SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 1
Download to read offline
Analysis of a Wireless Powered Cooperative Network using a
Hybrid Relay
Introduction
Contact: u5228414@anu.edu.au
Research School of Engineering
ANU College of Engineering & Computer Science
Kazi Ahnaf Ahmed Supervisor: Dr Xiangyun (Sean) Zhou
2nd Conference on Engineering Students Individual Projects
CESIP
October 2015
Eliminating the need for recharging and replacing batteries in
wireless devices has been a long-standing ICT challenge. Wireless
Power Transfer (WPT) promises to be an attractive solution to cut
the last wires connecting mobiles devices to the grid. Recent
advancements in Microwave Power Transmission (MPT) have
made WPT a feasible technology for long range applications. This
research topic analyses a Wireless Powered Communication
(WPCN) powered by MPT technology to the answer the question:
‘How does the performance of a WPCN compare to a conventional
cellular network?’
Previous Work
Methodology
 The E-C protocol is superior to D-C protocol under all tested
scenarios
 Performance of the WPCN drops off significantly after 5-7m
 The WPCN should be implemented in high density this may
require an overhaul of the existing architecture
 Massive MIMO and Small Cell Networks are key enabling
technologies for WPCNs.
Results
The system performance is measured using the average
throughput. The throughput is the rate of successful message
delivery over a communication network. The source is moved
relative to the AP and hybrid relay and the throughput is measured
to determine the range of the WPCN.
The system is optimized for maximum throughput by varying the
energy transfer and power transmission time fractions. The
optimized system is then compared with a conventional cellular
network and the results are used to propose a network
architecture.
Conclusion
 (Chen et al. 2014) introduced a simple wireless powered
cooperative network model. This is used as the starting point to
answer the research question.
 (Huang & Lau 2014) proposes a network architecture of power
beacons overlaid on the existing cellular network.
 The research paper by (Huang & Zhou 2015) discusses key
breakthroughs for WPT including massive MIMO and Small Cell
Networks.
The optimized throughput for the for the Energy Cooperation
Protocol is shown by the surface plot in Figure 4. The
corresponding energy transfer time is illustrated using Figure 5.
Figure 1: System Model (Chen et al. 2014)
Figure 3: Dual-Cooperation ProtocolFigure 2: Energy-Cooperation
Protocol
Figure 4: Maximum Throughput Figure 5: Optimized time fraction
Figure 6: Comparison of system performance for conventional
cellular network and WPCN
Reference
The model by (Chen at al. 2014) shown in Figure 1 is analysed
using the two communication protocols illustrated in Figure 2 and
3. The Access Point (AP) and Hybrid Relay (R) are used to transfer
energy to the Source (S) in the first time instance. In the Energy
Cooperation (E-C) protocol the source transmits information
directly to the AP using the harvested energy. For the Dual
Cooperation (D-C) protocol the source transmits the information
signal through the hybrid relay in addition to the direct path.
Figure 6 below compares the un-optimized and optimized system
protocols with two conventional cellular network protocols.
 Chen, H. et al., 2014. Wireless-Powered Cooperative Communications via a Hybrid Relay. ,
p.5. Available at: http://arxiv.org/abs/1408.4841.
 Huang, K. & Lau, V.K.N., 2014. Realizing wireless power transfer in cellular networks.
Communications (ICC), 2014 IEEE International Conference on, 13(2), pp.5544–5549.
 Huang, K. & Zhou, X., 2015. Cutting the last wires for mobile communications by microwave
power transfer. IEEE Communications Magazine, 53(6), pp.86–93. Available at:
http://ieeexplore.ieee.org/lpdocs/epic03/wrapper.htm?arnumber=7120022

More Related Content

What's hot

Energy Efficient Wireless Communications
Energy Efficient Wireless CommunicationsEnergy Efficient Wireless Communications
Energy Efficient Wireless CommunicationsJingon Joung
 
Green Networks
Green NetworksGreen Networks
Green NetworksNeenu Ks
 
5G green communication
5G green communication5G green communication
5G green communicationAhmad El Tawil
 
Energy efficient wireless technology
Energy efficient wireless technologyEnergy efficient wireless technology
Energy efficient wireless technologyEisha Madhwal
 
Energy Behavior in Ad Hoc Network Minimizing the Number of Hops and Maintaini...
Energy Behavior in Ad Hoc Network Minimizing the Number of Hops and Maintaini...Energy Behavior in Ad Hoc Network Minimizing the Number of Hops and Maintaini...
Energy Behavior in Ad Hoc Network Minimizing the Number of Hops and Maintaini...CSCJournals
 
