Updating Construction Schedules
•       Procedure:
      – Change the duration of all completed activities
        to zeros.
      – Identify all activities on which work is currently
        proceeding as live activities.
      – Put early start time of live activities equals the
        update time and their durations equal the
        remaining duration given by the update report.
      – Change durations of future activities as given in
        the update report.
      – Carry out network analysis in the normal way
        and prepare a new activity schedule.
    Spring 2008,           Time and Cost Control        1
    King Saud University    Dr. Khalid Al-Gahtani
Example




Spring   Time and Cost Control    2
2008,     Dr. Khalid Al-Gahtani
Example
• The position of the activities at the end of the fifth
  week is as follows:
   – Activities B, C, D and E have been completed.
   – Activity F is ready to start at beginning of week 6.
   – Remaining duration of activity H is 4 weeks.
   – Remaining duration of activity I is 3 weeks.
   – Activity G will not start until end of week 7.
   – Volume of work in activity L has been increased by 33%
     approximately.
   – Activity J has been omitted.
   – It is decided to shorten activity K by 2 weeks.

• Construct the updated schedule indicating the critical
  path and showing new activities times.
  Spring 2008,           Time and Cost Control             3
  King Saud University    Dr. Khalid Al-Gahtani
Spring   Time and Cost Control    4
2008,     Dr. Khalid Al-Gahtani
Work Breakdown Structure
• WBS divides the project into recognizable systems (work
  packages, WP’s or Bid Packages) that responsible
  assignable work units, and for which accountability can
  be expected/assigned.

                    P ro ject



                W o rk P ackages



                   A ct ivit ies                 S equenc ing


Spring                  Time and Cost Control                   5
2008,                    Dr. Khalid Al-Gahtani
Traditional A/E PDS

                       O w ner



      A /E                               GC



     Su b1                  Su b2                     Su b3   Su b4




Spring 2008,                     Time and Cost Control                6
King Saud University              Dr. Khalid Al-Gahtani
Professional Construction Management

                                    O w ne r



                 A /E                 CM



  W P1                  W P2         W P3               W P4   W P4




 Spring 2008,                  Time and Cost Control                  7
 King Saud University           Dr. Khalid Al-Gahtani
Developing WPs
•        Develop WBS
     – Identify WPs
•        Draw a WPs Network

                               W P3
              W P1

                               W P4             W P6
              W P2

                               W P5

Spring                 Time and Cost Control           8
2008,                   Dr. Khalid Al-Gahtani
Developing WPs
•       Each WP must have
      – One Performing Agency (PA) such as
        Subcontractor
      – One Responsible Agency (RA) such owner’s
        Project Engineers
•       Interconnection between Packages should
        be district and clear to facilitate
        coordination
                                W P1           W P2


                                               W P3
    Spring            Time and Cost Control           9
    2008,              Dr. Khalid Al-Gahtani
Developing WPs
•        Bid a WP at the most short time so as to
         stimulate competition (Keep away
         uncertainty)


         W P1        W P2                      W P3   W P4




Spring                Time and Cost Control              10
2008,                  Dr. Khalid Al-Gahtani
Cost Coding System
• Cost Central level = Lowest level at which
  functional responsibility for individual WBS
  element exit.
     – XXX XXX XXX XXX
• An example:
     – 0534.02220.21.A.00.cf34




Spring 2008,           Time and Cost Control    11
King Saud University    Dr. Khalid Al-Gahtani
MASTERFORMAT system
T A B L E 1 M a jo r D ivisio ns in the U nifo rm C o nstructio n Inde x

0   C o nd itio ns o f the co ntract                9 F inishes
1   G enera l requ ire m e nts                      10 S pec ia lt ies
2   S ite w o rk                                    11 E quip m e nt
3   C o ncrete                                      12 Furnishing s
4   M aso nry                                       13 S pec ia l co nstructio n
5   M etals                                         14 C o nve ying syste m
6   W o o d and p last ic s                         15 M echa nica l
7   T herm a l a nd m o isture prevent io n         16 E lectrica l
8   D oors and w indo w s



