SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 9
Pricing Digital Arts and Culture through
PWYW Strategies:
A Reconsideration of the Ricardian
Theory of Value
By Racquel Antoun-Nakhle, Nizar Hariri &
Rim Haidar
The 5th International Conference on Digital Economy
Pay What You Want (PWYW) Participative
Pricing strategy
“Pay What You Want” (PWYW)
participative pricing strategy
New ways to
personalize &
differentiate
products
Expansion of
digital
markets of
arts
Irrelevance of traditional valuation
models in the era of digital distribution of
arts
Neoclassical &
Ricardian theories
Reproducible &
emotionally
valuable digital
arts
Pricing strategies based on customers’
value in use: A suitable solution
Why do consumers
pay a positive price for
a product they could
acquire for free?
The consumer may
value his relationship
with the supplier
The consumer may
perceive the supplier’s
offer as an act of
generosity and will act
out of reciprocation to
“reward” the supplier
for his kind behavior
The consumer may pay
fairly in order to ensure
the perpetuation of the
supplier’s offer
A Framework Suggestion:
The ArtFairPay
The E-
supplier
offers many
products
online
The consumer
chooses the
product that
suits him the
most
In a dialog-box,
the consumer
chooses the
price he would
like to pay
Based on other
consumers’
feedbacks, e-
suppliers
determine a
fair-price they
don’t reveal to
the consumers
Server displays
automatically a
probability of
fairness
depending on
the fair price
estimated by
the e-supplier
The supplier
rewards consumers
which behavior is
qualified as “high-
fair” after several
purchases
The supplier
assesses the
consumer’s
behavior
Nudging the consumer
The E-
supplier
offers many
products
online
The consumer
chooses the
product that
suits him the
most
In a dialog-box,
the consumer
chooses the
price he would
like to pay
Based on other
consumers’
feedbacks, e-
suppliers
determine a
fair-price they
don’t reveal to
the consumers
Server displays
automatically a
probability of
fairness
depending on
the fair price
estimated by
the e-supplier
Thank you!

More Related Content

Similar to Icdec2020_presentation_slides_8

Fundamental Of Marketing For Orientation
Fundamental Of Marketing For OrientationFundamental Of Marketing For Orientation
Fundamental Of Marketing For Orientation
Holostik India Ltd.
 
BUILDING AND SUSTAINING RELATIONSHIPS IN RETAILING.pptx
BUILDING AND SUSTAINING RELATIONSHIPS IN RETAILING.pptxBUILDING AND SUSTAINING RELATIONSHIPS IN RETAILING.pptx
BUILDING AND SUSTAINING RELATIONSHIPS IN RETAILING.pptx
henrysiy2
 
Introduction to Marketing By Philp Kotler Lecture No 1.0
Introduction to Marketing By Philp Kotler Lecture No 1.0Introduction to Marketing By Philp Kotler Lecture No 1.0
Introduction to Marketing By Philp Kotler Lecture No 1.0
Khurshid Swati
 
Digibites_Team PPT
Digibites_Team PPTDigibites_Team PPT
Digibites_Team PPT
pavikasin
 
L1 introduction to marketing mm i
L1   introduction to marketing mm iL1   introduction to marketing mm i
L1 introduction to marketing mm i
Kinshook Chaturvedi
 
Marketing management 01
Marketing management 01Marketing management 01
Marketing management 01
rambo004
 

Similar to Icdec2020_presentation_slides_8 (20)

Young Marketers 8 Final Round - DatingExperts
Young Marketers 8 Final Round - DatingExpertsYoung Marketers 8 Final Round - DatingExperts
Young Marketers 8 Final Round - DatingExperts
 
Fundamental Of Marketing For Orientation
Fundamental Of Marketing For OrientationFundamental Of Marketing For Orientation
Fundamental Of Marketing For Orientation
 
Value Oriented Marketing
Value Oriented Marketing Value Oriented Marketing
Value Oriented Marketing
 
The Money Mob - Lean Startup Machine
The Money Mob - Lean Startup MachineThe Money Mob - Lean Startup Machine
The Money Mob - Lean Startup Machine
 
