Compare and Contrast

1. Addie & Dick and
Carey Model
Hilda Farquharson

2. Addie Model
 Piskurich (2006) describes the Addie Model in
5 components as shown in the Figure 1.1
Figure 1.1
Addie Model

3. Dick and Carey Model
 Husain (2014) states that Dick and Carey
Model “promotes a system view of instruction
instead of viewing instruction as a sum of
isolated parts.”
Figure 1.2 Forest, E

4. Comparison
 According to Husain (2014) both models use
a system that determine learning or outcome
in designing the curriculum.

5. Figure 1.3
Ciesiolka, Silvas, Alexander
(2006)

6. Difference
 Addie is more systematic. The steps must be
followed in sequential order or the outcome is
likely to change.
 The Dick and Care comprises of two form of
evaluations-formative and summative. This
allows consistent revision. It is more data
driven and is used to assess weakness at
every state.
Figure 1.4

7. Addie Model
Advantage & Challenge
 The Addie Model can be used with many
types of business.
 The challenge is that all of the phases are
necessary and none of the steps can be
eliminated.

8. Dick & Carey Model
Advantage & Challenge
 The advantage is that the method has two
spots for evaluations. The first evaluations
concentrates on revision and the second
evaluation is used to determine what was
effective and in effective.
 Husain (2014) states that the objectives must
be clear and measurable otherwise it
becomes a weakness.

9. References
 Addie Model (2018). Retrieved March 16th, 2018
from http://gin-my.com/addie-model/
 Ciesiolka, J., Silvas, K., Alexander, A. (2006)
Instructional System Design. Retrieved March 16th
2018 from http://slideplayer.com/slide/6192277/
 Forest, E. (2018) Dick and Carey Model.
Retrieved March 16th, 2018 from
https://educationaltechnology.net/dick-and-carey-
instructional-model/