Impact of macrocellular network densification on the capacity, energy and cos...
Impact of macrocellular network densification on the capacity, energy and cos...Impact of macrocellular network densification on the capacity, energy and cos...
Impact of macrocellular network densification on the capacity, energy and cos...ijwmn
 
NETWORK ENERGY SAVING TECHNOLOGIES FOR GREEN WIRELESS ACCESS NETWORKS
NETWORK ENERGY SAVING TECHNOLOGIES FOR GREEN WIRELESS ACCESS NETWORKSNETWORK ENERGY SAVING TECHNOLOGIES FOR GREEN WIRELESS ACCESS NETWORKS
NETWORK ENERGY SAVING TECHNOLOGIES FOR GREEN WIRELESS ACCESS NETWORKSMadhav Thekkedath
 
Inter-Cell Interference Coordination in Heterogeneous Networks with Open Ac...
Inter-Cell Interference Coordination in  Heterogeneous Networks with Open  Ac...Inter-Cell Interference Coordination in  Heterogeneous Networks with Open  Ac...
Inter-Cell Interference Coordination in Heterogeneous Networks with Open Ac...toha ardi nugraha
 
Network efficiency enhancement by reactive channel state based allocation sch...
Network efficiency enhancement by reactive channel state based allocation sch...Network efficiency enhancement by reactive channel state based allocation sch...
Network efficiency enhancement by reactive channel state based allocation sch...IJECEIAES
 
Sierpinski carpet fractal monopole antenna for ultra-wideband applications
Sierpinski carpet fractal monopole antenna for ultra-wideband applications Sierpinski carpet fractal monopole antenna for ultra-wideband applications
Sierpinski carpet fractal monopole antenna for ultra-wideband applications IJECEIAES
 
Load Balancing for Achieving the Network Lifetime in WSN-A Survey
Load Balancing for Achieving the Network Lifetime in WSN-A SurveyLoad Balancing for Achieving the Network Lifetime in WSN-A Survey
Load Balancing for Achieving the Network Lifetime in WSN-A SurveyAM Publications
 
A Novel Weighted Clustering Based Approach for Improving the Wireless Sensor ...
A Novel Weighted Clustering Based Approach for Improving the Wireless Sensor ...A Novel Weighted Clustering Based Approach for Improving the Wireless Sensor ...
A Novel Weighted Clustering Based Approach for Improving the Wireless Sensor ...IJERA Editor
 
Performance of symmetric and asymmetric links in wireless networks
Performance of symmetric and asymmetric links in wireless networks Performance of symmetric and asymmetric links in wireless networks
Performance of symmetric and asymmetric links in wireless networks IJECEIAES
 
MeMLO: Mobility-Enabled Multi-Level Optimization Sensor Network
MeMLO: Mobility-Enabled Multi-Level Optimization Sensor Network MeMLO: Mobility-Enabled Multi-Level Optimization Sensor Network
MeMLO: Mobility-Enabled Multi-Level Optimization Sensor Network IJECEIAES
 
International Conference on IEEE ICT Convergence 2013
International Conference on IEEE ICT Convergence 2013International Conference on IEEE ICT Convergence 2013
International Conference on IEEE ICT Convergence 2013toha ardi nugraha
 
IRJET- MIMO-Energy Efficient and Spectrum Analysis using Congnitive Radio Tec...
IRJET- MIMO-Energy Efficient and Spectrum Analysis using Congnitive Radio Tec...IRJET- MIMO-Energy Efficient and Spectrum Analysis using Congnitive Radio Tec...
IRJET- MIMO-Energy Efficient and Spectrum Analysis using Congnitive Radio Tec...IRJET Journal
 

What's hot (17)

Energy Efficient Wireless Communications
Energy Efficient Wireless CommunicationsEnergy Efficient Wireless Communications
Energy Efficient Wireless Communications
 
Green Networks
Green NetworksGreen Networks
Green Networks
 
5G green communication
5G green communication5G green communication
5G green communication
 
Energy efficient wireless technology
Energy efficient wireless technologyEnergy efficient wireless technology
Energy efficient wireless technology
 
Energy Behavior in Ad Hoc Network Minimizing the Number of Hops and Maintaini...
Energy Behavior in Ad Hoc Network Minimizing the Number of Hops and Maintaini...Energy Behavior in Ad Hoc Network Minimizing the Number of Hops and Maintaini...
Energy Behavior in Ad Hoc Network Minimizing the Number of Hops and Maintaini...
 
