38 I AUTOMATING INEQ!!AUTY
during times of economic crisis. Poor and working-c
lass people
resist restrictions of their rights, dismantle discriminatory in
sti
tutions, and join together for survival and mutual aid. But ti
me
and again they face middle-class backlash. Social assistan
ce is re
cast as charity, mutual aid is reconstructed as dependency,
and
new techniques to turn back the progress of the poor prolifera
te .
A well-funded, widely supported, and wildly successful counter-
movement to deny basic human rights to poor and working-clas
s
people has grown steadily since the 1970s. The movement man
u
factures and circulates misleading stories about the poor: t
hat
they are an undeserving, fraudulent, dependent, and immo
ral
minority. Conservative critics of the welfare state continue to ru
n -
a very effective propaganda campaign to convince Americans t
hat __
-
the working class and the poor must battle each other in a z
ero-_
sum game over limited resources. More quietly, program
ministrators and data scientists push high-tech tools
promise to help more people, more humanely, while un_,,,.,_,.,,
efficiency, identifying fraud, and containing costs. The
poorhouse is framed as a way to rationalize and streamline
fits, but the real goal is what it has always been: to profile, vuJ«�
--,- -
and punish the poor.
2
AUTOMATING HIGIBIUTY IN
THE HEARTLAND
A little white donkey is chewing on a fencepost where we turn
coward the Stipes house on a narrow utility road paralleling
the train tracks in Tipton, Indiana. Michael "Dan" Skinner,
65-year-old ex-newspaper man and my guide to central Indiana,
heaves his mom's 19-year-old sedan across the tracks and imo
the Stipes family's driveway a mile or so later. Their big white
house is marooned in a sea of cornfields, but on this sunny day
.-. in March 2015, the stalks are cut back low and softened by snow
•-•· melting to mud. Kim and Kevin Stipes joke that they've had to
\ grow tall children: come July, the smaller ones disappear into the
\ corn. I'm here to talk to Kim and Kevin about their daughter So
/phie, who lost her Medicaid benefits during Indiana's experiment
\with welfare eligibility automation.
\ In 2012, I delivered a lecture at Indiana University Blooming
••••- ton about how new data-based technologies were impacting pub
\ lie services. When I was finished, a well-dressed man raised his hand
and asked the question that would launch this book. "You know,"
he asked, "what's going on here in Indiana, right?" I looked at
40 I AUTOMAUN_G INE~ALITY
him blankly and shook my head, He gave me a quick synopsis:
a $L3 billion contract to privatize and automate the state's
welfare eligibility processes, thousands losing benefits, a high-
profile breach-of-contract case for the Indiana Supreme Court,
He handed me his card, In gold letters it identified him as Matt
Pierce, Democratic member of the Indiana House of Represen-
tatives. ...
The document discusses hippies in the 1960s, describing them as the upcoming generation in America during that time who challenged views on war and society. It notes that while hippies are often portrayed negatively as dirty drug addicts, they actually led one of the largest historically defined movements by reconstructing judgments on issues like war. The summary provides context on how hippies emerged as a counterculture movement during that era that promoted peace, love, and alternative lifestyles.
This document discusses the history of social work and child protection in New Zealand. It summarizes that historically, social work involved adopting out children after World War I when women entered the workforce. It then discusses how today, social work focuses more on policing parents and removing children from homes over concerns of potential abuse. The document raises concerns that current practices mirror historical mistakes and that new parents are worried children will be taken at birth without cause. It lists the many government and non-government organizations that share information about families with child protection agencies.
This document discusses issues facing Aboriginal children in Canada, including historical contexts of discrimination and challenges today. It notes that Aboriginal children are overrepresented in child welfare systems and face higher risks like substance abuse, suicide, and poverty due to impacts of the residential school system, lack of culturally-appropriate support services, and jurisdictional disputes between governments over funding responsibilities. The document argues that Canada is not fully upholding the rights of Aboriginal children as outlined in the UN Convention on the Rights of the Child.
This document discusses several social ills in Indian society, including child labor, dowry, casteism, population growth, and poverty. It notes that child labor is driven by factors like poverty, population growth, and lack of education. Dowry is still practiced despite being outlawed, and can lead to dowry deaths. Casteism continues to create social and economic divides. Population growth outpacing resources exacerbates problems. Suggested solutions include improving education, literacy, family planning programs, and stronger enforcement of laws against practices like child labor and dowry. Overall, the document analyzes key social issues in India and their complex interrelationships.
Celebrating 10 Years of Great Journalism Fostered by the Dennis A. Hunt Fund ...reportingonhealth
This document provides information about the Dennis A. Hunt Fund for Health Journalism, which has supported over 60 journalists over the past 10 years in producing impactful investigative journalism projects related to community health issues. Some of the projects have led to policy changes and community improvements, such as increased access to healthcare and reductions in environmental toxins. The fund continues to support new classes of journalists each year in addressing important health topics.
The document discusses a forum on health care disparities in the African American community that Congressman Keith Ellison will attend. It provides background on the deinstitutionalization movement of the 1980s and issues facing minority families seeking services. The author recommends that Ellison hold community discussions on disability services, address barriers to community living, and close the Minnesota Extended Treatment Option program, diverting its funds to community-based options instead.
The annual report summarizes the Legal Aid Society of San Mateo County's work and impact in 2014. Some key details:
- They helped 2,844 low-income families and individuals with legal issues.
- 79% of their clients had extremely low incomes, while 14% had very low incomes.
- They obtained over 9,600 hours of pro bono legal services valued at $3.2 million from 421 legal professionals.
- Their work focused on preventing homelessness, obtaining healthcare and income support, overcoming domestic violence, and addressing education issues.
The document discusses hippies in the 1960s, describing them as the upcoming generation in America during that time who challenged views on war and society. It notes that while hippies are often portrayed negatively as dirty drug addicts, they actually led one of the largest historically defined movements by reconstructing judgments on issues like war. The summary provides context on how hippies emerged as a counterculture movement during that era that promoted peace, love, and alternative lifestyles.
This document discusses the history of social work and child protection in New Zealand. It summarizes that historically, social work involved adopting out children after World War I when women entered the workforce. It then discusses how today, social work focuses more on policing parents and removing children from homes over concerns of potential abuse. The document raises concerns that current practices mirror historical mistakes and that new parents are worried children will be taken at birth without cause. It lists the many government and non-government organizations that share information about families with child protection agencies.
This document discusses issues facing Aboriginal children in Canada, including historical contexts of discrimination and challenges today. It notes that Aboriginal children are overrepresented in child welfare systems and face higher risks like substance abuse, suicide, and poverty due to impacts of the residential school system, lack of culturally-appropriate support services, and jurisdictional disputes between governments over funding responsibilities. The document argues that Canada is not fully upholding the rights of Aboriginal children as outlined in the UN Convention on the Rights of the Child.
This document discusses several social ills in Indian society, including child labor, dowry, casteism, population growth, and poverty. It notes that child labor is driven by factors like poverty, population growth, and lack of education. Dowry is still practiced despite being outlawed, and can lead to dowry deaths. Casteism continues to create social and economic divides. Population growth outpacing resources exacerbates problems. Suggested solutions include improving education, literacy, family planning programs, and stronger enforcement of laws against practices like child labor and dowry. Overall, the document analyzes key social issues in India and their complex interrelationships.
Celebrating 10 Years of Great Journalism Fostered by the Dennis A. Hunt Fund ...reportingonhealth
This document provides information about the Dennis A. Hunt Fund for Health Journalism, which has supported over 60 journalists over the past 10 years in producing impactful investigative journalism projects related to community health issues. Some of the projects have led to policy changes and community improvements, such as increased access to healthcare and reductions in environmental toxins. The fund continues to support new classes of journalists each year in addressing important health topics.
The document discusses a forum on health care disparities in the African American community that Congressman Keith Ellison will attend. It provides background on the deinstitutionalization movement of the 1980s and issues facing minority families seeking services. The author recommends that Ellison hold community discussions on disability services, address barriers to community living, and close the Minnesota Extended Treatment Option program, diverting its funds to community-based options instead.
The annual report summarizes the Legal Aid Society of San Mateo County's work and impact in 2014. Some key details:
- They helped 2,844 low-income families and individuals with legal issues.
- 79% of their clients had extremely low incomes, while 14% had very low incomes.
- They obtained over 9,600 hours of pro bono legal services valued at $3.2 million from 421 legal professionals.
- Their work focused on preventing homelessness, obtaining healthcare and income support, overcoming domestic violence, and addressing education issues.
The document summarizes China's one-child policy, which was introduced in 1979 to reduce China's population growth. It discusses how the policy was enforced through a bureaucracy that monitored families and imposed fines or forced abortions/sterilizations for extra children. It also notes issues that arose, such as families hiding undocumented children or skirting the rules in other ways. Some children of parents who broke the rules were allegedly taken and sold to orphanages for international adoption, victimizing vulnerable families. In general, the policy was intended to control population but its stringent enforcement sometimes caused human rights issues.
A Modest Proposal Summary
Health Care Proposal Essay
Outline: a Modest Proposal Essay
Proposal Argument Essay
Project Proposal Essay
A Modest Proposal Thesis
Sports Program Proposal
Proposal Argument Essay
The one child policy was introduced in China in 1979 to control the country's large population growth. It limited urban families to only one child and rural families to two if the first was a girl. This led to forced abortions and sterilizations to meet quotas. It also caused societal issues like a gender imbalance. The policy was relaxed in the late 1990s and early 2000s, banning forced procedures and allowing two children in some areas. However, it was not fully abolished until 2015 due to concerns over caring for the aging population and workforce shortages.
The one child policy was introduced in China in 1979 to control the country's large population growth. It restricted urban families to only one child and rural families to two if the first was a girl. This led to forced abortions and sterilizations to meet quotas. It also caused societal issues like a gender imbalance. While it achieved population control, it was also criticized for infringing on personal freedoms. Recent changes allow two children per family and ban forced birth control measures.
Dr. Grace was privileged to offer this presentation to a panel at the Unicef located at UN headquarters concerning the ministry of the Kenya Heritage Foundation.
This document provides a summary and reflection of the documentary "Sicko" by Michael Moore. It discusses several key issues highlighted in the film, including the high costs of healthcare and medications for seniors in the US, the fully public healthcare system in countries like the UK, and how volunteers who helped with 9/11 recovery efforts struggled to get healthcare coverage afterwards. It also examines issues of healthcare access and costs in other countries like Canada and contrasts their systems to the problems in the US system focused on profits over patient care.
China introduced its one child policy in 1979 to alleviate social and economic problems caused by rapid population growth. The policy limited urban families to one child and rural families to two if the first was a girl. It has prevented over 250 million births but caused gender imbalance as families aborted female fetuses. As fewer young people now support an aging population, China will face soaring healthcare costs and worker shortages in coming decades.
An overview of poverty levels within ethnic communities in the US. Governmental attempts at a baseline. Five types of capital formation within a capitalist infrastructure as pathways out. This is the basis of the video at https://vimeo.com/vivgrigg/uspoverty
Thrilled to announce I've been awarded Fist Place in Roger William University's 2017 Advanced Writing Contest for my policy report “Children & Lunch-Shaming: America’s Neglected Stain."
Lunch-Shaming in America is not often talked about or understood, but has become an increasing problem for the esteem and development of America's children. Children are being wrongfully stigmatized for their family's finances by being denied the same lunch as their peers, receiving a stamp saying "Need Lunch Money", or being forced to perform chores for their lunch.
School lunch companies and school administrations should not be able to stigmatize 2nd, 3rd, 4th graders for something their parents need to deal with.
If any of this makes you sad/angry/annoyed, please feel free to read my report, Children & Lunch Shaming: America's Neglected Stain, and let me know your thoughts!
Pittsburgh Nonprofit Summit - Zero Poverty by 2020 WorkshopGPNP
The time is right for a nonprofit mission to eradicate poverty in the U.S. Escalating poverty is a concern for all and impacts nonprofits serving all purposes, from arts to environment to human services. What are the root causes and what can be done? The UK has committed to zero poverty by 2020. What are they doing to get there and how can we adopt this goal in Southwestern PA? Examine the bold policies set in the U.K. to eradicate poverty by 2020 and learn about other local initiatives that are helping to build the movement.
Documented immigrants need some form of immigration status and means to support themselves financially through jobs and income in order to afford housing in the United States; while documented immigrants can be eligible for public housing, there are usually long wait times of 5 years or more to receive housing. Obtaining a higher paying job allows documented immigrants to afford owning a home or renting an apartment.
Chapter 5The Mediaand ClaimsMedia and the Claims.docxrobertad6
Chapter 5
The Media
and Claims
Media and the Claimsmaking Process
Slide 1
Many claimsmakers seek media attention.
How can they get it?
Why might it be difficult to get?
Media and the Claimsmaking Process
Slide 2
Media coverage plays an important role in
how social problems are constructed.
Activists, experts, and other claimsmakers
hope that the media will bring their claims to
wider audiences and policymakers.
However, media coverage usually alters the
original claim.
Media and the Claimsmaking Process
Slide 3
There are constraints on media workers.
Deadlines
Space and time limits (the “newshole”)
Audience desires entertainment
As a result, primary claims are transformed
into secondary claims by the media.
Media and the Claimsmaking Process
Slide 4
Claimsmakers compete for media attention.
Claimsmakers try to present their claims as
new, fresh material for the media.
The marketplace for social problems can be
thought of as multiple arenas, each with a
limited carrying capacity.
Media workers decide what claims are
presented in the arena they manage.
Media and the Claimsmaking Process
Slide 5
News work locates and presents the news.
News work is constrained by economic
factors, deadlines, and cultural limitations
(such as professionalism).
News work seeks claims with an
entertainment value (“brand-new” stories,
easily filmed events, or claims that have
compelling typifying stories).
Media and the Claimsmaking Process
Slide 6
News work follows professional standards.
News workers may feel obligated to balance
coverage by reporting views from “both sides”
News workers pay attention to rivals and the
stories they decide to cover.
News workers try to avoid being manipulated
by claimsmakers seeking media coverage.
Media and the Claimsmaking Process
Slide 7
Geography influences what claims are heard.
News workers are concentrated in large cities.
Even claimsmakers who begin in distant
places tend to migrate to larger media centers.
Ultimately, the news is a social construction
produced by news workers.
Media and the Claimsmaking Process
Slide 8
How do claimsmakers get media attention?
Package claims in ways that help news
workers and parallel their constraints
Give the media advanced notice of events
Choose interesting individuals to represent
their cause (such as celebrity ambassadors)
Make events visually interesting for TV
Seek media that target the intended audience
Changes in the Media
Slide 1
Cable channels, especially 24-hour cable news
networks, which must fill the newshole on a daily
basis, have increased in number.
Much of the media now target particular
audiences (audience segmentation).
Changes in the Media
Slide 2
The Internet has an unlimited carrying
capacity for claims.
Claimsmakers can establish an online
presence at a minimal cost.
T.
Chapter 5The Mediaand ClaimsMedia and the Claims.docxketurahhazelhurst
Chapter 5
The Media
and Claims
Media and the Claimsmaking Process
Slide 1
Many claimsmakers seek media attention.
How can they get it?
Why might it be difficult to get?
Media and the Claimsmaking Process
Slide 2
Media coverage plays an important role in
how social problems are constructed.
Activists, experts, and other claimsmakers
hope that the media will bring their claims to
wider audiences and policymakers.
However, media coverage usually alters the
original claim.
Media and the Claimsmaking Process
Slide 3
There are constraints on media workers.
Deadlines
Space and time limits (the “newshole”)
Audience desires entertainment
As a result, primary claims are transformed
into secondary claims by the media.
Media and the Claimsmaking Process
Slide 4
Claimsmakers compete for media attention.
Claimsmakers try to present their claims as
new, fresh material for the media.
The marketplace for social problems can be
thought of as multiple arenas, each with a
limited carrying capacity.
Media workers decide what claims are
presented in the arena they manage.
Media and the Claimsmaking Process
Slide 5
News work locates and presents the news.
News work is constrained by economic
factors, deadlines, and cultural limitations
(such as professionalism).
News work seeks claims with an
entertainment value (“brand-new” stories,
easily filmed events, or claims that have
compelling typifying stories).
Media and the Claimsmaking Process
Slide 6
News work follows professional standards.
News workers may feel obligated to balance
coverage by reporting views from “both sides”
News workers pay attention to rivals and the
stories they decide to cover.
News workers try to avoid being manipulated
by claimsmakers seeking media coverage.
Media and the Claimsmaking Process
Slide 7
Geography influences what claims are heard.
News workers are concentrated in large cities.
Even claimsmakers who begin in distant
places tend to migrate to larger media centers.
Ultimately, the news is a social construction
produced by news workers.
Media and the Claimsmaking Process
Slide 8
How do claimsmakers get media attention?
Package claims in ways that help news
workers and parallel their constraints
Give the media advanced notice of events
Choose interesting individuals to represent
their cause (such as celebrity ambassadors)
Make events visually interesting for TV
Seek media that target the intended audience
Changes in the Media
Slide 1
Cable channels, especially 24-hour cable news
networks, which must fill the newshole on a daily
basis, have increased in number.
Much of the media now target particular
audiences (audience segmentation).
Changes in the Media
Slide 2
The Internet has an unlimited carrying
capacity for claims.
Claimsmakers can establish an online
presence at a minimal cost.
T ...
The document summarizes the 2015 Bateman Campaign conducted by Michigan State University students to raise awareness of the Home Matters movement in the Greater Lansing area. It includes an executive summary, situation analysis discussing homelessness statistics, secondary research findings from surveys and interviews, objectives to increase awareness and engagement with the campaign, strategies and tactics used such as social media and on-campus events, and outcomes such as exceeding goals for exposure and participation. The campaign was successful in educating students and the community about Home Matters and inspiring over 100 individuals to join the movement.
C ommentariesEnding Childhood Poverty in America 0c—Mari.docxjasoninnes20
C ommentaries
Ending Childhood Poverty in America 0c—
Marian Wright Edelman
From the Children’s Defense Fund, Washington, DC
The author reports no conflicts of interest.
Address correspondence to Marian Wright Edelman, Children’s Defense Fund, 25 E St NW, Washington, DC 20001 (e-mail: [email protected]
childrensdefense.org).
A cademic Pediatrics 2016;16:S6-S7
SARAH IS 3 years old. She and her 6-year-old brother,
Bryce, are inseparable except when it’s time for him to visit
the summer food program that provides meals at a school
near their Ohio home for children who otherwise would
go hungry. Sarah’s too young to make the trip. One morn
ing after Bryce had his fill of food for the day he made a
detour before heading home. He walked to the trash cans
and began rummaging through food others threw away.
Winnie Brewer, the Food Services Supervisor in Marion
City Schools, noticed the little boy and tapped him on
the shoulder to ask why he was sifting through the garbage.
“My little sister,” he explained. “She's hungry.” Bringing
her leftover food was the only way he knew to help.
“We run into a lot of situations where kids will come and
say they have younger siblings at home,” Brewer says.
“They always want to know if they can take something
back.” After Brewer spoke with Bryce, staff members fol
lowed him home with a care package for little Sarah. This
was a temporary solution to a huge problem Brewer
worries about every day. “Until we see that child digging
food out of a trash can, it doesn’t hit home,” Brewer
says. “When it does, you know you have to do something.”
Sarah and Bryce (not their real names) are far from
alone. Hunger is only one of the dangerous risks of growing
up poor in rich America. Despite 6 years of economic re
covery, children remain the poorest group in America
and the younger they are the poorer they are. The United
States has the second highest child poverty rate among
35 industrialized countries despite having the largest econ
omy in the world. More than 1 in 5 children in America
(21.1%) were living in poverty in 2014, compared with
13.5% of people ages 18 to 64 years and 10% of those
aged 65 years and older. Nearly 1 in 4 children younger
than the age of 5 years (23.8%) are poor during some of
the years of greatest brain development. Seventy percent
of the 15.5 million poor children in America were children
of color— who already constitute most of our nation’s
youngest children and will be the majority of all the chil
dren in our nation by 2020.
Poverty hurts children, creates opportunity gaps that can
last a lifetime, and hurts the nation’s economy. The toxic
stress of early poverty stunts children’s emotional and
physical development and increases the likelihood of
poor academic achievement and dropping out of high
school, which then increases the likelihood of unemploy
ment, economic hardship, and involvement in the criminal
justice system as an adult. These effects ...
4.1 EXPLORING INCENTIVE PAY4-1 Explore the incentive pay a.docxlorainedeserre
4.1 EXPLORING INCENTIVE PAY
4-1 Explore the incentive pay approach.
Incentive pay
(http://content.thuzelearning.com/books/Martocchio.7916.16.1/sections/bm01#bm01goss212) or
variable pay
(http://content.thuzelearning.com/books/Martocchio.7916.16.1/sections/bm01#bm01goss462)
rewards employees for partially or completely attaining a predetermined work objective.
Incentive or variable pay is defined as compensation, other than base wages or salaries that
fluctuate according to employees’ attainment of some standard, such as a preestablished
formula, individual or group goals, or company earnings.
Effective incentive pay systems are based on three assumptions:
Individual employees and work teams differ in how much they contribute to the
company, both in what they do as well as in how well they do it.
The company’s overall performance depends to a large degree on the performance of
individuals and groups within the company.
To attract, retain, and motivate high performers and to be fair to all employees, a
company needs to reward employees on the basis of their relative performance.
Much like seniority and merit pay approaches, incentive pay augments employees’ base pay,
but incentive pay appears as a one-time payment. Employees usually receive a combination
of recurring base pay and incentive pay, with base pay representing the greater portion of
core compensation. More employees are presently eligible for incentive pay than ever before,
as companies seek to control costs and motivate personnel continually to strive for exemplary
performance. Companies increasingly recognize the importance of applying incentive pay
programs to various kinds of employees as well, including production workers, technical
employees, and service workers.
