SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 12
NOTE: GENDER STEREO TYPES
Email Request: Current Document: 4
Time Of Request: Tuesday, October 21, 2014 23:35:14 EST
Send To:
NEXIS, 146BTS
DEVRY UNIVERSITY
3005 HIGHLAND PKWY
DOWNERS GROVE, IL 60515-5799
Terms: (gender stereotypes)
Source: Company Profiles and Directories;US Law Reviews and Journals,
Combined;Federal & State Court Cases - After 1944, Combined;Newspaper Stories,
Combined Papers
Combined Source: Company Profiles and Directories;US Law Reviews and Journals,
Combined;Federal & State Court Cases - After 1944, Combined;Newspaper Stories,
Combined Papers
Project ID:
Page 2
Page 3
25 Berkeley J. Gender L. & Just. 226, *
4 of 999 DOCUMENTS
Copyright (c) 2010 The Regents of the University of California on behalf
of
Berkeley Journal of Gender, Law & Justice
Spring, 2010
Berkeley Journal of Gender, Law & Justice
25 Berkeley J. Gender L. & Just. 226
LENGTH: 5189 words
Books Received: Gender Stereotyping: Transnational Legal Perspectives
by Rebecca J. Cook & Simone Cusack. Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania Press, 2010. 288 pp. $
49.95 hardback.
NAME: Aurora Kaiser
LEXISNEXIS SUMMARY:
... The authors indicate that "this section is intended to illuminate the types of questions that might
prove helpful in exposing and acknowledging the harms of gender stereotyping for women in different
contexts" (p. 60) (emphasis added). ... When identifying the harm, Cook and Cusack indicate three
major ways in which gender stereotypes can harm women: denying a benefit, imposing a burden, and
degrading women by diminishing their dignity or otherwise marginalizing them (pp. 60, 59-68). ... The
Women's Convention also requires States Parties to eliminate or modify "existing laws, regulations,
customs and practices which constitute discrimination against women" (p. 72). ... Basas's work lays the
foundation for advocates of women with disabilities to understand the complex ways in which gender
and disability stereotypes combine to negatively affect women.
HIGHLIGHT: The ability to eliminate a wrong is contingent on it first being "named," by which is
meant that a particular experience has been identified and publically acknowledged as a wrong in need
of legal and other forms of redress and subsequent prevention. (p. 39)
TEXT:
[*226]
Introduction
The book Gender Stereotyping: Transnational Legal Perspectives orients gender stereotyping as the
underlying cause of much of the discrimination that occurs against women throughout the world. The
book discusses the duty and ability of state and non-state actors to dismantle negative gender
stereotypes and diminish their effect. The authors, Rebecca J. Cook and Simone Cusack, writing from
a transnational perspective, n1
discuss this duty in the context of the Convention on the Elimination of
All Forms of Discrimination Against Women ("Women's Convention" or "Convention"). As Cook
explained in another article, "[the Women's Convention] is the definitive international legal instrument
requiring respect for and observance of the human rights of women; it is universal in reach,
comprehensive in scope and legally binding in character." n2
The Convention has over 150 member
states, n3
referred to as "States Parties" (p. [*227] 4). The Committee on the Elimination of
Discrimination Against Women ("Women's Committee" or "Committee") was established to monitor
States Parties' compliance with the Convention (p. 131). The Women's Committee was created, and its
duties were subsequently expanded, in order to enhance the Convention's role in eliminating harmful
Page 4
25 Berkeley J. Gender L. & Just. 226, *
stereotypes and discrimination (pp. 131, 135).
This refreshingly pragmatic book will interest practitioners and scholars of women's human rights
alike. The authors make suggestions for how to argue that a state is in violation of the Convention and
how the Committee should fulfill its role as a quasi-legislative body. In fact, the final chapters read as a
handbook for both practitioners and members of the Committee itself.
The book begins with a description of gender stereotyping (pp. 9-38). The authors suggest a
"coherent methodology to address gender stereotyping ... in presenting arguments, and in proposing
and drafting remedial judgments" (p. 177). This methodology consists of several steps, and can be
applied to any context in which there is suspected gender stereotyping or discrimination. First, an
advocate must name the operative gender stereotypes (pp. 39-70). This includes identifying their
forms, contexts, and means of perpetuation and elimination (pp. 54-58). This also includes articulating
the ways in which the stereotypes harm women (pp. 59-70). Once stereotypes have been named, and
the harms have been identified, a remedial or preventive solution can be crafted (pp. 39-70). This
process is analogous to the necessity of diagnosing a disease before it can be treated (p. 3).
In discussing this methodology, I will draw examples from an article in this volume of the
Berkeley Journal of Gender, Law & Justice, titled The New Boys: Women with Disabilities and the
Legal Profession. n4
The author, Carrie Griffin Basas, describes her qualitative study of women with
disabilities in the legal profession. She discusses the manner in which stereotypes about women with
disabilities affect the women's careers and lives.
The remaining chapters discuss the rights afforded by the Convention on the Elimination of All
Forms of Discrimination Against Women and the application of the aforementioned methodology to
issues that may be brought before the Women's Committee. Chapter 3 emphasizes states' obligations to
eliminate gender stereotyping and discrimination under the Women's Convention (pp. 71-103).
Chapter 4 describes the States Parties' obligation to eradicate gender stereotyping, which is itself a
form of discrimination (pp. 104-30). The authors then delve into what the role of the Women's
Committee is, and what it could and should be to best advance the goals of the Convention (pp. 131-
72). Although these chapters are informative and useful in understanding [*228] and combating
gender stereotyping and discrimination in international bodies that have ratified the Convention, this
article focuses on the first two chapters, which will likely be the most interesting to our readers.
I. The What, Why, and How of Gender Stereotyping
The book's overarching theme is the ability and duty of domestic and international law and actors to
eliminate or ameliorate the negative effects of gender stereotyping and discrimination. Inherent in that
theme is the concept that gender stereotypes are at the root of discrimination against women. In order
to understand the causative relationship, and thereafter to fashion remedies, it is necessary to
understand the nature of stereotypes (p. 3).
The first chapter, "Understanding Gender Stereotyping," goes in depth into the characteristics of
gender stereotypes. Even for those of us that are aware of gender stereotyping and devote time to its
study and elimination, this chapter will likely be illuminating. The authors regularly ask the reader to
consider their own experiences when reading. I frequently paused to ponder the ways that stereotypes
had affected my own life, whether I was being stereotyped or doing the stereotyping.
A perception can be deemed a stereotype despite a documented correlation between the
characteristic and the group of people presumed to have that characteristic (p. 9). At the same time, not
all stereotypes are negative. For example, the statistically accurate stereotype that "women are
physically weaker than men" is not problematic unless it is applied to the detriment of, for example, a
woman who is denied the ability to apply to be a firefighter regardless of her actual strength (pp. 12,
15-16). Discriminatory stereotyping occurs when one's individual characteristics are ignored, and other
characteristics are prescribed or presumed to exist merely due to the individual's membership in a
group. "All the dimensions of personality that make that individual unique are consequently filtered
through the lens of a generalized view or preconception of the group with which the individual is
identified." (p. 9) Stereotypes of men can also hurt women, and they are therefore also relevant to this
discussion (p. 6). For example, the stereotype that a man is or should be the breadwinner hurts men
because it assumes that they cannot play a caregiver role, and it hurts women because it forces them
into the caregiver role (pp. 11, 50-51).
Page 5
25 Berkeley J. Gender L. & Just. 226, *
The authors explain the "complex, varied and, sometimes, contradictory reasons" people
stereotype (p. 13). The major reasons we stereotype are: to maximize simplicity and predictability in
our uncomprehendingly complex world (pp. 14-16); to assign difference by labeling "people as being
other than the norm with which we are familiar, particularly ourselves" (p. 16); and to script identities,
which involves, when discussing gender stereotypes, "prescribing attributes, roles, and behaviors to
which men and women are expected to conform." (p. 18)
There are several types of gender stereotypes discussed in this book: sex, [*229] sexual, sex
role, and compounded (pp. 25-31). There is some conceptual overlap among the types of sex
stereotypes. "Sex stereotypes" are those that are allegedly based on physical or biological differences
(pp. 25-26). "Sexual stereotypes" are those based on the perceived characteristics that play a role in
sexuality, including, for example, sexual initiation, intimacy, possession, and objectification (pp. 27-
28). "Sex role stereotypes" describe a "normative or statistical view regarding appropriate roles or
behavior for men and women" (p. 28). Although all are relevant to individuals interested in gender
stereotypes, "compounded stereotypes" are most relevant to Berkeley Journal of Gender, Law &
Justice's mandate to publish scholarship that examines "the intersection of gender with one or more
other axes of subordination, including, but not limited to, race, class, sexual orientation, and disability."
n5
The difficulty in addressing and describing compounded stereotypes is "identifying the different
stereotypes that operate to discriminate against a woman because of each one of her traits, not just her
gender." (pp. 29-30) The authors note that "compounded stereotypes often reflect false preconceptions
about different subcategories of women, and evolve according to different articulations of patriarchy
and power structures" (p. 31).
Carrie Griffin Basas provides an example of compounded stereotypes, namely, women with
mental and/or physical disabilities in the legal profession. Women with disabilities are scripted as
weak, inadequate, and dependent. n6
Therefore, they may find it very hard to obtain and keep certain
types of employment, such as in large law firms, irrespective of their actual attributes or abilities. n7
These stereotypes illustrate the difficulty of separating the degree to which disabled women are
scripted due to their gender versus their disability. To the extent that this stereotype is linked to
gender, it can be thought of as a sex stereotype because the stereotype is based on assumptions about
physical and mental capacities of women with disabilities, and thus are linked to physical and
biological differences. Women with disabilities are also scripted as asexual, n8
which is a sexual
stereotype regarding the women's sexual capacity and the nature of her gender. Additionally, women
with physical disabilities may be perceived as failing to, or feel they fail to, live up to the sex role
stereotype that women should be attractive. n9
Gender stereotypes do not, of course, occur in a vacuum. The contexts in which gender
stereotyping can "contribute to social stratification and [*230] subordination" are "individual,"
"situational," or "broad" (p. 32).
The "individual" context includes the cognitive and behavioral. Women may internalize individual
factors, and "come to accept them uncritically as a normal or inevitable understanding of life" (p. 32).
Therefore, "cognitive processes and social pressures to conform are often cited as barriers to change
gender stereotypes. Once individuals accept a label from others, this secondary labeling results in
them conforming their self-image and behavior to that label" (p. 32). As Basas explains, "over time,
disabled women attorneys internalize ... low expectations." n10
It is through internalization that gender
stereotyping manifests in the "individual" context. Disabled women as a group are harmed when
women with disabilities internalize the shame and fear around disability, and thus submit to the
pressures to "cover." n11
Covering occurs when individuals are asked to downplay their differences or
"pretend that they are not affiliated with their minority identities." n12
This results in "self-perpetuating"
stigma, inasmuch as "opportunities are missed to make disability commonplace, familiar, and
comfortable to nondisabled people." n13
"Situational" contexts include "predisposing conditions, found in different sectors, including the
employment, family, and health sectors" (p. 32). Cook and Cusack explain that gender stereotypes are
most likely to intrude in the situational context when one of three factors is present: when the "target or
the subject of the stereotype is isolated"; when "members of a previously absent or omitted group
move into an occupation or employment that is nontraditional for their group"; or when there is a
"gender mismatch," in other words, "a preconceived lack of fit between the person's attributes and
occupation" (p. 33). Not only are lawyers unlikely to have disabilities n14
and women unlikely to make
Page 6
25 Berkeley J. Gender L. & Just. 226, *
partner, n15
but women with disabilities are perceived as having attributes (such as weakness) that do not
fit with the attributes perceived as being required for being lawyers, particularly in large firms. n16
That
puts female lawyers with disabilities at a high risk of being the subject of hostile gender stereotyping,
according to the theory explained by Cook and Cusack, which is supported by the data collected by
Basas. n17
Finally, gender stereotyping acts to subordinate women in "broader" contexts, such as "cultural,
religious, economic, and legal" (p. 32). Basas describes the "ableist culture" of large law firms,
dominated by "paternalistic power hierarchies, incentives, and social (dis)order," n18
which values men
with [*231] disabilities over women with disabilities. n19
Thus, gender and disability stereotypes act
together within the professional culture of law firms to prescribe roles and limit opportunities for
women with disabilities, but not necessarily for their non-disabled female and disabled male peers.
II. The Importance of Naming Gender Stereotypes and the Associated Harms
Cook and Cusack indicate that in scholarship or advocacy one must enunciate the forms, contexts, and
methods of perpetuation of stereotypes, as well as the harms caused by them. They refer to this as
"naming" the stereotype and explain that it "is an important tool for revealing an otherwise hidden
harm, explaining its implications, and labeling it as a human rights concern, grievance, or possible
human rights violation" (p. 39). In fact, the ability to eliminate wrongful gender stereotyping is
contingent on examining "the nature, forms, causes, and effects" of stereotyping (p. 40).
Naming gender stereotyping raises awareness of the harms associated with gender stereotyping
(p. 41). This is especially important considering how much gender stereotyping operates at the
subconscious level and is "frequently accepted as a culturally "normal' aspect of our sexed and
gendered lives" (p. 41).
Throughout the chapter, the authors recommend questions to ask to tease out gender stereotypes
