By Boru Douthwaite. As part of a CPWF September 2011 workshop in Thailand regarding global drivers. We have divided driver types into five categories:
1. Demographic/Social,
2. Economic,
3. Political/Institutional/Legal,
4. Environmental/Climate change,
5. Technological/ Innovations
6. Before… and after the project.
(Photograph by Olivier Joffre)
CRESMIL impact in Vietnam, showing what is
possible
Mr. Nguyen Hoang Ben
Ap Lung Chim, Xa Dinh Thanh, Dong Hai.
10. Technological change as a global
driver?
Technological change happens everywhere
Lever of riches
Mokyr –defining feature of successful civilizations (China,
Europe)
Technological changes that count as global drivers
Information revolution
Brainstorming ......
10
11. What drives technology change in
agriculture?
1 kWhr costs 10 cents
1 person can work continuously at 30 W
33 hrs to earn 10 cents?
Substituting fossil for human power drives TC in ag
US agriculture uses 45 times more energy than traditional
agriculture
Doubling or trebling of energy costs won’t reverse the
trend
11
12. Trends versus drivers
Dramatic weather events
Food crisis threaten global security
Impending water wars
Fossil fuels running out
Rising political power of ‘developing nations’
Saving forests makes money
Faith traditions support stewardship
Younger generations demand action
12
13. Technological responses in basins
with global relevance
Brainstorm
Global drivers
Demographic, social, economic
Climate change and environmental
Political and institutional
Basins
13
14. What basin teams should know
How technological change happens
How research can be used as a lever of technological
change
What basin responses / trends (i.e., aggregate
behavioural change) have global relevance
14
15. How technological change happens
An emergent property
Of multitude interaction between people going
through individual and social learning cycles
An evolutionary process
15
16. Research as lever of technological
change
Manage research process to make beneficial
emergence more likely
The levers
Novelty
Selection
Interaction
Motivation
Reducing uncertainty
Work with partners in spotting early emergence,
stabilize and amplify
16
17. Reducing uncertainty
Technically, impossible to predict emergence in
complex systems (the equations don’t exist; ones we have sensitive
to small errors in parameterization)
“Uncertainty keeps increasing with the more research
money they put in” Pioneer climate scientist Manabe
But ...
Simple predictions possible
Model to better understand the present, system fragilities
(tundra), possible future scenarios
Learn from innovation histories, innovation research
Uncertainty leads to polarization
17
A woman listens with other demonstrators, who demanded the resignation of Prime Minister Mohamed Ghannouchi, to a speech during a march in Tunis, Tunisia, on Jan. 19, 2011.Cell phones and social media enabled the Arab Spring by allowing people to organize and get their message out. Video clips shown on World Media, Blogs, etc. Arab Spring some say in response to demographics – young populations without a voice.
Adoption of combine harvesting drives people out of work, requires changes in field size. Itself a response to labour-shortage as people go to the cities, sucked in in part
A complex adaptive system consists of one or more populations of agents, along with the artifacts (e.g., things, technologies, databases, etc) and strategies (including norms) that they use. An agent is an entity, such as an individual or organization, which has agency, i.e. can make thing happen. In a CAS, the agents use strategies in their interactions with other agents and with artifacts. The agents evaluate the subsequent results of these interactions and as a result select to copy strategies or artifacts, or recombine or invent new ones. Copying itself is error prone. This evolutionary process of selecting what works, copying, recombining and inventing constantly introduces novelty. Over time, the evolutionary process changes the frequency and variation of types of agents, strategies and artifacts as the populations of “fitter” agents, strategies and artifacts increases in relation to others