses transparency for innovation goals, the second addresses larger issues of data use for public engagement and greater government accountability. Together they help explain the potential and also the barriers to reaching both kinds of goals.
I principali risultati del progetto sono: la federazione dei portali delle Regioni partecipanti, che permette di effettuare ricerche di dati contemporaneamente su tutti i portali, anche attraverso soluzioni per la transnazionalità di metadati; le app sviluppate - a partire dai dati liberati nel progetto - nel contesto di HACK4MED, hackathon internazionale che si è svolto in sei sedi di cinque paesi diversi.
Il progetto ha recentemente organizzato un evento, nel contesto dell’European week of regions and cities 'Open Days 2014', in cui si è discusso del futuro degli Open Data nella Agenda Digitale Europea.
More info: http://homerproject.eu/
The document summarizes the work of the Moldova Innovation Lab, which aims to improve public services and policies in Moldova. The Lab works to redesign public services through simplifying processes and digitizing services. It also tests new approaches to policymaking, such as using evidence-based research, behavioral insights, and crowdsourcing ideas from citizens. Current projects include streamlining residence registration and helping migrants find work, as well as gathering community feedback to better inform local planning. The Lab brings together experts and partners to apply skills like service design, data analysis, and citizens engagement to pilot innovative solutions for public authorities in Moldova.
The document discusses the upcoming European Commission eGovernment Action Plan for 2016-2020. The action plan will focus on three pillars: 1) Digitalizing public administration with ICT, 2) Enabling cross-border mobility with digital public services, and 3) Facilitating participation in policymaking and co-creation of services. It will implement objectives agreed at the EU level and allow citizens to suggest voluntary actions. A stakeholder consultation platform will crowdsource ideas, apply selection criteria, and monitor implementation of actions using data. The overall goal is to modernize public administration and facilitate interaction between governments and citizens/businesses across Europe.
“Open Research Data: Implications for Science and Society”, Warsaw, Poland, May 28–29, 2015, conference organized by the Open Science Platform — an initiative of the Interdisciplinary Centre for Mathematical and Computational Modelling at the University of Warsaw. pon.edu.pl @OpenSciPlatform #ORD2015
Similar to E-Society 2016 - The GOV Indicator - Mark Verhijde (20)
Het artikel Identiteitsdragers behandelt de verschillende vormen van burgerbetrokkenheid bij openbare verlichting. Het artikel is geplaatst in het blad 'Ruimte en Licht' 2016 - 2 van Acquire Publishing. Met verwijzingen en links.
In dit artikel schrijf ik over het fenomeen Tiny Houses, naar aanleiding van het interview met Gerard Dijkstra, Mill Home. Met relevante verwijzingen en links. Verschenen in Stedenbouw & Architectuur 2016 nr 3 van Acquire Publishing.
Meer Participatie - Mark Verhijde - SBO opleiding Wijk- en Gebiedsmanager jun...Mark Verhijde
Voor Studiecentrum Bedrijf en Overheid (SBO) heb ik als docent dag 3 van de opleiding Wijk- en Gebiedsmanager 2016 verzorgd. Onderwerpen zijn burgerparticipatie, maatschappelijke initiatieven, games en gamechangers, en strategieën van 'sterke trekkers'.
Mark Verhijde - Groen en smaakvol LeeuwardenMark Verhijde
Artikel in Stedenbouw & Architectuur 2015-6 van Acquire Publishing: Stedenspecial Leeuwarden, over burgerparticipatie, groene maatschappelijke initiatieven en gemeentelijke programmasturing op duurzaamheid en vergroening van Leeuwarden. Met dank aan Gjalt Faber, Daniel Appelo en Sjoerd Jelle Wiersma.
Mark Verhijde - De Participatiesamenleving is een grote kans voor bedrijven e...Mark Verhijde
Artikel in BuitenBeeld 2015-2, Struyk Verwo Infra, met dank aan Elisabeth Voogt, LVB Networks. Voorbeelden onder meer Zelfsturing Grootstraat Merselo, Venray.
