SlideShare a Scribd company logo
The (de)feasibility of
smart cities
Alexandre Monnin
Origens Medialab / ESC Clermont
MSc « Strategy & Design for the Anthropocene »
The example of
researchers
I ONCE ASKED MY FORMER
COLLEAGUES AT INRIA WHY
THEY WERE WORKING ON
SMART CITIES.
NO ONE COULD ANSWER
THAT QUESTION.
NO ONE KNEW WHOSE
DEMAND SUCH A RESEARCH
PROGRAM WAS
ANSWERING (IBM! CISCO!).
Solving
current issues
through
technology
(and data
management)
Sevareid’s law (1970):
« The chief source of problems is
solutions. »
• i.e., aiming to solve a problem
(making urban areas more
« resilient », the environmental
crisis, etc.) by aggravating it.
Have you
solved…?
the Jevon’s
paradox and the
rebound effect
(the problem with
optimization)
the issue of
decoupling growth
and
envrironmental
« impact » ?
the problem with
the so-called
dematerialization?
the issue with the
continuous growth
of the
environmental
impact of digital
technologies?
References
• Magee, Christopher L., et Tessaleno C. Devezas. « A Simple Extension of Dematerialization Theory:
Incorporation of Technical Progress and the Rebound Effect ». Technological Forecasting and Social
Change 117 (avril 2017): 196-205. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.techfore.2016.12.001.
• EEB - The European Environmental Bureau. « Decoupling Debunked – Evidence and Arguments against
Green Growth as a Sole Strategy for Sustainability ». Consulté le 6 août 2019.
https://eeb.org/library/decoupling-debunked/.
• Wiedenhofer, Dominik, Doris Virág, Gerald Kalt, Barbara Plank, Jan Streeck, Melanie Pichler, Andreas
Mayer, et al. « A Systematic Review of the Evidence on Decoupling of GDP, Resource Use and GHG
Emissions, Part I: Bibliometric and Conceptual Mapping ». Environmental Research Letters 15, no 6
(juin 2020): 063002. https://doi.org/10.1088/1748-9326/ab8429.
• Haberl, Helmut, Dominik Wiedenhofer, Doris Virág, Gerald Kalt, Barbara Plank, Paul Brockway, Tomer
Fishman, et al. « A Systematic Review of the Evidence on Decoupling of GDP, Resource Use and GHG
Emissions, Part II: Synthesizing the Insights ». Environmental Research Letters 15, no 6 (juin 2020):
065003. https://doi.org/10.1088/1748-9326/ab842a.
Smart cities are not disruptive solutions but (cybernetic) business as usual
"advocates of smartness (…) see
opportunities to decentralize agency
and intelligence by distributing it
among objects, networks, and life
forms.“
In Halpern, Orit, Robert Mitchell, et Bernard Dionysius
Geoghegan. « The Smartness Mandate: Notes toward a
Critique ». Grey Room 68 (septembre 2017): 106-29.
https://doi.org/10.1162/GREY_a_00221.
« to preach the corporate cosmology » (1976/2008)
With smart cities, this cosmology
extends to cities themselves, they
become firms, have competitors
and rely on the same
infrastructures as corporations do.
Why « solutions » won’t
work : adversarial trends
The problem with digital technologies is not an
accidental but an essential one :
- The rebound paradox won’t go away.
- « Zombie technologies » (José Halloy) will stay such.
- Decoupling is nigh on impossible.
About zombie
technologies
Monnin, Alexandre, José Halloy, et Nicolas Nova. « Au-
delà du low tech : technologies zombies, soutenabilité
et inventions. Interview croisée de José Halloy et
Nicolas Nova par Alexandre Monnin ». In Low tech :
face au tout-numérique, se réapproprier les
technologies, édité par Isabelle Attard, Emmanuel
Charles, Fergus, Alexandre Monnin, Laura Pigeon,
Edouard V. Piely, Amélie Polachowska, Caroline Weill,
et Mathieu Wostyn, 120-28. Passerelle 21. Paris:
ritimo, 2020.
Why « solutions » won’t
work?
• Environmental issues are not merely a
byproduct but an integral part of the model…
• … i.e., not a « negative externality » but a
necessity.
• Yet, smart cities (and techno-fixes in general)
fit well within the model of global
governance of climate issues.
• More and more parties are taking up climate
issues (cities, corporations, etc.)…
• … at their level, without tackling fundamental
issues of growth, the extraction and use of
fossil fuel, etc.
The Climatisation of the World, Stefan Aykut,
2020
“This model is based on so-called "end-of-pipe" measures, i.e. we will try to regulate outputs, and
therefore greenhouse gas emissions. International negotiations will therefore mainly concern the
distribution of the global effort to reduce emissions. On the other hand, we will not tackle the
question of inputs, i.e. the processes that determine the evolution of emissions, such as energy
production, industrial development models or the functioning of the world economy. Thirdly, this
approach has also fostered the isolation of climate governance on the international scene, by separating
it from a whole range of other international arenas and regimes. While the functioning of global energy
markets has been identified as one of the "root causes" of the problem, the regulation of these markets
is not one of the topics discussed in climate negotiations (Victor, 2011, 19). Other crucial issues are
absent from these talks: the regulation of world trade is dealt with within the World Trade Organization
or in bilateral negotiations; and the regulation of financial markets is negotiated in confidential arenas
such as the Basel Committee on Banking Supervision. These arenas do not take the climate issue into