and the resultant sex discrimination that are sometimes difficult to detect. The two key questions
necessary to "name" stereotypes are: "How does a law, policy, or practice stereotype men or women?"
and "How does the application, enforcement, or perpetuation of a gender stereotype in a law, policy,
or practice harm women?" (p. 42). Although the questions may seem obvious, the answers to these
questions are vital to understanding and eliminating gender discrimination. Because the question of
whether stereotyping is affecting individuals is ultimately a factual one (p. 46), the authors provide
examples, expand on the above questions, and give factors that may indicate when gender stereotyping
is present (pp. 46-58). Additionally, in answering these questions, the authors recommend that the
forms, contexts, means of perpetuation, and means of elimination be considered (pp. 54-58).
Part of this process is exposing operative gender stereotypes and their forms. The authors, in this
regard, suggest first indentifying "what attributes, characteristics, or roles" the gender stereotype
ascribes to individuals (p. 51). Then, one can ask, "What does it mean to ascribe to women certain
attributes, characteristics, or roles?" (p. 51). This seems like an effective method for advocates and
scholars to be clear and concise in "naming" gender stereotypes as the underlying cause of the harms
discussed. Several examples include:
. "women should be mothers and, therefore, they and not men ought to [*232] be concerned with
matters relating to the bearing and rearing of children;" (p. 51)
. "women are sexually passive and, therefore, they are disposed submissively to surrender to men's
sexual advances;" (p. 52)
. "women should dress modestly and, therefore, an immodestly dressed woman is responsible for her
own sexual assault" (p. 53).
Page 7
25 Berkeley J. Gender L. & Just. 226, *
One such identification of gender stereotypes in Basas's article would be:
. women with disabilities are weak and helpless and, therefore, they are not capable of performing the
difficult and demanding work required in a large law-firm setting.
Identification of the stereotype is vitally necessary as the first step in dismantling it. The second step
is identifying its form, including the type, context and means of perpetuation (pp. 54-58). Finally, the
third step is naming the harm (pp. 59-68). As Cook and Cusack explain, these three steps "are critical to
making [the gender stereotype] recognizable, and therefore legally cognizable, that is, able to be
judicially examined. Naming a stereotype is necessary in much the same way that a medical diagnosis
is required before treatment can be applied." (p. 175)
The same stereotype may result in different harms "according to community, country, or region"
(p. 60). The authors give the example of the gender stereotype of women as men's property, which
"may enable the marriage of girl children before the legal age of marriage in one community, contribute
to some of the preconditions for forced marriage in another, or, elsewhere, the rape of a sister to punish
her brother" (p. 60) (citations omitted). The authors indicate that "this section is intended to illuminate
the types of questions that might prove helpful in exposing and acknowledging the harms of gender
stereotyping for women in different contexts" (p. 60) (emphasis added).
When identifying the harm, Cook and Cusack indicate three major ways in which gender
stereotypes can harm women: denying a benefit, imposing a burden, and degrading women by
diminishing their dignity or otherwise marginalizing them (pp. 60, 59-68). The women in Basas's study
were denied a benefit when they were denied or forced out of employment, or certain types of
employment, because they are women with disabilities n20
(p. 62). The burdens imposed on them due to
stereotypes surrounding disability and gender include feeling the need to "cover." n21
Basas explains
that, "in order to succeed, they are expected ... to fade gently into the background when any
manifestation of their disability causes discomfort or awkwardness for their coworkers or [*233]
supervisors." n22
As Cook and Cusack explain, a "gender stereotype might burden women when it
restricts them to culturally acceptable roles or behavior" (p. 63).
The third harm of gender stereotyping, degradation, manifests in number of different ways,
including the "lowering of women's status, position, or rank in their marriages, families, and
communities" (p. 64). This includes "downplaying or undermining women's competence, such as in
cases where stereotypes posit that women are incapable of rigorous, abstract thought" (p. 64). Another
example of degrading harm is simply "being treated differently than a man on account of a gender
stereotype," or when it "diminishes their dignity as human beings" by "failing to recognize their
intrinsic and equal worth as human beings or when, for example, it treats them in ways that do not take
into account their actual situations" (pp. 64-65). The women in Basas's study were degraded in this
manner, when they were deemed incompetent to perform certain types of work regardless of their
individual capabilities. n23
III. Women's Convention and Women's Committee
The Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Discrimination Against Women explicitly links
gender stereotyping to discrimination against women and is an extremely valuable tool for combating
these problems in a forum specifically created to eradicate them. The authors provide a type of manual
for litigating and arguing these types of claims, and include significant advice for the Women's
Committee members. This section gives a brief overview of the breadth and depth of the protections
available under the Convention.
The Convention specifically requires states to take appropriate measures to eliminate wrongful
stereotyping (p. 71). The Women's Convention also requires States Parties to eliminate or modify
"existing laws, regulations, customs and practices which constitute discrimination against women" (p.
72). The authors explain in detail what constitutes discrimination (pp. 104-30). Due to the highly
factual nature of discrimination claims, the authors provide questions that should be asked in each
circumstance to determine whether the action was prohibited by the convention. These include, for
example, "Did a law, policy, or practice impair or nullify any of a woman's human rights or
fundamental freedoms?" and "Was the application, enforcement, or perpetuation of a gender
Page 8
25 Berkeley J. Gender L. & Just. 226, *
stereotype in a law, policy, or practice justified?" (p. 106).
The Convention applies to all state actors, including the executive, legislative and judicial
branches (pp. 84-88). Moreover, the Convention may also apply to non-state actors under certain
circumstances. For example, a State Party can be held responsible for "its failure to act with due
diligence to prevent, investigate, deter, punish, and remedy wrongful gender stereotyping by non-state
actors," such as private employers or places of public accommodation (p. 89).
[*234] The Convention requires States Parties to remedy wrongful gender stereotyping (p. 93).
The failure to provide effective remedies "fuels a climate of disregard, disrespect, and devaluation of
women in all sectors of society" (p. 93). Cook and Cusack explain that effective remedies must contain
individual compensatory remedies and "structural dimensions," which deinstitutionalize gender
stereotypes from the laws, policies, and practices of States Parties (pp. 94-98).
The Women's Committee monitors States Parties' compliance with the Convention. The
Committee reviews States Parties' periodic reports, which are submitted every four years (p. 131). The
reports typically "address measures undertaken to eliminate discrimination against women, as well as
any factors or difficulties affecting implementation of the Convention" (p. 131). The reporting process
has caused States Parties to "reflect on the adequacy of their steps undertaken to address wrongful
forms of gender stereotyping" (p. 132). The Committee views these as a "constructive dialogue" and
takes the opportunity to question representatives on the State Party's report and respond with
Concluding Observations in which it identifies the strengths and weaknesses of the report (p. 132).
The authors stress the normative function of the Committee. The Committee is a quasi-legislative
body, which can hear claims under certain circumstances and can issue written recommendations to the
State Party if it is found to have fallen short on its obligations under the Convention (pp. 135-37, 142-
60). In this regard, the authors suggest that "it would be helpful that the Committee not only articulate
norms and standards on States Parties' obligations to eliminate and remedy gender stereotyping, but
that it also engage in detailed factual and legal analysis of wrongful gender stereotyping" (p. 156).
Additionally, the Committee can formulate General Recommendations, which interpret and define the
obligations under the Convention (pp. 134-35). The authors suggest ways in which the Committee
could craft a General Recommendation regarding the scope of States Parties' duties to eliminate
wrongful gender stereotyping (p. 138). In many ways, this discussion mirrors the discussion in the
preceding section of this article, regarding naming gender stereotyping and delineating its harms
(pp.138-40). Finally, the Committee has the power to conduct an inquiry when it receives reliable
information concerning grave or systematic violations by a State Party (pp. 160-65). At the end of the
inquiry, the Committee publically issues its findings, comments, and recommendations to the State
Party (p. 161). In all of these functions the Committee has the opportunity to play an important role
defining the norms with which States Parties are expected to conform.
Conclusion
This book provides a clear and concise framework for discussing gender stereotypes and the manner
in which they negatively impact women's human [*235] rights. For many inquiries it will be a starting
point, and will suggest future areas to explore (such as other contexts in which a pernicious gender
stereotype acts). In a similar manner, Basas's article is a starting point. n24
She has primarily named the
stereotypes and described their harms. As Cook and Cusack have explained, the first step in treating a
disease is to diagnose it (p. 3). Basas's work, in conjunction with Cook and Cusack's, would be
invaluable to someone using the Convention to pursue rights for a woman with disabilities.
When women have been discriminated against on the basis of compound stereotypes, advocates
and tribunals may fail to identify all of the harmful stereotypes. Instead, the focus may be on a single
aspect, like race or gender or disability. Cook and Cusack describe a case in which a Turkish national
woman residing in the Netherlands was terminated from her job after becoming a mother. The
explanation for termination stated that unlike women from the Netherlands who, the employer
assumed, give up working right away, ""foreign women workers ... take the child to neighbours or
family and at the slightest setback disappear on sick leave under the terms of the Sickness Act. They
repeat that endlessly'" (p. 95). The woman was successful in her claim before the United Nations
Committee on the Elimination of Race Discrimination that she was discriminated against on grounds of
her ethnic Turkish status (p. 96). However, the Race Committee failed to recognize the gender
stereotype that was at work, which stereotyped the woman "as an inferior mother because she had to
Page 9
25 Berkeley J. Gender L. & Just. 226, *
combine her roles as both mother and contributing breadwinner" (p. 96).
It is easy to imagine that an advocate of a woman with a disability would focus solely on the
disability as the claim of discrimination. This may be due to the difficulty of teasing out the various
aspects of the discrimination. However, as Cook and Cusack explain, the Women's Convention is a
valuable tool to women who have been discriminated against on the basis of compounded stereotypes.
Basas's work lays the foundation for advocates of women with disabilities to understand the complex
ways in which gender and disability stereotypes combine to negatively affect women.
Legal Topics:
For related research and practice materials, see the following legal topics:
Labor & Employment LawDisability & Unemployment InsuranceDisability BenefitsGeneral
OverviewLabor & Employment LawDiscriminationGender & Sex DiscriminationCoverage &
DefinitionsSexual OrientationLabor & Employment LawDiscriminationGender & Sex
DiscriminationCoverage & DefinitionsStereotypes
FOOTNOTES:
n1. A transnational legal process is characterized by four distinctive features:
"First, it is nontraditional: it breaks down two traditional dichotomies that have historically dominated the study of
international law: between domestic and international, public and private. Second, it is nonstatist; the actors in this
process are not just, or even primarily, nation states, but include nonstate actors as well. Third, transnational legal
process is dynamic, not static. Transnational law transforms, mutates, and percolates up and down, from the public to
the private, from the domestic to the international level and back down again. Fourth and finally, it is normative. From
this process of interaction, new rules of law emerge, which are interpreted, internalized, and enforced, thus beginning
the process all over again."
(p. 8) (quoting Harold Hongju Koh, Transnational Legal Process, 75 Neb. L. Rev. 181, 184 (1996)).
n2. Rebecca Cook, Reservations to The Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Discrimination Against
Women, 30 Va. J. Int'l L. 643, 643 (1990).
n3. United Nations Treaty Collection, Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Discrimination Against Women,
http://treaties.un.org/Pages/ViewDetails.aspx?src=TREATY& mtdsg_no=IV-8&chapter=4&lang=en (indicating which
states have ratified the treaty since its inception in 1979, including most recently, Qatar in 2009) (last visited Mar. 24,
2010). The United States is a signatory to the Women's Convention, but has not ratified it. Id.
n4. Carrie Griffin Basas, The New Boys: Women with Disabilities and the Legal Profession, 25 Berk. J. Gender L. &
Just. 32 (2010).
n5. Berkeley Journal of Gender, Law & Justice, http://www.boalt.org/bglj/ (last visited Mar. 24, 2010).
n6. Basas, supra note 4, at 73 n.192 ("Women with disabilities are often excluded from stereotypically feminine jobs,
as well as stereotypically masculine jobs because of society's perception of them as weak, dependent, and asexual.")
(citation omitted).
Page 10
25 Berkeley J. Gender L. & Just. 226, *
n7. Id. at 73-75.
n8. Id. at 73 n.192.
n9. See id. at 73 ("More than anything, women with disabilities in mainstream American society often represent to
others the perceived culmination of weaknesses, shortcomings, and inadequacies. They fail to meet gender ideals of
beauty and perfection.").
n10. Id. at 55.
n11. Id. at 56-57, 70-76.
n12. Id. at 70.
n13. Id. at 56-57.
n14. Id. at 67 n.161.
n15. Id. at 68 n.166.
n16. Id. at 73-75.
n17. See generally id.
n18. Id. at 48.
n19. Id. at 55-56 ("Men with disabilities in the office had made partner years earlier or had directed some of the firm's
paid work toward disability initiatives.").
n20. See id. at 64-66.
n21. Id. at 70.
Page 11
25 Berkeley J. Gender L. & Just. 226, *
n22. Id. at 71.
n23. See id. at 64-66.
n24. Id. at 112. This is something that Basas recognized. She indicated, "While these data provide a start to
understanding the processes that lead to career choice and stratification among women with disabilities, they deserve
more attention and dedicated studies of their experiences." Id.
25 berkeley j._gender_l._&_just._226,_-2

