Successfully reported this slideshow.
We use your LinkedIn profile and activity data to personalize ads and to show you more relevant ads. You can change your ad preferences anytime.
1
TRANSFORMING MĀORI EXPERIENCES OF HISTORICAL
INTERGENERATIONAL TRAUMA
"Māku anō e hangā tōku nei whare,
ko te tāhuhu he ...
2
Declaration
To the best of my knowledge and belief this thesis contains no material
previously published by any other pe...
3
Copyright
Copyright is owned by the author of this thesis. Permission is given for this thesis to be read
and referenced...
4
ABSTRACT
This thesis examines links between Māori deficit statistics, Māori experiences of
historical intergenerational ...
5
Acknowledgements
Ki te taha o tōku Matua, Ko Tainui te Waka
Ko Taupiri me Kario ōku maunga
Ko Whaingaroa te moana
Ko Wai...
6
Piripi Pikari, Gary Watene. I want to acknowledge the brothers; Johnny Leosavii, Masami,
Glen Paekau, Ritchie Rich, Simo...
7
Contents
Acknowledgements .................................................................................................
8
3.5 Indigenous Research Methodologies ..................................................................... 54
Participa...
9
5.8 Pōuritanga ............................................................................................................
10
Māku Anō E Hangā Tōku Nei Whare- I Will Rebuild My Own House ........................... 153
Introduction ................
11
List of Figures
Figure 1.1 Waikato Tainui landmark
boundary
15
Figure 2.1 Definition of Aboriginality [table 1] 33
Figu...
12
Figure 6.4 Murder Trial [Waikato Times] 130
6.5 Redemption of David Karena 140
Figure 6.6 The War on Violence
[NZ Women...
13
14
Chapter One
Te Tongi a Tāwhiao – The Prophecy of King Tāwhiao
Introduction
The Te Tongi a Tawhiao 1
can be considered a...
15
original form of the North Island. The Waikato people all descend from the Tainui
waka, or canoe that came to New Zeala...
16
1.1 Choosing a Māori King
In the 1850s various hapū throughout the country including Te Wai Pounamu (South
Island) deli...
17
1.2 Te Tongi a Tawhiao
Māhuta (2007) contended that as a way of responding to their situation “Tāwhiao left
a legacy of...
18
A significant feature of the Te Tongi a Tawhiao prophesy concerns the timber
Tāwhiao refers to and chose to rebuild his...
19
My great grandfathers’ name was Te Nahu Te Kuri, Waretini- Wetene. He was born
in 1840. As a young man growing up in th...
20
1.4 Intergenerational Impacts on Whānau
My grandfather Te Kapa o Te Wharua Waretini-Wetene was born in the 1920s and
br...
21
communication, Jan 10 2011) contended that "Princess Te Puea named him Te
Kapa o te Wharua because when there was work ...
22
Summary of Thesis
This first chapter is entitled Te Tongi a Tāwhiao – The Prophecy of Tāwhiao, gives a
historical accou...
23
cover the era of pre-colonisation to 1840. In this section Ngāpuhi connections and
whakapapa will become apparent. This...
24
Conclusion
In this chapter I have explained the prophecy of Tāwhiao which provides a
theoretical framework for this the...
25
26
Chapter Two
A Literary Review of Historical Intergenerational Trauma
Overview
This chapter critically reviews the liter...
27
The second aspect employed here is based on the work of Churchill (1993), Jackson
(2012), and Armitage (1995) who discu...
28
legacy of trauma is helpful for participants, and that the importance of sharing and
talking about the trauma allows su...
29
environment. Overall, despite the fact that Rod Lea and Geoffrey Chamber’s
research was hugely discredited, for not mee...
30
Recognition of the legal and moral rights by which a nation occupies its
land base is a fundamental issue of its existe...
31
efforts of legal scholars such as Franciscus de Victoria and Matias de Pas, that the
Spanish articulation of the Discov...
32
colonial societies around the world today. The enormity of this law and the
theft of the rights and assets of Indigenou...
33
hierarchy according to colour. "The white race was at the top, and the
darkest race was at the bottom. The Australian A...
34
The previous table highlights a timeline defining aboriginality stemming from the
1860's through to 1975. It clearly em...
35
Figure 2.2 Governmental Aboriginal Land Policy Armitage, 1995, pp. 200-201)
The table above highlights a timeline of go...
36
may pass on this trauma to subsequent generations. This seems to support Black
Cloud (1990) who explained their traditi...
37
Figure 2.3 Historical Trauma Influences on Health & Health care (Estrada, 2009, p.336).
This list highlights aspects th...
38
Further statistics from Brave Heart, Chase, Elkins, & Altschul (2011) highlights that
death from alcohol related causes...
39
What these statistics indicate, is that on a variety of levels, Māori alcohol and drug
usage per capita is far higher t...
40
the trauma until it can be traced back in history to its original source and that
essence and energy is freed to be abl...
41
adjudged as mercenary (Graham, 1930 as cited in Armitage, 1995, p.
165).
Figure 2.4 Children in care and supervision (A...
42
only thing I know is 'stomach.' Yes! I know that! Oh, yes, Sister Anne,
Sister Dorothy, Sister Jessie and Mr Laughton a...
43
over turned the decision due to Papal Bull Decree 1493 Terra Nullus. Under that
Papal Bull decree the pope of the time ...
44
Conclusion
In this chapter we reviewed the relevant literature that introduced and defined
historical intergenerational...
45
46
Chapter Three
Māhere Rautaki Rangāhau- Research Methodologies and Methods
Introduction
This chapter examines the method...
47
generational trauma, intergenerational post-traumatic stress and
multigenerational trauma." (p. 182).
What Walters et a...
48
wellbeing. It also develops strategies that put in parameters to stop residue of
trauma spilling over into the next gen...
49
Governments quest for power and control highlighting some of the mechanisms
involved that include legislative violation...
50
Theoretical Perspectives
This part of the thesis focuses on three research methodologies. The first
methodology employe...
Transforming Māori Experiences of Historical Intergenerational Trauma  Phd thesis 2014
Transforming Māori Experiences of Historical Intergenerational Trauma  Phd thesis 2014
Transforming Māori Experiences of Historical Intergenerational Trauma  Phd thesis 2014
Transforming Māori Experiences of Historical Intergenerational Trauma  Phd thesis 2014
Transforming Māori Experiences of Historical Intergenerational Trauma  Phd thesis 2014
Transforming Māori Experiences of Historical Intergenerational Trauma  Phd thesis 2014
Transforming Māori Experiences of Historical Intergenerational Trauma  Phd thesis 2014
Transforming Māori Experiences of Historical Intergenerational Trauma  Phd thesis 2014
Transforming Māori Experiences of Historical Intergenerational Trauma  Phd thesis 2014
Transforming Māori Experiences of Historical Intergenerational Trauma  Phd thesis 2014
Transforming Māori Experiences of Historical Intergenerational Trauma  Phd thesis 2014
Transforming Māori Experiences of Historical Intergenerational Trauma  Phd thesis 2014
Transforming Māori Experiences of Historical Intergenerational Trauma  Phd thesis 2014
Transforming Māori Experiences of Historical Intergenerational Trauma  Phd thesis 2014
Transforming Māori Experiences of Historical Intergenerational Trauma  Phd thesis 2014
Transforming Māori Experiences of Historical Intergenerational Trauma  Phd thesis 2014
Transforming Māori Experiences of Historical Intergenerational Trauma  Phd thesis 2014
Transforming Māori Experiences of Historical Intergenerational Trauma  Phd thesis 2014
Transforming Māori Experiences of Historical Intergenerational Trauma  Phd thesis 2014
Transforming Māori Experiences of Historical Intergenerational Trauma  Phd thesis 2014
Transforming Māori Experiences of Historical Intergenerational Trauma  Phd thesis 2014
Transforming Māori Experiences of Historical Intergenerational Trauma  Phd thesis 2014
Transforming Māori Experiences of Historical Intergenerational Trauma  Phd thesis 2014
Transforming Māori Experiences of Historical Intergenerational Trauma  Phd thesis 2014
Transforming Māori Experiences of Historical Intergenerational Trauma  Phd thesis 2014
Transforming Māori Experiences of Historical Intergenerational Trauma  Phd thesis 2014
Transforming Māori Experiences of Historical Intergenerational Trauma  Phd thesis 2014
Transforming Māori Experiences of Historical Intergenerational Trauma  Phd thesis 2014
Transforming Māori Experiences of Historical Intergenerational Trauma  Phd thesis 2014
Transforming Māori Experiences of Historical Intergenerational Trauma  Phd thesis 2014
Transforming Māori Experiences of Historical Intergenerational Trauma  Phd thesis 2014
Transforming Māori Experiences of Historical Intergenerational Trauma  Phd thesis 2014
Transforming Māori Experiences of Historical Intergenerational Trauma  Phd thesis 2014
Transforming Māori Experiences of Historical Intergenerational Trauma  Phd thesis 2014
Transforming Māori Experiences of Historical Intergenerational Trauma  Phd thesis 2014
Transforming Māori Experiences of Historical Intergenerational Trauma  Phd thesis 2014
Transforming Māori Experiences of Historical Intergenerational Trauma  Phd thesis 2014
Transforming Māori Experiences of Historical Intergenerational Trauma  Phd thesis 2014
Transforming Māori Experiences of Historical Intergenerational Trauma  Phd thesis 2014
Transforming Māori Experiences of Historical Intergenerational Trauma  Phd thesis 2014
Transforming Māori Experiences of Historical Intergenerational Trauma  Phd thesis 2014
Transforming Māori Experiences of Historical Intergenerational Trauma  Phd thesis 2014
Transforming Māori Experiences of Historical Intergenerational Trauma  Phd thesis 2014
Transforming Māori Experiences of Historical Intergenerational Trauma  Phd thesis 2014
Transforming Māori Experiences of Historical Intergenerational Trauma  Phd thesis 2014
Transforming Māori Experiences of Historical Intergenerational Trauma  Phd thesis 2014
Transforming Māori Experiences of Historical Intergenerational Trauma  Phd thesis 2014
Transforming Māori Experiences of Historical Intergenerational Trauma  Phd thesis 2014
Transforming Māori Experiences of Historical Intergenerational Trauma  Phd thesis 2014
Transforming Māori Experiences of Historical Intergenerational Trauma  Phd thesis 2014
Transforming Māori Experiences of Historical Intergenerational Trauma  Phd thesis 2014
Transforming Māori Experiences of Historical Intergenerational Trauma  Phd thesis 2014
Transforming Māori Experiences of Historical Intergenerational Trauma  Phd thesis 2014
Transforming Māori Experiences of Historical Intergenerational Trauma  Phd thesis 2014
Transforming Māori Experiences of Historical Intergenerational Trauma  Phd thesis 2014
Transforming Māori Experiences of Historical Intergenerational Trauma  Phd thesis 2014
Transforming Māori Experiences of Historical Intergenerational Trauma  Phd thesis 2014
Transforming Māori Experiences of Historical Intergenerational Trauma  Phd thesis 2014
Transforming Māori Experiences of Historical Intergenerational Trauma  Phd thesis 2014
Transforming Māori Experiences of Historical Intergenerational Trauma  Phd thesis 2014
Transforming Māori Experiences of Historical Intergenerational Trauma  Phd thesis 2014
Transforming Māori Experiences of Historical Intergenerational Trauma  Phd thesis 2014
Transforming Māori Experiences of Historical Intergenerational Trauma  Phd thesis 2014
Transforming Māori Experiences of Historical Intergenerational Trauma  Phd thesis 2014
Transforming Māori Experiences of Historical Intergenerational Trauma  Phd thesis 2014
Transforming Māori Experiences of Historical Intergenerational Trauma  Phd thesis 2014
Transforming Māori Experiences of Historical Intergenerational Trauma  Phd thesis 2014
Transforming Māori Experiences of Historical Intergenerational Trauma  Phd thesis 2014
Transforming Māori Experiences of Historical Intergenerational Trauma  Phd thesis 2014
Transforming Māori Experiences of Historical Intergenerational Trauma  Phd thesis 2014
Transforming Māori Experiences of Historical Intergenerational Trauma  Phd thesis 2014
Transforming Māori Experiences of Historical Intergenerational Trauma  Phd thesis 2014
Transforming Māori Experiences of Historical Intergenerational Trauma  Phd thesis 2014
Transforming Māori Experiences of Historical Intergenerational Trauma  Phd thesis 2014
Transforming Māori Experiences of Historical Intergenerational Trauma  Phd thesis 2014
Transforming Māori Experiences of Historical Intergenerational Trauma  Phd thesis 2014
Transforming Māori Experiences of Historical Intergenerational Trauma  Phd thesis 2014
Transforming Māori Experiences of Historical Intergenerational Trauma  Phd thesis 2014
Transforming Māori Experiences of Historical Intergenerational Trauma  Phd thesis 2014
Transforming Māori Experiences of Historical Intergenerational Trauma  Phd thesis 2014
