Laporan Hasil Penelitian Putusan Hakim Tingkat Banding Mengenai Cerai Talak Antara Kasboelah Setio Oetomo Dengan Liliek Sugiarsih

1. r-f,fal,na"

2. lT"4lainfuFbtut
6 hhsi tuh &r Ask a,* 14 Dbdh6Dgh --

3. rt
tukffiasdihoffis,d!!n
!.snlhnMfiieige}di|M

4. ,;
@tbr'4No3lfuMr4b4
fu4-bffu6wrfue'&ic,ePL),dl
olh se6tulru)
r,,&a,M- hw 8tu4 Pd wNo t rtu tel tun esi etu
Pffi ,6'&b,ofu lMEi[cq D{),
.Lful.fugNa7krwD8rdqfueb)c@

5. Ddu bae D e dier6b! n€4€r, i€ni4 Putuo F3 n6jad dnl knu
1.Nob Ftututusdobj*p{did
, Diputu ddm nuylld M&rt Hen Pocdh T4e Asna r*6 Dda
ui(mi!la39ls.lsfos,6:Mb3t!
ud!o!EdhFduT4iA3@Jfu
DE H Am Dnhid s H (Hr rktu)
2 h Mudr6d!,ss 6!!kin
r h s Mld r'$Fdi, s E (rtu hssh)
T@dlaedbni

6. P{gdibThggiAeaeJfut6E@*ad@!4dipgt&aDrll4i3i
nfugFlNonE!407.(d!dofuv$d
LjDdsBjtdh,s,Ebdsukbru
I&FfuihT!i$hND'xo.15k0urc07'
Quh@hh4dEgi(s!rohnPdocdwjdda
Pdobi (khdd sd0 odono bb rrtu sd. odono cld Denel6 sua
p@oh{,@ bk (c@, hr*) k+da rmoho! (L i.k susircih! s.s bhrisfilmn
&Eier , Asutu 2r0r yu8 rh[,qdana di (+oiE@ P{gr o Ats a

7. @l didsi k+u sbab seb cdld q!
6- "tu -. r-dm rh" "-F du cnb@ i6hdq Pwobq. rmor@
Teodu rrd b@isah hPd no&sr *j
66aro 1go^a&ni) berB sbitug lmh d,rrya tug r6h 205 Ni de4a ea
se$d r 80 Ni bdirr @ th6 vuc

8. Pcmohoo no$jukm
FEdLird Dier rErD!@ de Ptu
ejeF vdb dd pdohi rhh b@
uniFPfrohoihmohtrk+daPgd0
A@a&p*nf,ufukus4aieriktri
l.M!4dfu.eluruhrtrnolomiPmobl
pulo3d4,GanfuPdogdry,fuThu'
&4u Pd B &al dibrgi 2 (du) sm. bsmy. r, blgi

9. i, tuva pel@ho@ knohoo ytrs dljuku
dr P4gd e dguB ii ddth rqrd! diii (@dr) Ed$ spsyoF Ebs6
(Pr) riddo yd3 .dmsF
jtu ke P4d[u a,@a ddd Pmdon
tu rlmd@ bdsMlsmln{ch&p du n{rl.$iktu lasrisibs Ede6ii
-bdl,%Bd',d^@!|rh'dui
biggr2rlEdl9d'dehr.tdim
cbagjnoadiududchPfrdoeh,l
MdolddsilrssP€I4Pue.Bclu(I
r. 3m n$aj ta iujua |ed bs
h Pmd@ hrq sb.b $&b r4dirF
pdtri'Iodaldul9&j&hb&h
&oTmd@nsnhE4{b9UaDiid
)b{ disluh ore[ PoDoho! ,qEbr ddd m.sdad.

10. s Flg s6uB &o$ klmnbaoF, y c
iDurE. BiMq&buh jud
'e3
ibd
nMbi drh k44r6s &r.bd dasi
kdr eD juir dmi d.d d@ s
dd@ohmFBld.hndgbaid]idgi
.rhd4l@ohobahatmob^F!3tld*hliiid.ae$b&dosde{n.
0t tmohom! ii di !jub!
bdkeajibu mlnbd Bftah nmah uos!
ldilnub4intiekd*d*fuyc

11. Addd sbe' dd* d rdru Pdoioiiue n{yiisun&ryi43uB $d rqmirrku
emkh &i ildh Fyi /e rede, ,eruh
n lur rund sr hnF Fg dh
bkh drnur Abs manu r6cbd p4esr tu si ie@kr nd.ldh k+r&
s!j, sd iu,eslsd rbPd id i4i
k! rb b.k nr 343.i p@v.i i4ai sipir,
s€jd itu b@4 jNab q{tuF &bsi
dik li r ohu adid 1{ iur rupd. A4qr0

