Getting $hIT Done: Implementing Your Digital Strategy
SPONSORED BY THE DIGITAL STRATEGIES AND TRANSFORMATIONS SIG
November 6, 2015
Introductions
Image source: http://i.imgur.com/984uGbL.jpg
Image source: https://www.facebook.com/artsmia/photos/a.60164728068.67478.8448903068/10153690331158069/?type=3&theater
DH
Douglas Hegley
Director of Media and Technology
Minneapolis Institute of Art
John Gordy
Chief of Digital Outreach
National Gallery of Art
Bill Weinstein
The John H. McFadden and Lisa D. Kabnick
Director of Information and Interpretive Technologies
Philadelphia Museum of Art
Jane Alexander
Chief Information Officer
Cleveland Museum of Art
Image source: http://4.bp.blogspot.com/-OGhI5V_LRGg/UNOCdvBdN5I/AAAAAAAABdE/Qx40uIvKS0g/s1600/Digital_Strategy.jpg
Digital Strategy
JG
Jean-Leon Gerome, The Carpet Merchant, c. 1887, Minneapolis Institute of Art , 70.40
DH
Implementing Digital
Strategy
MCN 201509
Image source: http://2.bp.blogspot.com/-ibdVGFGmoLA/Url-0PaZaSI/AAAAAAAAAq8/kyujzS9nz1g/s1600/highlander.jpg
There can be only
one … strategy
DH
You Want Strategy?
DH
MCN 201512 JG
MCN 201513 JG
Philadelphia Museum of Art
Strategic Plan
MCN 201514
WW
Philadelphia Museum of Art
Brand Initiative Goals
MCN 201515
WW
Philadelphia Museum of Art
Roadmap to Digital Excellence
MCN 201516
Infrastructure, Hardware, and
Systems
Legacy Platforms,
Siloed Data
Technology Skills Centered in
IT
Tightly Structured,
Less Participatory
Focused on Outcomes
Integrated Systems, Data
Driven Decisions
Digital Thinking, Digital Skills
Throughout the Institution
Collaborative, Agile, and
Adaptive
WW
"Art museums might have a lot to gain
by upping their digital game, according
to a new report.“ –NCAR
But we already knew that,
right?
DIGITAL STRATEGY ?
DIGITAL ROADMAP ?
DIGITAL INTEGRATION PLAN ?
What are we calling this?
STOP WORDSMITHING
Based on the mission of museum
• Give direction, energy and guidelines to
move your organization forward.
• Succinct and unambiguous.
• Helps to allocate budgets and other
resources,
• Explains its impact on other departments
• realities of your organization in the future.
• Gives direction to the people who will have to
do the actual work of making digital
engagement reality.
Digital Strategy Objectives
• activate the collection
• connect art and audience through active experien
• promote new scholarship
• support research
• facilitate internal and external collaboration
• drive attendance
• increase revenue
• streamline work
Yes, “digital strategy” = LRP strategies with tech me
Basic Technology Guidelines
• set up and maintained according to industry best
practices
• common platforms and “cores”
• minimize licenses / maximize open source
• data must be accessible
– minimize manual steps & re-keying
– save money and effort
• digital assets must reusable and findable
• no “one off” projects
Digital Strategy Implementation
• focus on core data
• build sustainable, modular systems
– open-source & industry-standard software
– best practices
• architect with reuse/multi-use in mind
• no one-off projects
EVERYTHING in terms of the BIG PICTURE
“One does not ‘manage’ people. The task is to lead
people. And the goal is to make productive the
specific strengths and knowledge of every
individual.”
- Peter Drucker
Image source: http://54ventures.com/demo-images/fuse-slide-4-11-1800x800.jpg DH
Character shall you
hire.
Skill train you may.
