SlideShare a Scribd company logo
Cognitive & Socio-Emotional
Resilience in Dyslexia
Fumiko Hoeft MD PhD
fumiko.hoeft@ucsf.edu | @fumikohoeft
UC Multicampus Science-based Innovation in Learning Center (SILC)
UCSF LENS | Dept of Psychiatry | Weill Institute for Neurosciences
R01HD078351 (Hoeft, UCSF)
R01HD086168 (Hoeft/Pugh, UCSF/Haskins)
R01HD065794 (Pugh, Haskins)
P01HD001994 (Rueckl, Haskins/UConn)
R01MH104438 (Nordahl, UCDavis/MIND)
R01MH103371 (Amaral, UCDavis/MIND)
FUNDING
Liebe Patterson
Dennis & Shannon Wong – DSEA ‘88 Foundation
Toney & Potter Family
NSF1540854 SL-CN (Gazzaley/Uncapher, UCSF)
Holy Names
University | Raskob School | 01.20.2017
Why is each child so different?
How can we ensure success in each child?
TAIGA
“INFORMATION
SEEKER”
KAITO
“STORY MAN”
“3D MAN”
Empathic
Spiderman
- Halloween
Analytic
Red/White
blood cell
- Halloween
Not a good reader
Avoids reading
Avid reader
Jack Horner, a paleontologist
from Jurassic Park/World
NOW
Technical Advisor of Jurassic Park
(= Dr. Alan Grant)
MacArthur Genius Award (‘86)
Romer-Simpson Medal (’13)
THEN
Severely dyslexic
Graduated high school with D---
Failed college 7 times
Never graduated
GPA 0.06
(Honorary doctorate, ’06)
Importance of resilience
Importance of environment & community
Importance of looking at an individual as a whole
(including literacy but also other cognitive and
socio-emotional aspects) 3
Outline
• BACKGROUND
– Dyslexia costly in many dimensions
– Importance of an integrative approach
• TODAY’S FOCUS (CURRENT WORK)
– The resilience framework of dyslexia
– Cognitive resilience
– Socio-Emotional resilience
• CONCLUSION & THE FUTURE
Background | Resilience Framework | Cognitive Resilience | Socio-Emotional Resilience | Conclusion
Outline
• BACKGROUND
– Dyslexia costly in many dimensions
– Importance of an integrative approach
• TODAY’S FOCUS (CURRENT WORK)
– The resilience framework of dyslexia
– Cognitive resilience
– Socio-Emotional resilience
• CONCLUSION & THE FUTURE
Background | Resilience Framework | Cognitive Resilience | Socio-Emotional Resilience | Conclusion
Cost of Dyslexia
Risks
Dyslexia
POOR OUTCOME: Reading Comprehension, Educational
Attainment, Psychosocial Adjustment
DLPFC
ORTHOGRAPHIC
PHONOLOGICAL
IF
G
op
Pr
eC
G
SMG
pSTG
FusiG
ITG
Insula
dStr
PPC
SUSCEPTABILITY
GENES
Background | Resilience Framework | Cognitive Resilience | Socio-Emotional Resilience | Conclusion
Cost of Dyslexia is High
Developing dyslexia up to 50% with family history,
(4 times higher)
Cost to individual >£100k less earning ($150k)
Cost to (UK) society >£1bn/year ($1.5bn)
High School drop out 2.5x
Prison population 32-46% (note low IQ and not SLD!)
Anxiety disorder 2.0x (5.0x severe test anxiety)
Depression 2.0x
Substance abuse 2.7x
ADHD 4.5x
Snowling et al. Psychol Bull 2016; Pennington & Lefly. Child Develop 2001; Cosden JLD 2001;
Wilson et al. JLD 2009; Foresight Mental Capital and Wellbeing Project. 2008 ; DuPaul et al.
JLD 2012;
Background | Resilience Framework | Cognitive Resilience | Socio-Emotional Resilience | Conclusion
Latest Thinking on the Factors that Contribute to
Dyslexia: Multiple Factors Contribute
Neurobio
Risk2
Neurobio
Risk1
Neurobio
Protective1
Neurobio
Protective2
Dyslexia
Risk
Pennington. Cognition 2006. Pennington et al. J Abnorm Psychol 2012. – Multiple deficit model
Environment
Risk1
Environment
Protective1
Diathesis-stress model: Rosenthal ed. “The Genain Quadruplets” ‘64
Liability threshold model: Gottesman & Shields. PNAS ‘67
Background | Resilience Framework | Cognitive Resilience | Socio-Emotional Resilience | Conclusion
Importance of an Integrative Approach to Maximizing
Children’s Learning Potential
Maximizing
children’s
learning
potential
NEUROBIOLOGY
EXTERNAL
ENVIRONMENT
INTERNAL
ENVIRONMENT
STEREOTYPE THREAT
MOTIVATION & MINDSET
RESILIENCE & GRIT
Background | Resilience Framework | Cognitive Resilience | Socio-Emotional Resilience | Conclusion
TODAY’S TOPIC: Cognitive and Socio-Emotional
Resilience in Dyslexia
Maximizing
children’s
learning
potential
NEUROBIOLOGY
EXTERNAL
ENVIRONMENT
INTERNAL
ENVIRONMENT
STEREOTYPE THREAT
MOTIVATION & MINDSET
RESILIENCE & GRIT
Background | Resilience Framework | Cognitive Resilience | Socio-Emotional Resilience | Conclusion
Outline
• BACKGROUND
– Dyslexia costly in many dimensions
– Importance of an integrative approach
• TODAY’S FOCUS (CURRENT WORK)
– The resilience framework of dyslexia
– Cognitive resilience
– Socio-Emotional resilience
• CONCLUSION & THE FUTURE
Background | Resilience Framework | Cognitive Resilience | Socio-Emotional Resilience | Conclusion
Resilience
The ability to adapt to stressors in the
environment (adversity) by “bending” but
not “breaking”
(Karatsoreos & McEwen F1000Prime Reports 2013)
Socio-emotional resilience Cognitive resilience
Background | Resilience Framework | Cognitive Resilience | Socio-Emotional Resilience | Conclusion
Resilience Framework of Dyslexia: Promoting
Resilience & Optimizing Dyslexia Outcome
Risks
Dyslexia
Poor Functional Outcome
• Poor Reading Comprehension
• Negative Psychosocial Adjustment
Haft, Myers, Hoeft. Curr Opin Beh Sci 2016
Stephanie
Haft
Socio-
Emotional
Protect. F.
INTERNAL
• Growth mindset
• Hopeful thinking
• Sense of coherence
• Locus of control
• Self determination
FAMILY
• Family cohesion
• Maternal affect
• Strong parental
attachment
• Parental support &
understanding of RD
PEER/SCHOOL
• Peer relationships
• Mentorship by
teachers
• Teacher support
• Small class-size
Cognitive
Protective
Factors
• Oral language skills
• Motor skills
• Task-focused behavior
• Executive functions
• Interpersonal
relationships
Less Severe
Dyslexia
• Morphological awareness
• Vocabulary
• Verbal reasoning
• Executive functions
• Grammar
Positive Outcome
Weaknesses vs. Relative strengths
Risk vs. Protective factors
Vulnerability vs. Resilience
Background | Resilience Framework | Cognitive Resilience | Socio-Emotional Resilience | Conclusion
The Neuroscience of Dyslexia – Traditional View
Focus on Weaknesses, Risks & Vulnerability
phonological
processing
(visual/selective)
attention
cognitive
implicit procedural learning
short-term memory
information
processing
RELATIVE WEAKNESSES
d
Background | Resilience Framework | Cognitive Resilience | Socio-Emotional Resilience | Conclusion
The Neuroscience of Dyslexia – Traditional View
Focus on Weaknesses, Risks & Vulnerability
Occipito-Temporal (OT)
Orthographic processing
Temporo-Parietal (TP)
Phonological processing
POOR READERS & DYSLEXIA.
Reduced efficiency in brain
networks related to speech &
visual aspects of reading.
Shaywitz et al. NEJM ’98; Hoeft et al. J
Neurosci ‘06. Hoeft et al. PNAS ‘07
Background | Resilience Framework | Cognitive Resilience | Socio-Emotional Resilience | Conclusion
character traits,
socio-emotional
Grit, Resilience,
Mindset, Empathy
The Neuroscience of Dyslexia – Emerging View
Focus Also on Strengths, Protective Factors & Resilience
visuo-spatial
Holistic, 3d
cognitive
explicit memory
comprehension
IQ, reasoning,
oral language …
RELATIVE STRENGTHS phonological
processing
(visual/selective)
attention
cognitive
implicit procedural learning
short-term memory
information
processing
RELATIVE WEAKNESSES
d
Background | Resilience Framework | Cognitive Resilience | Socio-Emotional Resilience | Conclusion
The Neuroscience of Dyslexia – Emerging View
Focus Also on Strengths, Protective Factors & Resilience
Occipito-Temporal (OT)
Orthographic processing
Temporo-Parietal (TP)
Phonological processing
PROTECTIVE FACTORS & RESILIENCE
Which brain systems???
What mechanism???
Coincidence. Bryden MP.
Laterality ’87
Compensatory. Lansdell
HJ. Comp Physio Psychol ‘69,
Levy J. Nature ’69
Causal. Kosslyn SM. Psychol
Rev ’87, Cai et al. PNAS ’13.
Evolutionary
advantage Geschwind N.
Annals of Dyslexia ‘84
Background | Resilience Framework | Cognitive Resilience | Socio-Emotional Resilience | Conclusion
Outline
• BACKGROUND
– Dyslexia costly in many dimensions
– Importance of an integrative approach
(Geschwind Lecture 2014)
• TODAY’S FOCUS (CURRENT WORK)
– The resilience framework of dyslexia
– Cognitive resilience
– Socio-Emotional resilience
• CONCLUSION & THE FUTURE
Background | Resilience Framework | Cognitive Resilience | Socio-Emotional Resilience | Conclusion
Resilience Framework of Dyslexia:
COGNITIVE RESILIENCE
Risks
Dyslexia
Poor Functional Outcome
• Poor Reading Comprehension
• Negative Psychosocial Adjustment
Haft, Myers, Hoeft. Curr Opin Beh Sci 2016
Cognitive
Protective
Factors
• Oral language skills
• Motor skills
• Task-focused behavior
• Executive functions
• Interpersonal
relationships
Less Severe
Dyslexia
• Morphological awareness
• Vocabulary
• Verbal reasoning
• Executive functions
• Grammar
Positive Outcome
Background | Resilience Framework | Cognitive Resilience | Socio-Emotional Resilience | Conclusion
COGNITIVE RESILIENCE
Resilient Dyslexics
RESILIENT READERS: Those
with good comprehension
despite poor decoding.
Those with decoding
difficulties rely more on
contextual information to be
able to read successfully.
INTERACTIVE COMPENSATORY
MODEL OF DYSLEXIA
(Stanovich, 1980)
Implications for intervention.
Smadar
Patael PhD
Laurie
Cutting PhD
Patael et al. under review
Background | Resilience Framework | Cognitive Resilience | Socio-Emotional Resilience | Conclusion
COGNITIVE RESILIENCE
Brain Mechanism?
RESILIENT
READERS
POOR
READERS
TYPICAL
READERS
Expected pattern related to:
RESILIENCE
DECODING
COMPREHENSION
Decoding
Comprehension
TYPICAL
READERS
Good
comprehension but
good decoding alsoPOOR
READERS
Poor decoding but
also poor
comprehension
RESILIENT
READERS
Patael et al. under review
Background | Resilience Framework | Cognitive Resilience | Socio-Emotional Resilience | Conclusion
COGNITIVE RESILIENCE
Left Dorsolateral Prefrontal Cortex (DLPFC)
Resilient > Poor readers
Resilient > Typical readers
RESILIENT
READERS
POOR
READERS
TYPICAL
READERS
RESILIENCE
DECODING
COMPREHENSIO
N
Patael et al. under review
Background | Resilience Framework | Cognitive Resilience | Socio-Emotional Resilience | Conclusion
COGNITIVE RESILIENCE
Not just dyslexics but anyone can have it.
R² = 0.1241
0.3
0.4
0.5
0.6
0.7
0.8
0.9
1
-40 -20 0 20 40
PrefrontalVolume
Cognitive Resilience
10-16yo children with &
without poor decoding
Patael et al. under review
Background | Resilience Framework | Cognitive Resilience | Socio-Emotional Resilience | Conclusion
COGNITIVE RESILIENCE
Chicken or egg? Show signs BEFORE reading failure.
R² = 0.1241
R² = 0.14
0.3
0.4
0.5
0.6
0.7
0.8
0.9
1
-40 -20 0 20 40
PrefrontalVolume
Cognitive Resilience
Prereading kids’ left DLPFC
predicts future ‘resilience’
Patael et al. under review
Background | Resilience Framework | Cognitive Resilience | Socio-Emotional Resilience | Conclusion
COGNITIVE RESILIENCE
Role of DLPFC Network?
-2
0
2
4
6
work
working1back
memory
wm
2back
load
encoded
maintenance
oddball
salient
shifting
attention
distractor
cues
congruent
executive
rule
rehearsalconflictincongruentmonitoring
rules
verbal
verb
visuospatial
spatially
dyslexia
reading
readers
phonology
phonological
phonetic
semantic
semantically
nouns
noun
1000 Functional Connectome. Neurosynth.org
Related to learning, attention, & cognitive flexibility
Fronto-parietal network
Patael et al. under review
Background | Resilience Framework | Cognitive Resilience | Socio-Emotional Resilience | Conclusion
COGNITIVE RESILIENCE
Fronto-parietal network “flexible learning hub”.
Dynamically changes how it
connects to other key
networks based on current
goals.
Critical for learning new skills
and building mental rules.
Allows immediate & flexible
transfer of skills.
Cole et al. Nat Neuroscience ’13
Patael et al. under review
Background | Resilience Framework | Cognitive Resilience | Socio-Emotional Resilience | Conclusion
COGNITIVE RESILIENCE: Summary
• Prefrontal & fronto-parietal
network
• Cognitive flexibility, learning
network
• Related studies also point to
prefrontal mechanisms
• May suggest importance of
promoting activities to enhance
cognitive flexibility & self-
regulation early
Patael et al. under rev; Hoeft et al. PNAS ’07 & PNAS ’11; Hancock Richlan Hoeft. Neurosci Beh Rev
Background | Resilience Framework | Cognitive Resilience | Socio-Emotional Resilience | Conclusion
Outline
• BACKGROUND
– Dyslexia costly in many dimensions
– Importance of an integrative approach
• TODAY’S FOCUS (CURRENT WORK)
– The resilience framework of dyslexia
– Cognitive resilience
– Socio-Emotional resilience
• CONCLUSION & THE FUTURE
Background | Resilience Framework | Cognitive Resilience | Socio-Emotional Resilience | Conclusion
Resilience Model of LD:
SOCIO-EMOTIONAL RESILIENCE
Risks
Dyslexia
Poor Functional Outcome
• Poor Reading Comprehension
• Negative Psychosocial Adjustment
Haft, Myers, Hoeft. Curr Opin Beh Sci 2016
Socio-
Emotional
Protect. F.
INTERNAL
• Growth mindset
• Hopeful thinking
• Sense of coherence
• Locus of control
• Self determination
FAMILY
• Family cohesion
• Maternal affect
• Strong parental
attachment
• Parental support &
understanding of RD
PEER/SCHOOL
• Peer relationships
• Mentorship by
teachers
• Teacher support
• Small class-size
Positive Outcome
Background | Resilience Framework | Cognitive Resilience | Socio-Emotional Resilience | Conclusion
SOCIO-EMOTIONAL RESILIENCE
Character traits critical for success
Self discipline, more predictive
than IQ (2x) & above and beyond
achievement itself
(Duckworth & Seligman, Psychol Sci ‘05)
2x
Above & beyond IQ & achievement
Background | Resilience Framework | Cognitive Resilience | Socio-Emotional Resilience | Conclusion
SOCIO-EMOTIONAL RESILIENCE
Brain mechanisms
VTA
GROWTH MIND-SET:
Belief that ability is effort based
GROWTH MINDSET
COGNITIVE REAPPRAISAL
(Doherty et al. Science ‘04)
INTRINSIC MOTIVATION
(Muyrayama et al. PNAS ’10)
VTA
GRIT:
Perseverance toward a long term goal
GRIT
PERSISTENCE
(Gusnard et al. PNAS ‘03)
FUTURE REWARD
(Doherty et al. Science ’04)
Myers et al. SCAN 2016
Multiple targets – Multiple routes to enhance learning
Chelsea
Myers
Background | Resilience Framework | Cognitive Resilience | Socio-Emotional Resilience | Conclusion
SOCIO-EMOTIONAL RESILIENCE
Stereotype threat may put individuals at risk
“Stereotype threat is being at risk of confirming, as
self-characteristic, a negative stereotype about one’s
group.” –Steele and Aronson (1995)
“White men can’t jump.” “Women are not good at math.”
reducingstereotypethreat.org, Whistling vivaldi by Claude Steele
“African Americans have lower intelligence
than their white peers .”
Background | Resilience Framework | Cognitive Resilience | Socio-Emotional Resilience | Conclusion
SOCIO-EMOTIONAL RESILIENCE
Stereotype threat MAY exist in LDs
Why might individuals with learning disabilities
