Cognitive Development:Piaget and VygotskyRichard Poore
Piaget’s TheoryClinical MethodClass Inclusion
Key Ideas to Piaget’s TheoryChildren are active and motivated learnersChildren organize what they learn from their experiencesSchemesOperationsChildren adapt to their environment through:AssimilationAccommodation
Key Ideas to Piaget’s TheoryInteraction with the physical environment is critical for cognitive developmentInteraction with other people is equally criticalThe process of equilibration promotes increasingly complex forms of thoughtEquilibriumDisequilibriumChildren think in qualitatively different ways at different age levels
Piaget’s Stagesof Cognitive DevelopmentSensorimotor StageBirth through 2 yearsPreoperational2 through 6/7 yearsConcrete Operations6/7 through 11/12 yearsFormal Operations11/12 through adulthood
Sensorimotor StageTrial and ErrorGoal Directed BehaviorObject PermanenceSymbolic Thought
Preoperational StageRapid Linguistic AbilityVocabulary and SyntaxExtensive Pretend PlayIntuitive Thought
Concrete OperationsDistinctions BetweenOne’s own andOthers’ perspectivesClass InclusionConservation
Formal OperationsReasoning about abstracthypothetical,And contrary-to-factideasSeparation and control ofvariablesProportional ReasoningIdealism
Current Perspectives related toPiaget’s TheoryCapabilities of different age-groupsEffects of prior knowledge and experienceEffects of cultureDoes cognitive development occur in stages?Neo-Piagetian theories
Key Ideas inNeo-Piagetian TheoriesCognitive development is constrained by the maturation of information processing mechanisms in the brainWorking memoryChildren acquire new knowledge through both unintentional and intentional learning processes
Key Ideas inNeo-Piagetian TheoriesChildren acquire cognitive structures that affect their thinking in particular content domainsCentral Conceptual StructuresDevelopment in specific content domains can sometimes be characterized as a series of stages
Applying Piagetian IdeasProvide opportunities for children to experiment with physical objects and natural phenomenaExplore children’s reasoning with problem-solving tasks and probing questionsKeep Piaget’s stages in mind when interpreting children’s behavior and when planning activities, but don’t take the stages too literally.
Applying Piagetian IdeasPresent situations and ideas that children cannot easily explain using their existing knowledge and beliefsUse familiar content and tasks when asking children to reason in sophisticated waysPlan group activities in which young people share their beliefs and perspectives with one another
Vygotsky’sSociocultural TheoryFocused on tools – concepts, problem-solving strategies, etc – rather than physical objectsAdult assistance
Vygotsky’s Key IdeasSome cognitive processes are seen in a variety of species; others are unique to human beingsThrough both informal interactions and formal schooling, adults convey to children the ways in which their culture interprets the worldEvery culture passes along physical and cognitive tools that make daily living more effective and efficient
Vygotsky’s Key IdeasThought and language become increasingly interdependent in the first few years of lifeSelf-talkInner speachComplex mental processes begin as social activities and gradually evolve into internal mental activities that children can use independentlyInternalization
Vygotsky’s Key IdeasChildren acquire their culture’s tools in their own ideosyncratic mannerAppropriationChildren can perform more challenging tasks when assisted by more advanced and competent individualsChallenging tasks promote maximum cognitive growthZone of Proximal Development
Vygotsky’s Key IdeasPlay allows children to stretch themselves cognitivelySociodramatic play
Current Perspectives related toVygotsky’s TheorySocial construction of meaningMediated learning experienceScaffoldingParticipation in adult activitiesGuided participationAprenticeshipCognitive AprenticeshipAcquisition of teaching skills
Applying Vygotsky’s IdeasHelp children acquire the basic cognitive tools of various activities and academic disciplinesUse group learning activities to help children internalize cognitive strategiesReciprocal teachingPresent challenging tasks, and provide sufficient scaffolding to enable children to accomplish them successfully
Applying Vygotsky’s IdeasAssess children’s abilities under a variety of work conditionsProvide opportunities to engage in authentic activitiesGive children the chance to play
Piaget and VygotskyCommon ThemesConstructive processes in learningConstructivism, social and individualReadinessChallengeImportance of social interaction
Piaget vs. VygotskyTheoretical DifferencesHow essential is language for cognitive development?What kinds of experiences promote development?What social interactions are most valuable?How influential is culture?

