SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 19
Download to read offline
03/09/2020 Topics in Communication System Design: Carrier Triple Beats
https://www.microwavejournal.com/articles/3377-topics-in-communication-system-design-carrier-triple-beats 1/19
Sign In
Subscribe
News
Channels
eLearning
Community
Events
Buyers Guide
Multimedia
Magazine
Home
About Us
Contact Us
Advertise With Us
Submit An Article
ERB Members
Reprints
Privacy
Microwave Journal
685 Canton St.
Norwood, MA 02062 USA
Tel: (781) 769-9750
Fax: (781) 769-5037
For magazine subscriptions and newsletter customer service:
Tel: 978-671-0449
Email: mwj@e-circ.net
Channels
5G/6G
Aerospace & Defense
Broadband
Cellular/4G/LTE
EMC/EMI
Industrial/Scientific/Medical
IoT/M2M/V2V
RFID/GPS/Location
RFIC
Software/EDA
Test & Measurement
eLearning
Acronyms List
Design Tools
eBook Library
History of Wireless
Microwave Basics
Webinars
White Papers
Community
Blogs
03/09/2020 Topics in Communication System Design: Carrier Triple Beats
https://www.microwavejournal.com/articles/3377-topics-in-communication-system-design-carrier-triple-beats 2/19
Classifieds Section
RF & Microwave LinkedIn Group
Facebook
Twitter
Instagram
Mobile App
Events
Webinars
Trade Shows
Training-User Meetings
IMS2020 Online Show Daily
European Microwave Week
EDI CON Online
EDI CON China
Multimedia
Videos
Podcasts
Photo Galleries
Magazine
Current Issue
Archives
Article Reprints
Subscribe
Subscription Renewal
We use cookies to provide you with a better experience. By continuing to browse the site you are agreeing to
our use of cookies in accordance with our Privacy Policy.
MWJ China
Sign In
Subscribe
Microwave Journal
News
Channels
03/09/2020 Topics in Communication System Design: Carrier Triple Beats
https://www.microwavejournal.com/articles/3377-topics-in-communication-system-design-carrier-triple-beats 3/19
5G/6G
Aerospace & Defense
Broadband
Cellular/4G/LTE
EMC/EMI
Industrial/Scientific/Medical
IoT/M2M/V2V
RFID/GPS/Location
RFIC
Software/EDA
Test & Measurement
eLearning
Acronyms List
Design Tools
eBook Library
History of Wireless
Microwave Basics
Webinars
White Papers
Community
Blogs
Classifieds Section
RF & Microwave LinkedIn Group
Facebook
Twitter
Instagram
Mobile App
Events
Webinars
Trade Shows
Training-User Meetings
IMS2020 Online Show Daily
European Microwave Week
EDI CON Online
EDI CON China
Buyers Guide
Multimedia
Videos
Podcasts
Photo Galleries
Magazine
Current Issue
Archives
Article Reprints
Subscribe
Subscription Renewal
Home » Topics in Communication System Design: Carrier Triple Beats
Industry News Semiconductors / Integrated Circuits
Topics in Communication System Design: Carrier Triple Beats
Analysis of carrier triple beats that create third-order
intermodulation interference when two or more carriers are present
in one channel
January 1, 2002
03/09/2020 Topics in Communication System Design: Carrier Triple Beats
https://www.microwavejournal.com/articles/3377-topics-in-communication-system-design-carrier-triple-beats 4/19
Howard Hausman
No Comments
Technical Feature
Topics in Communication System Design: Carrier Triple Beats
Related Resources
Cadence® AWR Design Environment® Version 15
CMTA Software for Signaling Testers MD8475A/B
Zero Bias Schottky Detector Diodes: SZB900 Series
Howard Hausman
Miteq Inc.
Hauppauge, NY
Intermodulation interference is typically calculated based on two signals present in the RF or IF bandwidth.
When the bandwidth is less than an octave, even-order intermodulation products, such as second- and fourth-
order intermodulation interference, are out of band and can be filtered out. Odd-order intermodulation, such as
third- and fifth-order products, are in-band interference, with sidebands as close to the carrier as the spacing of
the desired carriers. In general, these signals cannot be filtered and must be dealt with by linearizing the system
such that the interference is suppressed below the desired dynamic range. Third-order intermodulation, which is
created by the mixing of the fundamental of one signal and the second harmonic of the other signal, is usually
higher in amplitude than the fifth-order intermodulation product and therefore of primary concern to the system
designer.
When more than two carriers are present in a channel, third-order intermodulation interference can be created
by the multiplication of three fundamental carriers; this is called carrier triple beats (CTB). These spurious
signals (CTB) are in-band at a level 6 dB higher than the third-order intermodulation products created from two
signals because there is no second harmonic involved in the production of the interference signal. The level of
CTB interference is further enhanced by the fact that multiple CTB signals can occur in the same frequency
band. The number of interference signals that can be superimposed on any particular channel is related to the
number of desired carriers present. Statistically, more CTB interference occurs in the center of the band.
Determining Intermodulation Interference Levels
CTB interference is a spurious signal created from the interaction of three or more signals summed together in a
nonlinear device. The level of the interference signal is related to the levels of the input signals and the
nonlinearity of the device. In designing a system, the required operating signal levels and the respective
acceptable spurious levels determine the acceptable nonlinearity of the equipment. Given the system's nonlinear
characteristics, the acceptable spurious level and the output level of the carriers, the maximum number of
carriers can be determined.
To determine the maximum operating signal, the nonlinear characteristics of the components are defined and the
resultant spurious responses are evaluated. The same analysis is performed in reverse to define the acceptable
nonlinearity given an operating signal range. A generalized nonlinear system can be represented by a Taylor
series expansion of the nonlinear transfer characteristic.
So = a0 + a1 Si + a2 Si
2 + a3 Si
3 + a4 Si
4 + … (1)
where
So = output signal
Si = input signal
an = coefficients of the device
(n = 0, 1, 2, 3, 4, …)
03/09/2020 Topics in Communication System Design: Carrier Triple Beats
https://www.microwavejournal.com/articles/3377-topics-in-communication-system-design-carrier-triple-beats 5/19
For a linear system
an = 0 for n > 1
If the device is AC coupled
a0 = 0
If Si consists of three signals of equal amplitude, then
Si = E1cos(w1 t) + E1cos(w2 t) + E1cos(w3 t)
where
E1 = peak amplitude
w1, w2 and w3 = respective radian frequencies
When Si is applied to a nonlinear system, intermodulation products are created in all the higher order terms,
proportional to the coefficients of the respective term.
Second-order Intermodulation of CTB
The second-order intermodulation product of three in-band signals is usually almost an octave away from the
desired carriers. In a narrow band system, these signals can easily be filtered and are therefore not considered in
the spurious analysis. Appendix A is a detailed derivation of the resultant spectrum of the second-order
intermodulation from three in-band signals.
The second-order intermodulation term is expressed as
Second-order Intermodulation
=2nd order=
a2 Si
2 = a2 [E1cos(w1 t) + E1cos(w2 t) + E1cos(w3 t)]2
Expanding the terms
2nd order =
a2 {[E1cos(w1 t)]2 + [E1cos(w2 t)]2
+ [E1cos(w3 t)]2 + 2[E1cos(w1 t)
· E1cos(w2 t)] + 2[E1cos(w1 t)
· E1cos(w3 t)] + 2[E1cos(w3 t)
· E1cos(w2 t)]} (2)
All of the terms are the sum or difference frequency of two carriers closely spaced (narrow band). A
trigonometric expansion would put all of the interference signals almost an octave away. For systems with a
bandwidth less than an octave, these products can be filtered and therefore their effects on the system
performance are negated. For the purpose of this analysis the second-order effects of three carriers beating with
each other will be considered negligible.
CTB Intermodulation Interference Signals
CTB intermodulation products are spurious signals due to the cube of the input signal multiplied by the a3
coefficient of the Taylor series expansion. A trigonometric expansion of this term confirms that the interference
signals are in-band and therefore cannot be filtered out.
An Analysis of Third-order Intermodulation of CTB Signals
If Si consists of three signals of equal amplitude:
03/09/2020 Topics in Communication System Design: Carrier Triple Beats
https://www.microwavejournal.com/articles/3377-topics-in-communication-system-design-carrier-triple-beats 6/19
Si = E1cos(w1 t) + E1cos(w2 t) + E1cos(w3 t)
Third-order CTB =3rd order=
a3 Si
3 = a3 [E1cos(w1 t) + E1cos(w2 t) + E1cos(w3 t)]3 (3)
Expanding the terms
3rd order = a3 [E1cos(w1 t) + E1cos(w2 t) + E1cos(w3 t)]
· {[E1cos(w1 t)]2 + [E1cos(w2 t)]2 + [E1cos(w3 t)]2
+ 2[E1cos(w1 t) E1cos(w2 t)]+ 2[E1cos(w1 t) E1cos(w3 t)]
+ 2[E1cos(w3 t) E1cos(w2 t)]} (4)
Multiplying out and combining terms (see Appendix B for the detailed derivation)
3rd order = a3 E13 {[cos(w1 t)]3 + [cos(w2 t)]3 + [cos(w3 t)]3
+ 3/2[2cos(w1 t) + 2cos(w2 t) + 2cos(w3 t)
+ 1/2cos((2w1 -w2 )t) + 1/2cos((2w1 +w2 )t)
+ 1/2cos((2w1 -w3 )t) + 1/2cos((2w1 +w3 )t)
+ 1/2cos((2w2 -w1 )t) + 1/2cos((2w2 +w1 )t)
+ 1/2cos((2w3 -w1 )t) + 1/2cos((2w3 +w1 )t)
+ 1/2cos((2w2 -w3 )t) + 1/2cos((2w2 +w3 )t)
+ 1/2cos((2w3 -w2 )t) + 1/2cos((2w3 +w2 )t)
+ (6/4)cos((w1 -w2 +w3 )t) + (6/4)cos((w1 -w2 -w3 )t)
+ (6/4)cos((w1 +w2 +w3 )t)
+ (6/4)cos((w1 +w2 -w3 )t)} (5)
Assuming that all carrier frequencies (w1 , w2 , w3 …) are located in a narrow band (much less than an octave)
and considering only the in-band terms, other than the fundamental
3rd order (in-band) =
a3 E13 · {1/2cos((2w1 -w2 )t)
+ 1/2cos((2w1 -w3 )t)
+ 1/2cos((2w2 -w1 )t)
+ 1/2cos((2w3 -w1 )t)
+ 1/2cos((2w2 -w3 )t)
+ 1/2cos((2w3 -w2 )t)
+ (6/4)cos((w1 -w2 +w3 )t)
+ (6/4)cos((w1 -w2 -w3 )t)
+ (6/4)cos((w1 +w2 -w3 )t)} (6)
The resultant frequencies are 2 Sig 3rd order (2w2 -w1 ) and CTB. The relative amplitudes are (1/2)a3 E13 and
(6/4)a3 E13 , respectively.