(including dyslexics, but also ADHD etc) experience
stereotype threat?
• Group identification - low achievement
• Aware of stereotype (Kelly and Norwich, 2004; Rashkind et al., 2006)
• Negative academic self-concept (Zeleke, 2004)
• Low self-esteem, negative affect, anxiety, and
depression when faced with performance-avoidance
goals (the desire to perform less poorly than others)
(Sideridis, 2007; Aquino, 2011)
Background | Resilience Framework | Cognitive Resilience | Socio-Emotional Resilience | Conclusion
SOCIO-EMOTIONAL RESILIENCE
An Integrated Process Model of Stereotype Threat
Concept of
Ability Domain
Concept of
Group
Concept of Self
“I am a
girl…”
“I think I am
good at math…”
“Girls are
bad at math
(and math
is important
to me)…”
Forbes et al., 2008
Discordance leads to stereotype threat
Reduced attention
Stress & Anxiety
Fear & Threat
Reduced learning & memory, & performance
Everyone is prone.
Background | Resilience Framework | Cognitive Resilience | Socio-Emotional Resilience | Conclusion
SOCIO-EMOTIONAL RESILIENCE
Brain mechanism of stereotype threat?
Women & under-
performance in math
Krendl et al. Psychol Sci 2008
Lack of improvement
in math performance
over time under ST
(interaction: p<.005)
Stereotype threat
impacts key
cognitive networks
and emotion-related
networks negatively
Lack of MATH related
activation under ST
Increase in EMOTIONal
response under ST
No ST group ST group No ST group ST group
Background | Resilience Framework | Cognitive Resilience | Socio-Emotional Resilience | Conclusion
SOCIO-EMOTIONAL RESILIENCE
Building Resilience Against Stereotype Threat
• Reframing the task (e.g. Quinn & Spencer, 2001)
• De-emphasizing threatened social identities (e.g. Stricker and
Ward, 2004)
• Role models (e.g. Blanton et al., 2000)
• External attributions for difficulty (e.g. Good et al, 2003)
• Self-affirmations (e.g. Schimel et al., 2004)
• Growth mindset (e.g. Aronson et al., 2002)
Background | Resilience Framework | Cognitive Resilience | Socio-Emotional Resilience | Conclusion
SOCIO-EMOTIONAL RESILIENCE
Strength-based approach may build resilience
von Károlyi et al., ‘01; ‘03; Diehl … Hoeft … Pugh. NeuroImage ‘14
Visuo-spatial processing show yin-yang
relationship with reading
Ken Pugh
R² = 0.1439
reading
visuo-spatial
r=0.42
p<0.05
BEHAVIOR
dyslexics non-dyslexics
BRAIN
Background | Resilience Framework | Cognitive Resilience | Socio-Emotional Resilience | Conclusion
SOCIO-EMOTIONAL RESILIENCE
Mentoring may build resilience
Scores
26.7%
***P<0.0001
12.5%
~*P=0.05
2.5
3
3.5
4
4.5
5
Response to
failure
Depression Self Esteem
Fall Spring
Display more positive emotions and
effort-based strategies in the face of failure.
IMPROVEMENT IN:
SELF ESTEEM (12%)
GRIT (value) (8-36%)
GROWTH MINDSET (14%)
LD IDENTITY (comfort, bond,
importance) (24-52%)
READING SELF-CONCEPT
(19%)
etc…
N=48
Background | Resilience Framework | Cognitive Resilience | Socio-Emotional Resilience | Conclusion
SOCIO-EMOTIONAL RESILIENCE
Mentoring may build resilience
-100
-50
0
50
100
150
1.5 2 2.5 3 3.5
Self-Esteem
(FalltoSpring%increase)
Mentee-Rated Mentorship Quality (1-low to 3-high) N=39
R2=0.13 (r=0.36)
P=0.025
Background | Resilience Framework | Cognitive Resilience | Socio-Emotional Resilience | Conclusion
SOCIO-EMOTIONAL RESILIENCE: Summary
• Stereotype threat & fixed mindset could be potential mechanisms underlying
underperformance in those with learning challenges.
• Others such as anxiety, motivation and reduced grit likely interact with
stereotype threat and fixed mindset, and result in further underperformance.
Dyslexia
Stereotype
Threat
Attention
PF resources Fixed
mindset
Reduced
grit
Reduced academic achievement
Reduced
motivation
Anxiety
Background | Resilience Framework | Cognitive Resilience | Socio-Emotional Resilience | Conclusion
Outline
• BACKGROUND
– Dyslexia costly in many dimensions
– Importance of an integrative approach
• TODAY’S FOCUS (CURRENT WORK)
– The resilience framework of dyslexia
– Cognitive resilience
– Socio-Emotional resilience
• CONCLUSION & THE FUTURE
Background | Resilience Framework | Cognitive Resilience | Socio-Emotional Resilience | Conclusion
CONCLUSION: Promoting Resilience
Risks
Dyslexia
Poor Functional Outcome
• Poor Reading Comprehension
• Negative Psychosocial Adjustment
Haft, Myers, Hoeft. Curr Opin Beh Sci 2016
Socio-
Emotional
Protect. F.
INTERNAL
• Growth mindset
• Hopeful thinking
• Sense of coherence
• Locus of control
• Self determination
FAMILY
• Family cohesion
• Maternal affect
• Strong parental
attachment
• Parental support &
understanding of RD
PEER/SCHOOL
• Peer relationships
• Mentorship by
teachers
• Teacher support
• Small class-size
Cognitive
Protective
Factors
• Oral language skills
• Motor skills
• Task-focused behavior
• Executive functions
• Interpersonal
relationships
Less Severe
Dyslexia
• Morphological awareness
• Vocabulary
• Verbal reasoning
• Executive functions
• Grammar
Positive Outcome
COGNITIVE
TRAINING
SOCIO-
EMOTIONAL
LEARNING
(mentoring)
LITERACY
INTER-
VENTIONS
Background | Resilience Framework | Cognitive Resilience | Socio-Emotional Resilience | Conclusion
CONCLUSION: Promoting Resilience
• Cognitive reappraisal & positive reframing >>> Cognitive
control, self-regulation, grit
• Strength based approach >>> Confidence, Optimism
• Growth mindset – Active coping (sense of control), Optimism
• Social support, role model, mentoring – Connection to
community
• Reduce stereotype threat – Optimize learning environment &
enhanced performance
• Stress inoculation (exposure to tolerable levels of stress &
challenges)
Charney. Nat Rev Neurosci 2009; Ken Ginsberg http://www.fosteringresilience.com/7cs.php
Background | Resilience Framework | Cognitive Resilience | Socio-Emotional Resilience | Conclusion
Can we become resilient?
Background | Resilience Framework | Cognitive Resilience | Socio-Emotional Resilience | Conclusion
Neuroscience Research Space
msec
years
Learning
Cognition, Language
Reading, Math
Perception
Socio-emotional
Preconception
Prenatal
Postnatal
Child
Adult
Adolescent
DEVELOPMENTALSTAGE
Gene
Neurochemistry
Physiology
Neuroanatomy
Behavior
CURRENT/FUTURE WORK @
Socio-emotional,
Character traits
Early identification &
prevention
Mechanisms of
dyslexia, reading &
learning
Community
Background | Resilience Framework | Cognitive Resilience | Socio-Emotional Resilience | Conclusion
Bay Area
UCSF (NC White, R Hendren, K LeWinn, L Pasch, M Gorno-
Tempini, B Miller);
UC Berkeley (S Bunge);
UC Davis (Y Uchikoshi, D Amaral, C Wu Nordahl);
U of SF (G Leung);
USA/Canada
Boston College (J Black);
Georgia State U (R Morris);
Harvard U, Boston Children’s Hospital (L Prock Albers);
MIT (J Gabrieli);
U of British Columbia (L Siegel);
U of Michigan (I Kovelman, R Marks);
Vanderbilt U (L Cutting);
Yale U, Haskins Labs, U Conn (K Pugh, J Reuckl; E Grigorenko);
Asia
Beijing Normal U, China (H Shu);
Hebrew U, Israel (R Frost);
Keio U, Tokyo, Japan (B Yamagata, M Mimura);
Nat’l Cntrl U, Inst of Cog Neurosci, Taiwan (D Wu, O Tseng)
U Hong Kong, China (C McBride);
Europe
BCBL, Spain (M Carreiras);
U College London, UK (C Hulme);
U of Jyvaskyla, Finland (H Lyytinen, P Leppannen, U
Richardson);
U of Salzburg, Austria (F Richlan);
fumiko.hoeft@ucsf.edu | @fumikohoeft | brainlens.org
Background | Resilience Framework | Cognitive Resilience | Socio-Emotional Resilience | Conclusion
POSTDOC & CENTER MANAGER WANTED!
Thank you…
POSTDOC & CENTER MANAGER WANTED!
Background | Resilience Framework | Cognitive Resilience | Socio-Emotional Resilience | Conclusion
fumiko.hoeft@ucsf.edu | @fumikohoeft | brainlens.org
Science-based Innovation in Learning Center
(SILC)
AWARD NAME.
University of California Office of the President (UCOP)
Multicampus Research Programs and Initiatives (MRPI) Award
Grant # MRP-17-454925
DATES
1/1/2017 – 12/31/2019
Science-based Innovation in Learning Center
(SILC)
WHO WE ARE A new and cross-disciplinary ‘Precision Ed-Health’ center
across the (6) UC campuses with expertise in (bilingual) education, sp-ed,
cog psych, neuroscience, medicine, & policy.
Precision Medicine is an emerging data-driven approach for disease treatment and prevention that takes into
account individual variability in environment, lifestyle and genes for each person. (2015)
Precision Ed-Health is an data-driven approach to prevent the spiral effect of poor educational attainment to
health disparity taking into account variability in each child by looking at large amounts of data from the
environment, psychological, cognitive, neuroscience, biomedical information.
MISSION. Tackle issues associated with education and health disparity
with a particular emphasis on underrepresented populations.
LONG-TERM GOAL. To provide the best educational and health outcomes
for ALL CHILDREN regardless of their background.
MODEL. Adoption of STAR (Services, Training, Advocacy, Research)
SHORT TERM GOAL. Early identification and intervention of children at
risk for learning challenges in English learners.
Science-based Innovation in Learning Center
(SILC)
CAMPUSES & KEY PERSONNEL
UCSF. Director: Fumiko Hoeft MD PhD, Neuroscience of LD, Medical science
UC Berkeley. Silvia Bunge PhD, Cognitive neuroscience
UC Davis. Jamal Abedi PhD, English Learners, Macro-data
UC Irvine. Carol Conner PhD, Literacy Instruction
UCLA. Marcelo Suarez-Orozco PhD, Education Policy together with Stanford
University Center for Education Policy Analysis Susanna Loeb PhD
UC Merced. Jeff Gilger PhD, Neuroscience of dyslexia, Training & education
Others. Roeland Hancock for computation and biostatistics, Elissa Epel /
Nicki Bush for health disparity, Nancy Cushen White for intervention and
dyslexia, MariLu Gorno Tempini for language processes, Bob Hendren on
mental health comorbidity, and Linda Siegel on multilingualism and dyslexia
(UBC)
Science-based Innovation in Learning Center
(SILC)
SILC
STAR
SERVICES
• Professional
development
• Intervention
TRAINING
• Multidisciplin
ary
• Faculty,
Postdocs,
Students
ADVOCACY
• US DOE OCR
• CDE
RESEARCH
• Archival
• Prospective
Science-based Innovation in Learning Center
(SILC)
AIM 1.
• To establish a cross-campus interdisciplinary research center to develop STAR
with an initial focus on ELs, RDs, literacy intervention and health disparity.
AIM 2. Mine existing data
• Find out early predictors of literacy acquisition in ELs.
• Adjusting the A2i model for Spanish ELLs.
• Study health outcome measures (obesity, stress, immune, cognitive aging).
AIM 3. Perform a prospective, longitudinal, multisite proof-of-concept study in K-
Gr1.
• Test modified ISI/A2i algorithm.
• Compare predictors of RD-risk.
• Test feasibility of collecting and studying health measures and biomarkers.
Science-based Innovation in Learning Center
(SILC)
Current
(Eng)
Best
(Eng+Sp)
A2i-revised
Research
(non-lang)
Health
Environment
CENTER of INNOVATION IN NEUROSCIENCE-BASED
TECHNOLOGY FOR EEUCATION AND LEARNING
UCSF | UC Berkeley | Stanford
adam bruce fumiko
joaquin jyoti melina
miriam roeland silvia
S I L C
UCSF - Stanford-UC Berkeley
Science of Learning Collaborative Network (SL-CN)
Before Birth PreSch/K 2nd-4thGr Adult
Evidence-based
Precision/Personalized
Education
Early identification
Preventive intervention
fumiko.hoeft@ucsf.edu | @fumikohoeft | brainlens.org
Science-based Innovation in Learning Center
(SILC)
AIM 1.
• To establish a cross-campus interdisciplinary research center to develop
Services, Training, Advocacy and Research (STAR) with an initial focus on ELLs,
RDs, literacy intervention and health disparity.
AIM 2.
• Collaboratively integrate existing rich data on Spanish ELL children across SILC
UC sites to identify candidate early predictors of literacy outcomes and health
outcomes and model child × instruction interactions in ELLs to revise the A2i
algorithm for this population.
AIM 3.
• Perform a prospective, longitudinal, multisite proof-of-concept study in first
grade ELLs to: (a) evaluate the predictive power of early RD-risk measures that
can be used for all ELLs, regardless of native language, and relating these to
health disparity measures; (b) evaluate the effectiveness of the revised A2i
algorithm in improving academic outcomes in Spanish ELLs.
Science-based Innovation in Learning Center
(SILC)
BACKGROUND.
In the US, 9.2% of public school children are English learners (ELs), and EL
enrollment has grown 50% over the past decade, outpacing non-EL enrollment. In
California (CA), a quarter of the school-aged children in the public schools are ELs. ELs are
twice as likely as non-ELs to live in poverty and more likely to be misidentified than non-
ELs for learning disabilities (LDs) such as reading disorders (RD). Learning disabilities and
their misidentification in ELs further contributes to EL inequality in English proficiency and
educational attainment, leading to income and health disparity.
Reducing education-related risks for poor health outcomes in ELs requires
efforts to better understand the link between educational attainment and health disparity
in this population, and early identification of LD in ELs. Although there are good predictors
of RD in English monolinguals, extending these to ELs is complicated by variability in
language experience, lack of English proficiency, variability in the native languages spoken
by ELs, and the lack of normed measures (except Spanish) and qualified practitioners. One
third of all US ELs are in CA, making these issues particularly significant for the state and
UC, while at the same time providing the opportunity for UC to be a leader in addressing
these issues.
Science-based Innovation in Learning Center
(SILC)
SHORT-TERM GOALS.
(1) setup an innovative, multicampus, cross-disciplinary collaboration bridging education,
cognitive sciences, medicine and policy, and
(2) perform a series of pilot studies to examine the links between academic and health
outcomes in ELs and evaluate individualized prescription of reading interventions that
will prepare us to compete for federal center and collaborative research grants in the
near future.
LONG-TERM GOALS.
For the proposed UC center to be a national leader in ‘Precision Ed-Health’, and tackle
issues associated with education and health disparity in underrepresented populations,
with an initial emphasis on early identification and intervention of children at risk for
learning challenges.
CENTRAL MISSION.
Includes performing high quality research and providing training, services and advocacy.
Such efforts will ultimately enhance the lives of children and families, while addressing
major issues in CA and the US, including the cost of education, difficulties of educating
diverse populations including ELs, and the health consequences of poor school
performance.