Image source: http://img1.wikia.nocookie.net/__cb20131106213953/starwars/images/d/d6/Yoda_SWSB.png
DH
DH
Cool Blue
Do a select few
Seek funding & partners
(We wish we could do them all)
Risk: Too many at once (saying yes to
everything)
Red Flag
Do only if necessary
Stop! (or proceed with extreme
caution)
(We wish we could have none)
Risk: Bogs down & exhausts resources
Green Light
Do these fast
Make a prioritized list, get
moving
(We wish there were fewer)
Risk: Resources pulled away from Cool Blue
Gray Fog
Do only if there are resources
“Busy work” or dreamy
distractions
(We wish we had more time)
Risk: People fall into this , esp. in times of
stress
High
High
(Hard)
Low
Low
(Easy)
Importance,
based on
STRATEGY
Difficulty, based
in Reality
(gasp!)
Making Decisions
DH
DHImage source: http://www.wlnfe.org/wp-content/uploads/2015/01/bookshelf.jpg
Questions?
MCN 201529
Overcoming Resistance
MCN 201530
Source of quote: http://www.forbes.com/sites/glennllopis/2012/11/05/5-most-effective-ways-to-sell-change/
Without strategy, change is merely substitution, not evolution
- Glenn Llopis
Image source of quote: http://redequip.com.au/uploads/Redequip-Graph-1.jpg
DH
Adapted from: http://www.forbes.com/sites/johnkotter/2011/07/12/change-management-vs-change-leadership-whats-the-difference/
Change Management v. Change Leadership
Image source: http://www.agilepm.com/downloads/dirtyharry.jpg
Image source: http://www.intesolv.com/wp-content/uploads/2013/02/Careers-Mission-514x360.jpg
DH
Adapted from: http://www.forbes.com/sites/johnkotter/2011/07/12/change-management-vs-change-leadership-whats-the-difference/
Change Management v. Change Leadership
Tools and Procedures
Detailed plans
Minimize distractions
Limit impact
Small dedicated team
Incremental steps
Keep it under control
DH
Adapted from: http://www.forbes.com/sites/johnkotter/2011/07/12/change-management-vs-change-leadership-whats-the-difference/
Change Management v. Change Leadership
Tools and Procedures Vision and Drive
Detailed plans Establish and share WHY
Minimize distractions Sense of urgency and importance
Limit impact Expect wide impact
Small dedicated team Involve everyone
Incremental steps Enable big leaps
Keep it under control … by the way, almost no one is good at this
DH
Communication is Key
MCN 201535
• Get in early.
• Meetings, meetings and more meetings.
• Manage up.
• Stop making things people don’t want.
Gallery One and ArtLens were the
first beneficiaries of the museum’s
digital strategy
CMA wanted the technology
implementation to be innovative,
intelligent and in-line with tech
industry best practices
Proof of Concept
• Gallery One & ArtLens = prototype
– backend build-out
– data flow model
– automation
– interdepartmental team model
– vendor management model
– orient toward long-term planning
• Central Table
– interoperability / integration
– application modularity
A FEW OF THE MANY…
• digital asset management
• archival repository
• open-source website
• mobile site
• dashboard
• central table
• integrated CCMS
All hardware can all be remotely
rebooted via LogMeIn
Questions?
MCN 201542
Getting Digital
Initiatives Approved,
Funded and
Implemented
MCN 201543
Digital Initiatives Steering Committee
• CIO
• Deputy Director/Chief Curator
• Deputy Director/Advancement
• Director of Collections Management
• Director of Communications and Marketing
• Director of Education and Interpretation
• Director of Exhibitions and Publications
• Director of Library and Archives
• Director of Research and Evaluation
Digital Initiatives Review Process
• All projects have a Sponsor
(department-director level or higher)
• IMTS previews and guides
• Digital Initiatives Steering Committee
– big picture planning
– approval process
– review process
• Measurements of success are built in
MAKE PROCESS REALLY EASY
UMMM
THIS
STILL
MAY
NEEDS
SOME
WORK
Technology Funding
• Plan for the unexpected / rapid change
• 3-year rolling technology budget
• Project funding preferences
–outside funding / grants
–FYxxxx budget assignment
–Digital Initiatives set-aside fund
Interactive Project Process
MCN 201549
• Curator, Interpretation, Education and IIT generate interpretive
plan that identifies interactive technology needs.