More Related Content

What's hot

Queer theory and Blood Red Road
Queer theory and Blood Red RoadQueer theory and Blood Red Road
Queer theory and Blood Red Roadjudyhubbard
 
Judith butler powerpoint.pptx 2
Judith butler powerpoint.pptx 2Judith butler powerpoint.pptx 2
Judith butler powerpoint.pptx 2GenderStudies1
 
POSC 381 paper Number 5 May 7 2013
POSC 381 paper Number 5 May 7 2013POSC 381 paper Number 5 May 7 2013
POSC 381 paper Number 5 May 7 2013Laura Coholan
 
Amartya Sen - Inequality Reexamined (Russell Sage Foundation Books) (1992).pdf
Amartya Sen - Inequality Reexamined (Russell Sage Foundation Books) (1992).pdfAmartya Sen - Inequality Reexamined (Russell Sage Foundation Books) (1992).pdf
Amartya Sen - Inequality Reexamined (Russell Sage Foundation Books) (1992).pdfCamilaCubillos8
 
Feminist legal theories
Feminist legal theoriesFeminist legal theories
Feminist legal theoriesFAROUQ
 
Ms. c. badeaux engl 102 i1spring 2021essay ii a significant
Ms. c. badeaux engl 102 i1spring 2021essay ii  a significantMs. c. badeaux engl 102 i1spring 2021essay ii  a significant
Ms. c. badeaux engl 102 i1spring 2021essay ii a significantamit657720
 
JUNE 2012 SCLY4 EXAM PAPER
JUNE 2012 SCLY4 EXAM PAPERJUNE 2012 SCLY4 EXAM PAPER
JUNE 2012 SCLY4 EXAM PAPERmattyp99
 
IV Gender Studies
IV Gender StudiesIV Gender Studies
IV Gender Studiespvillacanas
 
Judith Butler - Resource Pack
Judith  Butler  - Resource PackJudith  Butler  - Resource Pack
Judith Butler - Resource PackGroup.6
 
Matt maycock understanding masculinity 26th jan 2016
Matt maycock   understanding masculinity 26th jan 2016Matt maycock   understanding masculinity 26th jan 2016
Matt maycock understanding masculinity 26th jan 2016Matthew Maycock
 
¿Qué es la democracia? ¿Cuál es su razón de ser? por Goldman
¿Qué es la democracia? ¿Cuál es su razón de ser? por Goldman¿Qué es la democracia? ¿Cuál es su razón de ser? por Goldman
¿Qué es la democracia? ¿Cuál es su razón de ser? por GoldmanYsrrael Camero
 
Implications Of Title Vii Of The Civil Rights Act Of 1964 By A. Walker
Implications Of Title Vii Of The Civil Rights Act Of 1964 By A. WalkerImplications Of Title Vii Of The Civil Rights Act Of 1964 By A. Walker
Implications Of Title Vii Of The Civil Rights Act Of 1964 By A. WalkerAmanda Walker
 

What's hot (20)

Queer theory and Blood Red Road
Queer theory and Blood Red RoadQueer theory and Blood Red Road
Queer theory and Blood Red Road
 
Judith butler powerpoint.pptx 2
Judith butler powerpoint.pptx 2Judith butler powerpoint.pptx 2
Judith butler powerpoint.pptx 2
 
Queer Theory
Queer TheoryQueer Theory
Queer Theory
 
Queer theory
Queer theoryQueer theory
Queer theory
 
POSC 381 paper Number 5 May 7 2013
POSC 381 paper Number 5 May 7 2013POSC 381 paper Number 5 May 7 2013
POSC 381 paper Number 5 May 7 2013
 
Amartya Sen - Inequality Reexamined (Russell Sage Foundation Books) (1992).pdf
Amartya Sen - Inequality Reexamined (Russell Sage Foundation Books) (1992).pdfAmartya Sen - Inequality Reexamined (Russell Sage Foundation Books) (1992).pdf
Amartya Sen - Inequality Reexamined (Russell Sage Foundation Books) (1992).pdf
 
CR3028 Final Essay
CR3028 Final EssayCR3028 Final Essay
CR3028 Final Essay
 
Feminist legal theories
Feminist legal theoriesFeminist legal theories
Feminist legal theories
 
Ms. c. badeaux engl 102 i1spring 2021essay ii a significant
Ms. c. badeaux engl 102 i1spring 2021essay ii  a significantMs. c. badeaux engl 102 i1spring 2021essay ii  a significant
Ms. c. badeaux engl 102 i1spring 2021essay ii a significant
 
JUNE 2012 SCLY4 EXAM PAPER
JUNE 2012 SCLY4 EXAM PAPERJUNE 2012 SCLY4 EXAM PAPER
JUNE 2012 SCLY4 EXAM PAPER
 
IV Gender Studies
IV Gender StudiesIV Gender Studies
IV Gender Studies
 
Judith Butler - Resource Pack
Judith  Butler  - Resource PackJudith  Butler  - Resource Pack
Judith Butler - Resource Pack
 
Queer theory
Queer theoryQueer theory
Queer theory
 
LGBTQ Subject Headings
LGBTQ Subject HeadingsLGBTQ Subject Headings
LGBTQ Subject Headings
 
Gender trouble
Gender troubleGender trouble
Gender trouble
 
Matt maycock understanding masculinity 26th jan 2016
Matt maycock   understanding masculinity 26th jan 2016Matt maycock   understanding masculinity 26th jan 2016
Matt maycock understanding masculinity 26th jan 2016
 