Economy of One
Economy of OneEconomy of One
Economy of One
 
Udig4
Udig4Udig4
Udig4
 
EBP 1014 Ch. 01
EBP 1014 Ch. 01EBP 1014 Ch. 01
EBP 1014 Ch. 01
 
BUILDING AND SUSTAINING RELATIONSHIPS IN RETAILING.pptx
BUILDING AND SUSTAINING RELATIONSHIPS IN RETAILING.pptxBUILDING AND SUSTAINING RELATIONSHIPS IN RETAILING.pptx
BUILDING AND SUSTAINING RELATIONSHIPS IN RETAILING.pptx
 
Introduction to Marketing By Philp Kotler Lecture No 1.0
Introduction to Marketing By Philp Kotler Lecture No 1.0Introduction to Marketing By Philp Kotler Lecture No 1.0
Introduction to Marketing By Philp Kotler Lecture No 1.0
 
Digibites_Team PPT
Digibites_Team PPTDigibites_Team PPT
Digibites_Team PPT
 
Montenegro, markman chapter 14
Montenegro, markman chapter 14Montenegro, markman chapter 14
Montenegro, markman chapter 14
 
L1 introduction to marketing mm i
L1   introduction to marketing mm iL1   introduction to marketing mm i
L1 introduction to marketing mm i
 
Introduction to marketing
Introduction to marketingIntroduction to marketing
Introduction to marketing
 
Services marketing mix - product, price, place, promotion
Services marketing mix - product, price, place, promotionServices marketing mix - product, price, place, promotion
Services marketing mix - product, price, place, promotion
 
"Product Pricing strategy" @ the 11th Prod.active meetup
"Product Pricing strategy" @ the 11th Prod.active meetup"Product Pricing strategy" @ the 11th Prod.active meetup
"Product Pricing strategy" @ the 11th Prod.active meetup
 
Lesson 1_Powerpoint material.pdf
Lesson 1_Powerpoint material.pdfLesson 1_Powerpoint material.pdf
Lesson 1_Powerpoint material.pdf
 
Evolution of luxury retailers in disruptive Omni-channel world
Evolution of luxury retailers in disruptive Omni-channel worldEvolution of luxury retailers in disruptive Omni-channel world
Evolution of luxury retailers in disruptive Omni-channel world
 
Reisman FairPay Overview -- Adaptive Win-Win Relationships / Revenue Strategy...
Reisman FairPay Overview -- Adaptive Win-Win Relationships / Revenue Strategy...Reisman FairPay Overview -- Adaptive Win-Win Relationships / Revenue Strategy...
Reisman FairPay Overview -- Adaptive Win-Win Relationships / Revenue Strategy...
 
Reisman FairPay Overview -- Adaptively Win-Win Relationships / Revenue Strate...
Reisman FairPay Overview -- Adaptively Win-Win Relationships / Revenue Strate...Reisman FairPay Overview -- Adaptively Win-Win Relationships / Revenue Strate...
Reisman FairPay Overview -- Adaptively Win-Win Relationships / Revenue Strate...
 
Marketing management 01
Marketing management 01Marketing management 01
Marketing management 01
 

More from ICDEcCnferenece

More from ICDEcCnferenece (20)

Total Experience. How to create user-focused digital products that accelerate...
Total Experience. How to create user-focused digital products that accelerate...Total Experience. How to create user-focused digital products that accelerate...
Total Experience. How to create user-focused digital products that accelerate...
 
Two faces of the same coin: Exploring the multilateral perspective of informa...
Two faces of the same coin: Exploring the multilateral perspective of informa...Two faces of the same coin: Exploring the multilateral perspective of informa...
Two faces of the same coin: Exploring the multilateral perspective of informa...
 
Spreading the Word on the Digital Economy
Spreading the Word on the Digital EconomySpreading the Word on the Digital Economy
Spreading the Word on the Digital Economy
 
Readiness of Russian companies for digital transformation: what's changed?
Readiness of Russian companies for digital transformation: what's changed?Readiness of Russian companies for digital transformation: what's changed?
Readiness of Russian companies for digital transformation: what's changed?
 
Possibilities and limitations of the Croatian police in communication via soc...
Possibilities and limitations of the Croatian police in communication via soc...Possibilities and limitations of the Croatian police in communication via soc...
Possibilities and limitations of the Croatian police in communication via soc...
 