Spring                         Time and Cost Control                               12
2008,                           Dr. Khalid Al-Gahtani
Cost Coding System
• Advantages of coding systems are:
     – Provide a numbering system to replace verbal
       descriptions of items.
     – These codes reduce the length or complexity of the
       information to be recorded.
     – aids consistency in definitions and categories
       between projects and among the various parties
       involved in a project.
     – aid in the retrieval of historical records of cost,
       productivity and duration on particular activities.
     – electronic data storage and retrieval operations are
       much more efficient with standard coding systems.
Spring 2008,             Time and Cost Control                13
King Saud University      Dr. Khalid Al-Gahtani
Project Cost Control
• Budgeted Cost of Work Scheduled (BCWS) is the
  budgeted amount of cost of the work scheduled to be
  accomplished in a given time period (including support
  and allocated overhead).

• Budgeted Cost of Work Performed (BCWP) is the
  budgeted amount of cost for the work completed in a
  given time period, including support effort and allocated
  overhead. (This is sometimes referred to as “earned
  value of work accomplished”.)

• Actual Cost of Work Performed (ACWP) is the amount
  reported as actually expended in completing the
  particular work accomplished within a given time period.
Spring 2008,            Time and Cost Control                 14
King Saud University     Dr. Khalid Al-Gahtani
Type of performance
                                                     BC W P


                                                     BC W S



                                                     ACW P




                       Fast & L o w

Spring 2008,                Time and Cost Control             15
King Saud University         Dr. Khalid Al-Gahtani   BCWS
Type of performance
                                                   ACW P


                                                   BC W P



                                                   BC W S




                       Fast & H ig h
Spring 2008,              Time and Cost Control             16
King Saud University       Dr. Khalid Al-Gahtani
Type of operformance
            Fast & L w


                                          BCWS


                                          BCW P



                                          AC W P




            S low & Low
Spring           Time and Cost Control             17
2008,             Dr. Khalid Al-Gahtani
TypeFast & performance
              of H ig h
                                          BCWS


                                          AC W P



                                          BCWP




              S low & H igh
Spring           Time and Cost Control             18
2008,             Dr. Khalid Al-Gahtani
Cost Index
C o st V ariance = B C W P A C W P
                         + ve      U nder B udget
C o st V ariance         0         W ithin B udget
                         - ve      O ver B udget
C o st P erfo rm ance Index = B C W P /A C W P
                          > 1        U nder B udget
CPI                       = 1        W ithin B udget
                          < 1        O ver B udget
% co st o verrun/u nderrun

                ACW P    BCWP
            =                         ,
                       BCWP
Spring 2008,                  Time and Cost Control    19
King Saud University           Dr. Khalid Al-Gahtani
Schedule Index
S chedu le/P erfo rma nc e V aria nce =B C W P -B C W S .
                          +ve          A head S chedule
S ch./per. V ariance      0            O n S chedule
                          -ve          B ehind S chedule
S chedu le P erfo rma nce Inde x = B C W P / B C W S .
                         >1          A head S chedule
SPI                      =1          O n S chedule
                         <1          B ehind S chedule


Spring 2008,              Time and Cost Control             20
King Saud University       Dr. Khalid Al-Gahtani
B udgeted C o st A t C o m pletio n (B A C )

 Estimatedo fCost/Timenit price
      = T o tal Q uantities U At Completion

 P udgeted C e A t t o o pletio n (T A C C
 Blanned T imo st A CC mm pletio n (B A ) )

            = T o tal o f Q uantities ÷ P lanned P ro ductivity
                            uantities U nit price
 E lanned T imo st A CC mm pletio n (E A C )
 P stim ated C e A t t o o pletio n (T A C )

          = T oC Wo f oD ate
            A tal PT Q uantities ÷ P lanned P ro ductivity
                                          BAC
          =                   BAC =
             B C W PT oD ate            C P I T oD ate
 E stim ated C o st A t C o m pletio n (E A C )
M ore accurate estim ate can be reach ed by using these form ulas:
  T o D ate VA C W P T im e
               ariance                            BAC
                        T oD ate
E stim ated=C o st A t Co m p let B A C = C )
                                    io n (E A
              BB C W PoD ate
                 C W PT                        C P I T oD ate
                          T oD ate
           =                         1     T im e T oD D ate
                                 (B A C - B C W PT o ate )
         = V arianceate im
  T o D ate A CB C W S T oD atee
                W P T oD T
                                         C P I T hisPeriod