¿Qué es la democracia? ¿Cuál es su razón de ser? por Goldman
¿Qué es la democracia? ¿Cuál es su razón de ser? por Goldman¿Qué es la democracia? ¿Cuál es su razón de ser? por Goldman
¿Qué es la democracia? ¿Cuál es su razón de ser? por Goldman
 
Judith butler
Judith butlerJudith butler
Judith butler
 
Implications Of Title Vii Of The Civil Rights Act Of 1964 By A. Walker
Implications Of Title Vii Of The Civil Rights Act Of 1964 By A. WalkerImplications Of Title Vii Of The Civil Rights Act Of 1964 By A. Walker
Implications Of Title Vii Of The Civil Rights Act Of 1964 By A. Walker
 
Queer theory
Queer theoryQueer theory
Queer theory
 

Viewers also liked

Negurako jaka motzak
Negurako jaka motzakNegurako jaka motzak
Negurako jaka motzakpaulaurquijo
 
DSA_Infographic_Final
DSA_Infographic_FinalDSA_Infographic_Final
DSA_Infographic_Finalmarc corbett
 
Magazine Research
Magazine ResearchMagazine Research
Magazine Researchsreed5
 
Business_International_3CPO_22-23 giugno 2010
Business_International_3CPO_22-23 giugno 2010Business_International_3CPO_22-23 giugno 2010
Business_International_3CPO_22-23 giugno 2010Vincenzo Madonna
 
Adele media work Question Three
Adele media work Question ThreeAdele media work Question Three
Adele media work Question Three08chambersa
 
БИТ.CRM. Управление коммерческой службой
БИТ.CRM. Управление коммерческой службойБИТ.CRM. Управление коммерческой службой
БИТ.CRM. Управление коммерческой службойПервый БИТ, Челябинск
 
Near to possession project in noida extension
Near to possession project in noida extensionNear to possession project in noida extension
Near to possession project in noida extensionKrishankant Sharma
 
Cromoterapie
CromoterapieCromoterapie
CromoterapieAna-Gri
 
Analysis about University Homepage
Analysis about University HomepageAnalysis about University Homepage
Analysis about University HomepageMena Govindasamy
 
D01_Gruppo-editoriale-lespresso-Madonna
D01_Gruppo-editoriale-lespresso-MadonnaD01_Gruppo-editoriale-lespresso-Madonna
D01_Gruppo-editoriale-lespresso-MadonnaVincenzo Madonna
 
KnowAtlanta Magazine Winter 2006
KnowAtlanta Magazine Winter 2006KnowAtlanta Magazine Winter 2006
KnowAtlanta Magazine Winter 2006Michelle Bourg
 

Viewers also liked (20)

Negurako jaka motzak
Negurako jaka motzakNegurako jaka motzak
Negurako jaka motzak
 
Ashman Resume
Ashman ResumeAshman Resume
Ashman Resume
 
DSA_Infographic_Final
DSA_Infographic_FinalDSA_Infographic_Final
DSA_Infographic_Final
 
ლოცვა
ლოცვა ლოცვა
ლოცვა
 
Magazine Research
Magazine ResearchMagazine Research
Magazine Research
 
Business_International_3CPO_22-23 giugno 2010
Business_International_3CPO_22-23 giugno 2010Business_International_3CPO_22-23 giugno 2010
Business_International_3CPO_22-23 giugno 2010
 
Ukhuwah - Studi Islam Awal Kuliah (Siwak)
Ukhuwah - Studi Islam Awal Kuliah (Siwak)Ukhuwah - Studi Islam Awal Kuliah (Siwak)
Ukhuwah - Studi Islam Awal Kuliah (Siwak)
 
Adele media work Question Three
Adele media work Question ThreeAdele media work Question Three
Adele media work Question Three
 
БИТ.CRM. Управление коммерческой службой
БИТ.CRM. Управление коммерческой службойБИТ.CRM. Управление коммерческой службой
БИТ.CRM. Управление коммерческой службой
 
MVR Profile (+Wave)
MVR Profile (+Wave)MVR Profile (+Wave)
MVR Profile (+Wave)
 
Изменения в законодательстве 2015
Изменения в законодательстве 2015 Изменения в законодательстве 2015
Изменения в законодательстве 2015
 
Near to possession project in noida extension
Near to possession project in noida extensionNear to possession project in noida extension
Near to possession project in noida extension
 
Cromoterapie
CromoterapieCromoterapie
Cromoterapie
 
Презентация программы БИТ.Красота
Презентация программы БИТ.КрасотаПрезентация программы БИТ.Красота
Презентация программы БИТ.Красота
 
Analysis about University Homepage
Analysis about University HomepageAnalysis about University Homepage
Analysis about University Homepage
 
D01_Gruppo-editoriale-lespresso-Madonna
D01_Gruppo-editoriale-lespresso-MadonnaD01_Gruppo-editoriale-lespresso-Madonna
D01_Gruppo-editoriale-lespresso-Madonna
 
beautiful*city
beautiful*citybeautiful*city
beautiful*city
 
KnowAtlanta Magazine Winter 2006
KnowAtlanta Magazine Winter 2006KnowAtlanta Magazine Winter 2006
KnowAtlanta Magazine Winter 2006
 
How To Save Money on Car Repair
How To Save Money on Car RepairHow To Save Money on Car Repair
How To Save Money on Car Repair
 
ლოცვის საზღაური
ლოცვის საზღაურილოცვის საზღაური
ლოცვის საზღაური
 

Similar to 25 berkeley j._gender_l._&_just._226,_-2

Addressing The Vilification Of Women A Functional Theory Of Harm And Implica...
Addressing The Vilification Of Women  A Functional Theory Of Harm And Implica...Addressing The Vilification Of Women  A Functional Theory Of Harm And Implica...
Addressing The Vilification Of Women A Functional Theory Of Harm And Implica...Angie Miller
 
- Equality and DiscriminationCivil LibertiesCivil libertie.docx
- Equality and DiscriminationCivil LibertiesCivil libertie.docx- Equality and DiscriminationCivil LibertiesCivil libertie.docx
- Equality and DiscriminationCivil LibertiesCivil libertie.docxhoney725342
 
Intersectionality: What does it mean and how can we better engage with it?
Intersectionality: What does it mean and how can we better engage with it?Intersectionality: What does it mean and how can we better engage with it?
Intersectionality: What does it mean and how can we better engage with it?CIFOR-ICRAF
 
Transgender identity
Transgender identityTransgender identity
Transgender identitytaylor jupin
 
Morrow tongleisociologyproject1
Morrow tongleisociologyproject1Morrow tongleisociologyproject1
Morrow tongleisociologyproject1Alexa Morrow
 
Constructions of Masulinity among Transgender Men
Constructions of Masulinity among Transgender MenConstructions of Masulinity among Transgender Men
Constructions of Masulinity among Transgender MenTaylor Briggs
 
INTRODUCTION 319 too emotional to be good leaders) are a.docx
INTRODUCTION  319 too emotional to be good leaders) are a.docxINTRODUCTION  319 too emotional to be good leaders) are a.docx
INTRODUCTION 319 too emotional to be good leaders) are a.docxnormanibarber20063
 
150 Captivating College Essay Topics To Deal With
150 Captivating College Essay Topics To Deal With150 Captivating College Essay Topics To Deal With
150 Captivating College Essay Topics To Deal WithLisa Frederick
 
Sexism powerpoint butler & palmer
Sexism powerpoint butler & palmerSexism powerpoint butler & palmer
Sexism powerpoint butler & palmerDeneathra Butler
 
Eastern Washington University Kathy L. Rowley, MA .docx
 Eastern Washington University  Kathy L. Rowley, MA .docx Eastern Washington University  Kathy L. Rowley, MA .docx
Eastern Washington University Kathy L. Rowley, MA .docxMARRY7
 
Personal Strengths And Weaknesses Essay.pdfPersonal Strengths And Weaknesses ...
Personal Strengths And Weaknesses Essay.pdfPersonal Strengths And Weaknesses ...Personal Strengths And Weaknesses Essay.pdfPersonal Strengths And Weaknesses ...
Personal Strengths And Weaknesses Essay.pdfPersonal Strengths And Weaknesses ...Katrina Wilson
 
Sexual Stigma and Sexual Prejudice in the United States.docx
     Sexual Stigma and Sexual Prejudice in the United States.docx     Sexual Stigma and Sexual Prejudice in the United States.docx
Sexual Stigma and Sexual Prejudice in the United States.docxShiraPrater50
 
Assignment Gender StereotypingGender stereotyping reflects
Assignment Gender StereotypingGender stereotyping reflects Assignment Gender StereotypingGender stereotyping reflects
Assignment Gender StereotypingGender stereotyping reflects AbramMartino96
 
Eastern Washington University Kathy L. Rowley, M.A. Co.docx
Eastern Washington University Kathy L. Rowley, M.A. Co.docxEastern Washington University Kathy L. Rowley, M.A. Co.docx
Eastern Washington University Kathy L. Rowley, M.A. Co.docxjacksnathalie
 
Readings and ResourcesArticles, Websites, and VideosDiscussio.docx
Readings and ResourcesArticles, Websites, and VideosDiscussio.docxReadings and ResourcesArticles, Websites, and VideosDiscussio.docx
Readings and ResourcesArticles, Websites, and VideosDiscussio.docxlillie234567
 
Running Head PRESENCE OF MASCULINITY IN INTERNATIONAL RELATIONS1.docx
Running Head PRESENCE OF MASCULINITY IN INTERNATIONAL RELATIONS1.docxRunning Head PRESENCE OF MASCULINITY IN INTERNATIONAL RELATIONS1.docx
Running Head PRESENCE OF MASCULINITY IN INTERNATIONAL RELATIONS1.docxcharisellington63520
 

Similar to 25 berkeley j._gender_l._&_just._226,_-2 (20)

Addressing The Vilification Of Women A Functional Theory Of Harm And Implica...
Addressing The Vilification Of Women  A Functional Theory Of Harm And Implica...Addressing The Vilification Of Women  A Functional Theory Of Harm And Implica...
Addressing The Vilification Of Women A Functional Theory Of Harm And Implica...
 
- Equality and DiscriminationCivil LibertiesCivil libertie.docx
- Equality and DiscriminationCivil LibertiesCivil libertie.docx- Equality and DiscriminationCivil LibertiesCivil libertie.docx
- Equality and DiscriminationCivil LibertiesCivil libertie.docx
 
Intersectionality: What does it mean and how can we better engage with it?
Intersectionality: What does it mean and how can we better engage with it?Intersectionality: What does it mean and how can we better engage with it?
Intersectionality: What does it mean and how can we better engage with it?
 