Changes in Global Virtual Team Conflict Over Time: The Role of Openness to Li...
Changes in Global Virtual Team Conflict Over Time: The Role of Openness to Li...Changes in Global Virtual Team Conflict Over Time: The Role of Openness to Li...
Changes in Global Virtual Team Conflict Over Time: The Role of Openness to Li...
 
Cause-related marketing: towards an exploration of the factors favoring the p...
Cause-related marketing: towards an exploration of the factors favoring the p...Cause-related marketing: towards an exploration of the factors favoring the p...
Cause-related marketing: towards an exploration of the factors favoring the p...
 
Relationship between culture and user's behavior in the context of informatio...
Relationship between culture and user's behavior in the context of informatio...Relationship between culture and user's behavior in the context of informatio...
Relationship between culture and user's behavior in the context of informatio...
 
Examining the Impact of Digitalization on Unemployment rate During COVID-19 P...
Examining the Impact of Digitalization on Unemployment rate During COVID-19 P...Examining the Impact of Digitalization on Unemployment rate During COVID-19 P...
Examining the Impact of Digitalization on Unemployment rate During COVID-19 P...
 
Success Factors for the Use of Open Educational Resources - A Quantitative Su...
Success Factors for the Use of Open Educational Resources - A Quantitative Su...Success Factors for the Use of Open Educational Resources - A Quantitative Su...
Success Factors for the Use of Open Educational Resources - A Quantitative Su...
 
A Maturity Model for Open Educational Resources in Higher Education Instituti...
A Maturity Model for Open Educational Resources in Higher Education Instituti...A Maturity Model for Open Educational Resources in Higher Education Instituti...
A Maturity Model for Open Educational Resources in Higher Education Instituti...
 
AI-based Business Models in Healthcare: An Empirical Study of Clinical Decisi...
AI-based Business Models in Healthcare: An Empirical Study of Clinical Decisi...AI-based Business Models in Healthcare: An Empirical Study of Clinical Decisi...
AI-based Business Models in Healthcare: An Empirical Study of Clinical Decisi...
 
Towards a better digital transformation: learning from the experience of a di...
Towards a better digital transformation: learning from the experience of a di...Towards a better digital transformation: learning from the experience of a di...
Towards a better digital transformation: learning from the experience of a di...
 
Digital Gender Gap in EU-27 ICT Employment During COVID-19 Impact
Digital Gender Gap in EU-27 ICT Employment During COVID-19 ImpactDigital Gender Gap in EU-27 ICT Employment During COVID-19 Impact
Digital Gender Gap in EU-27 ICT Employment During COVID-19 Impact
 
Consumer Satisfaction using fitness technology innovation
Consumer Satisfaction using fitness technology innovationConsumer Satisfaction using fitness technology innovation
Consumer Satisfaction using fitness technology innovation
 
Implementing an agile change process to improve digital transformation in hig...
Implementing an agile change process to improve digital transformation in hig...Implementing an agile change process to improve digital transformation in hig...
Implementing an agile change process to improve digital transformation in hig...
 
What leads customer to create and participate in anti-brand community: a netn...
What leads customer to create and participate in anti-brand community: a netn...What leads customer to create and participate in anti-brand community: a netn...
What leads customer to create and participate in anti-brand community: a netn...
 
Closing session: awards for best papers and reviewers
Closing session: awards for best papers and  reviewersClosing session: awards for best papers and  reviewers
Closing session: awards for best papers and reviewers
 
Transition to Tertiary Education and eLearning in Lebanon against the backdro...
Transition to Tertiary Education and eLearning in Lebanon against the backdro...Transition to Tertiary Education and eLearning in Lebanon against the backdro...
Transition to Tertiary Education and eLearning in Lebanon against the backdro...
 
Internet of Things healthcare system for reducing economic burden
Internet of Things healthcare system for reducing economic burdenInternet of Things healthcare system for reducing economic burden
Internet of Things healthcare system for reducing economic burden
 

Recently uploaded

FULL NIGHT — 9999894380 Call Girls In Delhi | Delhi
FULL NIGHT — 9999894380 Call Girls In Delhi | DelhiFULL NIGHT — 9999894380 Call Girls In Delhi | Delhi
FULL NIGHT — 9999894380 Call Girls In Delhi | Delhi
SaketCallGirlsCallUs
 
