READER-RESPONSE THEORY
A.Mohanraj M.A., M.Phil., CCFE., (Ph.D)
Assistant Professor of English,
SBK College, Aruppukottai – 626 101.
*Acknowledged – Some points and pictures have been taken from internet sources as I acknowledge them.
‘Do not worry aboutwhat criticssay. What is
your response?’
 Root as early as the 1930s
 The meaning of a text is contained in the text,
and it is not the product of the author or
reader.
THE INTENTIONAL FALLACY and
THE AFFECTIVE FALLACY
 INTENTIONAL FALLACY, term used in 20th
century literary criticism to describe
the problem inherent in trying to
judge a work of art by assuming
the intent or purpose of the artist who
created it.
 Introduced by W.K. Wimsatt, Jr., and
Monroe C. Beardsley in The Verbal
Icon (1954),
Affective fallacy evaluating a text on the basis
of its emotional effects on a reader
 ‘Objectivity of the text is an
illusion’ as Stanley Fish
would say.
 A work is not an achieved
structure of meanings...
the result or the outcome
of the evolving process of
reading.
 The work has no
independent existence.
 Readers do not merely consume the texts
passively; instead they are actively involved in
constructing a meaning out of it.
It comes into existence, and acquires life only when
a reader reads. The reader is absent when the writer
writes, and the writer is normally absent when the
reader reads.
 Readers can be classified broadly into two the ideal
and the actual. The usual tendency on our part is to
ignore the actual reader, ant then idealise readers.
 Kenneth Burke’s essay ‘Psychology and Form’ is a
good starting point for a discussion on readers and
reading---Different readers have different
expectations from a work and they ask different
questions.
IMPLIED READER
 Wolfgang Iser
 As the term suggests, the implied reader
is a hypothetical figure who is likely to
get most of what the author intended.
When authors write, they often do so
with certain readers in mind,
believing that this implied reader will
understand—or at least appreciate—
the metaphors, allusions, ironies, and so
forth.
IMPLIED AUTHOR
 Wayne Booth
 The implied author is a concept of
literary criticism developed in the
20th century. Distinct from the
author and the narrator, the term
refers to the "authorial character"
that a reader gathers from a text
based on the way a literary work
is written.
COMPETENT READER
 Jonathan Culler
 one who learnt or
mastered the skills
required to understand or
interpret a text. Such as
metaphor, the simile, etc.
PHENOMENOLOGICALAPPROACH
 Wolfgang Iser
 meaning is not contained in the text itself, but
generated in the reading process. Meaning is the
result of an interaction between the text and the
reader.
AFFECTIVE STYLISTICS
 It is usually associated with Stanley Fish. It is also based on
the assumption that the literary text is not just an object that
exists, but takes its existence from the act of reading.
 Structure of the text as it occurs from moment to moment,
when it undergoes the process of being read. Word-by-word,
or phrase-by-phrase. Another one is travels from one word to
another.
Not only do different readers read one and the same
text differently but the same reader may read one and
the same text differently on different occasions. A
text is not a physical object alone, but it is something
like an event, and an interaction with the reader
creates the text.
Three types:
 Transactional Reader-response Theory
 Subjective Reader-response Theory
 Psychological Reader-response Theory
TRANSACTIONALREADER-RESPONSE
 This theory was originally formulated by Louise Rosenblatt.
 Transaction between the text and the reader – text corrects
our interpretations – our approach should be aesthetic, and
not merely focussing on the facts contained in the text.
Wordsworth’s ‘Lucy’
A slumber did my spirit seal;
I had no human fears:
She seemed a thing that could not feel
The touch of earthly years.
No motion has she now, no force:
She neither hears nor sees,
Rolled round in earth's diurnal course
With rocks and stones and trees.
Two statements, in each stanzas.
I – narrator
She – protagonist (unknown) – assumed Lucy
Stanza one – she is not die
Stanza two – she is dead
The gap between the two stanza filled
by the reader.
Stanza one – she it ‘thing’
Stanza two – she achieved ‘immortality’
 Hopkin’s The Windhover
 Edger Allan Poe’s The Purloined Letter
 Henry James’ The Figure in the Carpet
SUBJECTIVE READER-RESPONSE
 David Bleich is the major spokesman of this
theory.
 Text guides and controls the reader in the reading
process. The text serves as the base.
 According to him, reading is wholly a subjective
matter – reader’s interpretations create the literary
text. He talks about real and symbolic objects. The
act of reading creates a conceptual, symbolic
world.
PSYCHOLOGICAL READER-RESPONSE
 Norman Holland advanced this theory.
 We do when we read a literary text is not in any
sense different from what we do in a real-life
situation, psychologically speaking.
 Freudian leanings in the use of concepts.
*Acknowledged – Some points and pictures have been taken from internet sources as I acknowledge them.

Reader response theory

  • 1.
