Social Machines:
Theoretical Perspectives
September 2017
Oxford, UK
Paul Smart
Book Structure
Sections
• Understanding Social
Machines
• Varieties of Social
Machines
• Interdisciplinary Linkages
Chapters
• Views of Social Machines
• The Mechanistic View of
Social Machines
• Views, Revisited
• The Conceptual
Landscape of the Social
Web
Book Structure
Sections
• Understanding Social
Machines
• Varieties of Social
Machines
• Interdisciplinary Linkages
Chapters
• Socio-Technical
Mechanisms
• Classifying Social
Machines
• The Social Machine
Morphospace
Book Structure
Sections
• Understanding Social
Machines
• Varieties of Social
Machines
• Implications and
Interdisciplinary
Linkages
Chapters
• Social Machines and
Social Mechanisms
• Social Physics
• Knowledge Machines
• Problem-Solving Engines
• The Social Computer
Views of Social Machines
Content Creation View Sociable Machines
View
Socially-Situated
Machines View
Extended Systems
View
Cognitive Systems
View
Socio-Computational
View
Narratological View
Process View
Views of Social Machines
Content Creation View Sociable Machines
View
Socially-Situated
Machines View
Extended Systems
View
Cognitive Systems
View
Socio-Computational
View
Narratological View
Process View
The Mechanistic View
• Focus on socio-technical mechanisms.
• Socio-technical mechanisms?
• Mechanisms:
• “A mechanism for a phenomenon consists of
entities (or parts) whose activities and
interactions are organized so as to be
responsible for the phenomenon.”
• Socio-technical mechanisms:
• Mechanisms made of people and technology.
Social Machine (Ψ-ing)
X3Φ3-ing
X2Φ2-ing
X1Φ1-ing X5Φ5-ing
Socio-Technical
Mechanism
Phenomenon
MECHANISTIC
REALIZATION/CONSTITUTION
Views of Social Machines
Content Creation View Sociable Machines
View
Socially-Situated
Machines View
Extended Systems
View
Cognitive Systems
View
Socio-Computational
View
Narratological View
Process View
Views of Social Machines
Content Creation View Sociable Machines
View
Socially-Situated
Machines View
Extended Systems
View
Cognitive Systems
View
Socio-Computational
View
Narratological View
Process View
Room for the Views?
• Content Creation View:
• human and machine components assigned specific
functional roles.
• Extended Systems View:
• human-extended machine cognition.
• Process View:
• processes realized by socio-technical mechanisms.
• Cognitive Systems View:
• phenomena of the cognitive kind.
• Socio-Computational View:
• phenomena of the computational kind.
• Narratological View:
• descriptions of mechanisms (Little, 2018).
Socially-Situated Machines
• Smart and Madaan (in press):
• The human mind is a socially-created artefact
(phylogeny / ontogeny).
• Two Red Queens:
• Socio-cognitive complexity.
• Socio-ecological variability.
• Internet provides contact with humanity.
• Social scaffolding of machine intelligence.
• AI as the product of social machines?
The Gift of Language
Conclusion
• Mechanistic View:
• Social machines as systems whose states,
events and processes are realized by socio-
technical mechanisms.
• Relaxed (but not lazy) pluralism:
• Multispectral conceptual analysis.
• Socially-Situated Machines Views:
• Social machines as socially-situated machines.
Publications
• Smart, P. R. (2017) Machine Intelligence and the
Social Web: How to Get a Cognitive Upgrade.
COGNITIVE’17, Athens, Greece.
• Smart, P. R. and Madaan (in press) The Social
Scaffolding of Machine Intelligence. Int. Journal of
Adv. Cognitive Systems.
• Smart, P. R. (in press) Predicting Me: A Route to
Digital Immortality? In The Mind–Technology
Problem. Springer, Berlin, Germany.
• Smart et al. (submitted) Towards an Understanding
of Social Machines. AI & Society.
