SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 39
Download to read offline
Robust Earth Retaining Wall System to Control
Ground Movement and Minimize Impact on
Adjacent Structures
T.S. Chua, Michelle Lew, V. Rama, H.L. Phua
Circle Line, CCL
Location plan of PPJ
CableTunnel
Pasir Panjang Station
Pre-war house
Design Analysis
Geology at the site
PPJ
Soil Profile
Existing cracks
Layout plan
P25P21 P22 P23 P24P20
Cross
wall
Cross wall
Tunnel
through
Cross wall – Case A
Tunnel
through
Cross wall – Case B
Cross wall
Tunnel
through
Cross wall – Case C
Cross wall
Tunnel
through
Design parameters
Plaxis Analysis-Removal of S5
Construction Sequence
Construction Sequence
J A S O N D J F M A M J J A S O N D J F M A M J J A S O N D J F M A M J J A S O N D
Diaphragm Walls
Traffic / Canal Diversion
Cross Walls
Decking Works
Excavation & Strutting
Base Slab
Tunnelling Works (West)
ACTIVITY
200820072005 2006
South Dwall
North Dwall North Dwall
Base Slab
Bulk Excavation
Road Diversion
Stage 1A
North Canal
Works
Road Diversion Stage 3
King Posts &
Deck Posts (West)
King Posts &
Deck Posts (North)
Road Diversion Stage 2
King Posts & Deck Posts (South)
Cross Walls
TBM at standstill pending
completion of PPJ base slab
West Drive
(inner bound) West Drive (outer bound)
TBM bore through PPJ
Construction Programme
Construction Stages
North D-wall Construction Top Deck Slab Construction
P24
Soil Condition
Crosswall: At pier locations
P22
P23
Cross wall - Stages of Construction
Crosswall Supports
Foundation for Cross wall
Toe of DW
Strutting system
Tunnel-through within station
Performance
Predicted versus Actual Behaviour
Instrumentation
General Purpose
• To provide necessary information for the design purposes
• To monitor performance during and after construction
• To ensure safety construction (minimise risk & damage)
• To allow less costly construction without danger of failure
Usage
• To monitor the deformation of
- Critical structures, particularly Pasir Panjang Semi Expressway
- Critical utilities: Water Pipes, Telecom, Power Cables and Gas Main
- Ground, including road and sideways settlement
• To measure performance of wall, strut forces and ground water response
Installed Instruments
Optical Prisms Inclinometers Settlement Markers Water Standpipes
Piezometers Strut Monitoring Devices (Strain Gages and Load Cells)
PPJ
P24
P23
P25
P22
P21
P20
IS3001
IS3002
IS3003
IS3004
IS3005
IS3006
IS3007
IS3010
IS3011
IS3012
IS3013
IS3014
IS3015
IS3016
IW3001
IW3002
IW3003
IW3005
IW3006
IW3007
IW3108
IW3109
IW3110
IW3111
IW3112
IW3113
IW3114
IW3115
IW3116
IW3117
Cross Walls are used
to minimize wall movement
Sensitive PPSE piers
to be protected
Utilities: Gas, Electricity, Water &
Telecoms
Ground Movement near Piers 21-24
during Grout Piles Installation