    READER-RESPONSE THEORY A.Mohanraj M.A.,M.Phil., CCFE., (Ph.D) Assistant Professor of English, SBK College, Aruppukottai – 626 101. *Acknowledged – Some points and pictures have been taken from internet sources as I acknowledge them.
  • 10.
    ‘Do not worryaboutwhat criticssay. What is your response?’  Root as early as the 1930s  The meaning of a text is contained in the text, and it is not the product of the author or reader.
  • 12.
    THE INTENTIONAL FALLACYand THE AFFECTIVE FALLACY  INTENTIONAL FALLACY, term used in 20th century literary criticism to describe the problem inherent in trying to judge a work of art by assuming the intent or purpose of the artist who created it.  Introduced by W.K. Wimsatt, Jr., and Monroe C. Beardsley in The Verbal Icon (1954),
  • 13.
    Affective fallacy evaluatinga text on the basis of its emotional effects on a reader
  • 14.
     ‘Objectivity ofthe text is an illusion’ as Stanley Fish would say.  A work is not an achieved structure of meanings... the result or the outcome of the evolving process of reading.  The work has no independent existence.
  • 15.
     Readers donot merely consume the texts passively; instead they are actively involved in constructing a meaning out of it. It comes into existence, and acquires life only when a reader reads. The reader is absent when the writer writes, and the writer is normally absent when the reader reads.
  • 16.
     Readers canbe classified broadly into two the ideal and the actual. The usual tendency on our part is to ignore the actual reader, ant then idealise readers.  Kenneth Burke’s essay ‘Psychology and Form’ is a good starting point for a discussion on readers and reading---Different readers have different expectations from a work and they ask different questions.
  • 17.
    IMPLIED READER  WolfgangIser  As the term suggests, the implied reader is a hypothetical figure who is likely to get most of what the author intended. When authors write, they often do so with certain readers in mind, believing that this implied reader will understand—or at least appreciate— the metaphors, allusions, ironies, and so forth.
  • 18.
    IMPLIED AUTHOR  WayneBooth  The implied author is a concept of literary criticism developed in the 20th century. Distinct from the author and the narrator, the term refers to the "authorial character" that a reader gathers from a text based on the way a literary work is written.
  • 19.
    COMPETENT READER  JonathanCuller  one who learnt or mastered the skills required to understand or interpret a text. Such as metaphor, the simile, etc.
  • 20.
    PHENOMENOLOGICALAPPROACH  Wolfgang Iser meaning is not contained in the text itself, but generated in the reading process. Meaning is the result of an interaction between the text and the reader.
  • 21.
    AFFECTIVE STYLISTICS  Itis usually associated with Stanley Fish. It is also based on the assumption that the literary text is not just an object that exists, but takes its existence from the act of reading.  Structure of the text as it occurs from moment to moment, when it undergoes the process of being read. Word-by-word, or phrase-by-phrase. Another one is travels from one word to another.
  • 22.
    Not only dodifferent readers read one and the same text differently but the same reader may read one and the same text differently on different occasions. A text is not a physical object alone, but it is something like an event, and an interaction with the reader creates the text.
  • 23.
    Three types:  TransactionalReader-response Theory  Subjective Reader-response Theory  Psychological Reader-response Theory
  • 24.
    TRANSACTIONALREADER-RESPONSE  This theorywas originally formulated by Louise Rosenblatt.  Transaction between the text and the reader – text corrects our interpretations – our approach should be aesthetic, and not merely focussing on the facts contained in the text.
  • 25.
    Wordsworth’s ‘Lucy’ A slumberdid my spirit seal; I had no human fears: She seemed a thing that could not feel The touch of earthly years. No motion has she now, no force: She neither hears nor sees, Rolled round in earth's diurnal course With rocks and stones and trees.
  • 26.
    Two statements, ineach stanzas. I – narrator She – protagonist (unknown) – assumed Lucy Stanza one – she is not die Stanza two – she is dead The gap between the two stanza filled by the reader. Stanza one – she it ‘thing’ Stanza two – she achieved ‘immortality’
  • 27.
     Hopkin’s TheWindhover  Edger Allan Poe’s The Purloined Letter  Henry James’ The Figure in the Carpet
  • 29.
    SUBJECTIVE READER-RESPONSE  DavidBleich is the major spokesman of this theory.  Text guides and controls the reader in the reading process. The text serves as the base.  According to him, reading is wholly a subjective matter – reader’s interpretations create the literary text. He talks about real and symbolic objects. The act of reading creates a conceptual, symbolic world.
  • 30.
    PSYCHOLOGICAL READER-RESPONSE  NormanHolland advanced this theory.  We do when we read a literary text is not in any sense different from what we do in a real-life situation, psychologically speaking.  Freudian leanings in the use of concepts.
  • 39.
    *Acknowledged – Somepoints and pictures have been taken from internet sources as I acknowledge them.