Vip Call Girls Vasant Kunj ➡️ Delhi ➡️ 9999965857 No Advance 24HRS Live
Flexigroup (FXL) - initiation report
1. BBY Limited
FinancialServices
FLEXIGROUP LIMITED
Economic moat, competitive advantage and growth options - attractively priced!
Recommendation: BUY
Investment Summary
Warren Buffett once said: “The key to investing is determining the competitive advantage
of any given company and, above all, the durability of that advantage. The products or
services that have wide, sustainable moats around them are the ones that deliver rewards
to investors”.
We believe Flexigroup Limited (FXL) has a uniquely attractive business model and
sustainable competitive advantages to satiate even Warren’s discerning investment
appetite. Recent performance, including the Certegy acquisition, has exceeded
expectations. We initiate coverage with a BUY recommendation and 12-month share
price target of A$1.92 (per DDM).
Attractive business model characteristics include: (i) attractive position within an
attractive industry (Porter’s Five Forces analysis); (ii) pricing power, manifest in high
and growing fee income and ROE >25%; (iii) product differentiation; (iv) strong
customer/retailer value propositions; and (v) scalability into adjacent segments and
new geographies.
FXL’s scalability and current price-value discount indicates investors implicitly receive
a “free” call option on multiple strategic growth options. We analyse ten strategic
growth options.
One leading indicator of when to buy stocks working through a bad debt cycle is when
the rate of increase in impaired loans slows (ie. negative second derivative). This trend
was evident in FXL’s FY09 results and also the major banks. This reinforces our BUY
conviction.
Source: FXL
George Gabriel, CFA
+612 9226 0091
ggg@bby.com.au
8 September 2009
ASX: FXL
Share Price:
A$1.45
Number of Shares:
238.9M
Market Capitalisation:
A$346.4M
Average Monthly
Turnover:
A$5.0M
12 Month High/Low:
A$1.70 / A$0.21
GICs Industry Group:
Diversified Financials
2. b
2 BBY Limited 8 September 2009
FLEXIGROUP LIMITED
Table of Contents
INVESTMENT SUMMARY...................................................................................................................................................3
FINANCIAL FORECASTS...................................................................................................................................................4
BUSINESS OVERVIEW.......................................................................................................................................................5
Executive Summary ........................................................................................................................................................ 5
Business Overview.......................................................................................................................................................... 6
Certegy Acquisition ....................................................................................................................................................... 10
INVESTMENT CONSIDERATIONS...................................................................................................................................11
Broker Recommendations............................................................................................................................................. 11
Bearish Drivers.............................................................................................................................................................. 11
Impairment Expense Outlook ........................................................................................................................................ 12
Bullish Investment Case................................................................................................................................................ 14
Bearish Investment Case .............................................................................................................................................. 14
VALUATION ......................................................................................................................................................................15
Volumes ........................................................................................................................................................................ 15
Net Interest Margin........................................................................................................................................................ 16
Sensitivity Analysis........................................................................................................................................................ 16
EARNINGS ANALYSIS .....................................................................................................................................................17
Earnings Driver Trend Analysis..................................................................................................................................... 17
Fee and Other Income .................................................................................................................................................. 17
Du Pont Analysis........................................................................................................................................................... 17
Earnings Quality............................................................................................................................................................ 18
FY09 Results................................................................................................................................................................. 23
FY10F Guidance ........................................................................................................................................................... 24
CORPORATE STRATEGY................................................................................................................................................25
Competitor Analysis ...................................................................................................................................................... 25
Competitive Strategy..................................................................................................................................................... 25
Value Proposition – Consumer and Retailer ................................................................................................................. 25
Porter’s Five Forces Analysis........................................................................................................................................ 26
SWOT Analysis ............................................................................................................................................................. 28
COMPETITIVE ADVANTAGE ...........................................................................................................................................29
Identifying Competitive Advantage................................................................................................................................ 29
Sources of FXL’s Competitive Advantage..................................................................................................................... 29
Revenue and Funding Model ........................................................................................................................................ 30
FXL Debt Facilities ........................................................................................................................................................ 32
TEN STRATEGIC GROWTH OPTIONS............................................................................................................................33
BOARD AND MANAGEMENT ..........................................................................................................................................34
Board............................................................................................................................................................................. 34
Management ................................................................................................................................................................. 34
Executive Options ......................................................................................................................................................... 35
Dilution scenario............................................................................................................................................................ 35
TIMELINE OF KEY EVENTS.............................................................................................................................................36
RETAIL SALES .................................................................................................................................................................37
Retail Market Overview ................................................................................................................................................. 37
Harvey Norman Overview ............................................................................................................................................. 40
3. b
8 September 2009 BBY Limited 3
FLEXIGROUP LIMITED
INVESTMENT SUMMARY
We initiate with a BUY
and A$1.82 price
target.
Warren Buffett once said: “The key to investing is determining the competitive advantage of
any given company and, above all, the durability of that advantage.
The products or services that have wide, sustainable moats around them are the ones that
deliver rewards to investors”. We believe Flexigroup Limited (FXL) has the competitive
advantages to satiate even Warren’s discerning investment appetite.
We initiate coverage with a BUY recommendation and share price target of
A$1.92 (per DDM).
Attractive business model characteristics include:
− Attractive position, attractive industry (Porter’s Five Forces analysis).
− Pricing power − manifest in high fee income, ROE >15% and EBIT margins >20%.
Charts 2,3 and 8.
− Product differentiation. Total product solutions approach provides competitive
differentiation.
− Sustainable competitive advantage.
− Highly scalable into adjacent product segments and new geographies.
Upside earnings risks include: (i) new product volume growth (eg. BLINK internet
broadband); (ii) impairment expense normalisation; (iii) fee income growth;
(iv) net interest margin normalisation; and (v) multiple strategic growth call options.
One leading indicator of when to buy stocks working through a bad debt cycle is when
the second derivative of impaired asset growth turns negative. This trend was evident in
FXL’s FY09 results. The trend is reinforced in current major bank trading updates. This
reinforces our BUY conviction.
FXL’s scalability and current price-value discount suggests today’s investors implicitly
receive a “free” embedded call option on multiple strategic growth options. Refer “Ten
Strategic Growth Options” discussion.
Certegy’s performance has exceeded expectations. Originally expected to lose A$1.5M
in Year 1, it generated +A$0.2M instead. Refer “Certegy Acquisition”.
Concentration risks are diminishing through increased product range and distribution
channel diversification. Following the Certegy acquisition: (i) the Harvey Norman channel
has reduced from 51% (FY06) to approx 25% (FY09) of total sales volumes; and (ii) the
computer/electrical category has reduced from 90% revenue to approx. 45%.
The confluence of bearish drivers which drove FXL’s recent de-rating is now well
mitigated. FXL was down 93% from peak-trough (A$2.90 on 31 Jan 07 to A$0.21 on 17
Nov 08). Refer “Bearish Drivers”.
We analyse: (i) competitive advantage: (ii) competitive strategy; (iii) Porter’s Five Forces; (iv)
Du Pont; (v) value proposition; (vi) SWOT; (vii) strategic growth options; (viii) valuation
sensitivity; and (ix) value driver time series trend analysis.
5. b
8 September 2009 BBY Limited 5
FLEXIGROUP LIMITED
BUSINESS OVERVIEW
Executive Summary
We initiate with a BUY
recommendation and
A$1.93 price target.
FXL is a leading provider of point of sale lease finance products in Australia and New Zealand,
focusing on sub-A$10,000 transactions through third party retail chains. FXL recently acquired the
Certegy retail finance business, enhancing FXL’s product, channel and customer diversification.
We initiate coverage of Flexigroup Limited (FXL) with a BUY recommendation and 12-month price
target of A$1.92 (DDM valuation). BBY’s BUY recommendation is based on:
(i) Attractive business model – high earnings quality, highly scalable, multiple strategic growth
options, pricing power, barriers to entry, multiple revenue streams and established
infrastructure. Table 1.
(ii) Valuation upside − 32% upside from the current A$1.45 to BBY’s DDM valuation.
(iii) Diminishing downside risks. Table 2.
TABLE 1: ATTRACTIVE BUSINESS MODEL
Attribute Description
Pricing power Demonstrated ability to raise prices and fee income, despite
recession.
Fee-based income generation Fee-based income has increased from 23.5% (FY06) to 37.4%
(FY09).
Barriers to entry Customer database, exclusive distribution channels, IT
infrastructure, sales and marketing culture, funding model, brand,
product innovation. Refer “Barriers to Entry” below.
Multiple revenue streams FXL generates lease interest; application fees; monthly account
fees; residual payments and sale of leased products to third
parties. Refer “revenue and funding model” below.
Highly scalable Multiple growth options exist. Refer “Strategic Growth Options”.
Established corporate infrastructure Over 1M discrete customer profiles.
