Health Informatics - transforming 
healthcare delivery in Hong Kong 
NT Cheung 
Head (IT & HI) / CMIO, HK Hospital Authority 
Consultant(eHealth), HK Government 
1 
1
Total 
Expenditure 
on 
Health 
as 
Percentage 
of 
GDP 
% 
16 
14 
12 
10 
8 
6 
4 
2 
1991 1993 1995 1997 1999 2001 2003 2005 
USA 
France 
New 
Zealand 
Sweden 
UK 
Australia 
Japan 
5.4% 
= 
2.4% 
+ 
3.0% 
GDP Public Private 
Hong 
Kong 
2011 
Year 
2007 2009 
18 
2011 
Sources: (1) Census and Sta2s2cs Department, 2011 GDP 
(2) OECD Health Data October 2012 2 
2
Walker et al, “The Value Of Health Care 
Information Exchange And Interoperability” 
Health Affairs 2005 
“…net savings from national implementation 
of fully standardized interoperability between 
providers… could yield $77.8 billion annually” 
“…We suspect that the clinical payoff in im-proved 
patient safety and quality of care could 
dwarf the financial benefits projected…” 
3 
3
Key Message 
A standardised eHealth system can achieve 
better, safer, more efficient care delivery 
on an industrial scale at a reasonable cost 
4
HA IT Services Hospital Authority 
❑ Established 1991 
❑ 42 Public Hospitals 
❑ 47 Specialist Outpatient Clinics (SOPD) 
❑ 73 General Outpatient Clinics (GOPC) 
❑ Close to 27,500 Beds 
❑ Around 67,600 Staff 
❑ Around 22,700 Nurses 
❑ Around 5,700 Doctors 
❑ Around HK$ 46b Annual Operating 
Budget (~US$6 billion) 
❑ 6.10m GOPC Attendances 
❑ 9.37m SOPD Attendances 
❑ 2.24m A&E Attendances 
❑ 1.57m Inpatient and Day Patient 
Discharges 
New Territories 
East 
Kowloon 
West 
New Territories 
West 
Kowloon 
Central 
Kowloon 
East 
Hong Kong 
West 
Hong Kong 
East 
Source: 
1. 
HA 
Statistical 
Report 
2012/13 
2. 
HA 
Information 
Fact 
Sheet 
Jun 
2014 
3. 
www.ha.org.hk 5 
5
eHealth in the HA - 
An ongoing journey 
1990 
1991 
1995 
2000 
2003 
2004 
2006 
2008 
2009 
2010 
2013 
“Green fields” 
Patient administration + Departmental systems 
Clinical Management System (CMS) 
Electronic Patient Record (ePR) 
eSARS 
ePR Image Distribution 
PPI ePR sharing 
CMS Phase III 
Filmless HA 
Hong Kong wide eHR 
Inpatient MOE 
Mobile CMS 
6 
6
Electronic Patient 
Record 
7
HA’s Clinical Management System 
- An essential clinical tool 
• 10M patients 
• 357M episodes of care 
• 1.8B laboratory results 
• 423M radiology images 
• 723M drug items 
• 5.1M updates / day 
• 1.6M hits / day 
• Sub-second response 
time 
• 7x24 >99.98% uptime 
since live run 
8 
8
The Seven Habits of Highly 
Effective Informaticians 
1. The customer is always right 
2. Medicine is an art and a science 
3. Win - Win - Win - Win - Win 
4. One step at a time 
5. Use it or lose it 
6. Focus and prioritize 
7. Embrace your informaticians 
9 
9
Principle 4: Step by Step 
Strategizing 
Building 
/Implementing 
Acculturating 
Realizing 
benefits 
10
Principle 5: Use it or Lose it 
Low data use Poor data quality 
Data use Data quality 
11 
11
Documentation becomes knowledge 
ePR 
Management data should 
be a byproduct of clinical 
documentation 
Data 
warehouse 
Diseases & 
procedures 
Departmental 
data 
Generic clinical documentation 
Clinical Data Analysis & 
Reporting (CDARS) 
12 
Reports & Analytics 
12
Medication management 
in the CMS 
Discharge medica-on 
Outpa-ent prescrip-ons 
