desi gning
  usine ss mo dels
b

                  d
a course prepare
                    r
by a lex osterwalde
and   yves pigneur
e -business
serv  ice design
s cenario & s torytelling
 t ask analysis
 p rototyping
        service to   business
 from
     ueprint & v isualization
  bl
  service  innovation
         ess model   innovation
   busin
   busin ess model
      usiness mo   del design
   ‣b
3 steps of business model design




 !"   VISUALIZE      #"                   %"                 $"



 !! "#$%&'(#)#*'$+,-) !! 2$$#$$)           !! (&2',$30&/)0,) !! 3.&,),#
    (.$',#$$)/0"#1)      $3&#,-34$)2,")       '/7&08#/#,3$)9)   ',30)2)7
                         5#26,#$$#$)          0770&3.,'+#$))    &02"/2
business
 model
     ign
        ^
  des
We believe that if managers adopted a design attitude, the
world of business would be different and better
[Boland & Collopy, 2004]
the desig   ner’s
tool kit ...
analyze from the customer perspective
PARTNER            KEY        OFFER     CUSTOMER          CUSTOMER
NETWORK          ACTIVITIES           RELATIONSHIPS       SEGMENTS




                   KEY                DISTRIBUTION
                RESOURCES              CHANNELS




          COST STRUCTURE                REVENUE STREAMS
Jan Chipchase
    (Nokia)
his main
weapon
India mobile
   study
Rich Ling
(Telenor)
photo usage
   study
do you d  o if you
                   what
                   don’t h ave an
                      nthropo logist or
                    a
                          logist h andy ?
                    socio
rf.snoitartsulli
(customer) empathy map
                                   what’s on his/her mind?
                                          his/her preoccupations
                                              his/her worries
                                            what he/she thinks




what does he/she                                                      what does he/she
     hear?                                                                  see?

    what his/her boss says                                                 his/her environment
   what his/her friends say                                                   his/her friends
 what media influences him/her                                         what the market offers him/her




                                  what does he/she say?
                                             his/her attitude
                                       how he/she appears in public
                                         what he/she tells others


[Source:
XPLANE,
the
visual
thinking
company]
co-designing
computer-aided designing
computer-aided designing
business
 model
        ^
      rns
pa tte
“ Pattern in architecture
  is the idea of capturing
  architectural design
  ideas as archetypal and
  reusable descriptions.
                                   ”
    Christopher Alexander’s idea
“ long  tail”
   pat tern
it’s about selling less of
         more…
focus on a small
           number of products
sales



           with large volume




        number of products
focus on a large
           number of products
sales



           with low volume




        number of products
the “traditional” record company
  PARTNER               KEY              OFFER           CUSTOMER           CUSTOMER
  NETWORK             ACTIVITIES                       RELATIONSHIPS        SEGMENTS


                  finding talent


                      marketing     super-star                             mass market
                                    artists & hits
distribution
   channel              KEY                            DISTRIBUTION
                     RESOURCES                          CHANNELS

                                                     retail outlets

                     protected
                      content
                                                      radio & TV

               COST STRUCTURE                            REVENUE STREAMS

    talent                                                         huge revenue
                                                                                s
“production                 marketing                            from few ar
                                                                             tists
            ”
New Ways to Discover & Popularize
            Music…
business model
 PARTNER              KEY             OFFER             CUSTOMER            CUSTOMER
 NETWORK            ACTIVITIES                        RELATIONSHIPS         SEGMENTS



                                                              ies            niche
                  platform        platform for       communit
                                                                           segments
                 management       musicians &
                                  fans/buyers
 content                                                                     niche
producers             KEY                              DISTRIBUTION
                                                                           segments
                   RESOURCES                            CHANNELS

                                  match-making
                                   with taste
                  breadth of                             online              niche
                   platform                                                segments


            COST STRUCTURE                               REVENUE STREAMS

                                              small revenu               music
             platform                                      es
                                               from many              subscription
            maintenanc
                       e                         artists                service?
37
38
“do uble si ded”
    pat tern
^
        Two-sided business ...
                              according to Evans




                two distinct sets of customers
                who need each other
                who can’t get together easily on their own
                and for which a platform reduces network
                effects

[Evans, 2006]
back t
       o the
             ...



         who
             area
the business model canvas
   KEY             KEY        OFFER     CUSTOMER          CUSTOMER
PARTNERS         ACTIVITIES           RELATIONSHIPS       SEGMENTS