High cashflow generation Unique funding model generates upfront cashflow from lenders
when leases are written. Figure 2.
FXL has an attractive
business model.
High quality of earnings. High translation of accounting earnings to cashflow. Chart 9.
Source: BBY
The bear case is now
less compelling.
We believe the bear case is not compelling. Table 2 summarises the bear case which drove FXL
down 93%, from A$2.90 (Jan 07) to A$0.20 (Nov 08).
TABLE 2: KEY RISKS AND MITIGANTS
Risk Probability Impact Mitigant
Concentration risks.
Refer “Product Mix”
below.
Low Medium Certegy has increased diversification of:
(i) distribution channel;
(ii) retail customer base; and
(iii) product category.
Funding risk. Low High (i) Maintained funding through the credit crisis,
including Certegy acquisition finance.
(ii) Nascent capital market recovery.
(iii) Existing facilities accommodate forecast volumes.
Certegy dilution.
Refer “Certegy” below.
Low Low Performance exceeding expectations.
Slowing retail sales.
Refer “retail sales”
below.
Medium Medium (i) BBY forecasts discount guidance.
(ii) Flat Flexirent volumes forecast.
(iii) Cyclical risks diminishing (stimulus and cycle).
Impairment expense. Medium Medium (i) Second derivative impaired assets negative.
(ii) Unemployment peak cycle risks diminishing.
Source: BBY.
6. b
6 BBY Limited 8 September 2009
FLEXIGROUP LIMITED
Business Overview
Product Mix
The FXL Group
comprises three
segments:
(i) Flexirent;
(ii) Certegy; and
(iii) BLINK.
FXL comprises two businesses: (i) Certegy (45% revenue); and (iii) Flexirent (55% revenue).
Chart 1 summarises revenue contribution per segment.
FXL provides consumer finance across 35 retail segments, including electrical, home
improvement and jewellery. Since the Oct 08 Certegy acquisition, FXL has reduced its reliance
on the computer/electrical category from 90% revenue to approx. 45%. Figure 1 illustrates the
size of the point of sale market by segment.
BLINK is the emerging mobile broadband product (refer “Strategic Growth Options” below).
Table 3 below compares Flexirent, Certegy and BLINK.
CHART 1: REVENUE BY PRODUCT MIX (FY09)
FXL has expanded its
product range to reduce
concentration risk and
create earnings growth
options.
Home
Improvement
12%
Electrical 9%
Furnishing 9%
Lending 8%
Medical 2%
Computer
36%
Other 12%
Jewellery
12%
Source: BBY, FXL.
Certegy Customer and Product Segments
Certegy’s average lease value is A$1,600, with an average lease term of 16 months. The
product range comprises approx. 45% of total FXL revenue and includes:
12% jewellery (engagement rings);
12% home improvement (eg. sheds, building, solar panels, pools, shutters,
renovations etc);
9% furnishings;
2% medical; and
10% other.
Certegy targets customers who are home owners as this generally reduces credit risk and
suggests they can provide the requisite deposit.
7. b
8 September 2009 BBY Limited 7
FLEXIGROUP LIMITED
Flexirent Customer and Product Segments
Flexirent lease terms range from 12-48 months (36 months average), with an average lease
value of A$2k (max A$20k). The product range comprises approx 55% of total FXL revenue
and includes:
36% computer;
9% electrical;
8% lending; and
2% other.
The average customer is male (>60%), aged 35-44, employed, with a mortgage and annual
income of A$30-60k.
BLINK – emerging growth product
BLINK and Certegy are
future growth drivers.
BLINK bundles sub-$1,200 notebooks with mobile internet broadband plans. It is a fast
growing product segment; FXL estimates total industry activations of 70,000 per month, and
industry CAGR of 26% over the next five years.
BLINK was launched in retailers in Feb 2009. In 2H09, FXL averaged 3,000 connections per
month. BLINK comprised 13% of total volumes and up to 10% by value.
Together, BLINK and Certegy (51% of total 2H09 unit volume and 62% by value) are FXL’s
future growth drivers.
BLINK is sold through Harvey Norman (HVN), Bing Lee, The Good Guys and other retailers.
The new products are Blink Nomad and Blink Bundle.
(i) Blink Nomad is a month to month contract mobile broadband plan. The customer
purchases a wireless USB modem and a gigabyte (GB) usage plan. FXL’s product
differentiation is via a free equipment loan service to customers should their
laptop/computer ever be in for repairs.
(ii) Blink Bundle bundles mobile broadband with a laptop into one monthly payment
(like a mobile phone plan) and includes a free equipment loan and protection against
theft, accidental loss and damage.
Other Product Segments
“Other” products include air-conditioners, IT, office equipment, brown goods, TVs, game
consoles, SatNav/GPS etc.
TABLE 3: COMPARING FLEXIRENT AND CERTEGY
Flexirent Certegy BLINK
FY09 new business A$168M p.a A$195M p.a Est. A$20M p.a.
# Contracts 100,000 pa 150,000 pa TBD (launch Feb 09)
Ave. ticket value A$2,200 A$1,600 A$480
Retail Outlets 5,600 1,400 350
Customers 350,000 725,000 Est. 36,000 pa
Key Products Computer / Electrical Home Furnishings &
Renovations
Jewellery
Mobile broadband
Laptops
Source: BBY, FXL.
8. b
8 BBY Limited 8 September 2009
FLEXIGROUP LIMITED
FIGURE 1: VOLUME OF POINT OF SALE MARKETING BY MARKET SECTOR
Source: FXL, 18 Feb 09.
Barriers to Entry
FXL enjoy several
barriers to entry.
Barriers to entry include:
Distribution agreements. Customer database. Approx. 1M unique customers.
Sales, marketing and training capability. Focused on “pushing” sales at point-of-sale,
upselling and rapid point of sale credit approvals. FXL works closely with retail channel
partners to co-ordinate marketing campaigns and develop product bundles.
IT platforms. Include customer databases, web-based rewards systems (“Flexichips”),
interface with retailers etc.
Regulatory compliance. FXL has internal systems to comply with taxation, consumer credit
and privacy codes.
Credit system. FXL has developed a proprietary credit scoring and collections systems.
Distribution Channels
FXL has over 11,000
channel partners.
FXL has over 11,000 distribution channel partners, including:
Harvey Norman (HVN)
– Distribution agreement through to 2015.
– FXL has reduced its channel concentration risk post the Certegy acquisition, with
HVN’s sales contribution reducing from 51% in FY06 to approx. 25%.
9. b
8 September 2009 BBY Limited 9
FLEXIGROUP LIMITED
FXL’s ideal distribution
partner:
(i) sells low priced
products;
(ii) has sales focused,
often commission-
based staff who
respond well to
training.
Noel Leeming – Similar to HVN, based in New Zealand (NZ). Over 80 retail stores
throughout NZ, specialising in consumer electronics through “Noel Leeming” and
“Bond & Bond” brands. Annual sales over NZ$500M.
Bing Lee – Electrical retailer, 37 stores through NSW and the ACT. FXL has a three year
distribution agreement.
The Good Guys – One of the largest electrical and white goods retailers in Australia, with
88 stores nationally. FXL has a three year distribution agreement (approx. two years
remain).
Certegy – 5,400 retailer network.
Travel agents – Agreements with Flight Centre and Stella Travel from FY08.
Other retail – Apple Centres, bicycle retailers etc.
Sales and Marketing Culture
Strong sales and
marketing culture.
FXL’s sales culture is evident through:
Sales staff rewards programs. FXL provides “Flexichip” bonuses (proprietary “frequent
flyer” type loyalty scheme).
Sales staff training programs. Staff are trained direct by FXL on product campaigns, FXL
processes etc, selling skills etc.
Retailer incentives. Retailers receive rebates for achieving sales volume targets.
Direct marketing. FXL leverages its extensive customer database to profile the market,
driving upsell and repeat business. In FY08, there were 65,000 new customers and 35,000
repeat purchases. Approx. 30% p.a. of new volumes are from existing FXL customers.
Channel partner marketing integration. FXL’s finance solutions are integrated into channel
partners’ marketing strategies and new product launches (eg. FXL had a range of financing
solutions and bundles ready for the initial release of X-box).
Sales Cycle
FXL drives sales
through the four stages
of the sales cycle.
FXL sells “payments
not a price”.
FXL drives the four steps in the sales process:
1. Pre-sale
Staff training. Trains sales staff and incentivises using reward-based schemes
(“Flexichips”).
Co-marketing program. FXL’s creative marketing team (c. 30-40 staff) work FXL
promotions into channel partners’ schedule and new product launches.
2. Point-of-sale
Sales strategies include: (i) add-on products; (ii) up-sales; (iii) increased credit limits where
possible; (iv) “while you wait” credit approval; and (v) selling “payments not a price”.
3. During the lease
Direct customer marketing for cross-sell and repeat sales.
