3. tom.mowlam@ubiquitypress.com | www.ubiquitypress.com | @ubiquitypress
The status quo is good for
legacy publishers
• Higher than average profit margins
• Large publishers are getting even larger
• 6% of publishers control 90% of articles
4. tom.mowlam@ubiquitypress.com | www.ubiquitypress.com | @ubiquitypress
OA is growing, but on the legacy
publishers’ terms
• Avg legacy publisher APC: $2,100 / €1,900
• Too high for most of HSS
• Price is based on what the market will
stand, not added value
• Legacy publishers say they are pro-OA,
but systematically lobby against it
5. tom.mowlam@ubiquitypress.com | www.ubiquitypress.com | @ubiquitypress
Research Works Act (H.R. 3699)
• Massive international outcry,
especially from researchers
• Contained provisions to prohibit
open-access mandates for
federally funded research
• Congress members who
introduced the act ‘motivated by
large donations by the academic
publisher X’
7. tom.mowlam@ubiquitypress.com | www.ubiquitypress.com | @ubiquitypress
Amid boycott, X backtracks on research bill
Journal publisher still opposes current U.S. rules mandating access to taxpayer-
funded research
CBC News
Posted: Feb 27, 2012
One of the largest academic publishers in the world withdrew its support Monday
from a controversial U.S. bill, the Research Works Act, that critics feel would restrict
public access to published, publicly-funded research.
The change of heart by Dutch publisher X follows a boycott of its journals and
publishing ventures by thousands of researchers around the world.
16. tom.mowlam@ubiquitypress.com | www.ubiquitypress.com | @ubiquitypress
This future is not what legacy
publishers want it to be
• it’s more than books and journals
• It’s open science
• It’s all forms of communication
• It’s unrestricted and collaborative
17. tom.mowlam@ubiquitypress.com | www.ubiquitypress.com | @ubiquitypress
This future is not what legacy
publishers want it to be
• It’s truly global, not a north-south
hierarchy
• It’s philanthropic, because that’s
what science and open access are
• It’s cost-effective and efficient
19. tom.mowlam@ubiquitypress.com | www.ubiquitypress.com | @ubiquitypress
Wider research community initiatives
• Content propagation: Scihub
• Publisher evaluation: DOAJ, OASPA, Quality
Open Access Market
• Collaborative authoring: Authorea, Overleaf
• Open source publishing platfoms: PKP, Collaborative
Knowledge Foundation (CKF)
• Funder mandates: Wellcome Trust, NIH, FP7,
Horizon2020, UK Research Councils
20. tom.mowlam@ubiquitypress.com | www.ubiquitypress.com | @ubiquitypress
Initiatives UP is involved in
• Rua: open source book management platform
• The Ubiquity Partner Network
• Open Library of the Humanities
• FutureTDM: promoting text and data mining in the EU
• LingOA
• INASP JOLs
• University Presses
28. tom.mowlam@ubiquitypress.com | www.ubiquitypress.com | @ubiquitypress
In summary
• OA publishing is currently on the legacy
publishers’ terms, but these terms are not
acceptable
• There are a lot of OA and open science
initiatives in the research community
• The UPN is an example of pulling a large
number of these initiatives together to
increase the chances of large scale disruption
• This is working and points the way to a viable
alternative, cooperative and fair future