SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 17
The empirical study on the
performance of 3G network
Project Guide : Dr. Huzur Saran


                   By: Ankit Bhadu
 Why do measurements ?
 What to measure ?
 How to measure ?
 References
 Bandwidth       related metrics:
  • Bulk Transfer Capacity (TCP throughput)
  • Available Bandwidth
  • Link Capacity
  • Error Rate.
 From   Where to Measure:
  • From End Host to Server .
  • From End Host to Gateway.(GGSN).
 Measurement    Models Discussed in the
 literature can be classified as
 • Available Bandwidth
    Probe gap model.(PGM)
    e.g. IGI, Spruce, Delphi.
   Probe rate model.(PRM)
    e.g. pathchrip, BART, TOPP, PTR.
 • Link Capacity
    e.g. Aymprobe, Capprobe
 • Packet loss Rate.
    e.g. ping.
E2E Uplink       E2E Downlink     E2 Gateway


TCP throughput   Iperf            Iperf


Available B/w    PathChirp/BART   PathChirp/BART   PathChirp/BART
                 /Spruce          /Spruce          /Spruce

Capacity         AsymProbe        AsymProbe        AsymProbe


Error Rate       Ping method      Ping method      Ping method
                                  from Server to
                                  End host
   W. L. Tan, F. Lam and W. C. Lau, “An Empirical Study on the Capacity and Performance
    of 3G Networks,” In IEEE Transactions on Mobile Computing, vol 7, no 6, June 2008.
   Zhou, A., Liu, M., Song, Y., Li, Z., Deng, H., & Yuanchen, M. (2008). A new
    method for end-to-end available bandwidth estimation. Paper presented at
    the GLOBECOM - IEEE Global Telecommunications Conference, 1519-1523
   Bergfeldt, E., Ekelin, S., & Karlsson, J. M. (2009). A performance study of
    bandwidth measurement tools over mobile connections. Paper presented at
    the IEEE Vehicular Technology Conference
   Castellanos, C. Ú, Villa, D. L., Teyeb, O. M., Ellingt, J., & Wigard, J. (2006).
    Comparison of available bandwidth estimation techniques in packet-switched
    mobile networks. Paper presented at the IEEE International Symposium on
    Personal, Indoor and Mobile Radio Communications, PIMRC
   Yao, J., Kanhere, S. S., & Hassan, M. (2008). An empirical study of bandwidth
    predictability in mobile computing. Paper presented at the Proceedings of the
    Annual International Conference on Mobile Computing and Networking,
    MOBICOM, 11-18.
Objectives:
- understand availability & performance of
  existing 3G infrastructure/network in Delhi.

-compare advertised and actual data rates
  of various companies.

- study the implication of existing network on
  higher layer protocols.
Various service provider offered
              Bandwidth
S no   Service provider   technology Speed up to
1      Reliance           HSPA/HSPA+ 21.6 Mbps

2      BSNL               HSPA         3.6 Mbps
                          EV-DO        2.4 Mbps
3      Idea               HSPA/HSPA+   14 Mbps
4      DOCOMO             HSPA/HSPA+   21.1 Mbps
5      MTNL               HSPA+        7.2 Mbps
6      Airtel             HSPA/HSPA+   7.2 Mbps
7      MTS                EV-DO        3.1 Mbps
Tasks Accomplished
• Study of GPRS/EDGE
  • Architecture of GPRS and New interface on GSM
  • Working of GPRS in PS (Packet Switching) Network
  • Comparison with EDGE Technology
• Study of HSPA (HSDPA/HSUPA)
  • Release 4
  • Release 5 (HSDPA)
  • Release 6 (HSUPA)
Architecture Network Diagram
 Curl   Test Result

              Airtel 3G (Kbps)   Mts (Kbps)
              Downloading        Downloading

              432.2              567.4

              612                732

              742                639.8

              866                511.1

              Avg(663.21)        Avg (612.8)
Shown the graph from both side (server side and client side)
Analysis:
    • Gap shows the packet loss.
    • It use the slow start phase.
Analysis
    • More no of retransmission
    • Small window size with compare to Airtel 3G
Prospective tasks:
• Study of HSPA+ (Release 7 and more)