account at all. And vice versa, climate institutions have little or no interest in trade or finance issues.
Quite the contrary, since "firewalls" have been established to prevent these regimes from interfering, as
noted by politician Elmar Altvater (2007, 37). By excluding these issues from climate governance,
important levers for influencing the emissions trajectory have been deprived.”
The problem
is not the
solution:
against the
pharmakon
• The late Bernard Stiegler and the
Internation collective wrote about smart
cities (Stiegler, Bernard, Collectif
Internation, Alain Supiot, & Jean-Marie Le
Clezio. Bifurquer: Il n’y a pas d’alternative.
Paris: Les Liens Qui Libèrent, 2020, chapter
2).
• Against technophobic trends they insisted
on the importance of technology, just as
Stiegler did for his entire life.
• But technology =/= technologies: one can oppose zombie
technologies (including smart cities) and yet refuse to embrace
a technophobic position.
 Technodiversity matters.
• The technical system is thought to be disrupting the social,
economical, legal, etc. systems. As if it was always in advance.
But this time, it’s not in advance but rather out of sync with
the current situation.
 IoT dates back from the 80s, smart cities appeared in 2005,
etc. and we know these perspectives do not fit well with the
Anthropocene/impending collapse/ecological
meltdown/looming extinction, etc.
The smart city is thus a good
example of what I call
« obsolete futures »
The consequences of the Anthropocene
• Raymond, Colin, Tom Matthews, et Radley M. Horton. « The Emergence of
Heat and Humidity Too Severe for Human Tolerance ». Science Advances 6, no
19 (mai 2020): eaaw1838. https://doi.org/10.1126/sciadv.aaw1838.
• Mora, Camilo, Bénédicte Dousset, Iain R. Caldwell, Farrah E. Powell, Rollan C.
Geronimo, Coral R. Bielecki, Chelsie W. W. Counsell, et al. « Global Risk of
Deadly Heat ». Nature Climate Change 7, no 7 (19 juin 2017): 501-6.
https://doi.org/10.1038/nclimate3322.
• Steffen, Will, Johan Rockström, Katherine Richardson, Timothy M. Lenton, Carl
Folke, Diana Liverman, Colin P. Summerhayes, et al. « Trajectories of the Earth
System in the Anthropocene ». Proceedings of the National Academy of
Sciences 115, no 33 (14 août 2018): 8252-59.
https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.1810141115.
Issues
Stiegler takes for granted
that smart cities will
happen.
01
No attention is given to
movements of resistance
and tactics deployed to shut
down some projects like
Quayside in Toronto.
02
From a strategic perspective,
no effort is dedicated to
synchronizing the scenario
of the smart city with what
we know about the
trajectory of the Earth-
system in the Anthropocene.
03
Smart cities as “negative commons”
“Negative commons refers to “resources”, material or immaterial, “negative” such as waste,
nuclear power plants, polluted soil or certain cultural legacies (the right of a colonizer, etc.). The
challenge is to take care of them collectively (commoning) if we cannot wipe out these realities. It
is therefore an extension of the classical theory of commons, particularly in relation to the
“positive” approach of the Commons Pool Resources proposed by Elinor Ostrom, sometimes
described as bucolic by Alexandre Monnin. The negative commons approach revolves around two
major axes a) giving a negative value to realities that are often considered positive - fossil energy
reserves, digital technologies, etc. - and b) giving a negative value to realities that are often
considered to be positive. b) the fact of building new institutions likely to allow collectives to
democratically reappropriate subjects that have escaped them until now, in particular co-existence
with negative commons, more or less at a distance (one can think of the recent measures taken by
mayors on the subject of pesticides, but also of the digital tomorrow, based on the same model).”
Monnin, Alexandre, et Lionel Maurel. « Glossaire · Politiques des communs ». In Politiques des communs, 2020.
https://politiquesdescommuns.cc/glossaire.
The Closing
Worlds
initiative
Two
directions
• Avoiding innovations to come to existence ;
• Dismantling existing technologies,
infrastructures, etc. unfit for the time to
come.
We are helping a City of 100 000+ inhabitants
to foreclose some of its infrastructures with
democratic “protocols of renunciation” that
call for broader transformations.
Looking at pressing issues for cities…
Food security Rising sea
levels
Extreme heat
Access to
water
Etc.
Smart cities?
• Smart cities (« metropoles »)
 get rid of the smart element
• Smart Cities
 how about cities in the Anthropocene?
There is an ongoing de-urbanizing movement because
cities might not fit well with what we know aout the
future? (see Faburel, Guillaume. Les Metropoles
Barbares - Poche - Demondialiser la Ville,
Desurbaniser la Terre. Le Passager Clandestin, 2019, )
• Meanwhile in France a Grenoble, once the place where smart city
was first implemented in France, is looking to ban 5G…
So… Smart Cities?
As jokes they
should be ridiculed.
As dystopias, they
should be seriously
fought.
As projects, we
should use them to
learn how to shut
down innovations.
As realities, we
should learn how to
inherit them as
ruins.
Thank you.

