The document provides a rubric for evaluating descriptive texts on 5 criteria: developing ideas, organizing ideas, grammar, vocabulary, and mechanics. Each criteria is scored on a scale of 1 to 5, with 5 being the highest score. A total score is calculated by adding the scores from each category, with scores ranging from weak (1-5 points), poor (6-11 points), good (12-16 points), satisfactory (17-21 points), to excellent (22-25 points). The rubric is then used to evaluate 4 sample texts, with total scores ranging from 10 to 25 points.

1. PUTRI FIRA NURUL HANIFAH
NIM. 4103 2122 12 1029
Developing
ideas
5 The descriptive text gives paragraph unity (topic, state good topic sentence,
supporting sentence, concluding sentence) and coherence (relationship among
ideas, understandable). It fulfill all criteria well
4 The descriptive text give paragraph unity (topic, state good topic sentence) but
one of the criteria is weak.
3 The descriptive text give paragraph unity (topic, state topic sentence,
conclusion of topic sentence) but some criteria above are weak
2 The descriptive text give paragraph unity (topic, state topic sentence) but most
criteria above are weak
1 The descriptive text still give topic but all criteria are weak
Organizing
ideas
5 The descriptive text is coherence and the coherences are correct. The text is
using chronological order. The descriptive text repeats key words.
4 The descriptive text is coherence and the coherences are correct. The text using
chronological order
3 The descriptive text is coherence and some criteria are appropriate enough
2 The descriptive text is coherence but the coherences among sentences are weak
1 The descriptive text is not coherence
Grammar
5 Use present tense correctly, use relational verb and adjective words correctly
4 Use present tense, use relational verb but do not use adjective words correctly
3 Make errors of tenses, use relational words and use adjective words
2 Make errors of tenses, do not use relational verbs correctly, and use adjective
words
1 Make errors of tenses, relational verbs and adjective words
Vocabulary
5 All or almost all of the descriptive text words are use effectively
4 Use many descriptive words effectively
3 Use some descriptive words
2 There are some mistakes in using descriptive words
1 Do not use the descriptive words correctly
Mechanics
5 The descriptive text uses correct punctuation, spelling and capitalization. It
fulfill all criteria
4 The descriptive text uses correct punctuation, spelling but fairly capitalization
but one of the criteria is weak
3 The descriptive text punctuation uses fairly punctuation but loosely correct
spelling and capitalization. Some criteria are weak
2 The descriptive text uses fairly punctuation but inadequate correct spelling and
capitalization. Most criteria are weak
1 The descriptive text do not use correct punctuation, spelling and capitalization.

2. Kategori :
1 – 5 = Weak
6 – 11 = Poor
12 – 16 = Good
17 – 21 = Satisfactory
22 – 25 = Excellent
No Nomor
Induk
Nama Skor
Developing
Ideas
Organizing
Ideas
Grammar Vocabulary Mechanics
Total
1. 1021 Arsy 5 5 5 5 5 25
2. 1022 Arna 4 5 3 2 2 16
3. 1023 Adara 4 4 2 3 2 15
4. 1024 Bambang 3 2 2 1 2 10