•““
  “”
                                ’‘‘ …“ Œ Vv Ž…“ Œ V„
                                fff€f¦©f¦haR ‹
                                    Љˆ ‡w†…q{y xf–€~}q{y xv
                                            |z w„ ƒ‚ |z w
                             ™kus¤qDD¤Df¦W¤k¦S¦f¦™
                               to r po j d d n m g h l j i h g e d
                               †Prv — pU†P…“ • ”U“v
                               S–¦©˜–SafESf¦4’
        PWS'DaSF‡DW%W‚€y¢wSStsqDSqQhf4%caYW¦SSQI
           r P ‘ e‰R ˆ † … „ e ƒ U xv P x vu P p U P U r P p i gR e d b `X V U T R P
                  £5GG 8 7¨  $!C !3  8 7¨ 5$!$33
                  '4¦'©HFEE'D#BA@96%4'$
          2  1$0  )!£¡  £¨$¡ ! £ ¥  ¡ £¨£ ¥£¡
           §¤©©¤('%# §©©§¦¤¢ 
•“Ð
  “”
                                  † v ƒv›P“PÈ ‘P„”U” › šr„P“Rr vR ›Ï†
                                   ¦cWSWS–aSS‡˜DDaWSf¦É˜ƒ
           PUrP ƒP†‰U v“È Pvrre† v“U‰Ur v“›rU”Îv† v„“eRP ƒ …„U v“„”v
           SfSchhSS¦WfÇf–ff¦WSqD¦WkaSqDh¦qDSc°k–¦–Daf©Í
                                   bPrP ‘e‰Rˆ er š”v“Èv† P šr xv ‘‰v
                                   fWS'fSÌ–SfWf¦assfˁ'Sf4Ê
                           PqDS¤haSS¦WfÉfWfD¦WkSSf¦WakS‡Ça¦–WfSQÆ
                             UrP ƒP†‰U v“È Pvrre† v“U‰Ur v“›rU” U v† v„“eRP
                                                                          » h€aa
                                                                            ½¤Ã©Ÿ©
                     ¡¨ ½¤ Ũ Á  ©ž ­ ž«žŸ ¨¡© ¦©Ÿ¯  ¡© ¦¤ ¦ º ­ ½ ª
                     fch§®¾f¦¾a¯sWaqaa§ q%Wh9a%D%©c§hž · Ä
                            »© ¡ ¢¤ §¤ ¯ ¢¨¡ ¢¤ §¤§ ¶  ¨ ½¤Ã©Ÿ© ž ¦© §
                            q¨–a–§¬¢–ahx–¾W¨ chh€aa BhxW¨ Â
                    »'hxW§ ©qa§–x¬Wa®¦hW¡ –hqfDc¢qh%©À
                      ­ ¦© §¨ ¨¡ ¢¤  ¤§ ©¤¡ Áž¸ž ©¤¡¡© Á© ½ ­¯ ¢§ ©© ¦
                » q¡qWqf#Waf¸af¤ ·  %f¿­'hxW#qkahxqx¾WDh¼
                   ©¨ ž§¨¤ ©¤¡ ©¡ ©© ¦¨ ¦© §¨§ ©¨¡ ¢¤ §¤§ ©¤ ½ ªž
                                         » ºf–a –§yWaa'¹fafaf¤ ·
                                             ¨ ¡ ¢ ¤ § ¤ ž¯  §© ª ¤ ¡ ¦ ¤¥ ¤ ¡ ¸ © ¡
        ¶ W¨µ´k±f4–± ¯°Wf¬ªa%Bhx§W9hž'¦'qqDhqqDhWaqaqœ
                  ³ ² ®  ­ «  © ¤ ¦ ž ¦©  ¨§ ¢ ¡ ¦žŸ¥ ¤Ÿ £ ¢ž¡ žŸ ž 
                                                         ‘P„”U” › šr… geP“ … gP ƒv
                                                         SqaqSs˜fqBW¢Bhc‚™
                                                                 ¡  ¥8£!£3 7 £5G
                                                                  #BD˜'˜—E'4¦' –
•“Û
  “”
                   ­¦ÙØcqf¤¬9¤xW§až · D6–hff¦Wah§–fa–x–BÚ
                     Á ¦Ÿ × ¯  ® Á© ž¶ ¤ ½ ©¤¡¸¨ Á«ž  ® ¨¤Ÿ §¤
                       ¯ ½¤Ã Ÿ© © §¨§ ¯ ž ÁØ ¦ Ÿ ¤ × Õ ÖÕ ¨ Á ž¡ Ÿ©
                        f¤Dhx©hWh°©%¦WWyFfÙcqf¬6{‚¦yq¤Ä