Presentatie voor de meerdaagse JS Consultancy Training "De Overheid als Regisseur; wat betekent dit voor beleidsadvseurs in het sociaal domein", gehouden op maandag 22 februari 2016 te Amsterdam.
SBO Presentatie Mark Verhijde - Burgerinitiatieven Mark Verhijde
Voor woningcorporaties Site Woondiensten, De Woonplaats en Sallant Wonen heb ik op dinsdag 23 juni als gastdocent een presentatie over burgerinitiatieven gehouden, in het kader van de SBO in-company opleiding Wijk- en Gebiedsmanagers Nieuwe Stijl, samen met hoofddocent Tom de Haas.
Mark Verhijde - Interim programmamanager en adviseur stedelijke ontwikkelingMark Verhijde
In deze presentatie kunt u een overzicht van mijn werkzaamheden vinden, als projectleider, programmamanager, kwartiermaker, adviseur, trainer en onderzoeker.
Burgerinitiatieven - PPT SBO-opleiding Nieuwe Wijk- en Gebiedsmanagers Dag 3 ...Mark Verhijde
Voor SBO - Studiecentrum voor Bedrijf en Overheid, opleiding Nieuwe Wijk- en Gebiedsmanagers die door hoofddocent Tom de Haas in company gegeven wordt aan woningcorporatie Viveste te Houten, heb ik voor dag 3 het thema Burgerinitiatieven gepresenteerd.
Burgerinitiatieven - Dialoog met Vereniging StadswerkMark Verhijde
Tijdens het Diner Pensant van de Vereniging Stadswerk op donderdag 13 november 2014 mocht ik deze dialoog aangaan, over burgerinitiatieven, de publicatie Regel die Burgerinitiatieven (Acquire Publishing, Zwolle 2014) en met de 40 aanwezigen echt praten over veiligheid, risico's, aansprakelijkheid en schade. In Villa Jongerius Utrecht.
Presentation 3e Project Meeting Magdeburg DE, Open Government in Europe Proje...Mark Verhijde
Civic Initiatives vs. Legal Issues in the Netherlands and beyond has been discussed at the Magdeburg 3e Project Meeting of the Open Governement in Europe Project, part of the GRUNDTVIG Lifelong Learning Partnership (LLP) Program. It deals with several aspects on the broad domain of liability, damages and risk-management in the Netherlands, wrt. DIY & civic initiatives in public space.
Rapport regel die burgerinitiatieven bijlagen - december 2013 klMark Verhijde
Dit document bevat de bijlagen bij het rapport Regel die Burgerinitiatieven, het resultaat van het BZK-onderzoek Burgerinitiatieven en Aansprakelijkheid, dat Maarten Bosman (M.Bosman BV) en ik gehouden hebben in 2013, samen met 3 gemeenten en 5 expertorganisaties.
Folder meedoen met vervolgacties regel die burgerinitiatievenMark Verhijde
Deze folder bevat het overzicht aan vervolgacties uit het rapport Regel die Burgerinitiatieven, het BZK-onderzoek dat Maarten Bosman (M.Bosman BV) en ik gehouden hebben in 2013. De vervolgacties starten in 2014 en lopen door tot 2016.
Rapport regel die burgerinitiatieven december 2013 klMark Verhijde
Het rapport Regel die Burgerinitiatieven is het resultaat van het BZK-onderzoek Burgerinitiatieven en Aansprakelijkheid, dat Maarten Bosman (M.Bosman BV) en ik in 2013 gehouden hebben, samen met de gemeenten Deventer, Den Helder en Venray, en de expertorganisaties CROW, LPB - Platform voor Wijkgericht Werken, Stichting WijkAlliantie, Bureau EN de Buurt en juridisch adviesbureau Van Alphen. Bij het rapport hoort een bijlagen document en een folder met vervolgacties (zie andere Slideshare documenten).
