Prepare to be Audited
 (The auditor is coming!
 The auditor is coming!)


    IT Best Practices

                        Bob Sturm
                        Director, IT Validation
Life Cycle of an Audit
What                      Responsibility

Request for information   IT Quality

Introductory meeting      IT Quality & Mngrs.
Information gathering &   IT Quality and
analysis                  Auditee(s)
Audit Close-out           IT Quality & Mngrs.

Reporting & follow-up     IT Quality
Prepare for the Audit

• HOW?
 – Attend this training.
 – Read and understand the sample
   questions in the handout.


• WHY?
 – You may be asked these questions.
Three Basic Concepts


• Follow the IT Policy Manual

• Adhering to our ITMS principles means we
  are Audit Ready!

• Understand the scope and objectives of
  the audit as explained by IT Quality
Preparing – IT Quality’s
          Responsibilities


• Email people an auditor(s) is coming
• Appoint an escort to be the host for the
  auditor(s)
• Ensure work space & appropriate
  badge access
• Arrange for a conference room where
  auditor(s) can meet
Preparing – IT Quality’s
      Responsibilities (More)

• Ensure a guest wireless network is
  available. Contact IT security if more
  bandwidth is needed.
• Confirm that management is available for
  the opening and closing meeting
• Confirm that personnel who have key roles
  in areas under review are available
Assign Tasks for Audit

• IT Quality and Managers meet to assign
  tasks needed for the audit
What’s Expected of You

• KEY - Know our ITMS practices inside and
  out!
• Know what is expected per your job
  description
• Understand applicable SOPs, WIs and
  other procedures for your job
• If unsure about anything, ask your
  manager or IT Quality
Conduct and Etiquette
NO                                 YES 

• Be professional, respectful and truthful with
  the auditor
• Have a positive attitude
• If you anticipate a finding, contact IT Quality
• Don’t take anything the auditor says
  personally
• Defend our systems and processes but don’t
  be overly defensive or argue with the auditor
Conduct and Etiquette - More


• Keep the atmosphere and the
  conversation friendly but professional
• Do not try to influence an auditor’s
  judgment
• Recognize when you are right and when
  you are wrong
• Do not become emotionally involved in
  the review
Conduct and Etiquette – Even More

• Be wary of an auditor who veers off topic
  and requests information not associated
  with the scope and objectives of audit
  – Defer these requests to IT Quality or your
    manager
• If the auditor requests information deemed
  proprietary, sensitive or highly confidential,
  refer the auditor to IT Quality or your
  manager
Responding to Questions

• IMPORTANT! – Answer only the questions
  posed by the auditor. Do NOT volunteer
  extra information or expand unnecessarily
  on any answer.
• Answer all questions truthfully. Do NOT
  stretch the truth or be misleading.
• Provide adequate and accurate answers.
  – Just the facts, not opinions!
Responding to Questions
      - More
• Before answering a question, be sure to
  understand the question.
• If unsure about the question, ask for
  clarification or paraphrase the question.
• Do NOT guess at the question!
• If unsure of an answer, inform the auditor you
  are not sure. Let auditor know you will get an
  answer or bring in a person who knows the
  answer.
• Follow up and set a date!
Sample Questions

• Is there a documented and approved disaster
  recovery plan on file? Has it been tested to
  ensure reliability?
• How are assets, including data safeguarded?
• Has the computer system been developed in
  a manner consistent with applicable
  regulatory guidances and industry standards?
• Do personnel have requisite training,
  education and experience to perform their job
  function and is the training documented?
Sample Questions - More

• What methods are established for traceability
  of documentation, including changes?
• What procedures exist to assure that
  standards are followed?
• Is approval authority for deliverable
  documentation clearly established?
• What procedures exist to assure the prompt
  detection and correction of deficiencies?
• Are acceptance tests monitored by QA?
Requests for Documents
• All document requests are handled by IT
  Quality or Managers
• Route all documents through IT Quality or
  Managers
• Put documents onto a SharePoint site set
  up for the audit by IT Quality
Audit Closeout – IT Quality and
         Managers
• Purpose is for the auditor to summarize
  events of the audit and present preliminary
  observations of non-conformance.
• Auditors present the facts of their findings.
• Our company ensures the root cause of the
  issue is determined
• Our company discusses the level of risk
  associated with the finding
Audit Closeout – IT Quality and
      Managers (More)
• Discuss potential solutions to the findings
• Our company ensures the auditor is not
  overly prescriptive in their
  recommendations.
• Provides an opportunity to discuss any
  misunderstandings that may have arisen
• IT Quality will ask about expected delivery
  of the formal report
Reference Material to READ

• Preparation for the Audit – IT Best
  practices, www.pharmait.co.uk,
  – Read pp 31-35.