• Understand the simulation of the MAC
  layer functioning in HSPA/HSPA+

• Bandwidth Comparison of 3G Providers
Thanks

More Related Content

What's hot

Dynamic resource allocation for opportunistic software-defined IoT networks: s...
Dynamic resource allocation for opportunistic software-defined IoT networks: s...Dynamic resource allocation for opportunistic software-defined IoT networks: s...
Dynamic resource allocation for opportunistic software-defined IoT networks: s...
IJECEIAES
 
Integrated approach for efficient power consumption and resource allocation i...
Integrated approach for efficient power consumption and resource allocation i...Integrated approach for efficient power consumption and resource allocation i...
Integrated approach for efficient power consumption and resource allocation i...
IJECEIAES
 

What's hot (20)

Load Balancing for Achieving the Network Lifetime in WSN-A Survey
Load Balancing for Achieving the Network Lifetime in WSN-A SurveyLoad Balancing for Achieving the Network Lifetime in WSN-A Survey
Load Balancing for Achieving the Network Lifetime in WSN-A Survey
 
Impact of macrocellular network densification on the capacity, energy and cos...
Impact of macrocellular network densification on the capacity, energy and cos...Impact of macrocellular network densification on the capacity, energy and cos...
Impact of macrocellular network densification on the capacity, energy and cos...
 
ENERGY SAVINGS IN APPLICATIONS FOR WIRELESS SENSOR NETWORKS TIME CRITICAL REQ...
ENERGY SAVINGS IN APPLICATIONS FOR WIRELESS SENSOR NETWORKS TIME CRITICAL REQ...ENERGY SAVINGS IN APPLICATIONS FOR WIRELESS SENSOR NETWORKS TIME CRITICAL REQ...
ENERGY SAVINGS IN APPLICATIONS FOR WIRELESS SENSOR NETWORKS TIME CRITICAL REQ...
 
Dynamic resource allocation for opportunistic software-defined IoT networks: s...
Dynamic resource allocation for opportunistic software-defined IoT networks: s...Dynamic resource allocation for opportunistic software-defined IoT networks: s...
Dynamic resource allocation for opportunistic software-defined IoT networks: s...
 
A DYNAMIC ROUTE DISCOVERY SCHEME FOR HETEROGENEOUS WIRELESS SENSOR NETWORKS B...
A DYNAMIC ROUTE DISCOVERY SCHEME FOR HETEROGENEOUS WIRELESS SENSOR NETWORKS B...A DYNAMIC ROUTE DISCOVERY SCHEME FOR HETEROGENEOUS WIRELESS SENSOR NETWORKS B...
A DYNAMIC ROUTE DISCOVERY SCHEME FOR HETEROGENEOUS WIRELESS SENSOR NETWORKS B...
 
Energy packet networks with energy harvesting
Energy packet networks with energy harvestingEnergy packet networks with energy harvesting
Energy packet networks with energy harvesting
 
Scheduling wireless virtual networks functions
Scheduling wireless virtual networks functionsScheduling wireless virtual networks functions
Scheduling wireless virtual networks functions
 
IEEE BE-BTECH NS2 PROJECT@ DREAMWEB TECHNO SOLUTION
IEEE BE-BTECH NS2 PROJECT@ DREAMWEB TECHNO SOLUTIONIEEE BE-BTECH NS2 PROJECT@ DREAMWEB TECHNO SOLUTION
IEEE BE-BTECH NS2 PROJECT@ DREAMWEB TECHNO SOLUTION
 
Inter-Cell Interference Coordination in Heterogeneous Networks with Open Ac...
Inter-Cell Interference Coordination in  Heterogeneous Networks with Open  Ac...Inter-Cell Interference Coordination in  Heterogeneous Networks with Open  Ac...
Inter-Cell Interference Coordination in Heterogeneous Networks with Open Ac...
 