Korte presentatie Regel die Burgerinitiatieven - Pakhuis de Zwijger Amsterdam...Mark Verhijde
Voor de deelsessie over Amsterdamse Versnellingszones gaven Maarten Bosman en ik deze presentatie. Kort, veel plaatjes, fijne risico-inschattingschema en aparte sheet Goed Gedogen is een Kunst.
The Power of Community Newsletters: A Case Study from Wolverton and Greenleys...Scribe
YOU WILL DISCOVER:
The engaging history and evolution of Wolverton and Greenleys Town Council's newsletter
Strategies for producing a successful community newsletter and generating income through advertising
The decision-making process behind moving newsletter design from in-house to outsourcing and its impacts
Dive into the success story of Wolverton and Greenleys Town Council's newsletter in this insightful webinar. Hear from Mandy Shipp and Jemma English about the newsletter's journey from its inception to becoming a vital part of their community's communication, including its history, production process, and revenue generation through advertising. Discover the reasons behind outsourcing its design and the benefits this brought. Ideal for anyone involved in community engagement or interested in starting their own newsletter.
Presentation by Rebecca Sachs and Joshua Varcie, analysts in CBO’s Health Analysis Division, at the 13th Annual Conference of the American Society of Health Economists.
Jennifer Schaus and Associates hosts a complimentary webinar series on The FAR in 2024. Join the webinars on Wednesdays and Fridays at noon, eastern.
Recordings are on YouTube and the company website.
https://www.youtube.com/@jenniferschaus/videos
How To Cultivate Community Affinity Throughout The Generosity JourneyAggregage
This session will dive into how to create rich generosity experiences that foster long-lasting relationships. You’ll walk away with actionable insights to redefine how you engage with your supporters — emphasizing trust, engagement, and community!
karnataka housing board schemes . all schemesnarinav14
The Karnataka government, along with the central government’s Pradhan Mantri Awas Yojana (PMAY), offers various housing schemes to cater to the diverse needs of citizens across the state. This article provides a comprehensive overview of the major housing schemes available in the Karnataka housing board for both urban and rural areas in 2024.
Bharat Mata - History of Indian culture.pdfBharat Mata
Bharat Mata Channel is an initiative towards keeping the culture of this country alive. Our effort is to spread the knowledge of Indian history, culture, religion and Vedas to the masses.
Presentation by Julie Topoleski, CBO’s Director of Labor, Income Security, and Long-Term Analysis, at the 16th Annual Meeting of the OECD Working Party of Parliamentary Budget Officials and Independent Fiscal Institutions.
Jennifer Schaus and Associates hosts a complimentary webinar series on The FAR in 2024. Join the webinars on Wednesdays and Fridays at noon, eastern.
Recordings are on YouTube and the company website.