More Related Content

What's hot

M maa rrss 20130921 v2
M maa rrss 20130921 v2M maa rrss 20130921 v2
M maa rrss 20130921 v2
ISSIP
 
K tech santa clara 20131114 v1
K tech santa clara 20131114 v1K tech santa clara 20131114 v1
K tech santa clara 20131114 v1
ISSIP
 
Technology Power Point
Technology Power PointTechnology Power Point
Technology Power Point
Mitch Wheaton
 
Week 2.1 tumblr
Week 2.1 tumblrWeek 2.1 tumblr
Week 2.1 tumblr
caradaggett
 
Inspired Magazine
Inspired MagazineInspired Magazine
Inspired Magazine
Susan Middeleer Mleczko
 
Open Source in Distributed Manufacturing
Open Source in Distributed ManufacturingOpen Source in Distributed Manufacturing
Open Source in Distributed Manufacturing
Peter Troxler
 
Jaap Van Til's Presentation at Emerging Communication Conference & Awards 200...
Jaap Van Til's Presentation at Emerging Communication Conference & Awards 200...Jaap Van Til's Presentation at Emerging Communication Conference & Awards 200...
Jaap Van Til's Presentation at Emerging Communication Conference & Awards 200...
eCommConf
 
Technological advance in a democratic society
Technological advance in a democratic societyTechnological advance in a democratic society
Technological advance in a democratic society
Sarah Young
 
Some Future Significant Technologies by 2050 for EC KT 2050 Scenarios Group
Some Future Significant Technologies by 2050 for EC KT 2050 Scenarios GroupSome Future Significant Technologies by 2050 for EC KT 2050 Scenarios Group
Some Future Significant Technologies by 2050 for EC KT 2050 Scenarios Group
Jerome Glenn
 
KULeuven Engineering & Innovation (2016)
KULeuven Engineering & Innovation (2016)KULeuven Engineering & Innovation (2016)
KULeuven Engineering & Innovation (2016)
Catherine Van Holder
 