Some companies use incentive pay extensively. Lincoln Electric Company, a manufacturer of
welding machines and motors, is renowned for its use of incentive pay plans. At Lincoln
Electric, production employees receive recurring base pay as well as incentive pay. The
company determines incentive pay awards according to five performance criteria: quality,
output, dependability, cooperation, and ideas. The company has awarded incentive payments
every year since 1934, through prosperous and poor economic times. In 2014, the average
profit sharing payment per employee was $33,984.
Coupled with average base
pay, total core compensation for Lincoln employees was $82,903. Over the past 10 years,
Lincoln’s profit-sharing payments averaged approximately 40 percent of annual salary.
1
(http://content.thuzelearning.com/books/Martocchio.7916.16.1/sections/ch04lev1sec11#ch04end1)
2
(http://content.thuzelearning.com/books/Martocchio.7916.16.1/sections/ch04lev1sec11#ch04end2)
3
(http://content.thuzelearning.com/books/Martocchio.7916.16.1/sections/ch04lev1sec11#ch04end3)
4
(http://content.thuzelearning.com/books/Martocchio.7916.16.1/sections/ch04lev1sec11#ch04end4)
4.1 Exploring Incentive Pay
4/15/20, 8:49 PM
Page 1 ...
38 u December 2017 January 2018The authorities beli.docxlorainedeserre
38 u December 2017 / January 2018
T
he authorities believe he slipped across the United States-Mexico
border sometime during the summer of 2016, likely deep in the
night. He carried no papers. The crossing happened in the rugged
backcountry of southeastern Arizona, where the main deterrent to
trespassers is the challenging nature of the terrain—not the metal
walls, checkpoints, and aerial surveillance that dominate much of the border.
But the border crosser was des-
ert-hardy and something of an expert
at camouflage. No one knows for cer-
tain how long he’d been in the United
States before a motion-activated cam-
era caught him walking a trail in the
Dos Cabezas Mountains on the night
of November 16. When a government
agency retrieved the photo in late Feb-
ruary, the image was plastered across
Arizona newspapers, causing an imme-
diate sensation.
The border crosser was a jaguar.
Jaguars once roamed throughout
the southwestern United States, but
are now quite rare. A core population
resides in the mountains of northern
Mexico, and occasionally an adventur-
ous jaguar will venture north of the bor-
der. When one of these elusive, graceful
cats makes an appearance stateside,
Mrill Ingram is The Progressive’s online media editor.
‘The Border Is
a Beautiful Place’
For Many, Both Sides of the
Arizona-Mexico Border Are Home
B
O
R
D
ER
A
R
TS
C
O
R
R
ID
O
R
By Mrill Ingram
Artists Ana Teresa Fernández in Agua Prieta, Mexico, and Jenea Sanchez in Douglas, Arizona, worked with dozens of community members to paint sections
of the border fence sky blue, “erasing” it as a symbolic act of resistance against increasing violence and oppression of human rights along the border.
https://apnews.com/79c83219af724016b8cfa2c505018ac4/agency-reports-rare-jaguar-sighting-mountains-arizona
The Progressive u 39
usually via a motion-triggered camera,
it may get celebrity status.
“We’ve had positive identifications
of seven cats, alive and well, in the last
twenty years in the United States,” says
Diana Hadley of the Mexico-based
Northern Jaguar Project, which works
with people in both countries to pro-
tect the big cat. One of those cats be-
came known as El Jefe, after he took
up residence in 2011 in the Santa Rita
Mountains south of Tucson, Arizona.
His presence was proof that the United
States still had enough wild habitat to
support a jaguar.
The new cat was especially excit-
ing because, based on size and shape,
observers initially thought it might
be female. “A lot of people in Arizona
would be very happy to have jaguars
from Mexico breeding in Arizona,” re-
marks Hadley.
In September 2017, the Arizo-
na-based Center for Biological Di-
versity released new video of the cat,
apparently a male, caught on a mo-
tion-triggered camera ambling through
the oak scrub forest in the Chiricahua
Mountains. He’s been named Sombra,
or Shadow, by schoolkids in Tucson.
Such things will no longer ...
3Prototypes of Ethical ProblemsObjectivesThe reader shou.docxlorainedeserre
This document outlines key concepts related to recognizing and analyzing ethical problems. It discusses how to distinguish ethical questions from clinical or legal ones, and introduces the common features of ethical problems - a moral agent, a course of action, and an outcome. It uses the story of a veteran, Bill, missing therapy appointments as an example, with his therapist Kate feeling uncertain about what to do.
4-5 Annotations and Writing Plan - Thu Jan 30 2111Claire Knaus.docxlorainedeserre
4-5 Annotations and Writing Plan - Thu Jan 30 21:11
Claire Knaus
Annotations:
Bekalu, M. A., McCloud, R. F., & Viswanath, K. (2019). Association of Social Media Use With Social Well-Being, Positive Mental Health, and Self-Rated Health: Disentangling Routine Use From Emotional Connection to Use. Health Education & Behavior, 46(2_suppl), 69S-80S. https://doi.org/10.1177/1090198119863768
It seems that this source is arguing the effect of social media on mental health. This source uses this evidence to support the argument: Provided studies focusing on why individuals use social media, types of social network platforms, and the value of social capital. A counterargument for this source is: Studies that focus more on statistical usage rather than emotion connection. Personally, I believe the source is doing a good job of supporting its arguments because it provides an abundance of study references and clearly portrays the information and intent. I think this source will be very helpful in supporting my argument because of the focus on emotional connection to social media and its effects on mental health.
Matsakis, L. (2019). How Pro-Eating Disorder Posts Evade Filters on Social Media. In Gale Opposing Viewpoints Online Collection. Farmington Hills, MI: Gale. (Reprinted from How Pro-Eating Disorder Posts Evade Filters on Social Media, Wired, 2018, June 13) Retrieved from https://link-gale-com.ezproxy.snhu.edu/apps/doc/UAZKKH366290962/OVIC?u=nhc_main&sid=OVIC&xid=2c90b7b5
It seems that this source is arguing that social media platforms are not doing enough to eliminate harmful pro-ED posts. This source uses this evidence to support the argument: Information about specific platforms and what they have done to moderate content, links for more information, and what constitutes as harmful content. A counterargument for this source is that it is too difficult for platforms to remove the content and to even find it. In addition, it is believed there may be harmful effects on vulnerable people posting this type of content. Personally, I believe the source is doing a good job of supporting its arguments because it provides opposing viewpoints as well as raising awareness of some of the dangers of social media posts. I think this source will be very helpful in supporting my argument because it provides information on specifically what is being done to moderate this type of content on social media, and what some of the difficulties in moderating are.
Investigators at University of Leeds Describe Findings in Eating Disorders (Pro-ana versus Pro-recovery: A Content Analytic Comparison of Social Media Users' Communication about Eating Disorders on Twitter and Tumblr). (2017, September 4). Mental Health Weekly Digest, 38. Retrieved from https://link-gale-com.ezproxy.snhu.edu/apps/doc/A502914419/OVIC?u=nhc_main&sid=OVIC&xid=5e60152f
It seems that this source is arguing that there are more positive, anti-anorexia posts on social media than harmful, pro-ED content. ...
3Moral Identity Codes of Ethics and Institutional Ethics .docxlorainedeserre
This document discusses codes of ethics and institutional ethics structures in healthcare organizations. It begins by outlining the key learning objectives which focus on understanding the importance of codes of ethics and how they reflect an organization's values. It then discusses the role of codes of ethics in shaping an organization's moral identity and standards of conduct. The document provides examples of codes from the American Medical Association and Trinity Health. It emphasizes that codes of ethics should apply to all healthcare workers and cover areas like cultural competence, privacy, and nondiscrimination. Institutional ethics committees and review boards also help address ethical issues.
3NIMH Opinion or FactThe National Institute of Mental Healt.docxlorainedeserre
3
NIMH: Opinion or Fact
The National Institute of Mental Health (NIMH) was formed in 1946 and is one of 27 institutes that form the National Institute of Health (NIH) (NIMH, 2019). The mission of the NIMH is “To transform the understanding and treatment of mental illnesses through basic and clinical research, paving the way for prevention, recovery, and cure.” (NIMH, 2019). There are many different mental illnesses discussed on the NIMH website to include Attention-Deficit/Hyperactivity Disorder (ADHD). The NIMH website about ADHD is effective at providing the public general information and meets the criteria of authority, objectivity, and currency.
The NIMH website about ADHD provides an overview of ADHD, discusses signs and symptoms, and risk factors. The NIMH continues with information about treatment and therapies. Information provided by the NIMH is intended for both children and adults. The NIMH concludes on the page with studies the public can join and more resources for the public such as booklets, brochures, research and clinical trials.
As described by Jim Kapoun authority can be identified by who or what institution/organization published the document and if the information in the document is cited correctly (Cornell, 2020). The information on the website is published by the NIMH which is the lead research institute related to mental health for the last 70 plus years (NIMH, 2019). On the page related to ADHD the NIMH references the program of Children and Adults with Attention-Deficit/Hyperactivity Disorder (CHADD) and provides a hyperlink to access the resources available with the agency (NIMH,2019). This link can be found under the support groups section in the treatment and therapies. On the website to the right of the area describing inattention the NIMH has a section on research. In this block there is a link to “PubMed: Journal Articles about Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder (ADHD)” which will take you to a search of the National Center for Biotechnology Information (NCBI) published by PubMed on ADHD (NIMH, 2019). Throughout the entire page the NIMH provides sources and hyperlinks to the sources as citations. Based on the reputation of the NIMH and the citations to the source material the website meets the criteria of authority.
According to Kapoun objectivity can be identified looking for areas where the author expresses his or her opinion (Cornell, 2020). Information provided on the NIMH page about ADHD does not express the opinion of the author. The author produces only factual information based on research. The NIMH makes it a point not to mention the names of medications when discussing treatments and only explains the medications fall in two categories stimulants and non-stimulants (NIMH, 2019). In this same area the NIMH provides hyperlinks to the NIMH Mental Health Medication and FDA website for information about medication. The extent at which the NIMH goes to not provide an opinion on the website meet ...
More Related Content
Similar to 38 I AUTOMATING INEQ!!AUTY during times of economic crisis.docx
The document summarizes China's one-child policy, which was introduced in 1979 to reduce China's population growth. It discusses how the policy was enforced through a bureaucracy that monitored families and imposed fines or forced abortions/sterilizations for extra children. It also notes issues that arose, such as families hiding undocumented children or skirting the rules in other ways. Some children of parents who broke the rules were allegedly taken and sold to orphanages for international adoption, victimizing vulnerable families. In general, the policy was intended to control population but its stringent enforcement sometimes caused human rights issues.
A Modest Proposal Summary
Health Care Proposal Essay
Outline: a Modest Proposal Essay
Proposal Argument Essay
Project Proposal Essay
A Modest Proposal Thesis
Sports Program Proposal
Proposal Argument Essay
The one child policy was introduced in China in 1979 to control the country's large population growth. It limited urban families to only one child and rural families to two if the first was a girl. This led to forced abortions and sterilizations to meet quotas. It also caused societal issues like a gender imbalance. The policy was relaxed in the late 1990s and early 2000s, banning forced procedures and allowing two children in some areas. However, it was not fully abolished until 2015 due to concerns over caring for the aging population and workforce shortages.
The one child policy was introduced in China in 1979 to control the country's large population growth. It restricted urban families to only one child and rural families to two if the first was a girl. This led to forced abortions and sterilizations to meet quotas. It also caused societal issues like a gender imbalance. While it achieved population control, it was also criticized for infringing on personal freedoms. Recent changes allow two children per family and ban forced birth control measures.
Dr. Grace was privileged to offer this presentation to a panel at the Unicef located at UN headquarters concerning the ministry of the Kenya Heritage Foundation.
This document provides a summary and reflection of the documentary "Sicko" by Michael Moore. It discusses several key issues highlighted in the film, including the high costs of healthcare and medications for seniors in the US, the fully public healthcare system in countries like the UK, and how volunteers who helped with 9/11 recovery efforts struggled to get healthcare coverage afterwards. It also examines issues of healthcare access and costs in other countries like Canada and contrasts their systems to the problems in the US system focused on profits over patient care.
China introduced its one child policy in 1979 to alleviate social and economic problems caused by rapid population growth. The policy limited urban families to one child and rural families to two if the first was a girl. It has prevented over 250 million births but caused gender imbalance as families aborted female fetuses. As fewer young people now support an aging population, China will face soaring healthcare costs and worker shortages in coming decades.
An overview of poverty levels within ethnic communities in the US. Governmental attempts at a baseline. Five types of capital formation within a capitalist infrastructure as pathways out. This is the basis of the video at https://vimeo.com/vivgrigg/uspoverty
Thrilled to announce I've been awarded Fist Place in Roger William University's 2017 Advanced Writing Contest for my policy report “Children & Lunch-Shaming: America’s Neglected Stain."
Lunch-Shaming in America is not often talked about or understood, but has become an increasing problem for the esteem and development of America's children. Children are being wrongfully stigmatized for their family's finances by being denied the same lunch as their peers, receiving a stamp saying "Need Lunch Money", or being forced to perform chores for their lunch.
School lunch companies and school administrations should not be able to stigmatize 2nd, 3rd, 4th graders for something their parents need to deal with.
If any of this makes you sad/angry/annoyed, please feel free to read my report, Children & Lunch Shaming: America's Neglected Stain, and let me know your thoughts!
Pittsburgh Nonprofit Summit - Zero Poverty by 2020 WorkshopGPNP
The time is right for a nonprofit mission to eradicate poverty in the U.S. Escalating poverty is a concern for all and impacts nonprofits serving all purposes, from arts to environment to human services. What are the root causes and what can be done? The UK has committed to zero poverty by 2020. What are they doing to get there and how can we adopt this goal in Southwestern PA? Examine the bold policies set in the U.K. to eradicate poverty by 2020 and learn about other local initiatives that are helping to build the movement.
Documented immigrants need some form of immigration status and means to support themselves financially through jobs and income in order to afford housing in the United States; while documented immigrants can be eligible for public housing, there are usually long wait times of 5 years or more to receive housing. Obtaining a higher paying job allows documented immigrants to afford owning a home or renting an apartment.
Chapter 5The Mediaand ClaimsMedia and the Claims.docxrobertad6
Chapter 5
The Media
and Claims
Media and the Claimsmaking Process
Slide 1
Many claimsmakers seek media attention.
How can they get it?
Why might it be difficult to get?
Media and the Claimsmaking Process
Slide 2
Media coverage plays an important role in
how social problems are constructed.
Activists, experts, and other claimsmakers
hope that the media will bring their claims to
wider audiences and policymakers.
However, media coverage usually alters the
original claim.
Media and the Claimsmaking Process
Slide 3
There are constraints on media workers.
Deadlines
Space and time limits (the “newshole”)
Audience desires entertainment
As a result, primary claims are transformed
into secondary claims by the media.
Media and the Claimsmaking Process
Slide 4
Claimsmakers compete for media attention.
Claimsmakers try to present their claims as
new, fresh material for the media.
The marketplace for social problems can be
thought of as multiple arenas, each with a
limited carrying capacity.
Media workers decide what claims are
presented in the arena they manage.
Media and the Claimsmaking Process
Slide 5
News work locates and presents the news.
News work is constrained by economic
factors, deadlines, and cultural limitations
(such as professionalism).
News work seeks claims with an
entertainment value (“brand-new” stories,
easily filmed events, or claims that have
compelling typifying stories).
Media and the Claimsmaking Process
Slide 6
News work follows professional standards.
News workers may feel obligated to balance
coverage by reporting views from “both sides”
News workers pay attention to rivals and the
stories they decide to cover.
News workers try to avoid being manipulated
by claimsmakers seeking media coverage.
Media and the Claimsmaking Process
Slide 7
Geography influences what claims are heard.
News workers are concentrated in large cities.
Even claimsmakers who begin in distant
places tend to migrate to larger media centers.
Ultimately, the news is a social construction
produced by news workers.
Media and the Claimsmaking Process
Slide 8
How do claimsmakers get media attention?
Package claims in ways that help news
workers and parallel their constraints
Give the media advanced notice of events
Choose interesting individuals to represent
their cause (such as celebrity ambassadors)
Make events visually interesting for TV
Seek media that target the intended audience
Changes in the Media
Slide 1
Cable channels, especially 24-hour cable news
networks, which must fill the newshole on a daily
basis, have increased in number.
Much of the media now target particular
audiences (audience segmentation).
Changes in the Media
Slide 2
The Internet has an unlimited carrying
capacity for claims.
Claimsmakers can establish an online
presence at a minimal cost.
T.
Chapter 5The Mediaand ClaimsMedia and the Claims.docxketurahhazelhurst
Chapter 5
The Media
and Claims
Media and the Claimsmaking Process
Slide 1
Many claimsmakers seek media attention.
How can they get it?
Why might it be difficult to get?
Media and the Claimsmaking Process
Slide 2
Media coverage plays an important role in
how social problems are constructed.
Activists, experts, and other claimsmakers
hope that the media will bring their claims to
wider audiences and policymakers.
However, media coverage usually alters the
original claim.
Media and the Claimsmaking Process
Slide 3
There are constraints on media workers.
Deadlines
Space and time limits (the “newshole”)
Audience desires entertainment
As a result, primary claims are transformed
into secondary claims by the media.
Media and the Claimsmaking Process
Slide 4
Claimsmakers compete for media attention.
Claimsmakers try to present their claims as
new, fresh material for the media.
The marketplace for social problems can be
thought of as multiple arenas, each with a
limited carrying capacity.
Media workers decide what claims are
presented in the arena they manage.
Media and the Claimsmaking Process
Slide 5
News work locates and presents the news.
News work is constrained by economic
factors, deadlines, and cultural limitations
(such as professionalism).
News work seeks claims with an
entertainment value (“brand-new” stories,
easily filmed events, or claims that have
compelling typifying stories).
Media and the Claimsmaking Process
Slide 6
News work follows professional standards.
News workers may feel obligated to balance
coverage by reporting views from “both sides”
News workers pay attention to rivals and the
stories they decide to cover.
News workers try to avoid being manipulated
by claimsmakers seeking media coverage.
Media and the Claimsmaking Process
Slide 7
Geography influences what claims are heard.
News workers are concentrated in large cities.
Even claimsmakers who begin in distant
places tend to migrate to larger media centers.
Ultimately, the news is a social construction
produced by news workers.
Media and the Claimsmaking Process
Slide 8
How do claimsmakers get media attention?
Package claims in ways that help news
workers and parallel their constraints
Give the media advanced notice of events
Choose interesting individuals to represent
their cause (such as celebrity ambassadors)
Make events visually interesting for TV
Seek media that target the intended audience
Changes in the Media
Slide 1
Cable channels, especially 24-hour cable news
networks, which must fill the newshole on a daily
basis, have increased in number.
Much of the media now target particular
audiences (audience segmentation).
Changes in the Media
Slide 2
The Internet has an unlimited carrying
capacity for claims.
Claimsmakers can establish an online
presence at a minimal cost.
T ...
The document summarizes the 2015 Bateman Campaign conducted by Michigan State University students to raise awareness of the Home Matters movement in the Greater Lansing area. It includes an executive summary, situation analysis discussing homelessness statistics, secondary research findings from surveys and interviews, objectives to increase awareness and engagement with the campaign, strategies and tactics used such as social media and on-campus events, and outcomes such as exceeding goals for exposure and participation. The campaign was successful in educating students and the community about Home Matters and inspiring over 100 individuals to join the movement.
C ommentariesEnding Childhood Poverty in America 0c—Mari.docxjasoninnes20
C ommentaries
Ending Childhood Poverty in America 0c—
Marian Wright Edelman
From the Children’s Defense Fund, Washington, DC
The author reports no conflicts of interest.
Address correspondence to Marian Wright Edelman, Children’s Defense Fund, 25 E St NW, Washington, DC 20001 (e-mail: [email protected]
childrensdefense.org).
A cademic Pediatrics 2016;16:S6-S7
SARAH IS 3 years old. She and her 6-year-old brother,
Bryce, are inseparable except when it’s time for him to visit
the summer food program that provides meals at a school
near their Ohio home for children who otherwise would
go hungry. Sarah’s too young to make the trip. One morn
ing after Bryce had his fill of food for the day he made a
detour before heading home. He walked to the trash cans
and began rummaging through food others threw away.
Winnie Brewer, the Food Services Supervisor in Marion
City Schools, noticed the little boy and tapped him on
the shoulder to ask why he was sifting through the garbage.
“My little sister,” he explained. “She's hungry.” Bringing
her leftover food was the only way he knew to help.
“We run into a lot of situations where kids will come and
say they have younger siblings at home,” Brewer says.
“They always want to know if they can take something
back.” After Brewer spoke with Bryce, staff members fol
lowed him home with a care package for little Sarah. This
was a temporary solution to a huge problem Brewer
worries about every day. “Until we see that child digging
food out of a trash can, it doesn’t hit home,” Brewer
says. “When it does, you know you have to do something.”
Sarah and Bryce (not their real names) are far from
alone. Hunger is only one of the dangerous risks of growing
up poor in rich America. Despite 6 years of economic re
covery, children remain the poorest group in America
and the younger they are the poorer they are. The United
States has the second highest child poverty rate among
35 industrialized countries despite having the largest econ
omy in the world. More than 1 in 5 children in America
(21.1%) were living in poverty in 2014, compared with
13.5% of people ages 18 to 64 years and 10% of those
aged 65 years and older. Nearly 1 in 4 children younger
than the age of 5 years (23.8%) are poor during some of
the years of greatest brain development. Seventy percent
of the 15.5 million poor children in America were children
of color— who already constitute most of our nation’s
youngest children and will be the majority of all the chil
dren in our nation by 2020.