• IIT and Interpretation begin preliminary design phase.
• IIT develops prototypes working with Interpretation and Visitor
Services to test with museum visitors.
• Curator, education review prototypes and work to refine
content.
• Curator, Interpretation, Education and IIT final review and
approval.
Project Review Process
MCN 201550
• Quarterly review of all interactive projects; Director, Curator of
Education, Director of IIT, Associate Director of Interactive
Technologies, Assistant Director of Interpretation, Deputy
Director for Collections and Programs.
• Weekly standing meeting; Curator of Education, Director of IIT,
Assistant Director of Interpretation, Associate Director of
Interactive Technologies.
Funding Projects
MCN 201551
• Special exhibition projects funded as part of overall exhibit
budget.
• Development liaison.
• Funding menu of projects, staff and infrastructure needs.
Working with the Subject Experts
MCN 201552
All projects, large and small, go through the same process
‒ A brief project description and background
‒ How does this help us meet the mission of the museum?
‒ What are the Measurable Goals and Objectives
‒ Who will be working on this and what are their roles?
‒ Detail the estimated budget and schedule
‒ What are the potential risks affecting the projects success?
Agile Working Group
MCN 201553
Weekly standing meetings that address outstanding issues
‒ Chief of Finance
‒ Head of IT
‒ Technical Representative from Administration
‒ Chief of Media Production
‒ Chief of Imaging
‒ Chief of Digital Outreach
Executive Level Buy In
MCN 201554
Monthly Meetings with Executive Officers
‒ Chief of Finance
‒ Chief of Administration
‒ Deputy Director
‒ Dean of Center of Advanced Study for Visual Art
Monthly Agenda with Executive Officers
‒ Review of current projects (budget, scale, schedule)
‒ Review new project proposals
‒ Foresee potential projects on the horizon
MCN 201555 DH
Cool digital initiative
Senior Administration
Potential Funders
Staff +
MCN 201556 DH
Frankly …
• Gravitas
- The “weight” of your experience + your network
- E.g., MCN
Maybe not quite like this:
MCN 201557 DH
Frankly …
• Gravitas
• Passion
- Do you believe in the initiative?
- Can you sell it, sincerely?
- Can you combine energy and eloquence?
“Working hard for something we
don’t care about is called stress.
Working hard for something we
love is called passion”.
- Simon Sinek
MCN 201558 DH
Frankly …
• Gravitas
• Passion
• Partnership
- With your Development staff
- With funders, where missions overlap
Image source: http://www.mandae.com.br/blog/wp-content/uploads/2015/09/partnership.jpg
Together: Unstoppable!
Questions?
MCN 201559
Measuring Success
MCN 201560
• Visitors use technology in the galleries
• They will spend time with it
• They read aloud and discuss as they do so
• Individuals and groups
Formal Evaluation
DH
• Use of tech does not detract from focus on the art
• When visitors left, descriptions of their visit were about the art,
and not about the technology.
DH
• People who used the technology spent more time in
the exhibit than those that did not use it (even after
subtracting the time spent using the technology)
DH
TRANSPARENCY
ANALYTICS
COLLECT
ANALYZE
SHARE
COLLECTS:
• Which game(s)?
• Time spent
• Repeat(s)
• Object(s) matched
• Share(s)
Questions?
MCN 201567
Keeping Strategy
Up-to-Date
MCN 201568
EXPERIMENT
Each iteration try
something new…
BETA GALLERY…
MCN 201570
DH
Image source: http://jacquelinewest.com/blog/wp-content/uploads/writing-binders-smaller.jpg
MCN 201571
Hurdles
MCN 201572
MCN 201573
Image source: http://personalexcellence.co/quotes/files/inspirational-quote-failure-thomas-edison-2.jpg
DH
Change is Hard
MCN 201574
• Listen to other staff.