May – August 2006
PIER INC INCLINOMETER READINGS (mm)
┴ to SITE // to SITE
Towards
SITE
Away fr
SITE
Towards
CITY
Away fr
CITY
P21 IS3001 0 3 0 4.9
P22 IS3002 2.1 0 4.3 0
P23 IS3003 0 6 1 0
P24 IS3006 0 1 0 5
P21 P24P23P22
PPJ SITE
CITY
Grout Piles are used to improve
trench stability during diaphragm
wall construction
IS3006 Readings near P24
Displacement during Grouting Works &
Installation of Diaphragm Wall Panels
Panel J17 Panel J18 Panel J19
Grouting Starts
Grouting Ends
Trenching Starts
Casting Ends
IS3006
… 4 mm max
F
M
F1
F1
E
S(IV)
S(III)
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
0 5 10
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
-5 0 5 10
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
0 5 10 15 20
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
-15 -10 -5 0 5 10
F
F1
M
E
S(IV)
F
F1
M
S(VI)
S(IV)
Cross Wall
Base Slab
IS3012 IS3002 IW3111 IW3001
Inclinometer Readings
PPSE
Perpendicular to Site
between Piers 22 & 23
As of Oct 08
Comparison of Results
Cross wallCross wall
DESIGN
ACTUAL
F1
E
F2
S(V)
S(IV)
F
F1
F2
S(VI)-S(V)
S(IV)
GL to S2 EXC
S3 EXC
S4 EXC
S5 EXC
S6 EXC
FEL EXC
S6 REM
S5 REM
M
NORTH SOUTH
IW3117
PPJ-13 PPJ-07
• At shallow depth the soil at south
side is stronger than the soil at
north side
• Preloaded struts
(100-250kN/m) “pushed” the north
wall backwards at shallow depths
• Movement towards excavation
only happened during strut
removals
PL=100kN/m
PL=250kN/m
PL=250kN/m
PL=500kN/m
PL=520kN/m
PL=500kN/m
Ref: Drawing F/856/PPJ/CT/2018B
Base Slab
-5
0
5
10
15
20
Displacement,mm
S1 EXC
S2 EXC
S3 EXC
S4 EXC
S5 EXC
S6 EXC
FEL
S6 REM
S5 REM
IW3108
IW3109 IW3110 IW3112 IW3114 IW3116
IW3111IW3117 IW3113 IW3115
North Wall - Max Lateral Displacement Profile
17mm max
Deformation of Structures
Comparison of Results
CORRESPONDING PIER AND WALL MOVEMENTS
92
94
96
98
100
102
104
02/04/07 01/06/07 31/07/07 29/09/07 28/11/07 27/01/08 27/03/08 26/05/08 25/07/08 23/09/08
PiezometricLevel(mRL)
GWV3018 GWV3019 GWV3020
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
02/04/07 01/06/07 31/07/07 29/09/07 28/11/07 27/01/08 27/03/08 26/05/08 25/07/08 23/09/08
Pier&GroundSettlement(mm)
LU3028 LB3016
Shallowest tip (5m)
Deepest tip (15m)
Pier 22 Settlement
Surrounding
Ground
Settlement
S1-S2EXC
S3EXC
S4EXC
S5EXC
S6EXC
F.E.L
S6REM
S5REM
92
94
96
98
100
102
104
02/04/07 01/06/07 31/07/07 29/09/07 28/11/07 27/01/08 27/03/08 26/05/08 25/07/08 23/09/08
PiezometricLevel(mRL)
GW V3015 GW V3016 GW V3017
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
02/04/07 01/06/07 31/07/07 29/09/07 28/11/07 27/01/08 27/03/08 26/05/08 25/07/08 23/09/08
Pier&GroundSettlement(mm)
LU3017 LB3018
Shallowest tip (5m)
Deepest tip (15m)
Pier 23 Settlement
Surrounding
Ground
Settlement
S1-S2EXC
S3EXC
S4EXC
S5EXC
S6EXC
F.E.L
S6REM
S5REM

