PromoHng	
  Energy	
  Savings	
  and	
  	
  
GHG	
  MiHgaHon	
  through	
  	
  
Industrial	
  Supply	
  Chain	
  IniHaHves	
  
eceee	
  Industrial	
  Summer	
  Study	
  
September	
  14,	
  2012,	
  Arnhem	
  
Amélie	
  Goldberg,	
  Julia	
  Reinaud,	
  Emelia	
  Holdaway,	
  Siobhan	
  O’Keeffe	
  




                                                Sharing	
  best	
  pracHces	
  for	
  the	
  low	
  carbon	
  future	
   |	
  	
  iipnetwork.org	
  
Purpose	
  and	
  IntroducHon	
  
Supply	
  chain	
  iniHaHves	
  a	
  promising	
  means	
  to	
  achieve	
  energy	
  and	
  
climate	
  goals	
  among	
  a	
  number	
  of	
  disparate	
  businesses	
  and	
  across	
  
naHonal	
  borders	
  	
  

Benefits	
  for	
  buyers	
  
•  Can	
  extend	
  exisHng	
  CSR/sustainability	
  efforts	
  if	
  they	
  are	
  able	
  to	
  exert	
  significant	
  leverage	
  
   with	
  their	
  industrial	
  suppliers	
  

•  Many	
  are	
  sHll	
  not	
  exploiHng	
  opportuniHes	
  fully	
  	
  	
  

Benefits	
  for	
  suppliers	
  
•  Energy	
  savings,	
  producHvity	
  improvements,	
  co-­‐benefits	
  
•  Secure	
  long-­‐term	
  contracts	
  with	
  buyers	
  and	
  aUract	
  new	
  buyers.	
  



                                                                            Sharing	
  best	
  pracHces	
  for	
  the	
  low	
  carbon	
  future	
   |	
  	
  iipnetwork.org	
  
Ten	
  SCIs	
  profiled	
  
…	
  to	
  explore	
  a	
  range	
  of	
  approaches,	
  industrial	
  sectors	
  targeted	
  and	
  global	
  reach	
  
1.  Walmart	
  
2.  Ford	
  
3.  Prorail	
  
4.  Suzhou	
  Energy	
  Efficiency	
  Star	
  scheme	
  
5.  IKEA	
  	
  
6.  SKF	
  
7.  BriHsh	
  Gypsum	
  
8.  General	
  Electric	
  
9.  BASF	
  
10. Home	
  Depot	
  and	
  Intertek’s	
  Think	
  Green	
  IniHaHve	
  

                                                                   Sharing	
  best	
  pracHces	
  for	
  the	
  low	
  carbon	
  future	
   |	
  	
  iipnetwork.org	
  


                                                                     iipnetwork.org/databases/supply-­‐chain	
  
Key	
  Types	
  of	
  Supply	
  Chain	
  IniHaHves	
  
Type	
                            DescripHon	
                                                                                                                    ExisHng	
  Examples	
  
Mandatory	
                       The	
  buyer	
  requires	
  the	
  supplier	
  to	
  comply	
  with	
  set	
  criteria.	
  	
                                   Ford,	
  SKF	
  
performance	
  
requirements	
  

Purchasing	
  approaches	
        Buyer	
  develops	
  procurement	
  policies	
  whereby	
  suppliers	
  score	
  higher	
  or	
                                 ProRail	
  CO2	
  Performance	
  
                                  lower	
  or	
  are	
  advantaged	
  or	
  disadvantaged	
  in	
  the	
  procurement	
  process	
                                Ladder	
  
Repor;ng	
  and	
                 Suppliers	
  must	
  report	
  their	
  emissions	
  or	
  energy	
  use	
  to	
  their	
  buyers.	
                            BASF	
  
monitoring	
  

Subsidised	
  audits	
            On-­‐site	
  audits	
  (full	
  or	
  parHally	
  funded	
  by	
  the	
  buyer)	
  to	
  determine	
  a	
  supplier's	
         Walmart,	
  IKEA	
  
                                  GHG/energy	
  performance.	
  
Capacity	
  building	
  and	
     Training,	
  workshops,	
  implementaHon	
  support	
  and	
  other	
  measures	
  to	
                                         General	
  Electric,	
  Walmart	
  
implementa;on	
                   improve	
  suppliers’	
  ability	
  to	
  implement	
  energy	
  efficiency	
  projects	
  and	
  
support	
                         improve	
  their	
  performance.	
  	
  
Supplier	
  forums	
  or	
        Conferences,	
  meeHngs,	
  webinars	
  or	
  online	
  forums	
  where	
  buyers	
  can	
                                      Walmart,	
  Intertek	
  (Home	
  
coali;on	
                        communicate	
  prioriHes,	
  and	
  suppliers	
  can	
  ask	
  quesHons,	
  receive	
  feedback	
                               Depot)	
  
                                  and	
  share	
  best	
  pracHce	
  amongst	
  themselves.	
  	