Poverty hurts children, creates opportunity gaps that can
last a lifetime, and hurts the nation’s economy. The toxic
stress of early poverty stunts children’s emotional and
physical development and increases the likelihood of
poor academic achievement and dropping out of high
school, which then increases the likelihood of unemploy
ment, economic hardship, and involvement in the criminal
justice system as an adult. These effects ...
Similar to 38 I AUTOMATING INEQ!!AUTY during times of economic crisis.docx (15)
4.1 EXPLORING INCENTIVE PAY4-1 Explore the incentive pay a.docxlorainedeserre
4.1 EXPLORING INCENTIVE PAY
4-1 Explore the incentive pay approach.
Incentive pay
(http://content.thuzelearning.com/books/Martocchio.7916.16.1/sections/bm01#bm01goss212) or
variable pay
(http://content.thuzelearning.com/books/Martocchio.7916.16.1/sections/bm01#bm01goss462)
rewards employees for partially or completely attaining a predetermined work objective.
Incentive or variable pay is defined as compensation, other than base wages or salaries that
fluctuate according to employees’ attainment of some standard, such as a preestablished
formula, individual or group goals, or company earnings.
Effective incentive pay systems are based on three assumptions:
Individual employees and work teams differ in how much they contribute to the
company, both in what they do as well as in how well they do it.
The company’s overall performance depends to a large degree on the performance of
individuals and groups within the company.
To attract, retain, and motivate high performers and to be fair to all employees, a
company needs to reward employees on the basis of their relative performance.
Much like seniority and merit pay approaches, incentive pay augments employees’ base pay,
but incentive pay appears as a one-time payment. Employees usually receive a combination
of recurring base pay and incentive pay, with base pay representing the greater portion of
core compensation. More employees are presently eligible for incentive pay than ever before,
as companies seek to control costs and motivate personnel continually to strive for exemplary
performance. Companies increasingly recognize the importance of applying incentive pay
programs to various kinds of employees as well, including production workers, technical
employees, and service workers.
Some companies use incentive pay extensively. Lincoln Electric Company, a manufacturer of
welding machines and motors, is renowned for its use of incentive pay plans. At Lincoln
Electric, production employees receive recurring base pay as well as incentive pay. The
company determines incentive pay awards according to five performance criteria: quality,
output, dependability, cooperation, and ideas. The company has awarded incentive payments
every year since 1934, through prosperous and poor economic times. In 2014, the average
profit sharing payment per employee was $33,984.
Coupled with average base
pay, total core compensation for Lincoln employees was $82,903. Over the past 10 years,
Lincoln’s profit-sharing payments averaged approximately 40 percent of annual salary.
1
(http://content.thuzelearning.com/books/Martocchio.7916.16.1/sections/ch04lev1sec11#ch04end1)
2
(http://content.thuzelearning.com/books/Martocchio.7916.16.1/sections/ch04lev1sec11#ch04end2)
3
(http://content.thuzelearning.com/books/Martocchio.7916.16.1/sections/ch04lev1sec11#ch04end3)
4
(http://content.thuzelearning.com/books/Martocchio.7916.16.1/sections/ch04lev1sec11#ch04end4)
4.1 Exploring Incentive Pay
4/15/20, 8:49 PM
Page 1 ...
38 u December 2017 January 2018The authorities beli.docxlorainedeserre
38 u December 2017 / January 2018
T
he authorities believe he slipped across the United States-Mexico
border sometime during the summer of 2016, likely deep in the
night. He carried no papers. The crossing happened in the rugged
backcountry of southeastern Arizona, where the main deterrent to
trespassers is the challenging nature of the terrain—not the metal
walls, checkpoints, and aerial surveillance that dominate much of the border.
But the border crosser was des-
ert-hardy and something of an expert
at camouflage. No one knows for cer-
tain how long he’d been in the United
States before a motion-activated cam-
era caught him walking a trail in the
Dos Cabezas Mountains on the night
of November 16. When a government
agency retrieved the photo in late Feb-
ruary, the image was plastered across
Arizona newspapers, causing an imme-
diate sensation.
The border crosser was a jaguar.
Jaguars once roamed throughout
the southwestern United States, but
are now quite rare. A core population
resides in the mountains of northern
Mexico, and occasionally an adventur-
ous jaguar will venture north of the bor-
der. When one of these elusive, graceful
cats makes an appearance stateside,
Mrill Ingram is The Progressive’s online media editor.
‘The Border Is
a Beautiful Place’
For Many, Both Sides of the
Arizona-Mexico Border Are Home
B
O
R
D
ER
A
R
TS
C
O
R
R
ID
O
R
By Mrill Ingram
Artists Ana Teresa Fernández in Agua Prieta, Mexico, and Jenea Sanchez in Douglas, Arizona, worked with dozens of community members to paint sections
of the border fence sky blue, “erasing” it as a symbolic act of resistance against increasing violence and oppression of human rights along the border.
https://apnews.com/79c83219af724016b8cfa2c505018ac4/agency-reports-rare-jaguar-sighting-mountains-arizona
The Progressive u 39
usually via a motion-triggered camera,
it may get celebrity status.
“We’ve had positive identifications
of seven cats, alive and well, in the last
twenty years in the United States,” says
Diana Hadley of the Mexico-based
Northern Jaguar Project, which works
with people in both countries to pro-
tect the big cat. One of those cats be-
came known as El Jefe, after he took
up residence in 2011 in the Santa Rita
Mountains south of Tucson, Arizona.
His presence was proof that the United
States still had enough wild habitat to
support a jaguar.
The new cat was especially excit-
ing because, based on size and shape,
observers initially thought it might
be female. “A lot of people in Arizona
would be very happy to have jaguars
from Mexico breeding in Arizona,” re-
marks Hadley.
In September 2017, the Arizo-
na-based Center for Biological Di-
versity released new video of the cat,
apparently a male, caught on a mo-
tion-triggered camera ambling through
the oak scrub forest in the Chiricahua
Mountains. He’s been named Sombra,
or Shadow, by schoolkids in Tucson.
Such things will no longer ...
3Prototypes of Ethical ProblemsObjectivesThe reader shou.docxlorainedeserre
This document outlines key concepts related to recognizing and analyzing ethical problems. It discusses how to distinguish ethical questions from clinical or legal ones, and introduces the common features of ethical problems - a moral agent, a course of action, and an outcome. It uses the story of a veteran, Bill, missing therapy appointments as an example, with his therapist Kate feeling uncertain about what to do.
4-5 Annotations and Writing Plan - Thu Jan 30 2111Claire Knaus.docxlorainedeserre
4-5 Annotations and Writing Plan - Thu Jan 30 21:11
Claire Knaus
Annotations:
Bekalu, M. A., McCloud, R. F., & Viswanath, K. (2019). Association of Social Media Use With Social Well-Being, Positive Mental Health, and Self-Rated Health: Disentangling Routine Use From Emotional Connection to Use. Health Education & Behavior, 46(2_suppl), 69S-80S. https://doi.org/10.1177/1090198119863768
It seems that this source is arguing the effect of social media on mental health. This source uses this evidence to support the argument: Provided studies focusing on why individuals use social media, types of social network platforms, and the value of social capital. A counterargument for this source is: Studies that focus more on statistical usage rather than emotion connection. Personally, I believe the source is doing a good job of supporting its arguments because it provides an abundance of study references and clearly portrays the information and intent. I think this source will be very helpful in supporting my argument because of the focus on emotional connection to social media and its effects on mental health.
Matsakis, L. (2019). How Pro-Eating Disorder Posts Evade Filters on Social Media. In Gale Opposing Viewpoints Online Collection. Farmington Hills, MI: Gale. (Reprinted from How Pro-Eating Disorder Posts Evade Filters on Social Media, Wired, 2018, June 13) Retrieved from https://link-gale-com.ezproxy.snhu.edu/apps/doc/UAZKKH366290962/OVIC?u=nhc_main&sid=OVIC&xid=2c90b7b5
It seems that this source is arguing that social media platforms are not doing enough to eliminate harmful pro-ED posts. This source uses this evidence to support the argument: Information about specific platforms and what they have done to moderate content, links for more information, and what constitutes as harmful content. A counterargument for this source is that it is too difficult for platforms to remove the content and to even find it. In addition, it is believed there may be harmful effects on vulnerable people posting this type of content. Personally, I believe the source is doing a good job of supporting its arguments because it provides opposing viewpoints as well as raising awareness of some of the dangers of social media posts. I think this source will be very helpful in supporting my argument because it provides information on specifically what is being done to moderate this type of content on social media, and what some of the difficulties in moderating are.
Investigators at University of Leeds Describe Findings in Eating Disorders (Pro-ana versus Pro-recovery: A Content Analytic Comparison of Social Media Users' Communication about Eating Disorders on Twitter and Tumblr). (2017, September 4). Mental Health Weekly Digest, 38. Retrieved from https://link-gale-com.ezproxy.snhu.edu/apps/doc/A502914419/OVIC?u=nhc_main&sid=OVIC&xid=5e60152f
It seems that this source is arguing that there are more positive, anti-anorexia posts on social media than harmful, pro-ED content. ...
3Moral Identity Codes of Ethics and Institutional Ethics .docxlorainedeserre
This document discusses codes of ethics and institutional ethics structures in healthcare organizations. It begins by outlining the key learning objectives which focus on understanding the importance of codes of ethics and how they reflect an organization's values. It then discusses the role of codes of ethics in shaping an organization's moral identity and standards of conduct. The document provides examples of codes from the American Medical Association and Trinity Health. It emphasizes that codes of ethics should apply to all healthcare workers and cover areas like cultural competence, privacy, and nondiscrimination. Institutional ethics committees and review boards also help address ethical issues.
3NIMH Opinion or FactThe National Institute of Mental Healt.docxlorainedeserre
3
NIMH: Opinion or Fact
The National Institute of Mental Health (NIMH) was formed in 1946 and is one of 27 institutes that form the National Institute of Health (NIH) (NIMH, 2019). The mission of the NIMH is “To transform the understanding and treatment of mental illnesses through basic and clinical research, paving the way for prevention, recovery, and cure.” (NIMH, 2019). There are many different mental illnesses discussed on the NIMH website to include Attention-Deficit/Hyperactivity Disorder (ADHD). The NIMH website about ADHD is effective at providing the public general information and meets the criteria of authority, objectivity, and currency.
The NIMH website about ADHD provides an overview of ADHD, discusses signs and symptoms, and risk factors. The NIMH continues with information about treatment and therapies. Information provided by the NIMH is intended for both children and adults. The NIMH concludes on the page with studies the public can join and more resources for the public such as booklets, brochures, research and clinical trials.
As described by Jim Kapoun authority can be identified by who or what institution/organization published the document and if the information in the document is cited correctly (Cornell, 2020). The information on the website is published by the NIMH which is the lead research institute related to mental health for the last 70 plus years (NIMH, 2019). On the page related to ADHD the NIMH references the program of Children and Adults with Attention-Deficit/Hyperactivity Disorder (CHADD) and provides a hyperlink to access the resources available with the agency (NIMH,2019). This link can be found under the support groups section in the treatment and therapies. On the website to the right of the area describing inattention the NIMH has a section on research. In this block there is a link to “PubMed: Journal Articles about Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder (ADHD)” which will take you to a search of the National Center for Biotechnology Information (NCBI) published by PubMed on ADHD (NIMH, 2019). Throughout the entire page the NIMH provides sources and hyperlinks to the sources as citations. Based on the reputation of the NIMH and the citations to the source material the website meets the criteria of authority.
According to Kapoun objectivity can be identified looking for areas where the author expresses his or her opinion (Cornell, 2020). Information provided on the NIMH page about ADHD does not express the opinion of the author. The author produces only factual information based on research. The NIMH makes it a point not to mention the names of medications when discussing treatments and only explains the medications fall in two categories stimulants and non-stimulants (NIMH, 2019). In this same area the NIMH provides hyperlinks to the NIMH Mental Health Medication and FDA website for information about medication. The extent at which the NIMH goes to not provide an opinion on the website meet ...
4.1
Updated April-09
Lecture Notes
Chapter 4
Enterprise Excellence
Implementation
ENTERPRISE EXCELLENCE
4.2
Updated April-09
Learning Objectives
• Management & Operations Plans
• Enterprise Excellence Projects
• Enterprise Excellence Project decision Process
• Planning the Enterprise Excellence Project
• Tollgate Reviews
• Project Notebook
4.3
Updated April-09
MANAGEMENT AND OPERATIONS PLANS
• The scope and complexity of the
implementation projects will vary from the
executive level, to the management level, to
the operational level
• Each plan, as it is developed and deployed,
will include projects to be accomplished
• Conflicts typically will occur amongst
requirements of quality, cost, and schedule
when executing a project
4.4
Updated April-09
ENTERPRISE EXCELLENCE PROJECTS
• An Enterprise Excellence project will be one of three
types:
1. Technology invention or innovation
2. New product, service, or process development
3. Product, service, or process improvement
• Enterprise Excellence uses the scientific method
• The scientific method is a process of organizing
empirical facts and their interrelationships in a
manner that allows a hypothesis to be developed and
tested
4.5
Updated April-09
ENTERPRISE EXCELLENCE PROJECTS
• The scientific method consists of the
following steps:
1. Observe and describe the situation
2. Formulate a hypothesis
3. Use the hypothesis to predict results
4. Perform controlled tests to confirm the hypothesis
4.6
Updated April-09
ENTERPRISE EXCELLENCE PROJECTS
• Figure 4.1 shows the project decision process
4.7
Updated April-09
ENTERPRISE EXCELLENCE PROJECT
DECISION PROCESS
• Inventing/Innovating Technology:
Technology development is accomplished using
system engineering
This system approach enables critical functional
parameters and responses to be quickly transferred
into now products, services, and processes
The process is a four-phase process (I2DOV):
Invention & Innovation – Develop – Optimize – Verify
4.8
Updated April-09
ENTERPRISE EXCELLENCE PROJECT
DECISION PROCESS
• Development of Products, Services, and
Processes
The Enterprise Excellence approach for developing
products, services, and processes is the Design for
Lean Six Sigma strategy.
This strategy helps to incorporate customer
requirements and expectations into the product
and/or service.
Concept – Design – Optimize - Verify (CDOV) is a
specific sequential design & development process
used to execute the design strategy.
4.9
Updated April-09
ENTERPRISE EXCELLENCE PROJECT
DECISION PROCESS
• Improving Products, Services, and Processes:
Improving products, services and processes usually
involves the effectiveness and efficiency of operations.
A product or service is said to be effective when it meets
all of its customer requirements.
Effectiveness can be simply expressed as "doing the
right things the first time ...
3Type your name hereType your three-letter and -number cours.docxlorainedeserre
3
Type your name here
Type your three-letter and -number course code here
The date goes here
Type instructor’s name here
Your Title Goes Here
This is an electronic template for papers written in GCU style. The purpose of the template is to help you follow the basic writing expectations for beginning your coursework at GCU. Margins are set at 1 inch for top, bottom, left, and right. The first line of each paragraph is indented a half inch (0.5"). The line spacing is double throughout the paper, even on the reference page. One space after punctuation is used at the end of a sentence. The font style used in this template is Times New Roman. The font size is 12 point. When you are ready to write, and after having read these instructions completely, you can delete these directions and start typing. The formatting should stay the same. If you have any questions, please consult with your instructor.
Citations are used to reference material from another source. When paraphrasing material from another source (such as a book, journal, website), include the author’s last name and the publication year in parentheses.When directly quoting material word-for-word from another source, use quotation marks and include the page number after the author’s last name and year.
Using citations to give credit to others whose ideas or words you have used is an essential requirement to avoid issues of plagiarism. Just as you would never steal someone else’s car, you should not steal his or her words either. To avoid potential problems, always be sure to cite your sources. Cite by referring to the author’s last name, the year of publication in parentheses at the end of the sentence, such as (George & Mallery, 2016), and page numbers if you are using word-for-word materials. For example, “The developments of the World War II years firmly established the probability sample survey as a tool for describing population characteristics, beliefs, and attitudes” (Heeringa, West, & Berglund, 2017, p. 3).
The reference list should appear at the end of a paper (see the next page). It provides the information necessary for a reader to locate and retrieve any source you cite in the body of the paper. Each source you cite in the paper must appear in your reference list; likewise, each entry in the reference list must be cited in your text. A sample reference page is included below; this page includes examples (George & Mallery, 2016; Heeringa et al., 2017; Smith et al., 2018; “USA swimming,” 2018; Yu, Johnson, Deutsch, & Varga, 2018) of how to format different reference types (e.g., books, journal articles, and a website). For additional examples, see the GCU Style Guide.
References
George, D., & Mallery, P. (2016). IBM SPSS statistics 23 step by step: A simple guide and reference. New York, NY: Routledge.
Heeringa, S. G., West, B. T., & Berglund, P. A. (2017). Applied survey data analysis (2nd ed.). New York, NY: Chapman & Hall/CRC Press.
Smith, P. D., Martin, B., Chewning, B., ...
3Welcome to Writing at Work! After you have completed.docxlorainedeserre
3
Welcome to Writing at Work! After you have completed the reading for the week, write an email to introduce yourself to your peers. The name of your thread should be what you would include in the subject of the email.
As you compose your email, keep in mind the following:
· You are addressing a group you will work with in a professional capacity for at least 15 weeks. Let us know something about you, but don't share anything you wouldn't want repeated.
· You should include what you perceive to be your relative strengths with regard to writing at work. What types of tasks would you feel most comfortable taking on?
· You should also include what aspects of writing at work make you feel least comfortable. What types of tasks would you not be as suited for?
· What do you hope to learn in the next several months?
Next, in an attachment, choose one of the following two prompts and write a letter, taking into account the purpose, audience, and appropriate style for the task.
1. Your organization has been contracted to complete a project for an important client, and you were charged with managing the project. It has unfortunately become clear that your team will not meet the deadline. Your supervisor has told you to contact the client in writing to alert them to the situation and wants to be cc'd on the message. Write a letter, which you will send via email, addressing the above.
2. After a year-long working relationship, your organization will no longer be making use of a freelancer's services due to no fault of their own. Write a letter alerting them to this fact.
Name:
HRT 4760 Assignment 01
Timeliness
First, you will choose one particular organization where you will conduct each of your 15 different observational assignments. Stick with this same organization throughout your coursework. (Do not switch around assignment locations at different organizations or locations.) The reason for continuing your observational assignments at the same organization is to give you a deeper understanding of this particular organization across the 15 different assignments. As you read on, you will get a more complete understanding as to how these 15 assignments come together.
Tip: Many students choose the organization where they are currently working. This works particularly well. If you are working there, you have much opportunity to gain access to the areas that will give you a more complete understanding of the quality of entire service package (the 15 different elements) that the organization offers to its customers.
This is one of a package of 15 different assignments that comprise the Elements of Service, which you will study this term. For this assignment, you will observe elements of service in almost any particular service establishment. A few examples of service establishments would include, but not be limited to these: Hotel, resort, private club, restaurant, airline, cruise line, grocery store, doctor’s office, coffee house, and scores of oth ...
3JWI 531 Finance II Assignment 1TemplateHOW TO USE THIS TEMP.docxlorainedeserre
3
JWI 531 Finance II Assignment 1Template
HOW TO USE THIS TEMPLATE:
This is a template and checklist corresponding to your Assignment 1 paper: Enterprise Risk Management and Moat Strength. See below for an explanation of the color-coding in this template:
· All green text includes instructions to support your writing. You should delete all green text before submitting your final paper.
· All blue text indicates areas where you need to replace text with your own information. Replace the blue text with your own words in black.
· Headings and subheadings are written in black, bold type. Keep these in your paper.
TIPS:
· Write in the third person, using “he” or “she” or “they”, or using specific names. Do not use the second person “you”.
· The body of this paper has one-inch margins and uses a professional font (size 10-12); we recommend Arial or Times New Roman fonts.
· The Assignment template is already formatted with all needed specifications like margins, appropriate font, and double spacing.
· Before submitting your paper, use Grammarly to check for punctuation and usage errors and make the required corrections. Then read aloud to edit for tone and flow.
· You should also run your paper through SafeAssign to ensure that it meets the required standards for originality.
FINALIZING YOUR PAPER
Your submission should be a maximum of 4 pages in length. The page count doesnotinclude the Cover Page at the beginning and the References page at the end. The final paper that you submit for grading should be in black text only with all remaining green text and blue text removed. Assignment 1: Enterprise Risk Analysis and Moat Strength
Author’s Name
Jack Welch Management Institute
Professor’s Name
JWI 531
Date
Introduction
An Introduction should be succinct and to the point. Start your Introduction with a general and brief observation about the paper’s topic. Write a thesis statement, which is the “road map” for your paper - it helps your reader to navigate your work. In your thesis statement, be specific about the major areas you plan to address in your paper.
The headings below should guide your introduction, since they identify the topics to be addressed in your paper. The introduction is not a graded part of your rubric but it helps your reader to understand what your assignment will be about. We recommend that you write this part of your Introduction after you complete the other sections of your paper. It only needs to be one paragraph in length.
Analysis and Recommendations
You must answer each of the following questions in your paper. Keep your responses focused on the topic. Straying off into additional areas, even if they are interesting, will not earn additional marks, and may actually detract from the clarity of your responses.