                                         ÁØ ¦ Ÿ ¤ × Õ ÖÕ ® § ¤¡ ¡© Áž¯ ¨
                                         Ù%–D#F6{QW–aWafhf¯ · Ô
                                        PrP ‘e‰Rˆ er š”v“Èv† P šr xv ‘‰v
                                        WS'fSÌ–SfWf¦assfˁ'Sf4Ê
                                           e†„”… gP„e‰eR v ƒ P šrpU gŒe
                                           DaaBhq–¦csfkBq–q„
        Ó† v ƒv›P“PÈ U gP ƒv ‘ † …„”vrrU„”U ÓeRU„re ‘P” ÓPUrP gP ƒP“
        q¦¤–SWÇBhc'Ì¢DafWDkkaqsfDWf©SSqfS¦hchWfÈ ‹
                                                                           Ñ Ò
                                                                            YfÑ
•“” à
  “
                                                                          © ÁØ ¦ Ÿ ¤
                                                                           Sqcqf¬×
         ¨y¯f¤D½hÃxhŸWh9©%¦W§W§ · – –D•¤¦hQf¨ · f'qfc6––W%f–©Ú
                 ¤ © © ©  ¨ ¦ ¨Ÿ ¥ Áž º §©¸¨ ¦ž¡¨ ½ ® ¨¡© ¦¨Ÿ
                             ¯ ½¤ © © ¦  §¨§ ¯ ž ÁØ ¦ Ÿ ¤ × Õ Ö ß ¨ Á ž¡ Ÿ©
                              f¤DhÃxhŸWh°©%W©WyFfÙcqf¬6%¦yq¤Ä
                                                ÁØ ¦ Ÿ ¤ × Õ Ö ß ® § ¤¡ ¡© Áž¯ ¨
                                                Ù%–D#F6%¬W–aWafhf¯ · Ô
                                               PrP ‘e‰Rˆ er š”v“Èv† P šr xv ‘‰v
                                               WS'fSÌ–SfWf¦assfˁ'Sf4Ê
                           Ý P gP ƒv ‘ U R “ P† v“ È ‘ „ U “ vu ge Ý U R ”P p U ‘ e r U
                            S¦hc'ÇSfSa¦WfÞk–f¦ÙBskSSSk6D–˜ƒ
         Ó† v ƒv›P“PÈ U gP ƒv ‘ † …„”vrrU„”U ÓeRU„re ‘P” ÓPUrP gP ƒP“
         q¦¤–SWÇBhc'Ì¢DafWDkkaqsfDWf©SSqfS¦hchWfÈ ‹
                                                                                          Ñ YÒ Ü
•“” ä
  “
         PrP ‘e‰Rˆ er š”v“Èv† P šr xv ‘‰v
         WS'fSÌ–SfWf¦assfˁ'Sf4Ê
                                            ã â
                                             µ€á
•“ì
  “”
               » º¨ëžŸ©¤ ©¨¡©¡© ¦¨Ÿ ¨ ©¨¡©¤Ÿ §¤
                Dffqaf#–WhW%f–q˰qWa–x–a
                     PrP ‘e‰Rˆ er š”v“Èv† P šr xv ‘‰v
                     WS'fSÌ–SfWf¦assfˁ'Sf4Ê
        ÝUTe“PÈv PUrPrP ‘U“È ÓPUrP êv“ÈÏ ÓPUrPv“„”v
        ¦fqSW¦ËSfSWS'ffsSqfS°¦WfD%SqfSf–Daf©Í
                                                        è è æ
                                                         éEçå
•“” ù
  “
              ÷fD¤hD YqØhWaŸf–#a€–x¦až · Dy–xxDhq
                Ø¡ Ÿ ¤ § ø ¡ ž «¤ ¯÷ ž¯ §® Á© ž¶ ¤ ½ ¨ §©¯ ¤Ÿ
         ¨¦¨ a· ¤xqhŸDaa¡Ëqk½Q¦Á€hõ©F–x¦xhaž · DWq¦afó
           Á ö §¤ «ž ¡ž ¨ § ô ž¯ §® Á© ž¶ ¤ ½ ® ¨¡ Á¤¤
                                 PrP ‘e‰Rˆ er š”v“Èv† P šr xv ‘‰v
                                 WS'fSÌ–SfWf¦assfˁ'Sf4Ê
                       ñ 0 ò 5 ñ ¨ ð ¥3£¨ G £¨£ ¡$5G ¥£!