Transforming Māori Experiences of Historical Intergenerational Trauma  Phd thesis 2014
Transforming Māori Experiences of Historical Intergenerational Trauma  Phd thesis 2014
Transforming Māori Experiences of Historical Intergenerational Trauma  Phd thesis 2014
Transforming Māori Experiences of Historical Intergenerational Trauma  Phd thesis 2014
Transforming Māori Experiences of Historical Intergenerational Trauma  Phd thesis 2014
Transforming Māori Experiences of Historical Intergenerational Trauma  Phd thesis 2014
Transforming Māori Experiences of Historical Intergenerational Trauma  Phd thesis 2014
Transforming Māori Experiences of Historical Intergenerational Trauma  Phd thesis 2014
Transforming Māori Experiences of Historical Intergenerational Trauma  Phd thesis 2014
Transforming Māori Experiences of Historical Intergenerational Trauma  Phd thesis 2014
Transforming Māori Experiences of Historical Intergenerational Trauma  Phd thesis 2014
Transforming Māori Experiences of Historical Intergenerational Trauma  Phd thesis 2014
Transforming Māori Experiences of Historical Intergenerational Trauma  Phd thesis 2014
Transforming Māori Experiences of Historical Intergenerational Trauma  Phd thesis 2014
Transforming Māori Experiences of Historical Intergenerational Trauma  Phd thesis 2014
Transforming Māori Experiences of Historical Intergenerational Trauma  Phd thesis 2014
Transforming Māori Experiences of Historical Intergenerational Trauma  Phd thesis 2014
Transforming Māori Experiences of Historical Intergenerational Trauma  Phd thesis 2014
Transforming Māori Experiences of Historical Intergenerational Trauma  Phd thesis 2014
Transforming Māori Experiences of Historical Intergenerational Trauma  Phd thesis 2014
Transforming Māori Experiences of Historical Intergenerational Trauma  Phd thesis 2014
Transforming Māori Experiences of Historical Intergenerational Trauma  Phd thesis 2014
Transforming Māori Experiences of Historical Intergenerational Trauma  Phd thesis 2014
Transforming Māori Experiences of Historical Intergenerational Trauma  Phd thesis 2014
Transforming Māori Experiences of Historical Intergenerational Trauma  Phd thesis 2014
Transforming Māori Experiences of Historical Intergenerational Trauma  Phd thesis 2014
Transforming Māori Experiences of Historical Intergenerational Trauma  Phd thesis 2014
Transforming Māori Experiences of Historical Intergenerational Trauma  Phd thesis 2014
Transforming Māori Experiences of Historical Intergenerational Trauma  Phd thesis 2014
Transforming Māori Experiences of Historical Intergenerational Trauma  Phd thesis 2014
Transforming Māori Experiences of Historical Intergenerational Trauma  Phd thesis 2014
Transforming Māori Experiences of Historical Intergenerational Trauma  Phd thesis 2014
Transforming Māori Experiences of Historical Intergenerational Trauma  Phd thesis 2014
Transforming Māori Experiences of Historical Intergenerational Trauma  Phd thesis 2014
Transforming Māori Experiences of Historical Intergenerational Trauma  Phd thesis 2014
Transforming Māori Experiences of Historical Intergenerational Trauma  Phd thesis 2014
Transforming Māori Experiences of Historical Intergenerational Trauma  Phd thesis 2014
Transforming Māori Experiences of Historical Intergenerational Trauma  Phd thesis 2014
Transforming Māori Experiences of Historical Intergenerational Trauma  Phd thesis 2014
Transforming Māori Experiences of Historical Intergenerational Trauma  Phd thesis 2014
Transforming Māori Experiences of Historical Intergenerational Trauma  Phd thesis 2014
Transforming Māori Experiences of Historical Intergenerational Trauma  Phd thesis 2014
Transforming Māori Experiences of Historical Intergenerational Trauma  Phd thesis 2014
Transforming Māori Experiences of Historical Intergenerational Trauma  Phd thesis 2014
Transforming Māori Experiences of Historical Intergenerational Trauma  Phd thesis 2014
Transforming Māori Experiences of Historical Intergenerational Trauma  Phd thesis 2014
Transforming Māori Experiences of Historical Intergenerational Trauma  Phd thesis 2014
Transforming Māori Experiences of Historical Intergenerational Trauma  Phd thesis 2014
Transforming Māori Experiences of Historical Intergenerational Trauma  Phd thesis 2014
Transforming Māori Experiences of Historical Intergenerational Trauma  Phd thesis 2014
Transforming Māori Experiences of Historical Intergenerational Trauma  Phd thesis 2014
Transforming Māori Experiences of Historical Intergenerational Trauma  Phd thesis 2014
Transforming Māori Experiences of Historical Intergenerational Trauma  Phd thesis 2014
Transforming Māori Experiences of Historical Intergenerational Trauma  Phd thesis 2014
Transforming Māori Experiences of Historical Intergenerational Trauma  Phd thesis 2014
Transforming Māori Experiences of Historical Intergenerational Trauma  Phd thesis 2014
Transforming Māori Experiences of Historical Intergenerational Trauma  Phd thesis 2014
Transforming Māori Experiences of Historical Intergenerational Trauma  Phd thesis 2014
Transforming Māori Experiences of Historical Intergenerational Trauma  Phd thesis 2014
Transforming Māori Experiences of Historical Intergenerational Trauma  Phd thesis 2014
Transforming Māori Experiences of Historical Intergenerational Trauma  Phd thesis 2014
Transforming Māori Experiences of Historical Intergenerational Trauma  Phd thesis 2014
Transforming Māori Experiences of Historical Intergenerational Trauma  Phd thesis 2014
Transforming Māori Experiences of Historical Intergenerational Trauma  Phd thesis 2014
Transforming Māori Experiences of Historical Intergenerational Trauma  Phd thesis 2014
Transforming Māori Experiences of Historical Intergenerational Trauma  Phd thesis 2014
Transforming Māori Experiences of Historical Intergenerational Trauma  Phd thesis 2014
Transforming Māori Experiences of Historical Intergenerational Trauma  Phd thesis 2014
Transforming Māori Experiences of Historical Intergenerational Trauma  Phd thesis 2014
Transforming Māori Experiences of Historical Intergenerational Trauma  Phd thesis 2014
Transforming Māori Experiences of Historical Intergenerational Trauma  Phd thesis 2014
Transforming Māori Experiences of Historical Intergenerational Trauma  Phd thesis 2014
Transforming Māori Experiences of Historical Intergenerational Trauma  Phd thesis 2014
Transforming Māori Experiences of Historical Intergenerational Trauma  Phd thesis 2014
Upcoming SlideShare
Loading in …5
×

Transforming Māori Experiences of Historical Intergenerational Trauma Phd thesis 2014

8,768 views

Published on

ABSTRACT

This PhD. thesis examines links between Māori deficit statistics, Māori experiences of historical intergenerational trauma or HIT, and colonisation. The thesis draws upon Western critical theory combined with Indigenous methodologies that employ Māori epistemologies or ways of knowing to make sense of historical discourses that have traditionally impeded Māori wellbeing and development. Indigenous methodologies such as Pūrākau theory are employed in this thesis to peel back layers of narratives that are sometimes intergenerational, to expose contributing factors to Māori deficit statistics. These theories interpret underlying themes and key factors in HIT. In essence the study examines Māori experiences; Māori concepts and oral traditions relevant to HIT. Essentially four research questions are posed. "What are Māori experiences of historical intergenerational trauma?" "What were the political, socio- economic implications for Māori both pre and post signing of Te Tiriti o Waitangi?" "What significance does locating self in this research have in terms of contextualising Māori experiences of historical intergenerational trauma?" And finally "What are Māori strategies that respond to this phenomenon?"
These research questions frame the thesis from a position that distinguishes Māori experiences of this phenomenon, from the distinctive lived experiences of other Indigenous cultures across the globe. The research questions also investigate the political, socio- economic environment both pre and post Te Tiriti o Waitangi. This gives a macro view that draws attention to Māori success in international trade and economic development pre Treaty [Te Tiriti o Waitangi]. The thesis then examines how Māori became subjugated to intergenerational positions of impoverishment, and displacement through war, and legislative policies of the New Zealand Settler Government who coveted Māori land, assets, raw materials and resources post Te Tiriti o Waitangi. Locating self in research offers a micro view contextualising how historical events may impact at a personal level. It also draws attention to how those impacts have the potential for manifesting deficit outcomes. The final frame is solution focused, and draws attention to strategies that respond to Māori experiences of historical intergenerational trauma.

Published in: Education, News & Politics
  • Congratulatioins e Rawiri. Hope you dont mind me connecting you to my facebook and linked.
       Reply 
    Are you sure you want to  Yes  No
    Your message goes here
  • Jah. Kia ora brother, a great read, truely inspirational. 👏🙏Bless
       Reply 
    Are you sure you want to  Yes  No
    Your message goes here

Transforming Māori Experiences of Historical Intergenerational Trauma Phd thesis 2014

  1. 1. 1 TRANSFORMING MĀORI EXPERIENCES OF HISTORICAL INTERGENERATIONAL TRAUMA "Māku anō e hangā tōku nei whare, ko te tāhuhu he Hīnau, ko ngā poupou he Mahoe, he Patatē" A thesis submitted in fulfilment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy (Ph.D) in Indigenous Studies. Te Whare Wānanga o Awanuiārangi. April 2014 by David (Rāwiri) Junior Waretini- Karena
  2. 2. 2 Declaration To the best of my knowledge and belief this thesis contains no material previously published by any other person except where due acknowledgment has been made. This thesis contains no material which has been accepted for the award of any other degree or diploma in any university. This thesis will be saved and stored at Te Whare Wānanga o Awanuiārangi and made available for future students and researchers to read and reference. Signature: David (Rawiri) Waretini-Karena Date: 02/04/2014
  3. 3. 3 Copyright Copyright is owned by the author of this thesis. Permission is given for this thesis to be read and referenced by you for the purposes of research and private study provided you comply with the provisions of the Copyright Act 1994 (New Zealand). This thesis may not be reproduced without the permission of the author. This is asserted by David (Rawiri) Waretini Karena in Whakatane, New Zealand, February 2014.
  4. 4. 4 ABSTRACT This thesis examines links between Māori deficit statistics, Māori experiences of historical intergenerational trauma or HIT, and colonisation. The thesis draws upon Western critical theory combined with Indigenous methodologies that employ Māori epistemologies or ways of knowing to make sense of historical discourses that have traditionally impeded Māori wellbeing and development. Indigenous methodologies such as Pūrākau theory are employed in this thesis to peel back layers of narratives that are sometimes intergenerational, to expose contributing factors to Māori deficit statistics. These theories interpret underlying themes and key factors in HIT. In essence the study examines Māori experiences; Māori concepts and oral traditions relevant to HIT. Essentially four research questions are posed. "What are Māori experiences of historical intergenerational trauma?" "What were the political, socio- economic implications for Māori both pre and post signing of Te Tiriti o Waitangi?" "What significance does locating self in this research have in terms of contextualising Māori experiences of historical intergenerational trauma?" And finally "What are Māori strategies that respond to this phenomenon?" These research questions frame the thesis from a position that distinguishes Māori experiences of this phenomenon, from the distinctive lived experiences of other Indigenous cultures across the globe. The research questions also investigate the political, socio- economic environment both pre and post Te Tiriti o Waitangi. This gives a macro view that draws attention to Māori success in international trade and economic development pre Treaty [Te Tiriti o Waitangi]. The thesis then examines how Māori became subjugated to intergenerational positions of impoverishment, and displacement through war, and legislative policies of the New Zealand Settler Government who coveted Māori land, assets, raw materials and resources post Te Tiriti o Waitangi. Locating self in research offers a micro view contextualising how historical events may impact at a personal level. It also draws attention to how those impacts have the potential for manifesting deficit outcomes. The final frame is solution focused, and draws attention to strategies that respond to Māori experiences of historical intergenerational trauma.
