MT5016
BUSINESS MODELS FOR HI-TECH PRODUCTS
Roberto De Joya Jr. A0118989E
Ryan Michael Gelig A0098535R
Zhou Xintao A0098599X
Liang Liang A0098464N
Jonathan Castillo A0098438M
Wong Chee Yeow A0104437M
INTRODUCTION
SCOPE OF ACTIVITES
VALUE PROPOSITION
COMPETITOR ANALYSIS
CUSTOMER SELECTION
VALUE CAPTURE
STRATEGIC CONTROL
CHANGING TREND IN HIGHER EDUCATION
Rising Costs
Perception of shrinking financial returns
of education
Unequal access to employers
Unequal access to education
RISING COSTS OF HIGHER EDUCATION
http://www.bloomberg.com/news/2013-08-26/college-costs-surge-500-in-u-s-since-1985-chart-of-the-day.html
http://money.cnn.com/2011/06/13/news/economy/college_tuition_middle_class/
Free and paid (for premium services)
educational courses offered online and
open to anyone
The concept started from
University of Phoenix’s initiative
in 1989
1st MOOC experiment launched in
2008 by Stephen Downes and George
Siemens, “Connectivism and
Connective Knowledge”
Current MOOC providers:
Coursera, Udacity, edX,
KhanX
New York Times
declared 2012 as
the "Year of the
MOOC"
MASSIVE OPEN ONLINE COURSES
MASSIVE OPEN ONLINE COURSES
http://elearninginfographics.com/wp-content/uploads/Are-MOOCs-the-Future-of-Online-Education-Infographic.jpg
COURSERA
Founded in 2012 by Prof. Daphne Koller
and Andrew Ng from Stanford University
Raised $65M in funding from Silicon
Valley VCs
6.8M registered users
Offering 600+ courses
108 partner institutions
COURSERA
INTRODUCTION
SCOPE OF ACTIVITIES
VALUE PROPOSITION
COMPETITOR ANALYSIS
CUSTOMER SELECTION
VALUE CAPTURE
STRATEGIC CONTROL
SCOPE OF ACTIVITIES
COURSERA
Learning
Institutions /
Universities
Amazon
Web Services
ACE Publishers Translators
Content Delivery X
Licensing X
Distribution X
Screening Services X
Marketing
X
Content
Development
X
Web Storage X
Server Infrastructure X
Search X
Accreditation X
Reading Materials X
Translations X
INTRODUCTION
SCOPE OF ACTIVITIES
VALUE PROPOSITION
COMPETITOR ANALYSIS
CUSTOMER SELECTION
VALUE CAPTURE
STRATEGIC CONTROL
Elite Universities,
Publishers
Students
Students
Students within
a course
Peer
assessments
Free + Paid
courses
Course content,
textbook
recommendations
Amazon
Ad exposure for
textbook
recommendations
Employers
Job placement
for qualified
students
List of
Qualified
Students to
Hire
Textbooks
ACE Credit
ACE Credits granted on
passing Signature Track and
Credit Exam
Course
Accreditation
Non-partner
Institutions
School
Credits
License to
use platform and
certain courses
VALUE PROPOSITION
VALUE NETWORK
 COURSERA will only
offer classes/content
from the most
reputable institutions.
 A composition of
the members of the
Association of
American Universities
or “top five”
universities in
countries outside of
North America.
VALUE PROPOSITION
PRESTIGIOUS COURSES
Students who have completed the course
with Signature Track will receive a Verified
Certificate issued by COURSERA and the
participating university.
VALUE PROPOSITION
SIGNATURE TRACK
 Verified Certificate proves
that they have met the
passing criteria of the
online courses offered by
a university on
COURSERA.
 It can be used to advance
in their careers, gain
valuable credentials, or
build on what they already
know.
 People can also list their
Verified Certificate on
their résumé/CV and
include it on social
media/career profiles.
VALUE PROPOSITION
VERIFIED CERTIFICATE
Students can earn an ACE
CREDIT (American Council
on Education’s College
Credit) by signing up for an
eligible course in
the Signature Track.
As well as taking an online
proctored Credit
Recommendation Exam at
the end of the course.
