Despite the efforts of many good dealers, a significant trust-gap still exists when it comes to the dealership appraisal process. In fact, recent research shows only 31% of consumers trust the trade-in value provided by the dealership. This session will explore how transparency in the appraisal process can help you build consumer confidence, acquire more vehicles, and improve your bottom line.
Rapple "Scholarly Communications and the Sustainable Development Goals"
Closing the Trust Gap: How Transparency in Trade Leads to Profit
1. Closing the Trust Gap in the Trade-in Process:
How transparency in the trade process leads to profitability
Kerri Wise
VP, Dealer Training and Industry
TrueCar
Title Sponsor
4. 4CONFIDENTIAL
Insights and best practices based on consumer and dealer research
• Online Mystery Shops
• Management Interviews
• Website review
• Focus Groups
• Survey Research
• Consumer Journey Diaries
6. CONFIDENTIAL
Despite the best efforts of many good dealers, a large “Trust Gap” still persists
2%
2%
4%
4%
9%
5%
5%
9%
7%
18%
9%
27%
30%
38%
34%
12%
15%
26%
30%
37%
42%
42%
40%
43%
38%
48%
46%
49%
42%
50%
Politicians
Used Car Dealers
New Car Dealers
Stock Broker
Journalists
Real Estate Agents
Home Repair Contractors
Lawyers
Auto Mechanics
Your Company's CEO
Bankers
Police Officers
Teachers
Airline Pilots
Doctors
Very Trusting
Somewhat Trusting
Level of Trust by Profession
84%
80%
79%
73%
57%
56%
50%
49%
47%
47%
46%
34%
30%
17%
14%
Source: YouGov Omnibus Study (April 2017)
n=1,165 US Adults; ”Your Company’s CEO” – n=561 US Adults.
In general how trusting, if at all, are you/would you be of information you receive from each of the following people?
7. 7CONFIDENTIAL
Consumer trust in trade-in values is low
Source: TrueCar Research
Diary; Total n=352; Buyers n=51; Non-Buyers n=301 Top Box: Completely/Somewhat Agree
Percent of consumers that trust each type of information given by dealers
Vehicle Information
73%
Financing Terms
45%
Asking Price
40%
Trade-in Values
31%
8. 8CONFIDENTIAL
Pain points in the dealer process solidify consumer distrust
Waste of Time
“Firstly, they were confused why I was there...
I drove a long way to visit them and it was a
waste of time”
Online Disconnect
“The people who contacted me from
dealerships knew nothing about my car that I
wanted to sell and the car I wanted to
buy...They were confused & lost.”
No Transparency
“They wouldn't give me a number over the
phone at all, they wanted me to drive all the
way out which is at least an hour. “
No Validation “I wasn’t sure if the offer the dealer provided
me for my vehicle was fair”
Sales Pressure “I specified that I was trying to sell my car
instead of trade in for another one.”
Source: TrueCar Research
9. 9CONFIDENTIAL
Family-Owned Dealer
#1 Sales Volume Leader
in Area
Buy car online
Prior purchase with Dealer
Pre-approved loan
before visit
Get monthly payment
before visit
Specific Contact
Person
Up-front
Trade-In Offer
Convenient Location
Good dealership
reviews
Knowing what
others paid
Up-front
Price
Incentives & Rebates
Large Inventory
Easy F&I
process
Preferred vehicle match
No Pressure
Experience
0%
5%
10%
15%
20%
25%
30%
35%
40%
45%
35% 45% 55% 65% 75% 85% 95%
Easy/DifficulttoFind
Importance to Consumer
Traditional dealership messaging fails to address the trust gap
• When thinking about your decision regarding which dealership(s) to visit, please tell us how important each of the following is to you when selecting a dealership.
• How difficult or easy was it to obtain the following information about dealerships?
Most Important/Hard to FindLeast Important/Hard to Find
Most Important/Easy to FindLeast Important/Easy to Find
10. 10CONFIDENTIAL
Consumers seek out 3rd party sites for independent info and validation
75%
23%
10%
6%
3rd Party Dealer Website Manufacturer Auto App
Website/App Consumers rely on for Trade-in values
Source: J.D. Power and Associates 2017 New Autoshopper study
“ Visited multiple car shopping
sites, as well as looking at
other people selling a similar
car privately with the same
mileage, and options and
things, and I just picked
somewhere in the middle.”
– Lesley W
11. 11
Dealers who can directly solve consumer pain
points in the trade/appraisal process have an
opportunity to differentiate themselves and
acquire cars at a competitive cost to market
14. 14CONFIDENTIAL
Many consumers want an upfront specific offer on their trade and are willing to
provide a high level of detail
Transaction
17 Digit VIN Color, Options, Mileage, Condition Offer
18. 18CONFIDENTIAL
Don’t forget the basics
5X
Faster in initial response
Respond Fast Customize the Response
32%
More likely to confirm the
trade-in vehicle details
Consistent Follow-up
30%
More follow-up attempts
What differentiates Top dealers?
28. 28CONFIDENTIAL
Sell the value of engaging further with you
“Our Shares Program is a unique, upfront, and transparent
way to have the customer self-discover and to get involved
in retailing of their car… This results in greater margins and
capture rates are over 70%.”
- TruWorth Auto
30. 30CONFIDENTIAL
Show them the value impacting options and condition that
affect the offer
Off Color, one key, and
above average mileage
Standard Color, two keys, and
below average mileage
32. 32CONFIDENTIAL
Avoid a “silent walk around” and involve the consumer
3X
More likely to provide
5-star rating when
given a side-by-side
appraisal
1.5X
More likely to trade or
sell their vehicle when
given a side-by-side
appraisal
47% 53%Yes No
Did Dealer Conduct a
Side-by-side Walk around?
Consumers that receive a
Side-by-side walk around
33. 33CONFIDENTIAL
Why does the consumer matter?
“If you’re competitor focused, you have
to wait until there is a competitor doing
something. Being customer focused
allows you to be more pioneering.”
Jeff Bezos
CEO, Amazon
A consumer first mentality will help you win in the long run
34. ENJOY THIS SESSION?
Post about it on social media using the hashtag #IS20G!
Share some love for your favorite speakers!
Title Sponsor
Contact Info:
Kerri Wise
VP, Dealer Training and Industry
TrueCar
kwise@truecar.com