                        #k#˜Þ¬Þ˜4¡ B'˜ïî''§k©¦§¦˜tí
•“ý
  “”
                      © ¦ Ÿ º ¤¡® Áž ¦ Ÿ ¤ Ø ÁØ ¦ Ÿ ¤ × ¨  §©¯ ¨ Ÿ
                       %–D¤¬× fah–Dh¡ · SÙcqf¬°–xhxf–©Ú
             ÷fD¤hD YqØhWažf–#a€–x¦až · Dy–xxDhq
               Ø¡ Ÿ ¤ § ø ¡  Ÿ«¤ ¯÷ ž¯ §® Á© ž¶ ¤ ½ ¨ §©¯ ¤Ÿ
        ¨¦¨ a· ¤xqhŸDaa¡Ëqk½Q¨¦€hõ©F–x¦xhaž · DWq¦afó
          Á ö §¤ «ž ¡ž Á§ ô ž¯ §® Á© ž¶ ¤ ½ ® ¨¡ Á¤ ¤
                                 PrP ‘e‰Rˆ er š”v“Èv† P šr xv ‘‰v
                                 WS'fSÌ–SfWf¦assfˁ'Sf4Ê
                               P ‘“v ü R PUrP ƒP†U“È ÓPUrPgP ƒP“
                                'f¦ESfSchhffsSqfS¦hchWfÈ ‹
                                                                     û ú á
                                                                      ÇEè
“”
•“
         ©§¥fa– aŸ · D¤ · Sf6–fa–x –BÚ
           ¨¦ ¤ º¤¡ © ¡ ¢Á½ ® ¨¤Ÿ §¤
           PrP ‘e‰Rˆ er š”v“Èv† P šr xv ‘‰v
           WS'fSÌ–SfWf¦assfˁ'Sf4Ê
                               ¢PUrPv“„”v
                               £qfSf–Daf©Í
         8 2   5$  5¡$ ÿ )$!C ñ 0G£ò¨£ ¥£¡ 
         §€¢¡%‚#˜¾'Dþ§''c''§¤¤#Ëí
“”
•““
              PrP ‘e‰Rˆ er š”v“Èv† P šr xv ‘‰v
              WS'fSÌ–SfWf¦assfˁ'Sf4Ê
          7¨   ñ ¨¨£ò ¨$!C  ñ£ £ ¥  0G 
          #xC #'''D#H©¦§B€H'©#Ëí
•“h•““
  “”
                                 ­Ÿ© ¦¨ŸŸ ¡ © ­ ª¤
                                 –W%fq–qWaf¤ · Bq¡ a6(
              ­'©hx§W§°faqqkÇffë · W–a#–fa–x–BÚ
                ¦   ¨ º¤¡¡ž ½ ø¨ žŸ §«ž ® ¨¤Ÿ §¤
                         PrP ‘e‰Rˆ er š”v“Èv† P šr xv ‘‰v
                         WS'fSÌ–SfWf¦assfˁ'Sf4Ê
          10$!5G #! 7!£ !3!5¨
          '§''6¦s%$©€6B#k0             $¡ 5G £5£ ¥
                                              %6¦¤ 4¦§˜4¡ –

20071104 verification konev_lecture14

  • 1.