ESpring ated T im eC W CooD ate letandn (EControl )
 stim            B A t PT m p io Cost T A C
                              Time                                 21
 2008,      =                          1       T im e
                                  Dr. Khalid Al-Gahtani T oD ate
Spring   Time and Cost Control    22
2008,     Dr. Khalid Al-Gahtani
Project Example




Spring 2008,               Time and Cost Control    23
King Saud University        Dr. Khalid Al-Gahtani
Project Example




Spring       Time and Cost Control    24
2008,         Dr. Khalid Al-Gahtani
Project Example
         E N G IN E E R IN G SU B T ASKS ST AT U S AT E N D O F M O N T H 3
                                 (tho usands o f do llars)

                T ask                      Status          BCW S    BCW P     ACW P
System design                          C o mp leted        $131.0   $131.0    $144.0
Subco ntract specs                       Started           132.0     82.0      84.0
M aterial tests                        C o mp leted         22.0     22.0      22.5
Specs review                             Started            22.0     15.0      15.5
D rafting                                Started            97.0     59.0      59.0
Fabricatio n/assembly suppo rt         C o mp leted         29.0     29.0      36.0
Fabricatio n/assembly pro cess           Started           100.0     63.0      67.0
T est suppo rt                           Started            21.0     21.0      21.0
E ngineering release and review        N ot Started
                T otal                                     $554.0   $422.0    $449.0

Spring 2008,                      Time and Cost Control                            25
King Saud University               Dr. Khalid Al-Gahtani
Project Example
Figure 5 -9 S tatus sum m ary o f engineering subtasks in pro gress and estim ate to co m plete.

               T ask                  BCWS      BCWP       ACW P                     S tatus
S ubco ntract specs                    $132       $82        $84      B e hind sc hedu le and o ver co st
S pecs review                           22         15        15.5 B e hind sc hedu le and o ver co st
D ra fting                              97         59         59      B e hind sc hedu le but w ithin co st
Fa bricat io n/asse m b ly pro cess    100         63         67      B e hind sc hedu le and o ver co st
T est suppo rt                          21         21         21      O n sc hedu le a nd w it hin co st
                                                         449
                            E stim ated to co m p lete:         765 = $812 K
                                                         442
S u m m ary: E ng ine ering w o rk is be hind sc hedu le a nd a co st o verrun is o ccurring




  Spring 2008,                            Time and Cost Control                                        26
  King Saud University                     Dr. Khalid Al-Gahtani