• Modify our thinking based on overall institutional goals.
• Enable use of technology.
• Letting our infrastructure go.
Digital Strategy Truths
Everyone on the team has:
• mad skillz in one or more areas.
• great creativity.
• unique ways of looking at problems.
• unique experiences.
• dedication to the museum.
• passion for their work.
Thank you
MCN 201576
Questions?
MCN 201577

Getting $*it Done: Implementing Your Digital Strategy (MCN2015)

  • 1.
    Getting $hIT Done:Implementing Your Digital Strategy SPONSORED BY THE DIGITAL STRATEGIES AND TRANSFORMATIONS SIG November 6, 2015
  • 2.
  • 3.
  • 4.
    John Gordy Chief ofDigital Outreach National Gallery of Art
  • 5.
    Bill Weinstein The JohnH. McFadden and Lisa D. Kabnick Director of Information and Interpretive Technologies Philadelphia Museum of Art
  • 6.
    Jane Alexander Chief InformationOfficer Cleveland Museum of Art
  • 7.
  • 8.
    Jean-Leon Gerome, TheCarpet Merchant, c. 1887, Minneapolis Institute of Art , 70.40 DH
  • 9.
  • 10.
  • 11.
  • 12.
  • 13.
  • 14.
    Philadelphia Museum ofArt Strategic Plan MCN 201514 WW
  • 15.
    Philadelphia Museum ofArt Brand Initiative Goals MCN 201515 WW
  • 16.
    Philadelphia Museum ofArt Roadmap to Digital Excellence MCN 201516 Infrastructure, Hardware, and Systems Legacy Platforms, Siloed Data Technology Skills Centered in IT Tightly Structured, Less Participatory Focused on Outcomes Integrated Systems, Data Driven Decisions Digital Thinking, Digital Skills Throughout the Institution Collaborative, Agile, and Adaptive WW
  • 17.
    "Art museums mighthave a lot to gain by upping their digital game, according to a new report.“ –NCAR But we already knew that, right?
  • 18.
    DIGITAL STRATEGY ? DIGITALROADMAP ? DIGITAL INTEGRATION PLAN ? What are we calling this?
  • 19.
  • 20.
    Based on themission of museum • Give direction, energy and guidelines to move your organization forward. • Succinct and unambiguous. • Helps to allocate budgets and other resources, • Explains its impact on other departments • realities of your organization in the future. • Gives direction to the people who will have to do the actual work of making digital engagement reality.
  • 21.
    Digital Strategy Objectives •activate the collection • connect art and audience through active experien • promote new scholarship • support research • facilitate internal and external collaboration • drive attendance • increase revenue • streamline work Yes, “digital strategy” = LRP strategies with tech me
  • 22.
    Basic Technology Guidelines •set up and maintained according to industry best practices • common platforms and “cores” • minimize licenses / maximize open source • data must be accessible – minimize manual steps & re-keying – save money and effort • digital assets must reusable and findable • no “one off” projects
  • 23.
    Digital Strategy Implementation •focus on core data • build sustainable, modular systems – open-source & industry-standard software – best practices • architect with reuse/multi-use in mind • no one-off projects EVERYTHING in terms of the BIG PICTURE
  • 24.
    “One does not‘manage’ people. The task is to lead people. And the goal is to make productive the specific strengths and knowledge of every individual.” - Peter Drucker Image source: http://54ventures.com/demo-images/fuse-slide-4-11-1800x800.jpg DH
  • 25.
    Character shall you hire. Skilltrain you may. Image source: http://img1.wikia.nocookie.net/__cb20131106213953/starwars/images/d/d6/Yoda_SWSB.png DH
  • 26.
  • 27.