Transgender identity
Transgender identityTransgender identity
Transgender identity
 
Morrow tongleisociologyproject1
Morrow tongleisociologyproject1Morrow tongleisociologyproject1
Morrow tongleisociologyproject1
 
discrimination
discriminationdiscrimination
discrimination
 
Constructions of Masulinity among Transgender Men
Constructions of Masulinity among Transgender MenConstructions of Masulinity among Transgender Men
Constructions of Masulinity among Transgender Men
 
INTRODUCTION 319 too emotional to be good leaders) are a.docx
INTRODUCTION  319 too emotional to be good leaders) are a.docxINTRODUCTION  319 too emotional to be good leaders) are a.docx
INTRODUCTION 319 too emotional to be good leaders) are a.docx
 
150 Captivating College Essay Topics To Deal With
150 Captivating College Essay Topics To Deal With150 Captivating College Essay Topics To Deal With
150 Captivating College Essay Topics To Deal With
 
Emerging Theories
Emerging Theories Emerging Theories
Emerging Theories
 
Sexism powerpoint butler & palmer
Sexism powerpoint butler & palmerSexism powerpoint butler & palmer
Sexism powerpoint butler & palmer
 
Eastern Washington University Kathy L. Rowley, MA .docx
 Eastern Washington University  Kathy L. Rowley, MA .docx Eastern Washington University  Kathy L. Rowley, MA .docx
Eastern Washington University Kathy L. Rowley, MA .docx
 
Feminism And The Feminist Theory Essay
Feminism And The Feminist Theory EssayFeminism And The Feminist Theory Essay
Feminism And The Feminist Theory Essay
 
Personal Strengths And Weaknesses Essay.pdfPersonal Strengths And Weaknesses ...
Personal Strengths And Weaknesses Essay.pdfPersonal Strengths And Weaknesses ...Personal Strengths And Weaknesses Essay.pdfPersonal Strengths And Weaknesses ...
Personal Strengths And Weaknesses Essay.pdfPersonal Strengths And Weaknesses ...
 
Sexual Stigma and Sexual Prejudice in the United States.docx
     Sexual Stigma and Sexual Prejudice in the United States.docx     Sexual Stigma and Sexual Prejudice in the United States.docx
Sexual Stigma and Sexual Prejudice in the United States.docx
 
Assignment Gender StereotypingGender stereotyping reflects
Assignment Gender StereotypingGender stereotyping reflects Assignment Gender StereotypingGender stereotyping reflects
Assignment Gender StereotypingGender stereotyping reflects
 
Eastern Washington University Kathy L. Rowley, M.A. Co.docx
Eastern Washington University Kathy L. Rowley, M.A. Co.docxEastern Washington University Kathy L. Rowley, M.A. Co.docx
Eastern Washington University Kathy L. Rowley, M.A. Co.docx
 
Readings and ResourcesArticles, Websites, and VideosDiscussio.docx
Readings and ResourcesArticles, Websites, and VideosDiscussio.docxReadings and ResourcesArticles, Websites, and VideosDiscussio.docx
Readings and ResourcesArticles, Websites, and VideosDiscussio.docx
 
a_a_a_mary_vanorskie
a_a_a_mary_vanorskiea_a_a_mary_vanorskie
a_a_a_mary_vanorskie
 
Running Head PRESENCE OF MASCULINITY IN INTERNATIONAL RELATIONS1.docx
Running Head PRESENCE OF MASCULINITY IN INTERNATIONAL RELATIONS1.docxRunning Head PRESENCE OF MASCULINITY IN INTERNATIONAL RELATIONS1.docx
Running Head PRESENCE OF MASCULINITY IN INTERNATIONAL RELATIONS1.docx
 

Recently uploaded

Marketing Management Business Plan_My Sweet Creations
Marketing Management Business Plan_My Sweet CreationsMarketing Management Business Plan_My Sweet Creations
Marketing Management Business Plan_My Sweet Creationsnakalysalcedo61
 
Lowrate Call Girls In Sector 18 Noida ❤️8860477959 Escorts 100% Genuine Servi...
Lowrate Call Girls In Sector 18 Noida ❤️8860477959 Escorts 100% Genuine Servi...Lowrate Call Girls In Sector 18 Noida ❤️8860477959 Escorts 100% Genuine Servi...
Lowrate Call Girls In Sector 18 Noida ❤️8860477959 Escorts 100% Genuine Servi...lizamodels9
 
VIP Call Girl Jamshedpur Aashi 8250192130 Independent Escort Service Jamshedpur
VIP Call Girl Jamshedpur Aashi 8250192130 Independent Escort Service JamshedpurVIP Call Girl Jamshedpur Aashi 8250192130 Independent Escort Service Jamshedpur
VIP Call Girl Jamshedpur Aashi 8250192130 Independent Escort Service JamshedpurSuhani Kapoor
 
Investment analysis and portfolio management
Investment analysis and portfolio managementInvestment analysis and portfolio management
Investment analysis and portfolio managementJunaidKhan750825
 
Call Girls In Radisson Blu Hotel New Delhi Paschim Vihar ❤️8860477959 Escorts...
Call Girls In Radisson Blu Hotel New Delhi Paschim Vihar ❤️8860477959 Escorts...Call Girls In Radisson Blu Hotel New Delhi Paschim Vihar ❤️8860477959 Escorts...
Call Girls In Radisson Blu Hotel New Delhi Paschim Vihar ❤️8860477959 Escorts...lizamodels9
 
Call Girls Miyapur 7001305949 all area service COD available Any Time
Call Girls Miyapur 7001305949 all area service COD available Any TimeCall Girls Miyapur 7001305949 all area service COD available Any Time
Call Girls Miyapur 7001305949 all area service COD available Any Timedelhimodelshub1
 
Lean: From Theory to Practice — One City’s (and Library’s) Lean Story… Abridged
Lean: From Theory to Practice — One City’s (and Library’s) Lean Story… AbridgedLean: From Theory to Practice — One City’s (and Library’s) Lean Story… Abridged
Lean: From Theory to Practice — One City’s (and Library’s) Lean Story… AbridgedKaiNexus
 
Progress Report - Oracle Database Analyst Summit
Progress  Report - Oracle Database Analyst SummitProgress  Report - Oracle Database Analyst Summit
Progress Report - Oracle Database Analyst SummitHolger Mueller
 
(8264348440) 🔝 Call Girls In Keshav Puram 🔝 Delhi NCR
(8264348440) 🔝 Call Girls In Keshav Puram 🔝 Delhi NCR(8264348440) 🔝 Call Girls In Keshav Puram 🔝 Delhi NCR
(8264348440) 🔝 Call Girls In Keshav Puram 🔝 Delhi NCRsoniya singh
 
BEST Call Girls In Old Faridabad ✨ 9773824855 ✨ Escorts Service In Delhi Ncr,
BEST Call Girls In Old Faridabad ✨ 9773824855 ✨ Escorts Service In Delhi Ncr,BEST Call Girls In Old Faridabad ✨ 9773824855 ✨ Escorts Service In Delhi Ncr,
BEST Call Girls In Old Faridabad ✨ 9773824855 ✨ Escorts Service In Delhi Ncr,noida100girls
 
Non Text Magic Studio Magic Design for Presentations L&P.pptx
Non Text Magic Studio Magic Design for Presentations L&P.pptxNon Text Magic Studio Magic Design for Presentations L&P.pptx
Non Text Magic Studio Magic Design for Presentations L&P.pptxAbhayThakur200703
 
Call Girls In ⇛⇛Chhatarpur⇚⇚. Brings Offer Delhi Contact Us 8377877756
Call Girls In ⇛⇛Chhatarpur⇚⇚. Brings Offer Delhi Contact Us 8377877756Call Girls In ⇛⇛Chhatarpur⇚⇚. Brings Offer Delhi Contact Us 8377877756
Call Girls In ⇛⇛Chhatarpur⇚⇚. Brings Offer Delhi Contact Us 8377877756dollysharma2066
 
Call Girls in DELHI Cantt, ( Call Me )-8377877756-Female Escort- In Delhi / Ncr
Call Girls in DELHI Cantt, ( Call Me )-8377877756-Female Escort- In Delhi / NcrCall Girls in DELHI Cantt, ( Call Me )-8377877756-Female Escort- In Delhi / Ncr
Call Girls in DELHI Cantt, ( Call Me )-8377877756-Female Escort- In Delhi / Ncrdollysharma2066
 
Call Girls In Sikandarpur Gurgaon ❤️8860477959_Russian 100% Genuine Escorts I...
Call Girls In Sikandarpur Gurgaon ❤️8860477959_Russian 100% Genuine Escorts I...Call Girls In Sikandarpur Gurgaon ❤️8860477959_Russian 100% Genuine Escorts I...
Call Girls In Sikandarpur Gurgaon ❤️8860477959_Russian 100% Genuine Escorts I...lizamodels9
 
2024 Numerator Consumer Study of Cannabis Usage
2024 Numerator Consumer Study of Cannabis Usage2024 Numerator Consumer Study of Cannabis Usage
2024 Numerator Consumer Study of Cannabis UsageNeil Kimberley
 
VIP Kolkata Call Girl Howrah 👉 8250192130 Available With Room
VIP Kolkata Call Girl Howrah 👉 8250192130  Available With RoomVIP Kolkata Call Girl Howrah 👉 8250192130  Available With Room
VIP Kolkata Call Girl Howrah 👉 8250192130 Available With Roomdivyansh0kumar0
 
Lowrate Call Girls In Laxmi Nagar Delhi ❤️8860477959 Escorts 100% Genuine Ser...
Lowrate Call Girls In Laxmi Nagar Delhi ❤️8860477959 Escorts 100% Genuine Ser...Lowrate Call Girls In Laxmi Nagar Delhi ❤️8860477959 Escorts 100% Genuine Ser...
Lowrate Call Girls In Laxmi Nagar Delhi ❤️8860477959 Escorts 100% Genuine Ser...lizamodels9
 

Recently uploaded (20)

Marketing Management Business Plan_My Sweet Creations
Marketing Management Business Plan_My Sweet CreationsMarketing Management Business Plan_My Sweet Creations
Marketing Management Business Plan_My Sweet Creations
 
Lowrate Call Girls In Sector 18 Noida ❤️8860477959 Escorts 100% Genuine Servi...
Lowrate Call Girls In Sector 18 Noida ❤️8860477959 Escorts 100% Genuine Servi...Lowrate Call Girls In Sector 18 Noida ❤️8860477959 Escorts 100% Genuine Servi...
Lowrate Call Girls In Sector 18 Noida ❤️8860477959 Escorts 100% Genuine Servi...
 