Time cost-control

  • 1.
    Updating Construction Schedules • Procedure: – Change the duration of all completed activities to zeros. – Identify all activities on which work is currently proceeding as live activities. – Put early start time of live activities equals the update time and their durations equal the remaining duration given by the update report. – Change durations of future activities as given in the update report. – Carry out network analysis in the normal way and prepare a new activity schedule. Spring 2008, Time and Cost Control 1 King Saud University Dr. Khalid Al-Gahtani
  • 2.
    Example Spring Time and Cost Control 2 2008, Dr. Khalid Al-Gahtani
  • 3.
    Example • The positionof the activities at the end of the fifth week is as follows: – Activities B, C, D and E have been completed. – Activity F is ready to start at beginning of week 6. – Remaining duration of activity H is 4 weeks. – Remaining duration of activity I is 3 weeks. – Activity G will not start until end of week 7. – Volume of work in activity L has been increased by 33% approximately. – Activity J has been omitted. – It is decided to shorten activity K by 2 weeks. • Construct the updated schedule indicating the critical path and showing new activities times. Spring 2008, Time and Cost Control 3 King Saud University Dr. Khalid Al-Gahtani
  • 4.
    Spring Time and Cost Control 4 2008, Dr. Khalid Al-Gahtani
  • 5.
    Work Breakdown Structure •WBS divides the project into recognizable systems (work packages, WP’s or Bid Packages) that responsible assignable work units, and for which accountability can be expected/assigned. P ro ject W o rk P ackages A ct ivit ies S equenc ing Spring Time and Cost Control 5 2008, Dr. Khalid Al-Gahtani
  • 6.
    Traditional A/E PDS O w ner A /E GC Su b1 Su b2 Su b3 Su b4 Spring 2008, Time and Cost Control 6 King Saud University Dr. Khalid Al-Gahtani
  • 7.
    Professional Construction Management O w ne r A /E CM W P1 W P2 W P3 W P4 W P4 Spring 2008, Time and Cost Control 7 King Saud University Dr. Khalid Al-Gahtani
  • 8.
    Developing WPs • Develop WBS – Identify WPs • Draw a WPs Network W P3 W P1 W P4 W P6 W P2 W P5 Spring Time and Cost Control 8 2008, Dr. Khalid Al-Gahtani
  • 9.
    Developing WPs • Each WP must have – One Performing Agency (PA) such as Subcontractor – One Responsible Agency (RA) such owner’s Project Engineers • Interconnection between Packages should be district and clear to facilitate coordination W P1 W P2 W P3 Spring Time and Cost Control 9 2008, Dr. Khalid Al-Gahtani
  • 10.
    Developing WPs • Bid a WP at the most short time so as to stimulate competition (Keep away uncertainty) W P1 W P2 W P3 W P4 Spring Time and Cost Control 10 2008, Dr. Khalid Al-Gahtani
  • 11.
    Cost Coding System •Cost Central level = Lowest level at which functional responsibility for individual WBS element exit. – XXX XXX XXX XXX • An example: – 0534.02220.21.A.00.cf34 Spring 2008, Time and Cost Control 11 King Saud University Dr. Khalid Al-Gahtani
  • 12.
    MASTERFORMAT system T AB L E 1 M a jo r D ivisio ns in the U nifo rm C o nstructio n Inde x 0 C o nd itio ns o f the co ntract 9 F inishes 1 G enera l requ ire m e nts 10 S pec ia lt ies 2 S ite w o rk 11 E quip m e nt 3 C o ncrete 12 Furnishing s 4 M aso nry 13 S pec ia l co nstructio n 5 M etals 14 C o nve ying syste m 6 W o o d and p last ic s 15 M echa nica l 7 T herm a l a nd m o isture prevent io n 16 E lectrica l 8 D oors and w indo w s Spring Time and Cost Control 12 2008, Dr. Khalid Al-Gahtani
  • 13.
    Cost Coding System •Advantages of coding systems are: – Provide a numbering system to replace verbal descriptions of items. – These codes reduce the length or complexity of the information to be recorded. – aids consistency in definitions and categories between projects and among the various parties involved in a project. – aid in the retrieval of historical records of cost, productivity and duration on particular activities. – electronic data storage and retrieval operations are much more efficient with standard coding systems. Spring 2008, Time and Cost Control 13 King Saud University Dr. Khalid Al-Gahtani
  • 14.