I. Where is each company in its corporate lifecycle (startup, growth, maturity or decline)? Explain.
Before writing your response to this question, make sure you understand what characterizes ea ...
3Big Data Analyst QuestionnaireWithin this document are fo.docxlorainedeserre
3
Big Data Analyst Questionnaire
Within this document are four different questions. Each question is structured in the following manner:
1) Premise
- Contains any needed background information
2) Request
- The actual question, what you are to solve
3) Notes
- A space if you feel like including notes of any kind for the given question
Please place your answer for each question in a separate file, following this naming convention:
Name_Qn.docx, where n = the question number (i.e., 1, 2 ...). So the file for the first question should be named ‘Name_Q1.docx’.
When complete, please package everything together and send email responses to the designated POCs.
Page | 1
Premise:
You have a table named “TRADES” with the following six columns:
Column Name
Data Type
Description
Date
DATE
The calendar date on which the trade took place.
Firm
VARCHAR(255)
A symbol representing the Broker/Dealer who conducted the trade.
Symbol
VARCHAR(10)
The security traded.
Side
VARCHAR(1)
Denotes whether the trade was a buy (purchase) or a sell (sale) of a security.
Quantity
BIGINT
The number of shares involved in the trade.
Price
DECIMAL(18,8)
The dollar price per share traded.
You write a query looking for all trades in the month of August 2019. The query returns the following:
DATE
FIRM
SYMBOL
SIDE
QUANTITY
PRICE
8/5/2019
ABC
123
B
200
41
8/5/2019
CDE
456
B
601
60
8/5/2019
ABC
789
S
600
70
8/5/2019
CDE
789
S
600
70
8/5/2019
FGH
456
B
200
62
8/6/2019
3CDE
456
X
300
61
8/8/2019
ABC
123
B
300
40
8/9/2019
ABC
123
S
300
30
8/9/2019
FGH
789
B
2100
71
8/10/2019
CDE
456
S
1100
63
Questions:
1) Conduct an analysis of the data set returned by your query. Write a paragraph describing your analysis. Please also note any questions or assumptions made about this data.
2) Your business user asks you to show them a table output that includes an additional column categorizing the TRADES data into volume based Tiers, with a column named ‘Tier’. Quantities between 0-250 will be considered ‘Small’, quantities greater than ‘Small’ but less than or equal to 500 will be considered ‘Medium’, quantities greater than ‘Medium’ but less than or equal to 500 will be considered ‘Large’, and quantities greater than ‘Tier 3’ will be considered ‘Very Large’ .
a. Please write the SQL query you would use to add the column to the table output.
b. Please show the exact results you expect based on your SQL query.
3) Your business user asks you to show them a table output summarizing the TRADES data (Buy and Sell) on week-by-week basis.
a. Please write the SQL query you would use to query this table.
b. Please show the exact results you expect based on your SQL query.
Notes:
1
Premise:
You need to describe in writing how to accomplish a task. Your audience has never completed this task before.
Question:
In a few paragraphs, please describe how to complete a task of your choice. You may choose a task of your own liking or one of the sample tasks below:
1) How to make a p ...
3HR StrategiesKey concepts and termsHigh commitment .docxlorainedeserre
3
HR Strategies
Key concepts and terms
High commitment management •
High performance management •
HR strategy •
High involvement management •
Horizontal fi t •
Vertical fi t •
On completing this chapter you should be able to defi ne these key concepts.
You should also understand:
Learning outcomes
T • he purpose of HR strategy
Specifi c HR strategy areas •
How HR strategy is formulated •
How the vertical integration of •
business and HR strategies is
achieved
How HR strategies can be set out •
General HR strategy areas •
The criteria for a successful HR •
strategy
The fundamental questions on •
the development of HR strategy
How horizontal fi t (bundling) is •
achieved
How HR strategies can be •
implemented
47
48 Human Resource Management
Introduction
As described in Chapter 2, strategic HRM is a mindset that leads to strategic actions and reac-
tions, either in the form of overall or specifi c HR strategies or strategic behaviour on the part
of HR professionals. This chapter focuses on HR strategies and answers the following ques-
tions: What are HR strategies? What are the main types of overall HR strategies? What are the
main areas in which specifi c HR strategies are developed? What are the criteria for an effective
HR strategy? How should HR strategies be developed? How should HR strategies be
implemented?
What are HR strategies?
HR strategies set out what the organization intends to do about its human resource manage-
ment policies and practices and how they should be integrated with the business strategy and
each other. They are described by Dyer and Reeves (1995) as ‘internally consistent bundles of
human resource practices’. Richardson and Thompson (1999) suggest that:
A strategy, whether it is an HR strategy or any other kind of management strategy must
have two key elements: there must be strategic objectives (ie things the strategy is sup-
posed to achieve), and there must be a plan of action (ie the means by which it is pro-
posed that the objectives will be met).
The purpose of HR strategies is to articulate what an organization intends to do about its
human resource management policies and practices now and in the longer term, bearing in
mind the dictum of Fombrun et al (1984) that business and managers should perform well in
the present to succeed in the future. HR strategies aim to meet both business and human needs
in the organization.
HR strategies may set out intentions and provide a sense of purpose and direction, but they are
not just long-term plans. As Gratton (2000) commented: ‘There is no great strategy, only great
execution.’
Because all organizations are different, all HR strategies are different. There is no such thing as
a standard strategy and research into HR strategy conducted by Armstrong and Long (1994)
and Armstrong and Baron (2002) revealed many variations. Some strategies are simply very
general declarations of intent. Others go into much more detail. ...
3Implementing ChangeConstruction workers on scaffolding..docxlorainedeserre
3
Implementing Change
Construction workers on scaffolding.
hxdbzxy/iStock/Thinkstock
Learning Objectives
After reading this chapter, you should be able to do the following:
Summarize the nine steps in Ackerman and Anderson’s road map for change.
Analyze Cummings and Worley’s five dimensions of leading and managing change.
Describe how to align an organization with its new vision and future state.
Explain how roles/relationships and interventions are used to implement change.
Examine ways to interact with and influence stakeholders.
Change is the law of life and those who look only to the past or present are certain to miss the future.
—John F. Kennedy
Alan Mulally was selected to lead Ford in 2006 after he was bypassed as CEO at Boeing, where he had worked and was expected to become CEO. Insiders and top-level managers at Ford, some of whom had expected to become CEO, were initially suspicious and then outraged when Mulally was hired. They questioned what someone from the airplane industry would know about the car business (Kiley, 2009).
Chair William (Bill) Clay Ford, Jr.—who selected Mulally as CEO—told Ford’s officers that the company needed a fresh perspective and a shake-up, especially since it had lost $14.8 billion in 2008—the most in its 105-year history—and had burned through $21.2 billion, or 61%, of its cash (Kiley, 2009). Because Ford knew that the company’s upper echelon culture was closed, bureaucratic, and rejected outsiders and new ways of thinking, he was not surprised by his officers’ reactions. However, Ford’s managers had no idea that the company was fighting for its life. To succeed, Mulally would need Chair Ford’s full endorsement and support, and he got it.
The company’s biggest cultural challenge was to break down the silos that various executives had built. As we will discuss more in Chapter 4, silos are specific processes or departments in an organization that work independently of each other without strong communication between or among them. A lack of communication can often stifle productivity and innovation, and this was exactly what was happening at Ford.
Mulally devised a turnaround strategy and developed it into the Way Forward Plan. The plan centralized and modernized plants to handle several models at once, to be sold in several markets. The plan was designed to break up the fiefdoms of isolated cultures, in which leaders independently developed and decided where to sell cars. Mulally’s plan also kept managers in positions for longer periods of time to deepen their expertise and improve consistency of operations. The manager who ran the Mazda Motor affiliate commented, “I’m going into my fourth year in the same job. I’ve never had such consistency of purpose before” (as cited in Kiley, 2009, “Meetings About Meetings,” para. 2).
Mulally’s leadership style involved evaluating and analyzing a situation using data and facts and then earning individuals’ support with his determinatio ...
3Assignment Three Purpose of the study and Research Questions.docxlorainedeserre
3
Assignment Three: Purpose of the study and Research Questions
RES 9300
Recently, Autism has become a serious health concern to parents. According to Center for Disease Control and Prevention (2018), about one in fifty nine United States children has been identified with autism spectrum disorder with one in six children developing developmental disability ranging from mild disabilities such as speech and language impairments to serious developmental disabilities, such as intellectual disabilities, cerebral palsy, and autism (CDC,2018). World Health Organization (2019) estimates that 1 in 160 children globally has autism making it one of the most prevalent diseases. Despite the disease prevalence, most population has little knowledge about the disease. Many health practitioners have proposed early care as a means to control the disease effects.
Purpose Statement
The purpose of this study is to determine whether early intervention services can help improve the development of children suffering from autism. This study also aims to explore the general public awareness and perception about autism disorder.
Research Questions
(1) How should service delivery for autistic patients be improved to promote their health? (2) What impact does early intervention services have on development of children suffering from autism? (3) How can public knowledge on autism improve support and care for autistic patients? (4) What effect will early intervention have on patient’s social skills?
References
Center for Disease Control and Prevention. (2018). Autism Spectrum Disorder (ASD). Data & Statistics. Retrieved From https://www.cdc.gov/ncbddd/autism/data.html
World Health Organization. (2019). Autism Spectrum Disorders. Fact Sheet. Retrieved From https://www.who.int/news-room/fact-sheets/detail/autism-spectrum-disorders
3
Assignment Two: Theoretical Perspective and Literature Review
RES 9300
Literature Map
Parenting an Autism Child
(Dependent Variable)
9
Mothers/Father Role
Education
Religious Beliefs
Gender/Age
Financial Resources
Maternal Relationship
Region
Public Awareness
Support
Ethnicity
Independent Variables
Secondary Source I Will Be Using In My Literature Review
Mother/Father Roles
Glynn, K. A. (2015). Predictors of parenting practices in parents of children with autism spectrum disorder.
Religious Beliefs
Huang, C. Y., Yen, H. C., Tseng, M. H., Tung, L. C., Chen, Y. D., & Chen, K. L. (2014). Impacts of autistic behaviors, emotional and behavioral problems on parenting stress in caregivers of children with autism. Journal of Autism and Developmental Disorders, 44(6), 1383-1390.
Education
Brezis, R. S., Weisner, T. S., Daley, T. C., Singhal, N., Barua, M., & Chollera, S. P. (2015). Parenting a child with autism in India: Narratives before and after a parent–child intervention program. Culture, Medicine, and Psychiatry, 39(2), 277-298.
Financial Resources
Zaidm ...
380067.docxby Jamie FeryllFILET IME SUBMIT T ED 22- .docxlorainedeserre
380067.docx
by Jamie Feryll
FILE
T IME SUBMIT T ED 22- MAR- 2019 06:38AM WORD COUNT 3608
CHARACT ER COUNT 204 57
380067 .DOCX (28.82K)
%4
SIMILARIT Y INDEX
EXCLUDE QUOT ES ON
EXCLUDE
BIBLIOGRAPHY
ON
380067.docx
ORIGINALITY REPORT
380067.docx
WRITECHECK REPORT
PAGE 1
PAGE 2
PAGE 3
PAGE 4
PAGE 5
PAGE 6
PAGE 7
PAGE 8
PAGE 9
PAGE 10
PAGE 11
PAGE 12
PAGE 13
PAGE 14
PAGE 15
PAGE 16
380067.docxby Jamie Feryll380067.docxORIGINALITY REPORT380067.docxWRITECHECK REPORT
380067
by Jamie Feryll
FILE
T IME SUBMIT T ED 13- MAR- 2019 03:56PM WORD COUNT 34 63
CHARACT ER COUNT 1957 5
ARCHAEOLOGY.DOCX (31.23K)
%5
SIMILARIT Y INDEX
EXCLUDE QUOT ES ON
EXCLUDE
BIBLIOGRAPHY
ON
380067
ORIGINALITY REPORT
380067
WRITECHECK REPORT
PAGE 1
PAGE 2
PAGE 3
PAGE 4
PAGE 5
PAGE 6
PAGE 7
PAGE 8
PAGE 9
PAGE 10
PAGE 11
PAGE 12
PAGE 13
PAGE 14
PAGE 15
380067by Jamie Feryll380067ORIGINALITY REPORT380067WRITECHECK REPORT
Interpretations of Iron Age Architecture Brochs in Society/Social Identity
Archaeology is a historical field which has advanced over the years based on more discoveries still being experienced by the archaeologists who seek them. According to Kelly and Thomas (2010; p.5), the concession that life existed in more ancient times than stipulated by biblical scholars and human culture allowed the archaeologists to dig deeper into genealogical data. Iron Age architecture and social/society identity relate to one another. For instance, the population, based on their identity and perception will construct buildings that directly reflect their beliefs. This essay will discuss these archaeological concepts of Iron Age architecture and society/social identity. Need a paragraph on brochs and how many and where they are across Scotland with patcialur focus on the atlantc region, this is not relevant for masters essay. Must define broch from its architecture and how long it would take to build and note famous ones and note the ones that will be referred to in this essay – this could be Perhaps incorpated into the next paragraph.
Iron Age architecture has over the years been dominated by differing archaeological concepts and debates. It was defined by settlements and settlement structures such as duns, brochs, wheelhouses, hillforts, stone-built round houses and timber. The social and societal identity which is identified through material remains indicates aspects of differentiation, regional patterns and segregation. According to Kelly and Thomas (2010; p.28), people who existed in Iron Age Scotland were isolated. This is demonstrated by the presence of a burial followed by an assembled chariot at Newbridge. Northern and western Scotland have been the source of the well-structured developments that have provided cultural, architectural and social data over time. Maes Howe, which is the largest Orkney burial cairn, located between Stromne ...
39Chapter 7Theories of TeachingIntroductionTheories of l.docxlorainedeserre
This document summarizes theories of teaching from several influential learning theorists. It discusses how theorists like Thorndike, Guthrie, Skinner, Hull, Tolman, and Gagné viewed the role of the teacher based on their behavioral and cognitive learning theories derived from animal and child studies. They generally saw teaching as managing external conditions to ensure specified behavioral changes in learners. The document then contrasts this with theories of teaching from adult learning theorists like Rogers, who rejected the notion that teaching is controlling learning and saw the teacher's role differently.
38 Monthly Labor Review • June 2012TelecommutingThe.docxlorainedeserre
38 Monthly Labor Review • June 2012
Telecommuting
The hard truth about telecommuting
Telecommuting has not permeated the American workplace, and
where it has become commonly used, it is not helpful in reducing
work-family conflicts; telecommuting appears, instead, to have
become instrumental in the general expansion of work hours,
facilitating workers’ needs for additional worktime beyond the
standard workweek and/or the ability of employers to increase or
intensify work demands among their salaried employees
Mary C. Noonan
and
Jennifer L. Glass
Mary C. Noonan is an Associate
Professor at the Department of
Sociology, The University of Iowa;
Jennifer L. Glass is the Barbara
Bush Regents Professor of Liberal
Arts at the Department of Sociol-
ogy and Population Research
Center, University of Texas at
Austin. Email: [email protected]
uiowa.edu or [email protected]
austin.utexas.edu.
Telecommuting, defined here as work tasks regularly performed at home, has achieved enough
traction in the American workplace to
merit intensive scrutiny, with 24 percent
of employed Americans reporting in recent
surveys that they work at least some hours
at home each week.1 The definitions of
telecommuting are quite diverse. In this ar-
ticle, we define telecommuters as employ-
ees who work regularly, but not exclusively,
at home. In our definition, at-home work
activities do not need to be technologically
mediated nor do telecommuters need a
formal arrangement with their employer to
work at home.
Telecommuting is popular with policy
makers and activists, with proponents
pointing out the multiple ways in which
telecommuting can cut commuting time
and costs,2 reduce energy consumption
and traffic congestion, and contribute to
worklife balance for those with caregiving
responsibilities.3 Changes in the structure
of jobs that enable mothers to more effec-
tively compete in the workplace, such as
telecommuting, may be needed to finally
eliminate the gender gap in earnings and
direct more earned income to children,
both important public policy goals.4
Evidence also reveals that an increasing num-
ber of jobs in the American economy could be
performed at home if employers were willing
to allow employees to do so.5 Often, employees
can perform jobs at home without supervision
in the “high-tech” sector, in the financial sector,
and many in the communication sector that are
technology dependent. The obstacles or barriers
to telecommuting seem to be more organiza-
tional, stemming from the managers’ reluctance
to give up direct supervisory control of workers
and from their fears of shirking among workers
who telecommute.6
Where the impact of telecommuting has
been empirically evaluated, it seems to boost
productivity, decrease absenteeism, and increase
retention.7 But can telecommuting live up to its
promise as an effective work-family policy that
helps employees meet their nonwork responsi-
bilities? To do so, tel ...
How to Setup Warehouse & Location in Odoo 17 InventoryCeline George
In this slide, we'll explore how to set up warehouses and locations in Odoo 17 Inventory. This will help us manage our stock effectively, track inventory levels, and streamline warehouse operations.
Temple of Asclepius in Thrace. Excavation resultsKrassimira Luka
The temple and the sanctuary around were dedicated to Asklepios Zmidrenus. This name has been known since 1875 when an inscription dedicated to him was discovered in Rome. The inscription is dated in 227 AD and was left by soldiers originating from the city of Philippopolis (modern Plovdiv).
Walmart Business+ and Spark Good for Nonprofits.pdfTechSoup
"Learn about all the ways Walmart supports nonprofit organizations.
You will hear from Liz Willett, the Head of Nonprofits, and hear about what Walmart is doing to help nonprofits, including Walmart Business and Spark Good. Walmart Business+ is a new offer for nonprofits that offers discounts and also streamlines nonprofits order and expense tracking, saving time and money.
The webinar may also give some examples on how nonprofits can best leverage Walmart Business+.
The event will cover the following::
Walmart Business + (https://business.walmart.com/plus) is a new shopping experience for nonprofits, schools, and local business customers that connects an exclusive online shopping experience to stores. Benefits include free delivery and shipping, a 'Spend Analytics” feature, special discounts, deals and tax-exempt shopping.
Special TechSoup offer for a free 180 days membership, and up to $150 in discounts on eligible orders.
Spark Good (walmart.com/sparkgood) is a charitable platform that enables nonprofits to receive donations directly from customers and associates.
Answers about how you can do more with Walmart!"
LAND USE LAND COVER AND NDVI OF MIRZAPUR DISTRICT, UPRAHUL
This Dissertation explores the particular circumstances of Mirzapur, a region located in the
core of India. Mirzapur, with its varied terrains and abundant biodiversity, offers an optimal
environment for investigating the changes in vegetation cover dynamics. Our study utilizes
advanced technologies such as GIS (Geographic Information Systems) and Remote sensing to
analyze the transformations that have taken place over the course of a decade.
The complex relationship between human activities and the environment has been the focus
of extensive research and worry. As the global community grapples with swift urbanization,
population expansion, and economic progress, the effects on natural ecosystems are becoming
more evident. A crucial element of this impact is the alteration of vegetation cover, which plays a
significant role in maintaining the ecological equilibrium of our planet.Land serves as the foundation for all human activities and provides the necessary materials for
these activities. As the most crucial natural resource, its utilization by humans results in different
'Land uses,' which are determined by both human activities and the physical characteristics of the
land.
The utilization of land is impacted by human needs and environmental factors. In countries
like India, rapid population growth and the emphasis on extensive resource exploitation can lead
to significant land degradation, adversely affecting the region's land cover.
Therefore, human intervention has significantly influenced land use patterns over many
centuries, evolving its structure over time and space. In the present era, these changes have
accelerated due to factors such as agriculture and urbanization. Information regarding land use and
cover is essential for various planning and management tasks related to the Earth's surface,
providing crucial environmental data for scientific, resource management, policy purposes, and
diverse human activities.
Accurate understanding of land use and cover is imperative for the development planning
of any area. Consequently, a wide range of professionals, including earth system scientists, land
and water managers, and urban planners, are interested in obtaining data on land use and cover
changes, conversion trends, and other related patterns. The spatial dimensions of land use and
cover support policymakers and scientists in making well-informed decisions, as alterations in
these patterns indicate shifts in economic and social conditions. Monitoring such changes with the
help of Advanced technologies like Remote Sensing and Geographic Information Systems is
crucial for coordinated efforts across different administrative levels. Advanced technologies like
Remote Sensing and Geographic Information Systems
9
Changes in vegetation cover refer to variations in the distribution, composition, and overall
structure of plant communities across different temporal and spatial scales. These changes can
occur natural.
This presentation was provided by Rebecca Benner, Ph.D., of the American Society of Anesthesiologists, for the second session of NISO's 2024 Training Series "DEIA in the Scholarly Landscape." Session Two: 'Expanding Pathways to Publishing Careers,' was held June 13, 2024.
The chapter Lifelines of National Economy in Class 10 Geography focuses on the various modes of transportation and communication that play a vital role in the economic development of a country. These lifelines are crucial for the movement of goods, services, and people, thereby connecting different regions and promoting economic activities.
Philippine Edukasyong Pantahanan at Pangkabuhayan (EPP) CurriculumMJDuyan
(𝐓𝐋𝐄 𝟏𝟎𝟎) (𝐋𝐞𝐬𝐬𝐨𝐧 𝟏)-𝐏𝐫𝐞𝐥𝐢𝐦𝐬
𝐃𝐢𝐬𝐜𝐮𝐬𝐬 𝐭𝐡𝐞 𝐄𝐏𝐏 𝐂𝐮𝐫𝐫𝐢𝐜𝐮𝐥𝐮𝐦 𝐢𝐧 𝐭𝐡𝐞 𝐏𝐡𝐢𝐥𝐢𝐩𝐩𝐢𝐧𝐞𝐬:
- Understand the goals and objectives of the Edukasyong Pantahanan at Pangkabuhayan (EPP) curriculum, recognizing its importance in fostering practical life skills and values among students. Students will also be able to identify the key components and subjects covered, such as agriculture, home economics, industrial arts, and information and communication technology.