    •““ “” ’‘‘ …“ Œ Vv Ž…“ Œ V„ fff€f¦©f¦haR ‹ Љˆ ‡w†…q{y xf–€~}q{y xv |z w„ ƒ‚ |z w ™kus¤qDD¤Df¦W¤k¦S¦f¦™ to r po j d d n m g h l j i h g e d †Prv — pU†P…“ • ”U“v S–¦©˜–SafESf¦4’ PWS'DaSF‡DW%W‚€y¢wSStsqDSqQhf4%caYW¦SSQI r P ‘ e‰R ˆ † … „ e ƒ U xv P x vu P p U P U r P p i gR e d b `X V U T R P £5GG 8 7¨ $!C !3 8 7¨ 5$!$33 '4¦'©HFEE'D#BA@96%4'$ 2 1$0 )!£¡ £¨$¡ ! £ ¥ ¡ £¨£ ¥£¡ §¤©©¤('%# §©©§¦¤¢ 
  • 2.
    •“Ð “” † v ƒv›P“PÈ ‘P„”U” › šr„P“Rr vR ›Ï† ¦cWSWS–aSS‡˜DDaWSf¦É˜ƒ PUrP ƒP†‰U v“È Pvrre† v“U‰Ur v“›rU”Îv† v„“eRP ƒ …„U v“„”v SfSchhSS¦WfÇf–ff¦WSqD¦WkaSqDh¦qDSc°k–¦–Daf©Í bPrP ‘e‰Rˆ er š”v“Èv† P šr xv ‘‰v fWS'fSÌ–SfWf¦assfˁ'Sf4Ê PqDS¤haSS¦WfÉfWfD¦WkSSf¦WakS‡Ça¦–WfSQÆ UrP ƒP†‰U v“È Pvrre† v“U‰Ur v“›rU” U v† v„“eRP » h€aa ½¤Ã©Ÿ© ¡¨ ½¤ Ũ Á  ©ž ­ ž«žŸ ¨¡© ¦©Ÿ¯  ¡© ¦¤ ¦ º ­ ½ ª fch§®¾f¦¾a¯sWaqaa§ q%Wh9a%D%©c§hž · Ä »© ¡ ¢¤ §¤ ¯ ¢¨¡ ¢¤ §¤§ ¶  ¨ ½¤Ã©Ÿ© ž ¦© § q¨–a–§¬¢–ahx–¾W¨ chh€aa BhxW¨  »'hxW§ ©qa§–x¬Wa®¦hW¡ –hqfDc¢qh%©À ­ ¦© §¨ ¨¡ ¢¤  ¤§ ©¤¡ Áž¸ž ©¤¡¡© Á© ½ ­¯ ¢§ ©© ¦ » q¡qWqf#Waf¸af¤ ·  %f¿­'hxW#qkahxqx¾WDh¼ ©¨ ž§¨¤ ©¤¡ ©¡ ©© ¦¨ ¦© §¨§ ©¨¡ ¢¤ §¤§ ©¤ ½ ªž » ºf–a –§yWaa'¹fafaf¤ · ¨ ¡ ¢ ¤ § ¤ ž¯  §© ª ¤ ¡ ¦ ¤¥ ¤ ¡ ¸ © ¡ ¶ W¨µ´k±f4–± ¯°Wf¬ªa%Bhx§W9hž'¦'qqDhqqDhWaqaqœ ³ ² ®  ­ «  © ¤ ¦ ž ¦©  ¨§ ¢ ¡ ¦žŸ¥ ¤Ÿ £ ¢ž¡ žŸ ž  ‘P„”U” › šr… geP“ … gP ƒv SqaqSs˜fqBW¢Bhc‚™ ¡ ¥8£!£3 7 £5G #BD˜'˜—E'4¦' –
  • 3.