    Project Cost Control •Budgeted Cost of Work Scheduled (BCWS) is the budgeted amount of cost of the work scheduled to be accomplished in a given time period (including support and allocated overhead). • Budgeted Cost of Work Performed (BCWP) is the budgeted amount of cost for the work completed in a given time period, including support effort and allocated overhead. (This is sometimes referred to as “earned value of work accomplished”.) • Actual Cost of Work Performed (ACWP) is the amount reported as actually expended in completing the particular work accomplished within a given time period. Spring 2008, Time and Cost Control 14 King Saud University Dr. Khalid Al-Gahtani
  • 15.
    Type of performance BC W P BC W S ACW P Fast & L o w Spring 2008, Time and Cost Control 15 King Saud University Dr. Khalid Al-Gahtani BCWS
  • 16.
    Type of performance ACW P BC W P BC W S Fast & H ig h Spring 2008, Time and Cost Control 16 King Saud University Dr. Khalid Al-Gahtani
  • 17.
    Type of operformance Fast & L w BCWS BCW P AC W P S low & Low Spring Time and Cost Control 17 2008, Dr. Khalid Al-Gahtani
  • 18.
    TypeFast & performance of H ig h BCWS AC W P BCWP S low & H igh Spring Time and Cost Control 18 2008, Dr. Khalid Al-Gahtani
  • 19.
    Cost Index C ost V ariance = B C W P A C W P + ve U nder B udget C o st V ariance 0 W ithin B udget - ve O ver B udget C o st P erfo rm ance Index = B C W P /A C W P > 1 U nder B udget CPI = 1 W ithin B udget < 1 O ver B udget % co st o verrun/u nderrun ACW P BCWP = , BCWP Spring 2008, Time and Cost Control 19 King Saud University Dr. Khalid Al-Gahtani
  • 20.
    Schedule Index S chedule/P erfo rma nc e V aria nce =B C W P -B C W S . +ve A head S chedule S ch./per. V ariance 0 O n S chedule -ve B ehind S chedule S chedu le P erfo rma nce Inde x = B C W P / B C W S . >1 A head S chedule SPI =1 O n S chedule <1 B ehind S chedule Spring 2008, Time and Cost Control 20 King Saud University Dr. Khalid Al-Gahtani
  • 21.
    B udgeted Co st A t C o m pletio n (B A C ) Estimatedo fCost/Timenit price = T o tal Q uantities U At Completion P udgeted C e A t t o o pletio n (T A C C Blanned T imo st A CC mm pletio n (B A ) ) = T o tal o f Q uantities ÷ P lanned P ro ductivity uantities U nit price E lanned T imo st A CC mm pletio n (E A C ) P stim ated C e A t t o o pletio n (T A C ) = T oC Wo f oD ate A tal PT Q uantities ÷ P lanned P ro ductivity BAC = BAC = B C W PT oD ate C P I T oD ate E stim ated C o st A t C o m pletio n (E A C ) M ore accurate estim ate can be reach ed by using these form ulas: T o D ate VA C W P T im e ariance BAC T oD ate E stim ated=C o st A t Co m p let B A C = C ) io n (E A BB C W PoD ate C W PT C P I T oD ate T oD ate = 1 T im e T oD D ate (B A C - B C W PT o ate ) = V arianceate im T o D ate A CB C W S T oD atee W P T oD T C P I T hisPeriod ESpring ated T im eC W CooD ate letandn (EControl ) stim B A t PT m p io Cost T A C Time 21 2008, = 1 T im e Dr. Khalid Al-Gahtani T oD ate
  • 22.
    Spring Time and Cost Control 22 2008, Dr. Khalid Al-Gahtani
  • 23.
    Project Example Spring 2008, Time and Cost Control 23 King Saud University Dr. Khalid Al-Gahtani
  • 24.
    Project Example Spring Time and Cost Control 24 2008, Dr. Khalid Al-Gahtani
  • 25.
    Project Example E N G IN E E R IN G SU B T ASKS ST AT U S AT E N D O F M O N T H 3 (tho usands o f do llars) T ask Status BCW S BCW P ACW P System design C o mp leted $131.0 $131.0 $144.0 Subco ntract specs Started 132.0 82.0 84.0 M aterial tests C o mp leted 22.0 22.0 22.5 Specs review Started 22.0 15.0 15.5 D rafting Started 97.0 59.0 59.0 Fabricatio n/assembly suppo rt C o mp leted 29.0 29.0 36.0 Fabricatio n/assembly pro cess Started 100.0 63.0 67.0 T est suppo rt Started 21.0 21.0 21.0 E ngineering release and review N ot Started T otal $554.0 $422.0 $449.0 Spring 2008, Time and Cost Control 25 King Saud University Dr. Khalid Al-Gahtani
  • 26.
    Project Example Figure 5-9 S tatus sum m ary o f engineering subtasks in pro gress and estim ate to co m plete. T ask BCWS BCWP ACW P S tatus S ubco ntract specs $132 $82 $84 B e hind sc hedu le and o ver co st S pecs review 22 15 15.5 B e hind sc hedu le and o ver co st D ra fting 97 59 59 B e hind sc hedu le but w ithin co st Fa bricat io n/asse m b ly pro cess 100 63 67 B e hind sc hedu le and o ver co st T est suppo rt 21 21 21 O n sc hedu le a nd w it hin co st 449 E stim ated to co m p lete: 765 = $812 K 442 S u m m ary: E ng ine ering w o rk is be hind sc hedu le a nd a co st o verrun is o ccurring Spring 2008, Time and Cost Control 26 King Saud University Dr. Khalid Al-Gahtani