                                                      buyers
                    KEY               DISTRIBUTION
                 RESOURCES             CHANNELS



                                                          sellers


           COST STRUCTURE               REVENUE STREAMS
back t
       o the
             ...



        what
             area
the business model canvas
   KEY             KEY         OFFER        CUSTOMER          CUSTOMER
PARTNERS         ACTIVITIES               RELATIONSHIPS       SEGMENTS




                                                          buyers
                        offer for
                 RESOURCES buyers
                    KEY                   DISTRIBUTION
                                           CHANNELS



                              offer for                       sellers
                               sellers

           COST STRUCTURE                   REVENUE STREAMS
Transaction costs




“ main economic role of multi-
   Reducing transactions costs is

  sided platforms
                  ”
audience building
cost saving
match making
http://www.pbase.com/srijith/image/88605858
the business model canvas
   KEY             KEY               OFFER           CUSTOMER          CUSTOMER
PARTNERS         ACTIVITIES                        RELATIONSHIPS       SEGMENTS




                            match                                  buyers
                    KEY
                            making           cost DISTRIBUTION
                 RESOURCES                          CHANNELS
                                             saving
                            audience                                   sellers
                             building
           COST STRUCTURE                            REVENUE STREAMS
back t
       o the
             ...



how much
             area
the business model canvas
   KEY             KEY        OFFER      CUSTOMER          CUSTOMER
PARTNERS         ACTIVITIES            RELATIONSHIPS       SEGMENTS




                    KEY                 DISTRIBUTION
                 RESOURCES               CHANNELS




           COST STRUCTURE                       revenue from
                                         REVENUE STREAMS

                              revenue from          sellers
                                  buyers
customers       who
pays?
        media
&
television readers/viewers
                           adverFsers                            adverFsers

                                                                 (mainly)

        credit
cards                             cardholders
                                                 merchants       merchants

                                                                 (mainly)

        web
aucFons                              buyers
                                                 sellers         sellers

                                                                 (mainly)

www.strategy-business.com/press/16635507/03301
back t
       o the
             ...



         how
             area
“ Value networks rely on a mediating
  technology  to link clients who are or
  wish to be interdependent [...] and
  facilitate exchange
  relationships among customers
  The firm provides a networking service. 
                                                  ”
    Charles Stabell et al.
     Configuring value for competitive advantage
the business model canvas
   KEY
PARTNERS
                   KEY
                 ACTIVITIES
                                   platform RELATIONSHIPS
                                      OFFER   CUSTOMER            CUSTOMER
                                                                  SEGMENTS

                                  management
platform
promotion
                       service
                 RESOURCESision
                    prov
                    KEY
                                ing            DISTRIBUTION
                                                CHANNELS




           COST STRUCTURE                       REVENUE STREAMS
the business model canvas
    KEY             KEY           OFFER           CUSTOMER             CUSTOMER
 PARTNERS         ACTIVITIES                    RELATIONSHIPS          SEGMENTS

platform
                   platform
promotion
                  management
                                                                 buyers
       service                              cost
                               match        saving
     provisioning    KEY                         DISTRIBUTION
                  RESOURCES
                               making             CHANNELS



                                          audience                     sellers
                                           building


            COST STRUCTURE                           REVENUE STREAMS


                                                                revenue from
                                          revenue from
                                                                    sellers
                                              buyers
59
“f ree”
pat tern
farm2.static.flickr.com/1177/683534694_3c70cebe3b_o_d.jpg
65
double-sided
         market

r evi ew ✓two sets of customers
         ✓who need each other
         ✓with network externalities
value
                             NETWORK PROMOTION
    Nobs
   Network                                                                                                                                                 flow

                                   Contract musicians            flow                SERVICE PROVISIONING         flow
                flow
                                                                         musicians                                            recordings
                             by MJF                                                                                                                  fit           NETWORK
                                                                                         Selling recordings                                                    INFRASTRUCTURE
                                   Contract sponsors                                                                        fit
                                                                                     by Montreux Sounds