FXL area managers promote in-store training of retailers’ staff.
Sales process quality control. A “mystery shopper” program assesses the knowledge base
of individual retail staff.
4. Lease residual – At lease end, there are four options:
Upgrade to another product, encouraged by waiver of last three payments on
existing lease.
Purchase the goods at a price set by FXL (the majority of outcomes).
Stop lease payments and return the goods.
Become “inertia renters” ie. continue the payments.
10. b
10 BBY Limited 8 September 2009
FLEXIGROUP LIMITED
High Operating Leverage and Scalability
FXL has a highly scalable business model given its:
Limited per unit marginal variable cost;
Business model transportable to new products and geographies; and
Existing operating infrastructure supportive of increased volumes.
Certegy Acquisition
Certegy acquisition
increases
diversification, scale
and expands the
customer base.
On 13 Oct 08, FXL acquired Certegy’s business and selected assets, but not its existing loan
portfolio. Certegy increased FXL’s diversification, scale and customer base. The Certegy
acquisition was for A$31.4M comprising:
A$15M cash;
A$15M interest only subordinated vendor note with final maturity extendible to three years;
and
3M FXL shares.
Certegy’s performance
has exceeded
expectations.
Since the acquisition, Certegy has exceeded FXL’s original expectations. Originally expected
to lose A$1.5M in Year 1, it made A$0.2M instead. FY10F guidance is A$268M new volume,
and +A$7.2M NPAT (A$6.0M NPAT post goodwill amortisation) as the Certegy portfolio
reaches steady state.
Key features of the Certegy business:
“No interest ever” provider of finance. That is, products are de facto under lay-by, with FXL
receiving its margin from the retailer, not the consumer.
150,000 transactions p.a.; 1,400 merchants.
Reduces credit risk by: (i) targeting home owners; and (ii) requiring a deposit of 10-25%.
Includes one of two major cheque guarantee businesses in Australia and New Zealand
(approx 10% earnings), offered in 4,500 merchants through 16,000 outlets.
11. b
8 September 2009 BBY Limited 11
FLEXIGROUP LIMITED
INVESTMENT CONSIDERATIONS
Broker Recommendations
The price-value gap in FXL is partially explained by limited sell-side analyst coverage.
TABLE 4: BROKER RECOMMENDATIONS
Firm Date Recommendation Target Price
BBY 07/09/09 Buy A$1.92
Ord Minnett 29/07/09 Buy A$1.46
GSJBW 21/08/09 Buy A$2.40
UBS 20/08/09 Buy A$1.55
Foresight 18/02/09 Hold A$0.40
ABN AMRO 26/08/08 Hold A$0.53
Source: Bloomberg. Note that neither Foresight nor ABN AMRO have published research on FXL for many
months. It is not clear whether their equity research coverage is continuing.
Bearish Drivers
The confluence of bear
market drivers which
drove the FXL de-rating
is now less cogent.
Applying small cap
index FY10F PE to FXL
implies a share price of
A$2.19.
We believe that the bearish stock drivers which drove FXL’s de-rating are now less compelling.
A confluence of bearish drivers drove FXL down 93% peak-trough (A$2.90 on 31 Jan 07 to A$0.21
on 17 Nov 08). These bearish drivers were:
(i) Small cap market liquidity discount. As the market re-rates, we believe this will be unwound.
Currently, ASX200 FY10F PE is 16.3x and the ASX Small Ordinaries index is 14.4x. This
compares with FXL’s FY10F PE of 12.5x. Applying the 14.4x FY10F index average PE to FXL
implies a share price of A$2.19. Indeed, FXL arguably warrants a premium to the Small Ords
Index, given its attractive business model.
(ii) Cyclical rotation out of retail stocks. FXL should benefit as portfolios are re-positioned to for
beta optimisation.
(iii) Refinance risk perception discount. At the height of the GFC, FXL received A$200M funding
for the Certegy business. Refer “FXL Debt Facilities” below.
(iv) Complex business models out of favour. Though FXL is not “complex” per se, understanding
the Loss Reserve, multiple product lines and modelling cash flows across multiple portfolios
over an average run-down period of 4 years requires some effort. It appears that FXL was
(unfairly) tarred with the same blemished brush as Babcock and Brown Ltd, Allco Group etc.
(v) Credit risk concerns. Refer “impairment expense” below.
(vi) Initial EPS dilution from Certegy acquisition. Given FXL acquired the Certegy cost base, but
not its existing portfolio, Certegy was expected to be EPS dilutive in Year 1. Some investors
have been waiting for evidence of successful acquisition integration prior to investing in FXL.
12. b
12 BBY Limited 8 September 2009
FLEXIGROUP LIMITED
Impairment Expense Outlook
BUY signal for lending
stocks: when the
second derivative of
impaired asset growth
turns negative.
This trend is evident
across the major banks
and FXL.
FXL’s impairment expense losses are limited to the Loss Reserve, with excess losses borne by the
Funders, though FXL’s margins are impacted. FXL writes off or recognises a 100% allowance for
losses for all leased and loans greater than 90 days past due.
One leading indicator of when to buy a lending-driven stock working through the bad debt
cycle is when the second derivative of impaired asset growth turns negative (ie. the rate of
increase in impaired assets slows). This trend was evident in FXL’s FY09 results. This trend
(and our BUY conviction) is reinforced by a similar trend among the major banks.
The data supporting our view that the bad debt cycle is turning is:
FXL. The rate of increase in FXL’s past due loans has slowed from 38.0% to 24.5%. Table 5.
CBA. Commonwealth Bank of Australia’s (CBA) rate of increase in non-performing loans (NPLs)
slowed from 179% in 1H09 to 48% in 2H09. (Refer BBY Note on CBA, “Bad debt write-backs
expected”, 18 Aug 09).
WBC. Westpac Banking Corporation’s (WBC) 3Q09 trading update (21 Aug 09) said: "the rate
of increase in stressed exposures is unlikely to be repeated in coming months".
ANZ. Australia and New Zealand Banking Group Ltd (ANZ) impaired loans/gross loans growth
rate was 31% in 1Q09, 18% in 2Q09 and 7% in 3Q09.
The fact that the rate of
increase in impaired
loans is slowing is a
leading indicator of a
peak in the bad debt
cycle.
Other relevant considerations include:
1. Overdue loans/gross loans has increased from 4.6% to 6.3% to 6.9% (FY07 to FY09). The
peak deterioration was from FY07 to FY08. This suggests the outlook is improving. Table 5.
2. The current Loss Reserve/gross loans ratio of 9.1% sufficiently covers BBY’s FY10F
impairment expenses of A$30.8M. Even assuming FY10F impairment expense = 9.1%, our
DDM valuation is A$1.85. Table 5.
3. The FY09 loss reserve balance exceeds FY09 impairment expenses by 1.8x, implying
significant scope for existing reserves to cover the risk of material bad debt deterioration.
Table 5.
4. FY09 impairment expense increase is being driven by the accumulation of the Certegy
portfolio. Lease losses (Flexirent) have stabilised (A$8.3M in both 1H09 and 2H09); personal
loan losses are falling (A$4.2M 1H09, A$3.2M 2H09) whilst this business segment is being
run down, and Certegy losses are increasing (A$0.1M to A$2.7M) whilst the loan portfolio is
accumulating. Table 6.
14. b
14 BBY Limited 8 September 2009
FLEXIGROUP LIMITED
Bullish Investment Case
Reason to BUY FXL include:
Attractive business model. Refer “Business Overview” and “Competitive Advantage”.
Sustainable competitive advantage. Refer “Competitive Advantage”.
Valuation upside. Price is at a 33% discount to BBY’s DDM. Refer “Valuation”.
Bad debt outlook improving. Refer “Impairment Expense Outlook”. Table 6. Chart 7. Existing
loss reserves cover FY09 bad debts by 1.8x. Table 5.
Growth outlook for Certegy and BLINK. Refer “Certegy Acquisition”.
Highly scalable with multiple strategic growth options. Core competencies include sales and
marketing and receivables management. Approx. 30% annual sales from existing customer
database (over 1M customers). Refer “Business Overview” and “Ten Strategic Growth
Options”.
Multiple revenue lines. Refer “Revenue and Funding Model”.
Established distribution relationships, including an exclusive through HVN stores. Refer “Retail
Market Overview”.
Downside risks diminishing. Refer “Bearish Drivers”. Table 7.
Bearish Investment Case
TABLE 7: DOWNSIDE RISK MITIGANTS
Risk Mitigant
Channel
concentration.
HVN contract expires 2015, no guarantee of renewal beyond then.
Noel Leeming contract signed to 2011.
Regulatory risk
(consumer credit,
tax).
New legislation not currently a part of government agenda.
Credit quality Rate of increase in impaired loans is declining.
Limited recourse loans.
