3. What do these two people
have in common?
Richard Branson
Sir David King, UK Government Virgin Group
former chief scientist
4. 10 February 2010 UK
Industry Task Force
Report...
âThe oil crunch will
happen in the next ďŹve
years...â
See: http://peakoiltaskforce.net/
5. 23 March 2010 Oxford
University report states
â...current oil reserves
should be downgraded
from 1150-1350 bbpd to
850-900 bbpd...â
The Status of Conventional Oil Reserves - Hype or Cause for Concern, Energy Policy Journal
See: http://www.off-grid.net/2010/03/22/peak-oil-back-in-the-news/
6. 4 February 2010
paper by
researchers at
Kuwait University
develop new model
âestimated world oil
production to peak
in 2014â
Published in: Ibrahim Sami Nashawi; Adel Malallah; Mohammed Al-Bisharah; Energy Fuels Article ASAP
9. Assertions
Climate change makes the carbon reduction
transition essential.
Peak oil makes it inevitable. Shifting away from
fossil fuels creates a huge energy short-fall.
Low carbon society, 2000 Watt Society, and
Transition initiatives make it feasible, viable and
attractive.
We have to change, but how fast can we change?
11. Techno- new energy sources allow continual
explosion (Star growth in material wealth
Trek!)
steady state economy based on use
Techno-stability of renewable energy
reduction of economic activity,
Energy Descent complexity and population as fossil
fuels are depleted
Collapse (Mad failure of systems that maintain and
Max) support industrial society
12. Can we portray âenergy descentâ in a
positive light?
13. Holgremâs Four Energy Descent Scenarios
Brown Tech Destructive Lifeboats
Top down constriction Civilisation triage
Global Warming
Slow oil decline 2% pa Fast oil decline 10% pa
Green Tech Earth Steward
Distributed powerdown Benign Bottom-up rebuild
http://www.futurescenarios.org
14. Settlement
Energy and Culture and
Scenario Form and Economy Politics Gender
Agriculture Spirituality
Mobility
Centralized Nationalist,
power, high tech High density
fascist, class
Brown Tech efficiency, non- cities,
structure and Super rationalist,
conventional oil, electric cars, National banks Male dominated
Top-down hinterland and currencies
rights, price
and blended
fundamentalist
gas, coal, rationing, dictonomy
constriction adandonment,
nuclear, bio population
shelter mass migration
control
agriculture
Distributed
Compact towns City state and
Green Tech network,
and cities, Regional hinterland,
conservation, Balanced and Humanist, eco-
Distributed gas, wind, solar,
electric public currencies and markets,
blended rationalist
powerdown transport, funds rationing,
forest, organic
telecommuting democracy
agriculture
Distributed local
hydro, methane Town and
Earth Steward Ruralization of
industrial bioregion Female
sub-urbia, rural Local currency,
Bottom-up salvage, forest,
resettlement, barter
Participatory dominated and Earth spirituality
re-build organic and democracy? gendered
minimal mobility
garden Neo-fuedalism
agriculture
Distributed local,
Lifeboats forest, range Hamlet and gated Household and Feudal systems
Male dominated
Civilization land, industrial communities, barter, precious Patriarchal
and gendered
Warrior Cult
triage salvage, nomads metals authority
Oasis agric.
15. Settlement
Energy and Culture and
Scenario Form and Economy Politics Gender
Agriculture Spirituality
Mobility
Centralized Nationalist,
power, high tech High density
fascist, class
Brown Tech efficiency, non- cities,
structure and Super rationalist,
conventional oil, electric cars, National banks Male dominated
Top-down hinterland and currencies
rights, price
and blended
fundamentalist
gas, coal, rationing, dictonomy
constriction adandonment,
nuclear, bio population
shelter mass migration
control
agriculture
Distributed
Compact towns City state and
Green Tech network,
and cities, Regional hinterland,
conservation, Balanced and Humanist, eco-
Distributed gas, wind, solar,
electric public currencies and markets,
blended rationalist
powerdown transport, funds rationing,
forest, organic
telecommuting democracy
agriculture
Distributed local
hydro, methane Town and
Earth Steward Ruralization of
industrial bioregion Female
sub-urbia, rural Local currency,
Bottom-up salvage, forest,
resettlement, barter
Participatory dominated and Earth spirituality
re-build organic and democracy? gendered
minimal mobility
garden Neo-fuedalism
agriculture
Distributed local,
Lifeboats forest, range Hamlet and gated Household and Feudal systems
Male dominated
Civilization land, industrial communities, barter, precious Patriarchal
and gendered
Warrior Cult
triage salvage, nomads metals authority
Oasis agric.