Cognitive development

  • 1.
  • 2.
  • 3.
    Key Ideas toPiaget’s TheoryChildren are active and motivated learnersChildren organize what they learn from their experiencesSchemesOperationsChildren adapt to their environment through:AssimilationAccommodation
  • 4.
    Key Ideas toPiaget’s TheoryInteraction with the physical environment is critical for cognitive developmentInteraction with other people is equally criticalThe process of equilibration promotes increasingly complex forms of thoughtEquilibriumDisequilibriumChildren think in qualitatively different ways at different age levels
  • 5.
    Piaget’s Stagesof CognitiveDevelopmentSensorimotor StageBirth through 2 yearsPreoperational2 through 6/7 yearsConcrete Operations6/7 through 11/12 yearsFormal Operations11/12 through adulthood
  • 6.
    Sensorimotor StageTrial andErrorGoal Directed BehaviorObject PermanenceSymbolic Thought
  • 7.
    Preoperational StageRapid LinguisticAbilityVocabulary and SyntaxExtensive Pretend PlayIntuitive Thought
  • 8.
    Concrete OperationsDistinctions BetweenOne’sown andOthers’ perspectivesClass InclusionConservation
  • 9.
    Formal OperationsReasoning aboutabstracthypothetical,And contrary-to-factideasSeparation and control ofvariablesProportional ReasoningIdealism
  • 10.
    Current Perspectives relatedtoPiaget’s TheoryCapabilities of different age-groupsEffects of prior knowledge and experienceEffects of cultureDoes cognitive development occur in stages?Neo-Piagetian theories
  • 11.
    Key Ideas inNeo-PiagetianTheoriesCognitive development is constrained by the maturation of information processing mechanisms in the brainWorking memoryChildren acquire new knowledge through both unintentional and intentional learning processes
  • 12.
    Key Ideas inNeo-PiagetianTheoriesChildren acquire cognitive structures that affect their thinking in particular content domainsCentral Conceptual StructuresDevelopment in specific content domains can sometimes be characterized as a series of stages
  • 13.
    Applying Piagetian IdeasProvideopportunities for children to experiment with physical objects and natural phenomenaExplore children’s reasoning with problem-solving tasks and probing questionsKeep Piaget’s stages in mind when interpreting children’s behavior and when planning activities, but don’t take the stages too literally.
  • 14.
    Applying Piagetian IdeasPresentsituations and ideas that children cannot easily explain using their existing knowledge and beliefsUse familiar content and tasks when asking children to reason in sophisticated waysPlan group activities in which young people share their beliefs and perspectives with one another
  • 15.
    Vygotsky’sSociocultural TheoryFocused ontools – concepts, problem-solving strategies, etc – rather than physical objectsAdult assistance
  • 16.
    Vygotsky’s Key IdeasSomecognitive processes are seen in a variety of species; others are unique to human beingsThrough both informal interactions and formal schooling, adults convey to children the ways in which their culture interprets the worldEvery culture passes along physical and cognitive tools that make daily living more effective and efficient
  • 17.
    Vygotsky’s Key IdeasThoughtand language become increasingly interdependent in the first few years of lifeSelf-talkInner speachComplex mental processes begin as social activities and gradually evolve into internal mental activities that children can use independentlyInternalization
  • 18.
    Vygotsky’s Key IdeasChildrenacquire their culture’s tools in their own ideosyncratic mannerAppropriationChildren can perform more challenging tasks when assisted by more advanced and competent individualsChallenging tasks promote maximum cognitive growthZone of Proximal Development
  • 19.
    Vygotsky’s Key IdeasPlayallows children to stretch themselves cognitivelySociodramatic play
  • 20.
    Current Perspectives relatedtoVygotsky’s TheorySocial construction of meaningMediated learning experienceScaffoldingParticipation in adult activitiesGuided participationAprenticeshipCognitive AprenticeshipAcquisition of teaching skills
  • 21.
    Applying Vygotsky’s IdeasHelpchildren acquire the basic cognitive tools of various activities and academic disciplinesUse group learning activities to help children internalize cognitive strategiesReciprocal teachingPresent challenging tasks, and provide sufficient scaffolding to enable children to accomplish them successfully
  • 22.
    Applying Vygotsky’s IdeasAssesschildren’s abilities under a variety of work conditionsProvide opportunities to engage in authentic activitiesGive children the chance to play
  • 23.
    Piaget and VygotskyCommonThemesConstructive processes in learningConstructivism, social and individualReadinessChallengeImportance of social interaction
  • 24.
    Piaget vs. VygotskyTheoreticalDifferencesHow essential is language for cognitive development?What kinds of experiences promote development?What social interactions are most valuable?How influential is culture?

Editor's Notes

  • #11 (DevelopmentalMetacognition, Aspects in young children) Shows a gradual development of metacognition and theory of mind leading to what Piaget called “de-centering”, where the child can see from another perspective Also found that 4-5yr old children who had a metacognitive advantage kept that advantage during the two year study
  • #22 Reciprocol teaching Summarizing: Identifying the main ideas of a reading passage Questioning: Asking oneself questions to check comprehension of ideas Clarifying: Taking steps to better understand a confusing point Predicting: Anticipating what points an author is apt to make laterScaffolding Cognitive modeling – Adult performs while verbalizing instructions Overt External guidance – Adult verbalizes instructions while child performs Overt self-guidance – Child repeats instructions while performing Faded, overt self-guidance – The child whispers instructions while performing Covert self-guidance – the child silently things about the instructions (inner speech) while performin
  • #23 Partition the classroom into small areas that give children numerous optionsProvide realistic toys that suggest certain activities and functions as well as more versatile objects that allow children to engage in fantasy and imaginationProvide enough toys and equipment to minimize potential conflicts, but keep them limited enough in number that children must share and cooperate