Drug checking 
Inpa-ent closed loop medica-ons 
1995 
1996 
2002 
2013 
20 
13
Stage 1: Discharge and 
outpatient prescriptions 
• Legible, standardized orders 
–Standardized formulary 
–Structured data 
• Link to pharmacy 
• Full medica-on history 
–Reduced transcrip-on 
14
Stage 2: Drug checking 
• Purchase of third party drug checking system 
• Capture allergies as structured data 
• Monitor override reasons 
–Adjust level of alerts 
• Add customized checking logic 
15
Improving medication safety 
• Since 2005, a CMS alert has caused the 
prescribing doctor to change a medication 
over 350,000 times 
– Allergy - 272,303 times 
– G6PD - 9,548 times 
– Pregnancy - 25,502 times 
– Drug-drug interaction - 38,162 times 
– Adverse drug reaction - 9,918 times 
16
Stage 3: Closed loop 
inpatient medications 
• Electronic 
Prescribing 
• Prescription vetting 
& dispensing 
• eMAR & barcoded 
administration 
17
New Prescribing Features 
Feature Safety Efficiency 
IV Drugs and IV Fluid infusion 
✔ ✔ 
orders 
Permissible diluents ✔ ✔ 
White / Black routes ✔ 
Conditional order ✔ ✔ 
Verbal orders ✔ 
Common orders ✔ 
Standardized drug display 
✔ 
format 
Dose calculation with Body 
weight 
✔ ✔ 
Medication reconciliation ✔ ✔ 
Digital signing ✔ 
18
Administration Features 
Feature Safety Efficiency 
Barcoding of right patient, drug, time ✔ ✔ 
Reminders and task lists ✔ ✔ 
Standardized schedules ✔ 
Verbal orders ✔ 
Urgent refills ✔ 
Barcode labels for prepared drugs ✔ ✔ 
Dose calculation with Body weight ✔ ✔ 
Downtime handling ✔ 
19
Patient safety 
with barcodes 
• Electronic orders 
• Bedside label 
printing for all 
specimens 
• Closed loop 
barcoding for 
transfusions 
20
Mis-­‐iden-fica-on 
Incidents per month 
10 
8 
5 
3 
0 
Pa-ent iden-fica-on using 2D barcode scanning for 
Hospital A 
Hosptial B 
Hospital C 
Hospital D 
Hospital E 
Hospital F 
Accurate patient identification using 2D 
barcode technology 
laboratory specimen collec-on 
Misiden-fica-on in department not 
using 2D barcode scanning 
-6 -5 -4 -3 -2 -1 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 
Month(s) pre & post implementa-on 
21
HARRPE 
(Hospital Admission 
Risk Reduction 
Programme for the 
Elderly ) 
Risk stratification for 
elderly Patients 
Targeted intervention by 
call centre nurses 
22 
22
Hospital Admission Risk Reduc-on Programme 
for the Elderly (HARRPE) 
14 Predictor Variables 
HARRPE score 
09/05/11 ©2011 Healthcare Informa-on and Management Systems Society Type 
23
Evaluation 
A&E 
attendance 
27% 
Acute patient 
days 
19% 
Emergency 
admission to 
medical ward 
26% 
24
Community Health Call 
Centre (CHCC) 
Identifying at-risk patients from the 
total population 
Delivering the patient lists to 
appropriate care providers in a 
timely fashion 
Enabling new models of care 
delivery 
25
Development of CHCC Services to Support 
Chronic Disease Management 
DM patients 
cared by HA : 
~360,000+ 
Foster Better Self-­‐management by Structured Telephone Advice 
-­‐ Exercise -­‐ Medication Management 
-­‐ Diet -­‐ Self-­‐monitoring 
Supporting all clusters, ~ 7,000 targeted DM patients in GOPCs 
Handled ~ 70,000 calls in 2013/14 
26 
Development of CHCC services to support 
DM patients with sub-­‐optimal disease control (2011) 
26