https://www.youtube.com/@jenniferschaus/videos
E-Society 2016 - The GOV Indicator - Mark Verhijde
1. THE GOV INDICATOR: LEARNING FROM
GOOD PRACTICES OFTHE EU GRUNDTVIG
LLP PROJECT OPENGOVEU 2013-2015
MarkVerhijde, Menno Both & Piet Kommers
14th International Conference on e-Society 2016
9 – 11 April,Villamoura, Algarve, Portugal
2. Overview
1. Open Government in Europe – Grundtvig LLL EU project 2013 - 2015
2. Analyzing dataset of 62 Good Practices
3. Models on government and active citizenship
4. Introducing GOV-indicator: 3 different kinds of government-citizens relationships
5. Applying GOV to OPENGOVEU dataset
6. Extending GOV to other datasets
7. Testing GOV –Transitions
8. Summary
2
4. EURO-NET (Project Coordinator)
IT - Italy
Naduvere Village Association
EE - Estonia
University Twente
NL -The Netherlands FA - Magdeburg GmbH
DE - Germany
Dimos Paionias (Municipality Of
Paionia)
GR - Greece
Governorship of Kirsehir
TK - Turkey
Interacting UK Limited
UK - United Kingdom
Societatea Nationala
de Cruce Rosie din
Romania, Filiala Sibiu
RO – Romania
LIPOR
Intermunicipal Waste Management
of Greater Porto
PT - Portugal
Connexion
Roumanie
FR - France
Euro-Idea Fundacja
Spoleczno-Kulturalna
PL - Poland
Associazione EURO
TWINS
IT - Italy
Intermezzo Ungdomsorganisasjon
NO - Norway
1. OPENGOVEU - Partners
• Programme LLP - Grundtvig Learning Partnership
• EU project 2013 – 2015
• 12 countries, 13 partners
4
5. 1. OPENGOVEU - Aims and Activities
• Promote the principles of the Open Government Declaration endorsed already by
34 countries in the world
• Investigate good practice examples of OG from across Europe
• Discuss the future of OG which will involve both public bodies and stakeholders
• Generate guidelines and innovative tools to activate participation which will be of
practical use for both public institutions and citizens (e.g. a manual style e-book)
• Disseminate the results and outputs of the project.This will include a database of
available materials on our internet platform.
5
9. 1. OPENGOVEU – Good Practices examples
9
https://data.gov.uk/
10. 1. OPENGOVEU – Good Practices examples
10
http://krakow.pl/budzet
11. 1. OPENGOVEU - Results
• Guide on Open Government in Europe, 3 chapters:
• Open Government
• Active citizenship
• Smart Cities
• Guide of Open SpaceTechnology, World Café and other tools/methods to activate
the citizens
• Best Practice Handbook, with 13 examples
• Dataset of 62 Good Practices
• Excellent evaluations on project results and projects meetings
• Ongoing dissemination of project results by project partners and fans
11
12. 1. OPENGOVEU – Dataset Good Practices
The research about good practice examples is based on the Preliminary research
(2013) about available tools, websites and activities that support Open
Government present and available in each partner own country.
It is composed by 5 examples from each country out of 3 categories (topics) below.
Categories (Topics):
1. Open Data -Transparency
2. E-government tools
3. Citizen Awareness and engagement (Participation)
Criteria used to select Good Practices: Innovative, Realistic Implementation, Impact
assessment,Transferability (not mandatory),Viability (not mandatory)
12
14. 2. Analyzing DatasetGood Practices
• Dataset consists of 62 examples, which refer to one or more categories (topics)
• Open Data –Transparency: 22 references
• E-government tools: 14 references
• CitizenAwareness and engagement (Participation): 32 references
• Broad selection of Good Practices due to difference in partners and backgrounds
• Online instruments (websites, Apps) are governmental, commercial or societal
• Not all Good Practices rely on online instruments
• Portugal – Participatory budgeting for schoolchildren
• Turkey – City and Counsel Human Rights Committee
• The Netherlands – Research on Civic Initiatives, DIY's & Liability
14
15. 2. Analyzing DatasetGood Practices
• Good Practices also differ in individual launch date (and thus on impact)
• UK – MySociety (2003)
• Italy – OpenPolis (2006)
• France – Regards Citoyens (2009)
• Greece – “Cl@rity” Program (2010)
• The Netherlands – Amsterdam Digital map on temporary use of available wastelands (2011)
• Italy – deRev (2013)
• Poland – Participatory budgeting pilot project in Kraków (2013)
• No comparable information about use of Good Practices, their results and their
effects is available.
15
16. 2. Analyzing DatasetGood Practices
Summarizing:
• Dataset of Good Practice examples offers an inspiring and rich overview of new
and innovative methods and instruments with respect to Open Government and
Active Citizenship.
• Selecting up to five Good Practices per project partner allows for state-of-the-art
examples from the perspective of each partner.
• Comparing between and learning from these Good Practices is not easy.
• Implementing these Good Practices to one’s own situation is quite hard.