More Related Content

What's hot

Presentatie psychiose escap 2015 m2 celso arango_escap_final
Presentatie psychiose escap 2015 m2 celso arango_escap_finalPresentatie psychiose escap 2015 m2 celso arango_escap_final
Presentatie psychiose escap 2015 m2 celso arango_escap_finalUtrecht
 
Do we-know-it-all!!!
Do we-know-it-all!!!Do we-know-it-all!!!
Do we-know-it-all!!!Rajul Vasa
 
Emotional intelligence-as-an-evolutive-factor-on-adult-with-adhd
Emotional intelligence-as-an-evolutive-factor-on-adult-with-adhdEmotional intelligence-as-an-evolutive-factor-on-adult-with-adhd
Emotional intelligence-as-an-evolutive-factor-on-adult-with-adhdRosa Vera Garcia
 
TBI and Holistic Neuropsychology
TBI and Holistic NeuropsychologyTBI and Holistic Neuropsychology
TBI and Holistic NeuropsychologyTad Gorske, Ph.D.
 

What's hot (8)

Lesson 42
Lesson 42Lesson 42
Lesson 42
 
Presentatie psychiose escap 2015 m2 celso arango_escap_final
Presentatie psychiose escap 2015 m2 celso arango_escap_finalPresentatie psychiose escap 2015 m2 celso arango_escap_final
Presentatie psychiose escap 2015 m2 celso arango_escap_final
 
Schizophrenia in mentally retarded patients
Schizophrenia in mentally retarded patientsSchizophrenia in mentally retarded patients
Schizophrenia in mentally retarded patients
 
Do we-know-it-all!!!
Do we-know-it-all!!!Do we-know-it-all!!!
Do we-know-it-all!!!
 