12. dhbogTqs$rcrqosikedaP499.eFm],.4aip'rsdgugd@ij
e!!elgid4!d4.U!d4Nnql
rckopo6i ioej6 Pmbtuh rlr,mi 6,,
I@aidoFtrcd]U!$nqtqlgal
i[y43yddsg@po@gldony4n.
r:iF reeujla 6 P!4!er rckdvd
I{$gtMdnsodd&nne4hadald
Mnlis Hltin Eid eru !
ftnFpd@ihe!€l+diFfuhrfu
t4g,cbddsdioodono6isBE
tr Piih& rcBt w rs4se R*o 6si
utuk nmbF Dtuh rriu,4 rada ftoggus'l rtorvasi reu RP 14 jnh
Gs!tuflPd P !!4nilnrups)
a6bo[(adsD&B[K6uuDu(d!

13. rrus Pro Ms (Pr, Fob@py ksLr6i
tP4), role@y sun' pdddu
ruebdbutu $rr $F, p4ilro ,od brd e I i
6'p iuroMbrysd e iuriree (Pr.
, bed n juii r q6 c7), Fob c4r sr,
ory su (F), roe@y s r hsd rr
s+1@bq re& (Pl1). Fdocopy sud r4s1 2r Asna D3 r (P r2). Fddopy $vd
rr@r r s$,mk rqt elr, Fdo
(Pr7), FoGory un',oggd Ma
'o1
(P[)
pmdFD bhh ntrg[dnk@ sksi Gd* hdr4 Rnohoi) F[u M mnd Ai]a
sbssd bdh sei iih ldk kdune knohd, bdFl*s lus Plhobtr &!
idiis{.sd!-rco 'd b..n ,r, -.
dak m{Frlko a4sr iF $e!$D
rinu (rr), Fd@opy ur (r). FoG.ry
B' (rr), rtuop, sud ,ud! hmd P! iem h&qi r Mli rer (84, tbhopy
(rs), foeopy su, M Fdn@
14311 14 iuni 1993 o1), Fdo@py ucl hs.r rr Ju[ tees (rr, rohopy Dt
14sL
'3
NoFnbq reee (16). fdo@p
*dd sip tudF prcbdngs G7| ror
E6t@o (r3) 6b@y pd*0 (+utuei

14. riuo 2000 h*cd re trii :00! rP9. Fd6
& (I0), robrcpy k{n! L.rue No 70dq Gr1). sucr kdqrloso Dd!tr
Plmreturc E rare or@rDou (rD)
sdn r pdr FkokrF noj€hkn blhva dsi dd k64i r@!e Pindq &r
6!ePe@hqnaik h1l3i
d64dB6d&,kdeFPlnohoddd
daeg!@ilfu&t6ecnoiqd{91
'ult]&l&B6lieti4$ksiljdlkm4hdnhP
s sinr Pd ProbF n{jeh*a b

15. 1$n0 Fs noFlG Pmoioi ns kd 4ina e6q,e da rde@@ sdd{dn
romrptr juts €hb oq4hdnlh s*
i+i 6e6q4! bh iD d m3d4 kem
Pinohor ndd bcr, nd* mt!j*a P
nc&Dkul4in4i{dartalk
4tld6aiNladlttrsdxn]rei'9d,
4d dhtsli tu+N *6i6 &6d tiiiF
l@@sebr,Emohoo*uu.qi3ld
&hfulided3Fedd4Pfldq,T!
ej* bdu Me' ro@ smps stu3 i
bcBm! (pno s0) bdr( $bidmg rtrd st,sF !u4 bbih 2s ia doua ea
lodsNo26ti3siI
3bNdl3!M:enhg},tFg€ldyog

16. NuEdngnsiogtqdmyBldfod
hd!EFmc6ebabdumdi6€'cuJGlo,
dlFddaqliD[F
foh$dlq,JefuTiDud.@bd*6
bqg0qlubnds@pEkaaDiMqdtHakinTiogiAgml,elnaadilil
((6b(nah slio odno)
rmoidsbadns Gdnk sug dh) s
odned$6tdn3
nflbaF hay! Frb! dtrogkr pdm. d,s r7o 000, GeBtu rjuh pd , nbu
A'Pe.A'PkN4ePdBh|'rq|d.rEdb

17. $rrd n.mrdaiar du nodir dosa
nmcfrmb!(LfddMicodjEMgdtdhl
bfdriq rrs ooEhjd
@ paa *, P@ohuhrnbmdis, kdu
(symul Amn) s6ud tdq4@Ya
E{uje doy! pdtu
Mrj.ris kin d4ld ba hs esnd4d
l.i4"odgPnd14tro4"iii!
$bei 3Mi isrei dd3!, iujw llu6nd kd@s ,runrh rhsio y@ bdrsis

