A 20-year-old male kidney transplant recipient presented with a fever and dental pain from a mass in his lower mandible. Imaging showed a cystic space occupying lesion involving his wisdom tooth. Surgical excision of the mass and extraction of the impacted teeth was performed. Histopathology revealed the mass was a giant cell reparative granuloma. This lesion is a benign non-neoplastic tumor that can develop from local trauma or vascular injury. It is rarely reported in kidney transplant patients and careful monitoring of parathyroid hormone levels and immunosuppression is important for management.