One for One
                       One person buys. One person is helped.




                                                    Group 3
                                                 M.M. Binte
                                                Min Jin Jeon
                                                Kye won Suh
                                             June Young Ahn

                                                          KSIM
                                          KAIST Business School




Strategic Management                                 Summer Semester 2011
C ONTENTS


                          Company Overview

                          Business Model

                          Current Strategy

                          Strategic Analysis

                          Issues

                          Root Cause Analysis

                          Recommendations

Strategic Management                             2                     7/7/2011
Prof. Han Earl Kim                                   KSIM, KAIST Business School
C OMPANY O VERVIEW

Company                   American footwear company based out of Santa Monica, California
                        Created by Blake Mycoskie in 2006 after traveling to
Business                 Argentina and realizing that the children have no shoes
Strategy                As of September 2010, TOMS has given over 1 million pairs
                         of new shoes to children in need
Analysis                Extended product-line to eyewear in 2011

Issues
Causes
Recommend.




Strategic Management                                                      3                     7/7/2011
Prof. Han Earl Kim                                                            KSIM, KAIST Business School
B USINESS M ODEL

Company                     One for OneTM
                                  One person buys. One person helped.
Business                          TOMS SHOES: With every pair you purchase , TOMS will give a new
                                   pair of shoes to a child in need.
Strategy                          TOMS EYEWEAR: With every pair you purchase , TOMS will give sight
                                   to a person in need. (Give prescribed eyeglasses)
Analysis
                        Creating sustainable business by turning customers into
Issues                   benefactors rather than depending on fundraising support
                        Viral Marketing with touching stories
Causes
Recommend.                                  Purchasing
                                           (Fundraising)
                                                                           Help Persons
                                                                          With Volunteers
                                                           Products                              Persons
                           Customers                                                            who need
                                           Satisfaction                  Touching Stories
                                                                                                  help
                           Word of Mouth
                            Marketing
Strategic Management                                                                 4                        7/7/2011
Prof. Han Earl Kim                                                                          KSIM, KAIST Business School
C URRENT S TRATEGY

Company                   Limitation of One for One BM
                              Profit margin for Shoe Business
Business                          Sales: 300,000 units * avg price $60 = $18 million
                                  Gross margin = 50% / Revenue for SG&A and tax = 30%
Strategy                          Net Profit = $4 million
                                  Manufacture and donation costs close to $4 million
Analysis
                              TOMS Eyewear – The new one for one
Issues                            It might have same profit margin as Shoe
                          Overcome Negative Profitability
Causes                        Sale for other items such as apparel and stickers
                                  Generate an additional revenue stream for the company
Recommend.
                              Partners with Non-profit organization
                                  Shoe Drop Tour volunteer opportunities
                              Aligns with other brands
                                  With Ralph Lauren Rugby to distribute one shoe model
Strategic Management
                                  AT&T “More Bars In More Places” campaign             5                     7/7/2011
Prof. Han Earl Kim                                                                          KSIM, KAIST Business School
C URRENT S TRATEGY

Company                   Word of Mouth Effect
                              No traditional advertising
Business                      Utilize SNS
                                  Movie clip Including touch stories and playful music
Strategy
                                  To explain TOMS’s social mission & To encourage you to get involve
Analysis                          Share donation activities through SNS
                                       337 bookmark or sharing services including Facebook, twitter

Issues
Causes
Recommend.