18. M4!u Mnk H*in dgkd b!0d4.
nhFbn*s 'rddis d4d r4adi kem
(0 mr$ sumi hi @s n&ro gidi pftdis@ d@
FftogkBndulid.d.hmr rortup u bs ddu lud ra@ " olnis
.kinlogk,6adig6+{&pdbdla
Novimb, sE &hh beiunr n ,tu (s&h nqihh) dh 23 rdui F3 *$.i d4u
gfomPPiobrikPohon',efbodig
rNrjibs rci 6mbsi mlk.h/bhF ii p
Lada kau@F &o dqh kdmF !u! Nrjlris d{h det, hdoc tq{&pd
rrewji6a yDg 1tu! ud n{egtu
aDd D,Byesnhndi$ L &$r dri sus'm iEymkr

19. i4 Ertu hrd, oajdi h*in 6srd &idrg
bqodq, bd!. bde*o sEr b&i re ylq aujukm rmohoditudbc
dhh PNs Fjd msc
,hrg6' bodis Frs basusk u je14 ltEpuy!
pasbs ro (sji, rujaoso dd tarLi6 F,c !dT). sMihr PmohmPeobtuhg
dds iba 6dsji (d{k ftlnpuyd tsBh6 o), oloN k ddo hubutrstr
$b@i sd ini neBie*dnq.j$k k@ Pmohd@budug srdu
du km k#.lih nmtd Dft.h o
Mq€Ls h*io riigk bodiB 64{d4d LdEibo rmohoiDqddiB $hh
dipr ialug keldibmYa itu rid* bdd
n*d6dFhdobry
r+drciolrs((kdkbduhhdqpimd(lokoD@dud{ltuk pd+rh;
Nfus@PogdihAsmlJfulinuxond:91@dlo00@A[.lmgd25
391llM!ful4IHTii4&pd

20. dpdd{bgik@bFfurul &bddka &o Pqd u rqd a@ rtu
piu Fq Irl@j*s Emoh@an ba d
iBhFn@au4udbgrded
Ud{N6d7Tltuil9s,ngk!6
Amrie yas bni n dkatitu &hm b
(Hrocc) Nuu d iti4 !! No 7 rdu'e8eh uu Nc a rdh,@6 ri14
sdry pcoids@ d tu dd Mjek
Dmdhh diL*uh *hr r0 Mi &n
Pmrko dker (ri&$ dsu dr) dn.M oth Msiels Htu *kuq
,a.7).
.,J.?J16
s/

21. inu dhtu &6n Pd 30 C) da, Psd &
0) !! No 7 rduo reler Psd 20
r4aii6@ bae ekin d(
dheelru &re Pur 32 (11 !! No 7 rtuo 1r3e jo Psrl 39 (t) rru No 1 rdN
relFPsd 3r PP No e rru an r
hoFPd!s,lsidnstsnuasdogr
oEh Malert Hdin pdig rue' I hr *i* 6@d Fi&n'h su! ssdu rr
d*br sb4i4ea d,eoro d2ru P6d 3o 0) w No. ? rdu! I qs jo rei ,
(1)PPNo erdm re5ioPrd 14ro)GLr
drNb re biba Phohoi (ksb@nd
sd6 orM) fhb ndejukd pmNbiu oo (cni !hk) kF&,emohn
rcmo.gi$rIo9'0}d'c,o1DdT
tal @ytu{ : "Mqirt!ry tuhw Ltuie
nnrrJrqknkbhhedmbhfurM*nqEhgdnh,

22. @rqhfue|ehdfiQBwdqgud6al
qor?qqt44 PrrktiJerh-
lmu&hn@lchdiliE|dbd!
Pd&@nuldtgti4iomlrb6u
elih 6a hd hdr u€roFkn
n Md r0r, Msn H*in rogrd pdoa rhh
tmoh!L4dTmohouddmbq

23. hd sjd
'dsr rdd!tuBtr psDD dlaa cued didtu pdr hE! ,
Aguius,mlseDdtrlpfrEodil!fuM
6da, M$kipu! Psd 2e (3) PP No e rd!! sr jo Psd r11 O) mr ehli
Fngksd!gugbpe(qinodi4!ry|
Tg4denlna'1b39ldi|!eregid
eFE knPd hosd sj* bdo Mnd
ilrf,h btu, !h !eaiad! mktu n*
Nlnuo dL hr pitukjeah leu Fnqi
fbsinm ditu &ho tu$r !e o) PP No. e reiu! 1975 jo P6, rlr B) @I
o Dx jo !@P ehuho rhnFsr rr6 F
yhg ndFbu.kd '!fteaiu dapd djldi keo! d6d dd d*u (! @,48 !d,,
Fn4ck.i,dlrld1kd4haPra
dhj!6dd P@ohu ddaE Fmohdm.m F