VIP Call Girl Jamshedpur Aashi 8250192130 Independent Escort Service Jamshedpur
VIP Call Girl Jamshedpur Aashi 8250192130 Independent Escort Service JamshedpurVIP Call Girl Jamshedpur Aashi 8250192130 Independent Escort Service Jamshedpur
VIP Call Girl Jamshedpur Aashi 8250192130 Independent Escort Service Jamshedpur
 
Investment analysis and portfolio management
Investment analysis and portfolio managementInvestment analysis and portfolio management
Investment analysis and portfolio management
 
Call Girls In Radisson Blu Hotel New Delhi Paschim Vihar ❤️8860477959 Escorts...
Call Girls In Radisson Blu Hotel New Delhi Paschim Vihar ❤️8860477959 Escorts...Call Girls In Radisson Blu Hotel New Delhi Paschim Vihar ❤️8860477959 Escorts...
Call Girls In Radisson Blu Hotel New Delhi Paschim Vihar ❤️8860477959 Escorts...
 
Call Girls Miyapur 7001305949 all area service COD available Any Time
Call Girls Miyapur 7001305949 all area service COD available Any TimeCall Girls Miyapur 7001305949 all area service COD available Any Time
Call Girls Miyapur 7001305949 all area service COD available Any Time
 
Lean: From Theory to Practice — One City’s (and Library’s) Lean Story… Abridged
Lean: From Theory to Practice — One City’s (and Library’s) Lean Story… AbridgedLean: From Theory to Practice — One City’s (and Library’s) Lean Story… Abridged
Lean: From Theory to Practice — One City’s (and Library’s) Lean Story… Abridged
 
Progress Report - Oracle Database Analyst Summit
Progress  Report - Oracle Database Analyst SummitProgress  Report - Oracle Database Analyst Summit
Progress Report - Oracle Database Analyst Summit
 
(8264348440) 🔝 Call Girls In Keshav Puram 🔝 Delhi NCR
(8264348440) 🔝 Call Girls In Keshav Puram 🔝 Delhi NCR(8264348440) 🔝 Call Girls In Keshav Puram 🔝 Delhi NCR
(8264348440) 🔝 Call Girls In Keshav Puram 🔝 Delhi NCR
 
BEST Call Girls In Old Faridabad ✨ 9773824855 ✨ Escorts Service In Delhi Ncr,
BEST Call Girls In Old Faridabad ✨ 9773824855 ✨ Escorts Service In Delhi Ncr,BEST Call Girls In Old Faridabad ✨ 9773824855 ✨ Escorts Service In Delhi Ncr,
BEST Call Girls In Old Faridabad ✨ 9773824855 ✨ Escorts Service In Delhi Ncr,
 
Enjoy ➥8448380779▻ Call Girls In Sector 18 Noida Escorts Delhi NCR
Enjoy ➥8448380779▻ Call Girls In Sector 18 Noida Escorts Delhi NCREnjoy ➥8448380779▻ Call Girls In Sector 18 Noida Escorts Delhi NCR
Enjoy ➥8448380779▻ Call Girls In Sector 18 Noida Escorts Delhi NCR
 
KestrelPro Flyer Japan IT Week 2024 (English)
KestrelPro Flyer Japan IT Week 2024 (English)KestrelPro Flyer Japan IT Week 2024 (English)
KestrelPro Flyer Japan IT Week 2024 (English)
 
Non Text Magic Studio Magic Design for Presentations L&P.pptx
Non Text Magic Studio Magic Design for Presentations L&P.pptxNon Text Magic Studio Magic Design for Presentations L&P.pptx
Non Text Magic Studio Magic Design for Presentations L&P.pptx
 
Call Girls In ⇛⇛Chhatarpur⇚⇚. Brings Offer Delhi Contact Us 8377877756
Call Girls In ⇛⇛Chhatarpur⇚⇚. Brings Offer Delhi Contact Us 8377877756Call Girls In ⇛⇛Chhatarpur⇚⇚. Brings Offer Delhi Contact Us 8377877756
Call Girls In ⇛⇛Chhatarpur⇚⇚. Brings Offer Delhi Contact Us 8377877756
 
Call Girls in DELHI Cantt, ( Call Me )-8377877756-Female Escort- In Delhi / Ncr
Call Girls in DELHI Cantt, ( Call Me )-8377877756-Female Escort- In Delhi / NcrCall Girls in DELHI Cantt, ( Call Me )-8377877756-Female Escort- In Delhi / Ncr
Call Girls in DELHI Cantt, ( Call Me )-8377877756-Female Escort- In Delhi / Ncr
 
Call Girls In Sikandarpur Gurgaon ❤️8860477959_Russian 100% Genuine Escorts I...
Call Girls In Sikandarpur Gurgaon ❤️8860477959_Russian 100% Genuine Escorts I...Call Girls In Sikandarpur Gurgaon ❤️8860477959_Russian 100% Genuine Escorts I...
Call Girls In Sikandarpur Gurgaon ❤️8860477959_Russian 100% Genuine Escorts I...
 
2024 Numerator Consumer Study of Cannabis Usage
2024 Numerator Consumer Study of Cannabis Usage2024 Numerator Consumer Study of Cannabis Usage
2024 Numerator Consumer Study of Cannabis Usage
 
Best Practices for Implementing an External Recruiting Partnership
Best Practices for Implementing an External Recruiting PartnershipBest Practices for Implementing an External Recruiting Partnership
Best Practices for Implementing an External Recruiting Partnership
 
VIP Kolkata Call Girl Howrah 👉 8250192130 Available With Room
VIP Kolkata Call Girl Howrah 👉 8250192130  Available With RoomVIP Kolkata Call Girl Howrah 👉 8250192130  Available With Room
VIP Kolkata Call Girl Howrah 👉 8250192130 Available With Room
 
Lowrate Call Girls In Laxmi Nagar Delhi ❤️8860477959 Escorts 100% Genuine Ser...
Lowrate Call Girls In Laxmi Nagar Delhi ❤️8860477959 Escorts 100% Genuine Ser...Lowrate Call Girls In Laxmi Nagar Delhi ❤️8860477959 Escorts 100% Genuine Ser...
Lowrate Call Girls In Laxmi Nagar Delhi ❤️8860477959 Escorts 100% Genuine Ser...
 