Sharing Economy Futures (2016)
Sharing Economy Futures (2016)Sharing Economy Futures (2016)
Sharing Economy Futures (2016)
Catherine Van Holder
 
Smartest Places on Earth presentation 4.6.16
Smartest Places on Earth presentation 4.6.16Smartest Places on Earth presentation 4.6.16
Smartest Places on Earth presentation 4.6.16
Brookings Metropolitan Policy Program
 
A tale from the future, by Eugenio Battaglia
A tale from the future, by Eugenio BattagliaA tale from the future, by Eugenio Battaglia
A tale from the future, by Eugenio Battaglia
bioflux
 
WWWW 2010 Conference - ICT4D 2.0
WWWW 2010 Conference - ICT4D 2.0 WWWW 2010 Conference - ICT4D 2.0
WWWW 2010 Conference - ICT4D 2.0
Craig Blewett
 
Embracing societal transformation 20111005 v1
Embracing societal transformation 20111005 v1Embracing societal transformation 20111005 v1
Embracing societal transformation 20111005 v1
ISSIP
 
UN Economic Commission on Latin America and the Caribbean 2014
UN Economic Commission on Latin America and the Caribbean 2014UN Economic Commission on Latin America and the Caribbean 2014
UN Economic Commission on Latin America and the Caribbean 2014
Jerome Glenn
 
Work/Technology 2050: Scenarios and Actions
Work/Technology 2050: Scenarios and ActionsWork/Technology 2050: Scenarios and Actions
Work/Technology 2050: Scenarios and Actions
Jerome Glenn
 
Work/Tech 2050 Global Scenarios
Work/Tech 2050 Global ScenariosWork/Tech 2050 Global Scenarios
Work/Tech 2050 Global Scenarios
Jerome Glenn
 
EFOW New Coptimism? Early Lessons from COP26.
 EFOW New Coptimism? Early Lessons from COP26. EFOW New Coptimism? Early Lessons from COP26.
EFOW New Coptimism? Early Lessons from COP26.
Energy for One World
 
Era of transition 2013 example slidedeck Tony Bosma
Era of transition 2013 example slidedeck Tony BosmaEra of transition 2013 example slidedeck Tony Bosma
Era of transition 2013 example slidedeck Tony Bosma
Tony Bosma
 

What's hot (20)

M maa rrss 20130921 v2
M maa rrss 20130921 v2M maa rrss 20130921 v2
M maa rrss 20130921 v2
 
K tech santa clara 20131114 v1
K tech santa clara 20131114 v1K tech santa clara 20131114 v1
K tech santa clara 20131114 v1
 
Technology Power Point
Technology Power PointTechnology Power Point
Technology Power Point
 
Week 2.1 tumblr
Week 2.1 tumblrWeek 2.1 tumblr
Week 2.1 tumblr
 
Inspired Magazine
Inspired MagazineInspired Magazine
Inspired Magazine
 
Open Source in Distributed Manufacturing
Open Source in Distributed ManufacturingOpen Source in Distributed Manufacturing
Open Source in Distributed Manufacturing
 
Jaap Van Til's Presentation at Emerging Communication Conference & Awards 200...
Jaap Van Til's Presentation at Emerging Communication Conference & Awards 200...Jaap Van Til's Presentation at Emerging Communication Conference & Awards 200...
Jaap Van Til's Presentation at Emerging Communication Conference & Awards 200...
 
Technological advance in a democratic society
Technological advance in a democratic societyTechnological advance in a democratic society
Technological advance in a democratic society
 
Some Future Significant Technologies by 2050 for EC KT 2050 Scenarios Group
Some Future Significant Technologies by 2050 for EC KT 2050 Scenarios GroupSome Future Significant Technologies by 2050 for EC KT 2050 Scenarios Group
Some Future Significant Technologies by 2050 for EC KT 2050 Scenarios Group
 
KULeuven Engineering & Innovation (2016)
KULeuven Engineering & Innovation (2016)KULeuven Engineering & Innovation (2016)
KULeuven Engineering & Innovation (2016)
 