Impact of macrocellular network densification on the capacity, energy and cos...
Impact of macrocellular network densification on the capacity, energy and cos...Impact of macrocellular network densification on the capacity, energy and cos...
Impact of macrocellular network densification on the capacity, energy and cos...
 
NETWORK ENERGY SAVING TECHNOLOGIES FOR GREEN WIRELESS ACCESS NETWORKS
NETWORK ENERGY SAVING TECHNOLOGIES FOR GREEN WIRELESS ACCESS NETWORKSNETWORK ENERGY SAVING TECHNOLOGIES FOR GREEN WIRELESS ACCESS NETWORKS
NETWORK ENERGY SAVING TECHNOLOGIES FOR GREEN WIRELESS ACCESS NETWORKS
 
Inter-Cell Interference Coordination in Heterogeneous Networks with Open Ac...
Inter-Cell Interference Coordination in  Heterogeneous Networks with Open  Ac...Inter-Cell Interference Coordination in  Heterogeneous Networks with Open  Ac...
Inter-Cell Interference Coordination in Heterogeneous Networks with Open Ac...
 
Network efficiency enhancement by reactive channel state based allocation sch...
Network efficiency enhancement by reactive channel state based allocation sch...Network efficiency enhancement by reactive channel state based allocation sch...
Network efficiency enhancement by reactive channel state based allocation sch...
 
Sierpinski carpet fractal monopole antenna for ultra-wideband applications
Sierpinski carpet fractal monopole antenna for ultra-wideband applications Sierpinski carpet fractal monopole antenna for ultra-wideband applications
Sierpinski carpet fractal monopole antenna for ultra-wideband applications
 
Load Balancing for Achieving the Network Lifetime in WSN-A Survey
Load Balancing for Achieving the Network Lifetime in WSN-A SurveyLoad Balancing for Achieving the Network Lifetime in WSN-A Survey
Load Balancing for Achieving the Network Lifetime in WSN-A Survey
 
A Novel Weighted Clustering Based Approach for Improving the Wireless Sensor ...
A Novel Weighted Clustering Based Approach for Improving the Wireless Sensor ...A Novel Weighted Clustering Based Approach for Improving the Wireless Sensor ...
A Novel Weighted Clustering Based Approach for Improving the Wireless Sensor ...
 
Performance of symmetric and asymmetric links in wireless networks
Performance of symmetric and asymmetric links in wireless networks Performance of symmetric and asymmetric links in wireless networks
Performance of symmetric and asymmetric links in wireless networks
 
MeMLO: Mobility-Enabled Multi-Level Optimization Sensor Network
MeMLO: Mobility-Enabled Multi-Level Optimization Sensor Network MeMLO: Mobility-Enabled Multi-Level Optimization Sensor Network
MeMLO: Mobility-Enabled Multi-Level Optimization Sensor Network
 
International Conference on IEEE ICT Convergence 2013
International Conference on IEEE ICT Convergence 2013International Conference on IEEE ICT Convergence 2013
International Conference on IEEE ICT Convergence 2013
 
IRJET- MIMO-Energy Efficient and Spectrum Analysis using Congnitive Radio Tec...
IRJET- MIMO-Energy Efficient and Spectrum Analysis using Congnitive Radio Tec...IRJET- MIMO-Energy Efficient and Spectrum Analysis using Congnitive Radio Tec...
IRJET- MIMO-Energy Efficient and Spectrum Analysis using Congnitive Radio Tec...
 
K016136062
K016136062K016136062
K016136062
 

Similar to Poster Version 4

2013 03-20 zhang
2013 03-20 zhang2013 03-20 zhang
2013 03-20 zhangSCEE Team
 
IRJET- Power Line Carrier Communication (PLCC) Systems: A Review
IRJET- Power Line Carrier Communication (PLCC) Systems: A ReviewIRJET- Power Line Carrier Communication (PLCC) Systems: A Review
IRJET- Power Line Carrier Communication (PLCC) Systems: A ReviewIRJET Journal
 
A Review Of The Power Distribution System In The Telecommunications Sector
A Review Of The Power Distribution System In The Telecommunications SectorA Review Of The Power Distribution System In The Telecommunications Sector
A Review Of The Power Distribution System In The Telecommunications SectorKarla Adamson
 