VALUE PROPOSITION
RECOGNITION OF CREDITS
COURSERA Career Services - opt-in recruiting service
that allows students to find and connect with positions
that “match their skills and interests.”
VALUE PROPOSITION
CAREER ADVANCEMENT
INTRODUCTION
SCOPE OF ACTIVITIES
VALUE PROPOSITION
COMPETITOR ANALYSIS
CUSTOMER SELECTION
VALUE CAPTURE
STRATEGIC CONTROL
COMPETITOR ANALYSIS
https://www.edsurge.com/n/2013-12-22-moocs-in-2013-breaking-down-the-numbers
*As of January 2014
COMPETITOR ANALYSIS
Organization Status For-profit For-profit Non-profit
Funding $65M $21.1M $60M
Number of Students 5+ million 1.8 million 1.65 million
Number of Courses
532
(Broad range of subjects)
33
(Technical fields)
125
(Broad range of subjects)
Number of
Languages
5 63+ 1
Pacing Start and end dates
No start/end dates (suggested
completion time)
Start and end dates
Verified Certification
Virtually verified certificates for
$30-100 for 70 courses
Virtually and physically proctored
exam certificates
Physically proctored exam
certificates
Accreditation
5 courses offered for ACE credit
for $90-190; Credit at licensing
institutions
5 courses offered for credit at
California State University
system for $150
Credit at licensing institutions
Career Services Limited number of companies Network of 400+ companies None
Platform
Development
Company Company + student contributions Open-source
Content
Development
Outsourced to elite partner
institutions
Co-developed with instructors
Developed by institutions in
xConsortium
COMPETITOR ANALYSIS
INTRODUCTION
SCOPE OF ACTIVITIES
VALUE PROPOSITION
COMPETITOR ANALYSIS
CUSTOMER SELECTION
VALUE CAPTURE
STRATEGIC CONTROL
CUSTOMER SELECTION
Individuals
Companies
Learning Institutions / Universities
Individuals from around the world
Individuals with busy schedulesIndividuals interested in prestigious courses
Individuals pursuing particular courses
CUSTOMER SELECTION
INDIVIDUALS
CUSTOMER SELECTION
INDIVIDUALS
Source: MOOCs @ Edinburgh 2013, 10 May 2013
95
41
33 32
20
12
7
1
LearnNew
Things
TryOnline
Education
Togeta
certificate
Improveone's
career
Seewhat
MOOC'sare
Meetnew
people
Browse
Edinburgh's
Offering
Unsure
Aspirations
MOTIVATION SURVEY
CUSTOMER SELECTION
INDIVIDUALS
http://mfeldstein.com/the-most-thorough-description-to-date-of-university-experience-with-mooc/
DEMOGRAPHIC SURVEY
INTRODUCTION
SCOPE OF ACTIVITIES
VALUE PROPOSITION
COMPETITOR ANALYSIS
CUSTOMER SELECTION
VALUE CAPTURE
STRATEGIC CONTROL
VALUE CAPTURE
Premium
Services
Licensing
Career
Services
Merchandise
Affiliates
Program
VALUE CAPTURE
VALUE CHAIN
Elite Universities,
Publishers
Students
Students
Students within
a course
Peer
assessments
Free + Paid
courses
Course content,
textbook
recommendations
% gross
revenue from
courses
Amazon
Exposure for
textbook
recommendations
% commission
on each book
sale
Employers
Job placement
for qualified
students
List of Qualified
Students to Hire
money
Textbooks
money
Payment for
Signature Track
Program
ACE Credit
ACE Credits granted on
passing Signature Track and
Credit Exam
Evaluation
Fee
Course
Accreditation
Non-partner
Institutions
School
Credits
Licensing Fees:
$3000 + additional
fee per student
License to
use platform and
certain courses
Signature Track
Premium Service
USD30-90 per course +
USD60-90 for exam
VALUE CAPTURE
PREMIUM SERVICES
Estimated total revenue of
USD$1,300,000 in 12 months
(25,000 students in the Signature Tracks)
Specialization
Certificate for a
set of courses
USD300-500 per
certificate
VALUE CAPTURE
PREMIUM SERVICES
VALUE CAPTURE
LICENSING
Licensing of COURSERA platform
and certain courses to non-
partner institutions
USD3,000 + additional fee per student
Affiliates Program with Amazon
COURSERA will collect profit from Amazon.com
each time students buy recommended textbooks.
http://www.timeshighereducation.co.uk/news/coursera-strikes-deal-with-publishers-on-textbooks/2003754.article
“The publishers will make relevant
chapters from e-textbooks
available free of charge, although
students who wish to read the
books in full, or read them once
their course has ended, will have
to purchase them.”