Only Certegy bad debts are increasing (matching portfolio
accumulation). Other segments are stabilising or negative (Flexirent,
personal loans). Table 6.
Funding `Refinance risk is mitigated by: (i) five different funders; (ii) average
tenure is 7.5 years and longest 21 years; (iii) funding support was
evident through the GFC; (iv) nascent (debt and equity) capital market
recovery; (v) all facilities reviewed in past 12 months renewed.
Margin risk Historical SPVs have fixed funding costs and fixed lease incomes.
Although new business volumes are being funded with higher cost
funding, some of this is offset by being passed through to customers.
Retail
volumes/interest
rates
Low price elasticity of demand given low payments.
Macroeconomic outlook improving.
Diversified products and distribution channels.
New product growth options.
Source: BBY.
15. b
8 September 2009 BBY Limited 15
FLEXIGROUP LIMITED
VALUATION
BBY’s base case dividend discount model (DDM) valuation of FXL is A$1.92. The key drivers are:
(i) volumes; (ii) net interest margin (NIM); and (iii) impairment expense. We discuss volume and
NIM below. We discussed “impairment expense outlook” above.
Volumes
Table 8 summarises FXL’s volume outlook. Key points are:
BLINK/other upside risk.
– BBY FY10F is A$17M.
– FXL estimates that the Mobile Broadband market is growing at 26% CAGR.
– The upside risk is increased penetration through existing channels (HVN, Bing Lee and
Good Guys) as well as roll-out through new channels (eg. Apple stores).
FXL. BBY forecasts flat lease revenue (in line with guidance) as the credit approach is cautious.
Certegy upside risk.
– BBY FY10F is A$268M, in line with guidance, as Certegy portfolio reaches full maturity in
Jan 2010.
– Certegy has recorded 35% volume CAGR over last five years (prior to acquisition).
Relevant data suggests the retail sales cycle bottomed around Jan-Mar 09:
HVN sales. HVN has experienced positive sales revenue growth (qoq) through the entire
financial crisis. Charts 20 and 21.
Australian Bureau of Statistics (ABS) data indicates that since 1999, monthly lease finance
commitments appear to not fall below a floor of A$50M, implying FXL can expect some
minimum ongoing level of IT leasing business. Chart 18. The growth rate in IT leasing appears
to have bottomed in Jan 09. Chart 19.
Household goods sales appear to have bottomed Mar 09 at -0.7% (coincident with equity
market nadir). Chart 17.
TABLE 8: VOLUMES
Volume (A$M) FY09 FY10F Growth
BLINK/other 54 56 0%
FXL Value 168 168 0%
Certegy Value 195 268 37%
Total new volumes 417 492 18%
Source: BBY, FXL
16. b
16 BBY Limited 8 September 2009
FLEXIGROUP LIMITED
Net Interest Margin
Pricing power to offset
rising borrowing costs.
We expect FXL to exercise pricing power to offset rising borrowing costs. We forecast NIM
contraction in FY10F, then expansion in FY11F. Chart 5.
TABLE 9: NIM TRENDS
Driver (A$M) FY07 FY08 FY09 FY10F FY11F
Average IEA 443.6 480.0 513.4 614.0 722.2
Lease income 126.2 135.2 136.3 159.7 187.8
Lease income/AIEA 28.5% 28.2% 26.5% 26.0% 26.0%
Average cash rate 5.6% 5.7% 3.3% 4.5% 4.5%
Margin to average cash rate 22.8% 22.5% 23.3% 21.5% 21.5%
Source: BBY
Sensitivity Analysis
TABLE 10: SENSITIVITY ANALYSIS
Sensitivity Downside
assumption
Base case Upside assumption
5% volume change is
worth +/- 10cps
FY09F Volumes A$467M A$492M A$517
DDM valuation A$1.81 A$1.92 A$2.04
1% NIM change is
worth +/- 8cps
NIM Down 1% across all
years
FY10F – 14.7%
FY11F – 15.7%
FY12F – 16.2%
FY13F – 17.3%
FY14F – 18.4%
Up 1% across all years
DDM valuation A$1.80 $1.92 $2.00
1% discount rate
change is worth
+/- 20-25cps
Discount rate 13.6% 12.6% 11.6%
DDM valuation $1.73 A$1.92 $2.19
Source: BBY
17. b
8 September 2009 BBY Limited 17
FLEXIGROUP LIMITED
EARNINGS ANALYSIS
Earnings Driver Trend Analysis
We expect ROE to
normalise from FY11F.
Key drivers will be:
(i) impairment
normalisation;
(ii) falling cost of funds;
(iii) rising non-interest
income; and
(iv) Certegy/BLINK
volume growth.
We analyse FXL’s FY09 result and trends in key drivers in Charts 2-13.
Key trends are:
High ROE and ROA. In recent years, ROE has been diluted by impairment expenses, cost of
funds and reduced volumes. As these normalise through FY11F, we expect ROE recovery.
Also, we expect additional non-interest income growth as FXL exercises pricing power for
margin recovery. Charts 2-4. Table 11.
Non-interest income increasing absolutely but stabilising from FY10F as % of total gross
income. Chart 3.
Interest income growth rate declined in FY09, driven by net interest margin compression.
Chart 5.
EPS growth. In FY07, as part of the initial public offering, EPS was diluted by a new 110M share
issue. Going forward, we expect EPS growth to be driven by operating profit margin increase
and impairment expense decline. Charts 7 and 8.
Trend decline in average lease values, offset by rising volumes of new product categories and
rising non-interest income. Charts 11 and 12.
New product sales. BLINK product to drive FY11 volume growth. Expected to be a loss of
approx A$2-3M in FY10, then positive thereafter. Investors should derive some confidence from
Certegy’s performance exceeding management expectations.
Fee and Other Income
Rising fee income
manifests FXL’s pricing
power.
Key drivers of non-interest income include:
Certegy fees ie. In FY09, fee income increased as low value, say A$2-3 per month, account
fees were applied to all Certegy customers.
Interim rental ie. paying upfront for product access prior to official lease commencement.
Protect income ie. insurance.
End of term income including asset sale ie. “inertia” payments.
Du Pont Analysis
We use extended Du Pont for key driver trend analysis. The basic formula is:
ROE = (Operating profit margin * total asset turnover – interest expense rate)
* (financial leverage multiplier * tax retention rate)
Margin expansion is the
key EPS driver.
Du Pont analysis indicates that margin expansion is the key driver of ROE/EPS growth. Margin
expansion is driven by: (i) declining impairment expense; (ii) recovering net interest margin; and
(iii) non-interest income growth.
18. b
18 BBY Limited 8 September 2009
FLEXIGROUP LIMITED
TABLE 11: DU PONT ANALYSIS
Du Pont Analysis FY06 FY07 FY08 FY09 FY10F FY11F
ROA (%) 4.1% 3.7% 5.1% 4.5% 4.2% 4.6%
ROE (%) 38.3% 27.9% 32.7% 27.5% 26.6% 28.9%
Operating profit margin (EBIT/sales) 54.2% 53.7% 55.2% 51.6% 55.6% 60.3%
Total asset turnover (sales/assets) 0.23x 0.22x 0.26x 0.25x 0.25x 0.24x
Interest expense rate
(interest expense/assets)
-6.5% -6.1% -7.0% -6.6% -7.8% -7.9%
Financial leverage multiplier
(assets/equity)
9.2x 7.5x 6.5x 6.1x 6.4x 6.3x
Tax retention rate (1-t) 71.4% 63.5% 68.2% 69.5% 70.0% 70.0%
ROE 38.3% 27.9% 32.7% 27.5% 26.6% 28.9%
Source: BBY
Earnings Quality
FXL is generating high
quality earnings
growth.
High earnings quality is generally derived from: (i) high accounting-cash earnings translation; and
(ii) increased sales volume, unit pricing and fee income. Conversely, low quality earnings is:
(i) growth from unsustainable sources such as cost cutting or one-off gains; or (ii) accounting
shenanigans.
We believe FXL is generating high quality earnings given:
(i) High translation of accounting earnings to net operating cashflow. Chart 17.
(ii) Earnings growth driven by sustainable earnings drivers (non-interest income, new product
categories, NIM recovery, volume growth).
CHART 2: ROE AND ROA TRENDS
0%
5%
10%
15%
20%
25%
30%
35%
40%
45%
FY06 FY07 FY08 FY09 FY10F FY11F
0%
1%
2%
3%
4%
5%
6%
ROE (%) LHS ROA (%) RHS
Source: BBY
21. b
8 September 2009 BBY Limited 21
FLEXIGROUP LIMITED
CHART 9: ACCOUNTING PROFIT VS OPERATING CASHFLOW
0%
20%
40%
60%
80%
100%
120%
FY06 FY07 FY08 FY09
(A$M)
Operating cashflow/accounting profit (%)
Source: BBY. Accounting profit adds back share payment expenses of FY07 A$6.2m and A$2.2M in FY08.