FULL NIGHT — 9999894380 Call Girls In Badarpur | Delhi
FULL NIGHT — 9999894380 Call Girls In Badarpur | DelhiFULL NIGHT — 9999894380 Call Girls In Badarpur | Delhi
FULL NIGHT — 9999894380 Call Girls In Badarpur | Delhi
SaketCallGirlsCallUs
 
Dubai Call Girls # 00971547881831 # Indian Call Girls In Dubai # (UAE)
Dubai Call Girls # 00971547881831 # Indian Call Girls In Dubai # (UAE)Dubai Call Girls # 00971547881831 # Indian Call Girls In Dubai # (UAE)
Dubai Call Girls # 00971547881831 # Indian Call Girls In Dubai # (UAE)
Business Bay Call Girls || 0529877582 || Call Girls Service in Business Bay Dubai
 
FULL NIGHT — 9999894380 Call Girls In Delhi Cantt | Delhi
FULL NIGHT — 9999894380 Call Girls In Delhi Cantt | DelhiFULL NIGHT — 9999894380 Call Girls In Delhi Cantt | Delhi
FULL NIGHT — 9999894380 Call Girls In Delhi Cantt | Delhi
SaketCallGirlsCallUs
 
FULL NIGHT — 9999894380 Call Girls In Uttam Nagar | Delhi
FULL NIGHT — 9999894380 Call Girls In Uttam Nagar | DelhiFULL NIGHT — 9999894380 Call Girls In Uttam Nagar | Delhi
FULL NIGHT — 9999894380 Call Girls In Uttam Nagar | Delhi
SaketCallGirlsCallUs
 
Dubai Call Girl Number # 0522916705 # Call Girl Number In Dubai # (UAE)
Dubai Call Girl Number # 0522916705 # Call Girl Number In Dubai # (UAE)Dubai Call Girl Number # 0522916705 # Call Girl Number In Dubai # (UAE)
Dubai Call Girl Number # 0522916705 # Call Girl Number In Dubai # (UAE)
Business Bay Call Girls || 0529877582 || Call Girls Service in Business Bay Dubai
 
Bobbie goods coloring book 81 pag_240127_163802.pdf
Bobbie goods coloring book 81 pag_240127_163802.pdfBobbie goods coloring book 81 pag_240127_163802.pdf
Bobbie goods coloring book 81 pag_240127_163802.pdf
MARIBEL442158
 
Authentic # 00971556872006 # Hot Call Girls Service in Dubai By International...
Authentic # 00971556872006 # Hot Call Girls Service in Dubai By International...Authentic # 00971556872006 # Hot Call Girls Service in Dubai By International...
Authentic # 00971556872006 # Hot Call Girls Service in Dubai By International...
home
 
Museum of fine arts Lauren Simpson…………..
Museum of fine arts Lauren Simpson…………..Museum of fine arts Lauren Simpson…………..
Museum of fine arts Lauren Simpson…………..
mvxpw22gfc
 
FULL NIGHT — 9999894380 Call Girls In New Ashok Nagar | Delhi
FULL NIGHT — 9999894380 Call Girls In New Ashok Nagar | DelhiFULL NIGHT — 9999894380 Call Girls In New Ashok Nagar | Delhi
FULL NIGHT — 9999894380 Call Girls In New Ashok Nagar | Delhi
SaketCallGirlsCallUs
 
DELHI NCR —@9711106444 Call Girls In Majnu Ka Tilla (MT)| Delhi
DELHI NCR —@9711106444 Call Girls In Majnu Ka Tilla (MT)| DelhiDELHI NCR —@9711106444 Call Girls In Majnu Ka Tilla (MT)| Delhi
DELHI NCR —@9711106444 Call Girls In Majnu Ka Tilla (MT)| Delhi
delhimunirka444
 
FULL NIGHT — 9999894380 Call Girls In Kishangarh | Delhi
FULL NIGHT — 9999894380 Call Girls In Kishangarh | DelhiFULL NIGHT — 9999894380 Call Girls In Kishangarh | Delhi
FULL NIGHT — 9999894380 Call Girls In Kishangarh | Delhi
SaketCallGirlsCallUs
 

Recently uploaded (20)

FULL NIGHT — 9999894380 Call Girls In Delhi | Delhi
FULL NIGHT — 9999894380 Call Girls In Delhi | DelhiFULL NIGHT — 9999894380 Call Girls In Delhi | Delhi
FULL NIGHT — 9999894380 Call Girls In Delhi | Delhi
 