VALUE CAPTURE
AFFILIATES PROGRAM
COURSERA Company Gear
Earns twice as much money than textbook revenues
VALUE CAPTURE
MERCHANDISE
COURSERA Career Services
Companies seeking qualified employees pay a
certain fee for introduction, with a share of that
revenue going to colleges that offer the course.
VALUE CAPTURE
CAREER SERVICES
INTRODUCTION
SCOPE OF ACTIVITIES
VALUE PROPOSITION
COMPETITOR ANALYSIS
CUSTOMER SELECTION
VALUE CAPTURE
STRATEGIC CONTROL
 Signature Track: Obtained certificates can be used as
degree credits.
 ACE credit: expand to more subjects
 College credit: Universities can offer courses that can be
counted for college credits
 Secure Assessments: Testing centers to prove students
have done work themselves
 Establish the Gold Standard in Course Certification
recognized worldwide (like GMAT, IELTS) by employers and
universities
 Security: Identity verification technology through keystroke
biometrics and webcam
 Partnerships:
 Job Opportunities
STRATEGIC CONTROL
COMPLIMENTARY ASSETS
STRATEGIC CONTROL
BARRIER OF ENTRY
 Strengthen and establish exclusive relationships
with Elite Institutions
 Course videos, tests and presentations are
delivered only through:
a. COURSERA website;
b. Mobile application for iOS, Android, Windows
Phone; or
c. Limit the usage of course materials within the
COURSERA web platform and mobile
application.
 Corporate learning: COURSERA provide specific
courses for companies with charges
 ‘Freemium’ model: Charge for courses that students
are interested to further pursue after introductory
chapters
 Company-sponsored courses: give options to
employers to bid for Signature Track with the courses
they prefer or build customized Track for employers
 Charging tuition: Universities can offer tutors for
courses
 Charging for Proctored Exams: offer proctoring
services that connect proctors and students via
webcam
STRATEGIC CONTROL
REVENUE
• Develop the COURSERAPad, a cheap tablet
device with all the tools pre-installed for
learning-on-the-go
• Can be used by students from primary to
university level
• Manufacturing will be outsourced
STRATEGIC CONTROL
REVENUE
COURSERAPad: a color multitouch tablet running
COURSERA OS for learning-on-the-go
• Software:
– OS: customized version of Android
– COURSERA Store: similar to iTunes University where
users can choose new courses to enroll in.
– COURSERA Apps: Pre-installed apps that can help in
learning Math, Algebra, Accounting, Physics, etc.
• Hardware:
– Processor and memory enough to run apps smoothly
– Webcam for identity verification in Signature Track
– WiFi for internet connectivity
– Touchscreen
STRATEGIC CONTROL
REVENUE
STRATEGIC CONTROL
BUSINESS MODEL
Employers
Students
Students
Students within
a course
Coursera
Peer
assessments
Freemium or Paid
Certified Courses
Screen and recommend
potential candidates
Advertisers
Advertising
Fees
InstaEDU
Online Tutor
Commission
on sales
Payment for Signature
Track and/or
COURSERAPad
LinkedIn
Student Data
(Grades and
Certifications)
Companies
Specialized
Courses
Exposure for
Online Tutor
services
Exposure for
Ads
Signature Track students
get free access to
LinkedIn’s Premium
Services
Commission on
recruited
COURSERA
students
Recruitment and
advertising fees
Access to talent
database and
ad space
Bid for Signature Track
courses based on
preferred topic
COURSERA
Pad
Fees for
corporate learning
Online
tutoring
Pay discounted rate
*In addition to COURSERA’s
current business model
THE
END
Revenue for 9 months
(ending in Sept. 30, 2013)
*numbers in thousands
 Business networking website
 Number of Users: 277 million, Revenue: $1.52 billion
 Alexa global website ranking: 8th
APPENDIX
 Online tutoring company matching students with online tutors
 Founded by 3 Stanford graduates
 High quality tutors screened
 Subjects cover topics in higher education
APPENDIX

BIz Model for Coursera

  • 1.