IRJET- Security and QoS Aware Dynamic Clustering (SQADC) Routing Protocol for...
IRJET- Security and QoS Aware Dynamic Clustering (SQADC) Routing Protocol for...IRJET- Security and QoS Aware Dynamic Clustering (SQADC) Routing Protocol for...
IRJET- Security and QoS Aware Dynamic Clustering (SQADC) Routing Protocol for...
 
An Efficient Parallel Algorithm for Secured Data Communication Using RSA Publ...
An Efficient Parallel Algorithm for Secured Data Communication Using RSA Publ...An Efficient Parallel Algorithm for Secured Data Communication Using RSA Publ...
An Efficient Parallel Algorithm for Secured Data Communication Using RSA Publ...
 
An automated dynamic offset for network selection in heterogeneous networks
An automated dynamic offset for network selection in heterogeneous networksAn automated dynamic offset for network selection in heterogeneous networks
An automated dynamic offset for network selection in heterogeneous networks
 
Routing in Wireless Sensor Networks: Improved Energy Efficiency and Coverage ...
Routing in Wireless Sensor Networks: Improved Energy Efficiency and Coverage ...Routing in Wireless Sensor Networks: Improved Energy Efficiency and Coverage ...
Routing in Wireless Sensor Networks: Improved Energy Efficiency and Coverage ...
 
Data collection in multi application sharing
Data collection in multi application sharingData collection in multi application sharing
Data collection in multi application sharing
 
Data collection in multi application sharing
Data collection in multi application sharingData collection in multi application sharing
Data collection in multi application sharing
 
50120140506003
5012014050600350120140506003
50120140506003
 
Integrated approach for efficient power consumption and resource allocation i...
Integrated approach for efficient power consumption and resource allocation i...Integrated approach for efficient power consumption and resource allocation i...
Integrated approach for efficient power consumption and resource allocation i...
 
Heterogeneous Network Project Topics
Heterogeneous Network Project TopicsHeterogeneous Network Project Topics
Heterogeneous Network Project Topics
 
Performance Analysis and Comparison of Routing Protocols in Wireless Sensor N...
Performance Analysis and Comparison of Routing Protocols in Wireless Sensor N...Performance Analysis and Comparison of Routing Protocols in Wireless Sensor N...
Performance Analysis and Comparison of Routing Protocols in Wireless Sensor N...
 
Adaptive Digital Filter Design for Linear Noise Cancellation Using Neural Net...
Adaptive Digital Filter Design for Linear Noise Cancellation Using Neural Net...Adaptive Digital Filter Design for Linear Noise Cancellation Using Neural Net...
Adaptive Digital Filter Design for Linear Noise Cancellation Using Neural Net...
 

Viewers also liked (6)

HSPA Evolution (HSPA+) overview July 2010
HSPA Evolution (HSPA+) overview July 2010HSPA Evolution (HSPA+) overview July 2010
HSPA Evolution (HSPA+) overview July 2010
 
DC-HSPA+ technology
DC-HSPA+ technologyDC-HSPA+ technology
DC-HSPA+ technology
 
2013 hspa optimization doc huawei
2013 hspa optimization doc huawei2013 hspa optimization doc huawei
2013 hspa optimization doc huawei
 
Techno-economical aspects of LTE mobile broadband at 800 MHz and 2.6 GHz
Techno-economical aspects of LTE mobile broadband at 800 MHz and 2.6 GHzTechno-economical aspects of LTE mobile broadband at 800 MHz and 2.6 GHz
Techno-economical aspects of LTE mobile broadband at 800 MHz and 2.6 GHz
 
Lte World Summit 2010
Lte World Summit 2010Lte World Summit 2010
Lte World Summit 2010
 
Capacity planning in mobile data networks experiencing exponential growth in ...
Capacity planning in mobile data networks experiencing exponential growth in ...Capacity planning in mobile data networks experiencing exponential growth in ...
Capacity planning in mobile data networks experiencing exponential growth in ...
 

