Burcu Durmuşoğlu
Büşranur Akgül
Özgün Kuran
Bige Özcan
Brief Description
• Company Background
• Industry Analysis
• Competitive Advantages On Principal Functions And Activities
• Performance On Retailing Sector And Format Overseas Countries
• VRIO Analysis
• Recommendations
Sam Walton opened his first WalMart in 1962.
According to Sam Walton
“Our strategy was to put good-sized stores
into little one-horse towns
that everyone else
was ignoring. ”.
• In 1970, WalMart opened 30 discount stores in Arkansas, Oklahoma,
and Missouri.
• In 1974, WalMart was the first retailer to use computers for inventory
control.
• In 1977, WalMart initiated EDI (Electronic Data Interchange) with its
vendors.
• A few years later, WalMart introduced bar code scanning.
• In 1980, there were 330 stores in 11 states.
In mid-1980s Sam’s Clubs which is main
distribution center was opened.
What lies behind of opening Sam’s Club?
• To maximize economies in purchasing, minimize operating costs, and
pass the savings on to members through very low prices.
• To take advantage of having own distribution channel.
• To demonstrate its ability to transfer its retailing capabilities to a very
different distribution format.
Retailer
Discount
Store
US Retail
Format
Sam’s
Club
Super-
center
• In 1984, WalMart started using their own satellite.
• In 1990s, WalMart was pioneering the use of data-mining.
• Since 1992, WalMart started to internationalize.
• In 1995, WalMart was in all 50 states in the US.
In 2007, WalMart became the world’s biggest retailer.
QUESTION 1
To what extent is Wal-Mart’s performance attributable to industry
attractiveness and to what extent to competitive advantage?
Rivalry among Existing
Firms
Fierce Competition
Potential Entrants
Threat: Low
- High barriers of entry.
- Existing companies established
strong and stable supplier networks.
Substitutes
Threat: Low
- Low number of company that
can sell their products at lower
prices.
Buyers
Power: Modarate
- Buyers are price-sensitive.
- Rural domination of WalMart..
Suppliers
Power: Low
- Own distribution channel.
- Strong negotiation with
suppliers.
According to this analysis
• WalMart has competitive advantages in
• Suppliers
• New Threats
• Substitutes Products
QUESTION 2
In which of WalMart’s principal functions and activities (namely:
purchasing, distribution and warehousing, instore operations,
marketing, IT, HRM, and organization and management systems/style)
do WalMart’s main competitive advantages lie?
Identify the distinctive resources and capabilities in each of these
functions/activities?
• Commitment to “everyday low prices”
• Matchless responsiveness to customer needs
• Logistics supported by leading-edge IT
• Commitment to employees
• Unremitting cost cutting
Purchasing and
Vendor
Relationships
- Electronic Data
Interchange
- Real time store-
by-store
information
- Economies of
scale
Warehousing and
Distribution
- Cross-docking
- Direct import
- Hub and spoke
configuration
In-store Operations
- “Store of the
Community”
philosophy.
- Point-of sale data
- “Satisfaction
Guaranteed”
program.
Marketing
- “Everyday Low
Prices”
- Word-of-mouth
- Patriotism and
national causes
Information
Technology
- Bar code scanning
- Data-mining
- Radio-frequency
identification
Human Resource
Management
- Organization
culture:
- Respect
- High expectations
- Close
communication
Organization and
Management Style
- Flat organizational
structure
- Fast-response
management
system
- Internal
recruitment
QUESTION 3
To what extent has WM been able to transfer the competitive
advantage it established in discount retailing in the US to other
countries, to other retail sectors and formats? Why has WM’s overseas
performance to date been so patchy?
WalMart’s first format was discount store.
They changed their discount stores to supercenters
which are equal to
Discount stores + Grocery süpermarket.
• They transferred their competitive advantages into
• Distribution/Logistics sector
• Manufacturing sector
• Retailing sector
• Service sector
Success
Mexico
Joint Venture
Canada
Acquisition
Argentina
Green field
Brazil
Joint Venture
UK
Acquisition
Failure
Japan Germany
South
Korea
Indonesia China
Reasons for failure
• Stick so closely to the domestic culture
• Wrong market selection which is already dominated
• Less concentration on geographical differences
• Unable to respond customer needs and wants
QUESTION 4
To what extent is WM’s competitive advantage sustainable? Why have
other retailers had limited success in imitating WM’s strategy and
duplicating its competitive advantage?
Sustainable Competitive Advantages
Competency Valuable Rare Inimitable Organised Competitive
Impact
Information Systems Yes Yes Yes Yes Sustainable
Logistics System Yes Yes Yes Yes Sustainable
Culture Yes Yes Yes Yes Sustainable
Management Routines
and Practices
Yes Yes Yes Yes Sustainable
Why cannot be imitated?
Culture
Supply
Chain
Information
Technology
QUESTION 5
• Looking ahead, what measures does WM need to take to sustain its
recent performance and defend against competitive (and other)
threats?
• More advertisement and marketing activities
• More social responsibility activities
• More concentration on labor rights
• More focus on environmental issues
• More flexibility on culture
• Give importance on market research rather than start-ups
THANK YOU FOR YOUR
ATTENTION!