CHART 10: EBIT INTEREST COVER
1.70x
1.75x
1.80x
1.85x
1.90x
1.95x
2.00x
2.05x
2.10x
FY07 FY08 FY09 FY10F FY11F
Ebit/interestcover(x)
Source: BBY.
CHART 11: FLEXIRENT AVERAGE LEASE VALUE (A$M)
$1,900
$1,950
$2,000
$2,050
$2,100
$2,150
$2,200
$2,250
$2,300
$2,350
1H08 2H08 1H09 2H09
Flexirentaverageleasevalue(A$M)
-8%
-6%
-4%
-2%
0%
2%
4%
6%
%growthinaverageleasevalue
Source: BBY. Note: IT/electrical prices increased in 2H09 due to the lagged effect of rising import costs from a
falling A$ being passed onto consumers. We expect this trend to reverse in future periods.
22. b
22 BBY Limited 8 September 2009
FLEXIGROUP LIMITED
CHART 12: GROUP PORTFOLIO AVERAGE LEASE VALUE (A$M)
200,000
220,000
240,000
260,000
280,000
300,000
320,000
340,000
360,000
380,000
400,000
FY07 FY08 FY09
$1,000
$1,100
$1,200
$1,300
$1,400
$1,500
$1,600
$1,700
$1,800
$1,900
No. contracts (LHS) Average $ value/contract (RHS)
Source: BBY
23. b
8 September 2009 BBY Limited 23
FLEXIGROUP LIMITED
FY09 Results
FY09 result
demonstrates:
(i) pricing power;
(ii) earnings
diversification;
(iii) scalability; and
(iv) funder support.
Certegy will be the
main FY10 profit driver.
FXL’s FY09 result drivers are illustrated in Chart 13. Lower net interest margin (NIM) and higher
impairment expenses were offset by higher fee income. Certegy generated +A$0.2M profit vs initial
guidance of A$1.5M loss.
The FY09 result demonstrates: (i) pricing power through rising fee income; (ii) diversification of
earnings away from HVN; (iii) scalability through new product category earnings growth (jewellery
and mobile broadband); and (iv) funder support.
Key FY09 result features are:
NPAT. FY09 NPAT increased 4% to A$32.8M vs pcp A$32.3M.
Fee income/total income grew strongly from 30.8% in FY08 to 37.4% in FY09.
Certegy. Since the acquisition, Certegy has exceeded FXL’s original expectations. Original
guidance was a A$1.5M loss in Year 1; it made A$0.2M profit instead. FY10F guidance is
+A$7.2M NPAT (pre-goodwill amortisation) as its portfolio reaches steady state (ie. run off =
new business volume).
Impairment expenses increased 23.9% from A$21.9M FY08 (4.5% of average interest earning
assets) to A$27.2M in FY09F (5.0% of AIEA). BBY FY10F is A$30.9M (5.0% AIEA), then
A$28.8M (4% AIEA) in FY11F.
EPS decline. EPS decline was partially driven by 3M scrip issuance for Certegy acquisition not
offset by an income contribution from Certegy (since the Certegy portfolio was not acquired).
Net interest margin (NIM). NIM fell from 18.8% in FY08 to 17.2% in FY09. We forecast FY10F
15.2% and FY11F 15.2%.
CHART 13: FY09 NPAT DRIVERS (A$M)
32.3 33.5
16.7
-7
-1
-5.3
-2.2
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
FY08 NPAT Fee/other
income
Opex Net interest
income
Bad debts Certegy
expense
FY09 NPAT
A$M
Source: BBY
24. b
24 BBY Limited 8 September 2009
FLEXIGROUP LIMITED
FY10F Guidance
Management’s recent guidance is summarised in Table 12 and described below:
NPAT. A$37-39M, up 13.4% vs FY09. BBY FY09F is A$37.0M.
Certegy. Portfolio reaches steady state in Jan 2010. A$7.2M FY10F NPAT guidance.
Flexirent. Flat lease volumes expected. We believe this is partially due to management’s stated
“cautious approach to credit” and also unemployment concerns.
BLINK. NPAT loss of A$2-3M until FY11 due to subscriber acquisition costs as portfolio
accumulates.
EPS. Cancellation of DRP and dilutive share issuance.
TABLE 12: FY10F GUIDANCE DRIVERS
Driver A$M
FY09 NPAT – starting point 33.5
Add: Certegy guidance 6.0
Less: BLINK ramp-up cost guidance (2.5)
FY10F NPAT guidance 37.0
Source: FXL, BBY
25. b
8 September 2009 BBY Limited 25
FLEXIGROUP LIMITED
CORPORATE STRATEGY
Competitor Analysis
Three main
competitors.
The three main competitors are:
Original equipment manufacturers’ direct leasing. All the major IT hardware brands have
some consumer finance product to facilitate sales eg. Dell, IBM, Technorent and CIT.
GE Money is a major supplier to HVN providing “interest free” plans (similar to Certegy) and
store cards. Domestically, GE has over A$35bn in assets and 4,600 staff serving 3.1M
customers through 10,000 retailers and 120 local branches.
Thinksmart (TSM). An ASX-listed company (market cap A$76M), started ten years ago in
WA. It offers similar consumer IT leasing products to FXL under the Rentsmart brand
through Coles Myer, David Jones, Dick Smith, JB Hi-Fi and Dixons (UK). Approx 70%
revenue is outside Australia, including the UK, Spain, France, Italy and New Zealand.
Competitive Strategy
Product differentiation
strategy confers pricing
power.
FXL has multiple
strategic growth
options.
Product differentiation confers pricing power to FXL. Strategies include:
Total customer solutions approach. FXL provides product bundles and after-sales service
including repairs and temporary replacement of damaged products (“loaner”). Table 13.
High retailer switching costs created through close integration into retailers’ businesses with
sales training, co-ordinated marketing programs, driving repeat sales, sales rewards
programs (“Flexichips”) etc. Table 5.
Product innovation. FXL continually creates new marketing campaigns and product bundles.
Other relevant strategies include:
Channel diversification. HVN channel concentration is reducing from 51% in FY06 to approx.
25% of total sales in FY09.
Product diversification. Computer/electrical products have reduced from approx 90% to less
than 45% revenue. Chart 1.
Refer “Ten Strategic Growth Options” for list of possible strategies.
Consumer value-add. Tables 13.
Retailer value-add. Table 14.
Value Proposition – Consumer and Retailer
TABLE 13: CUSTOMER VALUE PROPOSITION BY SEGMENT
Customers receive
benefits of:
(i) immediate product
access for small regular
outlay; and (ii) total
product solutions.
Customers Value proposition
Individuals (approx 65% total). Immediate product access.
Small regular outlay, improving cashflows.
Tax depreciation possible.
Ongoing “relationship” with retailer through FXL marketing
After-sales service eg. faulty product replacement, “loaner”.
Product bundling
Small business (approx 35%
total).
Cash flow enhancement
Operating lease tax incentives
Asset obsolescence management
Source: BBY
26. b
26 BBY Limited 8 September 2009
FLEXIGROUP LIMITED
TABLE 14: RETAILER VALUE PROPOSITION
Retailers receive
benefits of: (i)
increased sales
volume; (ii) higher
margin; and (iii)
increased staff training
and engagement.
Stakeholder Value proposition
Retailer Increased volumes through FXL marketing focus on
upsell, repeat business and product add-ons
Direct financial incentives paid – flat fee rebate of approx 3-4%
made in cash within 10 days from time lease is signed
Retailer’s sales staff “Flexichips” – sales staff incentive programs
FXL sales and training programs
Source: BBY
Porter’s Five Forces Analysis
FXL is well positioned
in an attractive
industry.
Porter’s Five Forces analysis helps analyse an industry’s competitive intensity.
FXL is well positioned in an attractive industry, suggesting sustainability of high margins, ROE
and competitive advantage. Table 15.
TABLE 15: PORTER’S FIVE FORCES ANALYSIS
This implies high
margins, ROE and
competitive advantage
are sustainable.
Force Risk Impact
1. Threat of substitutes Medium Low/medium
2. Threat of new entrants Low Medium
3. Competitive rivalry Low/medium Medium
4. Customer bargaining power Low Very low
5. Supplier bargaining power Medium Medium/high
Source: BBY
1. Substitute products Risk: Medium Impact: Low/medium
Purported substitutes
are inferior to FXL’s
value proposition.
The general rule is that close substitute products increase price elasticity of demand.
FXL’s substitutes include: (i) credit cards; (ii) direct leasing; and (iii) in-store finance. However, in
our view, purported substitutes are inferior alternatives to FXL’s value proposition because:
Credit card providers do not add value to retailers in the form of sales training, upselling,
direct marketing campaigns, rebates, volume generation, temporary product replacement
(“loaner”), bundled packages etc..