Awakning
AwakningAwakning
Awakning
 
Emotional intelligence-as-an-evolutive-factor-on-adult-with-adhd
Emotional intelligence-as-an-evolutive-factor-on-adult-with-adhdEmotional intelligence-as-an-evolutive-factor-on-adult-with-adhd
Emotional intelligence-as-an-evolutive-factor-on-adult-with-adhd
 
Do you know ...(braz tesol)
Do you know ...(braz tesol)Do you know ...(braz tesol)
Do you know ...(braz tesol)
 
TBI and Holistic Neuropsychology
TBI and Holistic NeuropsychologyTBI and Holistic Neuropsychology
TBI and Holistic Neuropsychology
 

Viewers also liked

Le grange cap gr 2.9.16
Le grange cap gr 2.9.16Le grange cap gr 2.9.16
Le grange cap gr 2.9.16dlegrange
 
The Future and Innovation
The Future and InnovationThe Future and Innovation
The Future and InnovationJohn Cousins
 
ER stress video abstract v2
ER stress video abstract v2ER stress video abstract v2
ER stress video abstract v2Eric Huang
 
Machine learning and cognitive neuroimaging: new tools can answer new questions
Machine learning and cognitive neuroimaging: new tools can answer new questionsMachine learning and cognitive neuroimaging: new tools can answer new questions
Machine learning and cognitive neuroimaging: new tools can answer new questionsGael Varoquaux
 
Banking Technology Vision 2017
Banking Technology Vision 2017Banking Technology Vision 2017
Banking Technology Vision 2017accenture
 
Visual Design with Data
Visual Design with DataVisual Design with Data
Visual Design with DataSeth Familian
 

Viewers also liked (9)

Le grange cap gr 2.9.16
Le grange cap gr 2.9.16Le grange cap gr 2.9.16
Le grange cap gr 2.9.16
 
Jayshree CV
Jayshree CVJayshree CV
Jayshree CV
 
The Future and Innovation
The Future and InnovationThe Future and Innovation
The Future and Innovation
 
ER stress video abstract v2
ER stress video abstract v2ER stress video abstract v2
ER stress video abstract v2
 
Machine learning and cognitive neuroimaging: new tools can answer new questions
Machine learning and cognitive neuroimaging: new tools can answer new questionsMachine learning and cognitive neuroimaging: new tools can answer new questions
Machine learning and cognitive neuroimaging: new tools can answer new questions
 
Trematodes
TrematodesTrematodes
Trematodes
 
Banking Technology Vision 2017
Banking Technology Vision 2017Banking Technology Vision 2017
Banking Technology Vision 2017
 
Dyslexia
DyslexiaDyslexia
Dyslexia
 
Visual Design with Data
Visual Design with DataVisual Design with Data
Visual Design with Data
 

Similar to Cognitive and Socio-Emotional Resilience in Dyslexia

TIMING MATTERS: HOW TO THINK ABOUT THE EFFECTS OF EARLY EXPERIENCE ON BRAIN...
TIMING MATTERS: HOW TO THINK  ABOUT THE EFFECTS OF EARLY  EXPERIENCE ON BRAIN...TIMING MATTERS: HOW TO THINK  ABOUT THE EFFECTS OF EARLY  EXPERIENCE ON BRAIN...
TIMING MATTERS: HOW TO THINK ABOUT THE EFFECTS OF EARLY EXPERIENCE ON BRAIN...happy-yurikago
 
Hearing, listening and reading: A complex interplay of factors that contribut...
Hearing, listening and reading: A complex interplay of factors that contribut...Hearing, listening and reading: A complex interplay of factors that contribut...
Hearing, listening and reading: A complex interplay of factors that contribut...HEARnet _
 
Autism 101 am 1/adhd
Autism 101 am 1/adhdAutism 101 am 1/adhd
Autism 101 am 1/adhdljcantu
 
Autism 101 am 1
Autism 101 am 1Autism 101 am 1
Autism 101 am 1ljcantu
 
Threshold concepts workshop durham 11 july 2014
Threshold concepts workshop durham 11 july 2014Threshold concepts workshop durham 11 july 2014
Threshold concepts workshop durham 11 july 2014Peter Jones
 
Ecopsychotherapy - ASPA Conference 2013
Ecopsychotherapy - ASPA Conference 2013Ecopsychotherapy - ASPA Conference 2013
Ecopsychotherapy - ASPA Conference 2013Werner Sattmann-Frese
 
Dyslexia: a case study of everyday neurobiology
Dyslexia: a case study of everyday neurobiologyDyslexia: a case study of everyday neurobiology
Dyslexia: a case study of everyday neurobiology2PIR
 
ADHD - Myth or Clinical Reality?
ADHD - Myth or Clinical Reality?ADHD - Myth or Clinical Reality?
ADHD - Myth or Clinical Reality?Mahendra Perera
 
The Creative Use of Music Therapy for the Pediatric Long-Term Brain Injury Pa...
The Creative Use of Music Therapy for the Pediatric Long-Term Brain Injury Pa...The Creative Use of Music Therapy for the Pediatric Long-Term Brain Injury Pa...
The Creative Use of Music Therapy for the Pediatric Long-Term Brain Injury Pa...Brain Injury Alliance of New Jersey
 
Sensory Enrichment Therapy Second RCT Design Study
Sensory Enrichment Therapy Second RCT Design StudySensory Enrichment Therapy Second RCT Design Study
Sensory Enrichment Therapy Second RCT Design StudyGreg Wootton, MOTR/L
 
Behavioral Interventions in children with Pervasive Developmental Disorders
Behavioral Interventions in children with Pervasive Developmental DisordersBehavioral Interventions in children with Pervasive Developmental Disorders
Behavioral Interventions in children with Pervasive Developmental DisordersPallav Pareek
 
Pseudo-scientific educational interventions
Pseudo-scientific educational interventionsPseudo-scientific educational interventions
Pseudo-scientific educational interventionsDrJBowring
 
Chap.01.Revised
Chap.01.RevisedChap.01.Revised
Chap.01.Reviseddrstanf
 
Presentatie autisme escap 2015m4 madrid how_malleable_is_autism_escap_post
Presentatie autisme escap 2015m4 madrid how_malleable_is_autism_escap_postPresentatie autisme escap 2015m4 madrid how_malleable_is_autism_escap_post
Presentatie autisme escap 2015m4 madrid how_malleable_is_autism_escap_postUtrecht
 
Lindamood-Bell's 17th Annual International Research Conference
Lindamood-Bell's 17th Annual International Research ConferenceLindamood-Bell's 17th Annual International Research Conference
Lindamood-Bell's 17th Annual International Research ConferenceLindamood-Bell Learning Processes
 
Trauma Informed Services and PBiS at LSSU
Trauma Informed Services and PBiS at LSSUTrauma Informed Services and PBiS at LSSU
Trauma Informed Services and PBiS at LSSUnmdreamcatcher
 
Undergraduate BA (Hons) Psychology Empirical Project
Undergraduate BA (Hons) Psychology Empirical ProjectUndergraduate BA (Hons) Psychology Empirical Project
Undergraduate BA (Hons) Psychology Empirical ProjectJordan Purcell
 

Similar to Cognitive and Socio-Emotional Resilience in Dyslexia (20)

TIMING MATTERS: HOW TO THINK ABOUT THE EFFECTS OF EARLY EXPERIENCE ON BRAIN...
TIMING MATTERS: HOW TO THINK  ABOUT THE EFFECTS OF EARLY  EXPERIENCE ON BRAIN...TIMING MATTERS: HOW TO THINK  ABOUT THE EFFECTS OF EARLY  EXPERIENCE ON BRAIN...
TIMING MATTERS: HOW TO THINK ABOUT THE EFFECTS OF EARLY EXPERIENCE ON BRAIN...
 
Hearing, listening and reading: A complex interplay of factors that contribut...
Hearing, listening and reading: A complex interplay of factors that contribut...Hearing, listening and reading: A complex interplay of factors that contribut...
Hearing, listening and reading: A complex interplay of factors that contribut...
 
Autism 101 am 1/adhd
Autism 101 am 1/adhdAutism 101 am 1/adhd
Autism 101 am 1/adhd
 
Autism 101 am 1
Autism 101 am 1Autism 101 am 1
Autism 101 am 1
 
Linked In Doc
Linked In DocLinked In Doc
Linked In Doc
 
Dyslexia assoc-pp
Dyslexia assoc-ppDyslexia assoc-pp
Dyslexia assoc-pp
 
Threshold concepts workshop durham 11 july 2014
Threshold concepts workshop durham 11 july 2014Threshold concepts workshop durham 11 july 2014
Threshold concepts workshop durham 11 july 2014
 
Ecopsychotherapy - ASPA Conference 2013
Ecopsychotherapy - ASPA Conference 2013Ecopsychotherapy - ASPA Conference 2013
Ecopsychotherapy - ASPA Conference 2013
 
Dyslexia: a case study of everyday neurobiology
Dyslexia: a case study of everyday neurobiologyDyslexia: a case study of everyday neurobiology
Dyslexia: a case study of everyday neurobiology
 
ADHD - Myth or Clinical Reality?
ADHD - Myth or Clinical Reality?ADHD - Myth or Clinical Reality?
ADHD - Myth or Clinical Reality?
 
The Creative Use of Music Therapy for the Pediatric Long-Term Brain Injury Pa...
The Creative Use of Music Therapy for the Pediatric Long-Term Brain Injury Pa...The Creative Use of Music Therapy for the Pediatric Long-Term Brain Injury Pa...
The Creative Use of Music Therapy for the Pediatric Long-Term Brain Injury Pa...
 
Sensory Enrichment Therapy Second RCT Design Study
Sensory Enrichment Therapy Second RCT Design StudySensory Enrichment Therapy Second RCT Design Study
Sensory Enrichment Therapy Second RCT Design Study
 
Behavioral Interventions in children with Pervasive Developmental Disorders
Behavioral Interventions in children with Pervasive Developmental DisordersBehavioral Interventions in children with Pervasive Developmental Disorders
Behavioral Interventions in children with Pervasive Developmental Disorders
 
Pseudo-scientific educational interventions
Pseudo-scientific educational interventionsPseudo-scientific educational interventions
Pseudo-scientific educational interventions
 
Chap.01.Revised
Chap.01.RevisedChap.01.Revised
Chap.01.Revised
 
The roots of anxiety
The roots of anxietyThe roots of anxiety
The roots of anxiety
 
Presentatie autisme escap 2015m4 madrid how_malleable_is_autism_escap_post
Presentatie autisme escap 2015m4 madrid how_malleable_is_autism_escap_postPresentatie autisme escap 2015m4 madrid how_malleable_is_autism_escap_post
Presentatie autisme escap 2015m4 madrid how_malleable_is_autism_escap_post
 
Lindamood-Bell's 17th Annual International Research Conference
Lindamood-Bell's 17th Annual International Research ConferenceLindamood-Bell's 17th Annual International Research Conference
Lindamood-Bell's 17th Annual International Research Conference
 
Trauma Informed Services and PBiS at LSSU
Trauma Informed Services and PBiS at LSSUTrauma Informed Services and PBiS at LSSU
Trauma Informed Services and PBiS at LSSU
 
Undergraduate BA (Hons) Psychology Empirical Project
Undergraduate BA (Hons) Psychology Empirical ProjectUndergraduate BA (Hons) Psychology Empirical Project
Undergraduate BA (Hons) Psychology Empirical Project
 

Recently uploaded

The basics of sentences session 4pptx.pptx
The basics of sentences session 4pptx.pptxThe basics of sentences session 4pptx.pptx
The basics of sentences session 4pptx.pptxheathfieldcps1
 
Basic_QTL_Marker-assisted_Selection_Sourabh.ppt
Basic_QTL_Marker-assisted_Selection_Sourabh.pptBasic_QTL_Marker-assisted_Selection_Sourabh.ppt
Basic_QTL_Marker-assisted_Selection_Sourabh.pptSourabh Kumar
 
The Art Pastor's Guide to Sabbath | Steve Thomason
The Art Pastor's Guide to Sabbath | Steve ThomasonThe Art Pastor's Guide to Sabbath | Steve Thomason
The Art Pastor's Guide to Sabbath | Steve ThomasonSteve Thomason
 
Basic Civil Engg Notes_Chapter-6_Environment Pollution & Engineering
Basic Civil Engg Notes_Chapter-6_Environment Pollution & EngineeringBasic Civil Engg Notes_Chapter-6_Environment Pollution & Engineering
Basic Civil Engg Notes_Chapter-6_Environment Pollution & EngineeringDenish Jangid
 
aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa
aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa
aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaasiemaillard
 
Gyanartha SciBizTech Quiz slideshare.pptx
Gyanartha SciBizTech Quiz slideshare.pptxGyanartha SciBizTech Quiz slideshare.pptx
Gyanartha SciBizTech Quiz slideshare.pptxShibin Azad
 
MARUTI SUZUKI- A Successful Joint Venture in India.pptx
MARUTI SUZUKI- A Successful Joint Venture in India.pptxMARUTI SUZUKI- A Successful Joint Venture in India.pptx
MARUTI SUZUKI- A Successful Joint Venture in India.pptxbennyroshan06
 
PART A. Introduction to Costumer Service
PART A. Introduction to Costumer ServicePART A. Introduction to Costumer Service
PART A. Introduction to Costumer ServicePedroFerreira53928
 
The Benefits and Challenges of Open Educational Resources
The Benefits and Challenges of Open Educational ResourcesThe Benefits and Challenges of Open Educational Resources
The Benefits and Challenges of Open Educational Resourcesaileywriter
 