                                                                                                                                                                                                network
                             by MJF                                                                                                                                   Programming
   Sponsors                                                                                     Concerts                                                                            see focus
                                       Ticketing                 flow                                                         instruments                   by MJF
                                                                           tickets   by MJF, artists                 fit
             flow            by MJF, Ticket Corner                                                                                             fit
                                                                                                                                                                  Recording concerts
                                                                                         Food & Beverages          fit
                                Advertising the MJF                                                                                                         by MJF
                                                                                     by MJF, caterers, Heineken                   venues
                             by MFJ, sponsors, media,                                                                                                                  Production
                             Swiss tourism, Montreux                                          Commerce
                                                                                                                                                            by MJF
                                                                                     by shops                     share
                                                                                                                                                     fit       Manage infrastructure
                                                                                           Merchandising
                                                                                                                                  JAZZ                      by MJF, Municipality
 Focus: Programming decomposed into its sub-activities (forming a value shop)        by MJF
                                                                                                                                               flow                 Manage JAZZ
                                  Problem finding
                                                                                                                                                            by MJF
                               Define concert date
                              and stage to be filled                    Problem                                                                                   Manage volunteers
Evaluation                                                              solving                                                                             by MJF
                           flow
    Evaluate concert               Nobs & staff              list music styles and
    and ticket sales                                            possible artists
                                                                                                                         Legend
                       Put artist in         Choose artist
        Execution       program                                 Choice                                                              Resource               Activity        By ACTOR




                                                               r evi ew ✓platform promotion
                                                                                                                                                                                                ✓service provisioning
                                                                                                                                                                                                ✓platform management