    MT5016 BUSINESS MODELS FORHI-TECH PRODUCTS Roberto De Joya Jr. A0118989E Ryan Michael Gelig A0098535R Zhou Xintao A0098599X Liang Liang A0098464N Jonathan Castillo A0098438M Wong Chee Yeow A0104437M
  • 2.
    INTRODUCTION SCOPE OF ACTIVITES VALUEPROPOSITION COMPETITOR ANALYSIS CUSTOMER SELECTION VALUE CAPTURE STRATEGIC CONTROL
  • 3.
    CHANGING TREND INHIGHER EDUCATION Rising Costs Perception of shrinking financial returns of education Unequal access to employers Unequal access to education
  • 4.
    RISING COSTS OFHIGHER EDUCATION http://www.bloomberg.com/news/2013-08-26/college-costs-surge-500-in-u-s-since-1985-chart-of-the-day.html http://money.cnn.com/2011/06/13/news/economy/college_tuition_middle_class/
  • 5.
    Free and paid(for premium services) educational courses offered online and open to anyone The concept started from University of Phoenix’s initiative in 1989 1st MOOC experiment launched in 2008 by Stephen Downes and George Siemens, “Connectivism and Connective Knowledge” Current MOOC providers: Coursera, Udacity, edX, KhanX New York Times declared 2012 as the "Year of the MOOC" MASSIVE OPEN ONLINE COURSES
  • 6.
    MASSIVE OPEN ONLINECOURSES http://elearninginfographics.com/wp-content/uploads/Are-MOOCs-the-Future-of-Online-Education-Infographic.jpg
  • 7.
    COURSERA Founded in 2012by Prof. Daphne Koller and Andrew Ng from Stanford University Raised $65M in funding from Silicon Valley VCs 6.8M registered users Offering 600+ courses 108 partner institutions
  • 8.
  • 9.
    INTRODUCTION SCOPE OF ACTIVITIES VALUEPROPOSITION COMPETITOR ANALYSIS CUSTOMER SELECTION VALUE CAPTURE STRATEGIC CONTROL
  • 10.
    SCOPE OF ACTIVITIES COURSERA Learning Institutions/ Universities Amazon Web Services ACE Publishers Translators Content Delivery X Licensing X Distribution X Screening Services X Marketing X Content Development X Web Storage X Server Infrastructure X Search X Accreditation X Reading Materials X Translations X
  • 11.
    INTRODUCTION SCOPE OF ACTIVITIES VALUEPROPOSITION COMPETITOR ANALYSIS CUSTOMER SELECTION VALUE CAPTURE STRATEGIC CONTROL
  • 12.
    Elite Universities, Publishers Students Students Students within acourse Peer assessments Free + Paid courses Course content, textbook recommendations Amazon Ad exposure for textbook recommendations Employers Job placement for qualified students List of Qualified Students to Hire Textbooks ACE Credit ACE Credits granted on passing Signature Track and Credit Exam Course Accreditation Non-partner Institutions School Credits License to use platform and certain courses VALUE PROPOSITION VALUE NETWORK
  • 13.
     COURSERA willonly offer classes/content from the most reputable institutions.  A composition of the members of the Association of American Universities or “top five” universities in countries outside of North America. VALUE PROPOSITION PRESTIGIOUS COURSES
  • 14.
    Students who havecompleted the course with Signature Track will receive a Verified Certificate issued by COURSERA and the participating university. VALUE PROPOSITION SIGNATURE TRACK
  • 15.
