Test Maturity Model integration (TMMi) e-Survey




           Listen | Challenge | Understand | Interpret | Create
Private & Confidential Experimentus Ltd   17a Dorset Square   London   NW1 6QB   T: +44 (0)207 871 2300   www.experimentus.com   v0.4
Content

 About TMMi


 TMMi Structure


 TMMi Levels


 e-Survey guidance




    Copyright © 2012 Experimentus Ltd   2
Test Maturity Model Integration

 Developed by the TMMi Foundation (http://www.tmmifoundation.org/)
 Based on a wide variety of public domain industry sources
  – including the TMM framework originally developed by Illinois Institute of
    Technology
 5 levels of test maturity (staged model)
  – Complements the existing CMMI framework
 Empirically validated
 The worlds only independent test process measurement method
 Describes the processes needed to ensure a well planned and
  controlled test organisation

     Copyright © 2012 Experimentus Ltd                                          3
TMMi Structure


                                             Maturity
                                              Level
                             indicates                    contains
                        Testing Process                 Process
                        capability                       Areas
                                         achieves                      contains

                                          Goals                      Specific &
                                                                  Generic Practices

                                                    describes
                                                     Implementation
   Copyright © 2012 Experimentus Ltd                                                  4
TMMi Maturity Levels


                                                                                                                    5 - Optimizing

                                                                                              4–
                                                                                              Quantitatively
                                                                    3 – Defined               Managed
                                                                                                                   5 - Optimisation
                                                                                                                   • Defect Prevention
                                        2 – Managed                                                                • Test Process
                                                                                              4 – Management         Optimisation
                                                                                              and Measurement      • Quality Control
                 1 – Initial                                                                  • Test Measurement
                                                                   3 – Defined                • Product Quality
                                                                   • Test Organisation          Evaluation
                                                                   • Test Training            • Advanced Reviews
                                       2 – Managed                   Programme
                                       • Test Policy & Strategy    • Test Life Cycle &
                                                                     Integration
                                       • Test Planning
                1 – Initial            • Test Monitoring &
                                                                   • Non-Functional Testing
                                         Control                   • Peer Reviews
                                       • Test Design & Execution
                                       • Test Environment




                                                                                                                                 5
   Copyright © 2012 Experimentus Ltd
Level 2 - Managed

 The status of the work products        Process Areas
  and the delivery of testing             2.1 Test Policy & Strategy
  services are visible to
  management, however testing             2.2 Test Planning
  may still start relatively late in      2.3 Test Monitoring & Control
  the development life cycle
                                          2.4 Test Design & Execution
 Testing is multileveled, i.e. there
  are unit, integration, system and  2.5 Test Environments
  acceptance test levels
 The main objective of testing in
  a TMMi level 2 organisation is to
  verify that the product satisfies
  the specified requirements
     Copyright © 2012 Experimentus Ltd                                  6
Level 3 - Defined

 Testing is fully integrated into       Process Areas
  the development life cycle              3.1 Test Organisation
 The organisations test                  3.2 Test Training Program
  standards are established and
  improved over time and test             3.3 Test Lifecycle & Integration
  process improvement is fully            3.4 Non Functional Testing
  institutionalised
                                          3.5 Peer Reviews
 A specific organisation test
  training programme exists and
  testing is perceived as being a
  profession and test
  professionals are involved with
  reviews of requirements
     Copyright © 2012 Experimentus Ltd                                  7
TMMi Reference Material




 For more information on TMMi, visit the TMMi foundation website




                                         www.tmmifoundation.org




                                                                  8
     Copyright © 2012 Experimentus Ltd
The TMMi e-Survey




                                       9
   Copyright © 2012 Experimentus Ltd
The e-Survey

   Browser based

   Sections:
    1. Testing trends &
       non-TMMi
    2. TMMi Process Area
       rating
    3. Optional Comments

   Features
    –         Simple scoring
              method
    –         Focuses on areas
              pertinent to your role
    –         “Save & Continue
              Survey Later”

                                            10
        Copyright © 2012 Experimentus Ltd
Completing the e-Survey

 Should take between 30 mins
  and 1 hour to complete
 Process areas presented based
  on your role in the organisation
  – You can select to complete all
    process areas if you like
 For each process area there
  are two elements:
  1. Statement scores against the
     model
  2. Process implementation
     effectiveness

                                        11
    Copyright © 2012 Experimentus Ltd
Completing the e-Survey

     Statement scores against the model
     –      Review each statement, then select a score between 0 and 10 based on
            how much you agree that the statement is true for your organisation
     –      If you don’t have an opinion, please leave the score blank




                                                                                   12
         Copyright © 2012 Experimentus Ltd
Completing the e-Survey

     Process implementation effectiveness
     –      For each process area, select a star ranking for:
                    How well you feel the organisation has approached the definition of the
                     process area
                    How well you feel the organisation has deployed changes in the process
                     area
                    How good you think the results of deployed process changes for the
                     process area are