ANY QUESTION?

Walmart

  • 1.
  • 2.
    Brief Description • CompanyBackground • Industry Analysis • Competitive Advantages On Principal Functions And Activities • Performance On Retailing Sector And Format Overseas Countries • VRIO Analysis • Recommendations
  • 3.
    Sam Walton openedhis first WalMart in 1962. According to Sam Walton “Our strategy was to put good-sized stores into little one-horse towns that everyone else was ignoring. ”.
  • 4.
    • In 1970,WalMart opened 30 discount stores in Arkansas, Oklahoma, and Missouri. • In 1974, WalMart was the first retailer to use computers for inventory control. • In 1977, WalMart initiated EDI (Electronic Data Interchange) with its vendors. • A few years later, WalMart introduced bar code scanning. • In 1980, there were 330 stores in 11 states.
  • 5.
    In mid-1980s Sam’sClubs which is main distribution center was opened. What lies behind of opening Sam’s Club? • To maximize economies in purchasing, minimize operating costs, and pass the savings on to members through very low prices. • To take advantage of having own distribution channel. • To demonstrate its ability to transfer its retailing capabilities to a very different distribution format.
  • 6.
  • 7.
    • In 1984,WalMart started using their own satellite. • In 1990s, WalMart was pioneering the use of data-mining. • Since 1992, WalMart started to internationalize. • In 1995, WalMart was in all 50 states in the US.
  • 8.
    In 2007, WalMartbecame the world’s biggest retailer.
  • 9.
    QUESTION 1 To whatextent is Wal-Mart’s performance attributable to industry attractiveness and to what extent to competitive advantage?
  • 10.
    Rivalry among Existing Firms FierceCompetition Potential Entrants Threat: Low - High barriers of entry. - Existing companies established strong and stable supplier networks. Substitutes Threat: Low - Low number of company that can sell their products at lower prices. Buyers Power: Modarate - Buyers are price-sensitive. - Rural domination of WalMart.. Suppliers Power: Low - Own distribution channel. - Strong negotiation with suppliers.
  • 11.
    According to thisanalysis • WalMart has competitive advantages in • Suppliers • New Threats • Substitutes Products
  • 12.
    QUESTION 2 In whichof WalMart’s principal functions and activities (namely: purchasing, distribution and warehousing, instore operations, marketing, IT, HRM, and organization and management systems/style) do WalMart’s main competitive advantages lie? Identify the distinctive resources and capabilities in each of these functions/activities?
  • 13.
    • Commitment to“everyday low prices” • Matchless responsiveness to customer needs • Logistics supported by leading-edge IT • Commitment to employees • Unremitting cost cutting
  • 14.
    Purchasing and Vendor Relationships - ElectronicData Interchange - Real time store- by-store information - Economies of scale Warehousing and Distribution - Cross-docking - Direct import - Hub and spoke configuration In-store Operations - “Store of the Community” philosophy. - Point-of sale data - “Satisfaction Guaranteed” program. Marketing - “Everyday Low Prices” - Word-of-mouth - Patriotism and national causes Information Technology - Bar code scanning - Data-mining - Radio-frequency identification Human Resource Management - Organization culture: - Respect - High expectations - Close communication Organization and Management Style - Flat organizational structure - Fast-response management system - Internal recruitment
  • 15.
    QUESTION 3 To whatextent has WM been able to transfer the competitive advantage it established in discount retailing in the US to other countries, to other retail sectors and formats? Why has WM’s overseas performance to date been so patchy?
  • 16.
    WalMart’s first formatwas discount store. They changed their discount stores to supercenters which are equal to Discount stores + Grocery süpermarket.
  • 17.
    • They transferredtheir competitive advantages into • Distribution/Logistics sector • Manufacturing sector • Retailing sector • Service sector
  • 18.
  • 19.
  • 20.
    Reasons for failure •Stick so closely to the domestic culture • Wrong market selection which is already dominated • Less concentration on geographical differences • Unable to respond customer needs and wants
  • 21.
    QUESTION 4 To whatextent is WM’s competitive advantage sustainable? Why have other retailers had limited success in imitating WM’s strategy and duplicating its competitive advantage?
  • 22.
    Sustainable Competitive Advantages CompetencyValuable Rare Inimitable Organised Competitive Impact Information Systems Yes Yes Yes Yes Sustainable Logistics System Yes Yes Yes Yes Sustainable Culture Yes Yes Yes Yes Sustainable Management Routines and Practices Yes Yes Yes Yes Sustainable
  • 23.
    Why cannot beimitated? Culture Supply Chain Information Technology
  • 24.
    QUESTION 5 • Lookingahead, what measures does WM need to take to sustain its recent performance and defend against competitive (and other) threats?
  • 25.
    • More advertisementand marketing activities • More social responsibility activities • More concentration on labor rights • More focus on environmental issues • More flexibility on culture • Give importance on market research rather than start-ups
  • 26.
    THANK YOU FORYOUR ATTENTION! ANY QUESTION?