comparative study between two nationalistic heroes of subcontinent independence struggle; Muhammad Ali Jinnah and Subhas Chandra Bose

1. Sidra Jabeen Khan

2. Introduction Heroes
 success and lost legacy
 Jinnah: Charismatic
leader
 Bose: true nationalist
 criticism
 Great Quaid
 Warrior Bose
 Conflict in thoughts

3. Beginning Years (early life-1910)
 S.C.Bose:
 Intellectual
 studies in philosophy
 Calcutta and Cambridge educational institutes
 Swami Viveknanda as spiritual guide
 violent means
 ICS officer

4. Beginning Years (early life-1910)
 M.A.Jinnah:
 studied law
 Madrasa tul Islam
 England
 charisma emerging
 Start of Politics
 Joining of Congress
 A lawyer

5. Formative Years (1911-1920)
 S.C.Bose:
 completion of studies
 Topped ranks
 ICS officer
 4th position in ICS exam

6. Formative Years (1911-1920)
 M.A.Jinnah:
 Formation of intrinsic magnetism
 hypocrisy of Congress
 political journey
 Marriage
 daughter

7. 1913: joining Muslim
League
1917: president of Home
rule league
1920: resigned home rule
league and congress

8. Years of disillusionment and
tangled politics (1920-1935)
 S.C.Bose:
 political career
 hard struggle
 campaigns, strikes
 prison timings
 fighting’s against Raj

9. 1934:
Returned
to India
11 time jails
1932: Issued
manifesto in
Vienna
Nov, 1934:
Issued book:
“The Indian
Struggle”
1930: mayor
of Calcutta

10. Years of disillusionment and
tangled politics (1920-1935)
 M.A.Jinnah:
 political rivalries
 ambassador of Hindu-Muslim unity
 Hindu Vendetta
 suffered in personal life
 Exile
 return to India
 tactics

11. 1922: APC
1927: Simon
Commission
1925: national
convention
1929: Nehru
Report
1930: Round
Table
Conferences

12. Reawakening (1935-1940)
 S.C.Bose:
 joining of Congress
 Jinnah-Bose correspondence
 violent means
 differences with Gandhi
 Resignation
 house arrest

13. Reawakening (1935-1940)
 M.A.Jinnah:
 Elections
 Congress Raj
 height of Charisma
 resolution as phoenix in the ashes

14. 1936: elections
1937: provincial elections
Congress raj
1939: day of Deliverance
1940: Lahore Resolution passed

15. A good fighter & a warrior (1941-
1948)
 S.C.Bose:
 escaped house arrest
 seek Hitler’s help
 formation of Azad Hind
Radio, army and Govt
 war against British
 counterattack of
commonwealth
 escaped to Russia
 killed in Japanese Bomber
(1945)

16. Calcutta
Gomo
PeshawarKabul
Germany
Escaped
house
arrest
Seeked help
from Adolf
Hitler

17. Formed:
Azad Hind
Radio Station
(1943)
Azad Hind Fauj
(Singapore,
India)
Azad Hind
Government
(own rules)

18. Freed admand &
Mcobar Islands
Named them as
Swaraj &
Shaheed
Rangoon became
new basecamp
Barma: Hoist
Indian flag in
Manipul
Counterattack of
common wealth
Retreat and fall
of Rangoon
Bose’s dreams
destroyed
Escaped to
Russia for
seeking help
Got killed in
Japanese Bomber
in Taipei

19. A good fighter & a warrior (1941-
1948)
 M.A.Jinnah:
 Jinnah’s success
 AIML sessions
 Gandhi Jinnah talks
 cabinet Mission plan
 Independence
 Quaid-e-Azam
 1st governor General
 death (1948)

20. A
Fighter
1943: rejected
Raja Gopal
Acchariya
formula
1944: Gandhi
Jinnah talks
1945: Simla
conference
1946: sweeps
polls in
elections,
accept cabinet
mission plan
then rejected
1947: Indian
Independence
act passed,
Pakistan came
into being

21. Conclusion
 Brave and courageous
 Charisma
 magnetic personalities
 mastermind tactician Jinnah
 Emotional fool Bose
 lost legacy of Bose
 A great hero Jinnah