The CTB signals are three times higher than the third-order intermodulation products when more than two
carriers are present.
Two Signal, Third-order Intermodulation Distortion
The resultant frequencies are (see Appendix B for the derivation) 2w1 -w2 and 2w2 -w1 . The relative
amplitudes are (3/4)a3 E13 for both.
03/09/2020 Topics in Communication System Design: Carrier Triple Beats
https://www.microwavejournal.com/articles/3377-topics-in-communication-system-design-carrier-triple-beats 7/19
Fig. 1 Third-order
intermodulation levels for a
typical 10 dB gain amplifier.
Fig. 2 Two-tone, third-order
intermodulation levels.
CTB Levels Compared to Third-order Intermodulation
A tabulation of the third-order intermodulation is listed in Table 1 .
Table 1
Third-order Intermodulation
Distortion
Two Signals CTB
Relative
amplitude
(3/4)a3 E13 (6/4)a3 E13
The CTB intermodulation is 6 dB higher than the two-tone, third-order intermodulation products. The level of a
single carrier triple beat product can therefore be determined by using the familiar equations for two-tone, third-
order intermodulation product interference.
The two-tone, third-order intermodulation product interference is determined by
noting the relative single carrier power with respect to the third-order intercept
point (usually 10 db above the 1 dB compression point), as shown in Figure 1 .
IP3 = -2(I3rd -A)
CTB = IP3 +6 dB
where
IP3 = relative third-order intermodulation level (dBc)
CTB = relative carrier triple beat intermodulation level (dBc)
A = signal 1 amplitude
= signal 2 amplitude (dBm)
I3rd = third-order intercept point (dBm)
dBc = relative level of the intermodulation with respect to the single carrier amplitude (A)
An example for two output signals of equal amplitude A, as shown in Figure 2 , is
A = +3 dBm
I3rd = +20 dBm
IP3 = -34 dBc
(absolute level = -31 dBm)
Three carriers of equal amplitude A will have a CTB interference of CTB = IP3 - 6
dB = -34 dBc + 6 dB = -28 dBc (-25 dBm), as shown in Figure 3 . The three
interference signals each down 28 dBc are products of the three carriers at
frequencies w1 , w2 and w3 . The lowest interference signal is at frequency w1 +w2
-w3 . In the center the interference signal is at frequency w3 +w1 -w2 and the
highest frequency is at w3 +w2 -w1 .
Calculating CTB Intermodulation Levels for N Equal Amplitude Signals
Unlike third-order intermodulation interference, CTB signals can overlap each other and
add noncoherently. This considerably increases the overall spurious in any given
channel. The total spurious interference is related to the number of carriers and the
position of the carrier, that is, carriers at the ends of the bandwidth have less interference
03/09/2020 Topics in Communication System Design: Carrier Triple Beats
https://www.microwavejournal.com/articles/3377-topics-in-communication-system-design-carrier-triple-beats 8/19
Fig. 3 Carrier triple beat
intermodulation diagram.
products than channels in the center of the band. The number of interference carriers
(beats) in any channel is given by
where
beats = number of interference carriers in the measured channel
N = number channels
M = number of the measured channel, 1 ≤ M ≤ N
The maximum number of interference carriers occurs in the center of the band (M » N/2). For N >> 1, the
maximum number of beats (beatmax ) is given by
The worst-case level of CTB can be arrived at by calculating the level of each CTB (which is the third-order
intermodulation level + 6 dB), adding noncoherently the number of beat signals that will fall into the respective
band (the worst-case being in the center of the band). The CTB interference can therefore be determined using
CTB = 2(I3rd -carrier) + 6 + 10log(beatmax ) (8)
where
I3rd = third-order intercept point (dBm)
carrier = single carrier output signal level (dBm)
beatmax = number of interference products in any signal channel
In terms of the total number of carriers N
For example,
I3rd = +15
carrier = -20 dBm
N = 24
CTB = -45.5 dBc
Calculating the Number of Carriers in a Given Channel
Inversely, the total number of carriers that can be multiplexed into a single channel, knowing the required CTB
interference level, can be calculated assuming that all of the interference signals are noncoherent and the
bandwidth is wide enough for all of the carriers to exist with acceptable adjacent channel interference.
The total number of carriers N is given by
03/09/2020 Topics in Communication System Design: Carrier Triple Beats
https://www.microwavejournal.com/articles/3377-topics-in-communication-system-design-carrier-triple-beats 9/19
where
CTB = maximum acceptable CTB interference level (dBc)
I3rd = third-order intercept point (dBm)
carrier = single carrier output signal level (dBm)
N = number of modulated carriers
As an example,
CTB = ≤ -57.6 dBc
I3rd = +20 dBm
carrier = -15 dBm
The relative third-order intermodulation level is
IP3 (dBc) = -2 (I3rd -A)
where
A = signal 1 amplitude = Signal 2 amplitude (dBm)
For N output signals
A = +3 dBm
I3rd = +20 dBm
IP3 = -34 dBc (absolute level = -31 dBm)
First check to see that the two-tone, third-order intermodulation interference is below the required specification
where A = +3 dBm
IP3 = -2(I3rd - carrier) = -2(20 - (-15)) = -70 dBc
This obviously meets the desired criteria.
The total number of carriers considering CTB interference is
N = 5.909 = 5 carriers
It should be noted that this analysis is valid for CW carriers, which should be considered a worst-case signal.
Modulated carriers exhibit spectrum spreading, which in effect will lower the intermodulation interference.
Table 2 is convenient for estimating the number of carriers that a given bandwidth could sustain (neglecting the
bandwidth of the carrier, interchannel interference and available system bandwidth). Across the top is the level
03/09/2020 Topics in Communication System Design: Carrier Triple Beats
https://www.microwavejournal.com/articles/3377-topics-in-communication-system-design-carrier-triple-beats 10/19
of each carrier (assuming all the carriers are the same level) below the third-order intercept point. To the left is
the acceptable interference level.
Table 2
Number of Carriers in a Single Channel
Level Below
Third-order
Intercept
20 dB 25 dB 30 dB 35 dB 40 dB
CTB (dBc) Number of Carriers
-20 14 44 141 448 1420
-25 7 25 79 252 797
-30 4 14 44 141 448
-35 2 7 25 79 252
-40 1 4 14 44 141
-45 0 2 7 25 79
-50 0 1 4 14 44
-55 0 0 2 7 25
-60 0 0 1 4 14
-65 0 0 0 2 7
-70 0 0 0 1 4
-75 0 0 0 0 2
-80 0 0 0 0 1
Conclusion
Determining the capacity of a channel is more involved than allocating enough bandwidth. CTB interference is
an important factor to consider when a channel is loaded with many carriers. It has been shown that the
03/09/2020 Topics in Communication System Design: Carrier Triple Beats
https://www.microwavejournal.com/articles/3377-topics-in-communication-system-design-carrier-triple-beats 11/19
interference level increases as the square of the increase in the number of carriers. The worst-case interference
is in the center of the band where there are more combinations of frequencies in a given channel. At the ends of
the band the interference levels go down, but unless the power level of the carriers in the center are lower than
the carrier powers at the band edges, it is prudent to assume the worst interference for the system design.
Although the problem is critical as the number of carriers increase, it should be noted that even with only three
in-band carriers, the interference level is more than 6 dB above that calculated for two-signal, third-order
intermodulation.
It must be noted that this is a worst-case analysis. Most modulated carriers exhibit a band spreading that lowers
the average spectral density, which will somewhat lower the respective interference.
References
1. S. Winder, "Single Tone Intermodulation Testing," RF Design , December 1993.
2. M. Leffel, "Intermodulation Distortion in a Multi-signal Environment," RF Design , June 1995.
3. R. Hawkins, "Combining Gain, Noise Figure and Intercept Points for Cascaded Circuit Elements," RF Design , March 1990.
4. J. Waltrich, "Compute CTB in Hybrid Fiber/Coax Systems," Microwaves & RF , December 1998.
5. D. Henkes and S. Kwok, "Intermodulation: Concepts and Calculations," Applied Microwaves & Wireless , July/August 1997.
Howard Hausman received his BSEE and MSEE degrees from Polytechnic University and is currently chief
technology engineer at Miteq Inc. During his career he has designed microwave systems and components for
satellite communications, radar and reconnaissance, which includes receivers, transmitters and synthesizers.
Mr. Hausman is also an adjunct professor at Polytechnic University, where he teaches graduate courses in
electrical engineering, and has been an adjunct professor at Hofstra University. He has presented lectures and
authored papers relating to microwave and communication systems.
Appendix A
Derivation of second-Order Intermodulation of Three In-Band Signals
This analysis is presented to show that the second-order effects are out of band (assuming a narrow band
system) even when there are more than two carriers present.
Second-order intermodulation of three in-band signals is usually almost an octave away from the desired
carriers. In a narrow band system, these signals can be easily filtered and therefore not considered in the
spurious analysis. This is a derivation of the resultant spectrum of second-order intermodulation on three in-
band signals.
Second-order intermodulation of CTB
Second-order Intermodulation = 2nd order = a2 Si
2 = a2 [E1cos(w1 t) + E1cos(w2 t) + E1cos(w3 t)]2
Expanding the terms:
2nd order = a2 {[E1cos(w1 t)]2 + [E1cos(w2 t)]2 + [E1cos(w3 t)]2 + 2[E1cos(w1 t) · E1cos(w2 t)] + 2[E1cos(w1
t) · E1cos(w3 t)] + 2[E1cos(w3 t) · E1cos(w2 t)]}
If all of the carriers are in a narrow frequency band the second-order products are approximately an octave
away. Systems less than an octave wide can filter these products and therefore negate their effects on the system