Strategic Management                                                                        6                     7/7/2011
Prof. Han Earl Kim                                                                              KSIM, KAIST Business School
C URRENT S TRATEGY

Company                   Customer Participation
                              Style Your Sole
Business                          Select a date for your event that works for your guests
                                  Promoting and collect money from your guests including shipping costs
Strategy                          Need to place your bulk order NO LATER than 2 weeks
                                  Order all plain white canvas TOMS (the easiest to decorate and customize)
                                  Invite local bands or artists to join your event
Analysis
Issues
Causes
                              For one day without shoes
Recommend.                        Host event or find & participate in event




                              Upload pictures wearing Toms or without shoes
Strategic Management                                                                  7                     7/7/2011
Prof. Han Earl Kim                                                                        KSIM, KAIST Business School
F IVE F ORCES A NALYSIS

Company
                                             Threats of New
Business                                        Entrants
                                                  LOW
Strategy
Analysis
                        Bargaining                                          Bargaining
Issues                   Power of              Competitive                   Power of
                        Suppliers                Rivalry                    Customers
Causes                     LOW                    HIGH                         HIGH
                                           Converse, Birkenstock, Roc
                        China, Argentina     ket Dog, UGGS, Vans
Recommend.

                                                Threat of
                                                Substitute
                                                   HIGH
Strategic Management                                                    8                      7/7/2011
Prof. Han Earl Kim                                                           KSIM, KAIST Business School
SWOT A NALYSIS

Company
Business                           Strengths:                    Weaknesses:
                                   •   The message               •   Young Company
                        Internal


                                   •   Product material          •   Limited distribution
Strategy                           •   Customizability           •   Brand awareness
                                   •   Global Brand              •   Limited Style
Analysis                           •   Innovative Options        •   Very defined target customer
                                       (Vegan, wrap boot)
Issues
                                   Opportunities:                Threats:
Causes                             • Large potential market      • Older and more established
                                   • More people becoming          competition with greater
                        External




Recommend.                           active in social causes       media exposure
                                   • Rise in green marketing     • Oversaturation of shoe market
                                   • Nontraditional              • Overall lack of advertising
                                     stance(facebook, twitter,
                                     YouTube) in media

Strategic Management                                                                9                     7/7/2011
Prof. Han Earl Kim                                                                      KSIM, KAIST Business School
I SSUES

Company                   From Five-Forces and SWOT Analysis
                              Unisex Designs
Business                           Preferred by women and kids, not men
                              Unreasonable Price
Strategy                           Compared to material’s quality and Product Life Cycle - Expensive

Analysis                      Low Brand awareness
                                   No traditional mass marketing
Issues                        Limited distribution channel
                                   Few offline shops in US & globally online sale
Causes                        Defined target customer
                                   Targeting only young generation
Recommend.
                          Others
                              Controversial cognition
                                   Poverty vs. Dignity
                                   An angel? or A wolf in sheep´s clothing?

Strategic Management                                                                   10                     7/7/2011
Prof. Han Earl Kim                                                                          KSIM, KAIST Business School
R OOT C AUSE A NALYSIS

Company                                                 ISSUES                     Root Causes               Recommendations
                                                     Designs                      Many Designs cost
                                                     (Men’s shoe)
Business                                                                               much                     Low cost design
                       Five-forces & SWOT Analysis


                                                     Price
Strategy                                             (compared to the quality     Low profit margin
                                                     of the materials and life   (because of charity cost)
                                                     cycle of the product -
Analysis                                             expensive)                                               Various product-line
                                                                                  Low-price strategy         to many fashion items
                                                     Brand awareness
Issues                                               (low)

                                                     Distribution                Only on-line channel
Causes                                               channel (limited)
                                                                                                                   Increase
                                                                                                               Brand Awareness
Recommend.                                           Target customer
                                                     (very defined)              No mass marketing

                                                     Controversial
                       Others




                                                                                                                     Keep
                                                     cognition                     Business Model             its Business Model
                                                     (poverty vs. dignity)

Strategic Management                                                                                             11                     7/7/2011
Prof. Han Earl Kim                                                                                                    KSIM, KAIST Business School
R ECOMMENDATIONS

Company                   Make various product design!
                              Develop plans how to make design without cost
Business                      Examples about getting low cost design
                                  Fashion Design Contest
Strategy                               Online – SNS,   Offline - Fashion design school
                                  Star Donation
Analysis
                                       Fund Raising, Designed by Stars, Utilization as a model etc