More Related Content

What's hot

Dynamic characteristics of alluvial deposits a case study
Dynamic characteristics of alluvial deposits a case studyDynamic characteristics of alluvial deposits a case study
Dynamic characteristics of alluvial deposits a case studyInfocengrs63
 
Max Sommers CV 2017
Max Sommers CV 2017Max Sommers CV 2017
Max Sommers CV 2017Max Sommers
 
Geotechnical report by Dr. Malek Samdi of GEOTILL
Geotechnical report by Dr. Malek Samdi of GEOTILLGeotechnical report by Dr. Malek Samdi of GEOTILL
Geotechnical report by Dr. Malek Samdi of GEOTILLDr. Malek Smadi
 
Construction Time Analysis For Different Steps In Drill-And-Blast Method Of H...
Construction Time Analysis For Different Steps In Drill-And-Blast Method Of H...Construction Time Analysis For Different Steps In Drill-And-Blast Method Of H...
Construction Time Analysis For Different Steps In Drill-And-Blast Method Of H...IJERA Editor
 
Site Surveys_Rig Safety-Link
Site Surveys_Rig Safety-LinkSite Surveys_Rig Safety-Link
Site Surveys_Rig Safety-LinkAbdul Rahim
 
Professional WORK EXPERIENCE
Professional WORK EXPERIENCEProfessional WORK EXPERIENCE
Professional WORK EXPERIENCEJesse Marley
 
Dr. Malek Smadi, Ph.D. thesis lateral deformation and associated settlement r...
Dr. Malek Smadi, Ph.D. thesis lateral deformation and associated settlement r...Dr. Malek Smadi, Ph.D. thesis lateral deformation and associated settlement r...
Dr. Malek Smadi, Ph.D. thesis lateral deformation and associated settlement r...Dr. Malek Smadi
 
Schlumberger - Drilling and Measurement Segment - Internship Presentation
Schlumberger - Drilling and Measurement Segment - Internship PresentationSchlumberger - Drilling and Measurement Segment - Internship Presentation
Schlumberger - Drilling and Measurement Segment - Internship PresentationZorays Solar Pakistan
 
CM - Jauregui - Sapienza University of Rome (60 min, part i, members modified)
CM - Jauregui - Sapienza University of Rome (60 min, part i, members modified)CM - Jauregui - Sapienza University of Rome (60 min, part i, members modified)
CM - Jauregui - Sapienza University of Rome (60 min, part i, members modified)Franco Bontempi Org Didattica
 
Ground Investigation by Horizontal Directional Drilling
Ground Investigation by Horizontal Directional DrillingGround Investigation by Horizontal Directional Drilling
Ground Investigation by Horizontal Directional DrillingTim Leung
 
ASCE PL Div 2001 40574-017-002
ASCE PL Div 2001 40574-017-002ASCE PL Div 2001 40574-017-002
ASCE PL Div 2001 40574-017-002William Godwin
 
Technical Paper on Chennai Metro Project (Mr Klaus Muenz and Nandan Kumar)
Technical Paper on Chennai Metro Project (Mr Klaus Muenz and Nandan Kumar)Technical Paper on Chennai Metro Project (Mr Klaus Muenz and Nandan Kumar)
Technical Paper on Chennai Metro Project (Mr Klaus Muenz and Nandan Kumar)Nandan Shandilya
 
Code of practice for mine surveyors
Code of practice for mine surveyorsCode of practice for mine surveyors
Code of practice for mine surveyorsKrishna Deo Prasad
 

What's hot (20)

Dynamic characteristics of alluvial deposits a case study
Dynamic characteristics of alluvial deposits a case studyDynamic characteristics of alluvial deposits a case study
Dynamic characteristics of alluvial deposits a case study
 
Max Sommers CV 2017
Max Sommers CV 2017Max Sommers CV 2017
Max Sommers CV 2017
 
Geotechnical report by Dr. Malek Samdi of GEOTILL
Geotechnical report by Dr. Malek Samdi of GEOTILLGeotechnical report by Dr. Malek Samdi of GEOTILL
Geotechnical report by Dr. Malek Samdi of GEOTILL
 
Engineering Geologist
Engineering GeologistEngineering Geologist
Engineering Geologist
 
Construction Time Analysis For Different Steps In Drill-And-Blast Method Of H...
Construction Time Analysis For Different Steps In Drill-And-Blast Method Of H...Construction Time Analysis For Different Steps In Drill-And-Blast Method Of H...
Construction Time Analysis For Different Steps In Drill-And-Blast Method Of H...
 
Site Surveys_Rig Safety-Link
Site Surveys_Rig Safety-LinkSite Surveys_Rig Safety-Link
Site Surveys_Rig Safety-Link
 
Professional WORK EXPERIENCE
Professional WORK EXPERIENCEProfessional WORK EXPERIENCE
Professional WORK EXPERIENCE
 
Work Experience large
Work Experience largeWork Experience large
Work Experience large
 
Dr. Malek Smadi, Ph.D. thesis lateral deformation and associated settlement r...
Dr. Malek Smadi, Ph.D. thesis lateral deformation and associated settlement r...Dr. Malek Smadi, Ph.D. thesis lateral deformation and associated settlement r...
Dr. Malek Smadi, Ph.D. thesis lateral deformation and associated settlement r...
 