Novel Optimization to Reduce Power Drainage in Mobile Devices for Multicarrie...
Novel Optimization to Reduce Power Drainage in Mobile Devices for Multicarrie...Novel Optimization to Reduce Power Drainage in Mobile Devices for Multicarrie...
Novel Optimization to Reduce Power Drainage in Mobile Devices for Multicarrie...IJECEIAES
 
Novel Optimization to Reduce Power Drainage in Mobile Devices for Multicarrie...
Novel Optimization to Reduce Power Drainage in Mobile Devices for Multicarrie...Novel Optimization to Reduce Power Drainage in Mobile Devices for Multicarrie...
Novel Optimization to Reduce Power Drainage in Mobile Devices for Multicarrie...IJECEIAES
 
ADVANCED OPTIMIZATION CIRCUIT FOR WIRELESS POWER TRANSFER
ADVANCED OPTIMIZATION CIRCUIT FOR WIRELESS POWER TRANSFERADVANCED OPTIMIZATION CIRCUIT FOR WIRELESS POWER TRANSFER
ADVANCED OPTIMIZATION CIRCUIT FOR WIRELESS POWER TRANSFERJournal For Research
 
Throughput analysis of non-orthogonal multiple access and orthogonal multipl...
Throughput analysis of non-orthogonal multiple access and  orthogonal multipl...Throughput analysis of non-orthogonal multiple access and  orthogonal multipl...
Throughput analysis of non-orthogonal multiple access and orthogonal multipl...IJECEIAES
 
Design and simulation analysis of smart grid in power management to monitor a...
Design and simulation analysis of smart grid in power management to monitor a...Design and simulation analysis of smart grid in power management to monitor a...
Design and simulation analysis of smart grid in power management to monitor a...saddam hussain
 
Serial & Circular Peer Harvesting by Wireless Powered Communication Network
Serial & Circular Peer Harvesting by Wireless Powered Communication NetworkSerial & Circular Peer Harvesting by Wireless Powered Communication Network
Serial & Circular Peer Harvesting by Wireless Powered Communication NetworkIRJET Journal
 
Outage performance of downlink NOMA-aided small cell network with wireless po...
Outage performance of downlink NOMA-aided small cell network with wireless po...Outage performance of downlink NOMA-aided small cell network with wireless po...
Outage performance of downlink NOMA-aided small cell network with wireless po...journalBEEI
 
Application Aware Topology Generation for Surface Wave Networks-on-Chip
Application Aware Topology Generation for Surface Wave Networks-on-ChipApplication Aware Topology Generation for Surface Wave Networks-on-Chip
Application Aware Topology Generation for Surface Wave Networks-on-Chipzhao fu
 
Energy Splitting for SWIPT in QoS-constraint MTC Network: A Non-Cooperative G...
Energy Splitting for SWIPT in QoS-constraint MTC Network: A Non-Cooperative G...Energy Splitting for SWIPT in QoS-constraint MTC Network: A Non-Cooperative G...
Energy Splitting for SWIPT in QoS-constraint MTC Network: A Non-Cooperative G...IJCNCJournal
 
Kezunovic project t 37-pserc_final_report_2010
Kezunovic project t 37-pserc_final_report_2010Kezunovic project t 37-pserc_final_report_2010
Kezunovic project t 37-pserc_final_report_2010backam78
 
Device to Device Communication in Cellular Networks
Device to Device Communication in Cellular NetworksDevice to Device Communication in Cellular Networks
Device to Device Communication in Cellular Networksaroosa khan
 
A REVIEW OF ASYNCHRONOUS AD HOC NETWORK WITH WIRELESS ENERGY HARVESTING AND C...
A REVIEW OF ASYNCHRONOUS AD HOC NETWORK WITH WIRELESS ENERGY HARVESTING AND C...A REVIEW OF ASYNCHRONOUS AD HOC NETWORK WITH WIRELESS ENERGY HARVESTING AND C...
A REVIEW OF ASYNCHRONOUS AD HOC NETWORK WITH WIRELESS ENERGY HARVESTING AND C...IJSRED
 
Impact of Electric Vehicle Integration on Grid
Impact of Electric Vehicle Integration on GridImpact of Electric Vehicle Integration on Grid
Impact of Electric Vehicle Integration on Gridvivatechijri
 