16. Settlement
Energy and Culture and
Scenario Form and Economy Politics Gender
Agriculture Spirituality
Mobility
Centralized Nationalist,
power, high tech High density
fascist, class
Brown Tech efficiency, non- cities,
structure and Super rationalist,
conventional oil, electric cars, National banks Male dominated
Top-down hinterland and currencies
rights, price
and blended
fundamentalist
gas, coal, rationing, dictonomy
constriction adandonment,
nuclear, bio population
shelter mass migration
control
agriculture
Distributed
Compact towns City state and
Green Tech network,
and cities, Regional hinterland,
conservation, Balanced and Humanist, eco-
Distributed gas, wind, solar,
electric public currencies and markets,
blended rationalist
powerdown transport, funds rationing,
forest, organic
telecommuting democracy
agriculture
Distributed local
hydro, methane Town and
Earth Steward Ruralization of
industrial bioregion Female
sub-urbia, rural Local currency,
Bottom-up salvage, forest,
resettlement, barter
Participatory dominated and Earth spirituality
re-build organic and democracy? gendered
minimal mobility
garden Neo-fuedalism
agriculture
Distributed local,
Lifeboats forest, range Hamlet and gated Household and Feudal systems
Male dominated
Civilization land, industrial communities, barter, precious Patriarchal
and gendered
Warrior Cult
triage salvage, nomads metals authority
Oasis agric.
17. Settlement
Energy and Culture and
Scenario Form and Economy Politics Gender
Agriculture Spirituality
Mobility
Centralized Nationalist,
power, high tech High density
fascist, class
Brown Tech efficiency, non- cities,
structure and Super rationalist,
conventional oil, electric cars, National banks Male dominated
Top-down hinterland and currencies
rights, price
and blended
fundamentalist
gas, coal, rationing, dictonomy
constriction adandonment,
nuclear, bio population
shelter mass migration
control
agriculture
Distributed
Compact towns City state and
Green Tech network,
and cities, Regional hinterland,
conservation, Balanced and Humanist, eco-
Distributed gas, wind, solar,
electric public currencies and markets,
blended rationalist
powerdown transport, funds rationing,
forest, organic
telecommuting democracy
agriculture
Distributed local
hydro, methane Town and
Earth Steward Ruralization of
industrial bioregion Female
sub-urbia, rural Local currency,
Bottom-up salvage, forest,
resettlement, barter
Participatory dominated and Earth spirituality
re-build organic and democracy? gendered
minimal mobility
garden Neo-fuedalism
agriculture
Distributed local,
Lifeboats forest, range Hamlet and gated Household and Feudal systems
Male dominated
Civilization land, industrial communities, barter, precious Patriarchal
and gendered
Warrior Cult
triage salvage, nomads metals authority
Oasis agric.