OKEREKE CHISOM CV
OKEREKE CHISOM CVOKEREKE CHISOM CV
OKEREKE CHISOM CV
 
CV ASIF MAHMOOD
CV ASIF MAHMOODCV ASIF MAHMOOD
CV ASIF MAHMOOD
 
Schlumberger - Drilling and Measurement Segment - Internship Presentation
Schlumberger - Drilling and Measurement Segment - Internship PresentationSchlumberger - Drilling and Measurement Segment - Internship Presentation
Schlumberger - Drilling and Measurement Segment - Internship Presentation
 
CM - Jauregui - Sapienza University of Rome (60 min, part i, members modified)
CM - Jauregui - Sapienza University of Rome (60 min, part i, members modified)CM - Jauregui - Sapienza University of Rome (60 min, part i, members modified)
CM - Jauregui - Sapienza University of Rome (60 min, part i, members modified)
 
Ground Investigation by Horizontal Directional Drilling
Ground Investigation by Horizontal Directional DrillingGround Investigation by Horizontal Directional Drilling
Ground Investigation by Horizontal Directional Drilling
 
ASCE PL Div 2001 40574-017-002
ASCE PL Div 2001 40574-017-002ASCE PL Div 2001 40574-017-002
ASCE PL Div 2001 40574-017-002
 
35
3535
35
 
Jason Abendroth Resume_10_2015
Jason Abendroth Resume_10_2015Jason Abendroth Resume_10_2015
Jason Abendroth Resume_10_2015
 
Mining surveys
Mining surveysMining surveys
Mining surveys
 
Technical Paper on Chennai Metro Project (Mr Klaus Muenz and Nandan Kumar)
Technical Paper on Chennai Metro Project (Mr Klaus Muenz and Nandan Kumar)Technical Paper on Chennai Metro Project (Mr Klaus Muenz and Nandan Kumar)
Technical Paper on Chennai Metro Project (Mr Klaus Muenz and Nandan Kumar)
 
Code of practice for mine surveyors
Code of practice for mine surveyorsCode of practice for mine surveyors
Code of practice for mine surveyors
 

Similar to ICDE2008, Singapore

IRJET- Parametric Study on Effect of Soil-Structure Interaction on Bridge Piers
IRJET- Parametric Study on Effect of Soil-Structure Interaction on Bridge PiersIRJET- Parametric Study on Effect of Soil-Structure Interaction on Bridge Piers
IRJET- Parametric Study on Effect of Soil-Structure Interaction on Bridge PiersIRJET Journal
 
NJI Portfolio Short
NJI Portfolio ShortNJI Portfolio Short
NJI Portfolio ShortNick Ivill
 
ATAL TUNNEL.pptx
ATAL TUNNEL.pptxATAL TUNNEL.pptx
ATAL TUNNEL.pptxAditya Mane
 
ATAL TUNNEL.pptx
ATAL TUNNEL.pptxATAL TUNNEL.pptx
ATAL TUNNEL.pptxAditya Mane
 
Al Jewaibyah Regulating Tank 70,000m3
Al Jewaibyah Regulating Tank  70,000m3Al Jewaibyah Regulating Tank  70,000m3
Al Jewaibyah Regulating Tank 70,000m3Vladimir Popovic
 
Man Made River Project IV Phase - Ghadames Project - AJRT Regulating Tank 70....
Man Made River Project IV Phase - Ghadames Project - AJRT Regulating Tank 70....Man Made River Project IV Phase - Ghadames Project - AJRT Regulating Tank 70....
Man Made River Project IV Phase - Ghadames Project - AJRT Regulating Tank 70....Vladimir Popovic
 
Civil - Structural Works
Civil - Structural WorksCivil - Structural Works
Civil - Structural WorksBabu Arumugam
 