Issues
                                        Best Design                          Prize Money
Causes
Recommend.
                                                           Winner gives
                                                           the low cost
                                                                but
                                                           best design


Strategic Management                                                                         12                     7/7/2011
Prof. Han Earl Kim                                                                                KSIM, KAIST Business School
R ECOMMENDATIONS

Company                   Change brand position as a charity brand!
                              From shoes manufacturing to fashion, charity brand
Business                      New One for One - Make various product lines
                                  Example – School Project
Strategy
                                     School Bag      Get much profit
Analysis                                             Bag pack`s price is more expensive than shoes
                                                     Good product to make collection
Issues                                               Student’s Fashionable item
                                                     Develop school supplies as well
Causes
                                  Example – Disease Project
Recommend.                                   Disease              Get much profit
                                                                  High demand - household items
                                                                  Soap, Toothpaste, hand washer etc
                                                                  Prevention is better than cure
                                                                  Reduce the possibility of getting disease

Strategic Management                                                                 13                     7/7/2011
Prof. Han Earl Kim                                                                        KSIM, KAIST Business School
R ECOMMENDATIONS

Company                   Promote Toms brand & business!
                              Must increase Brand awareness
Business                          Awareness of TOMS Shoe company research by The Clemetine group
                                  Focus Group interview, March 2010 (Most respondents living in US)
Strategy
Analysis                                             It means
                                                     Marketing efforts are incredibly ineffective!
Issues
                              Utilize traditional mass media
Causes                            Keep strategy not to make commercials
                                  Instead of Ads, Open big global event for interview and report
Recommend.                        Example – World travel relay without shoes

                              Partnership with Unesco & Unicef
                                  Unesco – Open workcamp making shoes for volunteers
                                  Unicef – Utilize Unicef shop & honorary ambassadors

Strategic Management                                                                   14                     7/7/2011
Prof. Han Earl Kim                                                                          KSIM, KAIST Business School
R ECOMMENDATIONS

Company                   Give customer price options!
                              Keep original business model - One for One
Business
                              Partially add “Two for Two” model
Strategy                          Target – someone to want to buy different color or give gift to another
                                  ‘One for One’ recently 49$ → ‘One for Two’ about 90$ (cheaper)
Analysis
                              Partially add “One for Two” or “One for Three”
Issues                            Target – someone to want to donate more through toms
                                  ‘One for One’ recently 49$ → ‘One for Two’ about 70$ (cheaper)
Causes                            Record customers name in the hall of fame

Recommend.                             Increase sale volume & Reduce shipping cost
                                           Discount Benefit to regular customers
                                          Establish donation culture though Toms


Strategic Management                                                                   15                     7/7/2011
Prof. Han Earl Kim                                                                          KSIM, KAIST Business School
Thank you

