Sustainable Value Cycle Solutions




Ellen MacArthur Foundation webinar 24 April 2012

             “Innovation and Value Creation”
Invention or Innovation ?

Invention:
    The creation of an idea or a method

Innovation:
    The use of a new idea or method
Where does innovation take place?

Technical environment
Jet engine, Digital revolution, nuclear fusion, synthetic fibre (Nylon)




Business Model
Amazon, MacDonalds, Zara, EasyJet, Dell




System Level
Harley Davidson, Facebook, Google, Ford
Where does innovation take place?

Technical environment
Jet engine, Digital revolution, nuclear fusion, synthetic fibre (Nylon)




Business Model
Amazon, MacDonalds, Zara, EasyJet, Dell




System Level
Harley Davidson, Facebook, Google, Ford
Henry Ford’s real legacy

            Ford’s vision was a car for every home….

            "I will build a car for the great multitude. It will be large
            enough for the family, but small enough for the individual to
            run and care for. It will be constructed of the best materials, by
            the best men to be hired, after the simplest designs that
            modern engineering can devise. But it will be so low in price
            that no man making a good salary will be unable to own one –
            and enjoy with his family the blessing of hours of pleasure in
            God's great open spaces”




Personal mobility
Innovation             Business



         ?
                                                                Revenue and
                                          Value
                       Innovation                                 business
                                         Creation                  growth




"Companies cannot grow through cost reduction and re-engineering
alone... Innovation is the key element in providing aggressive top-line
growth, and for increasing bottom-line results."
                                         Davila et al. ”Making Innovation Work” (2006)
Drivers for Innovation
Resources




                                                                                                       Social
                                                                 Consumer/Market
                                 Technology
            • Historical issue                • 1950-70s                           • 1980-00s                   • 2005+
            • Materials                       • Mass                               • Marketing/Brand            • People/network
            • Labour                            production and                       driven                       driven
            • Water                             manufacturing                      • Experience                 • Transformation
            • Fuel                            • Consumption                        • Consumer                   • Co-creation and
            • Crisis/war                      • Push to                              Insights                     content
                                                consumer

                                              • “company is                        • “customer is               • “Customer is my
                                                King”                                King”                        best friend”
..but something else is changing


“..Traditional approaches to business will collapse, and companies
will have to develop innovative solutions. That will happen only when
executives recognize a simple truth: Sustainability = Innovation..”
Source: HBR, Sept 2009




        “It is more intriguing that outperformance on revenue
        growth is correlated with superior creation of stakeholder value”
        Source: “The granularity of growth”, McKinsey Quarterly, 2007
The additional drivers for innovation

   Traditional
Cost
Technology
Consumer needs

                                  Stakeholder   Revenue and
      Drivers        Innovation      value        business
                                    creation       growth


Resources/waste
Social
Environmental
   Holistic


                          …a formula for business success
Current economy




Resources
“We can't solve problems by
   using the same kind of
 thinking we used when we
       created them”
        – Albert Einstein –
Albert Einstein   Gene Simmons - KISS
Circular   Economy
Stakeholder         Revenue and
    Design for
                       Innovation            value              business
      Value
                                            creation             growth




The only sustainability strategy that should be considered is one that is
integral with the business and does not compromise it; a systems approach.

..a cyclic process of innovation, value creation and value recovery.



                    .. a   "Value Cycle"
From concept to reality


1.   Communicate the concept simply
2.   Design “value”products for the system
3.   Use “Trustful and Recoverable” materials
4.   Consumer is my best friend
1. Value Cycle concept



Design
injection               Create
point
                                  Collect

               Source


                             Recover
2. Design “value” products for the system




Great product               Added value
• Deliver on brand promise
• Designed for recycling & value recovery
• Defined periods of use
3. Use trustful and recoverable materials

                               
Source        Content          Usage


                                 
  Source         Content         Usage




                €
•   Managed/renewable source
•   100% known & evaluated content
•   Known use scenario
•   Technically recylable
•   Commercially recoverable
•   Second life target product
•   Safe end of life



      Select and retain materials value
4. Consumer is my best friend




Your design


                       Health and happiness


                 Do more good, not less bad
The result

•   Great products
•   Delighted consumers
•   Lower costs through better design
•   Return on materials investment
•   Eimination of toxins and waste
•   Materials and chemicals (risk) management
•   Brand image enhancement
•   Improved employee engagement

