Chapter018

Copyright © 2011 Wolters Kluwer Health | Lippincott Williams & Wilkins
Chapter 18
Generating Evidence Through
Qualitative Research

Qualitative Studies
• Helpful in answering particular kinds of research
questions concerned with human responses and
meanings within situations
• Help develop knowledge when a concept or phenomenon
is not well understood or is inadequately covered in the
literature
• Provide insights that explain the processes individuals go
through when dealing with an issue
• Increase sensitivity to human experiences in order to
enhance understanding or stimulate social action

Basic Understandings About Qualitative
Research
• Not all descriptive research is qualitative
− Qualitative research focuses on understanding and
meaning
− Interpretive in nature
− Openness and flexibility are key
− Procedures foster depth, accuracy, and completeness
− Multiple reporting styles are used
− Conclusions are not based on prior assumptions

Basic Understandings About Qualitative
Research (cont’d)
• Not all qualitative research is descriptive
− Many qualitative studies involve a higher level of
analytic complexity
• Interpretation
• Thick description
• There is no single set of procedures for designing and
performing qualitative research
• Mentorship yields the highest-quality results

Question
• Tell whether the following statement is true or false.
• The highest purpose for qualitative research is to provide
a sound foundation for subsequent quantitative studies.

Answer
• False
• Rationale: Qualitative research is not necessarily a
preliminary step to some other type of research. It is a
complete and valued end-product in and of itself.

Principles of Qualitative Research Design
• Identifying a study question
− Often this flows out of curiosity, hunches, and
existing knowledge
• Reviewing the literature
− Used as a framework to explain why the study is
important, to indicate what it may contribute to
knowledge about the topic, and to set the stage for
presentation of results
− Simply citing an absence of literature on a topic is
not sufficient

(cont’d)
• Defining the theoretical perspective
− May be explicitly stated or may be demonstrated
(implicit)
− Defining the theoretical perspective of a qualitative
study involves choices about how theory will be used

Selecting an Appropriate Research
Design
• Choices include:
− Ethnography when the purpose is to explain human
experience in cultural context, as an interpretation or
in theoretical terms
− Grounded theory when the purpose is to generate a
theory that explains the ways in which persons move
through an experience
− Phenomenology or hermeneutics when the
purpose is to produce an interpretation of what an
experience is like

Question
• A nurse researcher wishes to explore and explain the
phases that a patient experiences in the months after
being diagnosed with early-stage dementia. Which of the
following qualitative designs is likely best able to inform
the study question?
a. Hermeneutics
b. Phenomenology
c. Grounded theory
d. Ethnography

Answer
• c. Grounded theory
• Rationale: Grounded theory allows the researcher to
generate a theory that explains the ways in which
persons move through an experience in stages or phases.

(cont’d)
• Formulating a study purpose
− Purpose statements draw attention to the central
research focus, study participants, and the nature
and selected elements of the research design
• Establishing the study’s significance
− This should be established throughout the
conceptualization process, rather than as a discrete
“step”

Research Procedures
• Note that there is no single set of procedural steps in
qualitative research
• Sampling plan
− Purposeful selection is the norm
− Determining optimum sample size is based on:
• Usefulness of the data in various informational
categories
• Types of additional data sources needed
• Number of interviews and/or observations needed

Question
• Decisions around the size of the sample needed for a
qualitative study can be determined by performing a
power analysis.

Answer
• False
• Rationale: Power analysis is a statistical technique that
can inform decisions surrounding sample size in
quantitative methodologies. It is not, however, a relevant
or fitting consideration for qualitative studies.

Research Procedures (cont’d)
• Ethical considerations
• Data collection
− Multiple data collection strategies are often used in a
single study
− Commonly include interviews, focus groups,
observation

Research Procedures (cont’d)
• Data analysis and interpretation
− Ongoing activities that occur simultaneously with
data collection
− Common strategies
• Reading through all the data to get a general
sense; reflecting on possible meanings
• Coding/labeling, categorizing, and writing
reflective notes about the data
• Generating detailed written descriptions
• Searching for recurring themes and patterns
• Note how quality and scientific rigor will be monitored

(cont’d)
• Address study limitations
− Generalizability
− Transferability
− Validity
− Potential pitfalls in chosen methods and issues
related to the nature of the study topic should be
addressed

Question
• Qualitative research is not generalizable to individuals or
settings beyond those included in the study.

Answer
• False
• Rationale: Determining the generalizability or
transferability of a qualitative study requires critical
engagement with the methodology and findings.
However, it is simplistic to conclude that qualitative
findings may never be applicable to other patients or
places.

Chapter018

More Related Content

What's hot

Similar to Chapter018

More from stanbridge

Chapter018