Evaluation on 
Chronic Disease Management-­‐ DM Program 
Additional 0.23% point* 
reduction in HbA1c 
Improvement in 
Behaviours 
Improvement in HbA1c 
27 
27
Community Health Call 
Centre (CHCC) 
High risk elderly (HARRPE) 
Mental Health Direct 
Chronic Disease Management 
Defaulter tracing 
2007 
2011 
2012 
2013 
28
Communicable disease & 
outbreak management 
eSARS 
eFlu, NDORS (No-fiable Outbreak & 
Repor-ng System) 
eMilk (melamine tainted milk tracking) 
MDRO (mul--­‐drug resistant organism) 
2003 
2005 
2008 
2012 
29
NDORS 
30
MDRO - management of 
superbugs 
Lists of MDRO positive results from 
lab system 
Tagging of MDRO positive patients 
Admission alert on MDRO positive 
patients 
Monitoring of overall MDRO 
situation 
30 
31
Big Gun Antibiotics Utilization 
- Moving from retrospective to prospective review 
32
Public-private integration 
Secure 
Trusted 
Peace of Mind 
33
The Hong Kong Wide 
Electronic Health Record 
34
eHR - An essential health infrastructure 
Patient-oriented 
healthcare records 
Public-private 
interface and 
partnership 
DH 
Family doctor 
concept; integrated 
primary and hospital 
care 
HA Private Hospitals 
Electronic Health Records Sharing Infrastructure 
35
HK-wide eHR Sharing System 
EHR 
Repository 
Access Portal 
DH 
HA 
ePR 
PPP 
CMS 
onramp 
Clinics 
software 
Private 
Hospitals 
Private 
Hospitals 
Clinics 
software 
36
eHR OnRamp 
37
eHR Viewer 
10-­‐Feb-­‐2012 Diabetes Mellitus AHN 
10-­‐Feb-­‐2012 
Type 
II 
DM 
with 
background 
retinopathy AHN 
10-­‐Feb-­‐2012 
Type 
II 
DM 
with 
over 
nephropathy AHN 
04-­‐Jan-­‐2004 Hepatitis Hospital 
A 
04-­‐Jan-­‐2004 
Portal 
hypertension Hospital 
A 
04-­‐Jan-­‐2003 Acute 
upper 
respiratory 
infection Hospital 
A 
01-­‐Feb-­‐1999 Viral 
hepatitis Dr 
Wong 
38 
38
Key Message 
A standardised eHealth system can achieve 
better, safer, more efficient care delivery on 
an industrial scale at a reasonable cost 
39
Bold Claim 
A standardised eHealth system can achieve 
better, safer, more efficient care delivery on 
an industrial scale at a reasonable cost 
In fact it may be the only thing that can do 
so 
40

Health informatics - Transforming healthcare delivery in hong kong

  • 1.
    Health Informatics -transforming healthcare delivery in Hong Kong NT Cheung Head (IT & HI) / CMIO, HK Hospital Authority Consultant(eHealth), HK Government 1 1
  • 2.
    Total Expenditure on Health as Percentage of GDP % 16 14 12 10 8 6 4 2 1991 1993 1995 1997 1999 2001 2003 2005 USA France New Zealand Sweden UK Australia Japan 5.4% = 2.4% + 3.0% GDP Public Private Hong Kong 2011 Year 2007 2009 18 2011 Sources: (1) Census and Sta2s2cs Department, 2011 GDP (2) OECD Health Data October 2012 2 2
  • 3.
    Walker et al,“The Value Of Health Care Information Exchange And Interoperability” Health Affairs 2005 “…net savings from national implementation of fully standardized interoperability between providers… could yield $77.8 billion annually” “…We suspect that the clinical payoff in im-proved patient safety and quality of care could dwarf the financial benefits projected…” 3 3
  • 4.
    Key Message Astandardised eHealth system can achieve better, safer, more efficient care delivery on an industrial scale at a reasonable cost 4
  • 5.