        Multi stakeholder value creation
Maximising Value
                                            Value Cycle design




Brand         • Brand promise
              • Social & Ethical position


                  • Primary function
Product           • Primary proposition


    Product        • Additional value
 discriminators    • Supporting argument
Case study… Desso AirMaster




Brand        •Brand promise: “Creativity, Ambition, Flexibility, Cradle to Cradle”
             •Social & Ethical position: Cradle to Cradle company & products


              •Primary function:   floor covering
Product       •Primary proposition: high quality, durable, trending designs



   Product    •Additional value: improves indoor air quality
Discriminator •Supporting argument: C2C certified, take back & recycling
Not just a one off

                             More Innovation..

                             • Light reflecting carpets
                             • Aviation carpeting


                              Desso profitability (EBIT)
                                                                  9%



60% accousitc damping
                                                    4.5%
+10dB sound reduction
                                      <1%

                               2006          2008          2010
The Value
           Internal value
•   New consumer value spaces/ideas
•   Innovative and critical designs
•   Materials risk and flow management
•   Reduced data set of materials
•   Reduced BoM
•   ROI from materials recovery
•   Employee engagement


                                              External value
                                   •   Brand enhancement
                                   •   Superior primary function
                                   •   Additional functionality (descriminator)
                                   •   Supported sustainability program
                                   •   Option to certify or label
                                   •   Delighted consumers
                                   •   Market and business growth
Sustainable Value Cycle Solutions



                                              “Value creation in sustainability”




Staff training   Strategic advice                 Interim expert management
  • Workshops    • Materials development               • Specialist competences
  • Coaching     • Supply chain development            • Partner selection & engagement
                 • Ideation for innovation
Corporate Sustainability office            CL Board of management



                                                             Andy Hall
  Consumer Lifestyle -C2C and resource effectiveness team      Sustainability
                                                            Innovation Manager




                                                               Preferred
                                                               Materials
                                                               Program