𝐄𝐱𝐩𝐥𝐚𝐢𝐧 𝐭𝐡𝐞 𝐍𝐚𝐭𝐮𝐫𝐞 𝐚𝐧𝐝 𝐒𝐜𝐨𝐩𝐞 𝐨𝐟 𝐚𝐧 𝐄𝐧𝐭𝐫𝐞𝐩𝐫𝐞𝐧𝐞𝐮𝐫:
-Define entrepreneurship, distinguishing it from general business activities by emphasizing its focus on innovation, risk-taking, and value creation. Students will describe the characteristics and traits of successful entrepreneurs, including their roles and responsibilities, and discuss the broader economic and social impacts of entrepreneurial activities on both local and global scales.
Beyond Degrees - Empowering the Workforce in the Context of Skills-First.pptxEduSkills OECD
Iván Bornacelly, Policy Analyst at the OECD Centre for Skills, OECD, presents at the webinar 'Tackling job market gaps with a skills-first approach' on 12 June 2024
38 I AUTOMATING INEQ!!AUTY during times of economic crisis.docx
1. 38 I AUTOMATING INEQ!!AUTY
during times of economic crisis. Poor and working-c
lass people
resist restrictions of their rights, dismantle discriminatory in
sti-
tutions, and join together for survival and mutual aid. But ti
me
and again they face middle-class backlash. Social assistan
ce is re-
cast as charity, mutual aid is reconstructed as dependency,
and
new techniques to turn back the progress of the poor prolifera
te .
A well-funded, widely supported, and wildly successful
counter-
movement to deny basic human rights to poor and working-clas
s
people has grown steadily since the 1970s. The movement man
u-
factures and circulates misleading stories about the poor: t
hat
2. they are an undeserving, fraudulent, dependent, and immo
ral
minority. Conservative critics of the welfare state continue to ru
n -
a very effective propaganda campaign to convince Americans t
hat __
-
the working class and the poor must battle each other in a z
ero-_
sum game over limited resources. More quietly, program
ministrators and data scientists push high-tech tools
promise to help more people, more humanely, while un_,,,.,_,.,,
efficiency, identifying fraud, and containing costs. The
poorhouse is framed as a way to rationalize and streamline
fits, but the real goal is what it has always been: to profile,
vuJ«�
--,- -
and punish the poor.
2
AUTOMATING HIGIBIUTY IN
THE HEARTLAND
3. A little white donkey is chewing on a fencepost where we turn
coward the Stipes house on a narrow utility road paralleling
the train tracks in Tipton, Indiana. Michael "Dan" Skinner,
65-year-old ex-newspaper man and my guide to central Indiana,
heaves his mom's 19-year-old sedan across the tracks and imo
the Stipes family's driveway a mile or so later. Their big white
house is marooned in a sea of cornfields, but on this sunny day
.-. in March 2015, the stalks are cut back low and softened by
snow
•-•· melting to mud. Kim and Kevin Stipes joke that they've had
to
grow tall children: come July, the smaller ones disappear into
the
corn. I'm here to talk to Kim and Kevin about their daughter
So-
/phie, who lost her Medicaid benefits during Indiana's
experiment
with welfare eligibility automation.
In 2012, I delivered a lecture at Indiana University Blooming-
••••- ton about how new data-based technologies were impacting
pub-
lie services. When I was finished, a well-dressed man raised
his hand
and asked the question that would launch this book. "You
know,"
he asked, "what's going on here in Indiana, right?" I looked at
40 I AUTOMAUN_G INE~ALITY
him blankly and shook my head, He gave me a quick synopsis:
a $L3 billion contract to privatize and automate the state's
4. welfare eligibility processes, thousands losing benefits, a high-
profile breach-of-contract case for the Indiana Supreme Court,
He handed me his card, In gold letters it identified him as Matt
Pierce, Democratic member of the Indiana House of Represen-
tatives.
Two and a half years later, the welfare automation story brought
me to the home of Sophie Stipes, a lively, sunny, stubborn girl
with dark brown hair, wide chocolate eyes, and the deep brow
characteristic of people with cerebral palsy, Shortly after she
was
born in 2002, she was diagnosed with failure to thrive, global
de-
velopmental delays, and periventricular leukomalacia, a white-
matter brain injury that affects newborns and fernses, She was
also diagnosed with lp36 deletion syndrome, which is believed
to
affect between l in 5,000 and 1 in 10,000 newborns, She has
sig-
nificant hearing loss in both ears, Kim and Kevin were told that
she might never sit up, walk, or speak, For her first two years,
all
she did was lie on her back She barely moved,
5. Her parents contacted representatives of First Steps, a pro-
gram of the Indiana Division of Disability and Rehabilitative
Services that helps young children with developmental delays,
Through the program, Sophie received therapy and nutrition ser-
vices, and her family received counseling and support, Most
important: she had a gastronomy tube implanted to deliver
nutri-
tion directly to her stomach; for the first two years of her life,
she
had not been eating very much at alL Shortly afi:er they started
feeding her directly through the G-tube, Sophie began to sit up,
At the time of my 2015 visit, Sophie is 13, She gets around on
her own and goes to schooL She knows all the letters of the al-
phabec Though doctors originally told Kim that it wouldn't
do any good to sign to her, Sophie understands 300 or 400
words
in the family's pidgin sign language and communicates with her
AUTOMATING ELIGIEIUTY IN TH.E HEARTLAND I 41
parents and friends, Sophie has been at school all day, so she is
relaxing in her room watching Elmo's World, wearing orange-
6. and-pink-striped pajamas, Kim Stipes introduces us, and we
wave
hello at each other,
I ask Kim to tell Sophie that I like her pink TV, and she laughs,
signing the message, "Kudos to Sophie," says her mom, a blond
with faded blue eyes, a gold thumb ring, and the slide-on Croes
worn by folks who spend a lot of time on their feet, "If other
kids worked half as hard, they'd all be geniuses making
millions,
That's how hard Sophie has worked,"
The Stipeses aren't strangers to hard work In a greenhouse
made of metal tubes and plastic sheeting, Kevin cultivates heir-
loom tomatoes, broccoli, lettuce, peppers, green beans, squash,
and
even peaches, They can and freeze produce to use throughout
the
winter, But 2008 was a rough year, Kevin lost his job, and with
it,
the family's health insurance, He and Kim were trying to
support
seven kids on what they could make selling auto parts on rhe
inter-
7. net, Their son Max had recently been diagnosed with type I
diabe-
tes, And Sophie had been very sick, throwing up all the time,
Without Medicaid Sophie's care would have been financially
overwhelming, Her formula was incredibly expensive, She
needed
specialized diapers for older children with developmental
delays,
It cost $1,700 every time Sophie had a G-tube implanted, The
cost of her care exceeded $6,000 a month,
Trouble really started in late 2007, when Kim applied for the
Healthy Indiana Plan, which provides catastrophic health insur-
ance for low-income adults, Though five of their children were
covered by Medicaid, she and Kevin had no health insurance,
Im-
mediately afi:er Kim started the application process, four
members
of the household became ill, Kim knew that she would not be
able
to fill out all the required paperwork while caring for them,
So she went to her local Family and Social Services Adminis-
8. tration (FSSA) office in Tipton, spoke to a caseworker, and
asked
42 AUTOMATING INEQ.::!ALITY
to have the application put on hold. The Tipton caseworker
told her that, because of recent changes at FSSA, application
decisions were no longer made at the local level. She would
have
to speak with a call center operator in Marion, 40 miles away.
Kim called the Marion office and was told that her application
"would be taken care of." Neither the Tipton caseworker nor the
Marion call center operator told Kim that she had to sign pa-
perwork declaring that she was stopping the application pro-
cess. Nor did they tell her that her failed attempt to get health
insurance for herself and her husband might impact her
children's
coverage.
Then, rhe family received a letter from the FSSA. It was ad-
dressed to six-year-old Sophie, and it informed her that she
would
9. be kicked off Medicaid in less than a month because she had
"failed to cooperate" in establishing her eligibility for the pro-
gram. The notice somehow managed to be both terrifyingly brief
and densely bureaucratic. Ir read:
Mailing Date: 3/26/08
Dear SOPHIE STIPES 1
MA D 01 (MI]
Your MEDICAID beilefits will be discontinued
effective APRIL 30, 2008 due to the following
reason(s}:
-FAILURE TO COOPERATE IN ESTABLISHING ELIGI-
BILITY
-FAILURE TO COOPERATE IN VERIFYING INCOME
SUPPORTING LAW(S) OR REGULATION(S) :
470IAC2,l-l-2
Iffiportant : If you believe you may be eligi-
ble for Medicaid benefits under another cat-
egory and have more information about your
AUTOlvIATING ELIGIBILITY IN THE HEARTLAND I 43
10. case, please contact us at the number listed
at the top of this notice within ten days (13
days if this notice is received by mail) of
the date of this notice.
. The nouce arrived on April 5, 2008. It had been ten days since
it was mailed. The family had three days lefi: to contact FSSA
and correct the mistake.
Kim sprang into action, composing a lengthy letter that
explained her situation and faxing it to the Marion office on
Sun-
day, April 6. In it, she stressed that Medicaid kept Sophie alive,
that she had no other insurance, and that her medical supplies
alone cost thousands of dollars a month. Sophie's medicines
were
due to run out in five days. Kim phoned the call center in
Marion
and was told that Sophie was being cut off because Kim had
failed
to sign the paperwork declaring that she was stopping her
earlier
applications for the Healthy Indiana Plan. Kim protested that no
11. one had ever told her about the paperwork.
But it was too late.
According to the state oflndiana, the Stipes family had failed
to cooperate with the eligibility determination process and,
under
state law, the punishment was total denial of medical benefits.
The sanction would impact both Kim and Kevin, who were try-
mg to get health insurance for themselves, and Sophie would be
demed the Medicaid she was already receiving. When Kim
asked
why their other children were not being cut off, she was
informed
that they were. She should expect four more letters.
. The Stipes family contacted Dan Skinner, who was spending
his retirement as a volunteer with United Senior Action,
working
on behalf of elderly Hoosiers. In early 2007, United Senior Ac-
tion started getting calls from individuals and organizations all
over central Indiana: the shelves at food pantries were empty
and
1,,
12. I
I
44 I AUTOMATING INE~LITY
the United Way was overrun by requem for emergency medical
help. Skinner began an independent investigation in Howard
County, visiting the mayor's office, the area agency on aging,
Catholic social services, the senior center, and Mental Health
America. He found that people were losing their benefits for
"failure to cooperate" in alarming numbers.
Sophie's case stood out to him as particularly appalling. "She
was six years old, and she was recovering. She learned how to
sign.
She was starting to walk!" Skinner said. "She was starting to be
able to eat a little bit, and they said when she could rake 3,000
calories, they would take the feeding tube out. She was right at
that stage, and her Medicaid was cut off for failure to
cooperate."
By the time the Stipes family reached him, Skinner
remembered,
13. they were in a desperate situation and needed immediate action.
Dan called John Cardwell, founder and director of The Gen-
erations Project, an organization dedicared to addressing long-
term health-care issues in the state oflndiana. The two gathered
their colleagues from the AARP and the Alliance for Retired
Americans, lobbied their contacts, worked the media, and called
an emergency press conference. Dan took Sophie and her
parents
to the Indianapolis State House in a van. "She had a little dress
on," Kim Stipes remembers. "She was not a happy camper then.
Her little life was rough." They walked into the governor's
office
with Sophie in her wheelchair and "TV cameras in tow," said
Skinner. "They didn't expect that."
At one point, Governor Mitch Daniels walked right by the
group. "He did have an opportunity, quite frankly, to walk right
over to us," Skinner recalled. "He just walked by. Mitch Roob
[Secretary of the FSSA] was with him. They just stared at us
and
kept on going." Kevin Stipes yelled across the room to Daniels,
14. inviting him to come talk with his family. But the governor and
FSSA secretary failed to acknowledge them. "They get to that
AUTOMATING ELIGIBILITY 1N TH.E HEARTLAND I 45
position they don't want to deal with chat stuff They want lay-
ers," Kevin theorized later, "They want people in between." The
group asked for Lawren Mills, Governor Daniels' policy direc-
tor for human services, who agreed to meet with them. The next
day at four o'clock in the afternoon, Sophie had her Medicaid
back.
Sophie's family was not alone. In 2006, Republican governor
Mitch Daniels instituted a welfare reform program that relied on
multinational corporations to streamline benefits applications,
privatize casework, and identify fraud. Daniels had long been a
foe
of public assistance. In 1987, while serving as President Ronald
Reagan's assistant for Political and Intergovernmental Affairs,
he
had been a high-profile supporter of a failed attempt to
eliminate
AFDC. Nearly 20 years later, he tried to eliminate TANF in
Indi-
15. ana. But this time he did it through high-tech tools, not policy-
making.
Governor Daniels famously applied a Yellow Pages test to
government services. If a product or service is listed in the
Yellow
Pages, he insisted, the government shouldn't provide it. So it
was
not surprising when, shortly after his election in 2004, Daniels
began an aggressive campaign to privatize many of the state's
public services, including the Indiana Toll Road, the Bureau of
Motor Vehicles, and the state's public assistance programs.
Daniels appointed Mitch Roob as FSSA secretary. In The
Indianapolis Stat, Daniels praised Raab, then a vice president at
Affiliated Computer Services (ACS), as being" deeply
committed
to_ the interests of the least fortunate among us and equally
com-
mitted to getting the most service from every tax dollar." As
their
first order of business, Roob and his boss commissioned an
audit
of what Daniels called in a 2007 South Bend Tribune editorial
16. "the monstrous bureaucracy known as the Family and Social
46 I AUTOMATING INEQYALITY
Service Administration." As agency's audit report was released
in June 2005, two FSSA employees were arrested and charged
with theft, welfare fraud, and a panoply of other offenses. One
of
the employees was accused of collaborating with church leaders
of the Greater Faith Missionary Baptist Church in Indianapolis
to collect $62,497 in food stamps and other welfare benefits
by creating dummy accounts for herself and fellow church
parishioners. Between them, the two caseworkers had 45 years
of
experience at the FSSA.
Daniels seized the political moment, In public speeches, press
releases, and reports, the governor repeatedly characterized
Indi-
ana's welfare system as "irretrievably broken," wasteful, fraudu-
lent, and "America's worst welfare system." Citing the system's
high error rate and poor customer service, Mitch Roob criss-
17. crossed the state arguing that the system was broken beyond
the ability of state employees to fix. In early 2006, the Daniels
administration released a request for proposal (RFP) to out-
source and automate eligibility processes for T ANF, food
stamps, and Medicaid. In the request, the state set very clear
goals: reduce fraud, curtail spending, and move clients off the
welfare rolls.
"The State is aware that poor policy and operations have con-
tributed to a culture of welfare dependency among some of its
cli-
ents," the RFP read. "Respondent will help address this issue by
agreeing to use welfare eligibility and other programs to help
cli-
ents reduce dependency on welfare assistance and transition
into a
paid work setting." While the state provided no incentives or
sup-
port for matching applicants to available jobs, the RFP
suggested
that the FSSA would be willing to provide extra financial incen-
tives for finding and denying ineligible cases. The state offered
to
"pay the Respondent for superior performance," for example, if
18. the company can "reduce ineligible cases" by identifying "client
misrepresentations."
AUTOMATING ELIGIBILITY .iiN THE HEARTLAND I 47
At the time, the Indiana FSSA was helping about a million
people access health care, social services, mental health
counsel-
ing, and other forms of support. The 2006 agency was sizable: it
had a budget of $6.55 billion and a staff of approximately
6,500.
But it was much smaller than it had been 15 years earlier. In
1991,
the Indiana General Assembly consolidated the departments of
Mental Health, Public Welfare, and Human Services, and out-
sourced many of its functions. By the time of the automation,
the
FSSA had halved its public workforce and was spending 92
percent
of its budget buying setvices from outside vendors.
Everyone-advocares, applicants, administrators, and legisla-
tors alike-agreed that the existing system faced serious chal-
lenges, FSSA offices were using an extremely out-of-date
19. system
called the Indiana Client Eligibility System (ICES) for daily ad-
minisrrative functions such as calculating eligibiliry and verify-
ing income. Customer service was uneven at best. A 2005
survey
found that applicants faced a slow intake process, a telephone
sys-
tem that rarely worked, and caseworkers who were difficult to
reach. A US. Department of Agriculture (USDA) smdy found
that food stamp applicants made up to four visits to county of
fices before receiving program benefits. Overstretched staff
couldn't handle demand or keep up with towering piles of paper
case files. 1
The Daniels administration insisted that moving away from
face-to-face casework and toward electronic communication
would make offices more organized and more efficient. Even
bet-
ter, they argued, moving paper shuflling and data collection to a
private contractor would free remaining state caseworkers to
work more closely with clients. Daniels and Roob built a
compel-
20. lmg case. And people listened.
However, many ofDaniels's other assertions about the failures
of FSSA have been contested, His claim that Indiana's welfare
system was the worst in the country, for example, was based
only
48 AUTOMATING INEQ!:!AUTY
on the state's record for moving Hoosiers off welfare. It is true
that Indiana reduced the number of people on public assistance
more slowly than other states in the decade after the 1996
welfare
reforms. But Indiana had seen a significant drop in the welfare
rolls years earlier. In the three years between the installation of
ICES and the implementation of federal welfare reform, Indi-
ana's caseload fell 23 percent. As Daniels began his term, only a
tiny proportion of poor Hoosiers-38 percent-were receiving
benefits from TANF, and only 74 percent of qualified individu-
als were receiving food stamps. Despite the administration's
insis-
tence that eligibility errors were spiraling out of control, the
FSSA
reported food stamp error rates consistent with national
21. averages.
The positive error rate-which measures those who receive bene-
fits for which they are not actually eligible-was 4.4 percent. The
negative error rate-which describes those who apply for benefits
and are incorrectly denied them-was 1.5 percent.
Only two bids were submitted for the contract, one from
Accenture LLC and the other from a coalition of companies
called the Hoosier Coalition for Self-Sufficiency. The coalition
was led by IBM and ACS, Roob's former employer. Accenture
dropped out of the bidding process. On December 27, 2006,
after holding a single public hearing on the topic, the governor
signed a ten-year, $1.16 billion contract with the IBM/ACS
coalition.
In a press release celebrating the plan, Daniels announced,
"Today, we act to clean up welfare waste, and to provide
Indiana's
neediest people a better chance to escape welfare for the world
of
work and dignity. We will make America's worst welfare system
better for the people it serves, a much fairer deal for taxpayers,
and for its own employees."2 According to the Daniels adminis-
22. tration, the modernization project would improve access to
services for needy, elderly, and disabled people while saving
taxc
AUTOMATING .EHGrn1uTY IN THE HEARTLAND I 49
payers' money. It would do this by automating welfare
eligibility
processes: substituting online applications for face-to-face
inter-
actions, building centralized call centers throughout the state,
and "transitioning" 1,500 state employees to private telephone
call centers run by ACS.
Daniels lauded his privatization plan and the automated
system in the 2007 South Bend Tribune editorial. "Today's wel-
fare system ... is totally indefensible," he wrote. "For Hoosier
taxpayers, reform means enormous savings: a half billion
dollars
over the next 10 years, and that's only on the administrative
side.
When today's high rates of errors and fraud are brought down,
savings will probably exceed $1 billion."3 By March, 70 percent
of
the FSSA workforce had moved to positions with private con-
23. tractors. In October the Indiana automation project rolled om
to 12 pilot counties in north central Indiana.
In the first nine weeks of the pilot, 143,899 people called the
toll-
free number and 2,858 applied online. System failures were
immediate. "The telephone appointment system was a disaster,"
remembered_Jamie Andree of Indiana Legal Services, an organ-
1zat10n providing legal assistance to low-income Hoosiers. "An
interview would be scheduled from 10 to 12 in the morning.
People would have to find a phone, sit by it, and wait to be
called.
Then the call wouldn't come, or they'd call at II:45 saying [the
mterv1ew] 1s being rescheduled for tomorrow."
Applicants who had taken time off work were often unable to
wait by the phone the next day for a new appointment. Others
received notices that required them to participate in phone inter-
views scheduled for dares that had already passed. According to
a
2010 USDA report, a food stamp (called the Supplemental
Nutri-
24. tion Assistance Program, or SNAP, after 2008) recipient added
the
call center number to her cell phone plan's "friends and family"
i:J
so I AUTOMATING INEQ.gALITY
because she spent so much time on phone with them. Ap-
plicants who failed to successfully complete their phone
intervkw
were terminated for failing to cooperate in eligibility determma-
tion. Says Andree, "It was a terrible, terrible, terrible system."
Private call center workers were not adequately trained to deal
with the severity of challenges faced by callers, nor were they
pro-
vided with sufficient information about applicable regulations.
Advocates report call center operators bursting into tears on
the phone. "The first person I called under modernization, I re-
member it vividly," reported Terry West, a patient advocate
with
15 years' experience in central Indiana. "She was young, and· · ,
25. did not have any experience whatsoever. ... There was a
problem,
a denial of a case. I talked to this young lady for about an hour.
I
kept citing [ the appropriate regulations]. After about a half an
hour, she just started crying. She said, 'I don't know what I'm
doing.' That's exactly what she told me. I said, 'Look, it's okay.
I
was a caseworker. I'm reading right out of your policy manual
what has to be done.' She just cried."
