More Related Content
What's hot
What's hot (20)
Similar to Editorial Process
Similar to Editorial Process (20)
Recently uploaded
Recently uploaded (20)
Editorial Process
- 1. The Editorial Process Thomas Lemberger
- 2. Scientific publishing The publication of scientific information is intended to move science forward. More specifically, the act of publishing is a quid pro quo in which authors receive credit and acknowledgment in exchange for disclosure of their scientific findings. Source: “Sharing Publication-Related Data and Materials: Responsibilities of Authorship in the Life Sciences”,. Board on Life Sciences, The National Academies Press (2003)
- 6. reviewers & editors readers authors
- 17. The editorial process editorial rejection review reject revise reject accept time
- 20. quality
- 22. R Aebersold GM Church L Hood E Liu P Bork Julie Ahringer Charles Auffray Ewan Birney Tom Blundell Thomas S. Deisboeck Jan Ellenberg Michael Elowitz Alan Fersht Stan Fields Mark Gerstein Frank Holstege Sung Hou Kim Hiroaki Kitano Doron Lancet Andrew J. Link Stephen Oliver Jeremy Nicholson Bernhard Palsson Rama Ranganathan Uwe Sauer Luis Serrano Lucy Shapiro Pamela Silver Michael Snyder Janet Thornton Masaru Tomita Marc Vidal Hans V. Westerhoff Lothar Willmitzer John Yates Senior Editors Advisory Board EMBO Editor
- 23. R Aebersold GM Church L Hood E Liu P Bork Julie Ahringer Charles Auffray Ewan Birney Tom Blundell Thomas S. Deisboeck Jan Ellenberg Michael Elowitz Alan Fersht Stan Fields Mark Gerstein Frank Holstege Sung Hou Kim Hiroaki Kitano Doron Lancet Andrew J. Link Stephen Oliver Jeremy Nicholson Bernhard Palsson Rama Ranganathan Uwe Sauer Luis Serrano Lucy Shapiro Pamela Silver Michael Snyder Janet Thornton Masaru Tomita Marc Vidal Hans V. Westerhoff Lothar Willmitzer John Yates Senior Editors Advisory Board EMBO Editor Scope & general policies
- 24. To review or not to review... editorial rejection review reject revise reject accept time
- 26. In case of doubt... R Aebersold GM Church L Hood E Liu P Bork Julie Ahringer Charles Auffray Ewan Birney Tom Blundell Thomas S. Deisboeck Jan Ellenberg Michael Elowitz Alan Fersht Stan Fields Mark Gerstein Frank Holstege Sung Hou Kim Hiroaki Kitano Doron Lancet Andrew J. Link Stephen Oliver Jeremy Nicholson Bernhard Palsson Rama Ranganathan Uwe Sauer Luis Serrano Lucy Shapiro Pamela Silver Michael Snyder Janet Thornton Masaru Tomita Marc Vidal Hans V. Westerhoff Lothar Willmitzer John Yates Senior Editors Advisory Board EMBO Editor
- 27. To review or not to review... editorial rejection review reject revise reject accept time
- 29. To review or not to review... editorial rejection review reject revise reject accept time
- 33. Why should I review? Source: “Peer Review Survey 2009: Preliminary Findings”, Sense About Science http://www.senseaboutscience.org.uk 16% 33% 34% 30% 46% 85% 69% 72% 90% n=3597 % agree
- 34. To review or not to review... editorial rejection review reject revise reject accept time
- 36. Post-revision review editorial rejection review reject revise reject accept time
- 38. manuscripts published paper author author author author reader reader reader reader reader Does all this come for free? 10 1-2 >1000 author
- 40. author- pay reader- pay open access subscription Th e EMBO Journal Molecul ar System s Biology
- 49. Editor?
- 50. excitement
- 52. broad
- 53. critical
- 54. reading
- 56. molecular biology systems
Editor's Notes
- Thank you ... Thank you very much to the organizers for giving me the opportunity to do a little show here.. As most of you probably know, Molecular Systems Biology is the journal published by Nature Publishing Group and EMBO that covers the fields of systems biology, systems medicine and synthetic biology.
- Strong roots in the community of researchers and highest quality standards are guaranteed by our Senior Editors and our Advisory Editorial Board...
- Strong roots in the community of researchers and highest quality standards are guaranteed by our Senior Editors and our Advisory Editorial Board...
- Open access has traditionally highlighted the role of text for text for mining purposes and accessibility to knowledge. But perhaps even more fundamental is the role of data in molecular biology. Central role of data integration implies that systems biology relies on accessibility and integrity of research data–quantitative data, computational data, and the flood of data generated by high-throughput technologies.
- Typical experiment. Quantitaion of phosphorylation levels of signaling components. How many replicates? What statistics? What are the peak values? Etc...
- Simply download the data directly from the figure. Figure and individual figure panels can be linked to excel tables or text files containing the..
- Data used to generate the graphic depiction shown in the respective figure panel. The link with the figure, the figure legend, the rest of the paper, including materials and methods, is what gives meaning to the data. It is at an experimental stage in the sense that there is usually no standard data exchange format and part of the purpose of the experiment is to see how researchers solve the problem when given only general guidelines on the format of the tables they can submit.