performance. For the purpose of this analysis the second-order effects of three carriers beating with each other
will be considered negligible.
Appendix B
Derivation of the Carrier Triple Beat (CTB) Equations and the Third-Order Intermodulation Equations
The following trigonometric expansion shows how CTB interference is formed. It should be noted that in
addition to carrier triple beat terms there are two-tone intermodulation terms (below the CTBs) and fundamental
03/09/2020 Topics in Communication System Design: Carrier Triple Beats
https://www.microwavejournal.com/articles/3377-topics-in-communication-system-design-carrier-triple-beats 12/19
terms that cause the familiar signal compression as the signal level increases.
Third-Order intermodulation of CTB
Third-order CTB = 3rd order = a3 Si
3 = a3 [E1cos(w1 t) + E1cos(w2 t) + E1cos(w3 t)]3
Expanding the terms:
3rd order = a3 [E1cos(w1 t) + E1cos(w2 t) + E1cos(w3 t)]
· {[E1cos(w1 t)]2 + [E1cos(w2 t)]2 + [E1cos(w3 t)]2 + 2[E1cos(w1 t)
· E1cos(w2 t)] + 2[E1cos(w1 t) · E1cos(w3 t)] + 2[E1cos(w3 t) E1cos(w2 t)]}
Multiplying out the cube term
3rd order CTB = a3 {[E1cos(w1 t)]3 + [E1cos(w2 t)]3
+ [E1cos(w3 t)]3 + 3[E1cos(w1 t)]2 · [E1cos(w2 t)] + 3[E1cos(w1 t)]2
· [E1cos(w3 t)] + 3[E1cos(w1 t)] · [E1cos(w2 t)]2 + 3[E1cos(w1 t)]
· [E1cos(w3 t)]2 + 3[E1cos(w2 t)]2 · [E1cos(w3 t)] + 3[E1cos(w2 t)]
· [E1cos(w3 t)]2 + 6[E1cos(w1 t)] · [E1cos(w2 t)] · [E1cos(w3 t)]}
Using the respective trigonometric identities for the resultant square term:
3rd order = a3 E13 {[cos(w1 t)]3 + [cos(w2 t)]3 + [cos(w3 t)]3
+ {3[1/2 + (1/2)cos(2w1 t)] cos(w2 t) + 3[1/2 + (1/2)cos(2w1 t)] cos(w3 t) +
3[1/2 + (1/2)cos(2w2 t )] cos(w1 t) + 3[1/2 + (1/2)cos(2w3 t)] cos(w1 t) +
3[1/2 + (1/2)cos(2w2 t)] cos(w3 t)+ 3[1/2 + (1/2)cos(2w3 t)] cos(w2 t)
+ 6[cos(w1 t) cos(w2 t) cos(w3 t)]}
Multiplying out the cube term:
3rd order = a3 E13 {[cos(w1 t)]3 + [cos(w2 t)]3 + [cos(w3 t)]3
+ [3/2 cos(w2 t) + (3/2)cos(2w1 t) cos(w2 t) + (3/2)cos(w3 t)
+ (3/2)cos(2w1 t ) cos(w3 t) + 3/2 cos(w1 t) + (3/2)cos (2w2 t ) cos(w1 t)
+ (3/2)cos(w1 t) + (3/2)cos (2w3 t) · cos(w1 t) + (3/2)cos(w3 t)
+ (3/2)cos(2w2 t )cos(w3 t) + (3/2)cos(w2 t) + (3/2)cos(2w3 t) cos(w2 t)
+ 6[cos(w1 t) cos(w2 t)cos(w3 t)]}
Factor out 3/2
3rd order = a3 E13 {[cos(w1 t)]3 + [cos(w2 t)]3 + [cos(w3 t)]3
+ {3/2[cos(w2 t) + cos(2w1 t) cos(w2 t) + cos(w3 t) + cos(2w1 t ) cos(w3 t)
+ cos(w1 t) + cos(2w2 t) cos(w1 t) + cos(w1 t) + cos(2w3 t ) · cos(w1 t)
+ cos(w3 t) + cos(2w2 t) cos(w3 t) + cos(w2 t) + cos(2w3 t) cos(w2 t)]
+ 6[cos(w1 t) cos(w2 t) cos(w3 t)]}
Combine 1st order terms
3rd order = a3 E13 {[cos(w1 t)]3 + [cos(w2 t)]3 + [cos(w3 t)]3
+ 3/2[2 cos(w1 t) + 2cos(w2 t) + 2cos(w3 t) + cos(2w1 t) cos(w2 t)
03/09/2020 Topics in Communication System Design: Carrier Triple Beats
https://www.microwavejournal.com/articles/3377-topics-in-communication-system-design-carrier-triple-beats 13/19
+ cos(2w1 t) cos(w3 t) + cos(2w2 t) cos(w1 t) + cos(2w3 t) · cos(w1 t)
+ cos(2w2 t )cos(w3 t) + cos(2w3 t) cos(w2 t)] + 6[cos(w1 t) cos(w2 t)cos(w3 t)]}
Expand the third-order terms
3rd order = a3 E13 {[cos(w1 t)]3 + [cos(w2 t)]3 + [cos(w3 t)]3
+ 3/2[2 cos(w1 t) + 2cos(w2 t) + 2cos(w3 t) + (1/2)cos((2w1 -w2 )t)
+ (1/2)cos((2w1 +w2 )t) + (1/2)cos((2w1 -w3 )t) + (1/2)cos((2w1 +w3 )t)
+ (1/2)cos((2w2 -w1 )t) + (1/2)cos((2w2 +w1 )t) + (1/2)cos((2w3 -w1 )t)
+ (1/2)cos((2w3 +w1 )t) + (1/2)cos((2w2 -w3 )t) + (1/2)cos((2w2 +w3 )t)
+ (1/2)cos((2w3 -w2 )t) + (1/2)cos((2w3 +w2 )t) + 6[(1/2)cos((w1 -w2 )t)
+ (1/2)cos((w1 +w2 )t)]cos(w3 t)}
Further expand the third-order terms
3rd order = a3 E13 {[cos(w1 t)]3 + [cos(w2 t)]3 + [cos(w3 t)]3
+ 3/2[2 cos(w1 t) + 2cos(w2 t) + 2cos(w3 t) + (1/2)cos((2w1 -w2 )t)
+ (1/2)cos((2w1 +w2 )t) + (1/2)cos((2w1 -w3 )t) + (1/2)cos((2w1 +w3 )t)
+ (1/2)cos((2w2 -w1 )t) + (1/2)cos((2w2 +w1 )t) + (1/2)cos((2w3 -w1 )t)
+ (1/2)cos((2w3 +w1 )t) + (1/2)cos((2w2 -w3 )t) + (1/2)cos((2w2 +w3 )t)
+ (1/2)cos((2w3 -w2 )t) + (1/2)cos((2w3 +w2 )t) + 6[(1/4)cos((w1 -w2 +w3 )t)
+ (1/4)cos((w1 -w2 -w3 )t) + (1/4)cos((w1 +w2 +w3 )t) + (1/4)cos((w1 +w2 -w3 )t)]}
Third-order Intermodulation Interference Signals
Third-order intermodulation products are spurious signals due to the cube of the input signal multiplied by the
a3 coefficient of the Taylor series expansion.
Third-order Intermodulation = 3rd order =
a3 Si
3 = a3 [E1cos(w1 t) + E1cos(w2 t)]3
Expanding the terms:
3rd order = a3 [E1cos(w1 t) + E1cos(w2 t)] · {[E1cos(w1 t)]2
+ [E1cos(w2 t)]2 + 2[E1cos(w1 t) · E1cos(w2 t)]}
Factoring out the cube term and using the respective trigonometric identities for the resultant square term:
3rd order = a3 E13 {cos(w1 t) + cos(w2 t)} {[1/2 + (1/2)cos(2w1 t)]
+ [1/2 + (1/2)cos(2w2 t)] + [cos(w1 t-w2 t) + cos(w1 t+w2 t)]}
Multiplying out the cube term:
3rd order = a3 E13 {cos(w1 t) + cos(w2 t) + [[(1/2)cos(2w1 t)]
· [cos(w1 t)] + cos(w2 t)] + [[(1/2)cos(2w2 t)] · [cos(w1 t) + cos(w2 t)]]
+ [[cos(w1 t-w2 t)] · [cos(w1 t) + cos(w2 t)]]
+ [[cos(w1 t+w2 t)] · [cos(w1 t) + cos(w2 t)]]}
If the system is less than an octave in bandwidth, all of the frequency terms that are added (w1 + w2 ) are
filtered out and can be discarded in this analysis:
03/09/2020 Topics in Communication System Design: Carrier Triple Beats
https://www.microwavejournal.com/articles/3377-topics-in-communication-system-design-carrier-triple-beats 14/19
3rd order = a3 E13 {cos(w1 t) + cos(w2 t) + (1/4)cos(w1 t )
+ (1/4) [cos(2w1 t-w2 t)] + (1/4)cos(2w2 t-w1 t) + (1/4)cos(w2 t)
+ (1/2)[cos(2w1 t-w2 t) + cos(-w2 t) + cos(w1 t-2w2 t) + cos(w1 t)]
+ 1/2[cos(w2 t) + cos(w1 t)]}
Note: cos(-w2 t) = cos(w2 t) and cos(w1 t-2w2 t) = cos(2w2 t-w1 t)
Combining terms:
3rd order = a3 E13 {(9/4)cos(w1 t) + (9/4)cos(w2 t)
+ (3/4)cos(2w1 t-w2 t) + (3/4)cos(2w2 t-w1 t)}
The resultant spectral frequencies are at:
Frequency w1 , w2 , 2w1 -w2 , 2w2 -w1
Relative Amplitude (9/4) a3 E13 (9/4) a3 E13 (3/4) a3 E13 (3/4) a3 E13
The third-order intermodulation produces signals at the input frequencies and two side bands on either side of
the input frequencies.
The coefficient a3 is typically 180° out of phase with the coefficient a1. In cases where the input is a single
signal, this out of phase relationship effectively reduces the output level when the input signal becomes large.
The effective reduction is related to the a3 coefficient. This suggests a relationship between third-order
intermodulation levels and single signal compression points (the 1 dB output gain compression level is typically
10 dB below the third-order output intercept point).
Related Articles
China Mobile Market, MWs in Space and the State-of-
Communication ICs in China - topics in EDI CON keynotes
Agilent Technologies' Integrated 3D Electromagnetic Simulation and
Advanced Design System EDA Platform Speeds Design, Verification
EMDS-for-ADS Reduces Steps in Module, Board, Planar Antenna
Design
Post a comment to this article
Name*
E-mail (will not be displayed)*
Subject
Comment*
Create Comment Reset
03/09/2020 Topics in Communication System Design: Carrier Triple Beats
https://www.microwavejournal.com/articles/3377-topics-in-communication-system-design-carrier-triple-beats 15/19
Free Newsletter
Subscribe Now
Current Issue
Digital Edition
How Drone Technology Will Revolutionize Satellite Antenna TestingThe Growing Importance of Oscillators
With 5GImproving Stability and Accuracy of High Frequency VNA Measurements Over DistanceCable
Dielectric Minimizes Phase Change Over Temperature1200 W LDMOS Power Transistor Targets Particle
AcceleratorsNew Products
Buyer's Guide
Buyer's GuideGet Listed
Popular Posts
Survey of mmWave Semiconductor Test Systems
03/09/2020 Topics in Communication System Design: Carrier Triple Beats
https://www.microwavejournal.com/articles/3377-topics-in-communication-system-design-carrier-triple-beats 17/19
Digital Edition
Online Edition
Home
About Us
Contact Us
Advertise With Us
Submit An Article
ERB Members
Reprints
Privacy
Microwave Journal
685 Canton St.
Norwood, MA 02062 USA
Tel: (781) 769-9750
Fax: (781) 769-5037
For magazine subscriptions and newsletter customer service:
Tel: 978-671-0449
Email: mwj@e-circ.net
03/09/2020 Topics in Communication System Design: Carrier Triple Beats
https://www.microwavejournal.com/articles/3377-topics-in-communication-system-design-carrier-triple-beats 16/19
GaN Solutions for Wide Bandwidths and High Frequencies
How Drone Technology Will Revolutionize Satellite Antenna Testing
The Growing Importance of Oscillators With 5G
IMS2020 Virtual Exhibition Product Highlights
Featured Videos
Frequency Matters Aug 24: BEACH Episode, Aug issue &
IMS2020/2021
See More Videos
Subscribe here to receive Microwave Journal
How Drone Technology Will Revolutionize Satellite Antenna Testing
By Joakim Espeland and Andrian Buchi, QuadSAT, Denmark
Subscribe
The Growing Importance of Oscillators With 5G
By Pasternack, Irvine, Calif.
Improving Stability and Accuracy of High Frequency VNA Measurements Over Distance
By Stan Oda, Anritsu, Morgan Hill, Calif.
03/09/2020 Topics in Communication System Design: Carrier Triple Beats
https://www.microwavejournal.com/articles/3377-topics-in-communication-system-design-carrier-triple-beats 18/19
Microwave Journal
Copyright ©2020. All Rights Reserved
Design, CMS, Hosting & Web Development | ePublishing
News
Channels
5G/6G
Aerospace & Defense
Broadband
Cellular/4G/LTE
EMC/EMI
Industrial/Scientific/Medical
IoT/M2M/V2V
RFID/GPS/Location
RFIC
Software/EDA
Test & Measurement
eLearning
Acronyms List
Design Tools
eBook Library
History of Wireless
Microwave Basics
Webinars
White Papers
Community
Blogs
Classifieds Section
RF & Microwave LinkedIn Group
Facebook
Twitter
Instagram
Mobile App
Events
Webinars
Trade Shows
Training-User Meetings
IMS2020 Online Show Daily
European Microwave Week
EDI CON Online
EDI CON China
Buyers Guide
Multimedia
Videos
Podcasts
03/09/2020 Topics in Communication System Design: Carrier Triple Beats
https://www.microwavejournal.com/articles/3377-topics-in-communication-system-design-carrier-triple-beats 19/19
Photo Galleries
Magazine
Current Issue
Archives
Article Reprints
Subscribe
Subscription Renewal