  
Labeling	
                        Labeling	
  of	
  energy	
  performance	
  as	
  an	
  informaHonal	
  tool	
  for	
  buyers.	
  	
                             Suzhou	
  EE	
  Star	
  Program	
  

External	
  facilita;on	
         Plaiorms	
  that	
  help	
  connect	
  or	
  match	
  GHG/energy	
  performance	
  of	
  suppliers	
                            Intertek	
  (Home	
  Depot)	
  
tools	
                           with	
  buyers'	
  interests	
  or	
  criteria.	
  




                                                                                                      Sharing	
  best	
  pracHces	
  for	
  the	
  low	
  carbon	
  future	
   |	
  	
  iipnetwork.org	
  
Examples	
  of	
  case	
  studies	
  
General	
  Electric	
  
•  “Integrity	
  Program”,	
  onsite	
  audits	
  and	
  “Treasure	
  Hunts”	
  
•  Local	
  training	
  programs	
  and	
  supplier	
  summits	
  in	
  partnership	
  w	
  ISC,	
  WBSCD,	
  Guandong	
  Academy	
  

IKEA	
  
•  IWAY	
  code	
  of	
  conduct	
  for	
  suppliers	
  with	
  regular	
  on-­‐site	
  audits	
  
•  WWF	
  collaboraHon	
  on	
  a	
  ‘Developing	
  Climate	
  PosiHve	
  OpportuniHes	
  for	
  Suppliers’	
  

The	
  Home	
  Depot	
  
•  Works	
  through	
  Intertek’s	
  TGI	
  –	
  on-­‐site	
  assessments,	
  idenHficaHon	
  and	
  implementaHon	
  of	
  EE	
  
  measures	
  

SKF	
  
•  Supplier	
  cerHficaHon	
  of	
  ISO	
  14001	
  (and	
  recently	
  ISO	
  50001	
  announced)	
  
•  Energy	
  Challenge	
  and	
  Energy	
  Excellence	
  awards	
  


                                                                    Sharing	
  best	
  pracHces	
  for	
  the	
  low	
  carbon	
  future	
   |	
  	
  iipnetwork.org	
  
Impacts	
  of	
  selected	
  examples	
  
GE	
  
•  Between	
  2009	
  and	
  2011,	
  the	
  supplier’s	
  carbon	
  emissions	
  fell	
  by	
  19%,	
  through	
  energy	
  
   saving	
  measures	
  and	
  facility	
  upgrades	
  following	
  its	
  audiHng	
  and	
  capacity	
  building	
  
   programme.	
  	
  

IKEA	
  	
  
•  Under	
  the	
  IKEA-­‐WWF	
  partnership,	
  supplier	
  reduced	
  GHG	
  emissions	
  by	
  35%	
  between	
  2009	
  
   and	
  2010	
  through	
  furnace	
  upgrades	
  and	
  fuel	
  switching.	
  
•  Another	
  texHle	
  supplier	
  in	
  Bangladesh	
  idenHfied	
  and	
  implemented	
  a	
  number	
  of	
  efficiency	
  
   measures	
  in	
  2011	
  that	
  reduced	
  energy	
  consumpHon	
  by	
  29%	
  and	
  cut	
  CO2	
  emissions	
  by	
  
   25%.	
  

Intertek	
  (Home	
  Depot)	
  
•  TGI	
  program	
  cost	
  US$43,500	
  (paid	
  by	
  the	
  suppliers),	
  and	
  achieved	
  overall	
  cost	
  savings	
  of	
  
   over	
  $US3	
  million.	
  


                                                                        Sharing	
  best	
  pracHces	
  for	
  the	
  low	
  carbon	
  future	
   |	
  	
  iipnetwork.org	
  


                                                                          iipnetwork.org/databases/supply-­‐chain	
  
Some	
  Lessons	
  learnt	
  
Procurement	
  and	
  contractual	
  arrangements	
  can	
  
encourage	
  suppliers	
  more	
  fully	
  
InternaHonally	
  recognised	
  tools	
  
Partnership,	
  fostering	
  trust	
  and	
  implementaHon	
  
support	
  
MulH-­‐stakeholder	
  collaboraHon	
  including	
  third	
  party	
  
involvement	
  
QA,	
  transparency	
  and	
  verificaHon	
  –	
  external	
  
plaiorms	
  

                                      Sharing	
  best	
  pracHces	
  for	
  the	
  low	
  carbon	
  future	
   |	
  	
  iipnetwork.org	
  
Success	
  factors	
  




                         Sharing	
  best	
  pracHces	
  for	
  the	
  low	
  carbon	
  future	
   |	
  	
  iipnetwork.org	
  
Conclusions	
  and	
  Discussion	
  
•  Wide	
  diversity	
  of	
  approaches	
  and	
  new	
  models	
  emerging	
  
  •      Many	
  are	
  in	
  early	
  stages	
  and	
  “learning	
  by	
  doing”	
  