Similar to Presentation1

Ncct Ieee Software Abstract Collection Volume 2 50+ Abst
Ncct   Ieee Software Abstract Collection Volume 2   50+ AbstNcct   Ieee Software Abstract Collection Volume 2   50+ Abst
Ncct Ieee Software Abstract Collection Volume 2 50+ Abst
ncct
 
Ftp and database statistics in wireless network environment for web client 2
Ftp and database statistics in wireless network environment for web client 2Ftp and database statistics in wireless network environment for web client 2
Ftp and database statistics in wireless network environment for web client 2
IAEME Publication
 
A Survey on Vehicle to Infrastructure Communication System
A Survey on Vehicle to Infrastructure Communication SystemA Survey on Vehicle to Infrastructure Communication System
A Survey on Vehicle to Infrastructure Communication System
IOSR Journals
 
Ppt on smart small cell with hybrid beamforming for 5 g
Ppt on smart small cell with hybrid beamforming for 5 gPpt on smart small cell with hybrid beamforming for 5 g
Ppt on smart small cell with hybrid beamforming for 5 g
Bhaskar Gurana
 
AN EFFICIENT BANDWIDTH OPTIMIZATION AND MINIMIZING ENERGY CONSUMPTION UTILIZI...
AN EFFICIENT BANDWIDTH OPTIMIZATION AND MINIMIZING ENERGY CONSUMPTION UTILIZI...AN EFFICIENT BANDWIDTH OPTIMIZATION AND MINIMIZING ENERGY CONSUMPTION UTILIZI...
AN EFFICIENT BANDWIDTH OPTIMIZATION AND MINIMIZING ENERGY CONSUMPTION UTILIZI...
IJCNCJournal
 
Throughput Maximization using Spatial Reusability in Multi Hop Wireless Network
Throughput Maximization using Spatial Reusability in Multi Hop Wireless NetworkThroughput Maximization using Spatial Reusability in Multi Hop Wireless Network
Throughput Maximization using Spatial Reusability in Multi Hop Wireless Network
ijtsrd
 

Similar to Presentation1 (20)

Radio Link Analysis for 4G TD- LTE Technology at 2.3 GHz Frequency
Radio Link Analysis for 4G TD- LTE Technology at 2.3 GHz FrequencyRadio Link Analysis for 4G TD- LTE Technology at 2.3 GHz Frequency
Radio Link Analysis for 4G TD- LTE Technology at 2.3 GHz Frequency
 
SYNOPSIS ON IMPLEMENTING SC-FDMA AND OFDMA IN MATLAB
SYNOPSIS ON IMPLEMENTING SC-FDMA AND  OFDMA IN MATLAB  SYNOPSIS ON IMPLEMENTING SC-FDMA AND  OFDMA IN MATLAB
SYNOPSIS ON IMPLEMENTING SC-FDMA AND OFDMA IN MATLAB
 
Ncct Ieee Software Abstract Collection Volume 2 50+ Abst
Ncct   Ieee Software Abstract Collection Volume 2   50+ AbstNcct   Ieee Software Abstract Collection Volume 2   50+ Abst
Ncct Ieee Software Abstract Collection Volume 2 50+ Abst
 
Location Based Routing Protocols and its Performances in Wireless Sensor Netw...
Location Based Routing Protocols and its Performances in Wireless Sensor Netw...Location Based Routing Protocols and its Performances in Wireless Sensor Netw...
Location Based Routing Protocols and its Performances in Wireless Sensor Netw...
 
Ftp and database statistics in wireless network environment for web client 2
Ftp and database statistics in wireless network environment for web client 2Ftp and database statistics in wireless network environment for web client 2
Ftp and database statistics in wireless network environment for web client 2
 
Performance Analysis of Different Modulation Schemes using Wi-Max And LTE
Performance Analysis of Different Modulation Schemes using Wi-Max And LTEPerformance Analysis of Different Modulation Schemes using Wi-Max And LTE
Performance Analysis of Different Modulation Schemes using Wi-Max And LTE
 
EMPIRICAL PERFORMANCE EVALUATION OF ENHANCED THROUGHPUT SCHEMES OF IEEE802.11...
EMPIRICAL PERFORMANCE EVALUATION OF ENHANCED THROUGHPUT SCHEMES OF IEEE802.11...EMPIRICAL PERFORMANCE EVALUATION OF ENHANCED THROUGHPUT SCHEMES OF IEEE802.11...
EMPIRICAL PERFORMANCE EVALUATION OF ENHANCED THROUGHPUT SCHEMES OF IEEE802.11...
 