More Related Content

Similar to Topics in communication system design carrier triple beats

A Review Of Diversity Techniques For Wireless Communiation Systems
A Review Of Diversity Techniques For Wireless Communiation SystemsA Review Of Diversity Techniques For Wireless Communiation Systems
A Review Of Diversity Techniques For Wireless Communiation SystemsCourtney Esco
 
Comparitive analysis of bit error rates of multiple input multiple output tra...
Comparitive analysis of bit error rates of multiple input multiple output tra...Comparitive analysis of bit error rates of multiple input multiple output tra...
Comparitive analysis of bit error rates of multiple input multiple output tra...slinpublishers
 
Performance Analysis of Differential Beamforming in Decentralized Networks
Performance Analysis of Differential Beamforming in Decentralized NetworksPerformance Analysis of Differential Beamforming in Decentralized Networks
Performance Analysis of Differential Beamforming in Decentralized NetworksIJECEIAES
 
PERFORMANCE ANALYSIS OF CLIPPED STBC CODED MIMO OFDM SYSTEM
PERFORMANCE ANALYSIS OF CLIPPED STBC CODED MIMO OFDM SYSTEMPERFORMANCE ANALYSIS OF CLIPPED STBC CODED MIMO OFDM SYSTEM
PERFORMANCE ANALYSIS OF CLIPPED STBC CODED MIMO OFDM SYSTEMIAEME Publication
 
CHANNEL ESTIMATION AND MULTIUSER DETECTION IN ASYNCHRONOUS SATELLITE COMMUNIC...
CHANNEL ESTIMATION AND MULTIUSER DETECTION IN ASYNCHRONOUS SATELLITE COMMUNIC...CHANNEL ESTIMATION AND MULTIUSER DETECTION IN ASYNCHRONOUS SATELLITE COMMUNIC...
CHANNEL ESTIMATION AND MULTIUSER DETECTION IN ASYNCHRONOUS SATELLITE COMMUNIC...ijwmn
 
Performance Analysis of CIR and Path Loss Propagation Models in the Downlink ...
Performance Analysis of CIR and Path Loss Propagation Models in the Downlink ...Performance Analysis of CIR and Path Loss Propagation Models in the Downlink ...
Performance Analysis of CIR and Path Loss Propagation Models in the Downlink ...ijtsrd
 
The Physical Layer
The Physical LayerThe Physical Layer
The Physical Layeradil raja
 
Popular Interview Wireless Question with Answer
Popular Interview Wireless Question with AnswerPopular Interview Wireless Question with Answer
Popular Interview Wireless Question with AnswerVARUN KUMAR
 
Energy Efficiency of MIMO-OFDM Communication System
Energy Efficiency of MIMO-OFDM Communication SystemEnergy Efficiency of MIMO-OFDM Communication System
Energy Efficiency of MIMO-OFDM Communication SystemIJERA Editor
 
BER ENHANCEMENT OF MIMO-CDMA BASED ON SPACE-TIME BLOCK CODES
BER ENHANCEMENT OF MIMO-CDMA BASED ON SPACE-TIME BLOCK CODESBER ENHANCEMENT OF MIMO-CDMA BASED ON SPACE-TIME BLOCK CODES
BER ENHANCEMENT OF MIMO-CDMA BASED ON SPACE-TIME BLOCK CODEScscpconf
 
Pilot induced cyclostationarity based method for dvb system identification
Pilot induced cyclostationarity based method for dvb system identificationPilot induced cyclostationarity based method for dvb system identification
Pilot induced cyclostationarity based method for dvb system identificationiaemedu
 
Reduction of Outage Probability in Fast Rayleigh Fading MIMO Channels Using OFDM
Reduction of Outage Probability in Fast Rayleigh Fading MIMO Channels Using OFDMReduction of Outage Probability in Fast Rayleigh Fading MIMO Channels Using OFDM
Reduction of Outage Probability in Fast Rayleigh Fading MIMO Channels Using OFDMIJERA Editor
 
An Analytical Analysis of Path Loss Models for Mobile Cellular Wireless Commu...
An Analytical Analysis of Path Loss Models for Mobile Cellular Wireless Commu...An Analytical Analysis of Path Loss Models for Mobile Cellular Wireless Commu...
An Analytical Analysis of Path Loss Models for Mobile Cellular Wireless Commu...IJCI JOURNAL
 
AN ANALYTICAL ANALYSIS OF PATH LOSS MODELS FOR MOBILE CELLULAR WIRELESS COMMU...
AN ANALYTICAL ANALYSIS OF PATH LOSS MODELS FOR MOBILE CELLULAR WIRELESS COMMU...AN ANALYTICAL ANALYSIS OF PATH LOSS MODELS FOR MOBILE CELLULAR WIRELESS COMMU...
AN ANALYTICAL ANALYSIS OF PATH LOSS MODELS FOR MOBILE CELLULAR WIRELESS COMMU...IJCI JOURNAL
 
Multi user performance on mc cdma single relay cooperative system by distribu...
Multi user performance on mc cdma single relay cooperative system by distribu...Multi user performance on mc cdma single relay cooperative system by distribu...
Multi user performance on mc cdma single relay cooperative system by distribu...IJCNCJournal
 
Intermodulation Distortion Cancellation by Feedforward Linearization of Power...
Intermodulation Distortion Cancellation by Feedforward Linearization of Power...Intermodulation Distortion Cancellation by Feedforward Linearization of Power...
Intermodulation Distortion Cancellation by Feedforward Linearization of Power...IJERA Editor
 

Similar to Topics in communication system design carrier triple beats (20)

A Review Of Diversity Techniques For Wireless Communiation Systems
A Review Of Diversity Techniques For Wireless Communiation SystemsA Review Of Diversity Techniques For Wireless Communiation Systems
A Review Of Diversity Techniques For Wireless Communiation Systems
 
International Journal of Engineering Inventions (IJEI)
International Journal of Engineering Inventions (IJEI)International Journal of Engineering Inventions (IJEI)
International Journal of Engineering Inventions (IJEI)
 
Comparitive analysis of bit error rates of multiple input multiple output tra...
Comparitive analysis of bit error rates of multiple input multiple output tra...Comparitive analysis of bit error rates of multiple input multiple output tra...
Comparitive analysis of bit error rates of multiple input multiple output tra...
 
Performance Analysis of Differential Beamforming in Decentralized Networks
Performance Analysis of Differential Beamforming in Decentralized NetworksPerformance Analysis of Differential Beamforming in Decentralized Networks
Performance Analysis of Differential Beamforming in Decentralized Networks
 
PERFORMANCE ANALYSIS OF CLIPPED STBC CODED MIMO OFDM SYSTEM
PERFORMANCE ANALYSIS OF CLIPPED STBC CODED MIMO OFDM SYSTEMPERFORMANCE ANALYSIS OF CLIPPED STBC CODED MIMO OFDM SYSTEM
PERFORMANCE ANALYSIS OF CLIPPED STBC CODED MIMO OFDM SYSTEM
 
Ac35162165
Ac35162165Ac35162165
Ac35162165
 
Ac35162165
Ac35162165Ac35162165
Ac35162165
 
Ac35162165
Ac35162165Ac35162165
Ac35162165
 
CHANNEL ESTIMATION AND MULTIUSER DETECTION IN ASYNCHRONOUS SATELLITE COMMUNIC...
CHANNEL ESTIMATION AND MULTIUSER DETECTION IN ASYNCHRONOUS SATELLITE COMMUNIC...CHANNEL ESTIMATION AND MULTIUSER DETECTION IN ASYNCHRONOUS SATELLITE COMMUNIC...
CHANNEL ESTIMATION AND MULTIUSER DETECTION IN ASYNCHRONOUS SATELLITE COMMUNIC...
 
Performance Analysis of CIR and Path Loss Propagation Models in the Downlink ...
Performance Analysis of CIR and Path Loss Propagation Models in the Downlink ...Performance Analysis of CIR and Path Loss Propagation Models in the Downlink ...
Performance Analysis of CIR and Path Loss Propagation Models in the Downlink ...
 
The Physical Layer
The Physical LayerThe Physical Layer
The Physical Layer
 
Popular Interview Wireless Question with Answer
Popular Interview Wireless Question with AnswerPopular Interview Wireless Question with Answer
Popular Interview Wireless Question with Answer
 
Energy Efficiency of MIMO-OFDM Communication System
Energy Efficiency of MIMO-OFDM Communication SystemEnergy Efficiency of MIMO-OFDM Communication System
Energy Efficiency of MIMO-OFDM Communication System
 
BER ENHANCEMENT OF MIMO-CDMA BASED ON SPACE-TIME BLOCK CODES
BER ENHANCEMENT OF MIMO-CDMA BASED ON SPACE-TIME BLOCK CODESBER ENHANCEMENT OF MIMO-CDMA BASED ON SPACE-TIME BLOCK CODES
BER ENHANCEMENT OF MIMO-CDMA BASED ON SPACE-TIME BLOCK CODES
 
Pilot induced cyclostationarity based method for dvb system identification
Pilot induced cyclostationarity based method for dvb system identificationPilot induced cyclostationarity based method for dvb system identification
Pilot induced cyclostationarity based method for dvb system identification
 
Reduction of Outage Probability in Fast Rayleigh Fading MIMO Channels Using OFDM
Reduction of Outage Probability in Fast Rayleigh Fading MIMO Channels Using OFDMReduction of Outage Probability in Fast Rayleigh Fading MIMO Channels Using OFDM
Reduction of Outage Probability in Fast Rayleigh Fading MIMO Channels Using OFDM
 
An Analytical Analysis of Path Loss Models for Mobile Cellular Wireless Commu...
An Analytical Analysis of Path Loss Models for Mobile Cellular Wireless Commu...An Analytical Analysis of Path Loss Models for Mobile Cellular Wireless Commu...
An Analytical Analysis of Path Loss Models for Mobile Cellular Wireless Commu...
 
AN ANALYTICAL ANALYSIS OF PATH LOSS MODELS FOR MOBILE CELLULAR WIRELESS COMMU...
AN ANALYTICAL ANALYSIS OF PATH LOSS MODELS FOR MOBILE CELLULAR WIRELESS COMMU...AN ANALYTICAL ANALYSIS OF PATH LOSS MODELS FOR MOBILE CELLULAR WIRELESS COMMU...
AN ANALYTICAL ANALYSIS OF PATH LOSS MODELS FOR MOBILE CELLULAR WIRELESS COMMU...
 