  5. 5. 5 Acknowledgements Ki te taha o tōku Matua, Ko Tainui te Waka Ko Taupiri me Kario ōku maunga Ko Whaingaroa te moana Ko Waikato te awa Ko Ngāti Māhanga, Ngāti Māhuta ōku iwi Ko Tainui Āwhiro te hapū Ko Tūrangawaewae me Poehakena ōku marae Ko Tūheitia te tangata Ki te taha o tōku whaea ko Ngātokimatawhaorua, ko Mamaru, ko Tinana ōku waka Ko Pūtahi, ko Maungataniwha, ko Pangaru ki Popta ōku maunga Ko Waioro te Awa, me Rangāunu raua ko Hokianga oku moana Ko Ngāti Hine, Ngāti Kāhu, Te Rarawa ōku iwi Ko Ngāti Whakaeke, ko Patukoraha, ko Ngāti Manawa ōku hapū Ko Te Kotahitanga, ko Karaponia, ko Motiti ōku marae Ko Hohaia, Ko Rapehana Tohe, ko Paparoa ōku whānau Tihei Mauri Ora He hōnore he kōroria ki te Matua, te Whaea, te Tama, te Tamāhine, te Wairua tapu me ngā Anahera pono, Pai marire. I acknowledge my ancestors who I believe guided me on this path. I acknowledge that I stand on the back of giants who have walked before me challenging colonial oppression. I acknowledge two of my relations who have been inspirational in giving me a Tūrangawaewae or a foundation to stand and position myself in this work. The first is Eva Rickard on my father's side and Whina Cooper on my mother's side. I want to acknowledge and thank my mother and father Neta and Raymond Waretini-Karena, as well as my siblings Chris, Amelia, Laura, Denz, Stephen, Rayna and Corbin. I realise that had we not gone on the journey that we did, this Ph.D thesis may never have been written. I also want to acknowledge my mentor and whangāi mum Rebecca Fox Vercoe (Becky), Gordana, Māhinarangāi, Derek Fox, Atareta Pōnanga, Andrew Vercoe along with Graeme and Margret Vercoe for believing in me especially during the times I didn't believe in myself. I acknowledge some pretty special people, groups, families and organisations that made a difference in my life. Wayne Lehaarve, Murray Sampson, the Corbett Family Willy, Mere, George, Vanessa, Violet, Wiremu, Christina, Ngāhuia and Jock, Graham Waewae , Bop Mutu and family, Miranda Harcourt, AVP Waikato / Aotearoa, Elaine Dyer, Rere Stroud,
  6. 6. 6 Piripi Pikari, Gary Watene. I want to acknowledge the brothers; Johnny Leosavii, Masami, Glen Paekau, Ritchie Rich, Simon Webb, Stephen Harney, Duke-Derek Kaitapu, Sonny Paito, Dwight Fatu, John Hedges, the Barbarian. I want to recognise current and former colleagues, Taima Moeke-Pickering, Jacquelyn Elkington, Maria Rangā, Caroll Aupouri Mclean, Ariana Patiole nee Jameson, and Vyonna Berryman Conrad. I acknowledge families from the Latter Day Saints; The Grey family, Bill, Marilyn Grey, Aaron, Karyn, Penny, Mike and Steve, Khazia and Corom Grey/ Karena., the Higgins family and Mike Wilson and family. I also acknowledge organisations that have supported me; Raymond and Loraine Phillips from Hamilton Security Services, Te Toi Ā Kiwa School of Māori and Pacifika Studies, WINTEC, Media Arts WINTEC, The Centre for Health and Social Practice (CHASP) from the Waikato Institute of Technology, WINTEC, and Te Whare Wānanga o Awanuiārangi. I want to especially acknowledge and thank Waikato Tainui, Te Atawhai o Te Ao-He Kokongā Whare and the Ngārimu VC 28th Māori Battalion Doctoral Scholarship board for supporting and believing in me. Finally I want to acknowledge the CEO Distinguished Professor Dr Graham Smith, Dr Linda Tuhiwai Smith, Dr Cherryl Smith, Dr Leonie Pihama, Dr John Reid, Dr Takarirangi Smith, Dr Paul Reynolds, Dr Patricia Johnston, Dr Te Tuhi Robust, Dr Phillipa Pehi, Dr Richard Smith, Dr Virginia Warriner, Dr Margaret Wilke and Moana Jackson. I also acknowledge and thank my examiners, Dr Tina Ngāroimata Fraser, Dr Wiremu Doherty, and Dr Marilyn Brewin. Lastly I acknowledge my Ph.D supervisor Dr Rapata Wiri. To conclude I dedicate this thesis to the memory of Nelson (Madiba) Mandela who has been influential and inspirational in achieving the impossible in South Africa, and who by example led the way for Indigenous peoples to respond to colonial oppression, through the power of reconciliation and forgiveness. Mā te huruhuru ka rere te manu It is with feathers the bird flies
  7. 7. 7 Contents Acknowledgements ........................................................................................................... 5 Contents ........................................................................................................................ 7 List of Figures.................................................................................................................. 11 Chapter One ...................................................................................................................... 14 Te Tongi a Tāwhiao – The Prophecy of King Tāwhiao ................................................... 14 Introduction ..................................................................................................................... 14 Kingitanga Movement...................................................................................................... 14 1.1 Choosing a Māori King........................................................................................... 16 1.2 Te Tongi a Tawhiao ............................................................................................... 17 Whānau Connection to Kingitanga .................................................................................. 18 1.3 Whānau connection to Waikato Invasion and Orākau Battle .................................. 19 1.4 Intergenerational Impacts on Whānau.................................................................... 20 Summary of Thesis.......................................................................................................... 22 Chapter Two ...................................................................................................................... 26 A Literary Review of Historical Intergenerational Trauma ............................................. 26 Introduction ..................................................................................................................... 26 Historical Intergenerational Trauma (HIT)........................................................................ 27 2.1 Historical Catalyst for Historical Intergenerational Trauma ..................................... 29 2.2 Prejudicial Policies ................................................................................................. 32 Influences on Health and Wellbeing ................................................................................ 35 2.3 Alcoholism ............................................................................................................. 37 2.4 Māori Alcohol Statistics .......................................................................................... 38 2.5 Boarding Schools for Assimilation.......................................................................... 39 2.6 Māori People and Child Welfare Policy .................................................................. 40 2.7 Indicators for Māori Counselling............................................................................. 42 Chapter Three.................................................................................................................... 46 Māhere Rautaki Rangāhau- Research Methodologies and Methods............................. 46 Introduction ..................................................................................................................... 46 Literature Review Summary ............................................................................................ 46 Research Plan................................................................................................................. 48 3.1 Objectives .............................................................................................................. 48 Theoretical Perspectives ................................................................................................. 50 3.2 Pūrākau Theory ..................................................................................................... 50 3.3 Conflict / Critical Theory ......................................................................................... 51 3.4 Poverty Welfare and Social Exclusion.................................................................... 52
  8. 8. 8 3.5 Indigenous Research Methodologies ..................................................................... 54 Participants ..................................................................................................................... 58 Data Collection................................................................................................................ 60 3.6 Data Collation ........................................................................................................ 62 3.7 Importance and Limitations .................................................................................... 63 Proposed Analysis of Data .............................................................................................. 64 Chapter Four ..................................................................................................................... 69 Ko te Hinau - The Hinau Pillar.......................................................................................... 69 Introduction ..................................................................................................................... 69 Ngāpuhi Links to the Research........................................................................................ 70 Mātauranga Māori ........................................................................................................... 71 4.1 The Exercising of Mana ......................................................................................... 74 4.2 Mana Atua ............................................................................................................. 75 4.3 Mana Whenua........................................................................................................ 75 4.4 Mana Tangata........................................................................................................ 76 Te Wakaminenga and Economic Success....................................................................... 77 4.5 Te Wakaminenga................................................................................................... 78 4.6 Initial Kaupapa Māori Research ............................................................................. 78 4.7 Establishing an International Flag .......................................................................... 81 He Wakaputanga and their use of the Term Mana .......................................................... 82 4.8 Letter to King William in 1831................................................................................. 82 4.9 Creating ‘He Wakaputanga’ ................................................................................... 84 Chapter Five ...................................................................................................................... 87 Ko te Mahoe - The Mahoe Pillar ....................................................................................... 87 Introduction ..................................................................................................................... 87 Contextualising Te Tiriti o Waitangi via Doctrine of Discovery ......................................... 87 5.1 Ngāpuhi Evidence Concerning Te Tiriti o Waitangi................................................. 89 5.2 Hobson's Statements and Assurances to Māori with regard to the Treaty.............. 90 5.3 Hobson's Actual Letter ........................................................................................... 92 Historical Contexts Leading to Legislative Violations ....................................................... 94 5.4 Imposition of Crown Rule ....................................................................................... 95 5.5 Legislative Violations.............................................................................................. 98 The Destruction of Māori Society................................................................................... 100 5.6 Māori Experiences of Historical Intergenerational Trauma ................................... 101 Te Kauwae Runga and External Knowledge.................................................................. 102 5.7 Te Kauwae Raro and Internal Knowledge ............................................................ 102
  9. 9. 9 5.8 Pōuritanga ........................................................................................................... 103 5.9 Whakamomori...................................................................................................... 103 5.10 Traditional Songs and Historical Intergenerational Trauma ................................ 104 5.11 Epigenetic Research.......................................................................................... 106 5.12 Human Needs / Ends Theory ............................................................................. 107 Māori Deficit Statistics ................................................................................................... 112 5.13 Māori Crime ....................................................................................................... 112 5.14 Deficit Theories.................................................................................................. 113 5.15 Responding to Deficit Theories .......................................................................... 113 Chapter Six...................................................................................................................... 119 Ko te Patatē – The Patatē Pillar...................................................................................... 119 Introduction ................................................................................................................... 119 Locating Self in the Research .................................................................................... 119 Personal Experiences of Domestic Violence and Child Abuse ................................... 121 6.1 Personal Trauma - Flashbacks, Hearing Voices Trances..................................... 122 6.2 Beginning a Crime Wave...................................................................................... 122 6.3 Death of Brother................................................................................................... 123 6.4 The Last Abuse.................................................................................................... 124 Gwenda Rowe............................................................................................................... 125 6.5 Foster Home ........................................................................................................ 126 6.6 Displaying Extreme Behaviour ............................................................................. 127 Beginning of the End ..................................................................................................... 128 6.6 Sentenced to Life Imprisonment - The Turbulent Years ....................................... 131 6.7 Plan of Redemption.............................................................................................. 132 6.8 Making Changes.................................................................................................. 133 6.9 New Beginnings....................................................................................................... 134 6.10 The Tides of Change.......................................................................................... 134 Alternatives to Violence Project Waikato ....................................................................... 135 6.11 Learning My Cultural Identity.............................................................................. 136 Becky Fox-Vercoe ......................................................................................................... 136 6.12 National Parole Board ........................................................................................ 137 6.13 The Road to Recovery ....................................................................................... 139 Rebuilding Worth and Integrity ...................................................................................... 141 6.14 Education........................................................................................................... 141 Contextualising Māori Experiences of Intergenerational Trauma ................................... 148 Chapter Seven................................................................................................................. 153