Bit Error Rate Analysis in WiMAX Communication at Vehicular Speeds using mod...
Bit Error Rate Analysis in WiMAX Communication at Vehicular  Speeds using mod...Bit Error Rate Analysis in WiMAX Communication at Vehicular  Speeds using mod...
Bit Error Rate Analysis in WiMAX Communication at Vehicular Speeds using mod...
 
Gokul
GokulGokul
Gokul
 
Review on design of advanced opportunistics routing in manet
Review on design of advanced opportunistics routing in manetReview on design of advanced opportunistics routing in manet
Review on design of advanced opportunistics routing in manet
 
AN ADVANCED QOS ANALYSIS AND EVALUATION METHOD FOR MOBILE INTERNET ACCESS
AN ADVANCED QOS ANALYSIS AND EVALUATION METHOD FOR MOBILE INTERNET ACCESS AN ADVANCED QOS ANALYSIS AND EVALUATION METHOD FOR MOBILE INTERNET ACCESS
AN ADVANCED QOS ANALYSIS AND EVALUATION METHOD FOR MOBILE INTERNET ACCESS
 
AN ADVANCED QOS ANALYSIS AND EVALUATION METHOD FOR MOBILE INTERNET ACCESS
AN ADVANCED QOS ANALYSIS AND EVALUATION METHOD FOR MOBILE INTERNET ACCESS AN ADVANCED QOS ANALYSIS AND EVALUATION METHOD FOR MOBILE INTERNET ACCESS
AN ADVANCED QOS ANALYSIS AND EVALUATION METHOD FOR MOBILE INTERNET ACCESS
 
A Survey on Vehicle to Infrastructure Communication System
A Survey on Vehicle to Infrastructure Communication SystemA Survey on Vehicle to Infrastructure Communication System
A Survey on Vehicle to Infrastructure Communication System
 
011001010 a
011001010 a011001010 a
011001010 a
 
Ppt on smart small cell with hybrid beamforming for 5 g
Ppt on smart small cell with hybrid beamforming for 5 gPpt on smart small cell with hybrid beamforming for 5 g
Ppt on smart small cell with hybrid beamforming for 5 g
 
4 gstudy
4 gstudy4 gstudy
4 gstudy
 
AN EFFICIENT BANDWIDTH OPTIMIZATION AND MINIMIZING ENERGY CONSUMPTION UTILIZI...
AN EFFICIENT BANDWIDTH OPTIMIZATION AND MINIMIZING ENERGY CONSUMPTION UTILIZI...AN EFFICIENT BANDWIDTH OPTIMIZATION AND MINIMIZING ENERGY CONSUMPTION UTILIZI...
AN EFFICIENT BANDWIDTH OPTIMIZATION AND MINIMIZING ENERGY CONSUMPTION UTILIZI...
 
L010636772
L010636772L010636772
L010636772
 
A Comparative Study on 4G and 5G Technology for Wireless Applications
A Comparative Study on 4G and 5G Technology for Wireless ApplicationsA Comparative Study on 4G and 5G Technology for Wireless Applications
A Comparative Study on 4G and 5G Technology for Wireless Applications
 
Throughput Maximization using Spatial Reusability in Multi Hop Wireless Network
Throughput Maximization using Spatial Reusability in Multi Hop Wireless NetworkThroughput Maximization using Spatial Reusability in Multi Hop Wireless Network
Throughput Maximization using Spatial Reusability in Multi Hop Wireless Network
 