Multi user performance on mc cdma single relay cooperative system by distribu...
Multi user performance on mc cdma single relay cooperative system by distribu...Multi user performance on mc cdma single relay cooperative system by distribu...
Multi user performance on mc cdma single relay cooperative system by distribu...
 
Intermodulation Distortion Cancellation by Feedforward Linearization of Power...
Intermodulation Distortion Cancellation by Feedforward Linearization of Power...Intermodulation Distortion Cancellation by Feedforward Linearization of Power...
Intermodulation Distortion Cancellation by Feedforward Linearization of Power...
 

Recently uploaded

Convergence of Robotics and Gen AI offers excellent opportunities for Entrepr...
Convergence of Robotics and Gen AI offers excellent opportunities for Entrepr...Convergence of Robotics and Gen AI offers excellent opportunities for Entrepr...
Convergence of Robotics and Gen AI offers excellent opportunities for Entrepr...ssuserdfc773
 
Independent Solar-Powered Electric Vehicle Charging Station
Independent Solar-Powered Electric Vehicle Charging StationIndependent Solar-Powered Electric Vehicle Charging Station
Independent Solar-Powered Electric Vehicle Charging Stationsiddharthteach18
 
Study of Computer Hardware System using Block Diagram
Study of Computer Hardware System using Block DiagramStudy of Computer Hardware System using Block Diagram
Study of Computer Hardware System using Block DiagramChandrakantDivate1
 
Involute of a circle,Square, pentagon,HexagonInvolute_Engineering Drawing.pdf
Involute of a circle,Square, pentagon,HexagonInvolute_Engineering Drawing.pdfInvolute of a circle,Square, pentagon,HexagonInvolute_Engineering Drawing.pdf
Involute of a circle,Square, pentagon,HexagonInvolute_Engineering Drawing.pdfJNTUA
 
21P35A0312 Internship eccccccReport.docx
21P35A0312 Internship eccccccReport.docx21P35A0312 Internship eccccccReport.docx
21P35A0312 Internship eccccccReport.docxrahulmanepalli02
 
Theory of Time 2024 (Universal Theory for Everything)
Theory of Time 2024 (Universal Theory for Everything)Theory of Time 2024 (Universal Theory for Everything)
Theory of Time 2024 (Universal Theory for Everything)Ramkumar k
 
Autodesk Construction Cloud (Autodesk Build).pptx
Autodesk Construction Cloud (Autodesk Build).pptxAutodesk Construction Cloud (Autodesk Build).pptx
Autodesk Construction Cloud (Autodesk Build).pptxMustafa Ahmed
 
Degrees of freedom for the robots 1.pptx
Degrees of freedom for the robots 1.pptxDegrees of freedom for the robots 1.pptx
Degrees of freedom for the robots 1.pptxMostafa Mahmoud
 
1_Introduction + EAM Vocabulary + how to navigate in EAM.pdf
1_Introduction + EAM Vocabulary + how to navigate in EAM.pdf1_Introduction + EAM Vocabulary + how to navigate in EAM.pdf
1_Introduction + EAM Vocabulary + how to navigate in EAM.pdfAldoGarca30
 
Overview of Transformation in Computer Graphics
Overview of Transformation in Computer GraphicsOverview of Transformation in Computer Graphics
Overview of Transformation in Computer GraphicsChandrakantDivate1
 
UNIT 4 PTRP final Convergence in probability.pptx
UNIT 4 PTRP final Convergence in probability.pptxUNIT 4 PTRP final Convergence in probability.pptx
UNIT 4 PTRP final Convergence in probability.pptxkalpana413121
 
Introduction to Artificial Intelligence ( AI)
Introduction to Artificial Intelligence ( AI)Introduction to Artificial Intelligence ( AI)
Introduction to Artificial Intelligence ( AI)ChandrakantDivate1
 
Augmented Reality (AR) with Augin Software.pptx
Augmented Reality (AR) with Augin Software.pptxAugmented Reality (AR) with Augin Software.pptx
Augmented Reality (AR) with Augin Software.pptxMustafa Ahmed
 
Basics of Relay for Engineering Students
Basics of Relay for Engineering StudentsBasics of Relay for Engineering Students
Basics of Relay for Engineering Studentskannan348865
 
Adsorption (mass transfer operations 2) ppt
Adsorption (mass transfer operations 2) pptAdsorption (mass transfer operations 2) ppt
Adsorption (mass transfer operations 2) pptjigup7320
 
NEWLETTER FRANCE HELICES/ SDS SURFACE DRIVES - MAY 2024
NEWLETTER FRANCE HELICES/ SDS SURFACE DRIVES - MAY 2024NEWLETTER FRANCE HELICES/ SDS SURFACE DRIVES - MAY 2024
NEWLETTER FRANCE HELICES/ SDS SURFACE DRIVES - MAY 2024EMMANUELLEFRANCEHELI
 
What is Coordinate Measuring Machine? CMM Types, Features, Functions
What is Coordinate Measuring Machine? CMM Types, Features, FunctionsWhat is Coordinate Measuring Machine? CMM Types, Features, Functions
What is Coordinate Measuring Machine? CMM Types, Features, FunctionsVIEW
 
Instruct Nirmaana 24-Smart and Lean Construction Through Technology.pdf
Instruct Nirmaana 24-Smart and Lean Construction Through Technology.pdfInstruct Nirmaana 24-Smart and Lean Construction Through Technology.pdf
Instruct Nirmaana 24-Smart and Lean Construction Through Technology.pdfEr.Sonali Nasikkar
 
Working Principle of Echo Sounder and Doppler Effect.pdf
Working Principle of Echo Sounder and Doppler Effect.pdfWorking Principle of Echo Sounder and Doppler Effect.pdf
Working Principle of Echo Sounder and Doppler Effect.pdfSkNahidulIslamShrabo
 
8th International Conference on Soft Computing, Mathematics and Control (SMC ...
8th International Conference on Soft Computing, Mathematics and Control (SMC ...8th International Conference on Soft Computing, Mathematics and Control (SMC ...
8th International Conference on Soft Computing, Mathematics and Control (SMC ...josephjonse
 

Recently uploaded (20)

Convergence of Robotics and Gen AI offers excellent opportunities for Entrepr...
Convergence of Robotics and Gen AI offers excellent opportunities for Entrepr...Convergence of Robotics and Gen AI offers excellent opportunities for Entrepr...
Convergence of Robotics and Gen AI offers excellent opportunities for Entrepr...
 
Independent Solar-Powered Electric Vehicle Charging Station
Independent Solar-Powered Electric Vehicle Charging StationIndependent Solar-Powered Electric Vehicle Charging Station
Independent Solar-Powered Electric Vehicle Charging Station
 
Study of Computer Hardware System using Block Diagram
Study of Computer Hardware System using Block DiagramStudy of Computer Hardware System using Block Diagram
Study of Computer Hardware System using Block Diagram
 
Involute of a circle,Square, pentagon,HexagonInvolute_Engineering Drawing.pdf
Involute of a circle,Square, pentagon,HexagonInvolute_Engineering Drawing.pdfInvolute of a circle,Square, pentagon,HexagonInvolute_Engineering Drawing.pdf
Involute of a circle,Square, pentagon,HexagonInvolute_Engineering Drawing.pdf
 
21P35A0312 Internship eccccccReport.docx
21P35A0312 Internship eccccccReport.docx21P35A0312 Internship eccccccReport.docx
21P35A0312 Internship eccccccReport.docx
 
Theory of Time 2024 (Universal Theory for Everything)
Theory of Time 2024 (Universal Theory for Everything)Theory of Time 2024 (Universal Theory for Everything)
Theory of Time 2024 (Universal Theory for Everything)
 
Autodesk Construction Cloud (Autodesk Build).pptx
Autodesk Construction Cloud (Autodesk Build).pptxAutodesk Construction Cloud (Autodesk Build).pptx
Autodesk Construction Cloud (Autodesk Build).pptx
 
Degrees of freedom for the robots 1.pptx
Degrees of freedom for the robots 1.pptxDegrees of freedom for the robots 1.pptx
Degrees of freedom for the robots 1.pptx
 
1_Introduction + EAM Vocabulary + how to navigate in EAM.pdf
1_Introduction + EAM Vocabulary + how to navigate in EAM.pdf1_Introduction + EAM Vocabulary + how to navigate in EAM.pdf
1_Introduction + EAM Vocabulary + how to navigate in EAM.pdf
 
Overview of Transformation in Computer Graphics
Overview of Transformation in Computer GraphicsOverview of Transformation in Computer Graphics
Overview of Transformation in Computer Graphics
 
UNIT 4 PTRP final Convergence in probability.pptx
UNIT 4 PTRP final Convergence in probability.pptxUNIT 4 PTRP final Convergence in probability.pptx
UNIT 4 PTRP final Convergence in probability.pptx
 
Introduction to Artificial Intelligence ( AI)
Introduction to Artificial Intelligence ( AI)Introduction to Artificial Intelligence ( AI)
Introduction to Artificial Intelligence ( AI)
 
Augmented Reality (AR) with Augin Software.pptx
Augmented Reality (AR) with Augin Software.pptxAugmented Reality (AR) with Augin Software.pptx
Augmented Reality (AR) with Augin Software.pptx
 
Basics of Relay for Engineering Students
Basics of Relay for Engineering StudentsBasics of Relay for Engineering Students
Basics of Relay for Engineering Students
 
Adsorption (mass transfer operations 2) ppt
Adsorption (mass transfer operations 2) pptAdsorption (mass transfer operations 2) ppt
Adsorption (mass transfer operations 2) ppt
 
NEWLETTER FRANCE HELICES/ SDS SURFACE DRIVES - MAY 2024
NEWLETTER FRANCE HELICES/ SDS SURFACE DRIVES - MAY 2024NEWLETTER FRANCE HELICES/ SDS SURFACE DRIVES - MAY 2024
NEWLETTER FRANCE HELICES/ SDS SURFACE DRIVES - MAY 2024
 
What is Coordinate Measuring Machine? CMM Types, Features, Functions
What is Coordinate Measuring Machine? CMM Types, Features, FunctionsWhat is Coordinate Measuring Machine? CMM Types, Features, Functions
What is Coordinate Measuring Machine? CMM Types, Features, Functions
 
Instruct Nirmaana 24-Smart and Lean Construction Through Technology.pdf
Instruct Nirmaana 24-Smart and Lean Construction Through Technology.pdfInstruct Nirmaana 24-Smart and Lean Construction Through Technology.pdf
Instruct Nirmaana 24-Smart and Lean Construction Through Technology.pdf
 
Working Principle of Echo Sounder and Doppler Effect.pdf
Working Principle of Echo Sounder and Doppler Effect.pdfWorking Principle of Echo Sounder and Doppler Effect.pdf
Working Principle of Echo Sounder and Doppler Effect.pdf
 
8th International Conference on Soft Computing, Mathematics and Control (SMC ...
8th International Conference on Soft Computing, Mathematics and Control (SMC ...8th International Conference on Soft Computing, Mathematics and Control (SMC ...
8th International Conference on Soft Computing, Mathematics and Control (SMC ...
 