Millions of copies of drivers' licenses, social security cards,
and other supporting documents were faxed to a centralized
document processing center in Grant County; so many of them
disappeared that advocates started calling it "the black hole in
Marion." Each month the number of verification documents that
vanished-were not attached properly ro digital case files in a
pro-
cess called "indexing" -rose exponentially. According to court
documents, in December 2007 just over 11,000 documents were
unindexed. By February 2009, nearly 283,000 documents had
disappeared, an increase of 2,473 percent. The rise in technical
26. errors far outpaced increased system use. The consequences are
staggering if you consider chat any single missing document
could
cause an applicant robe denied benefits.
Performance metrics designed to speed eligibility determina-
tions created perverse incentives for call center workers to close
AUTOMATING ELIGIBILITY IN nm HEARTLAND I 51
cases prematurely. Timeliness could be improved by denying
ap-
plications and then advising applicants ro reapply, which
required
that they wait an additional 30 or 60 days for a new
determination.
Some administrative snafus were simple mistakes, integration
problems, and technical glitches. But many errors were the
result
of inflexible rules that interpreted any deviation from the newly
rigid application process, no matter how inconsequential or
inad-
vertent, as an active refusal to cooperate.
The automation's impacts were devastating for poor and
working-class Hoosiers. Between 2006 and 2008, the state ofln-
27. diana denied more than a million applications for food stamps,
Medicaid, and cash benefits, a 54 percent increase compared to
the three years prior to automation.
Michelle "Shelli" Birden, a soft-spoken and serious young
woman
from Kokomo, lost her benefits during the automation experi-
ment. Shelli was diagnosed with epilepsy at six months of age;
by the time she reached adulthood, she was suffering as many as
five grand ma! seizures a day. Despite having surgery to
implant a
vagus nerve stimulator-something like a pacemaker for the
brain-she was still, in her own words, "violently ill" when the
modernization hit. In late April 2008 she received a recertifica-
tion notice from the FSSA. She faxed her response, a pile of
forms,
and other documentation eight days later. On June 25, Shelli re-
ceived a letter dated June 12 informing her that her Medicaid
benefits would be discontinued in five days for "failure to
cooper-
ate m establishing eligibility."
The failure to cooperate notice had originally been sent to an
28. outdated address, which delayed its delivery. Now Shelli, in a
panic, phoned the call center. An ACS worker told her to try to
correct her application online. When that failed, she and her
boyfriend Jeff Stewart phoned the call center several more
times,
trying to identify the problem. "I started reading her letters to
52 I AUTOMATING INEQ:g.ALITY
figure our what to do, and where to go, and who to call," Jeff
re-
membered, "but you couldn't get anywhere on the phone. It was
like you were talking to a computer instead of a person:" .
On July 11, call center operators connected Shelli with one
of the few remaining state caseworkers in Marion, who told her
that she had neglected to sign a required form but did not tell
her which one. By this point, she was starting to run out of
her anticonvulsant medications. She would have to find a free
source for her drugs, which cost close to $800 a month, or risk
violent seizures, panic attacks, dizziness, insomnia, blurred vi-
sion, and an increased risk of death from going off them cold
29. turkey. .
Shelli contacted the United Way, which ptovided her with a
few days of emergency medication. The staff also advised her to
immediately file an appeal of the "failure to cooperate" determi-
nation. She reached out to the Marion office again, on July 14,
and asked to lodge an appeal. But she was informed that the 30-
day deadline to contest the June 12 decision had passed. It was
too late to appeal the FSSA'.s decision. She'd have to reapply.
A new determination would take 45 days. She had three days
of medication left.
The governor and the FSSA promised that an autom~ted
eligibil-
ity system would offer increased client control, a fairer applica-
tion process, and more timely decisions. The problem with the
existing caseworker-centered system, as they saw it, was
twofold.
First, caseworkers spent more time manually processing papers
and collecting data than "using their social work expertise to
help
clients." Second, rhe outdated data system allowed caseworkers
to
30. collude with outside co-conspirators to illegally obtain benefits
and defraud taxpayers. The old system involved caseworkers_
de-
veloping one-on-one relationships with individuals and families
and following cases through to completion. The new system was
AUTOMATING ELIGIBILITY rn THE HEARTLAND I 53
"self-serve," technology-focused, and presented call center
ers with a list of tasks to complete rather than a docker of
families
to serve. No one worker had oversight of a case from beginning
to
end; when clients called the 1-800 number, they always spoke to
a
new worker. Because the Daniels administration saw relation-
ships between caseworkers and clients as invitations to fraud,
the
system was designed to sever those links.
The FSSA packed up all its existing records and moved them
to a central storage facility in Indianapolis. These paper records
were set aside in case the state needed them for appeal hearings,
but were not scanned into the modernized system. All current
31. recipients of TANF, food stamps/SNAP, and Medicaid were re-
quired to turn in all their supporting documentation again, no
matter how long they had been receiving benefits. "All of the
doc-
uments that identified the members of the household-birth cer-
tificates and that sort of thing-were in the local office until the
modernization. And then they were gone," remembered Jamie
Andree. "It was as if they had never existed. So one of the
things
that happened with modernization is that people [were] asked to
turn in [obscure] stuff, like the tide to a vehicle that they hadn't
owned smce 1988. They were being asked to turn in things that
the agency already had."
When clients did manage to find decades-old documents, de-
lays between the document center receiving paperwork and the
contractors processing it were consistently interpreted as the
fault
of the applicant. Chris Holly, a Medicaid attorney in Blooming-
ton, estimated that 95 percent of the Medicaid applications he
handled during the automation resulted in eligibility determina-
tion errors. According to Holly, all the errors were generated by
32. the state and its contractors, not his clients. "We knew we had
submitted everything by the deadline," he said in December of
2014, "and we were still getting denials for failure to cooperate"
I l .
t wou d take three or four days for documentation to get
ii
ii
I' ,,'
54 j AUTOMATING INEQ:gALITY
Th Id deny it on the d b ,, h never waited. ey wou
processe , ut t ey . d . f l et denied, they assume
[d
di' ] r even before. An 1 peop e g , .
ea me , o . , . Th 'II accept that they re JUSt
the system knows what its domg. ey
ineligible and give up." h . their health insurance
1 · t foug t to retam
Still, many app ,can s f idable odds. Like Shelli, they
or food assistance against these orm c t out a single error in
. d · t yingto rerre
became tenacious etecnves, r f es Failure to cooper-
!. . · gdozens o pag · complex app ,canons runnm . l d that
33. some-
cc d 1· l uuidance They s1mp Y state
ate notices orrere itt e " . . . h t speciiftcally was
. h . h n apphcanon, not W a
thing was not ng twit a . d ·lleoible? Was
. sing lost unsigne , or l ,r
wrong. Was a document mis , , , "Failure to
. h FSSA or the contractor.
it the fault of the chent, t e h ' ,, · d Glenn Cardwell, a re-
h t've p rase, note cooperate was t e opera ' l' . in Vigo County,
k d administrator now ,vmg
tired casewor er an . , . bl m and not the city, ,not the
"because then it was the clients pro e
contractor." . k s or omissions in an ap-
Under the previous system, m1sta e . equiring case-
bl and nme-consummg, r
plication were trou esome d cuments like birth
workers and clients to collaborate tofsecfure ome social security
d . l ts proo o mco , certificates, me ,ca repor , d . t'on they had
some-
. ''B fi mo ern1za 1 ,
cards, and rental receipts.. e ore . d this notice. What do I
11 d 'Listen I receive one to ca up an say, ' . R "And the an-
d
, ,, 11 d ACLU attorney Gavm ose.
34. need to al reca e . . ht now I'll make sure
'R . d wn to me fax it over ng ·
swer was un it o , f h' , ,, Before the auroma-
. Iii d 'II take care o t is.
it gets m your e an we ,, h d been a last-ditch punishment
tion, "failure to cooperate a . h . ly re•used to par-
d . few clients w o acuve J'
caseworkers use agamst a Aft the automation, the
. h 1· 'b'l'ty process. er
ticipate m t e e ,g1 ' ! h !fare rolls, no
phrase became a chain saw that clearcut t e we
matter the collateral damage.
lk. bout what she remembers as
Shelli Birden was wary of ta mg a. . . of her life. Ulric
one of the most confusing and ternfymg times
AUTOMATING ELIGIB1UTY IN THE HEARTLAND I 55
mately she discovered the signature she had missed. "I had
to go back through my papers," she said. "l always copied my
pa-
pers. l missed one question, and boom, they shut me off." When
we spoke in 2015, she remembered feeling completely alone in
a life-threatening situation. "They didn't give us enough infor-
mation," she said. "They didn't send us in with our social work-
ers anymore. They made us do it on our own."
35. But Shelli, as smart and tenacious as she is, didn't do it entirely
on her own. She received help from advocate Dan Skinner,
whose
contacts with FSSA staff fast-tracked solutions. Her boyfriend
took on navigating the debacle like it was a second job. She re-
ceived help from the United Way, which provided advice and
support. Birden was reinstated to Medicaid on July 17. She re-
ceived her medication in time to save her life. Seven years later,
with her health stabilized, Shelli was holding a job at Wal-
Marc.
'Tm doing really good," she said. 'Tm actually able to get back
to
work, and I feel like my life matters."
But many orhers were not so lucky. "As attorneys, we had ac-
cess ro people that could fix things," noted Chris Holly. "But
average well-meaning people that needed help? They were the
ones that suffered the most." Jane Porter Gresham, a retired
caseworker with nearly 30 years' experience at FSSA, agreed.
"The most vulnerable of our population-the parents of children
who didn't have food to eat, who needed medical treatment, and
36. the disabled who were not able to speak for themselves-were
the ones who iook it on the chin, took it in the gut, and in the
heart."
Lindsay Kidwell of Windfall also lost public benefits during the
modernization experiment. Six months after giving birth to her
first child, Maddox, in December 2008, Lindsay was informed
that she was due to recertify for food stamps/SNAP and Hoosier
Healthwise, Indiana's Medicaid program for low-income
parents,
56 AUTOMATING 1NEQEAL1TY
and children. She participated in a phone inter-
pregnant women, k . n Marion, who
. December 10 with a call center wor er 1 h
view on d d rovide Among t e
told her what documentation she nee e to P . J k Wil-
b for her partner, ac
documents requested were pay stu s h Buck-
d b t $400 a week before taxes at t e l' who ma e a ou h'
,ams, d Lounge Lindsay faxed everyt mg except
horn Restaurant an . D b 19 because
h stubs to the document center on ecem er '
37. J
t ekpay 'd by bank check and didn't have any stubs. His boss at
ac got pa1 fi d h w to sup-
lled the document center to n out o
t~e Bucl17~i~~aaes. Following their directions, she wrote out a
P y proo o "d d faxed them to the document
list of paychecks an amounts an
center on December 23. . d d' al biH informing her
Januar 2 Lindsay receive a me lC On y ' b d . d d that she would
be re-
M d' 'dh d een en1e, an
that her e 1ca1 a f k t ror her recent postnatal
l f · $246 out o poc e r, sponsib e or paymg d grocery shopping
on
Wh h went out to o some
check-up4 h e~~; card-the debit-like card holding her food
January , er . J ar 15 she received
/SNAP benefits-was denied. On anu y ' stamp
a letter from FSSA.
Mailing Date: 1/13/09
Dear LINDSAY K KIDWELL,
FSOl (XD)
D STAMPS dated DECEM-
Your application for FOO
BER 10, 2008 has been denied.
38. not eligible because: You are
To COOPERATE IN VERIFYING INCOME -FAILURE
SUPPORTING LAW(S) OR REGULATION(S)
7CFR273.2(d)
MA C 01 (MI)
HEALTHWISE benefits will be Your HOOSIER
AUTOMATING ELIGIBILITY IN THE HEARTLAND I 57
discontinued effective JANUARY 31, 2009 due to
the following reason(s):
-FAILURE TO COOPERATE IN VERIFYING INCOME
SUPPORTING LAW(S) OR REGULATION(S) : 470IAC2.
1-1-2
A week later, well within the 13-daywindow to submit the
"miss-
ing" documents, Lindsay went to her local Tipton County FSSA
office, submitting a more complete listing of wages and photo-
copies of Jack's last three paychecks.
Lindsay had the wage report and canceled paychecks stamped
"Received" and asked for a copy. She watched the employee
scan
39. her paperwork into the system and took a copy of the "Scan
Suc-
cessful" notice confirming it was received by the document cen-
ter. She also filed an appeal of the earlier "failure to cooperate"
determinations. If she began a fair hearing process, her food
stamps/SNAP and Medicaid would be reinstated until an ad-
ministrative law judge ruled whether or not the decision to
termi-
nate her benefits was correct.
The Tipton County worker told Lindsay that she should file a
new application for benefits rather than an appeal. It would be
faster and easier, she insisted. Lindsay refused. She didn't want
to
reapply; she wanted to appeal what she saw as an incorrect
FSSA
decision.
Three weeks later she received a phone call from a young man
who informed her that she would receive a notice in the mail
soon-a hearing on her Medicaid case had been scheduled. Then
he advised her to drop her appeal. He was looking in the com-
puter, he said, and because Lindsay had never submitted payroll
information for Jack, she would lose her case. But Lindsay had
40. copies of his payroll information stamped "Received." She had
the canceled checks and the scan confirmation. Ir must be some
58 AUTOMATING lNE~ALITY
kind of mistake, she insisted. It didn't matter. Lindsay recalls
that
the man on the phone simply said, "I found no documentation of
recent payroll information in the computer. The judge will
simply
look in the computer, see this, and deny you."
One of the great victories of the welfare rights movement of the
1960s and '70s was the redefinition of welfare benefits as the
per-
sonal property of the recipient, rather than as charity that can be
bestowed or denied on a whim. Activists successfully
challenged
inequitable access to public assistance by appealing decisions
and
demanding access to administrative law procedures known as
fair
hearings.
In 1968, eight individuals denied due process in New York
41. launched a class action lawsnit chat led to a Snpreme Court
deci-
sion in Goldberg v. Kelly. This landmark case found that all
wel·
fare recipients h.ave a right to an evidentiary hearing-a proc_ess
that includes timely and adequate notice, disclosure of opposmg
evidence, an impartial decision-maker, cross-examination of
wit-
nesses, and the right to retain legal representation-before their
benefits can be terminated.
By successfully reframing public benefits as property rather
than charity, the welfare rights movement established that
public
assistance recipients must be provided due process under the
Fourteenth Amendment of the Constitution. The case hinged on
the understanding, expressed by Justice William Brennan, that
abrupt termination of aid deprives poor people of both their
means of survival and their ability to mount an adequate chal-
lenge to government decisions. "From its founding, the Nation's
basic commitment has been to foster the dignity and well-bemg
of all persons within its borders," Brennan wrote. "Public assis-
42. tance, then, is not mere charity, but a means to 'promote the
gen-
eral Welfare, and secure the Blessings of Liberty to ourselves
and
P
. ,,,4
our ostenty.
AUTOMATING ELlGIBIUTY IN THE HEARTLAND 1 59
. 'Il;e far-reaching and fundamenral changes introduced by In-
diana s automated system put it on an inevitable collision
course
with the poor's right to due process guaranteed by Goldberg. A
class action lawsuit, Perdue v. Murphy, was filed by Gavin Rose
and Jacquelyn Bowie Suess, staff artorneys from the ACLU of
Indiana, on behalf of more than a dozen individuals in north
central Indiana who had lost their Medicaid, food stamps/
SNAP, or TANF assistance for failure to cooperate. The case
explicitly challenged the loss of due process under the
automated
system.
The ACLU alleged chat notices were incomplete, "failure to
cooperate" was being used too broadly, and the new
caseworkerless
43. system denied the disabled equal access to public programs.
They
also claimed that the last resort of wrongly denied applicants-a
fair heanng-was made increasingly difficult to access. Call cen-
ter workers defaulted to the decisions of the automated system
over the administrative law process, discouraging appeals in
favor
of reapplication, and failed to notify applicants of their rights.
Applicants felt that they had nowhere to turn for redress.
Ali:er successes for the ACLU in lower courts, Perdue v. Mur-
phy eventually went to che Indiana Supreme Court, which found
that the state's" failure to cooperate" notices were
unconstitutional
and did not provide adequate due process protections. But, re·
versing a lower court's decision, Indiana's highest court held
that the ',;ate does have a right to deny applicants for "failure to
cooperate because at some point "failing" and "refusing" to
coop-
erate converge. The case forced the FSSA to create more
complete
and specific notices, but did little to return the individualized
at-
44. tention of caseworkers to the Indiana eligibility process, or to
stop the use of"failure to cooperate" to clearcut the rolls.
"The judge will simply look in the computer ... and deny you,"
the call center operator said to Lindsay Kidwell in February
2009.
60 AUTOMATING INE~ALITY
The words were a nightmare. Despire rhe fact that she had
stamped proof that she submitted all the appropriate payroll
mfor-
mation, Lindsay wavered. Should she cancel her appeal? If she
lost,
she'd be responsible for repaying all the benefits she received
while
waiting for a decision-months of medical and food bills.
Even though Lindsay knew she was in the right, there was no
guarantee she would win the case. A loss would mean more debt
for her young family. She asked the man on the phone if she
could
talk to an advisor before deciding whether or not to contmue her
appeal. He said, "No. I need an answer now. Are you going or
not?" Gathering her courage, she re-affirmed that she wanted a
fair hearing.
45. He hung up on her.
Lindsay remembered that the appeal hearing was ~retry
straightforward. "I went to my appeal," she said in 2017. ,:'ey
said basically that rhey messed up. I didn't owe them money.
Her
family met all of the eligibility requirements of the program;
their Hoosier Healrhwise and food stamp benefits were
officially
reinstated.
But her experience with the FSSA still haunts her today. Her
family was self-supporting for nearly a decade after the
eligibility
automation. Then she went through a divorce. When I spoke
with her in 2017, she knew she was probably eligible for help
from
FSSA. 'Tm going through a tough time," she said. 'Tm a singk
mom. I work full rime, but it doesn't always cut it." Her expen-
ence during the automation makes Lindsay hesitant to apply for
benefits again. "They make it so difficult. Ifl applied now I
could
probably get it, but that experience with being dented · · · I
,mean,
I cried. I did everything that they asked me to do. I don t even
know if it's worth the stress."
46. Applicants for TANF, food stamps/SNAP, and Medicaid were
not the only Hoosiers impacted by the shift to automated
AUTOMATING ELIGIBILJTY IN THE HEARTLAND j 61
decision-making. That's why I traveled to Fort Wayne in
March 2015 to talk to caseworkers about their experience with
the Indiana experiment.
Fort Wayne, the second-largest city in Indiana, is in the
northeast, 18 miles west of Ohio and 50 miles south of
Michigan.
General Electric and International Harvester had factories there
that closed or scaled their workforces back significantly during
the 1970s and 1980s. Driving to my first appointment of the
after-
noon, I pass the local headquarters of the National Association
of
Letter Carriers; George's International Market with its
incredible
selection of house-made salsas and bottled hot sauces; and
Uncle
Lou's Steel Mill Tavern, which sports a sign in the window that
reads "Honk if you like beer." I cross the railroad tracks and the
St. Marys River, swollen from recent Hooding, into a neighbor-
hood of modest two-story houses.
47. Jane Porter Gresham welcomes me into her tidy white home,
where we sit on a blue velveteen couch in het front parlor.
Gresham's wooden cross contrasts sharply with her matching
bluet-shirt and cardigan set. Gresham worked for the FSSA for
26 years, from 1985 to 2011, when she retired in the wake of
the
automation. Even four years later, rage and frustration Ricker
across her round face as we speak. "People who are [at FSSA]
for
the first time, you can see it in their eyes-fear. Fear of what I'm
going to do. People say to me, 'I never thought I'd have to be
here.' They're not trying to cheat the system; they don't know
where else to turn. Our responsibility as public employees is to
make certain that people who are eligible get the benefits
they're
entitled to."
With decades of experience and seniority, Gresham managed
to hold on to her state job when the automation rolled out to Al-
len County. But under the new system, she no longer carried a
caseload. Rather, she responded to tasks that were assigned by
the
new WorkRow Management System (WFMS). Tasks bounced
48. 62 AUTOMATING INE~ALITY
between 1,500 new ACS employees and 682 remaining state em-
ployees, now known as "state eligibility consultants."
The governor promised that no state workers would lose their
jobs due to the automation and that salaries would stay the same
or rise. But the reality of the new ACS positions created a wave
of retirements and resignations. After reapplying for jobs they
al-
ready held, sometimes for decades, and submitting to criminal
background checks and drug tests, workers found their positions
moved from their home county office to a regional call center,
They were offered moving bonuses if their new job was more
than
50 miles from their current work site, but many declined to up-
root their lives for the insecure new positions.
Under the eligibility automation, no single employee "owned"
or oversaw a case; staff were responsible for responding to
tasks
that dropped into their queue in the WFMS, Cases were not
handled in the county where applicants lived. Now, any
employee
49. could take any call from any county using the new system, even
if they knew nothing about the caller's local context, "We got
calls from all over the state," says Gresham, "I had never heard
of
Floyds Knobs [in southeastern Indiana] until we started that
pro-
cess! I had no idea of services that were available in that area,"
Reducing casework to a task-based system is dehumanizing,
she suggests, for both worker and client, "Ifl wanted to work in
a
factory, I would have worked in a factory. , , , You were
expected
to produce, and you couldn't do that if you listened to the
client's
story," The majority of clients Gresham saw during her long
career
were traumatized-by flood or fire, illness or accident, domestic
violence or extended unemployment. "People who have gone
through a trauma want some hope that it's going to get better,
That somebody's paying attention, that they're not in this
alone,"
she says, "That's what I think we did [before the automation],
We
listened to what they had to say and acted on it so that things
could get better."