18. Settlement
Energy and Culture and
Scenario Form and Economy Politics Gender
Agriculture Spirituality
Mobility
Centralized Nationalist,
power, high tech High density
fascist, class
Brown Tech efficiency, non- cities,
structure and Super rationalist,
conventional oil, electric cars, National banks Male dominated
Top-down hinterland and currencies
rights, price
and blended
fundamentalist
gas, coal, rationing, dictonomy
constriction adandonment,
nuclear, bio population
shelter mass migration
control
agriculture
Distributed
Compact towns City state and
Green Tech network,
and cities, Regional hinterland,
conservation, Balanced and Humanist, eco-
Distributed gas, wind, solar,
electric public currencies and markets,
blended rationalist
powerdown transport, funds rationing,
forest, organic
telecommuting democracy
agriculture
Distributed local
hydro, methane Town and
Earth Steward Ruralization of
industrial bioregion Female
sub-urbia, rural Local currency,
Bottom-up salvage, forest,
resettlement, barter
Participatory dominated and Earth spirituality
re-build organic and democracy? gendered
minimal mobility
garden Neo-fuedalism
agriculture
Distributed local,
Lifeboats forest, range Hamlet and gated Household and Feudal systems
Male dominated
Civilization land, industrial communities, barter, precious Patriarchal
and gendered
Warrior Cult
triage salvage, nomads metals authority
Oasis agric.
19. Transition to a post-peak oil world
Rob Hopkins,
permaculturist, set up the
Transition Movement.
Visit his blog at:
http://
transitionculture.org/
20. Transition Movement
Asks the question....
how can communities
respond to the
challenges, and
opportunities, of Peak
Oil and Climate
Change?
21. Transition Movement
We were creative, ingenious and adaptable on the
way up to the peak, and there's no reason that we
will not be the same on the down slope.
22. Transition Movement
âIf we collectively plan and act early enough ... we
can create a way of living that's signiďŹcantly more
connected, more vibrant and more in touch with
our environment than the oil-addicted treadmill
that we ďŹnd ourselves on today.â
23. Key Steps in the Transition
⢠awareness raising around peak oil, climate
change and the need to undertake a
community led process to rebuild resilience
and reduce carbon
⢠connect with existing groups in the
community and build bridges to local
government
⢠form groups to research all the key areas of
life (food, energy, transport, health, etc)
⢠kick off projects aimed at building people's
understanding of resilience and carbon
issues
⢠launch a community implemented "Energy
Descent Action Plan" over a 15 to 20 year
time scale
24. Economic
localisation is key to
the transition
process......
local currency
systems strengthen
the local economy
whilst preventing
money from leaking
out.
25. Resources
Transition Handbook by Rob
Hopkins.
Transition Primer.
Transition Timeline for a local,
resilient future.
Transition Town website (http://
transitiontowns.org)
26. Transition Towns
First Transition Town: Totnes,
Devon, began in 2005.
170 official TTs in UK,
Australia, USA, Ireland,
Canada, Chile, Germany, Italy,
Japan, Netherlands and New
Zealand.
600 more mulling the idea
over.
27. Cheerful Transition Disclaimer
âWe truly don't know if this will work. Transition is a social
experiment on a massive scale.
What we are convinced of is this: if we wait for the
governments, it'll be too little, too late
and if we act as individuals, it'll be too little.â
29. Japan as a Low Carbon Society
In 2004, researchers at the National Institute for
Environmental Studies began collaborating with
academics from across Japan and the UK on the idea of a
Low Carbon Economy/Society.
Their report was published in June 2008 and can be
downloaded at http://2050.nies.go.jp/:
30. Key conclusion
Japan has the technological potential to reduce its CO2
emission by 70% compared to 1990 level, while
satisfying the expected demand for energy services in
2050.
32. Vision A âDoraemonâ
Vivid, Technology-driven
Urban/Personal
Technological breakthroughs
Centralized production /recycling
Comfortable and Convenient
2% annual GDP growth
http://2050.nies.go.jp
33. Vision B âTotoroâ
Slow, Natural-oriented
Decentralized/Community
Self-sufficient
Produce locally, consume locally
Social and Cultural Values
1% annual GDP growth
http://2050.nies.go.jp
34. Innovations on the demand side
0 100 200 300 400
(Mtoe)
Passenger Freight
2000 Industry Household
transport transport
Business
2050
Scenario A
Reduced energy demand
2050
Scenario B 40-45 reduction
Industry Household Passenger Freight
Business transport transport
Smart consumer choices can reduce energy consumption by as much
as
40-45%!