24. o)u! No 7lrun les F Prd 2 C) PP No. e rahu rer
Dfl@6*iosEdksdu@dq
lq.dre Gqai cue,) $dd tFr kem
rEcbfNs chb dfenhserrtr dM r!tus@F
1!rds!!!4!,Ec!l:!I@!!4!l(!e!!.!4!!
(*ni &e,) yaB dqe P4!s4d k{rrr
m &rd &'j:dr k@ dsu d3u dst (rl
a ia oni an bds nqzru kntu @xdntu tu Fnqcrv@ dor d& oa
fuNpqrgbrrd{PrufulkEiaokfrfundh4$'s&gineadida&Ln
pNr!(2)wNo i rdu rr4joPsrDiudrPNo , rdff terh P6d I6
a/Pe. cr@r rldsa 25 Met tra2
A&Fi mtr ndeh ek,m lii3kd P.iln
d,[. dl Fmoh@trF tMg oij
aidis Mn Pdm dd :
..-;,deL.-., --.. ""b

25. Mnu! Mlj€rs tun PrA mlnbhr
PqohdP,funhgMlawtUgy
Nlmdafr,bo,dll,|sy6d1|0fr)
B.rd6dh tur rr4ul dilldra ldojuk dd Mj€h Hlkin PrA eh'r Frr.u,ih
Pd]nbr@la*buldj@dastldol
re75 lo Pd
'
16 hNi r M Dasu
D@FnLnbugkh rnidrryi d:'i m,jdi hen a@a bsrn pctuna
Ddln Fnihbms 6*in
'hgtd
pEnua s&h dirsik d e0 jehs, neouc
dd dtd$dkm saksi yats dhj!6 dd
rid d4d dijdlks bukri da ,id Frb dpdinbmgs

26. bdhi sm4iar &aHhoi urr
15 brn b "Pqc rqd aj i kt4"
p
'k
n.t4.tut ttut tu, stunq ,
Qw)bhnr*hlUhrp.Pih
lgiT.ohqiTqbddgdaltdu!mfuF
DdlfrrdrE osi Majck H*h Aslo
'Mnjd6n ih 7hek4 bl ebq ipd

27. tuhlr^try rture bqd" ktulrryq dqr
rhldaP mnh hk,m
irki da,N0shdktr ssumFLllalrba
lle EolEe mak @g rhr Dtrrkd
odbmF mss$ d du dn uoh&
iuFrell]&a{d4dbdMsonq,
'' kc oE4 lui v.llb nendi E! da
n+k hlhd 4eu ihgrd bndng t q fr$
'' onhtustur lr s tuaai4tu tuhw rwjbu P.furoLa.nbo'diry vhi'
sqsi $b.ti t,k tuhr nrte tuNr t6ta3 k4olih, tu ide robr
6d6 uoro dDqhhr

28. brhr ttur) d,ii I ndonaqtudits eri@d d,h ktpr0$ suBdat dr!*l,
igldb4dig,poditr&k$Fkldo$l
ohd diualbhi uht n€n6q'h! mrrn
4ai bun p4r-p6r ,{Ebr ddd
utsqtsu bNdl bhs vq i tutr Dqd qr bqi@ rsshurru d4 dtl
uNtukr '@tu
rrtqntua b@t tuk' i@rt
tt qqt tua 6d dor diloturt hkk hk
(Fht) rou stuidq (6!h P6k) d
fnisaBar mj€Ls hkrm bhdi4, ks
kxsa ceai mrd ddd nd rwallb

29. dis F3 dnjuh dch Pos{ bak di
ljiskd'eieimuPUdl]4kn6dig
elo@No I rdu 2006 F LU No I
sqDu Ffrnbq{ d! !n pduu Mlj
1+'bmae[uDmpqLjiu4rls
Mnis H*im PrA lue ,t* wEPdi
yeg dird*m dsn Frcqau sesLnsm rhh dntu &ro udu&mdmg (iil'
k+str@) N{nuirs dq,hu dosn
v mah Agu4 rnh DroDFdLnbaaslh knbri rewrl (pogi{g!in) k+ds
Mjer s H*in ,us nm c e{km 'i la€u doki dd ftn!.iinb4le
Dn'nbrde kmbdr riqnhdsl kq.da
Mdkand A&4 [{gaE ki.D! M,
&hgfk!ioDbiEahdIhlhnFgbesgbh