     Verified Certificateproves that they have met the passing criteria of the online courses offered by a university on COURSERA.  It can be used to advance in their careers, gain valuable credentials, or build on what they already know.  People can also list their Verified Certificate on their résumé/CV and include it on social media/career profiles. VALUE PROPOSITION VERIFIED CERTIFICATE
  • 16.
    Students can earnan ACE CREDIT (American Council on Education’s College Credit) by signing up for an eligible course in the Signature Track. As well as taking an online proctored Credit Recommendation Exam at the end of the course. VALUE PROPOSITION RECOGNITION OF CREDITS
  • 17.
    COURSERA Career Services- opt-in recruiting service that allows students to find and connect with positions that “match their skills and interests.” VALUE PROPOSITION CAREER ADVANCEMENT
  • 18.
    INTRODUCTION SCOPE OF ACTIVITIES VALUEPROPOSITION COMPETITOR ANALYSIS CUSTOMER SELECTION VALUE CAPTURE STRATEGIC CONTROL
  • 19.
  • 20.
    *As of January2014 COMPETITOR ANALYSIS Organization Status For-profit For-profit Non-profit Funding $65M $21.1M $60M Number of Students 5+ million 1.8 million 1.65 million Number of Courses 532 (Broad range of subjects) 33 (Technical fields) 125 (Broad range of subjects) Number of Languages 5 63+ 1 Pacing Start and end dates No start/end dates (suggested completion time) Start and end dates Verified Certification Virtually verified certificates for $30-100 for 70 courses Virtually and physically proctored exam certificates Physically proctored exam certificates Accreditation 5 courses offered for ACE credit for $90-190; Credit at licensing institutions 5 courses offered for credit at California State University system for $150 Credit at licensing institutions Career Services Limited number of companies Network of 400+ companies None Platform Development Company Company + student contributions Open-source Content Development Outsourced to elite partner institutions Co-developed with instructors Developed by institutions in xConsortium
  • 21.
  • 22.
    INTRODUCTION SCOPE OF ACTIVITIES VALUEPROPOSITION COMPETITOR ANALYSIS CUSTOMER SELECTION VALUE CAPTURE STRATEGIC CONTROL
  • 23.
  • 24.
    Individuals from aroundthe world Individuals with busy schedulesIndividuals interested in prestigious courses Individuals pursuing particular courses CUSTOMER SELECTION INDIVIDUALS
  • 25.
    CUSTOMER SELECTION INDIVIDUALS Source: MOOCs@ Edinburgh 2013, 10 May 2013 95 41 33 32 20 12 7 1 LearnNew Things TryOnline Education Togeta certificate Improveone's career Seewhat MOOC'sare Meetnew people Browse Edinburgh's Offering Unsure Aspirations MOTIVATION SURVEY
  • 26.
  • 27.
    INTRODUCTION SCOPE OF ACTIVITIES VALUEPROPOSITION COMPETITOR ANALYSIS CUSTOMER SELECTION VALUE CAPTURE STRATEGIC CONTROL
  • 28.
  • 29.
    VALUE CAPTURE VALUE CHAIN EliteUniversities, Publishers Students Students Students within a course Peer assessments Free + Paid courses Course content, textbook recommendations % gross revenue from courses Amazon Exposure for textbook recommendations % commission on each book sale Employers Job placement for qualified students List of Qualified Students to Hire money Textbooks money Payment for Signature Track Program ACE Credit ACE Credits granted on passing Signature Track and Credit Exam Evaluation Fee Course Accreditation Non-partner Institutions School Credits Licensing Fees: $3000 + additional fee per student License to use platform and certain courses
  • 30.
    Signature Track Premium Service USD30-90per course + USD60-90 for exam VALUE CAPTURE PREMIUM SERVICES Estimated total revenue of USD$1,300,000 in 12 months (25,000 students in the Signature Tracks)
  • 31.
    Specialization Certificate for a setof courses USD300-500 per certificate VALUE CAPTURE PREMIUM SERVICES
  • 32.
    VALUE CAPTURE LICENSING Licensing ofCOURSERA platform and certain courses to non- partner institutions USD3,000 + additional fee per student
  • 33.