Presentation1

  • 1. The empirical study on the performance of 3G network
  • 2. Project Guide : Dr. Huzur Saran By: Ankit Bhadu
  • 3.  Why do measurements ?  What to measure ?  How to measure ?  References
  • 4.  Bandwidth related metrics: • Bulk Transfer Capacity (TCP throughput) • Available Bandwidth • Link Capacity • Error Rate.  From Where to Measure: • From End Host to Server . • From End Host to Gateway.(GGSN).
  • 5.  Measurement Models Discussed in the literature can be classified as • Available Bandwidth  Probe gap model.(PGM)  e.g. IGI, Spruce, Delphi.  Probe rate model.(PRM)  e.g. pathchrip, BART, TOPP, PTR. • Link Capacity  e.g. Aymprobe, Capprobe • Packet loss Rate.  e.g. ping.
  • 6. E2E Uplink E2E Downlink E2 Gateway TCP throughput Iperf Iperf Available B/w PathChirp/BART PathChirp/BART PathChirp/BART /Spruce /Spruce /Spruce Capacity AsymProbe AsymProbe AsymProbe Error Rate Ping method Ping method Ping method from Server to End host
  • 7. W. L. Tan, F. Lam and W. C. Lau, “An Empirical Study on the Capacity and Performance of 3G Networks,” In IEEE Transactions on Mobile Computing, vol 7, no 6, June 2008.  Zhou, A., Liu, M., Song, Y., Li, Z., Deng, H., & Yuanchen, M. (2008). A new method for end-to-end available bandwidth estimation. Paper presented at the GLOBECOM - IEEE Global Telecommunications Conference, 1519-1523  Bergfeldt, E., Ekelin, S., & Karlsson, J. M. (2009). A performance study of bandwidth measurement tools over mobile connections. Paper presented at the IEEE Vehicular Technology Conference  Castellanos, C. Ú, Villa, D. L., Teyeb, O. M., Ellingt, J., & Wigard, J. (2006). Comparison of available bandwidth estimation techniques in packet-switched mobile networks. Paper presented at the IEEE International Symposium on Personal, Indoor and Mobile Radio Communications, PIMRC  Yao, J., Kanhere, S. S., & Hassan, M. (2008). An empirical study of bandwidth predictability in mobile computing. Paper presented at the Proceedings of the Annual International Conference on Mobile Computing and Networking, MOBICOM, 11-18.
  • 8. Objectives: - understand availability & performance of existing 3G infrastructure/network in Delhi. -compare advertised and actual data rates of various companies. - study the implication of existing network on higher layer protocols.
  • 9. Various service provider offered Bandwidth S no Service provider technology Speed up to 1 Reliance HSPA/HSPA+ 21.6 Mbps 2 BSNL HSPA 3.6 Mbps EV-DO 2.4 Mbps 3 Idea HSPA/HSPA+ 14 Mbps 4 DOCOMO HSPA/HSPA+ 21.1 Mbps 5 MTNL HSPA+ 7.2 Mbps 6 Airtel HSPA/HSPA+ 7.2 Mbps 7 MTS EV-DO 3.1 Mbps
  • 10. Tasks Accomplished • Study of GPRS/EDGE • Architecture of GPRS and New interface on GSM • Working of GPRS in PS (Packet Switching) Network • Comparison with EDGE Technology • Study of HSPA (HSDPA/HSUPA) • Release 4 • Release 5 (HSDPA) • Release 6 (HSUPA)
  • 12.  Curl Test Result Airtel 3G (Kbps) Mts (Kbps) Downloading Downloading 432.2 567.4 612 732 742 639.8 866 511.1 Avg(663.21) Avg (612.8)
  • 13. Shown the graph from both side (server side and client side) Analysis: • Gap shows the packet loss. • It use the slow start phase.
  • 14. Analysis • More no of retransmission • Small window size with compare to Airtel 3G
  • 15.
  • 16. Prospective tasks: • Study of HSPA+ (Release 7 and more) • Understand the simulation of the MAC layer functioning in HSPA/HSPA+ • Bandwidth Comparison of 3G Providers