TOMS Shoe

  • 1.
    One for One One person buys. One person is helped. Group 3 M.M. Binte Min Jin Jeon Kye won Suh June Young Ahn KSIM KAIST Business School Strategic Management Summer Semester 2011
  • 3.
    C ONTENTS  Company Overview  Business Model  Current Strategy  Strategic Analysis  Issues  Root Cause Analysis  Recommendations Strategic Management 2 7/7/2011 Prof. Han Earl Kim KSIM, KAIST Business School
  • 4.
    C OMPANY OVERVIEW Company  American footwear company based out of Santa Monica, California  Created by Blake Mycoskie in 2006 after traveling to Business Argentina and realizing that the children have no shoes Strategy  As of September 2010, TOMS has given over 1 million pairs of new shoes to children in need Analysis  Extended product-line to eyewear in 2011 Issues Causes Recommend. Strategic Management 3 7/7/2011 Prof. Han Earl Kim KSIM, KAIST Business School
  • 5.
    B USINESS MODEL Company  One for OneTM  One person buys. One person helped. Business  TOMS SHOES: With every pair you purchase , TOMS will give a new pair of shoes to a child in need. Strategy  TOMS EYEWEAR: With every pair you purchase , TOMS will give sight to a person in need. (Give prescribed eyeglasses) Analysis  Creating sustainable business by turning customers into Issues benefactors rather than depending on fundraising support  Viral Marketing with touching stories Causes Recommend. Purchasing (Fundraising) Help Persons With Volunteers Products Persons Customers who need Satisfaction Touching Stories help Word of Mouth Marketing Strategic Management 4 7/7/2011 Prof. Han Earl Kim KSIM, KAIST Business School
  • 6.
    C URRENT STRATEGY Company  Limitation of One for One BM  Profit margin for Shoe Business Business  Sales: 300,000 units * avg price $60 = $18 million  Gross margin = 50% / Revenue for SG&A and tax = 30% Strategy  Net Profit = $4 million  Manufacture and donation costs close to $4 million Analysis  TOMS Eyewear – The new one for one Issues  It might have same profit margin as Shoe  Overcome Negative Profitability Causes  Sale for other items such as apparel and stickers  Generate an additional revenue stream for the company Recommend.  Partners with Non-profit organization  Shoe Drop Tour volunteer opportunities  Aligns with other brands  With Ralph Lauren Rugby to distribute one shoe model Strategic Management  AT&T “More Bars In More Places” campaign 5 7/7/2011 Prof. Han Earl Kim KSIM, KAIST Business School
  • 7.
    C URRENT STRATEGY Company  Word of Mouth Effect  No traditional advertising Business  Utilize SNS  Movie clip Including touch stories and playful music Strategy  To explain TOMS’s social mission & To encourage you to get involve Analysis  Share donation activities through SNS  337 bookmark or sharing services including Facebook, twitter Issues Causes Recommend. Strategic Management 6 7/7/2011 Prof. Han Earl Kim KSIM, KAIST Business School
  • 8.
    C URRENT STRATEGY Company  Customer Participation  Style Your Sole Business  Select a date for your event that works for your guests  Promoting and collect money from your guests including shipping costs Strategy  Need to place your bulk order NO LATER than 2 weeks  Order all plain white canvas TOMS (the easiest to decorate and customize)  Invite local bands or artists to join your event Analysis Issues Causes  For one day without shoes Recommend.  Host event or find & participate in event  Upload pictures wearing Toms or without shoes Strategic Management 7 7/7/2011 Prof. Han Earl Kim KSIM, KAIST Business School
  • 9.
    F IVE FORCES A NALYSIS Company Threats of New Business Entrants LOW Strategy Analysis Bargaining Bargaining Issues Power of Competitive Power of Suppliers Rivalry Customers Causes LOW HIGH HIGH Converse, Birkenstock, Roc China, Argentina ket Dog, UGGS, Vans Recommend. Threat of Substitute HIGH Strategic Management 8 7/7/2011 Prof. Han Earl Kim KSIM, KAIST Business School
  • 10.
    SWOT A NALYSIS Company Business Strengths: Weaknesses: • The message • Young Company Internal • Product material • Limited distribution Strategy • Customizability • Brand awareness • Global Brand • Limited Style Analysis • Innovative Options • Very defined target customer (Vegan, wrap boot) Issues Opportunities: Threats: Causes • Large potential market • Older and more established • More people becoming competition with greater External Recommend. active in social causes media exposure • Rise in green marketing • Oversaturation of shoe market • Nontraditional • Overall lack of advertising stance(facebook, twitter, YouTube) in media Strategic Management 9 7/7/2011 Prof. Han Earl Kim KSIM, KAIST Business School