Andy Hall - Innovation and value creation

  • 1.
    Sustainable Value CycleSolutions Ellen MacArthur Foundation webinar 24 April 2012 “Innovation and Value Creation”
  • 2.
    Invention or Innovation? Invention: The creation of an idea or a method Innovation: The use of a new idea or method
  • 3.
    Where does innovationtake place? Technical environment Jet engine, Digital revolution, nuclear fusion, synthetic fibre (Nylon) Business Model Amazon, MacDonalds, Zara, EasyJet, Dell System Level Harley Davidson, Facebook, Google, Ford
  • 5.
    Where does innovationtake place? Technical environment Jet engine, Digital revolution, nuclear fusion, synthetic fibre (Nylon) Business Model Amazon, MacDonalds, Zara, EasyJet, Dell System Level Harley Davidson, Facebook, Google, Ford
  • 6.
    Henry Ford’s reallegacy Ford’s vision was a car for every home…. "I will build a car for the great multitude. It will be large enough for the family, but small enough for the individual to run and care for. It will be constructed of the best materials, by the best men to be hired, after the simplest designs that modern engineering can devise. But it will be so low in price that no man making a good salary will be unable to own one – and enjoy with his family the blessing of hours of pleasure in God's great open spaces” Personal mobility
  • 7.
    Innovation Business ? Revenue and Value Innovation business Creation growth "Companies cannot grow through cost reduction and re-engineering alone... Innovation is the key element in providing aggressive top-line growth, and for increasing bottom-line results." Davila et al. ”Making Innovation Work” (2006)
  • 8.
    Drivers for Innovation Resources Social Consumer/Market Technology • Historical issue • 1950-70s • 1980-00s • 2005+ • Materials • Mass • Marketing/Brand • People/network • Labour production and driven driven • Water manufacturing • Experience • Transformation • Fuel • Consumption • Consumer • Co-creation and • Crisis/war • Push to Insights content consumer • “company is • “customer is • “Customer is my King” King” best friend”
  • 9.
    ..but something elseis changing “..Traditional approaches to business will collapse, and companies will have to develop innovative solutions. That will happen only when executives recognize a simple truth: Sustainability = Innovation..” Source: HBR, Sept 2009 “It is more intriguing that outperformance on revenue growth is correlated with superior creation of stakeholder value” Source: “The granularity of growth”, McKinsey Quarterly, 2007
  • 10.
    The additional driversfor innovation Traditional Cost Technology Consumer needs Stakeholder Revenue and Drivers Innovation value business creation growth Resources/waste Social Environmental Holistic …a formula for business success
  • 11.
  • 12.
    “We can't solveproblems by using the same kind of thinking we used when we created them” – Albert Einstein –
  • 13.
    Albert Einstein Gene Simmons - KISS
  • 14.
    Circular Economy
  • 15.
    Stakeholder Revenue and Design for Innovation value business Value creation growth The only sustainability strategy that should be considered is one that is integral with the business and does not compromise it; a systems approach. ..a cyclic process of innovation, value creation and value recovery. .. a "Value Cycle"
  • 16.
    From concept toreality 1. Communicate the concept simply 2. Design “value”products for the system 3. Use “Trustful and Recoverable” materials 4. Consumer is my best friend
  • 17.
    1. Value Cycleconcept Design injection Create point Collect Source Recover
  • 18.
    2. Design “value”products for the system Great product Added value
  • 19.
    • Deliver onbrand promise • Designed for recycling & value recovery • Defined periods of use
  • 20.
    3. Use trustfuland recoverable materials    Source Content Usage    Source Content Usage €
  • 21.
    Managed/renewable source • 100% known & evaluated content • Known use scenario • Technically recylable • Commercially recoverable • Second life target product • Safe end of life Select and retain materials value
  • 22.
    4. Consumer ismy best friend Your design Health and happiness Do more good, not less bad
  • 23.
    The result • Great products • Delighted consumers • Lower costs through better design • Return on materials investment • Eimination of toxins and waste • Materials and chemicals (risk) management • Brand image enhancement • Improved employee engagement Multi stakeholder value creation
  • 24.
    Maximising Value Value Cycle design Brand • Brand promise • Social & Ethical position • Primary function Product • Primary proposition Product • Additional value discriminators • Supporting argument
  • 25.
    Case study… DessoAirMaster Brand •Brand promise: “Creativity, Ambition, Flexibility, Cradle to Cradle” •Social & Ethical position: Cradle to Cradle company & products •Primary function: floor covering Product •Primary proposition: high quality, durable, trending designs Product •Additional value: improves indoor air quality Discriminator •Supporting argument: C2C certified, take back & recycling
  • 26.
    Not just aone off More Innovation.. • Light reflecting carpets • Aviation carpeting Desso profitability (EBIT) 9% 60% accousitc damping 4.5% +10dB sound reduction <1% 2006 2008 2010
  • 27.
    The Value Internal value • New consumer value spaces/ideas • Innovative and critical designs • Materials risk and flow management • Reduced data set of materials • Reduced BoM • ROI from materials recovery • Employee engagement External value • Brand enhancement • Superior primary function • Additional functionality (descriminator) • Supported sustainability program • Option to certify or label • Delighted consumers • Market and business growth
  • 28.
    Sustainable Value CycleSolutions “Value creation in sustainability” Staff training Strategic advice Interim expert management • Workshops • Materials development • Specialist competences • Coaching • Supply chain development • Partner selection & engagement • Ideation for innovation
  • 29.
    Corporate Sustainability office CL Board of management Andy Hall Consumer Lifestyle -C2C and resource effectiveness team Sustainability Innovation Manager Preferred Materials Program

Editor's Notes

  • #3 It is about bringing the idea to market
  • #4 Apple also has a technical evolution history
  • #8 The difference between efficient and effective strategy.
  • #9 Take-Make-Dispose paradigm is not sustainable
  • #17 Normally where it goes wrong: the translation step to a practical operation
  • #24 Zoom in on chemicals and employees. What you have built is a value delivery &amp; recovery system, rather than a quantatative measurement tool.
  • #29  Your own personal tagline…….4 cs Cost, confusion, commitment and collaboration. Cost is the biggest barrier to sustainability activities but value is the business driver….SVCS identifies the innovation opportunities and the value creation scenarios.Not all innovation is technical. Premium brands need to discriminate on difference not compete on price or volume.