Direct leasing does not provide product bundles, loaners etc.
In-store finance is possibly the greatest substitute risk in that it is available at point-of-sale
and generally as user friendly as FXL finance. However, it still lacks FXL’s value
propositions. Tables 14, 15.
The impact of this risk is low/medium (highest risk is in 2015 when HVN exclusive distribution
agreement expires).
2. New entrants Risk: Low Impact: Medium
New entrant threat is
well mitigated.
This risk is mitigated by:
FXL’s brand equity.
Entry barriers (infrastructure costs, regulatory, IT platform, sales/marketing experience).
Retailer switching costs.
Distribution channel access.
Learning curve, particularly consumer credit database and knowledge.
27. b
8 September 2009 BBY Limited 27
FLEXIGROUP LIMITED
Incumbent competitor response (ie. FXL can leverage its customer base and extensive
retailer network to offer bundles that would be difficult to replicate).
Compliance, e.g. consumer credit, privacy and other government policies.
The long-term impact of this risk is of medium intensity. In the short-term, the risk appears well
mitigated.
3. Intensity of competitive rivalry Risk: Low/medium Impact: Medium
FXL mitigates price-
based competition by
“selling a payment, not
the price”.
FXL has flexibility in
competitive response.
Industry competition is about channel access (ie. “land grab”) and total product solutions, rather
than price-based. Price is less relevant when FXL “sells a payment, not a price”. When the
consumer focuses on (say) A$8 per week, this is less relevant than ticket price. This is evident
in FXL’s high margins and ROE.
The long-term impact of increased competition is of medium intensity. We believe that FXL’s
experience, extensive customer database and broad distribution network positions it well for
protective competitive response in the longer term.
4. Bargaining power of customers Risk: Low Impact: Low
FXL’s retail customers have low bargaining power as they tend to accept funding solutions at
point-of sale for low-value items, and generally focus on regular payment amount, not total ticket
price or implied internal rates of return (ie. >25%).
Given FXL’s diversified lending portfolio, the actions of any one customer will have a low impact.
5. Bargaining power of suppliers Risk: Medium Impact: Medium/High
High switching and
direct competition
costs reduce retail
channel partner
bargaining power.
5A. Bargaining power of retail channel partners Risk: Medium Impact: Medium/High
We analyse FXL’s two suppliers: (i) distribution partners; and (ii) wholesale financiers.
Retail channel partner bargaining power is medium, given high switching and competition costs.
The risk of direct channel partner competition is low given competition would entail direct costs
(IT, marketing and debt collection infrastructure) and indirect opportunity costs (sales staff
training and engagement, direct marketing campaigns, sales volume upside, bundled deals
etc.). Competition costs are likely prohibitive for most retailers except those with material scale
(eg. HVN).
The impact of increased bargaining by retail channel partners would be medium/high. This risk
is mitigated by FXL’s increasing channel diversification.
The risk is that
wholesale financiers:
(i) increase credit
margins; (ii) increase
the loss reserve; and/or
(iii) shift from limited to
full recourse.
5B. Bargaining power of wholesale financiers Risk: Medium Impact: High
Wholesale financier bargaining power is medium, but mitigated by: (i) nascent capital market
recovery; (ii) A$577M drawn debt is diversified across five financiers; and (iii) evident funding
support, manifest through finance being provided for the Certegy acquisition during the GFC.
The impact of increased bargaining by wholesale debt financiers would be high. However, we do
not believe that wholesale debt suppliers would cancel debt facilities, but rather the risks are:
(i) Increased credit margins.
(ii) Increased loss reserve. This would constrain future volume and earnings growth.
(iii) Shift from limited to full recourse lending. This would likely increase FXL’s equity beta, as
FXL becomes more leveraged.
28. b
28 BBY Limited 8 September 2009
FLEXIGROUP LIMITED
SWOT Analysis
Strengths
Barriers to entry – include distribution relationships; customer database; IT platform; channel
partner switching costs
Pricing power – manifest in high margin, high ROE. Table 11.
Limited recourse debt finance – Bad debt losses limited to Loss Reserve. This unique
funding structure generates high cash upfront for FXL and is unlikely to be made generally
available to new entrants.
Weaknesses
Channel partner concentration – 25% total sales through HVN.
Opportunities
New retail product category expansion. Refer “Ten Strategic Growth Options”.
Distribution channel partner expansion – new stores and new geographies.
Threats
Bad debt cycle. We believe the outlook is improving.
Interest rate cycle.
Consumer regulatory reform. Increased point-of-sale disclosure and regulation may limit
volumes.
Unit pricing decline.
29. b
8 September 2009 BBY Limited 29
FLEXIGROUP LIMITED
COMPETITIVE ADVANTAGE
Identifying Competitive Advantage
FXL’s competitive
advantage is manifest
in its pricing power,
high ROE and high
margins.
“You really want [a product] where, if they don’t have it in stock, you want to go across the
street to get it – a differentiated product” – Warren Buffett
Competitive advantage allows a company to sustainably generate excess returns. It is generally
evident through: (i) pricing power; (ii) ROE; and (iii) margins. FXL manifests these financial
indicators.
However, investors should distinguish between competitive advantage and operational efficiency.
Operational efficiency means a company is better than rivals at similar activities.
Competitive advantage means a company is performing better than rivals by: (i) doing different
activities; or (ii) performing similar activities in different ways. Only sustainable competitive
advantage sustains excess returns.
We believe FXL enjoys competitive advantage because its business model is unique.
Sources of FXL’s Competitive Advantage
The basis of
competition is a total
customer solutions
approach (ie. product
bundles, loaners etc),
not price.
Sources of FXL’s competitive advantage are:
Switching costs. Retail channel partners who switch away from FXL face both indirect
opportunity costs (sales staff training and engagement, direct marketing campaigns, bundled
deals etc.) and direct costs (lost sales volume).
Distribution channels. It is difficult for any competitor to replicate:
– long standing/exclusive relationship with HVN;
– ownership of Certegy channel;
– diversified retail distribution channels.
Differentiated product. Refer “Corporate Strategy”.
Sales and marketing core competency. Selling retail structured finance and managing
receivables are FXL’s core competencies.
Customer database. FXL has data on over 1M customers. Approx. 30% of FXL’s deals by
value are repeat customer sales.
Technology. FXL has a bespoke IT platform used for marketing and rewards programs
(“Flexichips”).
Revenue and funding model. FXL enjoys a funding structure that funders are not likely to
replicate. Refer “revenue and funding model” below.
Compliance processes. Privacy, consumer credit and tax codes have been developed over
time.
30. b
30 BBY Limited 8 September 2009
FLEXIGROUP LIMITED
Revenue and Funding Model
Multiple Revenue Streams
FXL generates multiple revenue streams, including:
net interest margin on leases;
application fees;
monthly account fees;
residual payments by lessee; and
sale of leased products to third parties.
Limited Recourse Debt Funding Model and the “Loss Reserve”
FXL’s bad debt exposure
is limited to the Loss
Reserve. Customer loan
defaults are funded out of
the loss reserve
provisions, with excess
losses borne by the
Funder.
FXL’s funding model is unique in that its debt facilities are limited recourse to FXL, ie. FXL’s
losses on customer loans are limited to the Loss Reserve. Losses exceeding the Loss Reserve
are borne by the Funder. The Loss Reserve works as follows:
FXL has five Funders. FXL has a separate special purpose vehicle (SPV) with each Funder.
Lending assets go into the SPV.
The Funder takes security over the SPV’s assets and cashflows.
Different Funders have different % requirements for their specific Loss Reserve ratio. There
are generally six monthly reviews for the SPVs and their loss reserves.
The Loss Reserve is cash on deposit, and accounted for as a debit on FXL’s balance sheet.
It earns interest which is retained as additional loss reserves and contributes to FXL’s P&L.
On default, Funders recover the full loan amount from the Loss Reserve. The defaulted lease
amount is recorded on FXL’s P&L as an impairment expense.
At the end of the lease term, any excess cash in the Loss Reserve is returned to FXL.
Increased credit defaults negatively impact FXL’s profit margin. Also, we would expect that
excessive drawdown on Loss Reserves is likely to result in: (i) higher Loss Reserve margin
requirements going forward; and (ii) higher borrowing rates for FXL.
Cashflow Funding Model
Funding model generates
high upfront cashflow.
Figure 2 illustrates the structure:
Step 1 − Retail product purchased. Assume product Face Value of A$2,200.
Step 2 – Funded Amount Advanced.
– Once lease is signed, within ten days the Funder pays the Funded Amount to the SPV.
– The Funded Amount is calculated as the present value of the lease payments expected
over the life of the lease. In Figure 2, the Funded Amount is A$2,847.