• Smart et al (in prep) Social Machines: A
Mechanistic Perspective.

Social Machines: Theoretical perspectives, Paul Smart

  • 1.
  • 3.
    Book Structure Sections • UnderstandingSocial Machines • Varieties of Social Machines • Interdisciplinary Linkages Chapters • Views of Social Machines • The Mechanistic View of Social Machines • Views, Revisited • The Conceptual Landscape of the Social Web
  • 4.
    Book Structure Sections • UnderstandingSocial Machines • Varieties of Social Machines • Interdisciplinary Linkages Chapters • Socio-Technical Mechanisms • Classifying Social Machines • The Social Machine Morphospace
  • 5.
    Book Structure Sections • UnderstandingSocial Machines • Varieties of Social Machines • Implications and Interdisciplinary Linkages Chapters • Social Machines and Social Mechanisms • Social Physics • Knowledge Machines • Problem-Solving Engines • The Social Computer
  • 6.
    Views of SocialMachines Content Creation View Sociable Machines View Socially-Situated Machines View Extended Systems View Cognitive Systems View Socio-Computational View Narratological View Process View
  • 7.
    Views of SocialMachines Content Creation View Sociable Machines View Socially-Situated Machines View Extended Systems View Cognitive Systems View Socio-Computational View Narratological View Process View
  • 8.
    The Mechanistic View •Focus on socio-technical mechanisms. • Socio-technical mechanisms? • Mechanisms: • “A mechanism for a phenomenon consists of entities (or parts) whose activities and interactions are organized so as to be responsible for the phenomenon.” • Socio-technical mechanisms: • Mechanisms made of people and technology.
  • 9.
    Social Machine (Ψ-ing) X3Φ3-ing X2Φ2-ing X1Φ1-ingX5Φ5-ing Socio-Technical Mechanism Phenomenon MECHANISTIC REALIZATION/CONSTITUTION
  • 10.
    Views of SocialMachines Content Creation View Sociable Machines View Socially-Situated Machines View Extended Systems View Cognitive Systems View Socio-Computational View Narratological View Process View
  • 11.
    Views of SocialMachines Content Creation View Sociable Machines View Socially-Situated Machines View Extended Systems View Cognitive Systems View Socio-Computational View Narratological View Process View
  • 12.
    Room for theViews? • Content Creation View: • human and machine components assigned specific functional roles. • Extended Systems View: • human-extended machine cognition. • Process View: • processes realized by socio-technical mechanisms. • Cognitive Systems View: • phenomena of the cognitive kind. • Socio-Computational View: • phenomena of the computational kind. • Narratological View: • descriptions of mechanisms (Little, 2018).
  • 13.
    Socially-Situated Machines • Smartand Madaan (in press): • The human mind is a socially-created artefact (phylogeny / ontogeny). • Two Red Queens: • Socio-cognitive complexity. • Socio-ecological variability. • Internet provides contact with humanity. • Social scaffolding of machine intelligence. • AI as the product of social machines?
  • 14.
    The Gift ofLanguage
  • 15.
    Conclusion • Mechanistic View: •Social machines as systems whose states, events and processes are realized by socio- technical mechanisms. • Relaxed (but not lazy) pluralism: • Multispectral conceptual analysis. • Socially-Situated Machines Views: • Social machines as socially-situated machines.
  • 16.
    Publications • Smart, P.R. (2017) Machine Intelligence and the Social Web: How to Get a Cognitive Upgrade. COGNITIVE’17, Athens, Greece. • Smart, P. R. and Madaan (in press) The Social Scaffolding of Machine Intelligence. Int. Journal of Adv. Cognitive Systems. • Smart, P. R. (in press) Predicting Me: A Route to Digital Immortality? In The Mind–Technology Problem. Springer, Berlin, Germany. • Smart et al. (submitted) Towards an Understanding of Social Machines. AI & Society. • Smart et al (in prep) Social Machines: A Mechanistic Perspective.