Topics in communication system design carrier triple beats

  • 1. 03/09/2020 Topics in Communication System Design: Carrier Triple Beats https://www.microwavejournal.com/articles/3377-topics-in-communication-system-design-carrier-triple-beats 1/19 Sign In Subscribe News Channels eLearning Community Events Buyers Guide Multimedia Magazine Home About Us Contact Us Advertise With Us Submit An Article ERB Members Reprints Privacy Microwave Journal 685 Canton St. Norwood, MA 02062 USA Tel: (781) 769-9750 Fax: (781) 769-5037 For magazine subscriptions and newsletter customer service: Tel: 978-671-0449 Email: mwj@e-circ.net Channels 5G/6G Aerospace & Defense Broadband Cellular/4G/LTE EMC/EMI Industrial/Scientific/Medical IoT/M2M/V2V RFID/GPS/Location RFIC Software/EDA Test & Measurement eLearning Acronyms List Design Tools eBook Library History of Wireless Microwave Basics Webinars White Papers Community Blogs
  • 2. 03/09/2020 Topics in Communication System Design: Carrier Triple Beats https://www.microwavejournal.com/articles/3377-topics-in-communication-system-design-carrier-triple-beats 2/19 Classifieds Section RF & Microwave LinkedIn Group Facebook Twitter Instagram Mobile App Events Webinars Trade Shows Training-User Meetings IMS2020 Online Show Daily European Microwave Week EDI CON Online EDI CON China Multimedia Videos Podcasts Photo Galleries Magazine Current Issue Archives Article Reprints Subscribe Subscription Renewal We use cookies to provide you with a better experience. By continuing to browse the site you are agreeing to our use of cookies in accordance with our Privacy Policy. MWJ China Sign In Subscribe Microwave Journal News Channels
  • 3. 03/09/2020 Topics in Communication System Design: Carrier Triple Beats https://www.microwavejournal.com/articles/3377-topics-in-communication-system-design-carrier-triple-beats 3/19 5G/6G Aerospace & Defense Broadband Cellular/4G/LTE EMC/EMI Industrial/Scientific/Medical IoT/M2M/V2V RFID/GPS/Location RFIC Software/EDA Test & Measurement eLearning Acronyms List Design Tools eBook Library History of Wireless Microwave Basics Webinars White Papers Community Blogs Classifieds Section RF & Microwave LinkedIn Group Facebook Twitter Instagram Mobile App Events Webinars Trade Shows Training-User Meetings IMS2020 Online Show Daily European Microwave Week EDI CON Online EDI CON China Buyers Guide Multimedia Videos Podcasts Photo Galleries Magazine Current Issue Archives Article Reprints Subscribe Subscription Renewal Home » Topics in Communication System Design: Carrier Triple Beats Industry News Semiconductors / Integrated Circuits Topics in Communication System Design: Carrier Triple Beats Analysis of carrier triple beats that create third-order intermodulation interference when two or more carriers are present in one channel January 1, 2002
  • 4. 03/09/2020 Topics in Communication System Design: Carrier Triple Beats https://www.microwavejournal.com/articles/3377-topics-in-communication-system-design-carrier-triple-beats 4/19 Howard Hausman No Comments Technical Feature Topics in Communication System Design: Carrier Triple Beats Related Resources Cadence® AWR Design Environment® Version 15 CMTA Software for Signaling Testers MD8475A/B Zero Bias Schottky Detector Diodes: SZB900 Series Howard Hausman Miteq Inc. Hauppauge, NY Intermodulation interference is typically calculated based on two signals present in the RF or IF bandwidth. When the bandwidth is less than an octave, even-order intermodulation products, such as second- and fourth- order intermodulation interference, are out of band and can be filtered out. Odd-order intermodulation, such as third- and fifth-order products, are in-band interference, with sidebands as close to the carrier as the spacing of the desired carriers. In general, these signals cannot be filtered and must be dealt with by linearizing the system such that the interference is suppressed below the desired dynamic range. Third-order intermodulation, which is created by the mixing of the fundamental of one signal and the second harmonic of the other signal, is usually higher in amplitude than the fifth-order intermodulation product and therefore of primary concern to the system designer. When more than two carriers are present in a channel, third-order intermodulation interference can be created by the multiplication of three fundamental carriers; this is called carrier triple beats (CTB). These spurious signals (CTB) are in-band at a level 6 dB higher than the third-order intermodulation products created from two signals because there is no second harmonic involved in the production of the interference signal. The level of CTB interference is further enhanced by the fact that multiple CTB signals can occur in the same frequency band. The number of interference signals that can be superimposed on any particular channel is related to the number of desired carriers present. Statistically, more CTB interference occurs in the center of the band. Determining Intermodulation Interference Levels CTB interference is a spurious signal created from the interaction of three or more signals summed together in a nonlinear device. The level of the interference signal is related to the levels of the input signals and the nonlinearity of the device. In designing a system, the required operating signal levels and the respective acceptable spurious levels determine the acceptable nonlinearity of the equipment. Given the system's nonlinear characteristics, the acceptable spurious level and the output level of the carriers, the maximum number of carriers can be determined. To determine the maximum operating signal, the nonlinear characteristics of the components are defined and the resultant spurious responses are evaluated. The same analysis is performed in reverse to define the acceptable nonlinearity given an operating signal range. A generalized nonlinear system can be represented by a Taylor series expansion of the nonlinear transfer characteristic. So = a0 + a1 Si + a2 Si 2 + a3 Si 3 + a4 Si 4 + … (1) where So = output signal Si = input signal an = coefficients of the device (n = 0, 1, 2, 3, 4, …)
  • 5. 03/09/2020 Topics in Communication System Design: Carrier Triple Beats https://www.microwavejournal.com/articles/3377-topics-in-communication-system-design-carrier-triple-beats 5/19 For a linear system an = 0 for n > 1 If the device is AC coupled a0 = 0 If Si consists of three signals of equal amplitude, then Si = E1cos(w1 t) + E1cos(w2 t) + E1cos(w3 t) where E1 = peak amplitude w1, w2 and w3 = respective radian frequencies When Si is applied to a nonlinear system, intermodulation products are created in all the higher order terms, proportional to the coefficients of the respective term. Second-order Intermodulation of CTB The second-order intermodulation product of three in-band signals is usually almost an octave away from the desired carriers. In a narrow band system, these signals can easily be filtered and are therefore not considered in the spurious analysis. Appendix A is a detailed derivation of the resultant spectrum of the second-order intermodulation from three in-band signals. The second-order intermodulation term is expressed as Second-order Intermodulation =2nd order= a2 Si 2 = a2 [E1cos(w1 t) + E1cos(w2 t) + E1cos(w3 t)]2 Expanding the terms 2nd order = a2 {[E1cos(w1 t)]2 + [E1cos(w2 t)]2 + [E1cos(w3 t)]2 + 2[E1cos(w1 t) · E1cos(w2 t)] + 2[E1cos(w1 t) · E1cos(w3 t)] + 2[E1cos(w3 t) · E1cos(w2 t)]} (2) All of the terms are the sum or difference frequency of two carriers closely spaced (narrow band). A trigonometric expansion would put all of the interference signals almost an octave away. For systems with a bandwidth less than an octave, these products can be filtered and therefore their effects on the system performance are negated. For the purpose of this analysis the second-order effects of three carriers beating with each other will be considered negligible. CTB Intermodulation Interference Signals CTB intermodulation products are spurious signals due to the cube of the input signal multiplied by the a3 coefficient of the Taylor series expansion. A trigonometric expansion of this term confirms that the interference signals are in-band and therefore cannot be filtered out. An Analysis of Third-order Intermodulation of CTB Signals If Si consists of three signals of equal amplitude:
  • 6. 03/09/2020 Topics in Communication System Design: Carrier Triple Beats https://www.microwavejournal.com/articles/3377-topics-in-communication-system-design-carrier-triple-beats 6/19 Si = E1cos(w1 t) + E1cos(w2 t) + E1cos(w3 t) Third-order CTB =3rd order= a3 Si 3 = a3 [E1cos(w1 t) + E1cos(w2 t) + E1cos(w3 t)]3 (3) Expanding the terms 3rd order = a3 [E1cos(w1 t) + E1cos(w2 t) + E1cos(w3 t)] · {[E1cos(w1 t)]2 + [E1cos(w2 t)]2 + [E1cos(w3 t)]2 + 2[E1cos(w1 t) E1cos(w2 t)]+ 2[E1cos(w1 t) E1cos(w3 t)] + 2[E1cos(w3 t) E1cos(w2 t)]} (4) Multiplying out and combining terms (see Appendix B for the detailed derivation) 3rd order = a3 E13 {[cos(w1 t)]3 + [cos(w2 t)]3 + [cos(w3 t)]3 + 3/2[2cos(w1 t) + 2cos(w2 t) + 2cos(w3 t) + 1/2cos((2w1 -w2 )t) + 1/2cos((2w1 +w2 )t) + 1/2cos((2w1 -w3 )t) + 1/2cos((2w1 +w3 )t) + 1/2cos((2w2 -w1 )t) + 1/2cos((2w2 +w1 )t) + 1/2cos((2w3 -w1 )t) + 1/2cos((2w3 +w1 )t) + 1/2cos((2w2 -w3 )t) + 1/2cos((2w2 +w3 )t) + 1/2cos((2w3 -w2 )t) + 1/2cos((2w3 +w2 )t) + (6/4)cos((w1 -w2 +w3 )t) + (6/4)cos((w1 -w2 -w3 )t) + (6/4)cos((w1 +w2 +w3 )t) + (6/4)cos((w1 +w2 -w3 )t)} (5) Assuming that all carrier frequencies (w1 , w2 , w3 …) are located in a narrow band (much less than an octave) and considering only the in-band terms, other than the fundamental 3rd order (in-band) = a3 E13 · {1/2cos((2w1 -w2 )t) + 1/2cos((2w1 -w3 )t) + 1/2cos((2w2 -w1 )t) + 1/2cos((2w3 -w1 )t) + 1/2cos((2w2 -w3 )t) + 1/2cos((2w3 -w2 )t) + (6/4)cos((w1 -w2 +w3 )t) + (6/4)cos((w1 -w2 -w3 )t) + (6/4)cos((w1 +w2 -w3 )t)} (6) The resultant frequencies are 2 Sig 3rd order (2w2 -w1 ) and CTB. The relative amplitudes are (1/2)a3 E13 and (6/4)a3 E13 , respectively. The CTB signals are three times higher than the third-order intermodulation products when more than two carriers are present. Two Signal, Third-order Intermodulation Distortion The resultant frequencies are (see Appendix B for the derivation) 2w1 -w2 and 2w2 -w1 . The relative amplitudes are (3/4)a3 E13 for both.