16
17. 2. Analyzing DatasetGood Practices
• Categories (topics) may not be the right instrument for ordering or evaluating the
Dataset.
• Standard benchmarks are limited to single category examples only (Socrata Open
Government Data Benchmark; EC eGovernment Benchmark Framework 2012-2015)
• OPENGOVEU partners did select 13 Best Practices from Dataset by voting.
• Best Practices examples tend to appreciate a new government-society relationship.
• Dataset analysis tool must include or refer to relationship between government and
citizens (society).
17
18. 3. Models on government and active citizenship
18
19. 3. Models on government and active citizenship
New Public Management
Policy Performance
Network Governance
Stakeholders and directors
Public Administration
Legitimacy and Laws
Responsive Government
DIY’s and Citizens’ Initiatives
19
20. 3. Models on government and active citizenship
New Public Management
Policy Performance
Network Governance
Stakeholders and directors
Public Administration
Legitimacy and Laws
Responsive Government
DIY’s and Citizens’ Initiatives
20
21. 3. Models on government and active citizenship
21
22. 3. Models on government and active citizenship
User participation Community
engagement
Citizens’ initiatives
Customers feedback,
public consultation
on invitation of public
administration
Volunteers
in care, sports or
education
Do it yourself
on urban farming or
sustainability
Policy making Societal activities Bottom-up activities
22
23. 3. Models on government AND active citizenship
23
24. 4. Introducing GOV-indicator
GOV 1.0
Top down government instruments
including occasional feedback from citizens
and public consultation
Optimizing organization, efficiency,
customer contacts (services),
managing on input-output items.
24
25. 4. Introducing GOV-indicator
GOV 2.0
Interactive government policy
with more regular and intense
top down and bottom up
interaction and communication,
resulting in co-creation and
coproduction often referred to as
(more) governance.
New services, new methods, new products,
sometimes even new type of organization,
managing input-output items.
25
26. 4. Introducing GOV-indicator
GOV 3.0
Policy making and government
positioning in network society, as
one stakeholder among many
others.
Agenda setting, creating arenas for knowledge exchange,
discussion and decision-making, managing some output but
mostly outcome items, with specific goals, timeframes.
26
27. 4. Introducing GOV-indicator
GOV 1.0
Good Practices as GOV 1.0 examples typically involve top-down
digital tools and methods, websites, portals, benchmarks,
sometime as services.
GOV 2.0
Good Practices that show GOV 2.0 aspects may involve digital tools
and methods but mostly stimulate citizens to interact and co-work
on problems and solutions, or perhaps provide budgets for society
to actually realize such co-productions.
GOV 3.0
Good Practices with GOV 3.0 structure concern civic initiatives, with
or without governmental involvement.
27
28. 5. Applying GOV to Dataset
62 Good Practice (GP) examples are categorized as GOV 1.0, GOV 2.0 or GOV 3.0
From the 62 Good Practices 13 Best Practices (BP) have been selected:
28
GOV 1.0 GOV 2.0 GOV 3.0
34 GP (50 %) 24 GP (40 %) 6 GP (10 %)
GOV 1.0 GOV 2.0 GOV 3.0
4 BP (31 %) 7 BP (54 %) 2 BP (15 %)
29. 5. Applying GOV to Dataset – GOV 1.0
29
GOV 1.0 Tag Transparency
Open Data DATA.GOV.UK (UK) open data license, free access/use
The UK GP regulates the specifics, free access and use of open data.
Other examples are: Both Norwegian GP’s Openness and information integrity, and National Archives and the Noark-
5 Standard; Greece GP data.gov.gr; and France GP Etalab data.gouv.fr & Dataconnexions, on health data.
Tag - general description
Brief content on GP’s function
Name GP
Overview of similar GP examples
30. 5. Applying GOV to Dataset – GOV 1.0
30
GOV 1.0 Tag Accountability
Volis (EST) transparency, policy monitoring,
The Estonian BP allows any citizen to follow online and livestream their politicians’ acts and decisions and react on
that information.