  10. 10. 10 Māku Anō E Hangā Tōku Nei Whare- I Will Rebuild My Own House ........................... 153 Introduction ................................................................................................................... 153 Findings......................................................................................................................... 154 7.1 Historical contexts pre Te Tiriti o Waitangi ........................................................... 154 7.2 Impact of the British and NZ Crown Collaboration post 1840 ............................... 156 7.3 Intergenerational Impacts for Māori...................................................................... 157 Analysis......................................................................................................................... 158 7.4 Key Issues from Literature Review....................................................................... 158 7.5 Colonising Patterns.............................................................................................. 159 7.6 Te Tiriti o Waitangi Patterns................................................................................. 160 7.7 Māori Rationale for Te Tiriti o Waitangi ................................................................ 163 7.8 Assimilation Patterns............................................................................................ 164 7.9 Intergenerational Trauma Links to Māori Deficit Statistics .................................... 165 Research Questions...................................................................................................... 167 Strategies of Response ................................................................................................. 168 7. 10 Māori Counselling Strategies ............................................................................ 170 7.11 He Kākano Ahau Framework ............................................................................. 170 7.12 The Pōwhiri Poutama Model............................................................................ 172 7.13 The Pūrākau Model............................................................................................ 174 7.14 Te Whare Tapawhā Model ................................................................................. 175 7.15 Te Tuakiri o Te Tangata Model .......................................................................... 177 The Pillars ..................................................................................................................... 179 Contribution to Knowledge............................................................................................. 180 Glossary of Māori terms ................................................................................................ 185 Bibliography .................................................................................................................. 189 Appendix ....................................................................................................................... 199
  11. 11. 11 List of Figures Figure 1.1 Waikato Tainui landmark boundary 15 Figure 2.1 Definition of Aboriginality [table 1] 33 Figure 2.2 Governmental Aboriginal Land Policy 35 Figure 2.3 HIT Influences on Health & Health care 37 Figure 2.4 Children in care and supervision 41 Figure 3.1 Māori Ethical Framework 57 Figure 4.1 Ngāpuhi-nui-tonu landmark boundaries 70 Figure 5.1 Treaty of Waitangi critical analysis 99 Figure 5.2 HIT transfer across generations 100 Figure 5.3 He Waiata Tangi – A Song of Lament 105 Figure 5.4 Needs versus needs not met 108 Figure 5.5 Poverties 109 Figure 5.6 Human-end Theory 110 Figure 5.7 Two Forms of Sub-Alternisation 111 Figure 6.1 Contextualising HIT in Genealogy 120 Figure 6.2 Mother fears for Safety [Waikato Times] 126 Figure 6.3 Stabbing incident [Waikato Times] 129
  12. 12. 12 Figure 6.4 Murder Trial [Waikato Times] 130 6.5 Redemption of David Karena 140 Figure 6.6 The War on Violence [NZ Women's Weekly] 141 Figure 6.7 Graduating with diploma [photo] 142 Figure 6.8 Graduating with Bachelor Degree [photo] 142 Figure 6.9 Master's graduation [photo] 142 Figure 6.10 Cusco Peru [photo] 144 Figure 6.11 Inca production [photo] 144 Figure 6.12 Machu Picchu [photo] 144 Figure 6.13 TAOTA Doctoral Scholarship [photo] 145 Figure 6.14 TAOTA Doctoral Scholarship recipients 146 Figure 6.15 Ngārimu & 28th Māori Battalion Doctoral scholarship 146 Figure 6.16 Scholarship recipients [photo] 147 Figure 6,17 Presenting at He Manawa Whenua Conference 148 Figure 7.1 He Kakano Ahau Framework 171 Figure 7.2 Pōwhiri Poutama framework 173 Figure 7.3 Pūrākau Model 175 Figure 7.4 Te Whare Tapawhā 176 Figure 7.5 Te Tuakiri o Te Tangata 178 Figure 7.6 The Colonising Tree 181
  13. 13. 13
  14. 14. 14 Chapter One Te Tongi a Tāwhiao – The Prophecy of King Tāwhiao Introduction The Te Tongi a Tawhiao 1 can be considered a prophecy, and a metaphor for rebuilding Māori communities and Māori society by assisting to rise above and move beyond the impacts of historical intergenerational trauma through the power, the resilience, recovery and re-emergence of the common people. This introductory chapter attempts to interweave threads of historical knowledge to make sense of current contemporary constructs that both impede Māori rights to autonomy, as well as impose legislative parameters and social, political and economic impacts that have impeded mana Māori, and tino rangatiratanga or self- determination since the signing of Te Tiriti o Waitangi. An integral aspect significant to this research takes a multi-layered approach to critically analysing the phenomena known as historical intergenerational trauma. While this chapter focuses on a Tainui perspective it also acknowledges my maternal whakapapa perspective through my connections to Ngāpuhi. In this chapter I will commence with introducing a brief history of the Waikato people and the Kingitanga Movement leading to Te Tongi a Tāwhiao. The second aspect will describe how I intend to weave Te Tongi a Tāwhiao throughout the Ph.D thesis. The fourth aspect will discuss how I am connected to King Tāwhiao. The fifth aspect will give a summary account of how I became involved with this topic. The final aspect will give an overview of the thesis outline. Kingitanga Movement The Waikato Tainui people are a collection of tribes or hapū that are based in the central north Island of Aotearoa New Zealand. The North Island for Māori is called Te Ika-ā-Maui or the fish of Māui. The name was given due to a Māori legend of an ancestor called Maui who upon fishing with his brothers caught and brought to the surface, up from the depths of the ocean a monstrous stingray, considered the 1 An explanation of Te Tongi a Tawhiao is on page 17 -Mahuta (2007)
  15. 15. 15 original form of the North Island. The Waikato people all descend from the Tainui waka, or canoe that came to New Zealand from Hawaiki many generations before. The Waikato people also descend from one ancestor, namely Hoturoa, who was the original captain of Tainui waka, when it made its voyage to Aotearoa New Zealand. Over many generations, for the Waikato people, and other Māori whānau, hapū and iwi, skills and abilities such as visions proverbs and prophecy are an important aspect of Mātauranga Māori and Māori epistemology. One famous prophecy employed as a theoretical framework for this thesis is by the prophet and second Māori King, Tawhiao of the Waikato tribes of New Zealand. The Māori King Movement, or Kīngitanga, began in 1858 in an attempt to unify Māori tribes and avert land alienation. Māhuta (2007) contended that; "the major issues that confronted Māori after the signing of the Treaty of Waitangi in 1840 were the desire of the growing settler population for more land, and increasing social disorganization as a result of European contact" (p.1). Three philosophies underpinned the establishment of Te Kingitanga. It was established to halt the bloodshed between the tribes, it was also established to unite the people, and block further sales of land to the European settlers. According to McLintock (1966), another feature that underpinned Te Kingitanga, was that a number of tribes supported the movement, but it became centred on the Waikato region and people (p.1). The desire to retain land was a central concern of the movement repeated in sayings, songs and haka. Figure 1.1 Waikato Tainui landmark boundaries
  16. 16. 16 1.1 Choosing a Māori King In the 1850s various hapū throughout the country including Te Wai Pounamu (South Island) deliberated as to who should be offered the mantle of king, and this led to the establishment of the Māori King Movement, Te Kīngitanga. The alliance of hapū involved finally decided the person to bestow the mantle upon was Pōtatau Te Wherowhero. Upon the passing of Pōtatau, his son Tāwhiao Te Wherowhero became the second Māori King. During the reign of Tāwhiao, many hapū throughout the land experienced the consequences of colonial might amounting in the Waikato war and invasion of 1863-1864. Papa and Meredith (2013) state that "Tāwhiao and his followers were declared rebels and some 1.2 million acres (almost 500,000 hectares) of their fertile lands were confiscated (p.1). The return of these confiscated lands became a central concern for Tāwhiao and subsequent Waikato leaders. Their catch cry was: ‘I riro whenua atu, me hoki whenua mai’ or “land was taken then land should be given back”. The impact of land confiscation created a situation where the people suffered from anxiety, deprivation, frustration and alienation. Māhuta (2007) contended that the Waikato people stated; This way of life will not continue beyond the days of my grandchildren when we shall reach salvation. Through his reading of Scripture and discussion with early missionaries, Tawhiao became aware that his was not a unique struggle. He believed that in time others would come to the assistance of his cause, hence his saying, 'My friends will come from the four ends of the world. They are the shoemakers, the blacksmiths and the carpenters (p.1). After nearly 20 years in exile Kingi Tāwhiao and the Waikato people came back to the land of their ancestors. Here they saw the way the European settlers had carved up their territory. For a people whose identity is interwoven with the land and the river, the impact of becoming impoverished, due to the confiscation of land had devastating effects. The despair and trauma of no longer being able to have that cultural connection to the whenua (land) which Waikato people considered an ancestor, created destitution and trauma that had intergenerational implications.
  17. 17. 17 1.2 Te Tongi a Tawhiao Māhuta (2007) contended that as a way of responding to their situation “Tāwhiao left a legacy of religious principles from which his people would draw a future dream for Tainui accumulating in the rebirth of a self-sufficient economic base, supported by the strength and stability of the people.” Another legacy Tāwhiao left was the poukai or communal feast. Māhuta (2007) highlighted that "Tawhiao sought solutions to Māori problems through the establishment of Māori institutions to deal with them (p.1). In 1885 he initiated the institution of poukai, where the King would pay annual visits to marae aligned with the King movement to encourage people to return to their home marae at least once a year. The first poukai (originally called puna-kai, or 'source of food') was held at Whatiwhatihoe in March 1885. It was a day for the less fortunate to be fed and entertained. The poukai developed into an event which would later ensure that the common people would get direct consultation with the King. Such was the foresight of Tāwhiao that many of the legacies he implemented are still relevant today. The Dictionary of NZ Biographies (1996) acknowledges that "Tāwhiao was regarded as a great visionary, and had many followers" (p.57). His sayings have been variously described as poropititangā, tongi and whakakitengā; all of these terms imply prophetic, visionary or 'prescient states of being' One of his famous prophecies is explained below is: Te Tongi a Tawhiao Māku anō e hanga tōku nei whare Ko te tāhūhū, ko te Hīnau. Ko ngā poupou ko te Māhoe, ko te Patatē I shall build my own house, The ridge-pole will be of Hīnau And the supporting posts of Māhoe and Patatē Māhuta (2007) stated that “native trees and foods symbolize strength and self- sufficiency” (p.1). During Tāwhiao's time in exile, the Waikato people pondered, reflected and focused on his prophetic sayings. Tāwhiao's words became embedded in the traditions and knowledge of the Waikato people, especially in regard to the reclamation of Tainui land and resources. Having taken into consideration the history of the King Movement let us turn to how it is interwoven into this thesis.
  18. 18. 18 A significant feature of the Te Tongi a Tawhiao prophesy concerns the timber Tāwhiao refers to and chose to rebuild his house with. In his prophetic saying, the timbers he chose are not the chiefly timbers such as the ‘Totara’, or the ‘Kauri’. The reason for their omission from this prophecy is important because carvers prefer to use the chiefly timbers to build houses and canoes. The type and quality of the timber used in building houses and other properties, imbues them with great status. However the timber Tāwhiao speaks of in the prophecy, are commonly grown in abundance throughout the forest. What is also known about the Hīnau, mahoe and Patatē is that they can be bent when pressure is applied, and not break. They possess a resilience about them that does not exist in the Totara or Kauri tree. One interpretation of the prophecy is by likening the concept of the timber to the nature of human beings. Given the circumstances that the Waikato people went through with the confiscation of land, I interpret those words to mean that the people will be restored by the power of resilience, adaption, recovery and re-emergence that exists within the common people. As a descendant of Tainui, I intend to use this analogy and interweave themes such as resilience, recovery, redemption, restoration, and wellbeing into the theoretical framework of this thesis. Although the mahoe, Hīnau and Patatē are common trees, like my ancestors before me, they are strong resilient and adaptable. Each tree represents a chapter of the central argument promulgated in this thesis and the prophecy allows me to contribute back to my community in ways that promote recovery, restoration, re-emergence and wellness. Whānau Connection to Kingitanga In trying to gain a sense of my own personal connection with Tāwhiao’s prophecy I decided to go on a personal journey of re-discovery. Before commencing on this journey, my understanding of the King Movement and the historical role my family played in contributing to the King movement was non-existent. My uncle Patrick Waratini kept stories from my grandfather and has researched archival documentation around the King movement. I was fortunate to gain access to these archives and peruse the documents and listen to the oral histories around the archives.