Wireless Powered Communications: Performance Analysis and Optimization
Wireless Powered Communications: Performance Analysis and OptimizationWireless Powered Communications: Performance Analysis and Optimization
Wireless Powered Communications: Performance Analysis and Optimizationdtvt2006
 

Similar to Poster Version 4 (20)

2013 03-20 zhang
2013 03-20 zhang2013 03-20 zhang
2013 03-20 zhang
 
IRJET- Power Line Carrier Communication (PLCC) Systems: A Review
IRJET- Power Line Carrier Communication (PLCC) Systems: A ReviewIRJET- Power Line Carrier Communication (PLCC) Systems: A Review
IRJET- Power Line Carrier Communication (PLCC) Systems: A Review
 
A Review Of The Power Distribution System In The Telecommunications Sector
A Review Of The Power Distribution System In The Telecommunications SectorA Review Of The Power Distribution System In The Telecommunications Sector
A Review Of The Power Distribution System In The Telecommunications Sector
 
Novel Optimization to Reduce Power Drainage in Mobile Devices for Multicarrie...
Novel Optimization to Reduce Power Drainage in Mobile Devices for Multicarrie...Novel Optimization to Reduce Power Drainage in Mobile Devices for Multicarrie...
Novel Optimization to Reduce Power Drainage in Mobile Devices for Multicarrie...
 
Novel Optimization to Reduce Power Drainage in Mobile Devices for Multicarrie...
Novel Optimization to Reduce Power Drainage in Mobile Devices for Multicarrie...Novel Optimization to Reduce Power Drainage in Mobile Devices for Multicarrie...
Novel Optimization to Reduce Power Drainage in Mobile Devices for Multicarrie...
 
ADVANCED OPTIMIZATION CIRCUIT FOR WIRELESS POWER TRANSFER
ADVANCED OPTIMIZATION CIRCUIT FOR WIRELESS POWER TRANSFERADVANCED OPTIMIZATION CIRCUIT FOR WIRELESS POWER TRANSFER
ADVANCED OPTIMIZATION CIRCUIT FOR WIRELESS POWER TRANSFER
 
Throughput analysis of non-orthogonal multiple access and orthogonal multipl...
Throughput analysis of non-orthogonal multiple access and  orthogonal multipl...Throughput analysis of non-orthogonal multiple access and  orthogonal multipl...
Throughput analysis of non-orthogonal multiple access and orthogonal multipl...
 
Design and simulation analysis of smart grid in power management to monitor a...
Design and simulation analysis of smart grid in power management to monitor a...Design and simulation analysis of smart grid in power management to monitor a...
Design and simulation analysis of smart grid in power management to monitor a...
 
Serial & Circular Peer Harvesting by Wireless Powered Communication Network
Serial & Circular Peer Harvesting by Wireless Powered Communication NetworkSerial & Circular Peer Harvesting by Wireless Powered Communication Network
Serial & Circular Peer Harvesting by Wireless Powered Communication Network
 
Outage performance of downlink NOMA-aided small cell network with wireless po...
Outage performance of downlink NOMA-aided small cell network with wireless po...Outage performance of downlink NOMA-aided small cell network with wireless po...
Outage performance of downlink NOMA-aided small cell network with wireless po...
 
Application Aware Topology Generation for Surface Wave Networks-on-Chip
Application Aware Topology Generation for Surface Wave Networks-on-ChipApplication Aware Topology Generation for Surface Wave Networks-on-Chip
Application Aware Topology Generation for Surface Wave Networks-on-Chip
 
Energy Splitting for SWIPT in QoS-constraint MTC Network: A Non-Cooperative G...
Energy Splitting for SWIPT in QoS-constraint MTC Network: A Non-Cooperative G...Energy Splitting for SWIPT in QoS-constraint MTC Network: A Non-Cooperative G...
Energy Splitting for SWIPT in QoS-constraint MTC Network: A Non-Cooperative G...
 
Abstract
AbstractAbstract
Abstract
 
Kezunovic project t 37-pserc_final_report_2010
Kezunovic project t 37-pserc_final_report_2010Kezunovic project t 37-pserc_final_report_2010
Kezunovic project t 37-pserc_final_report_2010
 
Device to Device Communication in Cellular Networks
Device to Device Communication in Cellular NetworksDevice to Device Communication in Cellular Networks
Device to Device Communication in Cellular Networks
 
A REVIEW OF ASYNCHRONOUS AD HOC NETWORK WITH WIRELESS ENERGY HARVESTING AND C...
A REVIEW OF ASYNCHRONOUS AD HOC NETWORK WITH WIRELESS ENERGY HARVESTING AND C...A REVIEW OF ASYNCHRONOUS AD HOC NETWORK WITH WIRELESS ENERGY HARVESTING AND C...
A REVIEW OF ASYNCHRONOUS AD HOC NETWORK WITH WIRELESS ENERGY HARVESTING AND C...
 