Presentation 1 st 4 km
Presentation 1 st 4 kmPresentation 1 st 4 km
Presentation 1 st 4 kmSvet Dotchev
 
PPT CAVITY Tunnel P1 610M--05.02.2021.pptx
PPT CAVITY Tunnel P1 610M--05.02.2021.pptxPPT CAVITY Tunnel P1 610M--05.02.2021.pptx
PPT CAVITY Tunnel P1 610M--05.02.2021.pptxAGNIVORAY1
 
Tunnel T80 across Pir Panjal Mountain Range: The Longest Transportation Tunne...
Tunnel T80 across Pir Panjal Mountain Range: The Longest Transportation Tunne...Tunnel T80 across Pir Panjal Mountain Range: The Longest Transportation Tunne...
Tunnel T80 across Pir Panjal Mountain Range: The Longest Transportation Tunne...Hitesh Khanna
 
PERFORMANCE EVALUATION OF DEEP EXCAVATION UNDER STATIC AND SEISMIC LOAD CONDI...
PERFORMANCE EVALUATION OF DEEP EXCAVATION UNDER STATIC AND SEISMIC LOAD CONDI...PERFORMANCE EVALUATION OF DEEP EXCAVATION UNDER STATIC AND SEISMIC LOAD CONDI...
PERFORMANCE EVALUATION OF DEEP EXCAVATION UNDER STATIC AND SEISMIC LOAD CONDI...IRJET Journal
 
State of the Art and Practice Geotechnical Design
State of the Art and Practice Geotechnical DesignState of the Art and Practice Geotechnical Design
State of the Art and Practice Geotechnical DesignDr Mazin Alhamrany
 
Geo-Tech Studies for Longwall
Geo-Tech Studies for LongwallGeo-Tech Studies for Longwall
Geo-Tech Studies for LongwallVR M
 
Computer aided analysis and design of multi story building
Computer aided analysis and design of multi story buildingComputer aided analysis and design of multi story building
Computer aided analysis and design of multi story buildingparas6904
 
s-Presentation-1ST 4 KM
s-Presentation-1ST 4 KMs-Presentation-1ST 4 KM
s-Presentation-1ST 4 KMSvet Dotchev
 
Introduction to Hydraulics "Engineering is your job"
Introduction to Hydraulics "Engineering is your job"Introduction to Hydraulics "Engineering is your job"
Introduction to Hydraulics "Engineering is your job"Dr. Ezzat Elsayed Gomaa
 
Numerical Investigation of Failure Mechanisms of Cast Iron Watermains
Numerical Investigation of Failure Mechanisms of Cast Iron WatermainsNumerical Investigation of Failure Mechanisms of Cast Iron Watermains
Numerical Investigation of Failure Mechanisms of Cast Iron Watermainskasuni200
 
TRAINING REPORT ON COSTRUCTION OF FLYOVER FROM MITHAPUR TO CHIRIYATAND (BIHAR)
TRAINING REPORT ON  COSTRUCTION OF FLYOVER FROM  MITHAPUR TO CHIRIYATAND (BIHAR)TRAINING REPORT ON  COSTRUCTION OF FLYOVER FROM  MITHAPUR TO CHIRIYATAND (BIHAR)
TRAINING REPORT ON COSTRUCTION OF FLYOVER FROM MITHAPUR TO CHIRIYATAND (BIHAR)vishal prakash
 

Similar to ICDE2008, Singapore (20)

IRJET- Parametric Study on Effect of Soil-Structure Interaction on Bridge Piers
IRJET- Parametric Study on Effect of Soil-Structure Interaction on Bridge PiersIRJET- Parametric Study on Effect of Soil-Structure Interaction on Bridge Piers
IRJET- Parametric Study on Effect of Soil-Structure Interaction on Bridge Piers
 
NJI Portfolio Short
NJI Portfolio ShortNJI Portfolio Short
NJI Portfolio Short
 
ATAL TUNNEL.pptx
ATAL TUNNEL.pptxATAL TUNNEL.pptx
ATAL TUNNEL.pptx
 
ATAL TUNNEL.pptx
ATAL TUNNEL.pptxATAL TUNNEL.pptx
ATAL TUNNEL.pptx
 
Al Jewaibyah Regulating Tank 70,000m3
Al Jewaibyah Regulating Tank  70,000m3Al Jewaibyah Regulating Tank  70,000m3
Al Jewaibyah Regulating Tank 70,000m3
 