                                                                                          13
         Copyright © 2012 Experimentus Ltd
Completing the e-Survey

 Testing Trends and non-TMMi section
  – Obtains a personal view of testing progress in your organisation over the last 2
    years
  – Contains statements on areas outside of TMMi that may still impact your
    organisations test process effectiveness




                                                                              14
     Copyright © 2012 Experimentus Ltd
Completing the e-Survey



 Your views are important: please answer honestly
 No preparation is required
 Do not use reference material to help you answer questions
 Your first answer is most often the right answer




                                                               15
     Copyright © 2012 Experimentus Ltd
“Save and continue survey later”

 Use this if you can’t complete the e-Survey in one session
 Allows you to save what you have entered and return later
 Only saves data entered on submitted pages




                                                               16
     Copyright © 2012 Experimentus Ltd
Things to note

 Responses are completely confidential
 Assessment Team only will see individual data
 Important: this should be a personal perspective:
  – Please do not collaborate with colleagues or management
  – Responses should be based on experience, not research
  – Do not spend too much time trying find the “right” response
  – Your first answer is generally the best answer




                                                                  17
    Copyright © 2012 Experimentus Ltd
Next steps




                                       18
   Copyright © 2012 Experimentus Ltd
Wrap-up and Next steps

 The survey must be completed
  within the requested time frame


 Results will be consolidated,
  analysed and summarised


 The final findings analysis is
  presented back to the sponsor




                                         19
     Copyright © 2012 Experimentus Ltd
Questions & Concerns

 For queries, please contact the Assessment Team Lead


 Alternatively, contact your TMMi assessment contact


 Details for both are provided in the invitation email




                                                          20
     Copyright © 2012 Experimentus Ltd
Thank you

                                     www.experimentus.com
                                        +44 (0) 207 871 2300

                           info@experimentus.com :        @experimentus


                                                                          21
Copyright © 2012 Experimentus Ltd

TMMi e-Survey guidance

  • 1.
    Test Maturity Modelintegration (TMMi) e-Survey Listen | Challenge | Understand | Interpret | Create Private & Confidential Experimentus Ltd 17a Dorset Square London NW1 6QB T: +44 (0)207 871 2300 www.experimentus.com v0.4
  • 2.
    Content  About TMMi TMMi Structure  TMMi Levels  e-Survey guidance Copyright © 2012 Experimentus Ltd 2
  • 3.
    Test Maturity ModelIntegration  Developed by the TMMi Foundation (http://www.tmmifoundation.org/)  Based on a wide variety of public domain industry sources – including the TMM framework originally developed by Illinois Institute of Technology  5 levels of test maturity (staged model) – Complements the existing CMMI framework  Empirically validated  The worlds only independent test process measurement method  Describes the processes needed to ensure a well planned and controlled test organisation Copyright © 2012 Experimentus Ltd 3
  • 4.
    TMMi Structure Maturity Level indicates contains Testing Process Process capability Areas achieves contains Goals Specific & Generic Practices describes Implementation Copyright © 2012 Experimentus Ltd 4
  • 5.
    TMMi Maturity Levels 5 - Optimizing 4– Quantitatively 3 – Defined Managed 5 - Optimisation • Defect Prevention 2 – Managed • Test Process 4 – Management Optimisation and Measurement • Quality Control 1 – Initial • Test Measurement 3 – Defined • Product Quality • Test Organisation Evaluation • Test Training • Advanced Reviews 2 – Managed Programme • Test Policy & Strategy • Test Life Cycle & Integration • Test Planning 1 – Initial • Test Monitoring & • Non-Functional Testing Control • Peer Reviews • Test Design & Execution • Test Environment 5 Copyright © 2012 Experimentus Ltd
  • 6.
    Level 2 -Managed  The status of the work products Process Areas and the delivery of testing  2.1 Test Policy & Strategy services are visible to management, however testing  2.2 Test Planning may still start relatively late in  2.3 Test Monitoring & Control the development life cycle  2.4 Test Design & Execution  Testing is multileveled, i.e. there are unit, integration, system and  2.5 Test Environments acceptance test levels  The main objective of testing in a TMMi level 2 organisation is to verify that the product satisfies the specified requirements Copyright © 2012 Experimentus Ltd 6
  • 7.
    Level 3 -Defined  Testing is fully integrated into Process Areas the development life cycle  3.1 Test Organisation  The organisations test  3.2 Test Training Program standards are established and improved over time and test  3.3 Test Lifecycle & Integration process improvement is fully  3.4 Non Functional Testing institutionalised  3.5 Peer Reviews  A specific organisation test training programme exists and testing is perceived as being a profession and test professionals are involved with reviews of requirements Copyright © 2012 Experimentus Ltd 7
  • 8.
    TMMi Reference Material For more information on TMMi, visit the TMMi foundation website www.tmmifoundation.org 8 Copyright © 2012 Experimentus Ltd
  • 9.
    The TMMi e-Survey 9 Copyright © 2012 Experimentus Ltd
  • 10.
    The e-Survey  Browser based  Sections: 1. Testing trends & non-TMMi 2. TMMi Process Area rating 3. Optional Comments  Features – Simple scoring method – Focuses on areas pertinent to your role – “Save & Continue Survey Later” 10 Copyright © 2012 Experimentus Ltd
  • 11.
    Completing the e-Survey Should take between 30 mins and 1 hour to complete  Process areas presented based on your role in the organisation – You can select to complete all process areas if you like  For each process area there are two elements: 1. Statement scores against the model 2. Process implementation effectiveness 11 Copyright © 2012 Experimentus Ltd
  • 12.
    Completing the e-Survey  Statement scores against the model – Review each statement, then select a score between 0 and 10 based on how much you agree that the statement is true for your organisation – If you don’t have an opinion, please leave the score blank 12 Copyright © 2012 Experimentus Ltd
  • 13.
    Completing the e-Survey  Process implementation effectiveness – For each process area, select a star ranking for:  How well you feel the organisation has approached the definition of the process area  How well you feel the organisation has deployed changes in the process area  How good you think the results of deployed process changes for the process area are 13 Copyright © 2012 Experimentus Ltd
  • 14.
    Completing the e-Survey Testing Trends and non-TMMi section – Obtains a personal view of testing progress in your organisation over the last 2 years – Contains statements on areas outside of TMMi that may still impact your organisations test process effectiveness 14 Copyright © 2012 Experimentus Ltd
  • 15.
    Completing the e-Survey Your views are important: please answer honestly  No preparation is required  Do not use reference material to help you answer questions  Your first answer is most often the right answer 15 Copyright © 2012 Experimentus Ltd
  • 16.
    “Save and continuesurvey later”  Use this if you can’t complete the e-Survey in one session  Allows you to save what you have entered and return later  Only saves data entered on submitted pages 16 Copyright © 2012 Experimentus Ltd
  • 17.
    Things to note Responses are completely confidential  Assessment Team only will see individual data  Important: this should be a personal perspective: – Please do not collaborate with colleagues or management – Responses should be based on experience, not research – Do not spend too much time trying find the “right” response – Your first answer is generally the best answer 17 Copyright © 2012 Experimentus Ltd
  • 18.
    Next steps 18 Copyright © 2012 Experimentus Ltd
  • 19.
    Wrap-up and Nextsteps  The survey must be completed within the requested time frame  Results will be consolidated, analysed and summarised  The final findings analysis is presented back to the sponsor 19 Copyright © 2012 Experimentus Ltd
  • 20.
    Questions & Concerns For queries, please contact the Assessment Team Lead  Alternatively, contact your TMMi assessment contact  Details for both are provided in the invitation email 20 Copyright © 2012 Experimentus Ltd
  • 21.
    Thank you www.experimentus.com +44 (0) 207 871 2300 info@experimentus.com : @experimentus 21 Copyright © 2012 Experimentus Ltd