Pragya Champions Chalice 2024 Prelims & Finals Q/A set, General Quiz
Pragya Champions Chalice 2024 Prelims & Finals Q/A set, General QuizPragya Champions Chalice 2024 Prelims & Finals Q/A set, General Quiz
Pragya Champions Chalice 2024 Prelims & Finals Q/A set, General QuizPragya - UEM Kolkata Quiz Club
 
50 ĐỀ LUYỆN THI IOE LỚP 9 - NĂM HỌC 2022-2023 (CÓ LINK HÌNH, FILE AUDIO VÀ ĐÁ...
50 ĐỀ LUYỆN THI IOE LỚP 9 - NĂM HỌC 2022-2023 (CÓ LINK HÌNH, FILE AUDIO VÀ ĐÁ...50 ĐỀ LUYỆN THI IOE LỚP 9 - NĂM HỌC 2022-2023 (CÓ LINK HÌNH, FILE AUDIO VÀ ĐÁ...
50 ĐỀ LUYỆN THI IOE LỚP 9 - NĂM HỌC 2022-2023 (CÓ LINK HÌNH, FILE AUDIO VÀ ĐÁ...Nguyen Thanh Tu Collection
 
Benefits and Challenges of Using Open Educational Resources
Benefits and Challenges of Using Open Educational ResourcesBenefits and Challenges of Using Open Educational Resources
Benefits and Challenges of Using Open Educational Resourcesdimpy50
 
How to Split Bills in the Odoo 17 POS Module
How to Split Bills in the Odoo 17 POS ModuleHow to Split Bills in the Odoo 17 POS Module
How to Split Bills in the Odoo 17 POS ModuleCeline George
 
Incoming and Outgoing Shipments in 2 STEPS Using Odoo 17
Incoming and Outgoing Shipments in 2 STEPS Using Odoo 17Incoming and Outgoing Shipments in 2 STEPS Using Odoo 17
Incoming and Outgoing Shipments in 2 STEPS Using Odoo 17Celine George
 
Matatag-Curriculum and the 21st Century Skills Presentation.pptx
Matatag-Curriculum and the 21st Century Skills Presentation.pptxMatatag-Curriculum and the 21st Century Skills Presentation.pptx
Matatag-Curriculum and the 21st Century Skills Presentation.pptxJenilouCasareno
 
Salient features of Environment protection Act 1986.pptx
Salient features of Environment protection Act 1986.pptxSalient features of Environment protection Act 1986.pptx
Salient features of Environment protection Act 1986.pptxakshayaramakrishnan21
 
How to Manage Notification Preferences in the Odoo 17
How to Manage Notification Preferences in the Odoo 17How to Manage Notification Preferences in the Odoo 17
How to Manage Notification Preferences in the Odoo 17Celine George
 
size separation d pharm 1st year pharmaceutics
size separation d pharm 1st year pharmaceuticssize separation d pharm 1st year pharmaceutics
size separation d pharm 1st year pharmaceuticspragatimahajan3
 
The impact of social media on mental health and well-being has been a topic o...
The impact of social media on mental health and well-being has been a topic o...The impact of social media on mental health and well-being has been a topic o...
The impact of social media on mental health and well-being has been a topic o...sanghavirahi2
 

Recently uploaded (20)

The basics of sentences session 4pptx.pptx
The basics of sentences session 4pptx.pptxThe basics of sentences session 4pptx.pptx
The basics of sentences session 4pptx.pptx
 
Introduction to Quality Improvement Essentials
Introduction to Quality Improvement EssentialsIntroduction to Quality Improvement Essentials
Introduction to Quality Improvement Essentials
 
Basic_QTL_Marker-assisted_Selection_Sourabh.ppt
Basic_QTL_Marker-assisted_Selection_Sourabh.pptBasic_QTL_Marker-assisted_Selection_Sourabh.ppt
Basic_QTL_Marker-assisted_Selection_Sourabh.ppt
 
The Art Pastor's Guide to Sabbath | Steve Thomason
The Art Pastor's Guide to Sabbath | Steve ThomasonThe Art Pastor's Guide to Sabbath | Steve Thomason
The Art Pastor's Guide to Sabbath | Steve Thomason
 
Basic Civil Engg Notes_Chapter-6_Environment Pollution & Engineering
Basic Civil Engg Notes_Chapter-6_Environment Pollution & EngineeringBasic Civil Engg Notes_Chapter-6_Environment Pollution & Engineering
Basic Civil Engg Notes_Chapter-6_Environment Pollution & Engineering
 
aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa
aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa
aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa
 
Gyanartha SciBizTech Quiz slideshare.pptx
Gyanartha SciBizTech Quiz slideshare.pptxGyanartha SciBizTech Quiz slideshare.pptx
Gyanartha SciBizTech Quiz slideshare.pptx
 
MARUTI SUZUKI- A Successful Joint Venture in India.pptx
MARUTI SUZUKI- A Successful Joint Venture in India.pptxMARUTI SUZUKI- A Successful Joint Venture in India.pptx
MARUTI SUZUKI- A Successful Joint Venture in India.pptx
 
PART A. Introduction to Costumer Service
PART A. Introduction to Costumer ServicePART A. Introduction to Costumer Service
PART A. Introduction to Costumer Service
 
The Benefits and Challenges of Open Educational Resources
The Benefits and Challenges of Open Educational ResourcesThe Benefits and Challenges of Open Educational Resources
The Benefits and Challenges of Open Educational Resources
 
Pragya Champions Chalice 2024 Prelims & Finals Q/A set, General Quiz
Pragya Champions Chalice 2024 Prelims & Finals Q/A set, General QuizPragya Champions Chalice 2024 Prelims & Finals Q/A set, General Quiz
Pragya Champions Chalice 2024 Prelims & Finals Q/A set, General Quiz
 
50 ĐỀ LUYỆN THI IOE LỚP 9 - NĂM HỌC 2022-2023 (CÓ LINK HÌNH, FILE AUDIO VÀ ĐÁ...
50 ĐỀ LUYỆN THI IOE LỚP 9 - NĂM HỌC 2022-2023 (CÓ LINK HÌNH, FILE AUDIO VÀ ĐÁ...50 ĐỀ LUYỆN THI IOE LỚP 9 - NĂM HỌC 2022-2023 (CÓ LINK HÌNH, FILE AUDIO VÀ ĐÁ...
50 ĐỀ LUYỆN THI IOE LỚP 9 - NĂM HỌC 2022-2023 (CÓ LINK HÌNH, FILE AUDIO VÀ ĐÁ...
 
Benefits and Challenges of Using Open Educational Resources
Benefits and Challenges of Using Open Educational ResourcesBenefits and Challenges of Using Open Educational Resources
Benefits and Challenges of Using Open Educational Resources
 
How to Split Bills in the Odoo 17 POS Module
How to Split Bills in the Odoo 17 POS ModuleHow to Split Bills in the Odoo 17 POS Module
How to Split Bills in the Odoo 17 POS Module
 
Incoming and Outgoing Shipments in 2 STEPS Using Odoo 17
Incoming and Outgoing Shipments in 2 STEPS Using Odoo 17Incoming and Outgoing Shipments in 2 STEPS Using Odoo 17
Incoming and Outgoing Shipments in 2 STEPS Using Odoo 17
 
Matatag-Curriculum and the 21st Century Skills Presentation.pptx
Matatag-Curriculum and the 21st Century Skills Presentation.pptxMatatag-Curriculum and the 21st Century Skills Presentation.pptx
Matatag-Curriculum and the 21st Century Skills Presentation.pptx
 
Salient features of Environment protection Act 1986.pptx
Salient features of Environment protection Act 1986.pptxSalient features of Environment protection Act 1986.pptx
Salient features of Environment protection Act 1986.pptx
 
How to Manage Notification Preferences in the Odoo 17
How to Manage Notification Preferences in the Odoo 17How to Manage Notification Preferences in the Odoo 17
How to Manage Notification Preferences in the Odoo 17
 
size separation d pharm 1st year pharmaceutics
size separation d pharm 1st year pharmaceuticssize separation d pharm 1st year pharmaceutics
size separation d pharm 1st year pharmaceutics
 
The impact of social media on mental health and well-being has been a topic o...
The impact of social media on mental health and well-being has been a topic o...The impact of social media on mental health and well-being has been a topic o...
The impact of social media on mental health and well-being has been a topic o...
 