  • 7. 03/09/2020 Topics in Communication System Design: Carrier Triple Beats https://www.microwavejournal.com/articles/3377-topics-in-communication-system-design-carrier-triple-beats 7/19 Fig. 1 Third-order intermodulation levels for a typical 10 dB gain amplifier. Fig. 2 Two-tone, third-order intermodulation levels. CTB Levels Compared to Third-order Intermodulation A tabulation of the third-order intermodulation is listed in Table 1 . Table 1 Third-order Intermodulation Distortion Two Signals CTB Relative amplitude (3/4)a3 E13 (6/4)a3 E13 The CTB intermodulation is 6 dB higher than the two-tone, third-order intermodulation products. The level of a single carrier triple beat product can therefore be determined by using the familiar equations for two-tone, third- order intermodulation product interference. The two-tone, third-order intermodulation product interference is determined by noting the relative single carrier power with respect to the third-order intercept point (usually 10 db above the 1 dB compression point), as shown in Figure 1 . IP3 = -2(I3rd -A) CTB = IP3 +6 dB where IP3 = relative third-order intermodulation level (dBc) CTB = relative carrier triple beat intermodulation level (dBc) A = signal 1 amplitude = signal 2 amplitude (dBm) I3rd = third-order intercept point (dBm) dBc = relative level of the intermodulation with respect to the single carrier amplitude (A) An example for two output signals of equal amplitude A, as shown in Figure 2 , is A = +3 dBm I3rd = +20 dBm IP3 = -34 dBc (absolute level = -31 dBm) Three carriers of equal amplitude A will have a CTB interference of CTB = IP3 - 6 dB = -34 dBc + 6 dB = -28 dBc (-25 dBm), as shown in Figure 3 . The three interference signals each down 28 dBc are products of the three carriers at frequencies w1 , w2 and w3 . The lowest interference signal is at frequency w1 +w2 -w3 . In the center the interference signal is at frequency w3 +w1 -w2 and the highest frequency is at w3 +w2 -w1 . Calculating CTB Intermodulation Levels for N Equal Amplitude Signals Unlike third-order intermodulation interference, CTB signals can overlap each other and add noncoherently. This considerably increases the overall spurious in any given channel. The total spurious interference is related to the number of carriers and the position of the carrier, that is, carriers at the ends of the bandwidth have less interference
  • 8. 03/09/2020 Topics in Communication System Design: Carrier Triple Beats https://www.microwavejournal.com/articles/3377-topics-in-communication-system-design-carrier-triple-beats 8/19 Fig. 3 Carrier triple beat intermodulation diagram. products than channels in the center of the band. The number of interference carriers (beats) in any channel is given by where beats = number of interference carriers in the measured channel N = number channels M = number of the measured channel, 1 ≤ M ≤ N The maximum number of interference carriers occurs in the center of the band (M » N/2). For N >> 1, the maximum number of beats (beatmax ) is given by The worst-case level of CTB can be arrived at by calculating the level of each CTB (which is the third-order intermodulation level + 6 dB), adding noncoherently the number of beat signals that will fall into the respective band (the worst-case being in the center of the band). The CTB interference can therefore be determined using CTB = 2(I3rd -carrier) + 6 + 10log(beatmax ) (8) where I3rd = third-order intercept point (dBm) carrier = single carrier output signal level (dBm) beatmax = number of interference products in any signal channel In terms of the total number of carriers N For example, I3rd = +15 carrier = -20 dBm N = 24 CTB = -45.5 dBc Calculating the Number of Carriers in a Given Channel Inversely, the total number of carriers that can be multiplexed into a single channel, knowing the required CTB interference level, can be calculated assuming that all of the interference signals are noncoherent and the bandwidth is wide enough for all of the carriers to exist with acceptable adjacent channel interference. The total number of carriers N is given by
  • 9. 03/09/2020 Topics in Communication System Design: Carrier Triple Beats https://www.microwavejournal.com/articles/3377-topics-in-communication-system-design-carrier-triple-beats 9/19 where CTB = maximum acceptable CTB interference level (dBc) I3rd = third-order intercept point (dBm) carrier = single carrier output signal level (dBm) N = number of modulated carriers As an example, CTB = ≤ -57.6 dBc I3rd = +20 dBm carrier = -15 dBm The relative third-order intermodulation level is IP3 (dBc) = -2 (I3rd -A) where A = signal 1 amplitude = Signal 2 amplitude (dBm) For N output signals A = +3 dBm I3rd = +20 dBm IP3 = -34 dBc (absolute level = -31 dBm) First check to see that the two-tone, third-order intermodulation interference is below the required specification where A = +3 dBm IP3 = -2(I3rd - carrier) = -2(20 - (-15)) = -70 dBc This obviously meets the desired criteria. The total number of carriers considering CTB interference is N = 5.909 = 5 carriers It should be noted that this analysis is valid for CW carriers, which should be considered a worst-case signal. Modulated carriers exhibit spectrum spreading, which in effect will lower the intermodulation interference. Table 2 is convenient for estimating the number of carriers that a given bandwidth could sustain (neglecting the bandwidth of the carrier, interchannel interference and available system bandwidth). Across the top is the level
  • 10. 03/09/2020 Topics in Communication System Design: Carrier Triple Beats https://www.microwavejournal.com/articles/3377-topics-in-communication-system-design-carrier-triple-beats 10/19 of each carrier (assuming all the carriers are the same level) below the third-order intercept point. To the left is the acceptable interference level. Table 2 Number of Carriers in a Single Channel Level Below Third-order Intercept 20 dB 25 dB 30 dB 35 dB 40 dB CTB (dBc) Number of Carriers -20 14 44 141 448 1420 -25 7 25 79 252 797 -30 4 14 44 141 448 -35 2 7 25 79 252 -40 1 4 14 44 141 -45 0 2 7 25 79 -50 0 1 4 14 44 -55 0 0 2 7 25 -60 0 0 1 4 14 -65 0 0 0 2 7 -70 0 0 0 1 4 -75 0 0 0 0 2 -80 0 0 0 0 1 Conclusion Determining the capacity of a channel is more involved than allocating enough bandwidth. CTB interference is an important factor to consider when a channel is loaded with many carriers. It has been shown that the
  • 11. 03/09/2020 Topics in Communication System Design: Carrier Triple Beats https://www.microwavejournal.com/articles/3377-topics-in-communication-system-design-carrier-triple-beats 11/19 interference level increases as the square of the increase in the number of carriers. The worst-case interference is in the center of the band where there are more combinations of frequencies in a given channel. At the ends of the band the interference levels go down, but unless the power level of the carriers in the center are lower than the carrier powers at the band edges, it is prudent to assume the worst interference for the system design. Although the problem is critical as the number of carriers increase, it should be noted that even with only three in-band carriers, the interference level is more than 6 dB above that calculated for two-signal, third-order intermodulation. It must be noted that this is a worst-case analysis. Most modulated carriers exhibit a band spreading that lowers the average spectral density, which will somewhat lower the respective interference. References 1. S. Winder, "Single Tone Intermodulation Testing," RF Design , December 1993. 2. M. Leffel, "Intermodulation Distortion in a Multi-signal Environment," RF Design , June 1995. 3. R. Hawkins, "Combining Gain, Noise Figure and Intercept Points for Cascaded Circuit Elements," RF Design , March 1990. 4. J. Waltrich, "Compute CTB in Hybrid Fiber/Coax Systems," Microwaves & RF , December 1998. 5. D. Henkes and S. Kwok, "Intermodulation: Concepts and Calculations," Applied Microwaves & Wireless , July/August 1997. Howard Hausman received his BSEE and MSEE degrees from Polytechnic University and is currently chief technology engineer at Miteq Inc. During his career he has designed microwave systems and components for satellite communications, radar and reconnaissance, which includes receivers, transmitters and synthesizers. Mr. Hausman is also an adjunct professor at Polytechnic University, where he teaches graduate courses in electrical engineering, and has been an adjunct professor at Hofstra University. He has presented lectures and authored papers relating to microwave and communication systems. Appendix A Derivation of second-Order Intermodulation of Three In-Band Signals This analysis is presented to show that the second-order effects are out of band (assuming a narrow band system) even when there are more than two carriers present. Second-order intermodulation of three in-band signals is usually almost an octave away from the desired carriers. In a narrow band system, these signals can be easily filtered and therefore not considered in the spurious analysis. This is a derivation of the resultant spectrum of second-order intermodulation on three in- band signals. Second-order intermodulation of CTB Second-order Intermodulation = 2nd order = a2 Si 2 = a2 [E1cos(w1 t) + E1cos(w2 t) + E1cos(w3 t)]2 Expanding the terms: 2nd order = a2 {[E1cos(w1 t)]2 + [E1cos(w2 t)]2 + [E1cos(w3 t)]2 + 2[E1cos(w1 t) · E1cos(w2 t)] + 2[E1cos(w1 t) · E1cos(w3 t)] + 2[E1cos(w3 t) · E1cos(w2 t)]} If all of the carriers are in a narrow frequency band the second-order products are approximately an octave away. Systems less than an octave wide can filter these products and therefore negate their effects on the system performance. For the purpose of this analysis the second-order effects of three carriers beating with each other will be considered negligible. Appendix B Derivation of the Carrier Triple Beat (CTB) Equations and the Third-Order Intermodulation Equations The following trigonometric expansion shows how CTB interference is formed. It should be noted that in addition to carrier triple beat terms there are two-tone intermodulation terms (below the CTBs) and fundamental