25 berkeley j._gender_l._&_just._226,_-2

  • 1. NOTE: GENDER STEREO TYPES Email Request: Current Document: 4 Time Of Request: Tuesday, October 21, 2014 23:35:14 EST Send To: NEXIS, 146BTS DEVRY UNIVERSITY 3005 HIGHLAND PKWY DOWNERS GROVE, IL 60515-5799 Terms: (gender stereotypes) Source: Company Profiles and Directories;US Law Reviews and Journals, Combined;Federal & State Court Cases - After 1944, Combined;Newspaper Stories, Combined Papers Combined Source: Company Profiles and Directories;US Law Reviews and Journals, Combined;Federal & State Court Cases - After 1944, Combined;Newspaper Stories, Combined Papers Project ID:
  • 3. Page 3 25 Berkeley J. Gender L. & Just. 226, * 4 of 999 DOCUMENTS Copyright (c) 2010 The Regents of the University of California on behalf of Berkeley Journal of Gender, Law & Justice Spring, 2010 Berkeley Journal of Gender, Law & Justice 25 Berkeley J. Gender L. & Just. 226 LENGTH: 5189 words Books Received: Gender Stereotyping: Transnational Legal Perspectives by Rebecca J. Cook & Simone Cusack. Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania Press, 2010. 288 pp. $ 49.95 hardback. NAME: Aurora Kaiser LEXISNEXIS SUMMARY: ... The authors indicate that "this section is intended to illuminate the types of questions that might prove helpful in exposing and acknowledging the harms of gender stereotyping for women in different contexts" (p. 60) (emphasis added). ... When identifying the harm, Cook and Cusack indicate three major ways in which gender stereotypes can harm women: denying a benefit, imposing a burden, and degrading women by diminishing their dignity or otherwise marginalizing them (pp. 60, 59-68). ... The Women's Convention also requires States Parties to eliminate or modify "existing laws, regulations, customs and practices which constitute discrimination against women" (p. 72). ... Basas's work lays the foundation for advocates of women with disabilities to understand the complex ways in which gender and disability stereotypes combine to negatively affect women. HIGHLIGHT: The ability to eliminate a wrong is contingent on it first being "named," by which is meant that a particular experience has been identified and publically acknowledged as a wrong in need of legal and other forms of redress and subsequent prevention. (p. 39) TEXT: [*226] Introduction The book Gender Stereotyping: Transnational Legal Perspectives orients gender stereotyping as the underlying cause of much of the discrimination that occurs against women throughout the world. The book discusses the duty and ability of state and non-state actors to dismantle negative gender stereotypes and diminish their effect. The authors, Rebecca J. Cook and Simone Cusack, writing from a transnational perspective, n1 discuss this duty in the context of the Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Discrimination Against Women ("Women's Convention" or "Convention"). As Cook explained in another article, "[the Women's Convention] is the definitive international legal instrument requiring respect for and observance of the human rights of women; it is universal in reach, comprehensive in scope and legally binding in character." n2 The Convention has over 150 member states, n3 referred to as "States Parties" (p. [*227] 4). The Committee on the Elimination of Discrimination Against Women ("Women's Committee" or "Committee") was established to monitor States Parties' compliance with the Convention (p. 131). The Women's Committee was created, and its duties were subsequently expanded, in order to enhance the Convention's role in eliminating harmful
  • 4. Page 4 25 Berkeley J. Gender L. & Just. 226, * stereotypes and discrimination (pp. 131, 135). This refreshingly pragmatic book will interest practitioners and scholars of women's human rights alike. The authors make suggestions for how to argue that a state is in violation of the Convention and how the Committee should fulfill its role as a quasi-legislative body. In fact, the final chapters read as a handbook for both practitioners and members of the Committee itself. The book begins with a description of gender stereotyping (pp. 9-38). The authors suggest a "coherent methodology to address gender stereotyping ... in presenting arguments, and in proposing and drafting remedial judgments" (p. 177). This methodology consists of several steps, and can be applied to any context in which there is suspected gender stereotyping or discrimination. First, an advocate must name the operative gender stereotypes (pp. 39-70). This includes identifying their forms, contexts, and means of perpetuation and elimination (pp. 54-58). This also includes articulating the ways in which the stereotypes harm women (pp. 59-70). Once stereotypes have been named, and the harms have been identified, a remedial or preventive solution can be crafted (pp. 39-70). This process is analogous to the necessity of diagnosing a disease before it can be treated (p. 3). In discussing this methodology, I will draw examples from an article in this volume of the Berkeley Journal of Gender, Law & Justice, titled The New Boys: Women with Disabilities and the Legal Profession. n4 The author, Carrie Griffin Basas, describes her qualitative study of women with disabilities in the legal profession. She discusses the manner in which stereotypes about women with disabilities affect the women's careers and lives. The remaining chapters discuss the rights afforded by the Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Discrimination Against Women and the application of the aforementioned methodology to issues that may be brought before the Women's Committee. Chapter 3 emphasizes states' obligations to eliminate gender stereotyping and discrimination under the Women's Convention (pp. 71-103). Chapter 4 describes the States Parties' obligation to eradicate gender stereotyping, which is itself a form of discrimination (pp. 104-30). The authors then delve into what the role of the Women's Committee is, and what it could and should be to best advance the goals of the Convention (pp. 131- 72). Although these chapters are informative and useful in understanding [*228] and combating gender stereotyping and discrimination in international bodies that have ratified the Convention, this article focuses on the first two chapters, which will likely be the most interesting to our readers. I. The What, Why, and How of Gender Stereotyping The book's overarching theme is the ability and duty of domestic and international law and actors to eliminate or ameliorate the negative effects of gender stereotyping and discrimination. Inherent in that theme is the concept that gender stereotypes are at the root of discrimination against women. In order to understand the causative relationship, and thereafter to fashion remedies, it is necessary to understand the nature of stereotypes (p. 3). The first chapter, "Understanding Gender Stereotyping," goes in depth into the characteristics of gender stereotypes. Even for those of us that are aware of gender stereotyping and devote time to its study and elimination, this chapter will likely be illuminating. The authors regularly ask the reader to consider their own experiences when reading. I frequently paused to ponder the ways that stereotypes had affected my own life, whether I was being stereotyped or doing the stereotyping. A perception can be deemed a stereotype despite a documented correlation between the characteristic and the group of people presumed to have that characteristic (p. 9). At the same time, not all stereotypes are negative. For example, the statistically accurate stereotype that "women are physically weaker than men" is not problematic unless it is applied to the detriment of, for example, a woman who is denied the ability to apply to be a firefighter regardless of her actual strength (pp. 12, 15-16). Discriminatory stereotyping occurs when one's individual characteristics are ignored, and other characteristics are prescribed or presumed to exist merely due to the individual's membership in a group. "All the dimensions of personality that make that individual unique are consequently filtered through the lens of a generalized view or preconception of the group with which the individual is identified." (p. 9) Stereotypes of men can also hurt women, and they are therefore also relevant to this discussion (p. 6). For example, the stereotype that a man is or should be the breadwinner hurts men because it assumes that they cannot play a caregiver role, and it hurts women because it forces them into the caregiver role (pp. 11, 50-51).
  • 5. Page 5 25 Berkeley J. Gender L. & Just. 226, * The authors explain the "complex, varied and, sometimes, contradictory reasons" people stereotype (p. 13). The major reasons we stereotype are: to maximize simplicity and predictability in our uncomprehendingly complex world (pp. 14-16); to assign difference by labeling "people as being other than the norm with which we are familiar, particularly ourselves" (p. 16); and to script identities, which involves, when discussing gender stereotypes, "prescribing attributes, roles, and behaviors to which men and women are expected to conform." (p. 18) There are several types of gender stereotypes discussed in this book: sex, [*229] sexual, sex role, and compounded (pp. 25-31). There is some conceptual overlap among the types of sex stereotypes. "Sex stereotypes" are those that are allegedly based on physical or biological differences (pp. 25-26). "Sexual stereotypes" are those based on the perceived characteristics that play a role in sexuality, including, for example, sexual initiation, intimacy, possession, and objectification (pp. 27- 28). "Sex role stereotypes" describe a "normative or statistical view regarding appropriate roles or behavior for men and women" (p. 28). Although all are relevant to individuals interested in gender stereotypes, "compounded stereotypes" are most relevant to Berkeley Journal of Gender, Law & Justice's mandate to publish scholarship that examines "the intersection of gender with one or more other axes of subordination, including, but not limited to, race, class, sexual orientation, and disability." n5 The difficulty in addressing and describing compounded stereotypes is "identifying the different stereotypes that operate to discriminate against a woman because of each one of her traits, not just her gender." (pp. 29-30) The authors note that "compounded stereotypes often reflect false preconceptions about different subcategories of women, and evolve according to different articulations of patriarchy and power structures" (p. 31). Carrie Griffin Basas provides an example of compounded stereotypes, namely, women with mental and/or physical disabilities in the legal profession. Women with disabilities are scripted as weak, inadequate, and dependent. n6 Therefore, they may find it very hard to obtain and keep certain types of employment, such as in large law firms, irrespective of their actual attributes or abilities. n7 These stereotypes illustrate the difficulty of separating the degree to which disabled women are scripted due to their gender versus their disability. To the extent that this stereotype is linked to gender, it can be thought of as a sex stereotype because the stereotype is based on assumptions about physical and mental capacities of women with disabilities, and thus are linked to physical and biological differences. Women with disabilities are also scripted as asexual, n8 which is a sexual stereotype regarding the women's sexual capacity and the nature of her gender. Additionally, women with physical disabilities may be perceived as failing to, or feel they fail to, live up to the sex role stereotype that women should be attractive. n9 Gender stereotypes do not, of course, occur in a vacuum. The contexts in which gender stereotyping can "contribute to social stratification and [*230] subordination" are "individual," "situational," or "broad" (p. 32). The "individual" context includes the cognitive and behavioral. Women may internalize individual factors, and "come to accept them uncritically as a normal or inevitable understanding of life" (p. 32). Therefore, "cognitive processes and social pressures to conform are often cited as barriers to change gender stereotypes. Once individuals accept a label from others, this secondary labeling results in them conforming their self-image and behavior to that label" (p. 32). As Basas explains, "over time, disabled women attorneys internalize ... low expectations." n10 It is through internalization that gender stereotyping manifests in the "individual" context. Disabled women as a group are harmed when women with disabilities internalize the shame and fear around disability, and thus submit to the pressures to "cover." n11 Covering occurs when individuals are asked to downplay their differences or "pretend that they are not affiliated with their minority identities." n12 This results in "self-perpetuating" stigma, inasmuch as "opportunities are missed to make disability commonplace, familiar, and comfortable to nondisabled people." n13 "Situational" contexts include "predisposing conditions, found in different sectors, including the employment, family, and health sectors" (p. 32). Cook and Cusack explain that gender stereotypes are most likely to intrude in the situational context when one of three factors is present: when the "target or the subject of the stereotype is isolated"; when "members of a previously absent or omitted group move into an occupation or employment that is nontraditional for their group"; or when there is a "gender mismatch," in other words, "a preconceived lack of fit between the person's attributes and occupation" (p. 33). Not only are lawyers unlikely to have disabilities n14 and women unlikely to make
  • 6. Page 6 25 Berkeley J. Gender L. & Just. 226, * partner, n15 but women with disabilities are perceived as having attributes (such as weakness) that do not fit with the attributes perceived as being required for being lawyers, particularly in large firms. n16 That puts female lawyers with disabilities at a high risk of being the subject of hostile gender stereotyping, according to the theory explained by Cook and Cusack, which is supported by the data collected by Basas. n17 Finally, gender stereotyping acts to subordinate women in "broader" contexts, such as "cultural, religious, economic, and legal" (p. 32). Basas describes the "ableist culture" of large law firms, dominated by "paternalistic power hierarchies, incentives, and social (dis)order," n18 which values men with [*231] disabilities over women with disabilities. n19 Thus, gender and disability stereotypes act together within the professional culture of law firms to prescribe roles and limit opportunities for women with disabilities, but not necessarily for their non-disabled female and disabled male peers. II. The Importance of Naming Gender Stereotypes and the Associated Harms Cook and Cusack indicate that in scholarship or advocacy one must enunciate the forms, contexts, and methods of perpetuation of stereotypes, as well as the harms caused by them. They refer to this as "naming" the stereotype and explain that it "is an important tool for revealing an otherwise hidden harm, explaining its implications, and labeling it as a human rights concern, grievance, or possible human rights violation" (p. 39). In fact, the ability to eliminate wrongful gender stereotyping is contingent on examining "the nature, forms, causes, and effects" of stereotyping (p. 40). Naming gender stereotyping raises awareness of the harms associated with gender stereotyping (p. 41). This is especially important considering how much gender stereotyping operates at the subconscious level and is "frequently accepted as a culturally "normal' aspect of our sexed and gendered lives" (p. 41). Throughout the chapter, the authors recommend questions to ask to tease out gender stereotypes and the resultant sex discrimination that are sometimes difficult to detect. The two key questions necessary to "name" stereotypes are: "How does a law, policy, or practice stereotype men or women?" and "How does the application, enforcement, or perpetuation of a gender stereotype in a law, policy, or practice harm women?" (p. 42). Although the questions may seem obvious, the answers to these questions are vital to understanding and eliminating gender discrimination. Because the question of whether stereotyping is affecting individuals is ultimately a factual one (p. 46), the authors provide examples, expand on the above questions, and give factors that may indicate when gender stereotyping is present (pp. 46-58). Additionally, in answering these questions, the authors recommend that the forms, contexts, means of perpetuation, and means of elimination be considered (pp. 54-58). Part of this process is exposing operative gender stereotypes and their forms. The authors, in this regard, suggest first indentifying "what attributes, characteristics, or roles" the gender stereotype ascribes to individuals (p. 51). Then, one can ask, "What does it mean to ascribe to women certain attributes, characteristics, or roles?" (p. 51). This seems like an effective method for advocates and scholars to be clear and concise in "naming" gender stereotypes as the underlying cause of the harms discussed. Several examples include: . "women should be mothers and, therefore, they and not men ought to [*232] be concerned with matters relating to the bearing and rearing of children;" (p. 51) . "women are sexually passive and, therefore, they are disposed submissively to surrender to men's sexual advances;" (p. 52) . "women should dress modestly and, therefore, an immodestly dressed woman is responsible for her own sexual assault" (p. 53).