35. And on the supply side
- 100 200 300 400 500 600
(Mtoe)
2000 Coal Oil Gas
Hydro
2050
Scenario A Nuclear Use of centralized energy
2050
Scenario B Biomass Solar/
Wind Use of distributed energy
Coal Oil Gas Biomass Nuclear Hydro Solar/Wind
Low carbon shift in primary energy sources via introduction of renewable
energies
36. Main Conclusion of the Research
70 CO2 reduction
feasible by 1% of annual
GDP
37. Carbon Footprints
We are all familiar with the idea of a
carbon footprint measured in kg of CO2
equivalents
Raises the issue of equity - how many kg
of CO2 per person?
Idea not discussed fully at COP15 was
Convergence.
See Age of Stupid Video.
44. Rationale
Change the conversation on personal
accountability in climate change away from the
common "carbon footprint" and towards collective
energy reduction.
45. Rationale
Measuring in power recognizes that it will not be
possible to support our current lifestyles with any
energy technology that we could implement in the
near future - our needs are not sustainable.
Energy reduction will need to be part of any
solution to the global climate challenge.
47. Saul Griffithâs New Life
(to ensure only 2 degree C increase in temp, 450ppm,
sharing fairly with 6.5 billion people)
Saul GrifďŹth 2008 The Game Plan Slide Set Release 1.0
48. 2000 Watt Society
The concept was developed in 1998 by
the Federal Institute of Technology in
Zurich (ETHZ).
Sets a target of 2000 Watts per person.
Do this without compromising living
standards and mobility.
Learn more at: http://www.novatlantis.ch/
index.php?id=5&L=1
50. Why 2000 Watts?
Saul GrifďŹth 2008 The Game Plan Slide Set Release 1.0
51. Why 2000 Watts?
15 TW
Saul GrifďŹth 2008 The Game Plan Slide Set Release 1.0
52. Why 2000 Watts?
15 000 000 000 000 Watts
= 2 255 Watts per person
6 650 000 000 People
53. Energy consumption per capita (today)
USA 10,381 W
Canada 11,055 W
Russia 5,890 W
Japan 5,381W
Italy 4,164 W
Malaysia 3,087 W
Mexico 2,041 W
China 1,516 W
Egypt 1,013 W
Ghana 533 W
All move to this line
Bangladesh 214 W
0 2500 5000 7500 10000 12500
54. What can we conclude?
Initiatives like Transition Towns, Local Carbon
Society and 2000 Watt Society are still new.
Our experience in these new ďŹelds is shallow.
Carbon footprints help identify our contribution to
climate change.
Watts helps to include consideration of how to
reduce energy (i.e. especially relevant for Peak Oil).
55. The 2005 Hirsch ReportMitigation
Peaking of World Oil Production: Impacts,
warned....
and Risk Management
Waiting until world oil production peaks would leave
the world with a liquid fuel deďŹcit for 20 years (very
painful = major economic upheaval).
Initiating a crash program 10 years before peaking
leaves a short-fall of liquid fuels for a decade
(painful).
Initiating a crash programme 20 years before peak
could avoid a global fuels short-fall (painless).
We prepared two different future visions, the keywords of the first scenario, Scenario A is,
Vivid, Technology-driven, Urban concentrated/ Individualistic, Centralized production /recycle, Convenient and Beneficial
On the other hands, In scenario B, the key words are
Slow, Natural-oriented, Decentralized/Community, Self-sufficient, Produce locally, consume locally
Social and Cultural Values
Following these concepts,
We prepared two different future visions, the keywords of the first scenario, Scenario A is,
Vivid, Technology-driven, Urban concentrated/ Individualistic, Centralized production /recycle, Convenient and Beneficial
On the other hands, In scenario B, the key words are
Slow, Natural-oriented, Decentralized/Community, Self-sufficient, Produce locally, consume locally
Social and Cultural Values
Following these concepts,