    HA IT ServicesHospital Authority ❑ Established 1991 ❑ 42 Public Hospitals ❑ 47 Specialist Outpatient Clinics (SOPD) ❑ 73 General Outpatient Clinics (GOPC) ❑ Close to 27,500 Beds ❑ Around 67,600 Staff ❑ Around 22,700 Nurses ❑ Around 5,700 Doctors ❑ Around HK$ 46b Annual Operating Budget (~US$6 billion) ❑ 6.10m GOPC Attendances ❑ 9.37m SOPD Attendances ❑ 2.24m A&E Attendances ❑ 1.57m Inpatient and Day Patient Discharges New Territories East Kowloon West New Territories West Kowloon Central Kowloon East Hong Kong West Hong Kong East Source: 1. HA Statistical Report 2012/13 2. HA Information Fact Sheet Jun 2014 3. www.ha.org.hk 5 5
  • 6.
    eHealth in theHA - An ongoing journey 1990 1991 1995 2000 2003 2004 2006 2008 2009 2010 2013 “Green fields” Patient administration + Departmental systems Clinical Management System (CMS) Electronic Patient Record (ePR) eSARS ePR Image Distribution PPI ePR sharing CMS Phase III Filmless HA Hong Kong wide eHR Inpatient MOE Mobile CMS 6 6
  • 7.
  • 8.
    HA’s Clinical ManagementSystem - An essential clinical tool • 10M patients • 357M episodes of care • 1.8B laboratory results • 423M radiology images • 723M drug items • 5.1M updates / day • 1.6M hits / day • Sub-second response time • 7x24 >99.98% uptime since live run 8 8
  • 9.
    The Seven Habitsof Highly Effective Informaticians 1. The customer is always right 2. Medicine is an art and a science 3. Win - Win - Win - Win - Win 4. One step at a time 5. Use it or lose it 6. Focus and prioritize 7. Embrace your informaticians 9 9
  • 10.
    Principle 4: Stepby Step Strategizing Building /Implementing Acculturating Realizing benefits 10
  • 11.
    Principle 5: Useit or Lose it Low data use Poor data quality Data use Data quality 11 11
  • 12.
    Documentation becomes knowledge ePR Management data should be a byproduct of clinical documentation Data warehouse Diseases & procedures Departmental data Generic clinical documentation Clinical Data Analysis & Reporting (CDARS) 12 Reports & Analytics 12
  • 13.
    Medication management inthe CMS Discharge medica-on Outpa-ent prescrip-ons Drug checking Inpa-ent closed loop medica-ons 1995 1996 2002 2013 20 13
  • 14.
    Stage 1: Dischargeand outpatient prescriptions • Legible, standardized orders –Standardized formulary –Structured data • Link to pharmacy • Full medica-on history –Reduced transcrip-on 14
  • 15.
    Stage 2: Drugchecking • Purchase of third party drug checking system • Capture allergies as structured data • Monitor override reasons –Adjust level of alerts • Add customized checking logic 15
  • 16.
    Improving medication safety • Since 2005, a CMS alert has caused the prescribing doctor to change a medication over 350,000 times – Allergy - 272,303 times – G6PD - 9,548 times – Pregnancy - 25,502 times – Drug-drug interaction - 38,162 times – Adverse drug reaction - 9,918 times 16
  • 17.
    Stage 3: Closedloop inpatient medications • Electronic Prescribing • Prescription vetting & dispensing • eMAR & barcoded administration 17
  • 18.
    New Prescribing Features Feature Safety Efficiency IV Drugs and IV Fluid infusion ✔ ✔ orders Permissible diluents ✔ ✔ White / Black routes ✔ Conditional order ✔ ✔ Verbal orders ✔ Common orders ✔ Standardized drug display ✔ format Dose calculation with Body weight ✔ ✔ Medication reconciliation ✔ ✔ Digital signing ✔ 18
  • 19.
    Administration Features FeatureSafety Efficiency Barcoding of right patient, drug, time ✔ ✔ Reminders and task lists ✔ ✔ Standardized schedules ✔ Verbal orders ✔ Urgent refills ✔ Barcode labels for prepared drugs ✔ ✔ Dose calculation with Body weight ✔ ✔ Downtime handling ✔ 19
  • 20.
    Patient safety withbarcodes • Electronic orders • Bedside label printing for all specimens • Closed loop barcoding for transfusions 20
  • 21.