  • 11.
    I SSUES Company  From Five-Forces and SWOT Analysis  Unisex Designs Business  Preferred by women and kids, not men  Unreasonable Price Strategy  Compared to material’s quality and Product Life Cycle - Expensive Analysis  Low Brand awareness  No traditional mass marketing Issues  Limited distribution channel  Few offline shops in US & globally online sale Causes  Defined target customer  Targeting only young generation Recommend.  Others  Controversial cognition  Poverty vs. Dignity  An angel? or A wolf in sheep´s clothing? Strategic Management 10 7/7/2011 Prof. Han Earl Kim KSIM, KAIST Business School
  • 12.
    R OOT CAUSE A NALYSIS Company ISSUES Root Causes Recommendations Designs Many Designs cost (Men’s shoe) Business much Low cost design Five-forces & SWOT Analysis Price Strategy (compared to the quality Low profit margin of the materials and life (because of charity cost) cycle of the product - Analysis expensive) Various product-line Low-price strategy to many fashion items Brand awareness Issues (low) Distribution Only on-line channel Causes channel (limited) Increase Brand Awareness Recommend. Target customer (very defined) No mass marketing Controversial Others Keep cognition Business Model its Business Model (poverty vs. dignity) Strategic Management 11 7/7/2011 Prof. Han Earl Kim KSIM, KAIST Business School
  • 13.
    R ECOMMENDATIONS Company  Make various product design!  Develop plans how to make design without cost Business  Examples about getting low cost design  Fashion Design Contest Strategy  Online – SNS, Offline - Fashion design school  Star Donation Analysis  Fund Raising, Designed by Stars, Utilization as a model etc Issues Best Design Prize Money Causes Recommend. Winner gives the low cost but best design Strategic Management 12 7/7/2011 Prof. Han Earl Kim KSIM, KAIST Business School
  • 14.
    R ECOMMENDATIONS Company  Change brand position as a charity brand!  From shoes manufacturing to fashion, charity brand Business  New One for One - Make various product lines  Example – School Project Strategy School Bag Get much profit Analysis Bag pack`s price is more expensive than shoes Good product to make collection Issues Student’s Fashionable item Develop school supplies as well Causes  Example – Disease Project Recommend. Disease Get much profit High demand - household items Soap, Toothpaste, hand washer etc Prevention is better than cure Reduce the possibility of getting disease Strategic Management 13 7/7/2011 Prof. Han Earl Kim KSIM, KAIST Business School
  • 15.
    R ECOMMENDATIONS Company  Promote Toms brand & business!  Must increase Brand awareness Business  Awareness of TOMS Shoe company research by The Clemetine group  Focus Group interview, March 2010 (Most respondents living in US) Strategy Analysis It means Marketing efforts are incredibly ineffective! Issues  Utilize traditional mass media Causes  Keep strategy not to make commercials  Instead of Ads, Open big global event for interview and report Recommend.  Example – World travel relay without shoes  Partnership with Unesco & Unicef  Unesco – Open workcamp making shoes for volunteers  Unicef – Utilize Unicef shop & honorary ambassadors Strategic Management 14 7/7/2011 Prof. Han Earl Kim KSIM, KAIST Business School
  • 16.
    R ECOMMENDATIONS Company  Give customer price options!  Keep original business model - One for One Business  Partially add “Two for Two” model Strategy  Target – someone to want to buy different color or give gift to another  ‘One for One’ recently 49$ → ‘One for Two’ about 90$ (cheaper) Analysis  Partially add “One for Two” or “One for Three” Issues  Target – someone to want to donate more through toms  ‘One for One’ recently 49$ → ‘One for Two’ about 70$ (cheaper) Causes  Record customers name in the hall of fame Recommend. Increase sale volume & Reduce shipping cost Discount Benefit to regular customers Establish donation culture though Toms Strategic Management 15 7/7/2011 Prof. Han Earl Kim KSIM, KAIST Business School
  • 17.

Editor's Notes

  • #4 A leading cause of disease in developing countries is soil-transmitted diseases, which can penetrate the skin through bare feet. Wearing shoes can help prevent these diseases, and the long-term physical and cognitive harm they cause.Many times children can't attend school barefoot because shoes are a required part of their uniform