Similar examples on accountability are: UK GP Ward Surgeries, allows citizens to follow their MP’s; Greece BP
Cl@rity program, forcing that every government decision is published on the internet; and Italian Perla PA.
31. 5. Applying GOV to Dataset – GOV 1.0
31
GOV 1.0 Tag user-participation
Partecipa! (IT) public consultation, e-government
The Italian GP Participa! aims to contribute to the national Open Government program, using a particular form of
public consultation on various policy items.
Similar examples on user-participation are: Italian GP’s MiglioraPA (enhance PA) targets customer satisfaction on
digital services, and comuni-chiame; Romanian GP OPENBUDGET.RO gives budget information to be manipulated by
users; Poland GP’s Fix my street - Naprawmy to, and Public Transportation journey planner - jakdojade.pl, both making
public data available with interaction options.
32. 5. Applying GOV to Dataset – GOV 1.0
32
GOV 1.0 Tag e-Government Tools
Government websites GOV.UK (UK) centralizing public websites
GOV.UK ensures that any public data and information regarding public administration is traceable and found using a
single digital access
Several GP’s can be categorized on e-Government. Some interesting examples are: Italian GP Compass of
Transparency, benchmarking public websites on quality and efficiency, with user participation; Romanian BP E-
GUVERNARE.RO; Turkey GP Bimer applications "Alo 150" ensures telephone contact with central PA is possible; France
GP Comite Interministriel pour les Archives de France provides digital access to decentralized district archives; and Italian
GP Linea Amica (Friendly Line), a nation-wide citizens care system based on multi-channel approach.
33. 5. Applying GOV to Dataset – GOV 2.0
33
GOV 2.0 Tag Governance
Open Estonian Foundation (OEF) accountability, social cohesion
Non-profit OEF, founding member of NEON, aims for more governance and social cohesion in Estonia by helping
grassroots initiatives and municipalities.
Other examples are: Estonian GP e-Governance Academy (eGA); UK GP Create the Debate, to actively stimulate
political discussions; France BP Commision Nationale de Debat Public (CNDP) and GP Regards Citoyens (Circulating and
sharing policy information); Dutch BP Research on Civic Initiatives, DIY's & Liability, which shows how legal issues may
or may not block activities of citizens.
34. 5. Applying GOV to Dataset – GOV 2.0
34
GOV 2.0 Tag Accountability
City and County Human Rights Committee (TR) transparency, representative democracy
The Turkey BP Human Rights Committee introduces a new tool to deal with potential inequality within the society.
Similar examples that involve accountability are: Turkey GP City Council; and UK BP MYSOCIETY.ORG, a set of
digital tools on democratic accountability.
35. 5. Applying GOV to Dataset – GOV 2.0
35
GOV 2.0 Tag Co-creation
Amsterdam Digital map temporary use available wastelands (NL) tool participatory democracy
The Dutch GP collects and digitally displays information on empty wastelands, thus stimulating active citizenship,
startups and entrepreneurship.
Other GP’s on co-creation are: Greece GP’s Conference Open access to scientific knowledge (NIRST), aims to open up
expert knowledge to citizens, and Study to sustainability of open data infrastructure; Estonian GP Infosystem of Drafts (EIS);
and Norwegian BP Company register as data (Bronnoysund Register Centre), on re-using public data.
36. 5. Applying GOV to Dataset – GOV 2.0
36
GOV 2.0 Tag Participatory Tools
Strategy sustainable development Ighiu, Alba Iulia public consultation, e-government
In the Romanian GP on sustainable development society and municipalities plan and realize as coproducing partners.
Many GP’s use interactive participatory tools, such as: Portuguese GP’s LA21 in the Parish Councils and the Landmark
EU-project Public Procurement, and BP Participatory budgeting for children; Poland BP Participatory budgeting pilot project
in Krakow, and GP My Country – mojePanstwo; Dutch GP’s MyBorne2030 and Winterswijk - Villages without rules (Dorp
zonder regels); and Estonian GP Participation Web.