  19. 19. 19 My great grandfathers’ name was Te Nahu Te Kuri, Waretini- Wetene. He was born in 1840. As a young man growing up in the Waikato, he was well versed in Tainui customs. His eyes saw the vast plantations that once stood at Te Kōpu Mania o Kirikiriroa Hamilton in the 1800s Te Kōpū Mānia o Kirikiriroa was a huge mara kai or vegetable garden that stemmed from the top of the hill in Hamilton, now known as the Waikato Institute of Technology, right down to the Waikato river. This vegetable garden produced crops that fed tribes throughout the Waikato, as well as providing resources to trade with the settlers. His feet trod through the many ancient pā sites along the Waikato including Kirikiriroa pā. What was significant about this pā is that it could only be accessed by the river. To gain access into the pā one had to climb vines to ascend to the top of the hill. The Miropiko pā site on River Road was also significant as it was created specifically for war. Another pā my great grandfather visited was Pūkete pā. This pā was well positioned as a look-out, to determine who was using the river. It is significant for me in terms of realising that my great grandfather saw these things when they were flourishing, while I currently describe the pā sites, as ancient remnants of a once traditionally prosperous people, with global economic and industrious aspirations. 1.3 Whānau connection to Waikato Invasion and Orākau Battle The Waikato invasion of 1863-1864 changed the way that Waikato people practiced their traditional ways of knowing and being. At 23 years of age, my great grandfather fought against the British Empire and the New Zealand Colonial Settler Government troops who invaded the Waikato region. After nearly a year of war, Te Nahu followed Kingi Tāwhiao into the King Country, and exile. P Waratini (personal communication, Jan 10 2011) contended that “whilst Te Nahu was in the King Country he ended up alongside Rewi Maniapoto and Tuhoe fighting the British troops at Orākau pā, he was lucky to escape with his life”. Te Nahu was said to be 80 years old when my grandfather Te Kapa Waretini-Wetene was born. In his later years he became a spiritual advisor to King Māhuta, King Te Rata and Princess Te Puea. Te Nahu, Te Kuri Waretini-Wetene lived to the age of 100 years old, and can be seen as an example of a man born into a collective life of wealth and abundance born from collaborative interdependent alliances pre Te Tiriti o Waitangi, to dying the under impoverished circumstances resulting from the confiscations of Māori land from the Waikato invasion in 1863 post Te Tiriti o Waitangi.
  20. 20. 20 1.4 Intergenerational Impacts on Whānau My grandfather Te Kapa o Te Wharua Waretini-Wetene was born in the 1920s and brought up by Princess Te Puea. He was born into an era where there were two major issues that impacted the Waikato people. The first issue was a growing sense of outrage over the confiscated lands in the Waikato. The Waikato people protested the actions of the respective New Zealand Settler Governments regarding the land confiscations and refused to participate in the First World War becoming conscientious objectors. This resulted in numerous Waikato men being jailed. The second issue came about in 1918. In 1918 an influenza epidemic struck lasting from approximately October to December 1918. King (1987) contended that "many Māori parents died leaving children orphaned, homeless, abandoned and destitute"(p.99). Karena (2009) contended that "Te Puea visited all the settlements between Mangatawhiri and the Waikato heads gathering up all the those orphaned as a result of the influenza epidemic"(p. 11). King (1987) stated that "the children numbered just over one hundred"(p.118). Princess Te Puea took the children under her wing and they were looked after by both her and the other surviving adults. King (1987) also contended that: During the depression the young orphans were sent out to the farms of the European settlers during the day to work for pennies milking cows and cutting scrub bushes. The money that the children gained from farm work was used to feed the community and among other things purchase musical instruments and clothing. During the night they would practice on their instruments. In 1921 Te Pou o Mangatawhiri was created in two parts. One side of the group performed kapa haka while the other half played as a band with an assortment of instruments (p.118). In my Master's thesis, on the Māori Show Bands titled; Māori Show bands; an intrepid journey, I refer to Te Pou o Mangatawhiri as the very first Māori Show Band. In the early 1920s, the concert party travelled throughout the North Island doing performances. What is important about the establishment of Te Pou O Mangatawhiri is that they played a significant role in the rejuvenation of the Waikato people. Their performances created part of the funding that enabled Princess Te Puea to buy the land upon which Tūrangawaewae marae now resides. Apparently Princess Te Puea had big plans and expectations for my grandfather and was grooming him in Tainui customs. However there was also a mischievous side to Kapa. P Waratini (personal
  21. 21. 21 communication, Jan 10 2011) contended that "Princess Te Puea named him Te Kapa o te Wharua because when there was work to be done he was gone like the wind." There were numerous occasions when the other children were sent into town to look for him and drag him back to the marae where he would get a scolding. While it upset him to be growled by Princess Te Puea, he knew that deep down inside, she loved him like she loved all her children. In spite of his mischievous behaviour Kapa still considered himself one of her favourites. Waratini (personal communication, Jan 10 2011) described an incident that happened at a poukai. "Princess Te Puea was standing at the front of the cue at this particular poukai watching the people put their money into a basket as they entered the door. Princess Te Puea noticed a kaumatua that was quite drunk walk up to the basket. Upon reaching into his pocket the kaumatua pulled out a handful of notes, silvers and pennies. Princess Te Puea became angry at the sight of this kaumatua sifting through his notes and silver coins to pick up a penny and put it in the basket. Princess Te Puea hit that basket with her tokotoko walking stick spilling the money all over the place. She then proceeded to grab him by the scruff of the neck and throw him out the door calling him cheap. My grandfather found the penny and asked if he could keep it. A hole was drilled in the penny and he wore it around his neck for most of his adult life. P Waratini (personal communication, Jan 10 2011) also spoke of an incident that changed Kapa's life. At 10 years of age Kapa was accused by a minister of setting fire to a house that the ministers daughter was asleep in, the daughter was killed. The social welfare removed Kapa from Turangawaewae marae, and put him in to a social welfare home. Kapa never saw his father again and became a ward of the state. Coming from an environment that mainly spoke Māori it was a shock for Kapa to continually be on the receiving end of beatings for speaking Māori to the point that he stopped using his native language. To this day many of his descendants do not speak the Māori language or attend marae meetings due to religious reasons based on Western paradigms. Kapa also swore till the day he died that he had nothing to do with the fire, nor the killing of the minister’s daughter. He passed away from a heart attack in 1989 while attending a hui at Tūrangawaewae marae.
  22. 22. 22 Summary of Thesis This first chapter is entitled Te Tongi a Tāwhiao – The Prophecy of Tāwhiao, gives a historical account of the famous Tainui prophecy Māku anō e hanga tōku nei whare, Ko te tāhūhū, he Hīnau. Ko ngā poupou he Māhoe he Patatē. This prophesy uttered by the second Māori King Tawhiao gave hope to the Waikato tribes that became intergenerationally impoverished, ravaged, destitute and displaced as a result of the after effects of the Waikato invasion in 1863. The concept of rebuilding the whare through promoting recovery, restoration, and re-emergence has been central to the healing process of Waikato Tainui in contemporary times. This in turn enables me to stand grounded in my whakapapa and history to build a strong foundation from which to launch this Ph.D thesis. The second chapter is a literature review on the topic of historical intergenerational trauma. The literature will give an account of the history of colonisation, and how the Doctrine of Discovery was used as a vehicle for acquiring the land of Indigenous peoples globally. The literature will also provide a comparative analysis of Australia, Canada, and New Zealand, as three countries subjected to assimilation policies that were initially established in the House of Commons Select Committee on Aborigines in England. The next aspect examines literature identifying intergenerational impacts for Indigenous peoples, and discusses two examples that are apparent in all three countries. The third chapter is Research Methodologies. This chapter will examine gaps noted in chapter two to formulate four research questions. The third chapter will also lay out the overall plan for the thesis that includes aims and objectives. The research methodology chapter will carry three theoretical perspectives. The first research methodology is Pūrākau theory based on the work of Dr. Jenny Lee, and the second is Conflict critical theory based on the work of Karl Marx. The third methodology is an Indigenous research methodology that guides the research practice of a Māori researcher. The fourth chapter will give an indication of how the prophesy of Tawhiao becomes interwoven into the thesis commencing with the title Ko Te Hīnau. Chapter four will
  23. 23. 23 cover the era of pre-colonisation to 1840. In this section Ngāpuhi connections and whakapapa will become apparent. This chapter will then commence by contextualising Te Tongi a Tawhiao emphasising underlying themes that stem from this proverb, and then contextualising Ngāpuhi links. The second aspect will discuss Mātauranga Māori. The third aspect will discuss mana and Māori concepts. The fourth aspect will discuss Te Wakaminenga and economic success. The final aspect will discuss He Wakaputanga and the mana that was established with it. The fifth chapter titled Ko te Mahoe carries an underlying theme of resilience that will give a macro systematic overview of intergenerational impacts post 1840. The first aspect will contextualise the background to Te Tiriti o Waitangi. The second aspect will investigate historical contexts leading to legislative violations, and its role in subjugating Māori, to ramifications that stem from intergenerational trauma, and their links to Māori deficit statistics. The third aspect will discuss Māori experiences of historical intergenerational trauma. The final aspect will discuss links to Māori deficit statistics. In chapter six titled Ko te Patatē, it will carry an underlying theme of recovery that will give a micro systematic overview of intergenerational impacts. It will give a personal account to the impact of colonisation, and examine how those impacts contribute to a journey of deficit behaviour leading to tragic consequences. The second aspect of the personal account will highlight moving from trauma to recovery, redemption, and then wellness. The final chapter seven titled Māku Anō e Hanga Tōku Nei Whare: I Will Rebuild My Own House carries an underlying theme based on re-emergence. This will give an overview of all the chapters and discuss findings and analysis. The analysis will then link back to the four proposed research questions. The next aspect will discuss a variety of strategies employed by Māori over the last 170 years, and then offer another strategy in the form of a Māori Counselling Framework that responds to Māori experiences of historical intergenerational trauma. Chapter seven finally draws together all the pillars that represent King Tawhiao's prophecy, and then discusses how this research contributes to Māori knowledge of health and wellbeing. The final aspect of chapter seven will conclude with a rationale as to why this research was conducted.
  24. 24. 24 Conclusion In this chapter I have explained the prophecy of Tāwhiao which provides a theoretical framework for this thesis. I also introduced the history of the Māori King Movement which led to the utterance of this prophecy. The next aspect discussed how this prophecy is applied to the thesis, its historical context and this links to personal whakapapa. In doing this, the prophecy explains the historical contexts at a macro-systemic level, as well as a micro-systemic level. This chapter also provides us with a prophecy and model for introducing a transformative framework that responds to Māori experiences of historical intergenerational trauma.