Business Model Design

  • 1.
    desi gning usine ss mo dels b d a course prepare r by a lex osterwalde and yves pigneur
  • 2.
    e -business serv ice design s cenario & s torytelling t ask analysis p rototyping service to business from ueprint & v isualization bl service innovation ess model innovation busin busin ess model usiness mo del design ‣b
  • 3.
    3 steps ofbusiness model design !" VISUALIZE #" %" $" !! "#$%&'(#)#*'$+,-) !! 2$$#$$) !! (&2',$30&/)0,) !! 3.&,),# (.$',#$$)/0"#1) $3&#,-34$)2,") '/7&08#/#,3$)9) ',30)2)7 5#26,#$$#$) 0770&3.,'+#$)) &02"/2
  • 4.
    business model ign ^ des
  • 5.
    We believe thatif managers adopted a design attitude, the world of business would be different and better [Boland & Collopy, 2004]
  • 6.
    the desig ner’s tool kit ...
  • 8.
    analyze from thecustomer perspective PARTNER KEY OFFER CUSTOMER CUSTOMER NETWORK ACTIVITIES RELATIONSHIPS SEGMENTS KEY DISTRIBUTION RESOURCES CHANNELS COST STRUCTURE REVENUE STREAMS
  • 9.
  • 10.
  • 12.
  • 13.
  • 14.
  • 15.
    do you d o if you what don’t h ave an nthropo logist or a logist h andy ? socio rf.snoitartsulli
  • 16.
    (customer) empathy map what’s on his/her mind? his/her preoccupations his/her worries what he/she thinks what does he/she what does he/she hear? see? what his/her boss says his/her environment what his/her friends say his/her friends what media influences him/her what the market offers him/her what does he/she say? his/her attitude how he/she appears in public what he/she tells others [Source:
XPLANE,
the
visual
thinking
company]
  • 19.
  • 20.
  • 21.
  • 25.
    business model ^ rns pa tte
  • 26.
    “ Pattern inarchitecture is the idea of capturing architectural design ideas as archetypal and reusable descriptions. ” Christopher Alexander’s idea
  • 27.
    “ long tail” pat tern
  • 29.
    it’s about sellingless of more…
  • 30.
    focus on asmall number of products sales with large volume number of products
  • 31.
    focus on alarge number of products sales with low volume number of products
  • 33.
    the “traditional” recordcompany PARTNER KEY OFFER CUSTOMER CUSTOMER NETWORK ACTIVITIES RELATIONSHIPS SEGMENTS finding talent marketing super-star mass market artists & hits distribution channel KEY DISTRIBUTION RESOURCES CHANNELS retail outlets protected content radio & TV COST STRUCTURE REVENUE STREAMS talent huge revenue s “production marketing from few ar tists ”
  • 34.
    New Ways toDiscover & Popularize Music…
  • 36.
    business model PARTNER KEY OFFER CUSTOMER CUSTOMER NETWORK ACTIVITIES RELATIONSHIPS SEGMENTS ies niche platform platform for communit segments management musicians & fans/buyers content niche producers KEY DISTRIBUTION segments RESOURCES CHANNELS match-making with taste breadth of online niche platform segments COST STRUCTURE REVENUE STREAMS small revenu music platform es from many subscription maintenanc e artists service?
  • 37.
  • 38.
  • 39.
    “do uble sided” pat tern
  • 42.
    ^ Two-sided business ... according to Evans two distinct sets of customers who need each other who can’t get together easily on their own and for which a platform reduces network effects [Evans, 2006]
  • 43.
    back t o the ... who area
  • 44.
    the business modelcanvas KEY KEY OFFER CUSTOMER CUSTOMER PARTNERS ACTIVITIES RELATIONSHIPS SEGMENTS buyers KEY DISTRIBUTION RESOURCES CHANNELS sellers COST STRUCTURE REVENUE STREAMS
  • 45.
    back t o the ... what area
  • 46.
    the business modelcanvas KEY KEY OFFER CUSTOMER CUSTOMER PARTNERS ACTIVITIES RELATIONSHIPS SEGMENTS buyers offer for RESOURCES buyers KEY DISTRIBUTION CHANNELS offer for sellers sellers COST STRUCTURE REVENUE STREAMS
  • 47.
    Transaction costs “ maineconomic role of multi- Reducing transactions costs is sided platforms ”
  • 48.
  • 49.
  • 50.
  • 51.
    the business modelcanvas KEY KEY OFFER CUSTOMER CUSTOMER PARTNERS ACTIVITIES RELATIONSHIPS SEGMENTS match buyers KEY making cost DISTRIBUTION RESOURCES CHANNELS saving audience sellers building COST STRUCTURE REVENUE STREAMS
  • 52.
    back t o the ... how much area
  • 53.
    the business modelcanvas KEY KEY OFFER CUSTOMER CUSTOMER PARTNERS ACTIVITIES RELATIONSHIPS SEGMENTS KEY DISTRIBUTION RESOURCES CHANNELS COST STRUCTURE revenue from REVENUE STREAMS revenue from sellers buyers
  • 54.
    customers who
pays? media
&
television readers/viewers adverFsers adverFsers
 (mainly) credit
cards cardholders merchants merchants
 (mainly) web
aucFons buyers sellers sellers
 (mainly) www.strategy-business.com/press/16635507/03301
  • 55.
    back t o the ... how area
  • 56.
    “ Value networks relyon a mediating technology  to link clients who are or wish to be interdependent [...] and facilitate exchange relationships among customers The firm provides a networking service.  ” Charles Stabell et al. Configuring value for competitive advantage
  • 57.
    the business modelcanvas KEY PARTNERS KEY ACTIVITIES platform RELATIONSHIPS OFFER CUSTOMER CUSTOMER SEGMENTS management platform promotion service RESOURCESision prov KEY ing DISTRIBUTION CHANNELS COST STRUCTURE REVENUE STREAMS
  • 58.
    the business modelcanvas KEY KEY OFFER CUSTOMER CUSTOMER PARTNERS ACTIVITIES RELATIONSHIPS SEGMENTS platform platform promotion management buyers service cost match saving provisioning KEY DISTRIBUTION RESOURCES making CHANNELS audience sellers building COST STRUCTURE REVENUE STREAMS revenue from revenue from sellers buyers
  • 59.
  • 61.
  • 63.
  • 65.
  • 66.
    double-sided market r evi ew ✓two sets of customers ✓who need each other ✓with network externalities
  • 67.
    value NETWORK PROMOTION Nobs Network flow Contract musicians flow SERVICE PROVISIONING flow flow musicians recordings by MJF fit NETWORK Selling recordings INFRASTRUCTURE Contract sponsors fit by Montreux Sounds network by MJF Programming Sponsors Concerts see focus Ticketing flow instruments by MJF tickets by MJF, artists fit flow by MJF, Ticket Corner fit Recording concerts Food & Beverages fit Advertising the MJF by MJF by MJF, caterers, Heineken venues by MFJ, sponsors, media, Production Swiss tourism, Montreux Commerce by MJF by shops share fit Manage infrastructure Merchandising JAZZ by MJF, Municipality Focus: Programming decomposed into its sub-activities (forming a value shop) by MJF flow Manage JAZZ Problem finding by MJF Define concert date and stage to be filled Problem Manage volunteers Evaluation solving by MJF flow Evaluate concert Nobs & staff list music styles and and ticket sales possible artists Legend Put artist in Choose artist Execution program Choice Resource Activity By ACTOR r evi ew ✓platform promotion ✓service provisioning ✓platform management