Sharing Economy Futures (2016)
Sharing Economy Futures (2016)Sharing Economy Futures (2016)
Sharing Economy Futures (2016)
 
Smartest Places on Earth presentation 4.6.16
Smartest Places on Earth presentation 4.6.16Smartest Places on Earth presentation 4.6.16
Smartest Places on Earth presentation 4.6.16
 
A tale from the future, by Eugenio Battaglia
A tale from the future, by Eugenio BattagliaA tale from the future, by Eugenio Battaglia
A tale from the future, by Eugenio Battaglia
 
WWWW 2010 Conference - ICT4D 2.0
WWWW 2010 Conference - ICT4D 2.0 WWWW 2010 Conference - ICT4D 2.0
WWWW 2010 Conference - ICT4D 2.0
 
Embracing societal transformation 20111005 v1
Embracing societal transformation 20111005 v1Embracing societal transformation 20111005 v1
Embracing societal transformation 20111005 v1
 
UN Economic Commission on Latin America and the Caribbean 2014
UN Economic Commission on Latin America and the Caribbean 2014UN Economic Commission on Latin America and the Caribbean 2014
UN Economic Commission on Latin America and the Caribbean 2014
 
Work/Technology 2050: Scenarios and Actions
Work/Technology 2050: Scenarios and ActionsWork/Technology 2050: Scenarios and Actions
Work/Technology 2050: Scenarios and Actions
 
Work/Tech 2050 Global Scenarios
Work/Tech 2050 Global ScenariosWork/Tech 2050 Global Scenarios
Work/Tech 2050 Global Scenarios
 
EFOW New Coptimism? Early Lessons from COP26.
 EFOW New Coptimism? Early Lessons from COP26. EFOW New Coptimism? Early Lessons from COP26.
EFOW New Coptimism? Early Lessons from COP26.
 
Era of transition 2013 example slidedeck Tony Bosma
Era of transition 2013 example slidedeck Tony BosmaEra of transition 2013 example slidedeck Tony Bosma
Era of transition 2013 example slidedeck Tony Bosma
 

Similar to The (de)feasibility of smart cities

Coping with Global Evolutionary Crisis in 21st century through Social Innovat...
Coping with Global Evolutionary Crisis in 21st century through Social Innovat...Coping with Global Evolutionary Crisis in 21st century through Social Innovat...
Coping with Global Evolutionary Crisis in 21st century through Social Innovat...
Pavel Luksha
 
Green it
Green itGreen it
Green it
Yogita Negi
 
A more responsible taxation in a more sustainable world
A more responsible taxation in a more sustainable worldA more responsible taxation in a more sustainable world
A more responsible taxation in a more sustainable world
Alain Ducass
 
Disruptive Ideas: Public Intellectuals and their Arguments for Action on Clim...
Disruptive Ideas: Public Intellectuals and their Arguments for Action on Clim...Disruptive Ideas: Public Intellectuals and their Arguments for Action on Clim...
Disruptive Ideas: Public Intellectuals and their Arguments for Action on Clim...
Matthew Nisbet
 
University Antwerp Guest Lecture (2016)
University Antwerp Guest Lecture (2016)University Antwerp Guest Lecture (2016)
University Antwerp Guest Lecture (2016)
Catherine Van Holder
 
The Sustainable Future Eco Landmarks at GI2013 INSPIRE Forum
The Sustainable Future Eco Landmarks at GI2013 INSPIRE Forum The Sustainable Future Eco Landmarks at GI2013 INSPIRE Forum
The Sustainable Future Eco Landmarks at GI2013 INSPIRE Forum
ΜΗΤΙΣ Παγκόσμιο Δίκτυο Ευαισθητοποίησης
 
The Sustainable Future Eco Landmarks at GI2013 INSPIRE Forum
The Sustainable Future Eco Landmarks at GI2013 INSPIRE Forum The Sustainable Future Eco Landmarks at GI2013 INSPIRE Forum
The Sustainable Future Eco Landmarks at GI2013 INSPIRE Forum
ΜΗΤΙΣ Παγκόσμιο Δίκτυο Ευαισθητοποίησης
 