  25. 25. 25
  26. 26. 26 Chapter Two A Literary Review of Historical Intergenerational Trauma Overview This chapter critically reviews the literature concerning historical intergenerational trauma. It will draw attention to the historically competitive desires of European cultures for land, resources and wealth belonging to Indigenous cultures in foreign lands. It will review examples of prevalent discourses around ideologies of superiority resulting in the need to subjugate other cultures from a mono-cultural and theistic point of view. Moreover, it highlights colonial mechanisms employed to dominate and oppress Indigenous cultures. The Papal Bull decrees 2 were used to incite genocide, ecocide, displacement and bio warfare for the sole purpose of acquiring Indigenous land and resources. The key themes outlined in this chapter will include: historical colonisation, assimilation, societal, institutional, personal racism, oppression, and discrimination. This chapter will then review how these legacies have contributed to coping strategies such as intergenerational addictions. The literature reveals historical content that is central to formulating underlying themes behind research into historical intergenerational trauma. Introduction The first aspect of this literature review concentrates on introducing and defining historical trauma. This chapter will establish and define this concept by focussing on the work of Brave Heart (2003), Walters (2004), Estrada (2009), Simonelli & Summer, (1995), as well as Duran & Walters (1998). There are also other authors this thesis acknowledges such as Fannon (1963) and Memmi (1991) who laid the foundations for reviewing and critiquing colonisation. This thesis also acknowledges the significant work of Paulo Freire (1975) in formulating an understanding of the pedagogy of oppression and its strategies that involve humanising and de- humanising mechanisms. This thesis takes these notions into account while formulating strategies relevant to this thesis. 2 Papal Bull decrees were letter formats of the Pope from the Vatican as explained by Churchill (1993) on page 30-31
  27. 27. 27 The second aspect employed here is based on the work of Churchill (1993), Jackson (2012), and Armitage (1995) who discusses a series of historical catalysts that initiated historical intergenerational trauma on a global scale. Other aspects identify legacies and policy making organisations and religious sects whose actions also contributed to traumatic incidents that had a detrimental impact on Indigenous peoples. The third aspect identifies examples of prejudicial policies. The fourth aspect discusses influences on health and well-being. The final aspect will discuss indicators for Māori counselling. Historical Intergenerational Trauma (HIT) What is historical intergenerational trauma? Historical intergenerational trauma is known by several names in the research literature: survival guilt, stressful life events, intergenerational grief and bereavement, post traumatic slave syndrome and cultural trauma (Brave Heart & De Bruyn, 1998: Cook, Withy, & Tarallo-Jensen, 2003: Danieli, 1998: Degruy Leary, 2005; Kellerman, 2001; Krieger, 2001) This thesis contends it to be the application of discriminatory and detrimental practices, that range from oppressive to genocidal, based on ideologies of superiority, for the purpose of alienating another culture from their lands, wealth and resources across generations. Whilst this is one view, there are also a host of others. Walters (2012) states in a video presentation that 'historical intergenerational trauma' can be defined as an event or series of events perpetrated against a group of people and their environment, namely people who share a specific group identity with genocidal or ethnocidal intent to systematically eradicate them as a people or eradicate their way of life. Brave Heart (1999a) defines historical trauma as... cumulative trauma over both the life span and across generations that results from massive cataclysmic events... (p.111). Brave Heart also contends that historical trauma (HIT) is cumulative emotional and psychological wounding, over the lifespan and across generations, emanating from massive group trauma experiences. The historical trauma response (HTR) is the constellation of features in reaction to this trauma (Brave Heart, 2003) argues that "while there seems to be a variety of definitions, the underlying threads carry similar themes" (p. 7). Dr Brave Heart (2000) supports the learning of historical intergenerational trauma by suggesting that understanding the
  28. 28. 28 legacy of trauma is helpful for participants, and that the importance of sharing and talking about the trauma allows sufferers to focus on a common identity. Arbor (2006) suggests that it is helpful to introduce a theory of cultural trauma into the study of collective memory and shed light on a socio-psychological dimension of remembering. What can stem from a theory of cultural trauma is a theory of collective memory that incorporates reiterated problem solving. The theory of cultural trauma can give us new analytical leverage to study how commemorative practices build on one another and how a traumatic event plays out in memory-identity formation of a collective. Other theories include discovering new ways of explaining the social, political and economic impacts of historical intergenerational trauma. Karina Walters' (2012) discussion in a video presentation brings to the fore new data that states 'epigenetic research' has discovered that at a cellular level, stress from one generation can be carried to the next generation. Bruce Lipton (2009) a cellular biologist in stem cell research supports the conclusions/perspectives of Walters by stating that he began stem cell research in 1967 in which he noted: In one of my experiments I put stem cells in three petri dishes. I then changed the growth medium, the constituents of the environment in each dish… In one dish it formed bone, in the next it formed muscle and in the final dish it formed fat cells… All of a sudden I’m like oh my gosh, I realised that here I am teaching at University that genes control the environment, while the cells are telling me that genes respond to the environment… (Dr Bruce Lipton, 2009 as cited in Stewart, 2009). In gaining a sense of cultural trauma and how it relates to memory-identity formation of a collective is quite significant. Links between these previous concepts and discovering new ways of explaining the social, political and economic impacts also seems to have a lot of merit. These theories and concepts also seem to run in contrast to Western research that paints a disparaging picture of Māori cultural tendencies towards violence. In 2006 Rod Lea and Geoffrey Chambers said high criminality among Māori was due to monoamine oxidase, or the "warrior" gene. Therefore this suggested that due to genes, Māori had a high propensity for violence. While this theory suggests that genes control our environment, Bruce Lipton's experiments conclude that at a cellular level genes respond to the
  29. 29. 29 environment. Overall, despite the fact that Rod Lea and Geoffrey Chamber’s research was hugely discredited, for not meeting outcomes, and for a lack of rigour in their findings, it still had a detrimental impact on how Māori culture was perceived in New Zealand, as well as globally as the findings emanated from so called reputable Western scholars. Although research from Western scholars such as Rod Lea and Geoffrey Chambers seem to legitimise deficit perceptions of Māori on many levels, other theorists (Smith 1999; Pihama, 2001, Friere, 1975; Moeke-Pickering, 2010; Fanon, 1963; Memmi, 1991; Jackson, 1988; Jackson, 2012; Brave Heart, 1999; Walters, 2012; Churchill, 1993, Church Council, 2012) give alternate views as to why Māori and Indigenous cultures around the globe under-achieve at one level, to becoming impoverished across generations at another level in today's Western capitalistic global environment. 2.1 Historical Catalyst for Historical Intergenerational Trauma Another theory considers the wider historical implications contributing to historical intergenerational trauma. Ward Churchill (1993) discusses the role of the European Monarchies and the Catholic Church's contribution to the impacts of historical intergenerational trauma of Māori and Indigenous peoples resulting from a document known as the Doctrine of Discovery. Jackson (2012) stated in a video presentation at the United Nations in New York that the Doctrine of Discovery was promoted as a legal authority for claiming the land of Indigenous peoples. This process initiated colonisation on a global scale based on stereotypical assumptions of both religious zeal and self-righteous positioning that was to have devastating outcomes for Indigenous cultures stemming from the 1300s, through to the 21st century. While there were many Western countries participating in the practice of colonisation based on the Doctrine of Discovery, such practices did not necessarily correspond with international law. Churchill (1993) argues that: History is replete with philosophical, theological and juridical arguments of one people’s alleged entitlement to the homeland of others, only to be rebuffed by the community of nations as lacking both moral force and sound legal principle (p. 33). Churchill (1993) further challenges dominant assumptions by stating that:
  30. 30. 30 Recognition of the legal and moral rights by which a nation occupies its land base is a fundamental issue of its existence. Typically such claims to sovereign and propriety interest in national territories rest on its citizenry being composed of direct descendants of peoples who have dwelt within the geographical area claimed since time immemorial. But when the dominating population is comprised either of immigrants (settlers') who can offer no such assertion of aboriginal lineage to justify their presence or ownership of property in the usual sense, the issue is vastly more complicated. (p. 33). Further investigation into how the Doctrine of Discovery was established brings to the fore disparaging ideologies, and genocidal practices of western countries who to this day, have never been held accountable for what Jackson (2012) argues, are crimes against humanity. From the 14th century in an era that was termed the age of discovery, other European countries were eager to experience similar exploits as Christopher Columbus. The European powers sent ambassadors out into the new world where they began encountering Indigenous cultures. These ambassadors’ also encountered emissaries from other European powers, and each were competing for trade with the Indigenous cultures. Churchill (1993) stated that "European powers realized that a formal code of judicial standards to legitimate what they required, lent to a patina of civilized legality to the actions of the European Crowns" (p. 34). The purpose of developing judicial standards was to resolve disputes between European Crown entities, as each jockeyed for position in disputes over gaining wealth through ownership of Indigenous land in the "New Worlds". Churchill (1993) maintained that: In order for any such regulatory code to be considered effectively binding by all Old World parties, it was vital that it be sanctioned by the Catholic Church”. A series of Papal Bulls begun by Pope Innocent IV during the late 13th century was used to define the proper [lawful] relationship between Christians and 'Infidels' in worldly matters such as property rights (p. 35). Papal Bulls can be defined as official decrees of the pope, and was the exclusive letter format of the Vatican from the fourteenth century. Churchill (1993) affirmed that
  31. 31. 31 efforts of legal scholars such as Franciscus de Victoria and Matias de Pas, that the Spanish articulation of the Discovery Doctrine, endorsed by the Pope, rapidly evolved to hold the following as primary tenets of international law (p. 35). 1. Outright ownership of land accrued to the crown represented by a given Christian ( European) discoverer only when the land discovered proved to be uninhabited (Papal Bull territorium res nullius ) 2. Title to inhabited lands discovered by Crown representatives was recognized as belonging inherently to the Indigenous people encountered, but rights to acquire land from, and to trade with the natives of the region accrued exclusively to the discovering Crown (Papal Bull vis-à-vis) 3. In exchange for this right the discovering power committed itself to proselytizing the Christian Gospel among the Natives. 4. Acquisition of land title from Indigenous peoples could only occur with their consent by an agreement usually involving purchase rather than through force of arms. At face value the Doctrine of Discovery appeared to have merit however, in application, the Doctrine of Discovery initiated a mandate followed by all European Crowns. The World Church Council (2012) stated that Papal Bull Decrees such as Romanus Pontifex 1455 called for non-Christian peoples to be invaded, captured, vanquished, subdued, and reduced to perpetual slavery and to have their possessions and property seized by Christian monarchs (p. 1). The World Church Council (2012) also stated that, Christopher Columbus was instructed, to discover and conquer, subdue and acquire distant lands. World Church Council (2012) conveyed that; "in 1493 Pope Alexander VI called for non-Christian "barbarous nations" to be subjugated and proselytized for the "propagation of the Christian empire" (p. 1). Another significant factor behind Christopher Columbus is the role he played in enslaving and annihilating an entire race of people known as the Taino from the Caribbean. After exterminating them he went on to establish the slave trade in Africa, contributing to the displacement, murder, abuse and trauma of the African American peoples. The World Church Council (2012) also declared that; The Doctrine mandated Christian European countries to attack, enslave and kill the Indigenous Peoples they encountered to acquire all of their assets. The Doctrine remains the law in various ways in almost all settler /
  32. 32. 32 colonial societies around the world today. The enormity of this law and the theft of the rights and assets of Indigenous Peoples have led Indigenous activists to work to educate the world about this situation and to galvanize opposition to the Doctrine. In the aftermath of the Doctrine of Discovery it is well documented that 100's of millions of Indigenous peoples lost their lives, were enslaved, had their land invaded, were dislocated from their tribal settings, were stripped of their identity, assimilated into a foreign culture and to this day are continually discriminated and oppressed in one form or another, in the land of their forefathers. What is significant about the Doctrine of Discovery is that it was a form of presumed legality that only existed between the foreign powers themselves. It was never discussed with the Indigenous peoples, they were never part of the decision making process. The European power’s dealings were amongst themselves, and their intentions were never disclosed to the Indigenous cultures they were dealing with who in turn were never in a position to make an informed decision as to what outcomes they wanted from any relationship with Western European powers. While the existence of the Doctrine of Discovery was hidden in history, and not evident in the education system, or discussed to a limited degree in universities, its legacy however, still plays out in a manner that affects other policies whose prejudicial undertones still have an impact on Indigenous peoples all around the world. 2.2 Prejudicial Policies One legacy stemming from the Doctrine of Discovery comes from the policy making practices of the House of Commons Select Committee on Aborigines. The House of Commons Select Committee on Aborigines was established in England in 1837. Armitage (1995) conveyed that one of their roles was to impose European civilization, Christianity, and assimilation upon the ‘Aborigines’. Armitage (1995) also conveyed that This required British administrators to determine who was, and who was not, an aboriginal person. This was the first step towards administering different policies and laws for settler societies and aboriginal societies respectively. Initially the distinction was based on a racial difference
  33. 33. 33 hierarchy according to colour. "The white race was at the top, and the darkest race was at the bottom. The Australian Aboriginal was seen as lower in hierarchy than were the lighter coloured Māori and the Northern American Indian" (p. 194). This hierarchy, according to skin colour practice seemed to be another mechanism in the arsenal of dominant cultures, was utilised as a means in which to undermine the Indigenous peoples it was subjugating by establishing a system that enables one culture to dominate another, according to the colour of their skin. Statistics New Zealand (2012) estimates that 6 per cent or 187,000 New Zealanders believed racial discrimination was the reason for them being treated unfairly or unfavourably. Armitage (1995) explains racial discrimination using three principle phases characterized by three different meanings. The first phase is race lineage and genealogical connections. The second phase talks of race as a sub-species presenting connotations that infer some species of race are of higher value than others. The third phase discusses “the role of race in establishing social divisions used for the purpose of one race benefiting at the expense of another ... (p. 221). Figure 2.1 Definition of Aboriginality (Armitage, 1995, pp. 96-97).