    Cool Blue Do aselect few Seek funding & partners (We wish we could do them all) Risk: Too many at once (saying yes to everything) Red Flag Do only if necessary Stop! (or proceed with extreme caution) (We wish we could have none) Risk: Bogs down & exhausts resources Green Light Do these fast Make a prioritized list, get moving (We wish there were fewer) Risk: Resources pulled away from Cool Blue Gray Fog Do only if there are resources “Busy work” or dreamy distractions (We wish we had more time) Risk: People fall into this , esp. in times of stress High High (Hard) Low Low (Easy) Importance, based on STRATEGY Difficulty, based in Reality (gasp!) Making Decisions DH
  • 28.
  • 29.
  • 30.
  • 31.
    Source of quote:http://www.forbes.com/sites/glennllopis/2012/11/05/5-most-effective-ways-to-sell-change/ Without strategy, change is merely substitution, not evolution - Glenn Llopis Image source of quote: http://redequip.com.au/uploads/Redequip-Graph-1.jpg DH
  • 32.
    Adapted from: http://www.forbes.com/sites/johnkotter/2011/07/12/change-management-vs-change-leadership-whats-the-difference/ ChangeManagement v. Change Leadership Image source: http://www.agilepm.com/downloads/dirtyharry.jpg Image source: http://www.intesolv.com/wp-content/uploads/2013/02/Careers-Mission-514x360.jpg DH
  • 33.
    Adapted from: http://www.forbes.com/sites/johnkotter/2011/07/12/change-management-vs-change-leadership-whats-the-difference/ ChangeManagement v. Change Leadership Tools and Procedures Detailed plans Minimize distractions Limit impact Small dedicated team Incremental steps Keep it under control DH
  • 34.
    Adapted from: http://www.forbes.com/sites/johnkotter/2011/07/12/change-management-vs-change-leadership-whats-the-difference/ ChangeManagement v. Change Leadership Tools and Procedures Vision and Drive Detailed plans Establish and share WHY Minimize distractions Sense of urgency and importance Limit impact Expect wide impact Small dedicated team Involve everyone Incremental steps Enable big leaps Keep it under control … by the way, almost no one is good at this DH
  • 35.
    Communication is Key MCN201535 • Get in early. • Meetings, meetings and more meetings. • Manage up. • Stop making things people don’t want.
  • 36.
    Gallery One andArtLens were the first beneficiaries of the museum’s digital strategy CMA wanted the technology implementation to be innovative, intelligent and in-line with tech industry best practices
  • 38.
    Proof of Concept •Gallery One & ArtLens = prototype – backend build-out – data flow model – automation – interdepartmental team model – vendor management model – orient toward long-term planning • Central Table – interoperability / integration – application modularity
  • 40.
    A FEW OFTHE MANY… • digital asset management • archival repository • open-source website • mobile site • dashboard • central table • integrated CCMS
  • 41.
    All hardware canall be remotely rebooted via LogMeIn
  • 42.
  • 43.
  • 44.
    Digital Initiatives SteeringCommittee • CIO • Deputy Director/Chief Curator • Deputy Director/Advancement • Director of Collections Management • Director of Communications and Marketing • Director of Education and Interpretation • Director of Exhibitions and Publications • Director of Library and Archives • Director of Research and Evaluation
  • 45.
    Digital Initiatives ReviewProcess • All projects have a Sponsor (department-director level or higher) • IMTS previews and guides • Digital Initiatives Steering Committee – big picture planning – approval process – review process • Measurements of success are built in
  • 46.
  • 47.
  • 48.
    Technology Funding • Planfor the unexpected / rapid change • 3-year rolling technology budget • Project funding preferences –outside funding / grants –FYxxxx budget assignment –Digital Initiatives set-aside fund
  • 49.
    Interactive Project Process MCN201549 • Curator, Interpretation, Education and IIT generate interpretive plan that identifies interactive technology needs. • IIT and Interpretation begin preliminary design phase. • IIT develops prototypes working with Interpretation and Visitor Services to test with museum visitors. • Curator, education review prototypes and work to refine content. • Curator, Interpretation, Education and IIT final review and approval.