    •“Û “” ­¦ÙØcqf¤¬9¤xW§až · D6–hff¦Wah§–fa–x–BÚ Á ¦Ÿ × ¯  ® Á© ž¶ ¤ ½ ©¤¡¸¨ Á«ž  ® ¨¤Ÿ §¤ ¯ ½¤Ã Ÿ© © §¨§ ¯ ž ÁØ ¦ Ÿ ¤ × Õ ÖÕ ¨ Á ž¡ Ÿ© f¤Dhx©hWh°©%¦WWyFfÙcqf¬6{‚¦yq¤Ä ÁØ ¦ Ÿ ¤ × Õ ÖÕ ® § ¤¡ ¡© Áž¯ ¨ Ù%–D#F6{QW–aWafhf¯ · Ô PrP ‘e‰Rˆ er š”v“Èv† P šr xv ‘‰v WS'fSÌ–SfWf¦assfˁ'Sf4Ê e†„”… gP„e‰eR v ƒ P šrpU gŒe DaaBhq–¦csfkBq–q„ Ó† v ƒv›P“PÈ U gP ƒv ‘ † …„”vrrU„”U ÓeRU„re ‘P” ÓPUrP gP ƒP“ q¦¤–SWÇBhc'Ì¢DafWDkkaqsfDWf©SSqfS¦hchWfÈ ‹ Ñ Ò YfÑ
  • 4.
    •“” à “ © ÁØ ¦ Ÿ ¤ Sqcqf¬× ¨y¯f¤D½hÃxhŸWh9©%¦W§W§ · – –D•¤¦hQf¨ · f'qfc6––W%f–©Ú ¤ © © ©  ¨ ¦ ¨Ÿ ¥ Áž º §©¸¨ ¦ž¡¨ ½ ® ¨¡© ¦¨Ÿ ¯ ½¤ © © ¦  §¨§ ¯ ž ÁØ ¦ Ÿ ¤ × Õ Ö ß ¨ Á ž¡ Ÿ© f¤DhÃxhŸWh°©%W©WyFfÙcqf¬6%¦yq¤Ä ÁØ ¦ Ÿ ¤ × Õ Ö ß ® § ¤¡ ¡© Áž¯ ¨ Ù%–D#F6%¬W–aWafhf¯ · Ô PrP ‘e‰Rˆ er š”v“Èv† P šr xv ‘‰v WS'fSÌ–SfWf¦assfˁ'Sf4Ê Ý P gP ƒv ‘ U R “ P† v“ È ‘ „ U “ vu ge Ý U R ”P p U ‘ e r U S¦hc'ÇSfSa¦WfÞk–f¦ÙBskSSSk6D–˜ƒ Ó† v ƒv›P“PÈ U gP ƒv ‘ † …„”vrrU„”U ÓeRU„re ‘P” ÓPUrP gP ƒP“ q¦¤–SWÇBhc'Ì¢DafWDkkaqsfDWf©SSqfS¦hchWfÈ ‹ Ñ YÒ Ü
  • 5.
    •“” ä “ PrP ‘e‰Rˆ er š”v“Èv† P šr xv ‘‰v WS'fSÌ–SfWf¦assfˁ'Sf4Ê ã â µ€á
  • 6.
    •“ì “” » º¨ëžŸ©¤ ©¨¡©¡© ¦¨Ÿ ¨ ©¨¡©¤Ÿ §¤ Dffqaf#–WhW%f–q˰qWa–x–a PrP ‘e‰Rˆ er š”v“Èv† P šr xv ‘‰v WS'fSÌ–SfWf¦assfˁ'Sf4Ê ÝUTe“PÈv PUrPrP ‘U“È ÓPUrP êv“ÈÏ ÓPUrPv“„”v ¦fqSW¦ËSfSWS'ffsSqfS°¦WfD%SqfSf–Daf©Í è è æ éEçå
  • 7.
