This document summarizes several audience theory models:
- Uses and Gratification Theory examines audience motives for media consumption and views audiences as active in choosing media to fulfill social and psychological needs.
- Reception Theory holds that media texts encode producer messages but audiences can decode meanings differently, such as preferred, negotiated, or oppositional readings.
- The Hypodermic Needle Theory sees audiences as passive receivers of media messages that directly influence behaviors, but this view is now outdated given more active audience roles.
2. Bulmer & Katz – Uses & Gratification
Theory
Effects of the media from the POV of audiences
The theory…
• Looks @ motives of the people who use the media, e.g. why we watch the
TV programmes we do
• Makes the audience active – they choose and have control over what they
consume
• Explains that audience has social & psychological needs which generate
certain expectations about mass media & what they’re exposed to
People are motivated by a desire to gratify certain needs – the 4 different
needs:
• Surveillance – aware of what is going on in the world
• Personal Identity – confirm the identity & positioning of ourselves within
society
• Personal Relationship – we form a relationship with the media & we use
media within relationships with real people
• Diversion – forget about our own lives & problems (escapism)
3. Stuart Hall – Reception Theory
The reception theory…
• States that media texts are encoded by the producer – whoever
produces the text fills the product with values & messages
• The text is then decoded by spectators
• Different spectators will decode the text in different ways – not always
the way the producer intended
Producer encodes message/meaning
Dominant/Preferred
Reading
Negotiated
Reading
Oppositional
Reading
Audience view the media
text in the way the producer
intended & agree with the
message
Audience accepts the view of
the producer but also has
their own
input/understanding of the
text (don’t agree or disagree)
Audience rejects the
preferred reading, as
they don’t agree with
the message & create
their own reading of the
text
4. Hypodermic Needle Theory
Creator Audience
Whatever the creator says, the audience will believe…
• Assumes audience will understand the message
• Audience = passive – we soak up the media like a sponge
• We don’t challenge – no individual differences
Implies media had a direct, immediate & powerful effect on audiences – mass
media in 40s & 50s were perceived as a powerful influence on behaviour change
Several factors contribute to this “strong effects” theory of communication
including:
• Fast rise & popularisation of radio & TV
• Emergence of the persuasion industries, such as ads & propaganda
Suggests that…
• Mass media could influence a large group of people directly & uniformly by
‘shooting’ & ‘injecting’ them with appropriate messages designed to trigger a
desired response
• There’s a direct flow of info from sender receiver
• Media = a dangerous means of communicating an idea because receiver is
powerless to resist the impact of the message
This theory is outdated & invalid – more up to date theories have proved that
audiences aren’t simply passive