Step 3 − From the Funded Amount, the SPV makes three payments:
– A Loss Reserve provision account (A$285). An agreed % of the funder’s advanced
amount is set aside as a Loss Reserve provision to meet expected defaults. In this
scenario, 10% loss reserve = A$285.
– FXL’s upfront gross cash margin (A$362).
Step 4 – SPV advances product Face Value (A$2,200) to borrower, who pays retailer.
Step 5 – FXL receives upfront cashflow. From FXL’s gross cash margin, it manages:
(i) FXL’s general operating expenses; (ii) makes incentive payments to retailer’s staff
(via “Flexichips” rewards program).
Step 6 – Borrower pays monthly lease payments to SPV.
Step 7 – SPV pays monthly funding cost to Funder. Cost of funds fixed in line with term of
contract.
31. b
8 September 2009 BBY Limited 31
FLEXIGROUP LIMITED
FIGURE 2 FUNDING MODEL – LEASE CASHFLOWS
10
Funding Model – lease cashflows
Funder SPV Borrower
FXL
Loss Reserve
(Cash at bank)
Step 1. Customer purchase
Lease Amt : $2,200
Lease rate : 30%
Term : 36 months
Mthly payment : $91
FXL Cost of Funds : 10%
PV@COF : $2,847
Loss reserve : $285 (@10%)
$91 per month $91 per month
$2,200
Retailer
$2,847
$285 *
Interest
$362 * $2,200
Flexichips
* $362 + $285 = $647 ( = PV of 36
months interest margins @ 20%,
paid up front)
Step 2
Step 3
Step 4
Step 4Step 5
Diagram 1 – typical lease cashflows
Step 6Step 7
Source: BBY.
Cashflow Model
The FXL model generates high cashflow upfront for the following reasons:
Limited growth capex requirement.
High upfront free cashflow generation from funding structure.
High upfront tax depreciation. Taxed as operating leases from FXL’s perspective
(ie. FXL receives the product’s tax depreciation benefits), but accounted for as finance leases.
Funded Amount = lease amount + PV future interest margins (ie. A$2,847).
Accounting
Revenue and cost recognition policies include:
Revenue recognition. Lease finance interest revenue is recognised by applying the interest
rate implicit in leases to the beginning period lease balance receivable. Most other revenue
items (eg. Protect Plan, cheque guarantee, interest on cash balances etc) are accounted for
on an accruals basis (source: note 1(e)(i) June 2009 accounts).
Cost capitalisation and amortisation. Initial direct costs associated with generating leases or
loans are capitalised as a contra asset “unamortised initial direct transaction costs” (against
receivables account) then are amortised generally at 50%/35%/15% over three years.
32. b
32 BBY Limited 8 September 2009
FLEXIGROUP LIMITED
FXL Debt Facilities
FXL has total debt
facilities of A$740M.
FXL has total debt facilities of A$740M. Key details are:
Drawn facilities − A$577M.
Undrawn facilities − A$163M, majority with two year availability, with 12-18 months to run.
Funding vs volume outlook. We estimate FXL will have A$96M in undrawn debt facilities by
the end of FY10F, comprising available debt facilities of A$484M (ie. A$163M undrawn plus
A$321M revolving use of repaid receivables) less new business volume of A$492M plus
Certegy new volumes repaid during FY10F (ie. 36% of new Certegy volume of A$268M plus
50% of BLINK’s A$16M sales value).
Non-recourse. FXL has A$15M in Certegy vendor finance. All other debt is non-recourse.
Funders. The identity of FXL’s five funders is undisclosed; average tenure is 7.5 years.
Debt maturity profile. Chart 14.
Interest expense is increasing. Chart 10 and Table 11.
Cost of funds is increasing − both via rising swap rates and credit margin.
Debt facility extension
could be a re-rating
catalyst.
The terms of FXL’s variable debt facilities (A$106M) are not clear. Chart 14.
FXL says it is “exploring opportunities to increase and restructure facilities to further diversify
base/lower funding costs; access capital markets when they re-open and fund growth
opportunities”.
An announcement on debt facility restructure could be a near-term stock catalyst.
Comparable: Wholesale Mortgage Manager
FXL is analogous to a
mortgage broker who
“white labels” third party
mortgages.
FXL is analogous to a mortgage broker who “white labels” third party mortgages. However, FXL
goes one step further: it both originates leases and manages the underlying cashflow
receivables.
Although FXL has 4.6x debt to equity, we believe this metric over-states financial risk given:
(i) FXL’s unique funding structure (ie. impairment losses are limited recourse to FXL and loan
assets sit in a special purpose vehicle (SPV) which FXL manages on behalf of its Funders); and
(ii) FXL records its SPVs on balance sheet; and (iii) EBIT/interest is approx. 2.0x. Chart 10.
CHART 14: TERM DEBT MATURITY PROFILE
0
50
100
150
200
250
300
Variable 1 year or less 1-2 years 2-3 years 3-4 years over 4 years
Borrowings(A$M)
Source: FXL, BBY.
33. b
8 September 2009 BBY Limited 33
FLEXIGROUP LIMITED
TEN STRATEGIC GROWTH OPTIONS
FXL investors at
current prices implicitly
receive a “free”
embedded call option
on growth.
Historically, FXL has experienced five growth drivers: (i) increased sales volumes;
(ii) price increases; (iii) rising fee and other income; (iv) selling new products; and (v) acquisitions.
Prospectively, FXL’s scalability and current price-value discount suggests today’s investors
implicitly receive a “free” embedded call option on multiple strategic growth options.
We list below some strategic options (from lowest to highest risk):.
1. Increased pricing and fee income.
2. Cross-sell and up-sell to existing customers.
3. Increased operating efficiencies (variable cost reduction). FXL could focus on variable cost
reduction, focusing on settlement costs, call centre productivity, approval processes,
collections procedures etc.
4. Increased operating efficiencies (fixed cost reduction). FXL has consciously not sought to
extract cost synergies from the Certegy-Flexirent integration until the Certegy portfolio/outlook
stabilises.
5. Increased channel penetration (ie. existing products, existing channels). This is the current
strategy for BLINK roll-out. This requires a continuous focus on sales, marketing and training
to maintain cross/up-sell. An example of an opportunity is that FXL has approx. 20%
penetration in the IT market at HVN but <2% in consumer electrical.
6. New products, existing channels. This includes bundling, new product launches (eg. Microsfot
X-box). Figure 1 above illustrates multiple new product growth options.
7. New geographies, existing retailers, existing products. Following retail channel partners into
new geographies (eg. HVN into Europe) is possible.
8. Existing products, new channels. New channels are likely to add cost with unknown upside.
Currently, FXL is sensibly focusing on #5.
9. New products, new channels. In our view, FXL is more likely to launch new products through
existing channels to mitigate risk.
10. Acquisitions. Whilst this could be high risk, Certegy shows that FXL can execute value-adding
acquisitions. Figure 1 illustrates the range of adjacent product segments where FXL could
acquire a leasing business. We do not expect FXL to acquire a “bricks and mortar” retailer
(which would be a poor strategy, in our view). Targets include lease portfolios, insurance and
finance companies.
34. b
34 BBY Limited 8 September 2009
FLEXIGROUP LIMITED
BOARD AND MANAGEMENT
Warren Buffett once said: “When a management with a reputation for brilliance tackles a business with a reputation
for bad economics, it is the reputation of the business that remains intact”.
Fortunately, FXL enjoys both good economics and an experienced management team. We summarise Board/management
experience and also consider executive options below.
Board
Margaret Jackson
Non executive
Chairman
BEc, MBA, Hon LLD (Monash), FCA, FAICD
John DeLano
Managing Director and
CEO
BA
CEO of FXL Group since Dec 08 and CEO of Flexirent since Sep 2003. Former MD of
Avis Australia; Senior VP Operations of Travel Services International (NASDAQ listed).
Andrew Abercrombie
Director
BEc, LLB, MBA
Founding Director of the original Flexirent business in 1991 and CEO until 2003. Experienced
commercial and tax lawyer; founding partner in a legal firm operating in both Sydney and
Melbourne.
Rajeev Dhawan
Director
BCom, ACA, MBA
Currently a partner of Equity Partners with 14 years venture capital/private equity experience.
Formerly represented Colonial First State Private Equity on the FXL board and has continued in
an advisory capacity following Colonial’s exit.
John Skippen
Director
ACA
Finance Director and Chief Financial Officer of Harvey Norman Holdings Limited for 12 years.
Over 30 years experience as a chartered accountant.