Cognitive and Socio-Emotional Resilience in Dyslexia

  • 1. Cognitive & Socio-Emotional Resilience in Dyslexia Fumiko Hoeft MD PhD fumiko.hoeft@ucsf.edu | @fumikohoeft UC Multicampus Science-based Innovation in Learning Center (SILC) UCSF LENS | Dept of Psychiatry | Weill Institute for Neurosciences R01HD078351 (Hoeft, UCSF) R01HD086168 (Hoeft/Pugh, UCSF/Haskins) R01HD065794 (Pugh, Haskins) P01HD001994 (Rueckl, Haskins/UConn) R01MH104438 (Nordahl, UCDavis/MIND) R01MH103371 (Amaral, UCDavis/MIND) FUNDING Liebe Patterson Dennis & Shannon Wong – DSEA ‘88 Foundation Toney & Potter Family NSF1540854 SL-CN (Gazzaley/Uncapher, UCSF) Holy Names University | Raskob School | 01.20.2017
  • 2. Why is each child so different? How can we ensure success in each child? TAIGA “INFORMATION SEEKER” KAITO “STORY MAN” “3D MAN” Empathic Spiderman - Halloween Analytic Red/White blood cell - Halloween Not a good reader Avoids reading Avid reader
  • 3. Jack Horner, a paleontologist from Jurassic Park/World NOW Technical Advisor of Jurassic Park (= Dr. Alan Grant) MacArthur Genius Award (‘86) Romer-Simpson Medal (’13) THEN Severely dyslexic Graduated high school with D--- Failed college 7 times Never graduated GPA 0.06 (Honorary doctorate, ’06) Importance of resilience Importance of environment & community Importance of looking at an individual as a whole (including literacy but also other cognitive and socio-emotional aspects) 3
  • 4. Outline • BACKGROUND – Dyslexia costly in many dimensions – Importance of an integrative approach • TODAY’S FOCUS (CURRENT WORK) – The resilience framework of dyslexia – Cognitive resilience – Socio-Emotional resilience • CONCLUSION & THE FUTURE Background | Resilience Framework | Cognitive Resilience | Socio-Emotional Resilience | Conclusion
  • 5. Outline • BACKGROUND – Dyslexia costly in many dimensions – Importance of an integrative approach • TODAY’S FOCUS (CURRENT WORK) – The resilience framework of dyslexia – Cognitive resilience – Socio-Emotional resilience • CONCLUSION & THE FUTURE Background | Resilience Framework | Cognitive Resilience | Socio-Emotional Resilience | Conclusion
  • 6. Cost of Dyslexia Risks Dyslexia POOR OUTCOME: Reading Comprehension, Educational Attainment, Psychosocial Adjustment DLPFC ORTHOGRAPHIC PHONOLOGICAL IF G op Pr eC G SMG pSTG FusiG ITG Insula dStr PPC SUSCEPTABILITY GENES Background | Resilience Framework | Cognitive Resilience | Socio-Emotional Resilience | Conclusion
  • 7. Cost of Dyslexia is High Developing dyslexia up to 50% with family history, (4 times higher) Cost to individual >£100k less earning ($150k) Cost to (UK) society >£1bn/year ($1.5bn) High School drop out 2.5x Prison population 32-46% (note low IQ and not SLD!) Anxiety disorder 2.0x (5.0x severe test anxiety) Depression 2.0x Substance abuse 2.7x ADHD 4.5x Snowling et al. Psychol Bull 2016; Pennington & Lefly. Child Develop 2001; Cosden JLD 2001; Wilson et al. JLD 2009; Foresight Mental Capital and Wellbeing Project. 2008 ; DuPaul et al. JLD 2012; Background | Resilience Framework | Cognitive Resilience | Socio-Emotional Resilience | Conclusion
  • 8. Latest Thinking on the Factors that Contribute to Dyslexia: Multiple Factors Contribute Neurobio Risk2 Neurobio Risk1 Neurobio Protective1 Neurobio Protective2 Dyslexia Risk Pennington. Cognition 2006. Pennington et al. J Abnorm Psychol 2012. – Multiple deficit model Environment Risk1 Environment Protective1 Diathesis-stress model: Rosenthal ed. “The Genain Quadruplets” ‘64 Liability threshold model: Gottesman & Shields. PNAS ‘67 Background | Resilience Framework | Cognitive Resilience | Socio-Emotional Resilience | Conclusion
  • 9. Importance of an Integrative Approach to Maximizing Children’s Learning Potential Maximizing children’s learning potential NEUROBIOLOGY EXTERNAL ENVIRONMENT INTERNAL ENVIRONMENT STEREOTYPE THREAT MOTIVATION & MINDSET RESILIENCE & GRIT Background | Resilience Framework | Cognitive Resilience | Socio-Emotional Resilience | Conclusion
  • 10. TODAY’S TOPIC: Cognitive and Socio-Emotional Resilience in Dyslexia Maximizing children’s learning potential NEUROBIOLOGY EXTERNAL ENVIRONMENT INTERNAL ENVIRONMENT STEREOTYPE THREAT MOTIVATION & MINDSET RESILIENCE & GRIT Background | Resilience Framework | Cognitive Resilience | Socio-Emotional Resilience | Conclusion
  • 11. Outline • BACKGROUND – Dyslexia costly in many dimensions – Importance of an integrative approach • TODAY’S FOCUS (CURRENT WORK) – The resilience framework of dyslexia – Cognitive resilience – Socio-Emotional resilience • CONCLUSION & THE FUTURE Background | Resilience Framework | Cognitive Resilience | Socio-Emotional Resilience | Conclusion
  • 12. Resilience The ability to adapt to stressors in the environment (adversity) by “bending” but not “breaking” (Karatsoreos & McEwen F1000Prime Reports 2013) Socio-emotional resilience Cognitive resilience Background | Resilience Framework | Cognitive Resilience | Socio-Emotional Resilience | Conclusion
  • 13. Resilience Framework of Dyslexia: Promoting Resilience & Optimizing Dyslexia Outcome Risks Dyslexia Poor Functional Outcome • Poor Reading Comprehension • Negative Psychosocial Adjustment Haft, Myers, Hoeft. Curr Opin Beh Sci 2016 Stephanie Haft Socio- Emotional Protect. F. INTERNAL • Growth mindset • Hopeful thinking • Sense of coherence • Locus of control • Self determination FAMILY • Family cohesion • Maternal affect • Strong parental attachment • Parental support & understanding of RD PEER/SCHOOL • Peer relationships • Mentorship by teachers • Teacher support • Small class-size Cognitive Protective Factors • Oral language skills • Motor skills • Task-focused behavior • Executive functions • Interpersonal relationships Less Severe Dyslexia • Morphological awareness • Vocabulary • Verbal reasoning • Executive functions • Grammar Positive Outcome Weaknesses vs. Relative strengths Risk vs. Protective factors Vulnerability vs. Resilience Background | Resilience Framework | Cognitive Resilience | Socio-Emotional Resilience | Conclusion
  • 14. The Neuroscience of Dyslexia – Traditional View Focus on Weaknesses, Risks & Vulnerability phonological processing (visual/selective) attention cognitive implicit procedural learning short-term memory information processing RELATIVE WEAKNESSES d Background | Resilience Framework | Cognitive Resilience | Socio-Emotional Resilience | Conclusion
  • 15. The Neuroscience of Dyslexia – Traditional View Focus on Weaknesses, Risks & Vulnerability Occipito-Temporal (OT) Orthographic processing Temporo-Parietal (TP) Phonological processing POOR READERS & DYSLEXIA. Reduced efficiency in brain networks related to speech & visual aspects of reading. Shaywitz et al. NEJM ’98; Hoeft et al. J Neurosci ‘06. Hoeft et al. PNAS ‘07 Background | Resilience Framework | Cognitive Resilience | Socio-Emotional Resilience | Conclusion
  • 16. character traits, socio-emotional Grit, Resilience, Mindset, Empathy The Neuroscience of Dyslexia – Emerging View Focus Also on Strengths, Protective Factors & Resilience visuo-spatial Holistic, 3d cognitive explicit memory comprehension IQ, reasoning, oral language … RELATIVE STRENGTHS phonological processing (visual/selective) attention cognitive implicit procedural learning short-term memory information processing RELATIVE WEAKNESSES d Background | Resilience Framework | Cognitive Resilience | Socio-Emotional Resilience | Conclusion
  • 17. The Neuroscience of Dyslexia – Emerging View Focus Also on Strengths, Protective Factors & Resilience Occipito-Temporal (OT) Orthographic processing Temporo-Parietal (TP) Phonological processing PROTECTIVE FACTORS & RESILIENCE Which brain systems??? What mechanism??? Coincidence. Bryden MP. Laterality ’87 Compensatory. Lansdell HJ. Comp Physio Psychol ‘69, Levy J. Nature ’69 Causal. Kosslyn SM. Psychol Rev ’87, Cai et al. PNAS ’13. Evolutionary advantage Geschwind N. Annals of Dyslexia ‘84 Background | Resilience Framework | Cognitive Resilience | Socio-Emotional Resilience | Conclusion
  • 18. Outline • BACKGROUND – Dyslexia costly in many dimensions – Importance of an integrative approach (Geschwind Lecture 2014) • TODAY’S FOCUS (CURRENT WORK) – The resilience framework of dyslexia – Cognitive resilience – Socio-Emotional resilience • CONCLUSION & THE FUTURE Background | Resilience Framework | Cognitive Resilience | Socio-Emotional Resilience | Conclusion
  • 19. Resilience Framework of Dyslexia: COGNITIVE RESILIENCE Risks Dyslexia Poor Functional Outcome • Poor Reading Comprehension • Negative Psychosocial Adjustment Haft, Myers, Hoeft. Curr Opin Beh Sci 2016 Cognitive Protective Factors • Oral language skills • Motor skills • Task-focused behavior • Executive functions • Interpersonal relationships Less Severe Dyslexia • Morphological awareness • Vocabulary • Verbal reasoning • Executive functions • Grammar Positive Outcome Background | Resilience Framework | Cognitive Resilience | Socio-Emotional Resilience | Conclusion
  • 20. COGNITIVE RESILIENCE Resilient Dyslexics RESILIENT READERS: Those with good comprehension despite poor decoding. Those with decoding difficulties rely more on contextual information to be able to read successfully. INTERACTIVE COMPENSATORY MODEL OF DYSLEXIA (Stanovich, 1980) Implications for intervention. Smadar Patael PhD Laurie Cutting PhD Patael et al. under review Background | Resilience Framework | Cognitive Resilience | Socio-Emotional Resilience | Conclusion
  • 21. COGNITIVE RESILIENCE Brain Mechanism? RESILIENT READERS POOR READERS TYPICAL READERS Expected pattern related to: RESILIENCE DECODING COMPREHENSION Decoding Comprehension TYPICAL READERS Good comprehension but good decoding alsoPOOR READERS Poor decoding but also poor comprehension RESILIENT READERS Patael et al. under review Background | Resilience Framework | Cognitive Resilience | Socio-Emotional Resilience | Conclusion
  • 22. COGNITIVE RESILIENCE Left Dorsolateral Prefrontal Cortex (DLPFC) Resilient > Poor readers Resilient > Typical readers RESILIENT READERS POOR READERS TYPICAL READERS RESILIENCE DECODING COMPREHENSIO N Patael et al. under review Background | Resilience Framework | Cognitive Resilience | Socio-Emotional Resilience | Conclusion
  • 23. COGNITIVE RESILIENCE Not just dyslexics but anyone can have it. R² = 0.1241 0.3 0.4 0.5 0.6 0.7 0.8 0.9 1 -40 -20 0 20 40 PrefrontalVolume Cognitive Resilience 10-16yo children with & without poor decoding Patael et al. under review Background | Resilience Framework | Cognitive Resilience | Socio-Emotional Resilience | Conclusion
  • 24. COGNITIVE RESILIENCE Chicken or egg? Show signs BEFORE reading failure. R² = 0.1241 R² = 0.14 0.3 0.4 0.5 0.6 0.7 0.8 0.9 1 -40 -20 0 20 40 PrefrontalVolume Cognitive Resilience Prereading kids’ left DLPFC predicts future ‘resilience’ Patael et al. under review Background | Resilience Framework | Cognitive Resilience | Socio-Emotional Resilience | Conclusion
  • 25. COGNITIVE RESILIENCE Role of DLPFC Network? -2 0 2 4 6 work working1back memory wm 2back load encoded maintenance oddball salient shifting attention distractor cues congruent executive rule rehearsalconflictincongruentmonitoring rules verbal verb visuospatial spatially dyslexia reading readers phonology phonological phonetic semantic semantically nouns noun 1000 Functional Connectome. Neurosynth.org Related to learning, attention, & cognitive flexibility Fronto-parietal network Patael et al. under review Background | Resilience Framework | Cognitive Resilience | Socio-Emotional Resilience | Conclusion
  • 26. COGNITIVE RESILIENCE Fronto-parietal network “flexible learning hub”. Dynamically changes how it connects to other key networks based on current goals. Critical for learning new skills and building mental rules. Allows immediate & flexible transfer of skills. Cole et al. Nat Neuroscience ’13 Patael et al. under review Background | Resilience Framework | Cognitive Resilience | Socio-Emotional Resilience | Conclusion
  • 27. COGNITIVE RESILIENCE: Summary • Prefrontal & fronto-parietal network • Cognitive flexibility, learning network • Related studies also point to prefrontal mechanisms • May suggest importance of promoting activities to enhance cognitive flexibility & self- regulation early Patael et al. under rev; Hoeft et al. PNAS ’07 & PNAS ’11; Hancock Richlan Hoeft. Neurosci Beh Rev Background | Resilience Framework | Cognitive Resilience | Socio-Emotional Resilience | Conclusion
  • 28. Outline • BACKGROUND – Dyslexia costly in many dimensions – Importance of an integrative approach • TODAY’S FOCUS (CURRENT WORK) – The resilience framework of dyslexia – Cognitive resilience – Socio-Emotional resilience • CONCLUSION & THE FUTURE Background | Resilience Framework | Cognitive Resilience | Socio-Emotional Resilience | Conclusion
  • 29. Resilience Model of LD: SOCIO-EMOTIONAL RESILIENCE Risks Dyslexia Poor Functional Outcome • Poor Reading Comprehension • Negative Psychosocial Adjustment Haft, Myers, Hoeft. Curr Opin Beh Sci 2016 Socio- Emotional Protect. F. INTERNAL • Growth mindset • Hopeful thinking • Sense of coherence • Locus of control • Self determination FAMILY • Family cohesion • Maternal affect • Strong parental attachment • Parental support & understanding of RD PEER/SCHOOL • Peer relationships • Mentorship by teachers • Teacher support • Small class-size Positive Outcome Background | Resilience Framework | Cognitive Resilience | Socio-Emotional Resilience | Conclusion
  • 30. SOCIO-EMOTIONAL RESILIENCE Character traits critical for success Self discipline, more predictive than IQ (2x) & above and beyond achievement itself (Duckworth & Seligman, Psychol Sci ‘05) 2x Above & beyond IQ & achievement Background | Resilience Framework | Cognitive Resilience | Socio-Emotional Resilience | Conclusion
  • 31. SOCIO-EMOTIONAL RESILIENCE Brain mechanisms VTA GROWTH MIND-SET: Belief that ability is effort based GROWTH MINDSET COGNITIVE REAPPRAISAL (Doherty et al. Science ‘04) INTRINSIC MOTIVATION (Muyrayama et al. PNAS ’10) VTA GRIT: Perseverance toward a long term goal GRIT PERSISTENCE (Gusnard et al. PNAS ‘03) FUTURE REWARD (Doherty et al. Science ’04) Myers et al. SCAN 2016 Multiple targets – Multiple routes to enhance learning Chelsea Myers Background | Resilience Framework | Cognitive Resilience | Socio-Emotional Resilience | Conclusion
  • 32. SOCIO-EMOTIONAL RESILIENCE Stereotype threat may put individuals at risk “Stereotype threat is being at risk of confirming, as self-characteristic, a negative stereotype about one’s group.” –Steele and Aronson (1995) “White men can’t jump.” “Women are not good at math.” reducingstereotypethreat.org, Whistling vivaldi by Claude Steele “African Americans have lower intelligence than their white peers .” Background | Resilience Framework | Cognitive Resilience | Socio-Emotional Resilience | Conclusion