The Corporate Country - A possible view on the future of Capitalism
The Corporate Country  - A possible view on the future of CapitalismThe Corporate Country  - A possible view on the future of Capitalism
The Corporate Country - A possible view on the future of Capitalism
Lucio Musacchio
 
iCity-Magazine-Introduction
iCity-Magazine-IntroductioniCity-Magazine-Introduction
iCity-Magazine-Introduction
Tenfore Associates BV
 
Manifesto: Luc Soete
Manifesto: Luc SoeteManifesto: Luc Soete
Manifesto: Luc Soete
STEPS Centre
 
Environmental ethics
Environmental ethicsEnvironmental ethics
Environmental ethics
AtiqurRehman129
 
Smart Cities
Smart CitiesSmart Cities
Smart Cities
Douglas Hinkel
 
Securityand policing2015(2.05)
Securityand policing2015(2.05)Securityand policing2015(2.05)
Securityand policing2015(2.05)
guest7227c5
 
Good Tech Lab 2018 Program Overview
Good Tech Lab 2018 Program OverviewGood Tech Lab 2018 Program Overview
Good Tech Lab 2018 Program Overview
Good Tech Lab
 
Stakeholder Identification and Mapping in highly contested megaprojects
Stakeholder Identification and Mapping in highly contested megaprojectsStakeholder Identification and Mapping in highly contested megaprojects
Stakeholder Identification and Mapping in highly contested megaprojects
Dario Cottafava
 
SCIENCE TECHNOLOGY AND SOCIETY MODULE 1
SCIENCE TECHNOLOGY AND SOCIETY MODULE 1SCIENCE TECHNOLOGY AND SOCIETY MODULE 1
SCIENCE TECHNOLOGY AND SOCIETY MODULE 1
PsalmGGeraldino
 
Week2 (STSP)
Week2 (STSP)Week2 (STSP)
Week2 (STSP)
University of York
 
The Fourth Industrial Revolution
The Fourth Industrial RevolutionThe Fourth Industrial Revolution
The Fourth Industrial Revolution
Luca Lamera
 
Future Outlook on Urban Competitiveness
Future Outlook on Urban CompetitivenessFuture Outlook on Urban Competitiveness
Future Outlook on Urban Competitiveness
Wendy Schultz
 
Megatrends 2016 by Sitra
Megatrends 2016 by SitraMegatrends 2016 by Sitra
Megatrends 2016 by Sitra
Sitra the Finnish Innovation Fund
 

Similar to The (de)feasibility of smart cities (20)

Coping with Global Evolutionary Crisis in 21st century through Social Innovat...
Coping with Global Evolutionary Crisis in 21st century through Social Innovat...Coping with Global Evolutionary Crisis in 21st century through Social Innovat...
Coping with Global Evolutionary Crisis in 21st century through Social Innovat...
 
Green it
Green itGreen it
Green it
 
A more responsible taxation in a more sustainable world
A more responsible taxation in a more sustainable worldA more responsible taxation in a more sustainable world
A more responsible taxation in a more sustainable world
 
Disruptive Ideas: Public Intellectuals and their Arguments for Action on Clim...
Disruptive Ideas: Public Intellectuals and their Arguments for Action on Clim...Disruptive Ideas: Public Intellectuals and their Arguments for Action on Clim...
Disruptive Ideas: Public Intellectuals and their Arguments for Action on Clim...
 
University Antwerp Guest Lecture (2016)
University Antwerp Guest Lecture (2016)University Antwerp Guest Lecture (2016)
University Antwerp Guest Lecture (2016)
 
The Sustainable Future Eco Landmarks at GI2013 INSPIRE Forum
The Sustainable Future Eco Landmarks at GI2013 INSPIRE Forum The Sustainable Future Eco Landmarks at GI2013 INSPIRE Forum
The Sustainable Future Eco Landmarks at GI2013 INSPIRE Forum
 
The Sustainable Future Eco Landmarks at GI2013 INSPIRE Forum
The Sustainable Future Eco Landmarks at GI2013 INSPIRE Forum The Sustainable Future Eco Landmarks at GI2013 INSPIRE Forum
The Sustainable Future Eco Landmarks at GI2013 INSPIRE Forum
 