  • 7. Page 7 25 Berkeley J. Gender L. & Just. 226, * One such identification of gender stereotypes in Basas's article would be: . women with disabilities are weak and helpless and, therefore, they are not capable of performing the difficult and demanding work required in a large law-firm setting. Identification of the stereotype is vitally necessary as the first step in dismantling it. The second step is identifying its form, including the type, context and means of perpetuation (pp. 54-58). Finally, the third step is naming the harm (pp. 59-68). As Cook and Cusack explain, these three steps "are critical to making [the gender stereotype] recognizable, and therefore legally cognizable, that is, able to be judicially examined. Naming a stereotype is necessary in much the same way that a medical diagnosis is required before treatment can be applied." (p. 175) The same stereotype may result in different harms "according to community, country, or region" (p. 60). The authors give the example of the gender stereotype of women as men's property, which "may enable the marriage of girl children before the legal age of marriage in one community, contribute to some of the preconditions for forced marriage in another, or, elsewhere, the rape of a sister to punish her brother" (p. 60) (citations omitted). The authors indicate that "this section is intended to illuminate the types of questions that might prove helpful in exposing and acknowledging the harms of gender stereotyping for women in different contexts" (p. 60) (emphasis added). When identifying the harm, Cook and Cusack indicate three major ways in which gender stereotypes can harm women: denying a benefit, imposing a burden, and degrading women by diminishing their dignity or otherwise marginalizing them (pp. 60, 59-68). The women in Basas's study were denied a benefit when they were denied or forced out of employment, or certain types of employment, because they are women with disabilities n20 (p. 62). The burdens imposed on them due to stereotypes surrounding disability and gender include feeling the need to "cover." n21 Basas explains that, "in order to succeed, they are expected ... to fade gently into the background when any manifestation of their disability causes discomfort or awkwardness for their coworkers or [*233] supervisors." n22 As Cook and Cusack explain, a "gender stereotype might burden women when it restricts them to culturally acceptable roles or behavior" (p. 63). The third harm of gender stereotyping, degradation, manifests in number of different ways, including the "lowering of women's status, position, or rank in their marriages, families, and communities" (p. 64). This includes "downplaying or undermining women's competence, such as in cases where stereotypes posit that women are incapable of rigorous, abstract thought" (p. 64). Another example of degrading harm is simply "being treated differently than a man on account of a gender stereotype," or when it "diminishes their dignity as human beings" by "failing to recognize their intrinsic and equal worth as human beings or when, for example, it treats them in ways that do not take into account their actual situations" (pp. 64-65). The women in Basas's study were degraded in this manner, when they were deemed incompetent to perform certain types of work regardless of their individual capabilities. n23 III. Women's Convention and Women's Committee The Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Discrimination Against Women explicitly links gender stereotyping to discrimination against women and is an extremely valuable tool for combating these problems in a forum specifically created to eradicate them. The authors provide a type of manual for litigating and arguing these types of claims, and include significant advice for the Women's Committee members. This section gives a brief overview of the breadth and depth of the protections available under the Convention. The Convention specifically requires states to take appropriate measures to eliminate wrongful stereotyping (p. 71). The Women's Convention also requires States Parties to eliminate or modify "existing laws, regulations, customs and practices which constitute discrimination against women" (p. 72). The authors explain in detail what constitutes discrimination (pp. 104-30). Due to the highly factual nature of discrimination claims, the authors provide questions that should be asked in each circumstance to determine whether the action was prohibited by the convention. These include, for example, "Did a law, policy, or practice impair or nullify any of a woman's human rights or fundamental freedoms?" and "Was the application, enforcement, or perpetuation of a gender
  • 8. Page 8 25 Berkeley J. Gender L. & Just. 226, * stereotype in a law, policy, or practice justified?" (p. 106). The Convention applies to all state actors, including the executive, legislative and judicial branches (pp. 84-88). Moreover, the Convention may also apply to non-state actors under certain circumstances. For example, a State Party can be held responsible for "its failure to act with due diligence to prevent, investigate, deter, punish, and remedy wrongful gender stereotyping by non-state actors," such as private employers or places of public accommodation (p. 89). [*234] The Convention requires States Parties to remedy wrongful gender stereotyping (p. 93). The failure to provide effective remedies "fuels a climate of disregard, disrespect, and devaluation of women in all sectors of society" (p. 93). Cook and Cusack explain that effective remedies must contain individual compensatory remedies and "structural dimensions," which deinstitutionalize gender stereotypes from the laws, policies, and practices of States Parties (pp. 94-98). The Women's Committee monitors States Parties' compliance with the Convention. The Committee reviews States Parties' periodic reports, which are submitted every four years (p. 131). The reports typically "address measures undertaken to eliminate discrimination against women, as well as any factors or difficulties affecting implementation of the Convention" (p. 131). The reporting process has caused States Parties to "reflect on the adequacy of their steps undertaken to address wrongful forms of gender stereotyping" (p. 132). The Committee views these as a "constructive dialogue" and takes the opportunity to question representatives on the State Party's report and respond with Concluding Observations in which it identifies the strengths and weaknesses of the report (p. 132). The authors stress the normative function of the Committee. The Committee is a quasi-legislative body, which can hear claims under certain circumstances and can issue written recommendations to the State Party if it is found to have fallen short on its obligations under the Convention (pp. 135-37, 142- 60). In this regard, the authors suggest that "it would be helpful that the Committee not only articulate norms and standards on States Parties' obligations to eliminate and remedy gender stereotyping, but that it also engage in detailed factual and legal analysis of wrongful gender stereotyping" (p. 156). Additionally, the Committee can formulate General Recommendations, which interpret and define the obligations under the Convention (pp. 134-35). The authors suggest ways in which the Committee could craft a General Recommendation regarding the scope of States Parties' duties to eliminate wrongful gender stereotyping (p. 138). In many ways, this discussion mirrors the discussion in the preceding section of this article, regarding naming gender stereotyping and delineating its harms (pp.138-40). Finally, the Committee has the power to conduct an inquiry when it receives reliable information concerning grave or systematic violations by a State Party (pp. 160-65). At the end of the inquiry, the Committee publically issues its findings, comments, and recommendations to the State Party (p. 161). In all of these functions the Committee has the opportunity to play an important role defining the norms with which States Parties are expected to conform. Conclusion This book provides a clear and concise framework for discussing gender stereotypes and the manner in which they negatively impact women's human [*235] rights. For many inquiries it will be a starting point, and will suggest future areas to explore (such as other contexts in which a pernicious gender stereotype acts). In a similar manner, Basas's article is a starting point. n24 She has primarily named the stereotypes and described their harms. As Cook and Cusack have explained, the first step in treating a disease is to diagnose it (p. 3). Basas's work, in conjunction with Cook and Cusack's, would be invaluable to someone using the Convention to pursue rights for a woman with disabilities. When women have been discriminated against on the basis of compound stereotypes, advocates and tribunals may fail to identify all of the harmful stereotypes. Instead, the focus may be on a single aspect, like race or gender or disability. Cook and Cusack describe a case in which a Turkish national woman residing in the Netherlands was terminated from her job after becoming a mother. The explanation for termination stated that unlike women from the Netherlands who, the employer assumed, give up working right away, ""foreign women workers ... take the child to neighbours or family and at the slightest setback disappear on sick leave under the terms of the Sickness Act. They repeat that endlessly'" (p. 95). The woman was successful in her claim before the United Nations Committee on the Elimination of Race Discrimination that she was discriminated against on grounds of her ethnic Turkish status (p. 96). However, the Race Committee failed to recognize the gender stereotype that was at work, which stereotyped the woman "as an inferior mother because she had to
  • 9. Page 9 25 Berkeley J. Gender L. & Just. 226, * combine her roles as both mother and contributing breadwinner" (p. 96). It is easy to imagine that an advocate of a woman with a disability would focus solely on the disability as the claim of discrimination. This may be due to the difficulty of teasing out the various aspects of the discrimination. However, as Cook and Cusack explain, the Women's Convention is a valuable tool to women who have been discriminated against on the basis of compounded stereotypes. Basas's work lays the foundation for advocates of women with disabilities to understand the complex ways in which gender and disability stereotypes combine to negatively affect women. Legal Topics: For related research and practice materials, see the following legal topics: Labor & Employment LawDisability & Unemployment InsuranceDisability BenefitsGeneral OverviewLabor & Employment LawDiscriminationGender & Sex DiscriminationCoverage & DefinitionsSexual OrientationLabor & Employment LawDiscriminationGender & Sex DiscriminationCoverage & DefinitionsStereotypes FOOTNOTES: n1. A transnational legal process is characterized by four distinctive features: "First, it is nontraditional: it breaks down two traditional dichotomies that have historically dominated the study of international law: between domestic and international, public and private. Second, it is nonstatist; the actors in this process are not just, or even primarily, nation states, but include nonstate actors as well. Third, transnational legal process is dynamic, not static. Transnational law transforms, mutates, and percolates up and down, from the public to the private, from the domestic to the international level and back down again. Fourth and finally, it is normative. From this process of interaction, new rules of law emerge, which are interpreted, internalized, and enforced, thus beginning the process all over again." (p. 8) (quoting Harold Hongju Koh, Transnational Legal Process, 75 Neb. L. Rev. 181, 184 (1996)). n2. Rebecca Cook, Reservations to The Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Discrimination Against Women, 30 Va. J. Int'l L. 643, 643 (1990). n3. United Nations Treaty Collection, Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Discrimination Against Women, http://treaties.un.org/Pages/ViewDetails.aspx?src=TREATY& mtdsg_no=IV-8&chapter=4&lang=en (indicating which states have ratified the treaty since its inception in 1979, including most recently, Qatar in 2009) (last visited Mar. 24, 2010). The United States is a signatory to the Women's Convention, but has not ratified it. Id. n4. Carrie Griffin Basas, The New Boys: Women with Disabilities and the Legal Profession, 25 Berk. J. Gender L. & Just. 32 (2010). n5. Berkeley Journal of Gender, Law & Justice, http://www.boalt.org/bglj/ (last visited Mar. 24, 2010). n6. Basas, supra note 4, at 73 n.192 ("Women with disabilities are often excluded from stereotypically feminine jobs, as well as stereotypically masculine jobs because of society's perception of them as weak, dependent, and asexual.") (citation omitted).
  • 10. Page 10 25 Berkeley J. Gender L. & Just. 226, * n7. Id. at 73-75. n8. Id. at 73 n.192. n9. See id. at 73 ("More than anything, women with disabilities in mainstream American society often represent to others the perceived culmination of weaknesses, shortcomings, and inadequacies. They fail to meet gender ideals of beauty and perfection."). n10. Id. at 55. n11. Id. at 56-57, 70-76. n12. Id. at 70. n13. Id. at 56-57. n14. Id. at 67 n.161. n15. Id. at 68 n.166. n16. Id. at 73-75. n17. See generally id. n18. Id. at 48. n19. Id. at 55-56 ("Men with disabilities in the office had made partner years earlier or had directed some of the firm's paid work toward disability initiatives."). n20. See id. at 64-66. n21. Id. at 70.
  • 11. Page 11 25 Berkeley J. Gender L. & Just. 226, * n22. Id. at 71. n23. See id. at 64-66. n24. Id. at 112. This is something that Basas recognized. She indicated, "While these data provide a start to understanding the processes that lead to career choice and stratification among women with disabilities, they deserve more attention and dedicated studies of their experiences." Id.