  34. 34. 34 The previous table highlights a timeline defining aboriginality stemming from the 1860's through to 1975. It clearly emphasises periods in time where policies were implemented in the 1800's through to meeting resistance in varying degrees during the 1970's. Other roles the House of Commons Select Committee on Aborigines participated in included distributing assimilation policies to Australia, Canada and New Zealand. Armitage (1995) states that: In Australia these policies were introduced through the protection of 'Aborigines' statutes which were passed in the period between 1869 and 1909; in Canada they were introduced within the framework of the Indian Act 1876, and its successors; and in New Zealand they were introduced in legislation establishing the Native Department (1861) and the Native Schools Act, 1867. Settlers, confident of their racial and cultural superiority, introduced these paternalistic policies in the 'best interests' of aboriginal peoples (189). What this brings to the fore are explanations as to why Indigenous cultures in three different countries had similar historical experiences with the colonising governments that occupy their lands. Other Indigenous cultures discuss similar experiences. Brave Heart, Chase, Elkins, Altschul, (2011), argues that; "over five hundred federally recognized tribes in the United States and over four hundred in Latin America have experienced pervasive and cataclysmic collective intergenerational massive group trauma and compounding discrimination, racism and oppression" (p. 282).
  35. 35. 35 Figure 2.2 Governmental Aboriginal Land Policy Armitage, 1995, pp. 200-201) The table above highlights a timeline of governmental land policies across Australia, Canada and New Zealand. It highlights various mechanisms used to infiltrate the land using assimilation tactics, and deficit legislation based on a colonising construct. In removing the historical veil over the colonising construct and the roles played by the European Crowns and the Vatican/ missionaries in implementing deficit policies, provides a sense of understanding and insight to both the thinking of the dominant cultures, as well as the impacts Indigenous cultures were subjected to. Further data from Armitage (1995), Churchill (1993), Walters (2012), Brave Heart (1998a) discusses how these policies created a legacy of disparaging poverty stricken socio- economic environments, and socio-psychological coping mechanisms that flowed from one generation to the next, across the Indigenous world. Influences on Health and Wellbeing This next aspect of this chapter looks into the lives of Indigenous peoples, coming to terms with some of the impacts that have befallen their culture. Brave Heart (1998) conveys that; generations of untreated historical intergenerational trauma victims
  36. 36. 36 may pass on this trauma to subsequent generations. This seems to support Black Cloud (1990) who explained their traditional way of mourning. They mourn for one year when one of their relations enters the spirit world. Their tradition is to wear black while mourning their lost one. The tradition is not to be happy, not to sing and dance and enjoy life's beauty during the time of mourning. The tradition is to suffer with the remembering of their lost one, and to give away much of what they own and to cut their hair short. Chief Sitting Bull was more than a relation. He represented an entire people: their freedom, their way of life... Black Cloud explained further that they have suffered remembering their great Chief given away much of what was theirs... And tens of thousands of Lakota Sioux have worn their hair short for a hundred years, and blackness has been around them for a hundred years... During this time the heartbeat of their people has been weak, and their life style has deteriorated to a devastating degree resulting in poverty, alcoholism, and suicide in the country of their forefathers (Black cloud, 1990 as cited in Brave Heart, 1995). This emphasises a descriptive picture that not only resonates with Indigenous people and their way of life, it carries a picture of how trauma has trickled from generation to generation lasting a hundred years manifesting in various shapes and forms supporting Karina Walters notions regarding intergenerational stress. Statistically speaking, cumulative intergenerational stress is believed to be the main cause of these disorders acting through a psychobiological stress response mechanism that influences neuroendocrine hyper activity, autonomic and metabolic responses, and the immune system (Schnurr & Green, 2004; Sotero, 2006).
  37. 37. 37 Figure 2.3 Historical Trauma Influences on Health & Health care (Estrada, 2009, p.336). This list highlights aspects that identify examples of stress trickling inter- generationally from one generation to the next. It will also give scope to some of the problems undermining Indigenous peoples. The next part will reveal two detrimental examples that have influenced Indigenous health and wellbeing and had damaging effects on Indigenous peoples across the globe. 2.3 Alcoholism The use of alcohol seems to be a mitigating factor in all Indigenous cultures. There have also been similar impacts for Indigenous cultures that have resulted from its use across generations. Oetting & Beauvais (1989) believes that trauma manifests as alcohol abuse among First Nations youth. There is a higher proportion of alcohol abuse amongst the Native population than the general U.S. population. Statistics highlight that 96% of Indian males and 92% of Indian females experience alcoholism by the time they have reached 12th grade. They contend that not only is the frequency and intensity of drinking greater and negative consequences more prevalent and severe; the age that one initially gets involved with alcohol is younger for Indian youths.
  38. 38. 38 Further statistics from Brave Heart, Chase, Elkins, & Altschul (2011) highlights that death from alcohol related causes being five times more likely than for White Americans, additionally, suicide rates are 50% higher than the national average (p. 283). 2.4 Māori Alcohol Statistics Māori alcohol statistics seem to carry a similar vein to Indigenous deficit statistics around the Indigenous world. Ebbet (2009) states that; "Māori were initially introduced to alcohol in the early 1800s by European settlers, whalers and other immigrants. Unlike most other nations, Māori did not have experience with any form of alcohol before this time” (p.2). A survey in the New Zealand Herald (2007) emphasised that a difference in drug and alcohol use, emphasises that Māori are more likely than other ethnicities to use drugs or drink in a hazardous way." The survey carried out face-to-face interviews with 12,992 New Zealanders on a range of behaviours and conditions relating to mental health and is part of the World Mental Health Survey Initiative. Key findings on alcohol use in the past 12 months and ethnicity:  Māori (82 per cent) and others (80 per cent) are more likely to be drinkers than Pacific Islanders (56 per cent).  Among those who consume alcohol, hazardous drinking occurs in 36 per cent of Māori, 33 per cent of Pacific people and 23 per cent of others.  Among those who consume alcohol, alcohol disorder prevalence is 6 per cent for Māori, 4 per cent for Pacific and 3 per cent for others. Key findings on drug use in the past 12 months and ethnicity:  Drug use occurs in 20 per cent of Māori, 13 per cent of others and 9 per cent of Pacific people.  Drug disorder is most common in Māori at 13 per cent of users, followed by Pacific Islanders at 10 per cent and others on 9 per cent.  Pacific people are often protected from substance use by abstinence, but are at greater risk than others if they do use drugs.  Treatment contact is low in those with a substance disorder: 4 per cent for Pacific, 12 per cent for Māori , and 14 per cent for others,
  39. 39. 39 What these statistics indicate, is that on a variety of levels, Māori alcohol and drug usage per capita is far higher than that of any other ethnic group in Aotearoa New Zealand. 2.5 Boarding Schools for Assimilation The legacy of traumatic history, specifically regarding boarding school, has negatively impacted in Canada as well as for first nations Lakota and other Native families in the United States. The historical trauma response is complicated by socio- economic conditions, racism and oppression. Risk factors for substance abuse, violence, mental illness, and other family problems among Native people may be exacerbated by historical trauma response (Brave Heart, 1999b; Robin, Chester & Goldman 1996; Holm, 1994). Brave Heart (1999a) explains some effects that state: I never bonded with any parental figures in my home. At seven years old I could be gone for days at a time and no one would look for me... I've never been in a boarding school. I wished I was [had] because all we've talked about happened in my home. If it had happened by strangers, it wouldn't have been so bad- the sexual abuse, the neglect. Then I could blame it all on another race ... And yes, they (my parents) went to boarding school. (p. 113). The above quote highlights some of the ramifications stemming from assimilation practices that include a disconnection and an alienation between family members that are in contrast to their traditional cultural principles and values. Brave Heart and Debruyn (1998) convey that: I feel like I have been carrying a weight around that I've inherited. I have this theory that grief is passed on genetically because it's there and I never knew where it came from. I feel a sense of responsibility to undo the pain of the past. I can't separate myself from the past, the history and the trauma. It has been paralyzing to us as a group (pp. 56-78). Steve Richards (2013) suggests that historical intergenerational trauma can carry over from genetics that can also stem from ancestral experiences of trauma that can be thousands of years old. Richards also believes that all of humanity are holographic multi-dimensional beings who across eons of time can be trapped in cycles of time and relive similar circumstances as those ancestors who first received
  40. 40. 40 the trauma until it can be traced back in history to its original source and that essence and energy is freed to be able to change cycles of time in the future. 2.6 Māori People and Child Welfare Policy While Māori never had their children stripped from them and sent to boarding schools like the Indigenous cultures of Australia and Canada and USA. Research highlights that boarding schools were used as a vehicle to implement assimilation policies to mitigate their cultural heritage, language and identity. In New Zealand other practices were put in place that had similar effects. Armitage (1995) argues that; "the 1837 House of Commons Select Committee on Aborigines believed that children offered the best means of ensuring that aboriginal peoples would be prepared for the responsibilities of Christianity, civilization, and British citizenship" (p. 204). Legislation that had a similar affect for Māori in New Zealand stemmed from legacies of child welfare policies. The initial piece of child welfare legislation in New Zealand was called the Neglected and Criminal Children's Act 1876. This piece of legislation was aimed at Māori youth and led to the establishment of industrial schools. The Department of Education was initially made responsible for these schools in 1880. Armitage (1995) stated that: In 1910, the Department of Education was made responsible for the supervision of orphanages, and in a further gradual extension of its role, it developed a range of child welfare services which had some mandate to interfere in family matters such as truancy officers, school nurses, protection officers, and probation officers (p.161). What is also significant to consider when investigating some of these historical social welfare acts, is to also take into consideration the Native Schools Act 1867. Under this piece of legislation only English was allowed to be spoken in schools, and was stringently enforced through corporal punishment. In 1930 George Graham wrote to the Auckland Star, objecting to the operation of the Child Welfare Act: But it is in respect of the application of this law to Māori childhood that I write. For here in particular operate officials who cannot speak Māori, neither know little of nor care less for Māori mentality. They are hence incompetent to allow for those factors; yet they undertake to gather Māori children within their official nets, whence they are relegated to institutions or boarded out to European foster parents whose motives cannot be
  41. 41. 41 adjudged as mercenary (Graham, 1930 as cited in Armitage, 1995, p. 165). Figure 2.4 Children in care and supervision (Armitage 1995, p.163) Figure 2.4 above highlights the amount of Māori children in Social Welfare care from 1921 through to 1986. While I find some of the figures quite staggering, it does not seem to indicate if any of these figures are shared among the same families emphasising intergenerational factors. What also seems staggering about these statistics is that per capita a significant number of Māori children are not with their own families. This automatically highlights issues such as a disconnection from cultural roots and whānau ties, a breakdown in a sharing of cultural knowledge, heritage, protocols and language. Binney and Chaplin (1983), support this theory by giving an account of the life of Putiputi Onekawa who was born in 1908 and who was sent away to school at Turakina in 1921: I started school quite old. And I can't talk English. All we got to do is cry, because 'Don't talk Māori in school' We can't talk English- so all we do is cry. Yes for a long while. I can't talk English no matter what. I try, but the
  42. 42. 42 only thing I know is 'stomach.' Yes! I know that! Oh, yes, Sister Anne, Sister Dorothy, Sister Jessie and Mr Laughton and Mr Currie. He's hard, very hard. No bloody humbug! A cousin of mine- we are all sitting on the floor, singing, and she was naughty. She did it on the floor. Because we don't know how to go outside! All we do is go like that [putting her hand up and point outside! And this girl she didn't like to say anything. She was sitting on her slate. She had her slate over it. We were just going to sing and I was going like that- pointing to her. Mr Currie gave me a good hiding, supple jack, eh across my back. He was a murdering thing! And Mr Laughton didn't like it. He knew, because I don't know how to say outside (pp. 150-165). What people like George Graham and Putiputi Onekawa emphasise are some of the more dire consequences that have had detrimental impacts on Māori youth who were initially subjected to the Child Welfare system and the Native Lands Act 1867. While there are not indicators in the timetable charts to suggest intergenerational implications, Waitangi Tribunal statistics highlight that in 1905, 95 per cent of Māori spoke their native language. By 1981 only 5 per cent of Māori spoke their native language. (Waitangi Tribunal, 1986). 2.7 Indicators for Māori Counselling The emphasis from a Māori counselling perspective behind identifying impacts of historical trauma stem from wanting to examine deficit statistics for Māori in New Zealand society regarding health, education, intergenerational impoverishment, high statistics regarding the amount of Māori who are entrenched over generations within the courts system, the prison system, as well as deficit statistics ingrained in the unemployment benefit system. Western dominant discourses are very quick to highlight and expose Māori deficit statistics however, on the other hand seem to lack an ability to provide a suitable rationale. The indicators that stem from Western dominant discourses suggest it is the flaw of those stuck in such a predicament. Another significant factor highlights a legacy from the Doctrine of Discovery that still spills over into modern day North America. Chief Oren Lyons (2010) told a story in a video presentation of how New York State wanting First Nations peoples to pay taxes on their tribal land. The tribe took the state to court stating that they were the original owners of the land and therefore under customary title did not have to pay rates. While the First Nations won their day in court on appeal the Supreme Court,
  43. 43. 43 over turned the decision due to Papal Bull Decree 1493 Terra Nullus. Under that Papal Bull decree the pope of the time declared America empty land due to the First Nations not being Christian. The pope went on to declare that as a result of First Nations being non-Christians, they did not have right of title to land. The Supreme Court took their position from the Doctrine of Discovery and upheld their decision under the jurisprudence of the Doctrine of Discovery 2007. The US Supreme Court's use of the Doctrine of Discovery as case law in modern times as a means for overturning a High Court's decision seems incomprehensible. It reveals that Western dominant discourses will continue to advantageously position themselves to make assumptions that undermine Indigenous perspectives from a perceived position of authority. The impact of the US Supreme Court's decision to declare that First Nations peoples had their customary title and human rights wavered under the jurisprudence of the Doctrine of Discovery due to being non- Christian reveals huge indicators. This means the First Nations peoples of America have been subjugated to inferior positions of being non-human. The inference suggests that a non-human position is similar to a horse, possession or any other chattel. This poses a question that assumes that paying tax is a fundamental human right. The question posed is, "how can non human's be subjected to tax?". Other indicators for Māori counselling practitioners suggest two points. The first point identifies that historical intergenerational trauma has an international scope that affects Indigenous peoples right across the world. What this emphasises, is that international Indigenous issues need international Indigenous solutions. The United Nations Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples document is one tool that is being utilised by Indigenous peoples across the globe that has begun addressing legacies of the Doctrine of Discovery. The second point recognises that gaining knowledge of underpinnings that have contributed to Māori experiences of historical intergenerational trauma may support Māori counsellors to be effective practitioners with their whānau / clientele due to having an understanding of some of the historical complexities that underpin working with Māori.