•  Varied	
  transparency	
  &	
  verificaHon	
  approaches	
  
•  EnMS	
  (e.g.	
  ISO	
  50001)	
  and	
  other	
  internaHonally	
  recognised	
  tools	
  are	
  
       emerging	
  as	
  promising	
  tools	
  
  •      Ouen	
  accompanied	
  by	
  MRV	
  support	
  to	
  substanHate	
  claims	
  


•  How	
  to	
  promote	
  ISO	
  50001	
  as	
  a	
  supply	
  chain	
  tool?	
  	
  
•  What	
  role	
  for	
  governments?	
  (e.g.	
  Japan,	
  Netherlands)	
  
  •      Extending	
  obligaHons	
  for	
  large	
  companies	
  to	
  take	
  acHons	
  across	
  the	
  supply	
  chain	
  




                                                                                    Sharing	
  best	
  pracHces	
  for	
  the	
  low	
  carbon	
  future	
   |	
  	
  iipnetwork.org	
  
Thank	
  you	
  

Industrial	
  Supply	
  Chain	
  IniHaHves	
  Database:	
  
www.iipnetwork.org/databases/supply-­‐chain	
  

In	
  collaboraHon	
  with	
  Ecofys	
  UK.	
  
Amelie	
  Goldberg	
                 	
  Amelie.goldberg@iipnetwork.org	
  
Julia	
  Reinaud 	
                  	
  julia.reinaud@iipnetwork.org	
  	
  
Emelia	
  Holdaway                   	
  (previously	
  with	
  Ecofys	
  UK)	
  
Siobhan	
  O’Keeffe                   	
  (previously	
  with	
  Ecofys	
  UK)	
  

                                                   Sharing	
  best	
  pracHces	
  for	
  the	
  low	
  carbon	
  future	
   |	
  	
  iipnetwork.org	
  

Promoting Energy Savings and GHG Mitigation through Industrial Supply Chain Initiatives