  • 33. SOCIO-EMOTIONAL RESILIENCE Stereotype threat MAY exist in LDs Why might individuals with learning disabilities (including dyslexics, but also ADHD etc) experience stereotype threat? • Group identification - low achievement • Aware of stereotype (Kelly and Norwich, 2004; Rashkind et al., 2006) • Negative academic self-concept (Zeleke, 2004) • Low self-esteem, negative affect, anxiety, and depression when faced with performance-avoidance goals (the desire to perform less poorly than others) (Sideridis, 2007; Aquino, 2011) Background | Resilience Framework | Cognitive Resilience | Socio-Emotional Resilience | Conclusion
  • 34. SOCIO-EMOTIONAL RESILIENCE An Integrated Process Model of Stereotype Threat Concept of Ability Domain Concept of Group Concept of Self “I am a girl…” “I think I am good at math…” “Girls are bad at math (and math is important to me)…” Forbes et al., 2008 Discordance leads to stereotype threat Reduced attention Stress & Anxiety Fear & Threat Reduced learning & memory, & performance Everyone is prone. Background | Resilience Framework | Cognitive Resilience | Socio-Emotional Resilience | Conclusion
  • 35. SOCIO-EMOTIONAL RESILIENCE Brain mechanism of stereotype threat? Women & under- performance in math Krendl et al. Psychol Sci 2008 Lack of improvement in math performance over time under ST (interaction: p<.005) Stereotype threat impacts key cognitive networks and emotion-related networks negatively Lack of MATH related activation under ST Increase in EMOTIONal response under ST No ST group ST group No ST group ST group Background | Resilience Framework | Cognitive Resilience | Socio-Emotional Resilience | Conclusion
  • 36. SOCIO-EMOTIONAL RESILIENCE Building Resilience Against Stereotype Threat • Reframing the task (e.g. Quinn & Spencer, 2001) • De-emphasizing threatened social identities (e.g. Stricker and Ward, 2004) • Role models (e.g. Blanton et al., 2000) • External attributions for difficulty (e.g. Good et al, 2003) • Self-affirmations (e.g. Schimel et al., 2004) • Growth mindset (e.g. Aronson et al., 2002) Background | Resilience Framework | Cognitive Resilience | Socio-Emotional Resilience | Conclusion
  • 37. SOCIO-EMOTIONAL RESILIENCE Strength-based approach may build resilience von Károlyi et al., ‘01; ‘03; Diehl … Hoeft … Pugh. NeuroImage ‘14 Visuo-spatial processing show yin-yang relationship with reading Ken Pugh R² = 0.1439 reading visuo-spatial r=0.42 p<0.05 BEHAVIOR dyslexics non-dyslexics BRAIN Background | Resilience Framework | Cognitive Resilience | Socio-Emotional Resilience | Conclusion
  • 38. SOCIO-EMOTIONAL RESILIENCE Mentoring may build resilience Scores 26.7% ***P<0.0001 12.5% ~*P=0.05 2.5 3 3.5 4 4.5 5 Response to failure Depression Self Esteem Fall Spring Display more positive emotions and effort-based strategies in the face of failure. IMPROVEMENT IN: SELF ESTEEM (12%) GRIT (value) (8-36%) GROWTH MINDSET (14%) LD IDENTITY (comfort, bond, importance) (24-52%) READING SELF-CONCEPT (19%) etc… N=48 Background | Resilience Framework | Cognitive Resilience | Socio-Emotional Resilience | Conclusion
  • 39. SOCIO-EMOTIONAL RESILIENCE Mentoring may build resilience -100 -50 0 50 100 150 1.5 2 2.5 3 3.5 Self-Esteem (FalltoSpring%increase) Mentee-Rated Mentorship Quality (1-low to 3-high) N=39 R2=0.13 (r=0.36) P=0.025 Background | Resilience Framework | Cognitive Resilience | Socio-Emotional Resilience | Conclusion
  • 40. SOCIO-EMOTIONAL RESILIENCE: Summary • Stereotype threat & fixed mindset could be potential mechanisms underlying underperformance in those with learning challenges. • Others such as anxiety, motivation and reduced grit likely interact with stereotype threat and fixed mindset, and result in further underperformance. Dyslexia Stereotype Threat Attention PF resources Fixed mindset Reduced grit Reduced academic achievement Reduced motivation Anxiety Background | Resilience Framework | Cognitive Resilience | Socio-Emotional Resilience | Conclusion
  • 41. Outline • BACKGROUND – Dyslexia costly in many dimensions – Importance of an integrative approach • TODAY’S FOCUS (CURRENT WORK) – The resilience framework of dyslexia – Cognitive resilience – Socio-Emotional resilience • CONCLUSION & THE FUTURE Background | Resilience Framework | Cognitive Resilience | Socio-Emotional Resilience | Conclusion
  • 42. CONCLUSION: Promoting Resilience Risks Dyslexia Poor Functional Outcome • Poor Reading Comprehension • Negative Psychosocial Adjustment Haft, Myers, Hoeft. Curr Opin Beh Sci 2016 Socio- Emotional Protect. F. INTERNAL • Growth mindset • Hopeful thinking • Sense of coherence • Locus of control • Self determination FAMILY • Family cohesion • Maternal affect • Strong parental attachment • Parental support & understanding of RD PEER/SCHOOL • Peer relationships • Mentorship by teachers • Teacher support • Small class-size Cognitive Protective Factors • Oral language skills • Motor skills • Task-focused behavior • Executive functions • Interpersonal relationships Less Severe Dyslexia • Morphological awareness • Vocabulary • Verbal reasoning • Executive functions • Grammar Positive Outcome COGNITIVE TRAINING SOCIO- EMOTIONAL LEARNING (mentoring) LITERACY INTER- VENTIONS Background | Resilience Framework | Cognitive Resilience | Socio-Emotional Resilience | Conclusion
  • 43. CONCLUSION: Promoting Resilience • Cognitive reappraisal & positive reframing >>> Cognitive control, self-regulation, grit • Strength based approach >>> Confidence, Optimism • Growth mindset – Active coping (sense of control), Optimism • Social support, role model, mentoring – Connection to community • Reduce stereotype threat – Optimize learning environment & enhanced performance • Stress inoculation (exposure to tolerable levels of stress & challenges) Charney. Nat Rev Neurosci 2009; Ken Ginsberg http://www.fosteringresilience.com/7cs.php Background | Resilience Framework | Cognitive Resilience | Socio-Emotional Resilience | Conclusion
  • 44. Can we become resilient? Background | Resilience Framework | Cognitive Resilience | Socio-Emotional Resilience | Conclusion
  • 45. Neuroscience Research Space msec years Learning Cognition, Language Reading, Math Perception Socio-emotional Preconception Prenatal Postnatal Child Adult Adolescent DEVELOPMENTALSTAGE Gene Neurochemistry Physiology Neuroanatomy Behavior
  • 46. CURRENT/FUTURE WORK @ Socio-emotional, Character traits Early identification & prevention Mechanisms of dyslexia, reading & learning Community Background | Resilience Framework | Cognitive Resilience | Socio-Emotional Resilience | Conclusion
  • 47. Bay Area UCSF (NC White, R Hendren, K LeWinn, L Pasch, M Gorno- Tempini, B Miller); UC Berkeley (S Bunge); UC Davis (Y Uchikoshi, D Amaral, C Wu Nordahl); U of SF (G Leung); USA/Canada Boston College (J Black); Georgia State U (R Morris); Harvard U, Boston Children’s Hospital (L Prock Albers); MIT (J Gabrieli); U of British Columbia (L Siegel); U of Michigan (I Kovelman, R Marks); Vanderbilt U (L Cutting); Yale U, Haskins Labs, U Conn (K Pugh, J Reuckl; E Grigorenko); Asia Beijing Normal U, China (H Shu); Hebrew U, Israel (R Frost); Keio U, Tokyo, Japan (B Yamagata, M Mimura); Nat’l Cntrl U, Inst of Cog Neurosci, Taiwan (D Wu, O Tseng) U Hong Kong, China (C McBride); Europe BCBL, Spain (M Carreiras); U College London, UK (C Hulme); U of Jyvaskyla, Finland (H Lyytinen, P Leppannen, U Richardson); U of Salzburg, Austria (F Richlan); fumiko.hoeft@ucsf.edu | @fumikohoeft | brainlens.org Background | Resilience Framework | Cognitive Resilience | Socio-Emotional Resilience | Conclusion POSTDOC & CENTER MANAGER WANTED!
  • 48. Thank you… POSTDOC & CENTER MANAGER WANTED! Background | Resilience Framework | Cognitive Resilience | Socio-Emotional Resilience | Conclusion fumiko.hoeft@ucsf.edu | @fumikohoeft | brainlens.org
  • 49.
  • 50. Science-based Innovation in Learning Center (SILC) AWARD NAME. University of California Office of the President (UCOP) Multicampus Research Programs and Initiatives (MRPI) Award Grant # MRP-17-454925 DATES 1/1/2017 – 12/31/2019
  • 51. Science-based Innovation in Learning Center (SILC) WHO WE ARE A new and cross-disciplinary ‘Precision Ed-Health’ center across the (6) UC campuses with expertise in (bilingual) education, sp-ed, cog psych, neuroscience, medicine, & policy. Precision Medicine is an emerging data-driven approach for disease treatment and prevention that takes into account individual variability in environment, lifestyle and genes for each person. (2015) Precision Ed-Health is an data-driven approach to prevent the spiral effect of poor educational attainment to health disparity taking into account variability in each child by looking at large amounts of data from the environment, psychological, cognitive, neuroscience, biomedical information. MISSION. Tackle issues associated with education and health disparity with a particular emphasis on underrepresented populations. LONG-TERM GOAL. To provide the best educational and health outcomes for ALL CHILDREN regardless of their background. MODEL. Adoption of STAR (Services, Training, Advocacy, Research) SHORT TERM GOAL. Early identification and intervention of children at risk for learning challenges in English learners.
  • 52. Science-based Innovation in Learning Center (SILC) CAMPUSES & KEY PERSONNEL UCSF. Director: Fumiko Hoeft MD PhD, Neuroscience of LD, Medical science UC Berkeley. Silvia Bunge PhD, Cognitive neuroscience UC Davis. Jamal Abedi PhD, English Learners, Macro-data UC Irvine. Carol Conner PhD, Literacy Instruction UCLA. Marcelo Suarez-Orozco PhD, Education Policy together with Stanford University Center for Education Policy Analysis Susanna Loeb PhD UC Merced. Jeff Gilger PhD, Neuroscience of dyslexia, Training & education Others. Roeland Hancock for computation and biostatistics, Elissa Epel / Nicki Bush for health disparity, Nancy Cushen White for intervention and dyslexia, MariLu Gorno Tempini for language processes, Bob Hendren on mental health comorbidity, and Linda Siegel on multilingualism and dyslexia (UBC)
  • 53. Science-based Innovation in Learning Center (SILC) SILC STAR SERVICES • Professional development • Intervention TRAINING • Multidisciplin ary • Faculty, Postdocs, Students ADVOCACY • US DOE OCR • CDE RESEARCH • Archival • Prospective
  • 54. Science-based Innovation in Learning Center (SILC) AIM 1. • To establish a cross-campus interdisciplinary research center to develop STAR with an initial focus on ELs, RDs, literacy intervention and health disparity. AIM 2. Mine existing data • Find out early predictors of literacy acquisition in ELs. • Adjusting the A2i model for Spanish ELLs. • Study health outcome measures (obesity, stress, immune, cognitive aging). AIM 3. Perform a prospective, longitudinal, multisite proof-of-concept study in K- Gr1. • Test modified ISI/A2i algorithm. • Compare predictors of RD-risk. • Test feasibility of collecting and studying health measures and biomarkers.
  • 55. Science-based Innovation in Learning Center (SILC) Current (Eng) Best (Eng+Sp) A2i-revised Research (non-lang) Health Environment
  • 56. CENTER of INNOVATION IN NEUROSCIENCE-BASED TECHNOLOGY FOR EEUCATION AND LEARNING UCSF | UC Berkeley | Stanford adam bruce fumiko joaquin jyoti melina miriam roeland silvia S I L C UCSF - Stanford-UC Berkeley Science of Learning Collaborative Network (SL-CN)
  • 57. Before Birth PreSch/K 2nd-4thGr Adult Evidence-based Precision/Personalized Education Early identification Preventive intervention fumiko.hoeft@ucsf.edu | @fumikohoeft | brainlens.org
  • 58.
  • 59. Science-based Innovation in Learning Center (SILC) AIM 1. • To establish a cross-campus interdisciplinary research center to develop Services, Training, Advocacy and Research (STAR) with an initial focus on ELLs, RDs, literacy intervention and health disparity. AIM 2. • Collaboratively integrate existing rich data on Spanish ELL children across SILC UC sites to identify candidate early predictors of literacy outcomes and health outcomes and model child × instruction interactions in ELLs to revise the A2i algorithm for this population. AIM 3. • Perform a prospective, longitudinal, multisite proof-of-concept study in first grade ELLs to: (a) evaluate the predictive power of early RD-risk measures that can be used for all ELLs, regardless of native language, and relating these to health disparity measures; (b) evaluate the effectiveness of the revised A2i algorithm in improving academic outcomes in Spanish ELLs.
  • 60. Science-based Innovation in Learning Center (SILC) BACKGROUND. In the US, 9.2% of public school children are English learners (ELs), and EL enrollment has grown 50% over the past decade, outpacing non-EL enrollment. In California (CA), a quarter of the school-aged children in the public schools are ELs. ELs are twice as likely as non-ELs to live in poverty and more likely to be misidentified than non- ELs for learning disabilities (LDs) such as reading disorders (RD). Learning disabilities and their misidentification in ELs further contributes to EL inequality in English proficiency and educational attainment, leading to income and health disparity. Reducing education-related risks for poor health outcomes in ELs requires efforts to better understand the link between educational attainment and health disparity in this population, and early identification of LD in ELs. Although there are good predictors of RD in English monolinguals, extending these to ELs is complicated by variability in language experience, lack of English proficiency, variability in the native languages spoken by ELs, and the lack of normed measures (except Spanish) and qualified practitioners. One third of all US ELs are in CA, making these issues particularly significant for the state and UC, while at the same time providing the opportunity for UC to be a leader in addressing these issues.
  • 61. Science-based Innovation in Learning Center (SILC) SHORT-TERM GOALS. (1) setup an innovative, multicampus, cross-disciplinary collaboration bridging education, cognitive sciences, medicine and policy, and (2) perform a series of pilot studies to examine the links between academic and health outcomes in ELs and evaluate individualized prescription of reading interventions that will prepare us to compete for federal center and collaborative research grants in the near future. LONG-TERM GOALS. For the proposed UC center to be a national leader in ‘Precision Ed-Health’, and tackle issues associated with education and health disparity in underrepresented populations, with an initial emphasis on early identification and intervention of children at risk for learning challenges. CENTRAL MISSION. Includes performing high quality research and providing training, services and advocacy. Such efforts will ultimately enhance the lives of children and families, while addressing major issues in CA and the US, including the cost of education, difficulties of educating diverse populations including ELs, and the health consequences of poor school performance.