WPT.pptx
WPT.pptxWPT.pptx
WPT.pptx
 
Impact of Electric Vehicle Integration on Grid
Impact of Electric Vehicle Integration on GridImpact of Electric Vehicle Integration on Grid
Impact of Electric Vehicle Integration on Grid
 
WCNC
WCNCWCNC
WCNC
 
Wireless Powered Communications: Performance Analysis and Optimization
Wireless Powered Communications: Performance Analysis and OptimizationWireless Powered Communications: Performance Analysis and Optimization
Wireless Powered Communications: Performance Analysis and Optimization
 

Poster Version 4

  • 1. Analysis of a Wireless Powered Cooperative Network using a Hybrid Relay Introduction Contact: u5228414@anu.edu.au Research School of Engineering ANU College of Engineering & Computer Science Kazi Ahnaf Ahmed Supervisor: Dr Xiangyun (Sean) Zhou 2nd Conference on Engineering Students Individual Projects CESIP October 2015 Eliminating the need for recharging and replacing batteries in wireless devices has been a long-standing ICT challenge. Wireless Power Transfer (WPT) promises to be an attractive solution to cut the last wires connecting mobiles devices to the grid. Recent advancements in Microwave Power Transmission (MPT) have made WPT a feasible technology for long range applications. This research topic analyses a Wireless Powered Communication (WPCN) powered by MPT technology to the answer the question: ‘How does the performance of a WPCN compare to a conventional cellular network?’ Previous Work Methodology  The E-C protocol is superior to D-C protocol under all tested scenarios  Performance of the WPCN drops off significantly after 5-7m  The WPCN should be implemented in high density this may require an overhaul of the existing architecture  Massive MIMO and Small Cell Networks are key enabling technologies for WPCNs. Results The system performance is measured using the average throughput. The throughput is the rate of successful message delivery over a communication network. The source is moved relative to the AP and hybrid relay and the throughput is measured to determine the range of the WPCN. The system is optimized for maximum throughput by varying the energy transfer and power transmission time fractions. The optimized system is then compared with a conventional cellular network and the results are used to propose a network architecture. Conclusion  (Chen et al. 2014) introduced a simple wireless powered cooperative network model. This is used as the starting point to answer the research question.  (Huang & Lau 2014) proposes a network architecture of power beacons overlaid on the existing cellular network.  The research paper by (Huang & Zhou 2015) discusses key breakthroughs for WPT including massive MIMO and Small Cell Networks. The optimized throughput for the for the Energy Cooperation Protocol is shown by the surface plot in Figure 4. The corresponding energy transfer time is illustrated using Figure 5. Figure 1: System Model (Chen et al. 2014) Figure 3: Dual-Cooperation ProtocolFigure 2: Energy-Cooperation Protocol Figure 4: Maximum Throughput Figure 5: Optimized time fraction Figure 6: Comparison of system performance for conventional cellular network and WPCN Reference The model by (Chen at al. 2014) shown in Figure 1 is analysed using the two communication protocols illustrated in Figure 2 and 3. The Access Point (AP) and Hybrid Relay (R) are used to transfer energy to the Source (S) in the first time instance. In the Energy Cooperation (E-C) protocol the source transmits information directly to the AP using the harvested energy. For the Dual Cooperation (D-C) protocol the source transmits the information signal through the hybrid relay in addition to the direct path. Figure 6 below compares the un-optimized and optimized system protocols with two conventional cellular network protocols.  Chen, H. et al., 2014. Wireless-Powered Cooperative Communications via a Hybrid Relay. , p.5. Available at: http://arxiv.org/abs/1408.4841.  Huang, K. & Lau, V.K.N., 2014. Realizing wireless power transfer in cellular networks. Communications (ICC), 2014 IEEE International Conference on, 13(2), pp.5544–5549.  Huang, K. & Zhou, X., 2015. Cutting the last wires for mobile communications by microwave power transfer. IEEE Communications Magazine, 53(6), pp.86–93. Available at: http://ieeexplore.ieee.org/lpdocs/epic03/wrapper.htm?arnumber=7120022