FULL NIGHT — 9999894380 Call Girls In Badarpur | Delhi
FULL NIGHT — 9999894380 Call Girls In Badarpur | DelhiFULL NIGHT — 9999894380 Call Girls In Badarpur | Delhi
FULL NIGHT — 9999894380 Call Girls In Badarpur | Delhi
 
Storyboard short: Ferrarius Tries to Sing
Storyboard short: Ferrarius Tries to SingStoryboard short: Ferrarius Tries to Sing
Storyboard short: Ferrarius Tries to Sing
 
❤Personal Whatsapp Srinagar Srinagar Call Girls 8617697112 💦✅.
❤Personal Whatsapp Srinagar Srinagar Call Girls 8617697112 💦✅.❤Personal Whatsapp Srinagar Srinagar Call Girls 8617697112 💦✅.
❤Personal Whatsapp Srinagar Srinagar Call Girls 8617697112 💦✅.
 
Dubai Call Girls # 00971547881831 # Indian Call Girls In Dubai # (UAE)
Dubai Call Girls # 00971547881831 # Indian Call Girls In Dubai # (UAE)Dubai Call Girls # 00971547881831 # Indian Call Girls In Dubai # (UAE)
Dubai Call Girls # 00971547881831 # Indian Call Girls In Dubai # (UAE)
 
Mayiladuthurai Call Girls 8617697112 Short 3000 Night 8000 Best call girls Se...
Mayiladuthurai Call Girls 8617697112 Short 3000 Night 8000 Best call girls Se...Mayiladuthurai Call Girls 8617697112 Short 3000 Night 8000 Best call girls Se...
Mayiladuthurai Call Girls 8617697112 Short 3000 Night 8000 Best call girls Se...
 
FULL NIGHT — 9999894380 Call Girls In Delhi Cantt | Delhi
FULL NIGHT — 9999894380 Call Girls In Delhi Cantt | DelhiFULL NIGHT — 9999894380 Call Girls In Delhi Cantt | Delhi
FULL NIGHT — 9999894380 Call Girls In Delhi Cantt | Delhi
 
FULL NIGHT — 9999894380 Call Girls In Uttam Nagar | Delhi
FULL NIGHT — 9999894380 Call Girls In Uttam Nagar | DelhiFULL NIGHT — 9999894380 Call Girls In Uttam Nagar | Delhi
FULL NIGHT — 9999894380 Call Girls In Uttam Nagar | Delhi
 
Dubai Call Girl Number # 0522916705 # Call Girl Number In Dubai # (UAE)
Dubai Call Girl Number # 0522916705 # Call Girl Number In Dubai # (UAE)Dubai Call Girl Number # 0522916705 # Call Girl Number In Dubai # (UAE)
Dubai Call Girl Number # 0522916705 # Call Girl Number In Dubai # (UAE)
 
VIP Ramnagar Call Girls, Ramnagar escorts Girls 📞 8617697112
VIP Ramnagar Call Girls, Ramnagar escorts Girls 📞 8617697112VIP Ramnagar Call Girls, Ramnagar escorts Girls 📞 8617697112
VIP Ramnagar Call Girls, Ramnagar escorts Girls 📞 8617697112
 
Bobbie goods coloring book 81 pag_240127_163802.pdf
Bobbie goods coloring book 81 pag_240127_163802.pdfBobbie goods coloring book 81 pag_240127_163802.pdf
Bobbie goods coloring book 81 pag_240127_163802.pdf
 
Call Girls Ludhiana Just Call 98765-12871 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
Call Girls Ludhiana Just Call 98765-12871 Top Class Call Girl Service AvailableCall Girls Ludhiana Just Call 98765-12871 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
Call Girls Ludhiana Just Call 98765-12871 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
 
(INDIRA) Call Girl Jammu Call Now 8617697112 Jammu Escorts 24x7
(INDIRA) Call Girl Jammu Call Now 8617697112 Jammu Escorts 24x7(INDIRA) Call Girl Jammu Call Now 8617697112 Jammu Escorts 24x7
(INDIRA) Call Girl Jammu Call Now 8617697112 Jammu Escorts 24x7
 
Authentic # 00971556872006 # Hot Call Girls Service in Dubai By International...
Authentic # 00971556872006 # Hot Call Girls Service in Dubai By International...Authentic # 00971556872006 # Hot Call Girls Service in Dubai By International...
Authentic # 00971556872006 # Hot Call Girls Service in Dubai By International...
 