  • 12. 03/09/2020 Topics in Communication System Design: Carrier Triple Beats https://www.microwavejournal.com/articles/3377-topics-in-communication-system-design-carrier-triple-beats 12/19 terms that cause the familiar signal compression as the signal level increases. Third-Order intermodulation of CTB Third-order CTB = 3rd order = a3 Si 3 = a3 [E1cos(w1 t) + E1cos(w2 t) + E1cos(w3 t)]3 Expanding the terms: 3rd order = a3 [E1cos(w1 t) + E1cos(w2 t) + E1cos(w3 t)] · {[E1cos(w1 t)]2 + [E1cos(w2 t)]2 + [E1cos(w3 t)]2 + 2[E1cos(w1 t) · E1cos(w2 t)] + 2[E1cos(w1 t) · E1cos(w3 t)] + 2[E1cos(w3 t) E1cos(w2 t)]} Multiplying out the cube term 3rd order CTB = a3 {[E1cos(w1 t)]3 + [E1cos(w2 t)]3 + [E1cos(w3 t)]3 + 3[E1cos(w1 t)]2 · [E1cos(w2 t)] + 3[E1cos(w1 t)]2 · [E1cos(w3 t)] + 3[E1cos(w1 t)] · [E1cos(w2 t)]2 + 3[E1cos(w1 t)] · [E1cos(w3 t)]2 + 3[E1cos(w2 t)]2 · [E1cos(w3 t)] + 3[E1cos(w2 t)] · [E1cos(w3 t)]2 + 6[E1cos(w1 t)] · [E1cos(w2 t)] · [E1cos(w3 t)]} Using the respective trigonometric identities for the resultant square term: 3rd order = a3 E13 {[cos(w1 t)]3 + [cos(w2 t)]3 + [cos(w3 t)]3 + {3[1/2 + (1/2)cos(2w1 t)] cos(w2 t) + 3[1/2 + (1/2)cos(2w1 t)] cos(w3 t) + 3[1/2 + (1/2)cos(2w2 t )] cos(w1 t) + 3[1/2 + (1/2)cos(2w3 t)] cos(w1 t) + 3[1/2 + (1/2)cos(2w2 t)] cos(w3 t)+ 3[1/2 + (1/2)cos(2w3 t)] cos(w2 t) + 6[cos(w1 t) cos(w2 t) cos(w3 t)]} Multiplying out the cube term: 3rd order = a3 E13 {[cos(w1 t)]3 + [cos(w2 t)]3 + [cos(w3 t)]3 + [3/2 cos(w2 t) + (3/2)cos(2w1 t) cos(w2 t) + (3/2)cos(w3 t) + (3/2)cos(2w1 t ) cos(w3 t) + 3/2 cos(w1 t) + (3/2)cos (2w2 t ) cos(w1 t) + (3/2)cos(w1 t) + (3/2)cos (2w3 t) · cos(w1 t) + (3/2)cos(w3 t) + (3/2)cos(2w2 t )cos(w3 t) + (3/2)cos(w2 t) + (3/2)cos(2w3 t) cos(w2 t) + 6[cos(w1 t) cos(w2 t)cos(w3 t)]} Factor out 3/2 3rd order = a3 E13 {[cos(w1 t)]3 + [cos(w2 t)]3 + [cos(w3 t)]3 + {3/2[cos(w2 t) + cos(2w1 t) cos(w2 t) + cos(w3 t) + cos(2w1 t ) cos(w3 t) + cos(w1 t) + cos(2w2 t) cos(w1 t) + cos(w1 t) + cos(2w3 t ) · cos(w1 t) + cos(w3 t) + cos(2w2 t) cos(w3 t) + cos(w2 t) + cos(2w3 t) cos(w2 t)] + 6[cos(w1 t) cos(w2 t) cos(w3 t)]} Combine 1st order terms 3rd order = a3 E13 {[cos(w1 t)]3 + [cos(w2 t)]3 + [cos(w3 t)]3 + 3/2[2 cos(w1 t) + 2cos(w2 t) + 2cos(w3 t) + cos(2w1 t) cos(w2 t)
  • 13. 03/09/2020 Topics in Communication System Design: Carrier Triple Beats https://www.microwavejournal.com/articles/3377-topics-in-communication-system-design-carrier-triple-beats 13/19 + cos(2w1 t) cos(w3 t) + cos(2w2 t) cos(w1 t) + cos(2w3 t) · cos(w1 t) + cos(2w2 t )cos(w3 t) + cos(2w3 t) cos(w2 t)] + 6[cos(w1 t) cos(w2 t)cos(w3 t)]} Expand the third-order terms 3rd order = a3 E13 {[cos(w1 t)]3 + [cos(w2 t)]3 + [cos(w3 t)]3 + 3/2[2 cos(w1 t) + 2cos(w2 t) + 2cos(w3 t) + (1/2)cos((2w1 -w2 )t) + (1/2)cos((2w1 +w2 )t) + (1/2)cos((2w1 -w3 )t) + (1/2)cos((2w1 +w3 )t) + (1/2)cos((2w2 -w1 )t) + (1/2)cos((2w2 +w1 )t) + (1/2)cos((2w3 -w1 )t) + (1/2)cos((2w3 +w1 )t) + (1/2)cos((2w2 -w3 )t) + (1/2)cos((2w2 +w3 )t) + (1/2)cos((2w3 -w2 )t) + (1/2)cos((2w3 +w2 )t) + 6[(1/2)cos((w1 -w2 )t) + (1/2)cos((w1 +w2 )t)]cos(w3 t)} Further expand the third-order terms 3rd order = a3 E13 {[cos(w1 t)]3 + [cos(w2 t)]3 + [cos(w3 t)]3 + 3/2[2 cos(w1 t) + 2cos(w2 t) + 2cos(w3 t) + (1/2)cos((2w1 -w2 )t) + (1/2)cos((2w1 +w2 )t) + (1/2)cos((2w1 -w3 )t) + (1/2)cos((2w1 +w3 )t) + (1/2)cos((2w2 -w1 )t) + (1/2)cos((2w2 +w1 )t) + (1/2)cos((2w3 -w1 )t) + (1/2)cos((2w3 +w1 )t) + (1/2)cos((2w2 -w3 )t) + (1/2)cos((2w2 +w3 )t) + (1/2)cos((2w3 -w2 )t) + (1/2)cos((2w3 +w2 )t) + 6[(1/4)cos((w1 -w2 +w3 )t) + (1/4)cos((w1 -w2 -w3 )t) + (1/4)cos((w1 +w2 +w3 )t) + (1/4)cos((w1 +w2 -w3 )t)]} Third-order Intermodulation Interference Signals Third-order intermodulation products are spurious signals due to the cube of the input signal multiplied by the a3 coefficient of the Taylor series expansion. Third-order Intermodulation = 3rd order = a3 Si 3 = a3 [E1cos(w1 t) + E1cos(w2 t)]3 Expanding the terms: 3rd order = a3 [E1cos(w1 t) + E1cos(w2 t)] · {[E1cos(w1 t)]2 + [E1cos(w2 t)]2 + 2[E1cos(w1 t) · E1cos(w2 t)]} Factoring out the cube term and using the respective trigonometric identities for the resultant square term: 3rd order = a3 E13 {cos(w1 t) + cos(w2 t)} {[1/2 + (1/2)cos(2w1 t)] + [1/2 + (1/2)cos(2w2 t)] + [cos(w1 t-w2 t) + cos(w1 t+w2 t)]} Multiplying out the cube term: 3rd order = a3 E13 {cos(w1 t) + cos(w2 t) + [[(1/2)cos(2w1 t)] · [cos(w1 t)] + cos(w2 t)] + [[(1/2)cos(2w2 t)] · [cos(w1 t) + cos(w2 t)]] + [[cos(w1 t-w2 t)] · [cos(w1 t) + cos(w2 t)]] + [[cos(w1 t+w2 t)] · [cos(w1 t) + cos(w2 t)]]} If the system is less than an octave in bandwidth, all of the frequency terms that are added (w1 + w2 ) are filtered out and can be discarded in this analysis:
  • 14. 03/09/2020 Topics in Communication System Design: Carrier Triple Beats https://www.microwavejournal.com/articles/3377-topics-in-communication-system-design-carrier-triple-beats 14/19 3rd order = a3 E13 {cos(w1 t) + cos(w2 t) + (1/4)cos(w1 t ) + (1/4) [cos(2w1 t-w2 t)] + (1/4)cos(2w2 t-w1 t) + (1/4)cos(w2 t) + (1/2)[cos(2w1 t-w2 t) + cos(-w2 t) + cos(w1 t-2w2 t) + cos(w1 t)] + 1/2[cos(w2 t) + cos(w1 t)]} Note: cos(-w2 t) = cos(w2 t) and cos(w1 t-2w2 t) = cos(2w2 t-w1 t) Combining terms: 3rd order = a3 E13 {(9/4)cos(w1 t) + (9/4)cos(w2 t) + (3/4)cos(2w1 t-w2 t) + (3/4)cos(2w2 t-w1 t)} The resultant spectral frequencies are at: Frequency w1 , w2 , 2w1 -w2 , 2w2 -w1 Relative Amplitude (9/4) a3 E13 (9/4) a3 E13 (3/4) a3 E13 (3/4) a3 E13 The third-order intermodulation produces signals at the input frequencies and two side bands on either side of the input frequencies. The coefficient a3 is typically 180° out of phase with the coefficient a1. In cases where the input is a single signal, this out of phase relationship effectively reduces the output level when the input signal becomes large. The effective reduction is related to the a3 coefficient. This suggests a relationship between third-order intermodulation levels and single signal compression points (the 1 dB output gain compression level is typically 10 dB below the third-order output intercept point). Related Articles China Mobile Market, MWs in Space and the State-of- Communication ICs in China - topics in EDI CON keynotes Agilent Technologies' Integrated 3D Electromagnetic Simulation and Advanced Design System EDA Platform Speeds Design, Verification EMDS-for-ADS Reduces Steps in Module, Board, Planar Antenna Design Post a comment to this article Name* E-mail (will not be displayed)* Subject Comment* Create Comment Reset
  • 15. 03/09/2020 Topics in Communication System Design: Carrier Triple Beats https://www.microwavejournal.com/articles/3377-topics-in-communication-system-design-carrier-triple-beats 15/19 Free Newsletter Subscribe Now Current Issue Digital Edition How Drone Technology Will Revolutionize Satellite Antenna TestingThe Growing Importance of Oscillators With 5GImproving Stability and Accuracy of High Frequency VNA Measurements Over DistanceCable Dielectric Minimizes Phase Change Over Temperature1200 W LDMOS Power Transistor Targets Particle AcceleratorsNew Products Buyer's Guide Buyer's GuideGet Listed Popular Posts Survey of mmWave Semiconductor Test Systems
  • 16. 03/09/2020 Topics in Communication System Design: Carrier Triple Beats https://www.microwavejournal.com/articles/3377-topics-in-communication-system-design-carrier-triple-beats 17/19 Digital Edition Online Edition Home About Us Contact Us Advertise With Us Submit An Article ERB Members Reprints Privacy Microwave Journal 685 Canton St. Norwood, MA 02062 USA Tel: (781) 769-9750 Fax: (781) 769-5037 For magazine subscriptions and newsletter customer service: Tel: 978-671-0449 Email: mwj@e-circ.net
  • 17. 03/09/2020 Topics in Communication System Design: Carrier Triple Beats https://www.microwavejournal.com/articles/3377-topics-in-communication-system-design-carrier-triple-beats 16/19 GaN Solutions for Wide Bandwidths and High Frequencies How Drone Technology Will Revolutionize Satellite Antenna Testing The Growing Importance of Oscillators With 5G IMS2020 Virtual Exhibition Product Highlights Featured Videos Frequency Matters Aug 24: BEACH Episode, Aug issue & IMS2020/2021 See More Videos Subscribe here to receive Microwave Journal How Drone Technology Will Revolutionize Satellite Antenna Testing By Joakim Espeland and Andrian Buchi, QuadSAT, Denmark Subscribe The Growing Importance of Oscillators With 5G By Pasternack, Irvine, Calif. Improving Stability and Accuracy of High Frequency VNA Measurements Over Distance By Stan Oda, Anritsu, Morgan Hill, Calif.
  • 18. 03/09/2020 Topics in Communication System Design: Carrier Triple Beats https://www.microwavejournal.com/articles/3377-topics-in-communication-system-design-carrier-triple-beats 18/19 Microwave Journal Copyright ©2020. All Rights Reserved Design, CMS, Hosting & Web Development | ePublishing News Channels 5G/6G Aerospace & Defense Broadband Cellular/4G/LTE EMC/EMI Industrial/Scientific/Medical IoT/M2M/V2V RFID/GPS/Location RFIC Software/EDA Test & Measurement eLearning Acronyms List Design Tools eBook Library History of Wireless Microwave Basics Webinars White Papers Community Blogs Classifieds Section RF & Microwave LinkedIn Group Facebook Twitter Instagram Mobile App Events Webinars Trade Shows Training-User Meetings IMS2020 Online Show Daily European Microwave Week EDI CON Online EDI CON China Buyers Guide Multimedia Videos Podcasts
  • 19. 03/09/2020 Topics in Communication System Design: Carrier Triple Beats https://www.microwavejournal.com/articles/3377-topics-in-communication-system-design-carrier-triple-beats 19/19 Photo Galleries Magazine Current Issue Archives Article Reprints Subscribe Subscription Renewal