The Corporate Country - A possible view on the future of Capitalism
The Corporate Country  - A possible view on the future of CapitalismThe Corporate Country  - A possible view on the future of Capitalism
The Corporate Country - A possible view on the future of Capitalism
 
iCity-Magazine-Introduction
iCity-Magazine-IntroductioniCity-Magazine-Introduction
iCity-Magazine-Introduction
 
Manifesto: Luc Soete
Manifesto: Luc SoeteManifesto: Luc Soete
Manifesto: Luc Soete
 
Environmental ethics
Environmental ethicsEnvironmental ethics
Environmental ethics
 
Smart Cities
Smart CitiesSmart Cities
Smart Cities
 
Securityand policing2015(2.05)
Securityand policing2015(2.05)Securityand policing2015(2.05)
Securityand policing2015(2.05)
 
Good Tech Lab 2018 Program Overview
Good Tech Lab 2018 Program OverviewGood Tech Lab 2018 Program Overview
Good Tech Lab 2018 Program Overview
 
Stakeholder Identification and Mapping in highly contested megaprojects
Stakeholder Identification and Mapping in highly contested megaprojectsStakeholder Identification and Mapping in highly contested megaprojects
Stakeholder Identification and Mapping in highly contested megaprojects
 
SCIENCE TECHNOLOGY AND SOCIETY MODULE 1
SCIENCE TECHNOLOGY AND SOCIETY MODULE 1SCIENCE TECHNOLOGY AND SOCIETY MODULE 1
SCIENCE TECHNOLOGY AND SOCIETY MODULE 1
 
Week2 (STSP)
Week2 (STSP)Week2 (STSP)
Week2 (STSP)
 
The Fourth Industrial Revolution
The Fourth Industrial RevolutionThe Fourth Industrial Revolution
The Fourth Industrial Revolution
 
Future Outlook on Urban Competitiveness
Future Outlook on Urban CompetitivenessFuture Outlook on Urban Competitiveness
Future Outlook on Urban Competitiveness
 
Megatrends 2016 by Sitra
Megatrends 2016 by SitraMegatrends 2016 by Sitra
Megatrends 2016 by Sitra
 

More from Alexandre Monnin

La 5G comme "commun négatif"
La 5G comme "commun négatif"La 5G comme "commun négatif"
La 5G comme "commun négatif"
Alexandre Monnin
 
Quel avenir pour le numérique
Quel avenir pour le numériqueQuel avenir pour le numérique
Quel avenir pour le numérique
Alexandre Monnin
 
The Future Web (we can afford)
The Future Web (we can afford)The Future Web (we can afford)
The Future Web (we can afford)
Alexandre Monnin
 
Quel rôle pour le design à l'heure de l'Anthropocène/Effondrement ?
Quel rôle pour le design à l'heure de l'Anthropocène/Effondrement ?Quel rôle pour le design à l'heure de l'Anthropocène/Effondrement ?
Quel rôle pour le design à l'heure de l'Anthropocène/Effondrement ?
Alexandre Monnin
 
L'obsolescence à programmer
L'obsolescence à programmer L'obsolescence à programmer
L'obsolescence à programmer
Alexandre Monnin
 
Approcher en pragmatiste les mondes en train de se défaire
Approcher en pragmatiste les mondes en train de se défaireApprocher en pragmatiste les mondes en train de se défaire
Approcher en pragmatiste les mondes en train de se défaire
Alexandre Monnin
 
​Le numérique est notre futur mais quel est notre avenir ? (R)évolution num...
​Le numérique est notre futur  mais quel est notre avenir ?  (R)évolution num...​Le numérique est notre futur  mais quel est notre avenir ?  (R)évolution num...
​Le numérique est notre futur mais quel est notre avenir ? (R)évolution num...
Alexandre Monnin
 
Cours sur REST
Cours sur RESTCours sur REST
Cours sur REST
Alexandre Monnin
 
Quel avenir pour le Web et le numérique à l’heure de l’Anthropocène ?
Quel avenir pour le Web et le numérique à  l’heure de l’Anthropocène ? Quel avenir pour le Web et le numérique à  l’heure de l’Anthropocène ?
Quel avenir pour le Web et le numérique à l’heure de l’Anthropocène ?
Alexandre Monnin
 