50. AUTOMATING ELIGIBILITY IN THE HEARTLAND I 63
"W'I e oecame slaves to the task system," said Fred Gilbert o
year FSSA employee . J" , , a ~o-h . . spena tz.n.ng in refugee
assistance "L'k
ot er private call center, it's 'just the facts' B t , I e any
is very complicated, That's the , b f , u the welfare system
wade through the mess," JO o caseworkers, to help people
ThegovernorandtheIBM/'"CS al', , , n co monpromi d · 1
dec1s1ons, more efficient use of resources and b tt se more time
y
vice B t k ' e er customer ser-
1
, u casewor ers experienced cascading technical fail
exp osron of errors that slo d , ures, an
poorly trained private wor;:rs :;hr;r;,1s:::e~h3;!'plicbaltions,a
hnd
created on t h . pro ems t ey
ACS ·k o t e remaming public employees. Mistakes made by
wm ers were referred to state worke fi ,
an omsized workload on the handf l fl rs or correction, piling
remained, u O ong-terrn employees that
By summer 2009, there was a back! f and 6 500 J og O nearly
32,000 cases
' peop e were waiting for ap l h .
to their month! pea eanngs. According
y management reports th FSSA
incredibl hi h £ d ' e was reporting
51. B y g oo stamp eligibility error rates to the USDA
etween 2006 and 2008 h b' · 1 d f ' t e com med error rate more
than t ,
Pe ' rom 5.9 percent to 19 4 M n-
h
, , percent, ost of that growth ,
t e negative error rate: 12 2 P f h was m , ercent o t ose ap I , f,
f, d
stamps were being incorrectly denied The t t ' f ymg or oo
for food st d , . ' s a es ong wait times
penalties f:::h:~~~:~ttracted notice and threats of financial
sic The pressure to keep timeliness numbers high to fulfill the
ba-
reqmremenrs of the contract combined , h backlo f I ' wit an
ever-growing
habitu:I :d cases£ ed to mass application denials and the now-
vice rom call center workers to "·us ,,
Gilbert reflected "Th I b b J t reapply, Fred
send something ;n e rufeshecame rittle, If[applicants] didn't
, one o t lfty docum ,
the case for failure to comply y; ;dnt~, you simply closed
to help somebody," , , , , ou cou n t go out of your way
oom, ane orter Gresham turns ren . , necnve. Back in her living
r J p
52. 64 I AUTOMATING INE~ALITY
he streer· If you want
"It didn't take long for word to get out on t b, h
, to the office [in person] ecause t ey
your benefits on nme, go ,, h "We were
have to give you a face-to-~:e :~~;i;~:~~:, ~ase ~:::~ing every-
inundated with people w d W didn't save
b d d
We didn't save space an rent, e
0 y own, , , , d,,
k W were inundated at the en , wor ers, , , , e d h wn health be-
G resham saw great workers burn out, an er o Id 't
11 , 1 w There cou n d , t "Morale was at an a -time o ,
gan to etenora e. ' e an camaraderie. It was just you
be reassurance, there couldn t b y d h d I realized this
" , f 11 "Towar s t e en '
out there, she says wist u y, , h'
1
one of the last
was affecting my health, my relations ips, was
holdouts,"
d l · ng class families
When failed by FSSA, Indiana's poor an wor G h- h F ed
! and eac ot er. ac 1· d on local governments, vo unteers, ,
53. re ie l , , f help recalcitrant state
with lines of desperate peop e wamng or ' k Hoosiers
ncies and dismissive private call center wor ers, .
;:: ht back One of the centers of their resistance was M~nte,
lnl:ana, the largest city in the automation experiments rst
pilot area, h h "Middletown, USN' pro-
Following State Route 32 t roug , Th ban-
vides a drive-by tour of the city's recent ind::~:~~:::he t::n as
doned million-square-foot BorgWarner,pla 1 d 5 000 people
Y
ou arrive from the west. In the 1950s, it emp oye 1 ' d , 2009
F d k but 1t c ose m , assembling transmissions for or true s,
sphalt
, h 11 by an enormous a
Two miles later on your ng t, you ro de the fa-
field site of the old General Motors plant, Wodrkers ma, , n for
' M , M-22 "Rock Crusher" four-spee transmissio
mous unc1e 1 d · 2006
h le cars of the 1960s there, but the plant c ose m .
t e muse h , b board in the Center
When I visited Muncie in 2015, t e JO ,r d ly a
T ' office ouere on
Township of Delaware County rustee s d' food
· · , gardener custo ian, handful of employment opportunities, '
54. service, Pepsi delivery,
AUTOMATING ELIGIBILITY IN THE HEARTLAND I 65
The state of Indiana is broken up into l,008 six-square-mile
townships, each with a local government office funded by prop-
erty taxes and run by a township board and an elected trustee,
Though each township office works a little differently, one of
their
primary responsibilities is to manage local poverty relief
Almost
immediately afi:er its rollout in October 2007, the failures of
the
automated system overwhelmed the Delaware County Trustee's
office, "People were devastated," Lead Case Coordinator Kim
Murphy said, "I mean they were just lost, Lost, lost, lost," Al-
ready suffering through the rash of plant closures, Muncie fami-
lies were now getting kicked off food stamps, cash assistance,
and
Medicaid, "They were confused, and they didn't know where to
turn," said Marilyn "Kay" Walker, Center Township trustee,
"There
55. was no case management, no personal connection, no communi-
cation among agencies, It was just the biggest mess,"
According to the lvluncie Star Press, by February 2008, the
number of households receiving food stamps in Delaware
County
dropped 7.47 percent, though the number of households
receiving
food assistance had climbed 4 percent in Indiana overalL Calls
to
the LifeStream 211 telephone hotline requesting information
about food pantries doubled, The Second Harvest Food Bank of
East Central Indiana faced severe shortages, The municipal
grave-
yard complained it had not been paid for thousands of dollars
worth of funerals for poor and indigent people,
The public was encouraged to apply for services through the
new online syStem; but low-income families in Muncie, as else-
where, did not have regular access to the internet. The majority
of
applicants had to rely on a community partner such as a local li-
brary, food pantry, or health clinic to access the online applica-
tion, The FSSA aggressively recruited community organizations
56. to support the new system by becoming part of a Voluntary
Com-
munity Assistance Network (V-CAN),
Asked to use her office's existing computers and staff to help
66 j AUTOMATING INEQ~ALITY
Muncie citizens submit applications for public assistance,
Walker
resisted, "When it came out that this is what they were going to
do, I was like, 'Excuse me, but, hell! You are not!' They were
try-
ing to get all these other organizations involved to do their
work,"
she remembered, "We're already overloaded," Walker made her
office available to people who needed to fax documents and par-
ticipate in phone appointments, and her staff went out of their
way to help applicants, but she drew the line at becoming a V-
CAN partner. "I didn't think it was our responsibility to start
doing FSSA'.s work"
Public libraries were particularly hard-hit by the automation
project. "We had lines of desperate people waiting for help,"
said
57. Muncie Public Library director Ginny Nilles, now retired, V-
CAN
partners received little to no compensation, training, or
oversight
to do what amounted to volunteer casework Librarians trained
community volunteers to help patrons submit welfare applica-
tions, but the library was quickly overwhelmed, The situation
worsened when budget cuts required reducing hours and laying
off staff.
Library staff and volunteers did a great job, said Nilles, but
there were serious issues, "Confidentiality is very important to
li-
brarians, The forms ask very personal questions, If they couldn't
use the computer, it was incumbent on us to read the questions
out loud and get the answers: social security numbers, mental
and
physical health, Volunteers are great, but if you pay someone to
do a job, it's their responsibility, It's about accountability,"
"Local agencies were victimized," said John Cardwell from
the Generations Project, who worked closely with local non-
profits throughout the automation, "They were being dumped
on, serving thousands of people they shouldn't have been
58. serving,
scrambling ro help people get their benefits restored, They
knew
these people, They weren't going to leave them without medical
care or food,"
AUTOMATING EUGIBIUTY IN THE HEARTLAND I 67
Faced with system failmes, increasing need, and little help
from the state, public assistance recipients, community organ-
izations, and trustee's offices began to organize, A group called
Concerned Hoosiers set up a website where FSSA and ACS
workers could share their experiences with the modernized
system, The Indiana Home Care Task Force held press confer-
ences on the automation experiment's impacts and drafted
model legislation to reverse damage, A subcommittee of ser-
vice providers, advocates, and welfare recipients calling them-
selves the Committee on Welfare Privatization Issues provided
emergency interventions for recipients facing benefits termi-
nation, organized press tours highlighting impacts on Hoosier
families, and launched campaigns to increase pressure on
59. policy-makers to stop the auromarion rollout and terminate
the IBM/ACS contract, With typical Hoosier humor, their ac-
ronym, COWPI, made it clear what they thought about the
new system.
Town Hall meetings on the welfare modernization spread
across the state, Anderson was first in April 2008 then M · ,
unc1e,
Bloomington, Terre Haute, Kokomo, One of the most successful
was the Muncie People's Town Hall meeting, held on May 13,
2008, Walker and Murphy proved to be shrewd organizers,
They printed flyers for the meeting and delivered them to so-
cial service agencies, convenience stores, and libraries, They
convmced the Dollar Tree to put a flyer in every customer's bag,
They scheduled the meeting to coincide with a free food distri-
bution by the Second Harvest Food Bank, They invited local
lawmakers, including State Senator Sue Errington, State Sena-
tor Tim Lanane, and State Representative Dennis Tyler, who
listened to hours of testimony from impacted constituents,
They invited Mitch Roob, who at first demurred, As the town
60. hall date approached, he changed his mind and asked Walker to
make space for a small army of caseworkers, eight computers,
68 I AUTOMATING INE~ALITY
and a photocopier, rn help attendees solve their eligibility prob-
lems on-site.
More than 500 people attended. A room-spanning line of
public assistance recipients testified about unanswered phones,
lost documents, and benefits denied capriciously. Melinda Jones
of Muncie, the mother of a ten-month-old with cancer, was
fighting to keep her Medicaid and food stamps. "I have to beg
and borrow from my family to give my daughter her food," she
said, "and I think it's utterly ridiculous that we do our children
like this."
Christina King, a diabetic and working mother of three, lost
her Medicaid during the modernization. She was unable to
afford
insulin for seven months and her blood sugar was out of control,
putting her at risk of stroke or coma. "What good does it do
when
61. my seven-year-old walks in and I physically cannot get out
ofbed?"
she asked. "I spent two days in the ICU because I have no medi-
cine. My kidneys are now at risk. My eyes are at risk. But I get
up
every day and I go to work, because I think it's important for me
to show my kids, 'Don't be dependent on the system.' I need a
hand up, not a handout. I'm raising three kids by myself. I am
try-
ing to show my kids, 'Don't be like me-do better.'"
Deaf, blind, disabled, and mentally ill clients were particu-
larly hard-hit. 'Tm deaf. How can I do a telephone interview?"
asked Dionna McGairk through a sign-language interpreter. "I
tell [ call-center operators] to use my relay service. They don't
understand what relay service is." When operators told her she
needed to get help to apply for public services, she responded:
"No-I can answer my questions myself. You are discriminating
against the deaf."
The day after the Muncie Town Hall meeting, State Represen-
tative Dennis Tyler sent a letter to his colleagues in the Indiana
House of Representatives requesting a summer General Assem-
62. bly meeting to address ongoing problems with the automated
sys-
AUTOMATING ELIGIBILITY KN THE HEARTLAND j 69
tern. "The state of Indiana isn't doing its job," he said to Joe
Cermak of NewsLink Indiana. "You don't want to think this sys-
tem is put in place to fail these people, bur what can you think
when it's failing this bad?" A few days later, on May 19, rhe
IBM/
ACS coalition, receiving a "go ahead" order from the FSSA,
rolled out the automated system to 20 more counties in
northeast-
ern and southwestern Indiana.
The modernized system had now reached 59 of 92 Indiana
counties, and was serving 430,000 social services clients, a bit
less
than half of the state's caseload. On May 30, a severe weather
system-including tornadoes, torrential rain, and high winds-
battered the state, causing widespread flooding. The IBM/ ACS
coalition pulled employees away from regular operations to
pitch
in for the flood effort, easing the way to emergency benefits for
63. thousands but worsening the already significant backlog for
regu-
lar public assistance applicants.
At a Bloomington Town Hall meeting a few weeks later,
State Senator Vi Simpson and State Representatives Peggy
Welch
and Matt Pierce listened to clienr testimony and grilled Zach
Main, director of the Division of Family Resources at FSSA and
Mitch Roob's right-hand man. Participants in the forum raised
similar concerns to those in Muncie: telephone lines were
always busy, Help Center offices had multi-day waits, failure to
cooperate notices were arbitrary and unclear, V-CAN partners
were not trained or supported. Main, visibly frustrated, re-
sponded to criticism of the new system. 'Tm nor here today to
argue, to defend," he said. Tm certainly not here to tell you that
everything is perfect with the system. What I will tell you is
that we're working very hard .... When Governor Daniels came
into office, Indiana was first in the nation in child deaths and
last in the nation in welfare-to-work. We had a system that was
64. undeniably broken, and the resulrs speak for themselves on
that."
70 I AUTOMATING INE~ALITY
He faced a skeptical, even incredulous, room. If the results
spoke for themselves, what were they saying, exactly? Simpson
and Welch, who had been responding to constituent complaints
for three months, weren't buying it. They pressed him with
ques-
tions about the ambiguity of failure to cooperate notices, inade-
quate caseworker support, lack ofFSSA accountability to its
own
processes, and failure to levy penalties against IBM and ACS
for
poor performance.
Peggy Welch shot back, 'Tm sorry Zach, but what we've heard
over and over again is about this telephone interview time, that
they tell you, 'We're going to call between 2 and 4 and you
better
be there,' and rhe call doesn't come through. They call at 8
o'clock
the next morning and then say 'failure to cooperate.' That's a
real
65. problem." Simpson added, "People don't know what it means
when they get 'failure to cooperate' on a denial notice. In the
old
days, they used to be able to call their caseworker and find out
what
piece of paper they were missing, or what signature line they
for-
got to sign, or whatever the problem was. Now they don't have
anyone to call."
The press was printing poignant human interest stories
emerging from the modernization: a nun denied Medicaid,
desperately ill patients spending their final months fighting to
get their health care back, food banks picked clean. Ollice
Holden, regional administrator of the Food and Nutrition Ser-
vice, which administers food stamps for the USDA, wrote a let-
ter to Secretary Roob requesting that the FSSA delay further
implementation. The federal government was concerned over
long
determination wait times.
The governor faced increasingly vocal challenges from state
legislators. "I asked for a point of personal privilege on the
House
66. floor," said Matt Pierce, a Democrat. "I said, 'This is a train
wreck
and everybody ought to know. This thing is hurting people.
We've really got to fix it.'" The governor attacked complaints as
AUTOMATING ELIGIBILITY V.N THE HEARTLAND I 71
partisan sniping. me tell you what," Daniels fired in
an interview with the Evansville Courier & Press, "[Legislators]
are hearing complaints from people who made money off the
past system. That's where the complaints are principally coming
from." 5
But Daniels' contention that the only people harmed by the
auto-
mation experiment were welfare chiselers proved unsustainable
when members of his own party began to attack the project. ln
October 2008, State Representative Suzanne Crouch and Stare
Senator Vaneta Becker, both Republicans, drafted legislation
that
would halt the expansion of the new eligibility system until the
Select Joint Commission on Medicaid Oversight could perform
a
thorough review. At the close of the year, Daniels announced
that
67. he was moving his friend and colleague, Mitch Roob, out of the
FSSA and making him the state's secretary of commerce and
CEO of the Indiana Economic Development Corporation. He
appointed Anne Waltermann Murphy, Roob's chief of staff, co
lead the troubled agency.
Within three months of taking control, Murphy demanded
that IBM submit a corrective action plan to improve 36 different
service deficiencies, including excessive wait times, lost docu-
ments, inaccurate data, interview scheduling problems, slow ap-
plication processing, and incorrect instructions to clients.
IBM argued that nothing in their contract required that they
respond to a corrective action plan, but agreed to evaluate exist-
ing operations and suggest areas for system improvement. Ac-
cording to Ken Kusmer of the News and Tribune, IBM released
a
362-page plan to fix problems, including "inaccurate and incom-
plete data gathering" and "incorrect communications to clients"
in late July.6 Secretary Murphy encouraged two longtime
welfare
68. officials, Richard Adams and Roger Zimmerman, to come up
with a "Plan B" in case IBM was unable or unwilling to make
72 AUTOMATING INE~ALITY
these changes. According to Adams' testimony in Perdue v.
Mur-
phy, the two sketched out a "hybrid system" that would bring
back some aspects of the pre-automated FSSA process on a
napkin
ovet lunch.
Daniels continued to defend the automation experiment, in-
sisting that Indiana would not back down from high-tech
welfare
teform and that "over time this issue will resolve itself." But the
political winds had changed. Daniels was now the subject of
spec-
ulation about a presidential run, and the failed automation was
embarrassing to the state and to his administration. In Octo-
ber 2009, with his eye on a national audience, the governor did
something unexpected. He admitted that the experiment had
failed and canceled the contract with IBM, calling the project a
"flawed concept that simply did not work out in practice."
69. In May 2010, Indiana sued IBM for $437 million, claiming
breach
of contract. The state claimed that the automation experiment
led to faulty benefit denials that harmed needy Hoosiers, and
de-
manded that the company pay back the nearly half-billion
dollars
they had received for running the modernization plus damages
for lawsuits, federal penalties, and state employee overtime.
IBM
countersued for about $100 million for the server, hardware, au-
tomated processes, and software that the state was still using to
determine benefit eligibility. IBM won the suit, and was
awarded
more than $52 million.
"Neither party deserves to win this case," wrote Marion Supe-
rior Court Judge David Dreyer in his judgment in favor of IBM.
"This story represents a 'perfect storm' of misguided
government
policy and overzealous corporate ambition. Overall, both parties
are to blame and Indiana's taxpayers are left as apparent losers
... ,
70. There is nothing in this case, or the Court's power, ... [to]
remedy the lost taxpayer money or personal suffering of needy
Hoosiers."
AUTOMATING ELIGIBILITY IN TH.E HEARTLAND I 73
In its suit against IBM, the state charged that the company
had misrepresented its ability to modernize complicated social
service programs and failed to meet the performance standards
contained in the contract. Automated counties lagged behind
"as-is" counties in almost every area of performance:
timeliness,
backlogs, data integrity, determination errors, and number of
ap-
peals requested.
The state even accused IBM of jury-rigging its processes to
make its performance look better. "A major cause of the
dramatic
rise in appeals in the Modernized counties," the private
attorneys
hired to represent the state argued, "was that the IBM Coalition
workers were so far behind in processing applications that they
would often recommend denial of an application to make their
71. timeliness numbers look better, but then would tell the applicant
to
appeal the decision. While the appeal was pending, the
Coalition
workers would actually process the application and benefits
would
be granted before the hearing date." According to the suit, "for
the three-year period, IBM was achieving higher-than-projected
profit margins at the same time that its modernized system was
floundering."
IBM argued on the contrary: the state had consistently praised
their efforts. In May 2008, Secretary Roob reported to the Gen-
eral Assembly that, "We are serving more people statewide and
in
a timelier manner than we ever have before." 7 In December
2008
Governor Daniels stated that the new system "was far better
rhan
what preceded it." IBM admitted that there were problems with
managing overload in the new system. But the company claimed
the problems that arose were due to factors beyond its control.
The Great Recession, the new Healthy Indiana P~ogram, and the
72. 2008 floods had pushed application levels beyond what either
party had imagined.
Judge Dreyer saw incompetence and negligence on both sides.
He noted that the state invited IBM to keep working on the
74 I AUTOMATING lNE~ALITY
project even as they rolled our the hybrid system, which was
based on IBM's tools, software, and skills, But since the Senate
had stripped the FSSA budget "bare" in early 2009, there was no
money to pay for change orders or modifications to the con-
tract, Secretary Murphy wrote in an email to her colleagues that
IBM would "not commit ro moving forward at no cost, , , ,
[T]hey want more money! We don't have money now and we
won't have money for the remainder of [State Fiscal Year] '10,
What a mess," 8 When IBM refused to do more work without
more
pay, the stare simply cut out the middle man, terminating their
contract while keeping their equipment, processes, and subcon-
tractors in place.
73. The state and IBM both blamed forces out of their control for
the plan's collapse. But in reality the coalition delivered exactly
what Indiana officials had asked for: smaller welfare rolls,
what-
ever the cost.
In the lawsuit, both the state and IBM avoided talking much
about the impact of the failed automation experiment on rhe
people oflndiana, The state knew from the beginning that what
it was doing posed enormous risks for public assistance
recipients
and their families, The state identified "several areas of
potentially
significant risk" with the automated system, but "concluded that
'the status quo is not acceptable"' and moved forward with the
plan anyway,9
The goals of the project were consistent throughout the auto-
mation experiment: maximize efficiency and eliminate fraud by
shifting to a task-based system and severing caseworker-co-
client
bonds, They were clearly reflected in contract metrics: response
74. time in the call centers was a key performance indicator;
determi-
nation accuracy was not, Efficiency and savings were built into
the contract; transparency and due process were not,
Judge Dreyer found that the problem with the automation ex-
AUTOMATING ELIGrnILITY m THE HEARTLAND I 75
periment was not contractor negligence, 'There was no material
breach of the Indiana/IBM contract, "The heart of the contract
remained intact throughout the project," he concluded in his
find-
ings, "although sometimes beating irregularly," The state
achieved
its goal of containing the cost of social service programs, The
con-
tractor, accountable only to its employer and its shareholders,
had
no obligation to measure the automation experiment's impact
on poor and working-class Hoosiers, The problem with the auto-
mation experiment was not that the IBM/ ACS coalition failed
to
deliver, it was that the state and its private partners refused to
an-
75. ticipate or address the system1s human costs.