• Software Quality Assurance Audits
  Guidebook, NASA, November 1990
  – Read Appendix B pp 17-21 (Sample Questions).

Prepare for an I.T. Audit

  • 1.
    Prepare to beAudited (The auditor is coming! The auditor is coming!) IT Best Practices Bob Sturm Director, IT Validation
  • 2.
    Life Cycle ofan Audit What Responsibility Request for information IT Quality Introductory meeting IT Quality & Mngrs. Information gathering & IT Quality and analysis Auditee(s) Audit Close-out IT Quality & Mngrs. Reporting & follow-up IT Quality
  • 3.
    Prepare for theAudit • HOW? – Attend this training. – Read and understand the sample questions in the handout. • WHY? – You may be asked these questions.
  • 4.
    Three Basic Concepts •Follow the IT Policy Manual • Adhering to our ITMS principles means we are Audit Ready! • Understand the scope and objectives of the audit as explained by IT Quality
  • 5.
    Preparing – ITQuality’s Responsibilities • Email people an auditor(s) is coming • Appoint an escort to be the host for the auditor(s) • Ensure work space & appropriate badge access • Arrange for a conference room where auditor(s) can meet
  • 6.
    Preparing – ITQuality’s Responsibilities (More) • Ensure a guest wireless network is available. Contact IT security if more bandwidth is needed. • Confirm that management is available for the opening and closing meeting • Confirm that personnel who have key roles in areas under review are available
  • 7.
    Assign Tasks forAudit • IT Quality and Managers meet to assign tasks needed for the audit
  • 8.
    What’s Expected ofYou • KEY - Know our ITMS practices inside and out! • Know what is expected per your job description • Understand applicable SOPs, WIs and other procedures for your job • If unsure about anything, ask your manager or IT Quality
  • 9.
    Conduct and Etiquette NO YES  • Be professional, respectful and truthful with the auditor • Have a positive attitude • If you anticipate a finding, contact IT Quality • Don’t take anything the auditor says personally • Defend our systems and processes but don’t be overly defensive or argue with the auditor
  • 10.
    Conduct and Etiquette- More • Keep the atmosphere and the conversation friendly but professional • Do not try to influence an auditor’s judgment • Recognize when you are right and when you are wrong • Do not become emotionally involved in the review
  • 11.
    Conduct and Etiquette– Even More • Be wary of an auditor who veers off topic and requests information not associated with the scope and objectives of audit – Defer these requests to IT Quality or your manager • If the auditor requests information deemed proprietary, sensitive or highly confidential, refer the auditor to IT Quality or your manager
  • 12.
    Responding to Questions •IMPORTANT! – Answer only the questions posed by the auditor. Do NOT volunteer extra information or expand unnecessarily on any answer. • Answer all questions truthfully. Do NOT stretch the truth or be misleading. • Provide adequate and accurate answers. – Just the facts, not opinions!
  • 13.
    Responding to Questions - More • Before answering a question, be sure to understand the question. • If unsure about the question, ask for clarification or paraphrase the question. • Do NOT guess at the question! • If unsure of an answer, inform the auditor you are not sure. Let auditor know you will get an answer or bring in a person who knows the answer. • Follow up and set a date!
  • 14.
    Sample Questions • Isthere a documented and approved disaster recovery plan on file? Has it been tested to ensure reliability? • How are assets, including data safeguarded? • Has the computer system been developed in a manner consistent with applicable regulatory guidances and industry standards? • Do personnel have requisite training, education and experience to perform their job function and is the training documented?
  • 15.
    Sample Questions -More • What methods are established for traceability of documentation, including changes? • What procedures exist to assure that standards are followed? • Is approval authority for deliverable documentation clearly established? • What procedures exist to assure the prompt detection and correction of deficiencies? • Are acceptance tests monitored by QA?
  • 16.
    Requests for Documents •All document requests are handled by IT Quality or Managers • Route all documents through IT Quality or Managers • Put documents onto a SharePoint site set up for the audit by IT Quality
  • 17.
    Audit Closeout –IT Quality and Managers • Purpose is for the auditor to summarize events of the audit and present preliminary observations of non-conformance. • Auditors present the facts of their findings. • Our company ensures the root cause of the issue is determined • Our company discusses the level of risk associated with the finding
  • 18.
    Audit Closeout –IT Quality and Managers (More) • Discuss potential solutions to the findings • Our company ensures the auditor is not overly prescriptive in their recommendations. • Provides an opportunity to discuss any misunderstandings that may have arisen • IT Quality will ask about expected delivery of the formal report
  • 19.
    Reference Material toREAD • Preparation for the Audit – IT Best practices, www.pharmait.co.uk, – Read pp 31-35. • Software Quality Assurance Audits Guidebook, NASA, November 1990 – Read Appendix B pp 17-21 (Sample Questions).