  • 50.
    Project Review Process MCN201550 • Quarterly review of all interactive projects; Director, Curator of Education, Director of IIT, Associate Director of Interactive Technologies, Assistant Director of Interpretation, Deputy Director for Collections and Programs. • Weekly standing meeting; Curator of Education, Director of IIT, Assistant Director of Interpretation, Associate Director of Interactive Technologies.
  • 51.
    Funding Projects MCN 201551 •Special exhibition projects funded as part of overall exhibit budget. • Development liaison. • Funding menu of projects, staff and infrastructure needs.
  • 52.
    Working with theSubject Experts MCN 201552 All projects, large and small, go through the same process ‒ A brief project description and background ‒ How does this help us meet the mission of the museum? ‒ What are the Measurable Goals and Objectives ‒ Who will be working on this and what are their roles? ‒ Detail the estimated budget and schedule ‒ What are the potential risks affecting the projects success?
  • 53.
    Agile Working Group MCN201553 Weekly standing meetings that address outstanding issues ‒ Chief of Finance ‒ Head of IT ‒ Technical Representative from Administration ‒ Chief of Media Production ‒ Chief of Imaging ‒ Chief of Digital Outreach
  • 54.
    Executive Level BuyIn MCN 201554 Monthly Meetings with Executive Officers ‒ Chief of Finance ‒ Chief of Administration ‒ Deputy Director ‒ Dean of Center of Advanced Study for Visual Art Monthly Agenda with Executive Officers ‒ Review of current projects (budget, scale, schedule) ‒ Review new project proposals ‒ Foresee potential projects on the horizon
  • 55.
    MCN 201555 DH Cooldigital initiative Senior Administration Potential Funders Staff +
  • 56.
    MCN 201556 DH Frankly… • Gravitas - The “weight” of your experience + your network - E.g., MCN Maybe not quite like this:
  • 57.
    MCN 201557 DH Frankly… • Gravitas • Passion - Do you believe in the initiative? - Can you sell it, sincerely? - Can you combine energy and eloquence? “Working hard for something we don’t care about is called stress. Working hard for something we love is called passion”. - Simon Sinek
  • 58.
    MCN 201558 DH Frankly… • Gravitas • Passion • Partnership - With your Development staff - With funders, where missions overlap Image source: http://www.mandae.com.br/blog/wp-content/uploads/2015/09/partnership.jpg Together: Unstoppable!
  • 59.
  • 60.
  • 61.
    • Visitors usetechnology in the galleries • They will spend time with it • They read aloud and discuss as they do so • Individuals and groups Formal Evaluation DH
  • 62.
    • Use oftech does not detract from focus on the art • When visitors left, descriptions of their visit were about the art, and not about the technology. DH
  • 63.
    • People whoused the technology spent more time in the exhibit than those that did not use it (even after subtracting the time spent using the technology) DH
  • 64.
  • 65.
  • 66.
    COLLECTS: • Which game(s)? •Time spent • Repeat(s) • Object(s) matched • Share(s)
  • 67.
  • 68.
  • 69.
  • 70.
    MCN 201570 DH Image source:http://jacquelinewest.com/blog/wp-content/uploads/writing-binders-smaller.jpg
  • 71.
  • 72.
  • 73.
    MCN 201573 Image source:http://personalexcellence.co/quotes/files/inspirational-quote-failure-thomas-edison-2.jpg DH
  • 74.
    Change is Hard MCN201574 • Listen to other staff. • Modify our thinking based on overall institutional goals. • Enable use of technology. • Letting our infrastructure go.
  • 75.
    Digital Strategy Truths Everyoneon the team has: • mad skillz in one or more areas. • great creativity. • unique ways of looking at problems. • unique experiences. • dedication to the museum. • passion for their work.
  • 76.
  • 77.