37. 5. Applying GOV to Dataset – GOV 3.0
37
GOV 3.0 Tag Social Innovation
Open Public Data Hackathon contest (GR) re-use public data
The Greece GP shows that events such as Open Public Data Hackathon contest results in new life for public data.
Other examples: German BP Open Data Portal Berlin (BODS); Italian BP deRev on discussion, social innovation and
crowdfunding; and Portuguese LIPOR GP Horta a Porta - Biological Kitchen Garden of Porto's Region on food and
sustainability.
38. 5. Applying GOV to Dataset – GOV 3.0
38
GOV 3.0 Tag Accountability
Openpolis (IT) transparency, e-government
Italian GP Openpolis is an independent organization that allows citizens to have access to public data, acts and
motivations of policy makers and members of parliament. Since 2009 it has developed from providing public information to
an actually online debate center in Italy, in coproduction with many parties and citizens.
40. 6. Extending GOV to other datasets
Argument
• GOV-typology is based on three kinds of relationship between government (public
administration) and citizens (society).
• It does not refer to specific organizational models of governments.
• Neither does it refer to different types of active citizenship.
• It includes both online and offline projects and activities.
Thus:
• GOV-typology should be applicable to any government-citizens relationship.
40
41. 6. Extending GOV to other datasets
• Some examples that aim to provide information on budgets and spending of local
governments (municipalities) or companies.
• GOV 1.0 : Dutch examples www.watdoethengelo.nl ; www.openspending.nl ;
www.begrotingswijzer.nl ;
• GOV 2.0 : Belgium example of Participatory Budgeting by the city of Antwerp
(What would you do with 1 million Euro’s?)
www.antwerpen.be/nl/overzicht/burgerbegroting-district-antwerpen/projecten-
2014-2015
• GOV 3.0 : International citizens’ initiative due to leaked Panama papers (Follow
the money) www.panamapapers.icij.org
41
42. 7.Testing GOV –Transitions
• GOV-typology aims to order and categorize Good Practices.
• GP’s may change their initial GOV status, due to time and scale:
• Volis (EST) has been given more functions, appears to move from GOV 1.0 to GOV 2.0
• Amsterdam Digital map temporary use available wastelands (NL) started originally as a
citizen’s initiative (GOV 3.0) but with the City ofAmsterdam transferred to GOV 2.0
• GOV status may also change due to the results of the Good Practice:
• Research on Civic Initiatives, DIY's & Liability (NL) appears to have two effects
• More knowledge and insight for local governments and their residents result stripped
legal forms and contracts (GOV 1.0)
• On the national level several experiments have been set up with active citizens to deal
with more stubborn problem on liability (GOV 3.0)
42
43. 8. Summary
• The EU-project ‘Open Government in Europe’ has resulted in a rich and inspiring
set of Good Practices.
• This dataset of 62 GP’s could not be properly analyzed, thus evaded learning from
it or applying the GP’s to own situation.
• Standard benchmark tools could not be used.
• GOV-indicator refers to 3 types of relationship of government – citizens (society).
• Comparing and learning is more easy within specific GOV stratum.
• GOV-indicator can be extended to categorize other datasets.
• GOV status may change, due to time and scale, and due to project results.
43
44. More information
• Menno Both - Both Social BV - Moutlaan 25, 7523 MC Enschede – Email:
menno@bothsocial.nl
• Piet Kommers - University ofTwente,The Netherlands - Faculty of
Behavioral Management and Social Sciences - Email:
kommers@edte.utwente.nl
• MarkVerhijde - MarkVerhijde – Interim programmamanager en adviseur
stedelijke ontwikkeling - G.Westenbergstraat 8, 7415CP Deventer – Email:
mark.Verhijde@gmail.com
44