Editor's Notes

  • #13 There are a total of 91 statements to reviewWe expect this to take you between 1 and 1.5 hoursYour views are important, please answer honestlyNo preparation is required to complete the e-Survey, nor should you use reference material to help you answer questionsRemember your first answer is most often the right answer The e-Survey allows you to partially complete, save and return as many times as your diary requiresPlease make time to complete the survey!
  • #14 There are a total of 91 statements to reviewWe expect this to take you between 1 and 1.5 hoursYour views are important, please answer honestlyNo preparation is required to complete the e-Survey, nor should you use reference material to help you answer questionsRemember your first answer is most often the right answer The e-Survey allows you to partially complete, save and return as many times as your diary requiresPlease make time to complete the survey!
  • #16 There are a total of 91 statements to reviewWe expect this to take you between 1 and 1.5 hoursYour views are important, please answer honestlyNo preparation is required to complete the e-Survey, nor should you use reference material to help you answer questionsRemember your first answer is most often the right answer The e-Survey allows you to partially complete, save and return as many times as your diary requiresPlease make time to complete the survey!
  • #17 It may not be possible to find time to complete the e-Survey in one sessionThis feature allows you to save what you have entered to date and return to your response laterIt will only save data entered on completed pages which have been submitted (i.e. where you have clicked on “Next Page” button)E.g. enter data for 2.1 – Test Policy and StrategyMove to page title 2.2 – Test Planning by clicking on “Next Page”Click on “Save & Continue Survey Later” – data up to and including 2.1 – Test Policy & Strategy is savedYou will be prompted for an email address. Enter your email address: a unique link will be sent to you to allow you to click and re-enter your e-Survey response where you left offNote: in above example, if you entered partial data in 2.2 –Test Planning, this would not be saved unless you had moved to the next page
  • #18 Your responses are completely confidential and only the Assessment Team will see individual’s dataDO NOT forward your unique survey URL to anybody (unless you wish to lose the confidentiality!)It is important that this is from a personal perspective: Please do not collaborate with colleagues/management when completingYour responses should be based on your experiences; not research!Do not spend too much time on trying to put down the “right” answer – your first answer is normally your best answerIf you really do not have a view on a particular statement or dimension of a statement, leave it blank
  • #20 Logo position