  • 1.
    PromoHng  Energy  Savings  and     GHG  MiHgaHon  through     Industrial  Supply  Chain  IniHaHves   eceee  Industrial  Summer  Study   September  14,  2012,  Arnhem   Amélie  Goldberg,  Julia  Reinaud,  Emelia  Holdaway,  Siobhan  O’Keeffe   Sharing  best  pracHces  for  the  low  carbon  future   |    iipnetwork.org  
  • 2.
    Purpose  and  IntroducHon   Supply  chain  iniHaHves  a  promising  means  to  achieve  energy  and   climate  goals  among  a  number  of  disparate  businesses  and  across   naHonal  borders     Benefits  for  buyers   •  Can  extend  exisHng  CSR/sustainability  efforts  if  they  are  able  to  exert  significant  leverage   with  their  industrial  suppliers   •  Many  are  sHll  not  exploiHng  opportuniHes  fully       Benefits  for  suppliers   •  Energy  savings,  producHvity  improvements,  co-­‐benefits   •  Secure  long-­‐term  contracts  with  buyers  and  aUract  new  buyers.   Sharing  best  pracHces  for  the  low  carbon  future   |    iipnetwork.org  
  • 3.
    Ten  SCIs  profiled   …  to  explore  a  range  of  approaches,  industrial  sectors  targeted  and  global  reach   1.  Walmart   2.  Ford   3.  Prorail   4.  Suzhou  Energy  Efficiency  Star  scheme   5.  IKEA     6.  SKF   7.  BriHsh  Gypsum   8.  General  Electric   9.  BASF   10. Home  Depot  and  Intertek’s  Think  Green  IniHaHve   Sharing  best  pracHces  for  the  low  carbon  future   |    iipnetwork.org   iipnetwork.org/databases/supply-­‐chain  
  • 4.
    Key  Types  of  Supply  Chain  IniHaHves   Type   DescripHon   ExisHng  Examples   Mandatory   The  buyer  requires  the  supplier  to  comply  with  set  criteria.     Ford,  SKF   performance   requirements   Purchasing  approaches   Buyer  develops  procurement  policies  whereby  suppliers  score  higher  or   ProRail  CO2  Performance   lower  or  are  advantaged  or  disadvantaged  in  the  procurement  process   Ladder   Repor;ng  and   Suppliers  must  report  their  emissions  or  energy  use  to  their  buyers.   BASF   monitoring   Subsidised  audits   On-­‐site  audits  (full  or  parHally  funded  by  the  buyer)  to  determine  a  supplier's   Walmart,  IKEA   GHG/energy  performance.   Capacity  building  and   Training,  workshops,  implementaHon  support  and  other  measures  to   General  Electric,  Walmart   implementa;on   improve  suppliers’  ability  to  implement  energy  efficiency  projects  and   support   improve  their  performance.     Supplier  forums  or   Conferences,  meeHngs,  webinars  or  online  forums  where  buyers  can   Walmart,  Intertek  (Home   coali;on   communicate  prioriHes,  and  suppliers  can  ask  quesHons,  receive  feedback   Depot)   and  share  best  pracHce  amongst  themselves.     Labeling   Labeling  of  energy  performance  as  an  informaHonal  tool  for  buyers.     Suzhou  EE  Star  Program   External  facilita;on   Plaiorms  that  help  connect  or  match  GHG/energy  performance  of  suppliers   Intertek  (Home  Depot)   tools   with  buyers'  interests  or  criteria.   Sharing  best  pracHces  for  the  low  carbon  future   |    iipnetwork.org  
  • 5.
    Examples  of  case  studies   General  Electric   •  “Integrity  Program”,  onsite  audits  and  “Treasure  Hunts”   •  Local  training  programs  and  supplier  summits  in  partnership  w  ISC,  WBSCD,  Guandong  Academy   IKEA   •  IWAY  code  of  conduct  for  suppliers  with  regular  on-­‐site  audits   •  WWF  collaboraHon  on  a  ‘Developing  Climate  PosiHve  OpportuniHes  for  Suppliers’   The  Home  Depot   •  Works  through  Intertek’s  TGI  –  on-­‐site  assessments,  idenHficaHon  and  implementaHon  of  EE   measures   SKF   •  Supplier  cerHficaHon  of  ISO  14001  (and  recently  ISO  50001  announced)   •  Energy  Challenge  and  Energy  Excellence  awards   Sharing  best  pracHces  for  the  low  carbon  future   |    iipnetwork.org  
  • 6.
    Impacts  of  selected  examples   GE   •  Between  2009  and  2011,  the  supplier’s  carbon  emissions  fell  by  19%,  through  energy   saving  measures  and  facility  upgrades  following  its  audiHng  and  capacity  building   programme.     IKEA     •  Under  the  IKEA-­‐WWF  partnership,  supplier  reduced  GHG  emissions  by  35%  between  2009   and  2010  through  furnace  upgrades  and  fuel  switching.   •  Another  texHle  supplier  in  Bangladesh  idenHfied  and  implemented  a  number  of  efficiency   measures  in  2011  that  reduced  energy  consumpHon  by  29%  and  cut  CO2  emissions  by   25%.   Intertek  (Home  Depot)   •  TGI  program  cost  US$43,500  (paid  by  the  suppliers),  and  achieved  overall  cost  savings  of   over  $US3  million.   Sharing  best  pracHces  for  the  low  carbon  future   |    iipnetwork.org   iipnetwork.org/databases/supply-­‐chain  
  • 7.
    Some  Lessons  learnt   Procurement  and  contractual  arrangements  can   encourage  suppliers  more  fully   InternaHonally  recognised  tools   Partnership,  fostering  trust  and  implementaHon   support   MulH-­‐stakeholder  collaboraHon  including  third  party   involvement   QA,  transparency  and  verificaHon  –  external   plaiorms   Sharing  best  pracHces  for  the  low  carbon  future   |    iipnetwork.org  
  • 8.
    Success  factors   Sharing  best  pracHces  for  the  low  carbon  future   |    iipnetwork.org  
  • 9.
    Conclusions  and  Discussion   •  Wide  diversity  of  approaches  and  new  models  emerging   •  Many  are  in  early  stages  and  “learning  by  doing”   •  Varied  transparency  &  verificaHon  approaches   •  EnMS  (e.g.  ISO  50001)  and  other  internaHonally  recognised  tools  are   emerging  as  promising  tools   •  Ouen  accompanied  by  MRV  support  to  substanHate  claims   •  How  to  promote  ISO  50001  as  a  supply  chain  tool?     •  What  role  for  governments?  (e.g.  Japan,  Netherlands)   •  Extending  obligaHons  for  large  companies  to  take  acHons  across  the  supply  chain   Sharing  best  pracHces  for  the  low  carbon  future   |    iipnetwork.org  
  • 10.
    Thank  you   Industrial  Supply  Chain  IniHaHves  Database:   www.iipnetwork.org/databases/supply-­‐chain   In  collaboraHon  with  Ecofys  UK.   Amelie  Goldberg    Amelie.goldberg@iipnetwork.org   Julia  Reinaud    julia.reinaud@iipnetwork.org     Emelia  Holdaway  (previously  with  Ecofys  UK)   Siobhan  O’Keeffe  (previously  with  Ecofys  UK)   Sharing  best  pracHces  for  the  low  carbon  future   |    iipnetwork.org