    Mis-­‐iden-fica-on Incidents permonth 10 8 5 3 0 Pa-ent iden-fica-on using 2D barcode scanning for Hospital A Hosptial B Hospital C Hospital D Hospital E Hospital F Accurate patient identification using 2D barcode technology laboratory specimen collec-on Misiden-fica-on in department not using 2D barcode scanning -6 -5 -4 -3 -2 -1 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 Month(s) pre & post implementa-on 21
  • 22.
    HARRPE (Hospital Admission Risk Reduction Programme for the Elderly ) Risk stratification for elderly Patients Targeted intervention by call centre nurses 22 22
  • 23.
    Hospital Admission RiskReduc-on Programme for the Elderly (HARRPE) 14 Predictor Variables HARRPE score 09/05/11 ©2011 Healthcare Informa-on and Management Systems Society Type 23
  • 24.
    Evaluation A&E attendance 27% Acute patient days 19% Emergency admission to medical ward 26% 24
  • 25.
    Community Health Call Centre (CHCC) Identifying at-risk patients from the total population Delivering the patient lists to appropriate care providers in a timely fashion Enabling new models of care delivery 25
  • 26.
    Development of CHCCServices to Support Chronic Disease Management DM patients cared by HA : ~360,000+ Foster Better Self-­‐management by Structured Telephone Advice -­‐ Exercise -­‐ Medication Management -­‐ Diet -­‐ Self-­‐monitoring Supporting all clusters, ~ 7,000 targeted DM patients in GOPCs Handled ~ 70,000 calls in 2013/14 26 Development of CHCC services to support DM patients with sub-­‐optimal disease control (2011) 26
  • 27.
    Evaluation on ChronicDisease Management-­‐ DM Program Additional 0.23% point* reduction in HbA1c Improvement in Behaviours Improvement in HbA1c 27 27
  • 28.
    Community Health Call Centre (CHCC) High risk elderly (HARRPE) Mental Health Direct Chronic Disease Management Defaulter tracing 2007 2011 2012 2013 28
  • 29.
    Communicable disease & outbreak management eSARS eFlu, NDORS (No-fiable Outbreak & Repor-ng System) eMilk (melamine tainted milk tracking) MDRO (mul--­‐drug resistant organism) 2003 2005 2008 2012 29
  • 30.
  • 31.
    MDRO - managementof superbugs Lists of MDRO positive results from lab system Tagging of MDRO positive patients Admission alert on MDRO positive patients Monitoring of overall MDRO situation 30 31
  • 32.
    Big Gun AntibioticsUtilization - Moving from retrospective to prospective review 32
  • 33.
    Public-private integration Secure Trusted Peace of Mind 33
  • 34.
    The Hong KongWide Electronic Health Record 34
  • 35.
    eHR - Anessential health infrastructure Patient-oriented healthcare records Public-private interface and partnership DH Family doctor concept; integrated primary and hospital care HA Private Hospitals Electronic Health Records Sharing Infrastructure 35
  • 36.
    HK-wide eHR SharingSystem EHR Repository Access Portal DH HA ePR PPP CMS onramp Clinics software Private Hospitals Private Hospitals Clinics software 36
  • 37.
  • 38.
    eHR Viewer 10-­‐Feb-­‐2012Diabetes Mellitus AHN 10-­‐Feb-­‐2012 Type II DM with background retinopathy AHN 10-­‐Feb-­‐2012 Type II DM with over nephropathy AHN 04-­‐Jan-­‐2004 Hepatitis Hospital A 04-­‐Jan-­‐2004 Portal hypertension Hospital A 04-­‐Jan-­‐2003 Acute upper respiratory infection Hospital A 01-­‐Feb-­‐1999 Viral hepatitis Dr Wong 38 38
  • 39.
    Key Message Astandardised eHealth system can achieve better, safer, more efficient care delivery on an industrial scale at a reasonable cost 39
  • 40.
    Bold Claim Astandardised eHealth system can achieve better, safer, more efficient care delivery on an industrial scale at a reasonable cost In fact it may be the only thing that can do so 40