Afi:er an expensive series of appeals of Judge Dreyer's
decision,
in March 2016 the Indiana Supreme Court ruled that IBM did
in fact materially breach its contract with the state, But the
legal
case only seeks to apportion blame and levy penalties, Indiana
v,
IBM, as Judge Dreyer pointed out, was about material breach of
contract, not the public trust or public injury, The teal cost of
the privatization experiment-the loss of life-saving benefits for
struggling families, the cost of the contract and legal disputes to
taxpayers, and the weakening of the public service system and
democratic process-has yet to be calculated, It is perhaps incal-
culable,
"There's a cost to people," said Jamie Andree oflndiana Legal
Services, "The cost of just waiting around without Medicaid
ben-
efits is enormous; it's really hard to make somebody whole,
Most
people will stop getting medical care while eligibility is being
de-
termined, There's no way to compensate them for that,"
76. The state now uses the hybrid eligibility system, which
combines
face-to-face interactions with public employees with the
electronic
data processing and privatized administration of the automated
system, Its design allows applicants to contact a team of
regional
caseworkers assigned to their case by phone, by internet, by
mail,
76 AUTOMATING lNE~ALITY
or in person, providing increased contact with state workers.
But
the hybrid system still relies on privatized, automated processes
for many core functions and retains the task-based case manage-
ment that caused so many problems during the modernization.
In the hybrid system, re-staffed local offices function as
problem
resolution centers, while regional and statewide "change
centers"-run by Xerox, which bought ACS in 2009 for $6.4
billion-review applications, collect and digitize documents,
77. schedule appointments, screen applications for fraud, process
fair
hearing requests, provide a first point of contact for clients, and
perform most updates to cases.
The move to the hybrid system in 2009 certainly quieted the
automated system's most vocal detractors. But it is unclear if it
works better to secure benefits for those who deserve them.
"They
got marginally better when they ditched IBM and did the hybrid
thing," said Chris Holly in December 2014. "They got better for
people like me. People who help poor people have access to the
local office directly to solve problems. So they took care of us.
I
don't think they took care of the normal person. I won't say they
bought us off, but they responded to us. We were the ones that
were complaining the loudest."
Representative Gail Riecken of Evansville agreed with Holly
in an op-ed she wrote in the Fort Wayne journal Gazette in
May 2010. "[FSSA Secretary Anne] Murphy reported that fewer
people are filing appeals for mistakes and wrong decisions
[under
78. the hybrid system]. But it is not clear why the appeals have de-
creased. Is it because the system is better, or have people
simply
given up fighting the system?" 10
For some caseworkers, the hybrid system is just the automated
system with a different name. "I don't see any change," said
Jane
Porter Gresham. "We're still working mandatory overtime. We
still have the same number of people clamoring to be heard in
face-to-face interviews. The workload has not diminished ... ,
AUTOMATING ELIGIBIUTY JN TH.E HEARTLAND j 77
The people that were the most vocal had their needs mer." When
I asked her why we weren't hearing more about the problems of
the hybnd system, she replied, "Experienced workers who knew
how it was supposed to be aren't there any more." Glenn
Cardwell
retired FSSA worker and advocate agreed "veah" h 'd "w, ' '
, • 1. 1 , e sa1 , we re
not satisfied [with the hybrid system], but that's partly a matter
of
energy. We won a big battle, but we weren't ever sure we won
79. the
war."
, . '"I~~y set that system up to just slide stuff under the rug and
mde 1t, argu~d Kevin Stipes, Sophie's dad. "People [on public
as-
sistance] don t have a voice That's one of th
· e reasons we went
down [to the state house]." Kim chimed in, "To put a face on
it!"
Kevm nodded at his wife. "We didn't mind standing up," he
said.
But there were a lot of people who didn't know what to do, or
felt
too vulnerable to rally to their own defense "Myw·c · ·
. . . He 1s persistent,
mtelligent-1 mean, it should have been a breeze for her to get
the
paperwork turned in correctly. I just can't imagine people with
lesser skills ... I know they couldn't, they didn't do it."
"The system doesn't seem to be set up to help people. It seems
to be set up to play t h " 'd Ch · H 11 " . . go c a, sa1 ns o y. In
our legal system
1t 1s better that ten guilty men go free than one innocent man
go
to Jail. The modernization flipped that on its head." Automated
eligibility was based on the assumption that it is better for ten
eli-
gible applicants to be denied public benefits than for one
80. ineligi-
ble person to receive them. "They had an opportunity to make a
syste_m that was responsive and effective, and ensure people
who
qualified for benefits received those benefits," Holly said. "My
gut feelmg 1s that they did not respect the people who needed
their help."
In_the fall of 2008'. Omega Young of Evansville missed an ap-
pomtment to recemfy for Medicaid because she was in the
hospi-
tal suffenng from terminal cancer. The cancer that began in her
78 j AUTOMATING INE~A.UTY
ovaries had spread to her kidneys, breast, and liver. Her chemo·
therapy lefi: her weak and emaciated. Young, a round-faced,
umber-skinned mother of two grown sons, struggled to meet the
new system's requirements. She called the Vanderburgh County
Help Center to let them know that she was hospitalized. Her
medical benefits and food stamps were still cut off for failure to
cooperate.
"The SO-year-old Young, who lived alone in a tiny apartment,
81. was frantic," reported Will Higgins in the Indianapolis Star.
11
She
called Cecilia Brennan, a staffer with Evansville-based South-
western Indiana Regional Council on Aging who had been help-
'"Wh I . d >"' H ingwith her case, crying, asking, at am gomgto
o. er
sister, Christal Bell, refrained from telling the press that rhe
Medicaid denial hastened Young's death, bur she did blame the
automated system for making her last days full of extra worry
and
trouble. Her brother-in-law, Tom Willis, rnld Higgins that he
routinely hid Young's medical bills from her so she would nor
ob-
sess about the $10,000 she owed.
Because she lost her benefits, Young was unable to afford her
medications. She lost her food stamps. She struggled to pay her
rent.
She lost access co free transportation to medical appointments.
Omega Young died March 1, 2009. The next day, on March 2,
she
won her FSSA appeal for wrongful termination and her benefits
82. were restored.
The public welfare system has never been simple, particularly
for Black women. The most restrictive eligibility rules were his-
torically aimed at them. "Suitable home" and "employable
mother"
rules were selectively interpreted to block African American
women from claiming their benefits until the rise of rhe welfare
rights movement in the 1970s. "Man in house" and "substitute
father" rules legitimized intrusion into their privacy, judgment
of
their sexuality, and invasions of their homes. Ronald Reagan's
1976 stump speech about the lavish lifestyle of "welfare queen"
AUTOMATING ELIGIBILITY IN THE HEARTLAND I 79
Linda was intended to make the face of welfare both Black
and female. "There's a woman in Chicago," he said during the
New Hampshire Republican presidential primary contest. "She
has 80 names, 30 addresses, 12 Social Security cards and is col-
lecting veterans' benefits on four non-existing deceased hus-
bands. She's got Medicaid, getting food stamps and she is
83. collecting welfare under each of her names. Her tax-free cash
in-
come alone is over $150,000." 12 Ms. Taylor was eventually
charged
with using 4 aliases, not 80, and collecting $8,000, not
$150,000,
but Reagan's overblown claims found fertile ground, and the im-
age of the welfare queen has remained central to our country's
understanding of public assistance.
Even today, audit studies find rhat nonwhite applicants in
welfare offices face more unprofessional behavior from
casework-
ers than whites: withholding crucial information, refusing to
pro-
vide applications, and other forms of outright rudeness. 1'
States
with higher African American populations have tougher rules,
more stringent work requirements, and higher sanction rates.14
Casework is a complex, human endeavor that relies on relation-
ships, requires a difficult mix of canniness and compassion, and
is
vulnerable to all the biases about race, class, and gender that
are
84. woven through our society. Concerns about discretionary
excesses
are valid. Caseworkers do turn down individuals based on
bigotry
or unconscious bias.
The majority of public assistance recipients in Indiana are
white, but race still played a major role in the automation
experi-
ment. Governor Mitch Daniels played on rural-urban tensions
and white racial anxiety when he persistently framed problems
in
terms of dependency, cheating, criminality, and collusion
despite
evidence that only a small proportion of those eligible for
public
assistance benefits actually claimed them and that fraud was not
a
particularly severe problem at FSSA. The fraud case he held up
as
mdicative of the worst problems in the system-the Greater Faith
80 AUTOMATING INE~ALITY
Missionary Baptist scam-involved Black defendants, It's hard
85. not to suspect that Daniels, like his anti-AFDC mentor Ronald
Reagan, cagily stoked Hoosiers' stereotypes about race, class,
and public assistance to drum up support for the move to an au-
tomated, privatized welfare system,
The Indiana counties with the smallest African American
populations were transitioned to the automated system first, and
the experiment was halted before it reached Indianapolis and
Gary, the two cities a large share of Black Hoosiers call home,
But
despite being rested primarily on poor whites, the automation
experiment had profound impacts on African Americans, Ac-
cording to census data, in 2000, African Americans made up
465 percent of the state's TANF rolls, and whites held a very
slim
majority in the program, at 47,2 percent, At the end of the auto-
mation experiment in 2010, the gap between white and African
American TANF and food stamp/SNAP recipients had widened
precipitously, Despite the fact that the African American
popula-
tion of Indiana had grown over the decade, the TANF rolls were
86. now 54,2 percent white and only 32,l percent African American,
Though eligibility modernization was tested on primarily white
communities, Black families still felt its worst effects,
Removing human discretion from public assistance eligibility
may seem like a compelling solution to the continuing discrimi-
nation African Americans face in the welfare system, After all,
a
computer applies the rules to each case consistently and without
prejudice, But historically, the removal of human discretion and
the creation of inflexible rules in public services only
compound
racially disparate harms,
For example, in the 1980s and 1990s Congress and many
state legislatures enacted a series of "Tough on Crime" laws that
established mandatory minimum sentences for many categories
of crime and removed a great deal of discretion from judges,
Iron-
ically, the changes were a result of organizing both by
conserva-
AUTOMATING ELIGIBILITY IN TH.E HEARTLAND j 81
tive law-and-order types and by some progressive civil rights
87. acnv1sts who saw the bias in judicial discretion as creating
racially
disparate outcomes in sentencing.
The evidence of the past 30 years is clear: racial disparity in
the criminal justice system is a great deal worse, As the Leader-
ship Conference on Civil and Human Rights wrote in a 2000 re-
port called "Justice on Trial," "Minorities fare much worse
under
mandatory sentencing laws and guidelines than they did under a
system favoring judicial discretion, By depriving judges of the
ul-
timate authority to impose just sentences, mandatory sentencing
laws and guidelines put sentencing on auto-pilot,"15
Automated decision-making can change government for the
better, and tracking program data may, in fact, help identify pat-
terns of biased decision-making. But justice sometimes requires
an ability to bend the rules, By removing human discretion from
frondine social servants and moving it instead to engineers and
private contractors, the Indiana experiment supercharged dis-
88. crimination.
The "social specs" for the automation were based on time-
worn, race- and class-motivated assumptions about welfare
recipi-
ents that were encoded into performance metrics and
programmed
into business processes: they are lazy and must be "prodded"
into
contributing to their own support, they are sneaky and prone to
fraudulent claims, and their burdensome use of public resources
must be repeatedly discouraged, Each of these assumptions
relies
on, and is bolstered by, race- and class-based stereotypes, Poor
Black women like Omega Young paid the price,
New high-tech tools allow for more precise measuring and
track-
ing, better sharing of information, and increased visibility of
tar-
geted populations, In a system dedicated to supporting poor and
working-class people's self-determination, such diligence would
guarantee that they attain all the benefits they are entitled to by
89. 82 AUTOMATING INE~ALlTY
law. In that context, integrated data and modernized administra-
tion would not necessarily result in bad outcomes for poor com-
munities. But automated decision-making in our current welfare
system acts a lot like older, atavistic forms of punishment and
con-
tainment. It filters and diverts. It is a gatekeeper, not a
facilitator.
The Indiana automated eligibility system enhanced the state's
already well-developed diversion apparatus, turbo-charging
what
must be seen as a remarkably efficient machine for denying
appli-
cations. By narrowing the gate for public benefits and raising
the
penalties for noncompliance, it achieved stunning welfare roll
re-
ductions. Even under the hybrid system and during the greatest
economic downturn since the Great Depression, drops in the
state's TANF caseload continued to outpace national averages.
As poverty in Indiana increased, caseloads dropped. When the
90. governor signed the contract with IBM in 2006, 38 percent of
poor families with children were receiving cash benefits from
TANF. By 2014, the number had dropped to 8 percent.
Struggling people like Omega Young, Lindsay Kidwell, and
Shelli Birden were the first victims of the automation, and they
bore the system's most terrifying impacts. Though the Stipes
family managed against incredible odds to reestablish their
daughter's Medicaid, the experience took a dreadful toll.
"During
that time, my mind was muddled because it was so stressful,"
said Kim Stipes. ''All my focus was getting Sophie back on that
Medicaid. Then crying afterwards because everybody was
calling
us white trash, moochers. It was like being sucked into this vac-
uum of nothingness."
In the seven years between the Stipes' battle with the automa-
tion experiment and my visit, Sophie's life improved: She
gained
weight, learned sign language, went to school and made friends,
But eight days after I interviewed the family in their Tipton
91. home, Dan Skinner sent me an email. "Sad news," it read. "Kim
Stipes called and told me that little Sophie died. She had been
AUTOMATING ELIGIBILITY IN THE HEARTLAND I 83
sic~ and throwing up on Friday and when rhey found her dead
;:i ;u;ay she was curled up in a fetal position looking peace-
. e octor said her heart simply stopped."
. _In the end, the Indiana automation experiment was a form of
d1g1tal d1vers1on for poor and working A . I d .
b rnencans. t en1ed them
enefirs, due process, dignity, and life itself "W, .
. . fi . we were not invest-
mg m our ellow human beings the way we should be," said John
Cardwell of The Generations Proiect "We were b . ll .
I , · as1ca y saying
to a arge percentage of people in Indiana •v ' h
h 'Wh ' wu te nonvon a
s it. at a horrible waste of humanity."
812912019 Print Display - Summary of the lmmigration Reform
and Control Act (Simpson-M azzoli Act, 1 986) - Poliiical,
Government & Court Docum ...
From ABC-CLIO's The Latino American Experience website
https://latinoamerican2.abc-clio.com/
92. SUMMARY OF THE IMMIGRATION REFORM AND
CONTROL ACT
(stM PSON-MAZZOL| ACT, 1 986)
The lmmigration Reform and Control Act of 1986 (IRCA)
sought to limit and manage the number of undocumented
immigrants in the LJnited
States. The act established penalties for employers who
knowingly hired undocumented workers; created a temporary
worker program;
barred discrimination based on rmmigration status; and granted
amnestyto undocumented immigrants who had arrived in the
U.S. before
1982 and could prove they had lived in the U.S. continuously
for five or more years. ln addition, refugees and other special
categories of
immigrants were exempted from immigration quotas. The IRCA,
also known as the Simpson-Mazzoli Act, amended the
lmmigration and
Nationality Act of 7 965. After the 7 965 act was passed,
immigration increased. Some raised concerns that
undocumented immigrants were
taking jobs from U.S. citizens and having a negative impact on
wages. Meanwhile, nativists in the U.S. pushed for anti-
immigration laws and
campaigned against bilingual education and affirmative action
and for English-only laws. ln response to such concerns, the
Select
Commission on lmmigration and Refugee Policy Commission
was established in 1978. Recommendations from the
commission's 7 981
report laid the groundwork for some of the provisions in the
IRCA. The following is an excerpt of the IRCA.
SUMMARY AS OF:
93. 1O/14/1986-Conference report filed in House. (There are 4
other summaries)
(Conference report filed in House, H, Rept. 99-1000)
IMMIGRATION REFORM AND CONTROL ACT OF .I985
Title l: Control of lllegal lmmigration-Part A: Employment-
Amends the lmmigration and Nationality Act to make it
unlawful for a person or
other entity to: (1) hire (including through subcontractors),
recruit, or refer for a fee for U.S. employment any alien
knowing that such person
is unauthorized to work, or any person without verifying his or
her work status; or (2) continue to employ an alien knowing of
such person's
u nauthorized work status.
Makes verification compliance (including the use of State
employment agency documentation) an affirmative defense to
any hiring or
referral violation.
Establishes an employment verification system. Requires: (1)
the employer to attest, on a form developed by the Attorney
General, that the
employee's work status has been verified by examination of a
passport, birth certificate, social security card, alien
documentation papers, or
other proof; (2) the worker to similarly attest that he or she is a
U.S. citizen or national, or authorized alien; and (3) the
employer to keep
such records for three years in the case of referral or
recruitment, or the later of three years or one year after
employment termination in
the case of hiring.
94. States that nothing in this Act shall be construed to authorize a
national identity card or system.
Directs the President to monitor and evaluate the verification
system and implement changes as necessary within 60 days after
notifying the
appropriate congressional committees (within two years for a
major change). Prohibits implementation of a major change
unless the
Congress provides funds for such purpose. Authorizes related
demonstration projects of up to three years.
Limits the use of such verification system or any required
identification document to enforcing this Act and not for other
law enforcement
purposes.
Directs the Attorney General to establish complaint and
investigation procedures which shall provide for: (1) individuals
and entities to file
written, signed complaints regarding potential hiringviolations;
(2) INS investigations of complaintswith substantial
probabllityof validity; (3)
Department ofJustice-initiated investigations; and (4)
designation of a specific INS unitto prosecute such violations.
Sets forth employer sanction provisions. Provides for a six-
month period of public education during which no employment
violation
penalties shall be imposed.
Provides for a subsequent 12-month period during which
violators shall be issued warning citations. Defers enforcement
for seasonal
agricultural services.
95. Provides, at the end of such citation period, for graduated first-
and subsequent-offense civil penalties, injunctive remedies, or
criminal
penalties (for pattern of practice violations). Subjects violators
to graduated civil penalties for related paperwork violations.
Directs the Attorney General to provide notice and, upon
request, an administrative hearing in the case of a disputed
penalty. States that: (1)
judicial review of a final administrative penalty shall be in the
U.S, court of appeals; and (2) suits to collect unpaid penalties
shall be filed in
U.S. district courts.
https://latinoamerican2.abc-
clio.com/Search/Display/1449563?terms=1986
immigration&webSiteCode=SLN_LAE_AC&returnToPage=%2f
Searcho/o2fD... 116
812912019 Print Display - Summary of the lmmigration Reform
and Control Act (Simpson-M azzoli Acl, 1986) - Political,
Government & Court Docum...
Makes it unlawful for an employer to require an employee to
provide any type of financial guarantee or indemnity against
any potential
employment liability. Subjects violators, after notice and
hearing opportunity, to a civil penalty for each violation and the
return of any such
amounts received.
States that such employer sanction provisions preempt State and
local laws.
96. Requires the General Accounting Office (GAO) to submit to the
Congress and to a specially created task force three annual
reports regarding
the operation of the employersanction program, lncludinga
determlnation of whethera pattern of national origin
discrimination has
resulted. States that if the GAO report makes such a
determination: ('l ) the task force shall so report to the
Congress; and (2) the House and
the Senate shall hold hearings within 60 days.
Terminates employer sanctions 30 days after receipt of the last
GAO report if: (1) GAO finds a wldespread pattern of
discrimination has
resulted from the employer sanctions; and (2) the Congress
enacts a joint resolution within such 30-day period approving
such findings.
Amends the Migrant and Seasonal Agricultural Worker
Protection Actto subjectfarm labor contractors to the
requirements of this Act,
beginning seven months after enactment.
Directs the Attorney General, in consultation with the Secretary
of Labor and the Secretary of Health and Human Services, to
conduct a study
of the use of a telephone system to verify the employment status
of job applicants. Requires related congressional reports.
Directs the Comptroller General to: (1) investigate ways to
reduce counterfeiting of social security account number cards;
and (2) report to
the appropriate congressional committees within one year.
Directs the Secretary of Health and Human Services, acting
97. through the Social Security Administration and in cooperation
with the Attorney
General and the Secretary of Labor, to: (1) conduct a study of
the feasibility of establishing a social security number
validation system; and
(2) report to the appropriate congressional committees within
two years.
Makes it an unfair immigration-related employment practice for
an employer of three or more persons to discriminate against
any individual
(other than an unauthorized alien) with respect to hiring,
recruitment, firing, or referral for fee, because of such
individual's origin or
citizenship (or intended citizenship) status. States that it is not
an unfair immigration-related employment practice to hire a
U.S. citizen or
national over an equally qualified alien.
Requires that complaints of violations of an immigration-related
employment practice be filed with the Special Counsel for
lmmigration-
Related Unfair Employment Practices (established by this Act)
within the Department of Justice. Prohibits the overlap of
immigration-related
discrimination complaints and discrimination complaints filed
with the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission.
Authorizes the Special Counsel to: (1) investigate complaints
and determine (within '1 20 days) whether to bring such
complaints before a
speciallytrained administrative law judge; and (2) initiate
investigations and complaints. Permits private actions if the
Special Counsel does
not file a complaint within such 120-day period. Sets forth
related administrative provisions.