Editor's Notes

  1. Insert IDA logo
  2. Family history Pennington Lefly 2001 Cost 100k less: Earnings Foresight Mental Capital and Wellbeing Project. Mental Capital and Wellbeing: Final Project Report (The Government Office for Science, 2008) – Usha Goswami NRN 2015 Grigorenko ADHD various papers 40% (vs. 9% in all children – NIH website) review of comorbidity of LD and ADHD with comorbidity rate estimates (DuPaul et al., 2012) Germano et al. Dev Neuropsychol ’10) Anxiety test anxiety 5x stats (Nelson ’13, Carroll ‘06), 8% from NIH, 2x stats on anxiety disorder (Wilson et al JLD 2009) Depression 14% in children according to NIH, according to Wilson et al. JLD 2009, it’s 14.6% (in LD) vs 7.4% (people without disabilities) Mental health stats in typical children generally come from the NIH website Abuse (Nat’l Assn on Alcohol, Drug, Disability, ’10) on disabilities generally or ID so not good. Abuse (Moody ’00) Karacostas & Fisher 1993 chemical dependence 24% in LD, 9% in non disabled students. Found in article Meredith Cosden et al. JLD 2001 Prison (Quinn, ’05) HS drop out rate - https://nces.ed.gov/fastfacts/display.asp?id=16 for typical population (7%), NCLD report for LD (18%), http://www.ncld.org/reports-and-studies/diplomas-at-risk-a-critical-look-at-the-high-school-graduation-rate/ hispanisc typical 12% HS graduation rate: http://nces.ed.gov/ccd/tables/ACGR_2010-11_to_2012-13.asp 81% (all children) vs. 68% (LD – NCLD 2014 report)
  3. BACKGROUND Reading is complex. Multifactorial Vulnerability Model can explain difficulties of dyslexia SOME RESEARCH TOPICS 1. Different identification approaches How should we identify dyslexia? What is the brain basis of different identification approaches? - Implications for policy. 2. Brain basis of dyslexia Is the ‘dyslexia network’ specific to dyslexia? What networks are related to compensation in dyslexia? 3. Resiliency How can some comprehend written texts in the face of difficulty in decoding? - Implications for intervention. 4. Internal environment How important are personal characteristics such as socio-emotional processing, motivation and grit? What are the brain bases?
  4. BACKGROUND Reading is complex. Multifactorial Vulnerability Model can explain difficulties of dyslexia SOME RESEARCH TOPICS 1. Different identification approaches How should we identify dyslexia? What is the brain basis of different identification approaches? - Implications for policy. 2. Brain basis of dyslexia Is the ‘dyslexia network’ specific to dyslexia? What networks are related to compensation in dyslexia? 3. Resiliency How can some comprehend written texts in the face of difficulty in decoding? - Implications for intervention. 4. Internal environment How important are personal characteristics such as socio-emotional processing, motivation and grit? What are the brain bases?
  5. “resilience is the capacity of a dynamic, malleable system to withstand challenges to its stability, viability or development (Karatsoreos F1000 ref 1) In Selye’s interpretation, stress was the result of an organism’s failed attempts to appropriately cope with a physical challenge [6], and since then the definition of stress has expanded to contain ideation or anticipation of impending threats [7]. Stress resilience refers to an individual’s capacity for successful adaptation to acute stress, trauma or more chronic forms of adversity
  6. Bo x 1 | Psychosocial factors and possible neurobiological underpinnings associated with resilience Facing fears and active coping Facing fears promotes active coping strategies such as planning and problem solving. The ability to face one’s fears might be facilitated by stress inoculation (exposure to tolerable levels of stress) during development, and might be linked to the optimal functioning of fear extinction mechanisms. Active, or ‘fight–flight’, responses in animals have been linked to more transient activation of the hypothalamus-pituitary-adrenal (HPA) axis27, although the relationship between HPA axis activity and active or passive coping might not be straightforward, as positive associations have also been found26. Physical exercise, which can be viewed as a form of active coping, has positive effects on mood, attenuates stress responses and is thought to promote neurogenesis13. Optimism and positive emotions Positive emotions might contribute to healthier cognitive responses17,128 and decreased autonomic arousal128. Mesolimbic dopamine pathways might be more reward responsive and/or stress resistant in individuals who remain optimistic when faced with trauma3. Accordingly, resilience in animals has been related to specific molecular adaptations in the mesolimbic dopamine system41. Cognitive reappraisal, positive reframing and acceptance Cognitive reappraisal involves reinterpreting the meaning of negative stimuli, with a resulting reduction in emotional responses. Resilient individuals might be better at reappraisal or might use reappraisal more frequently. Neurobiological mechanisms that underlie some of these processes include memory suppression, memory consolidation and cognitive control of emotion106,107. It is also likely that exposure to manageable stressors during development is associated with more adaptive coping with stress during adulthood139. In studies of squirrel monkeys and rodents, early exposure to manageable stressors (‘stress inoculation’) was found to be associated with reduced behavioural and hormonal responses to stress later in life65,140. Adaptive responses seem to be associated with the degree of behavioural control an animal has over stress141. Social competence and social support Social competence and openness to social support promote resilience in children and adults5,13. Mutual cooperation is associated with activation of brain reward circuits. Oxytocin enhances the reward value of social attachments and reduces fear responses. Future research might identify potential differences in these measures in resilient individuals. Purpose in life, a moral compass, meaning and spirituality A sense of purpose and an internal framework of beliefs about right and wrong are characteristic of resilient individuals8,13. Religious and spiritual beliefs and practices might also facilitate recovery and finding meaning after trauma13. Brain imaging studies are beginning to identify the neural correlates of human morality129.
  7. Bo x 1 | Psychosocial factors and possible neurobiological underpinnings associated with resilience Facing fears and active coping Facing fears promotes active coping strategies such as planning and problem solving. The ability to face one’s fears might be facilitated by stress inoculation (exposure to tolerable levels of stress) during development, and might be linked to the optimal functioning of fear extinction mechanisms. Active, or ‘fight–flight’, responses in animals have been linked to more transient activation of the hypothalamus-pituitary-adrenal (HPA) axis27, although the relationship between HPA axis activity and active or passive coping might not be straightforward, as positive associations have also been found26. Physical exercise, which can be viewed as a form of active coping, has positive effects on mood, attenuates stress responses and is thought to promote neurogenesis13. Optimism and positive emotions Positive emotions might contribute to healthier cognitive responses17,128 and decreased autonomic arousal128. Mesolimbic dopamine pathways might be more reward responsive and/or stress resistant in individuals who remain optimistic when faced with trauma3. Accordingly, resilience in animals has been related to specific molecular adaptations in the mesolimbic dopamine system41. Cognitive reappraisal, positive reframing and acceptance Cognitive reappraisal involves reinterpreting the meaning of negative stimuli, with a resulting reduction in emotional responses. Resilient individuals might be better at reappraisal or might use reappraisal more frequently. Neurobiological mechanisms that underlie some of these processes include memory suppression, memory consolidation and cognitive control of emotion106,107. It is also likely that exposure to manageable stressors during development is associated with more adaptive coping with stress during adulthood139. In studies of squirrel monkeys and rodents, early exposure to manageable stressors (‘stress inoculation’) was found to be associated with reduced behavioural and hormonal responses to stress later in life65,140. Adaptive responses seem to be associated with the degree of behavioural control an animal has over stress141. Social competence and social support Social competence and openness to social support promote resilience in children and adults5,13. Mutual cooperation is associated with activation of brain reward circuits. Oxytocin enhances the reward value of social attachments and reduces fear responses. Future research might identify potential differences in these measures in resilient individuals. Purpose in life, a moral compass, meaning and spirituality A sense of purpose and an internal framework of beliefs about right and wrong are characteristic of resilient individuals8,13. Religious and spiritual beliefs and practices might also facilitate recovery and finding meaning after trauma13. Brain imaging studies are beginning to identify the neural correlates of human morality129.
  8. Operate in a much larger space but each today will cover certain corners of this 4D space.
  9. Mechanism Neural noise hypothesis –Roeland Hancock, Ken Pugh, Al Galaburda
  10. Precision medicine is an emerging approach for disease treatment and prevention that takes into account individual variability in environment, lifestyle and genes for each person. Precision Ed-Health is an approach to prevent the spiral effect of poor educational attainment to health disparity taking into account variability in each child by looking at large amounts of data from the environment, psychological, cognitive, neuroscience, biomedical information.