    •“” ù “ ÷fD¤hD YqØhWaŸf–#a€–x¦až · Dy–xxDhq Ø¡ Ÿ ¤ § ø ¡ ž «¤ ¯÷ ž¯ §® Á© ž¶ ¤ ½ ¨ §©¯ ¤Ÿ ¨¦¨ a· ¤xqhŸDaa¡Ëqk½Q¦Á€hõ©F–x¦xhaž · DWq¦afó Á ö §¤ «ž ¡ž ¨ § ô ž¯ §® Á© ž¶ ¤ ½ ® ¨¡ Á¤¤ PrP ‘e‰Rˆ er š”v“Èv† P šr xv ‘‰v WS'fSÌ–SfWf¦assfˁ'Sf4Ê ñ 0 ò 5 ñ ¨ ð ¥3£¨ G £¨£ ¡$5G ¥£! #k#˜Þ¬Þ˜4¡ B'˜ïî''§k©¦§¦˜tí
  • 8.
    •“ý “” © ¦ Ÿ º ¤¡® Áž ¦ Ÿ ¤ Ø ÁØ ¦ Ÿ ¤ × ¨  §©¯ ¨ Ÿ %–D¤¬× fah–Dh¡ · SÙcqf¬°–xhxf–©Ú ÷fD¤hD YqØhWažf–#a€–x¦až · Dy–xxDhq Ø¡ Ÿ ¤ § ø ¡  Ÿ«¤ ¯÷ ž¯ §® Á© ž¶ ¤ ½ ¨ §©¯ ¤Ÿ ¨¦¨ a· ¤xqhŸDaa¡Ëqk½Q¨¦€hõ©F–x¦xhaž · DWq¦afó Á ö §¤ «ž ¡ž Á§ ô ž¯ §® Á© ž¶ ¤ ½ ® ¨¡ Á¤ ¤ PrP ‘e‰Rˆ er š”v“Èv† P šr xv ‘‰v WS'fSÌ–SfWf¦assfˁ'Sf4Ê P ‘“v ü R PUrP ƒP†U“È ÓPUrPgP ƒP“ 'f¦ESfSchhffsSqfS¦hchWfÈ ‹ û ú á ÇEè
  • 9.
    “” •“ ©§¥fa– aŸ · D¤ · Sf6–fa–x –BÚ ¨¦ ¤ º¤¡ © ¡ ¢Á½ ® ¨¤Ÿ §¤ PrP ‘e‰Rˆ er š”v“Èv† P šr xv ‘‰v WS'fSÌ–SfWf¦assfˁ'Sf4Ê ¢PUrPv“„”v £qfSf–Daf©Í 8 2   5$ 5¡$ ÿ )$!C ñ 0G£ò¨£ ¥£¡ §€¢¡%‚#˜¾'Dþ§''c''§¤¤#Ëí
  • 10.
    “” •““ PrP ‘e‰Rˆ er š”v“Èv† P šr xv ‘‰v WS'fSÌ–SfWf¦assfˁ'Sf4Ê 7¨ ñ ¨¨£ò ¨$!C ñ£ £ ¥ 0G #xC #'''D#H©¦§B€H'©#Ëí
  • 11.
    •“h•““ “” ­Ÿ© ¦¨ŸŸ ¡ © ­ ª¤ –W%fq–qWaf¤ · Bq¡ a6( ­'©hx§W§°faqqkÇffë · W–a#–fa–x–BÚ ¦   ¨ º¤¡¡ž ½ ø¨ žŸ §«ž ® ¨¤Ÿ §¤ PrP ‘e‰Rˆ er š”v“Èv† P šr xv ‘‰v WS'fSÌ–SfWf¦assfˁ'Sf4Ê 10$!5G #! 7!£ !3!5¨ '§''6¦s%$©€6B#k0 $¡ 5G £5£ ¥ %6¦¤ 4¦§˜4¡ –