Museum of fine arts Lauren Simpson…………..
Museum of fine arts Lauren Simpson…………..Museum of fine arts Lauren Simpson…………..
Museum of fine arts Lauren Simpson…………..
 
FULL NIGHT — 9999894380 Call Girls In New Ashok Nagar | Delhi
FULL NIGHT — 9999894380 Call Girls In New Ashok Nagar | DelhiFULL NIGHT — 9999894380 Call Girls In New Ashok Nagar | Delhi
FULL NIGHT — 9999894380 Call Girls In New Ashok Nagar | Delhi
 
DELHI NCR —@9711106444 Call Girls In Majnu Ka Tilla (MT)| Delhi
DELHI NCR —@9711106444 Call Girls In Majnu Ka Tilla (MT)| DelhiDELHI NCR —@9711106444 Call Girls In Majnu Ka Tilla (MT)| Delhi
DELHI NCR —@9711106444 Call Girls In Majnu Ka Tilla (MT)| Delhi
 
(INDIRA) Call Girl Dehradun Call Now 8617697112 Dehradun Escorts 24x7
(INDIRA) Call Girl Dehradun Call Now 8617697112 Dehradun Escorts 24x7(INDIRA) Call Girl Dehradun Call Now 8617697112 Dehradun Escorts 24x7
(INDIRA) Call Girl Dehradun Call Now 8617697112 Dehradun Escorts 24x7
 
(NEHA) Call Girls Mumbai Call Now 8250077686 Mumbai Escorts 24x7
(NEHA) Call Girls Mumbai Call Now 8250077686 Mumbai Escorts 24x7(NEHA) Call Girls Mumbai Call Now 8250077686 Mumbai Escorts 24x7
(NEHA) Call Girls Mumbai Call Now 8250077686 Mumbai Escorts 24x7
 
FULL NIGHT — 9999894380 Call Girls In Kishangarh | Delhi
FULL NIGHT — 9999894380 Call Girls In Kishangarh | DelhiFULL NIGHT — 9999894380 Call Girls In Kishangarh | Delhi
FULL NIGHT — 9999894380 Call Girls In Kishangarh | Delhi
 

Icdec2020_presentation_slides_8

  • 1. Pricing Digital Arts and Culture through PWYW Strategies: A Reconsideration of the Ricardian Theory of Value By Racquel Antoun-Nakhle, Nizar Hariri & Rim Haidar The 5th International Conference on Digital Economy
  • 2. Pay What You Want (PWYW) Participative Pricing strategy “Pay What You Want” (PWYW) participative pricing strategy New ways to personalize & differentiate products Expansion of digital markets of arts
  • 3. Irrelevance of traditional valuation models in the era of digital distribution of arts Neoclassical & Ricardian theories Reproducible & emotionally valuable digital arts
  • 4. Pricing strategies based on customers’ value in use: A suitable solution
  • 5. Why do consumers pay a positive price for a product they could acquire for free? The consumer may value his relationship with the supplier The consumer may perceive the supplier’s offer as an act of generosity and will act out of reciprocation to “reward” the supplier for his kind behavior The consumer may pay fairly in order to ensure the perpetuation of the supplier’s offer
  • 6. A Framework Suggestion: The ArtFairPay The E- supplier offers many products online The consumer chooses the product that suits him the most In a dialog-box, the consumer chooses the price he would like to pay Based on other consumers’ feedbacks, e- suppliers determine a fair-price they don’t reveal to the consumers Server displays automatically a probability of fairness depending on the fair price estimated by the e-supplier
  • 7. The supplier rewards consumers which behavior is qualified as “high- fair” after several purchases The supplier assesses the consumer’s behavior
  • 8. Nudging the consumer The E- supplier offers many products online The consumer chooses the product that suits him the most In a dialog-box, the consumer chooses the price he would like to pay Based on other consumers’ feedbacks, e- suppliers determine a fair-price they don’t reveal to the consumers Server displays automatically a probability of fairness depending on the fair price estimated by the e-supplier