Man Made River Project IV Phase - Ghadames Project - AJRT Regulating Tank 70....
Man Made River Project IV Phase - Ghadames Project - AJRT Regulating Tank 70....Man Made River Project IV Phase - Ghadames Project - AJRT Regulating Tank 70....
Man Made River Project IV Phase - Ghadames Project - AJRT Regulating Tank 70....
 
Civil - Structural Works
Civil - Structural WorksCivil - Structural Works
Civil - Structural Works
 
Presentation 1 st 4 km
Presentation 1 st 4 kmPresentation 1 st 4 km
Presentation 1 st 4 km
 
PPT CAVITY Tunnel P1 610M--05.02.2021.pptx
PPT CAVITY Tunnel P1 610M--05.02.2021.pptxPPT CAVITY Tunnel P1 610M--05.02.2021.pptx
PPT CAVITY Tunnel P1 610M--05.02.2021.pptx
 
subsea
subseasubsea
subsea
 
Tunnel T80 across Pir Panjal Mountain Range: The Longest Transportation Tunne...
Tunnel T80 across Pir Panjal Mountain Range: The Longest Transportation Tunne...Tunnel T80 across Pir Panjal Mountain Range: The Longest Transportation Tunne...
Tunnel T80 across Pir Panjal Mountain Range: The Longest Transportation Tunne...
 
PERFORMANCE EVALUATION OF DEEP EXCAVATION UNDER STATIC AND SEISMIC LOAD CONDI...
PERFORMANCE EVALUATION OF DEEP EXCAVATION UNDER STATIC AND SEISMIC LOAD CONDI...PERFORMANCE EVALUATION OF DEEP EXCAVATION UNDER STATIC AND SEISMIC LOAD CONDI...
PERFORMANCE EVALUATION OF DEEP EXCAVATION UNDER STATIC AND SEISMIC LOAD CONDI...
 
State of the Art and Practice Geotechnical Design
State of the Art and Practice Geotechnical DesignState of the Art and Practice Geotechnical Design
State of the Art and Practice Geotechnical Design
 
Geo-Tech Studies for Longwall
Geo-Tech Studies for LongwallGeo-Tech Studies for Longwall
Geo-Tech Studies for Longwall
 
Computer aided analysis and design of multi story building
Computer aided analysis and design of multi story buildingComputer aided analysis and design of multi story building
Computer aided analysis and design of multi story building
 
s-Presentation-1ST 4 KM
s-Presentation-1ST 4 KMs-Presentation-1ST 4 KM
s-Presentation-1ST 4 KM
 
Introduction to Hydraulics "Engineering is your job"
Introduction to Hydraulics "Engineering is your job"Introduction to Hydraulics "Engineering is your job"
Introduction to Hydraulics "Engineering is your job"
 
Numerical Investigation of Failure Mechanisms of Cast Iron Watermains
Numerical Investigation of Failure Mechanisms of Cast Iron WatermainsNumerical Investigation of Failure Mechanisms of Cast Iron Watermains
Numerical Investigation of Failure Mechanisms of Cast Iron Watermains
 
TRAINING REPORT ON COSTRUCTION OF FLYOVER FROM MITHAPUR TO CHIRIYATAND (BIHAR)
TRAINING REPORT ON  COSTRUCTION OF FLYOVER FROM  MITHAPUR TO CHIRIYATAND (BIHAR)TRAINING REPORT ON  COSTRUCTION OF FLYOVER FROM  MITHAPUR TO CHIRIYATAND (BIHAR)
TRAINING REPORT ON COSTRUCTION OF FLYOVER FROM MITHAPUR TO CHIRIYATAND (BIHAR)
 
Geotechnical Investigation
Geotechnical InvestigationGeotechnical Investigation
Geotechnical Investigation
 

ICDE2008, Singapore