    Affiliates Program withAmazon COURSERA will collect profit from Amazon.com each time students buy recommended textbooks. http://www.timeshighereducation.co.uk/news/coursera-strikes-deal-with-publishers-on-textbooks/2003754.article “The publishers will make relevant chapters from e-textbooks available free of charge, although students who wish to read the books in full, or read them once their course has ended, will have to purchase them.” VALUE CAPTURE AFFILIATES PROGRAM
  • 34.
    COURSERA Company Gear Earnstwice as much money than textbook revenues VALUE CAPTURE MERCHANDISE
  • 35.
    COURSERA Career Services Companiesseeking qualified employees pay a certain fee for introduction, with a share of that revenue going to colleges that offer the course. VALUE CAPTURE CAREER SERVICES
  • 36.
    INTRODUCTION SCOPE OF ACTIVITIES VALUEPROPOSITION COMPETITOR ANALYSIS CUSTOMER SELECTION VALUE CAPTURE STRATEGIC CONTROL
  • 37.
     Signature Track:Obtained certificates can be used as degree credits.  ACE credit: expand to more subjects  College credit: Universities can offer courses that can be counted for college credits  Secure Assessments: Testing centers to prove students have done work themselves  Establish the Gold Standard in Course Certification recognized worldwide (like GMAT, IELTS) by employers and universities  Security: Identity verification technology through keystroke biometrics and webcam  Partnerships:  Job Opportunities STRATEGIC CONTROL COMPLIMENTARY ASSETS
  • 38.
    STRATEGIC CONTROL BARRIER OFENTRY  Strengthen and establish exclusive relationships with Elite Institutions  Course videos, tests and presentations are delivered only through: a. COURSERA website; b. Mobile application for iOS, Android, Windows Phone; or c. Limit the usage of course materials within the COURSERA web platform and mobile application.
  • 39.
     Corporate learning:COURSERA provide specific courses for companies with charges  ‘Freemium’ model: Charge for courses that students are interested to further pursue after introductory chapters  Company-sponsored courses: give options to employers to bid for Signature Track with the courses they prefer or build customized Track for employers  Charging tuition: Universities can offer tutors for courses  Charging for Proctored Exams: offer proctoring services that connect proctors and students via webcam STRATEGIC CONTROL REVENUE
  • 40.
    • Develop theCOURSERAPad, a cheap tablet device with all the tools pre-installed for learning-on-the-go • Can be used by students from primary to university level • Manufacturing will be outsourced STRATEGIC CONTROL REVENUE
  • 41.
    COURSERAPad: a colormultitouch tablet running COURSERA OS for learning-on-the-go • Software: – OS: customized version of Android – COURSERA Store: similar to iTunes University where users can choose new courses to enroll in. – COURSERA Apps: Pre-installed apps that can help in learning Math, Algebra, Accounting, Physics, etc. • Hardware: – Processor and memory enough to run apps smoothly – Webcam for identity verification in Signature Track – WiFi for internet connectivity – Touchscreen STRATEGIC CONTROL REVENUE
  • 42.
    STRATEGIC CONTROL BUSINESS MODEL Employers Students Students Studentswithin a course Coursera Peer assessments Freemium or Paid Certified Courses Screen and recommend potential candidates Advertisers Advertising Fees InstaEDU Online Tutor Commission on sales Payment for Signature Track and/or COURSERAPad LinkedIn Student Data (Grades and Certifications) Companies Specialized Courses Exposure for Online Tutor services Exposure for Ads Signature Track students get free access to LinkedIn’s Premium Services Commission on recruited COURSERA students Recruitment and advertising fees Access to talent database and ad space Bid for Signature Track courses based on preferred topic COURSERA Pad Fees for corporate learning Online tutoring Pay discounted rate *In addition to COURSERA’s current business model
  • 43.
  • 44.
    Revenue for 9months (ending in Sept. 30, 2013) *numbers in thousands  Business networking website  Number of Users: 277 million, Revenue: $1.52 billion  Alexa global website ranking: 8th APPENDIX
  • 45.
     Online tutoringcompany matching students with online tutors  Founded by 3 Stanford graduates  High quality tutors screened  Subjects cover topics in higher education APPENDIX