Management
Garry McLennan
CFO
24 years of financial services experience with 23 years at HSBC Australia, including 10 years as
CFO and four years as COO and Executive Director
Pearl Laughton
CIO
15 years of experience managing the development of large scale IT systems and delivering
commercial grade software. Held senior IT management roles at Travel Services International
and Amadeus in the US
Doc Klotz
Head of Operations
20 years in executive management, sales, operations and business integration 2002-2006 he was
Senior VP of Hotels.com/Expedia. Previously he was SVP of Sales and Operations for Travel
Services International
Marilyn Conyer
Head of Marketing
Over 20 years experience, mostly recently as Marketing Director of Optus Business. Former
General Manager, Products and Marketing at Hutchison and held senior marketing roles with
Alcatel and Telstra
35. b
8 September 2009 BBY Limited 35
FLEXIGROUP LIMITED
Executive Options
Management is
incentivised to exceed
the A$2 share price.
As at 30 Jun 09, FXL had approximately 17.7M unissued ordinary shares subject to options and
performance rights as follows:
Options. 9.2M options with 31 Dec 2011 to 31 Dec 2012 expiries and a A$2.08 weighted
average exercise price (exercise prices range from A$1.59 and A$2.93). Given our DDM
valuation, we do not assume that these options cause any dilution.
Performance rights. The remaining 8.5M shares are subject to performance hurdles, with
expiry dates between 31 Dec 2012 and 31 Dec 2014. There are multiple hurdles and tranches
disclosed in the annual report.
Key details of the CEO John DeLano’s options are:
13M options with an exercise price of A$2 and expiries ranging from 31 Dec 2011 to
31 Dec 2012. 7.6M options relate to shares currently held by the founders exercisable on
similar terms so their exercise would not be dilutionary.
7,500,000 deferred shares; and
2,174,820 performance rights.
Dilution scenario
A reasonable share
dilution scenario would
result in a DDM
valuation of A$1.83 per
share.
Our base case scenario does not discount dilution through exercise of Board/management
options. However, if we assume the scenario where say 50% of performance rights (4.25M) and
the CEO’s deferred shares (7.5M) are exercised, BBY’s DDM would be diluted to A$1.83 per
share.
36. b
36 BBY Limited 8 September 2009
FLEXIGROUP LIMITED
TIMELINE OF KEY EVENTS
1988 FXL established, originally offering IT equipment vendor finance.
1995 Secured distribution agreement with HVN. Then grew into a small ticket lease
provider, specialising in IT equipment.
1997 FXL opened in New Zealand.
1998 Consumer lease product launched.
2003 Introduction of professional management (John Delano – CEO) and corporatisation.
2004 Investment in core reporting, collection and credit scoring systems.
2005 Ezyway product launched for the electrical channel.
2006 Five year contract with Noel Leeming signed.
12 Dec 06 First listed on the ASX.
13 Oct 08 Certegy acquisition completed.
28 Jul 09 Earnings upgrade.
20 Aug 08 FY09 results.
2015 Expiry of formalised contracts with HVN.
Source: FXL
37. b
8 September 2009 BBY Limited 37
FLEXIGROUP LIMITED
RETAIL SALES
Retail Market Overview
IBIS expects retail trade to
increase at 2.5% pa
average over five years to
2013-14.
Retail sales have increased by an average of 1.8% over the past five years, despite headwinds
including rising: (i) interest rates; (ii) fuel prices; and (iii) inflation. Chart 15.
IBIS expects retail trade to increase at an average 2.5% pa over the five years to 2013-14,
driven by resurgent consumer sentiment, job growth, government investment and housing
market strength. However, rising interest rates are the medium term risk. Chart 15.
Monthly retail sales growth appears to have bottomed in Feb 09, coincident with the apparent.
equity market bottom. Chart 16.
Household goods sales appear to have bottomed Mar 09 at -0.7%. Chart 15,16.
CHART 15: TOTAL RETAIL SALES GROWTH YOY (%)
0
2
4
6
8
10
12
14
16
1984
1986
1988
1990
1992
1994
1996
1998
2000
2002
2004
2006
2008
%change(yoy)
Source: ABS
CHART 16: TOTAL RETAIL SALES GROWTH MOM (%)
-3%
-2%
-1%
0%
1%
2%
3%
4%
5%
Jan08
Feb08
Mar08
Apr08
May08
Jun08
Jul08
Aug08
Sep08
Oct08
Nov08
Dec08
Jan09
Feb09
Mar09
Apr09
May09
Source: ABS
38. b
38 BBY Limited 8 September 2009
FLEXIGROUP LIMITED
CHART 17: HOUSEHOLD GOODS SALES GROWTH YOY (%)
-10.0
-5.0
0.0
5.0
10.0
15.0
20.0
25.0
30.0
35.0
1984
1986
1988
1990
1992
1994
1996
1998
2000
2002
2004
2006
2008
Source: ABS
Computer Retail
Laptop sales growth
has been very strong
since 1999.
Laptop price falls are
expected to continue,
offset by volume
increases driven by
replacements.
Computer retail
distribution markets are
relatively concentrated.
FXL’s exposure to computer retail includes desktop PCs, laptops, software, storage media and
computer accessories. Key trends include:
57% CAGR in laptop unit volume sales from 1999 to 2003 (22,000 to 135,000 units). Volumes
increased at 10% CAGR from 2003-04 to 2007-08 (150,000 to 220,000).
The total computer/software goods market was approx. A$6.4bn in FY08 (IBISWorld).
Over the next five years, FXL expects 6% p.a. market growth, with price falls offset by volume
increases.
IBIS expects “sales will largely be driven by the replacement market and will stem from the
lower end of the price spectrum”. This trend will benefit FXL.
Distribution channels including appliance stores, department stores and online shopping sites.
The Australian retail IT equipment market is concentrated, with 75% market share held by the
top four retailers (HVN, JB Hi-Fi, Retravision, Dick Smith). HVN, the market leader, holds
approx 40% market share.
In New Zealand, the retail IT equipment market is concentrated among Noel Leeming, Dick
Smith and Harvey Norman.
IT leasing
ABS data indicates:
Since 1999, monthly lease finance commitments appear to have a floor of A$50M.
The growth rate appears to have bottomed in Jan 09. Chart 18,19.
39. b
8 September 2009 BBY Limited 39
FLEXIGROUP LIMITED
CHART 18: ELECTRONIC DATA PROCESSING MONTHLY LEASE FINANCE COMMITMENTS (A$M)
50
100
150
200
250
300
350
1985
1987
1989
1991
1993
1995
1997
1999
2001
2003
2005
2007
2009
A$M
Source: ABS.
CHART 19: ELECTRONIC DATA PROCESSING LEASE FINANCE COMMITMENTS (% MOM GROWTH)
-40%
-20%
0%
20%
40%
60%
80%
Jul
08
Aug
08
Sep
08
Oct
08
Nov
08
Dec
08
Jan
09
Feb
09
Mar
09
Apr
09
May
09
Jun
09
%GrowthMoM
Source: ABS.
Jewellery Retail
Jewellery demand is driven by marriages and consumer sentiment. Key market metrics include:
0.7% sales growth to A$3.39 bn in 2008-09.
1.5% pa growth over the last five years; similar growth expected over the next five years.
Approx. 90% of total watch and jewellery retailing is through duty free stores, antique/used good
stores, online shopping and mail-order channels (source: IBISWorld).
40. b
40 BBY Limited 8 September 2009
FLEXIGROUP LIMITED
Domestic Appliances Retail
Drivers include disposable income, consumer sentiment, interest rates, housing construction and
new household formation rates.
In recent years, demand has increased for electronic entertainment goods, telephonic goods, and
high-tech whitegoods, driven by improved technology. The market grew 6.3% in 08-09 to approx.
A$23.6bn (source: IBISWorld). IBIS expects growth to stabilise at 2.7% pa over the next five
years.
85% of sales are distributed through department stores and online shopping.
Harvey Norman Overview
Distribution channel
concentration risk has
diminished following
Certegy acquisition.
FXL has an exclusive agreement through to 2015 to distribute through HVN’s 200 stores and
11,000 retail staff. FXL’s Certegy acquisition has reduced its HVN sales to 25% of total revenue,
diminishing distribution channel concentration risk.
HVN sales growth appears to have bottomed in Mar 09. Charts 20, 21.
CHART 20: HVN TOTAL SALES REVENUE
Rolling annual quarterly growth
0%
2%
4%
6%
8%
10%
12%
14%
16%
18%
20%
M
ar-07
M
ay-07
Jul-07
Sep-07
Nov-07
Jan-08
M
ar-08
M
ay-08
Jul-08
Sep-08
Nov-08
Jan-09
M
ar-09
M
ay-09
Rollingannual%salesgrowth(quarterlydata)
Source: BBY, HVN
CHART 21: HVN TOTAL SALES REVENUE
1
1.1
1.2
1.3
1.4
1.5
1.6
1.7
1.8
M
ar-07M
ay-07
Jul-07
Sep-07
Nov-07
Jan-08
M
ar-08M
ay-08
Jul-08
Sep-08
Nov-08
Jan-09
M
ar-09M
ay-09
QuartelySales(A$B)
Source: BBY, HVN