  44. 44. 44 Conclusion In this chapter we reviewed the relevant literature that introduced and defined historical intergenerational trauma. The second aspect discussed a series of historical catalysts that initiated historical intergenerational trauma on a global scale. It also identified legacies and policy making organizations and religious sects responsible for these traumatic incidents that had devastating social, political and economic impacts on Indigenous peoples. The third aspect discussed in this chapter identified examples of prejudicial policies. The fourth aspect discussed influences on health and wellbeing. The final aspect discussed indicators for Māori counselling. This literature review highlights three points about historical intergenerational trauma. The first point is that historical intergenerational trauma did not establish itself out of ‘thin air’, but was established as a result of a genealogy and legacy that impacts and invisibly interweaves itself across intergenerational timelines, creating dire health issues for future generations. The next significant point highlights that Indigenous peoples throughout the world never, in any way, shape or form consented to relinquishing land and resources or be subjected to trauma. What is also significant is that Western dominant discourses have been breaching and breaking their own international laws and standards for centuries to suit neo liberal capitalist agendas. For centuries Indigenous cultures have been seeking redress through judicial systems whose practices under both national and international law were constructed by the very organizations that imposed the Doctrine of Discovery. As a result moves towards Indigenous liberation and social justice strategies have been developed and applied in response to colonising practices.
  45. 45. 45
  46. 46. 46 Chapter Three Māhere Rautaki Rangāhau- Research Methodologies and Methods Introduction This chapter examines the methodology of this research explaining how the research combines the pūrākau or story-telling techniques and other Indigenous theoretical frameworks with Western critical theory. The chapter begins with a summary of the literature review. The second aspect introduces the research questions with a hypothesis from the literature. The third aspect examines the research plan including the aims, objectives, theories (theoretical perspectives) and methods. The fourth aspect focuses upon the research participants. The fifth aspect examines the data gathering and collating process. The sixth aspect looks at changes and implications. The seventh aspect provides an analysis of the data. Literature Review Summary The literature review introduced and defined historical intergenerational trauma. It discussed a series of historical catalysts that implemented policies and practices that globally resulted in historical intergenerational trauma across Indigenous cultures. It identified legacies that stemmed from policy making organisations and religious sects that had devastating social, political and economic impacts on Indigenous peoples. The literature review also identified examples of prejudicial policies, and their role in influencing disparaging health and wellbeing statistics. A significant element stemming from the literature review identified that while literature on historical intergenerational trauma is well documented amongst Native Americans, Native Hawaiians, Native Australians, Native Canadians and other Indigenous cultures across the globe, there is limited evidence in academia of Māori literature describing Māori experiences of historical intergenerational trauma. Māori authors such as Moana Jackson and Ranginui Walker tended to language the concept of historical intergenerational trauma in a manner that differed from other Indigenous academic authors. One of the reasons for confusion is due to multiple terminologies that are used to describe this phenomenon. Walters, et al, (2011) argues that Historical trauma is limited, in part because the expression itself has been used interchangeably with other terms such as soul wound, collective unresolved grief, collective trauma, intergenerational trauma, trans-
  47. 47. 47 generational trauma, intergenerational post-traumatic stress and multigenerational trauma." (p. 182). What Walters et al (2011) reveals is that although multiple terminologies differ across Indigenous cultures globally, the outcomes stemming from those terminologies across the Indigenous globe are similar. Further analysis led to pondering the difference between Indigenous and Māori experiences of historical intergenerational trauma. The literature review gave examples of historical intergenerational trauma and its impacts as stressed by numerous Indigenous academic authors globally. It also revealed gaps in Māori academic literature that refer specifically to Māori experiences of historical intergenerational trauma As a result, the first research question asks: “What are Māori experiences of historical intergenerational trauma?” This gives emphasis to identify and explore historical contexts pre-colonisation to ascertain what the environment was like in Aotearoa/ New Zealand before the British came. The rationale for examining what the Māori world was like prior to colonisation, and then to compare how the socio political and economic was shaped across generations. This research question also examines how Māori responded to the influx and impact of settlers residing in New Zealand, as well as its implications. The second research question asks: "What were the political, socio- economic implications for Māori both pre and post signing of Te Tiriti o Waitangi?". This enables the research to examine a macro view that explores the political and socio economic effects both pre and post Te Tiriti o Waitangi. The third research question asks: "What significance does locating self in this research have in terms of investigating Māori experiences of historical intergenerational trauma?” This question gives a micro view that contextualises how the implications of historical intergenerational trauma have a personal impact. The fourth question asks: "What are Māori strategies that respond to this phenomenon?” This question supports the development of a Māori counselling framework that deconstructs the impact of historical intergenerational trauma to critically analyse intergenerational layers in a Māori whānau or clientele's life for the purpose of making sense of extenuating circumstances that impede their health and
  48. 48. 48 wellbeing. It also develops strategies that put in parameters to stop residue of trauma spilling over into the next generation. Research Plan The aim of this research is to examine and explore Māori experiences of historical intergenerational trauma from three positions. The first position investigates Māori autonomy and success pre Te Tiriti o Waitangi. The second position investigates Māori autonomy post Te Tiriti o Waitangi examining a macro systemic viewpoint of impacts that have intergenerational implications for Māori in contemporary New Zealand. The third position gives a micro systematic view that contextualises intergenerational impacts by presenting a personal account of historical intergenerational trauma. 3.1 Objectives The objective for researching historical intergenerational trauma will be done using the pre-colonial approach, the post-colonial approach, and the locating self in research approach. This will give a historical context that gives wider scope to the broader implications for Māori pre-colonially. The post Te Tiriti o Waitangi approach will give a general overview of the impacts and its effects on Māori. The locating self in research approach will give a micro view that contextualises historical intergenerational trauma at a personal level. The pre-colonial approach will examine how Māori established their authority in New Zealand pre-colonial. It will also examine international relationships with the British Empire, and explore Māori international trade, as well as examine how the Māori trading flag became internationally recognised. It will also examine how Māori established their sovereignty becoming internationally recognised as an independent nation making its own decisions. The post-colonial approach will also examine its entrepreneurial success in building a strong Māori political as well as socio economic base that thrived across New Zealand. The post-colonial approach will give a general overview of Te Tiriti o Waitangi in terms of assurances versus intentions. It will examine the New Zealand Settler
  49. 49. 49 Governments quest for power and control highlighting some of the mechanisms involved that include legislative violations and war. The post-colonial approach also examines the impacts of these mechanisms on Māori in terms of Māori words, Māori expressions, Māori transmissions and Māori experiences of historical intergenerational trauma that are manifesting in health disparities and Māori deficit statistics in contemporary New Zealand society. The locating self in research approach examines how Māori experiences of historical intergenerational trauma are contextualised at a personal level with a view to understand both historical and future implications. The use of these three approaches creates space to identify and define historical intergenerational trauma, and then formulate a solution based approach for future generations. The solution based approach leads to the fourth research question "What are Māori counselling strategies that respond to this phenomenon?" examining Māori counselling strategies that respond to this phenomenon will be implemented as an approach in the final chapter in the form of a solution based idea whose underlying themes stem from a Māori worldview. Another central focus of this research plan follows qualitative research using an epistemology approach. An epistemology approach refers to the use of ways of knowing as a means for collecting data. Sheridan (2010) in a video presentation describes epistemology as an interpretivism method that is explorative and contains strategies like observations. While it can be debated that an epistemology approach does not have strategies based on hypothesis like quantitative research does, the critical analysis of interpreted observations is also a valid research method for collecting data. Badewi (2013) in a video presentation describes interpretivism by suggesting there is no one single reality, but multiple realities, so what interpretivism does is advocate the need to understand different contexts, and characters. Further consideration suggests that a descriptive approach to engaging with others and describing what they have observed can be defined as qualitative research. Although qualitative research is the dominant method for collecting data in this thesis, there is also statistical data based on quantitative research that supports this thesis.
  50. 50. 50 Theoretical Perspectives This part of the thesis focuses on three research methodologies. The first methodology employed is Pūrākau theory from the work of Dr. Jenny Lee. The second methodology is critical theory which is derived from the work of Karl Marx, and the final methodology is Indigenous methodologies from the works of Dr. Linda Tuhiwai Smith. 3.2 Pūrākau Theory The ‘Pūrākau theory,’ as a methodology is employed in this research because of its ability to layer stories one upon the other. Pūrākau is used in a variety of ways, and is a fundamental methodology for distributing knowledge, values, protocols and worldviews. Lee (2005, p.7) states that "it is one form of Māori narratives that originates from our oral literature traditions. Other narrative forms include moteatea (traditional song), whakapapa (genealogy) whaikōrero (speech making) and whakatauki (proverbs) each with their own categories, style, complex patterns and characteristics" (p.7). Pūrākau has been used traditionally as a means to connect back to tupuna (ancestors) in a manner that gave scope to the way in which they saw the world. Lee (2005) contends that "the reclamation of Pūrākau as a valid research method is part of a wider movement by Indigenous people to advance decolonizing methodologies (As cited in Smith, 1999, p.2), "in which cultural regeneration forms a cultural part of our education goals". Lee (2005) also discusses the importance of Pūrākau being emphasised in Māori language. It is not coincidental that the word Pūrākau literally refers to the roots or base (Pū) of the tree (rākau), rather it is significant that 'story telling' derives its meaning in Māori language from words that relate to the tree and bush, since the imagery of tree often reflect our cultural understandings of social relationships, our interconnectedness with each other and the natural environment (p.7). A major factor for using a Pūrākau approach as a methodology is that its very nature is founded in Māori epistemologies that layers and interconnects stories in a way that differs significantly to Western epistemologies. Pūrākau interconnects intergenerationally in a manner that suggests a time-line interweaving Pūrākau stories of tupuna throughout the continual history of its descendants flowing on into the future. While recognising that each his/story or her/story is inter dependant,

×