Présentation du projet ValueModels (Académie 1 de l'Idex UCA JEDI)
Présentation du projet ValueModels (Académie 1 de l'Idex UCA JEDI)Présentation du projet ValueModels (Académie 1 de l'Idex UCA JEDI)
Présentation du projet ValueModels (Académie 1 de l'Idex UCA JEDI)
Alexandre Monnin
 
La question de la durabilité des technologies de calcul et de télécommunication
La question de la durabilité des technologies de calcul et de télécommunicationLa question de la durabilité des technologies de calcul et de télécommunication
La question de la durabilité des technologies de calcul et de télécommunication
Alexandre Monnin
 
Le monde devient numérique, a-t-il les moyens de le rester ?
Le monde devient numérique, a-t-il les moyens de le rester ?Le monde devient numérique, a-t-il les moyens de le rester ?
Le monde devient numérique, a-t-il les moyens de le rester ?
Alexandre Monnin
 
A quoi peuvent servir les technologies « smart » en regard d’une vision réa...
A quoi peuvent servir les  technologies « smart » en regard  d’une vision réa...A quoi peuvent servir les  technologies « smart » en regard  d’une vision réa...
A quoi peuvent servir les technologies « smart » en regard d’une vision réa...
Alexandre Monnin
 
Transition numérique et effondrement écologique : quel monde d'après ?
Transition numérique et effondrement écologique : quel monde d'après ?Transition numérique et effondrement écologique : quel monde d'après ?
Transition numérique et effondrement écologique : quel monde d'après ?
Alexandre Monnin
 
Façonner les données. Travail et valeur de l'information
Façonner les données. Travail et valeur de l'informationFaçonner les données. Travail et valeur de l'information
Façonner les données. Travail et valeur de l'information
Alexandre Monnin
 
Routines et improvisation, à propos de Computation and Human Experience de Ph...
Routines et improvisation, à propos de Computation and Human Experience de Ph...Routines et improvisation, à propos de Computation and Human Experience de Ph...
Routines et improvisation, à propos de Computation and Human Experience de Ph...
Alexandre Monnin
 
The Knowledge ecology: Epistemic Credit and the Technologically Extended Mind
The Knowledge ecology: Epistemic Credit and the Technologically Extended MindThe Knowledge ecology: Epistemic Credit and the Technologically Extended Mind
The Knowledge ecology: Epistemic Credit and the Technologically Extended Mind
Alexandre Monnin
 
Thinking with your body and other things
Thinking with your body and other thingsThinking with your body and other things
Thinking with your body and other things
Alexandre Monnin
 
Internet et le Web : de nouveaux espaces à cartographier ?
Internet et le Web : de nouveaux espaces à cartographier ? Internet et le Web : de nouveaux espaces à cartographier ?
Internet et le Web : de nouveaux espaces à cartographier ?
Alexandre Monnin
 
Artefacts numériques et matérialités
Artefacts numériques et matérialitésArtefacts numériques et matérialités
Artefacts numériques et matérialités
Alexandre Monnin
 

More from Alexandre Monnin (20)

La 5G comme "commun négatif"
La 5G comme "commun négatif"La 5G comme "commun négatif"
La 5G comme "commun négatif"
 
Quel avenir pour le numérique
Quel avenir pour le numériqueQuel avenir pour le numérique
Quel avenir pour le numérique
 
The Future Web (we can afford)
The Future Web (we can afford)The Future Web (we can afford)
The Future Web (we can afford)
 
Quel rôle pour le design à l'heure de l'Anthropocène/Effondrement ?
Quel rôle pour le design à l'heure de l'Anthropocène/Effondrement ?Quel rôle pour le design à l'heure de l'Anthropocène/Effondrement ?
Quel rôle pour le design à l'heure de l'Anthropocène/Effondrement ?
 
L'obsolescence à programmer
L'obsolescence à programmer L'obsolescence à programmer
L'obsolescence à programmer
 
Approcher en pragmatiste les mondes en train de se défaire
Approcher en pragmatiste les mondes en train de se défaireApprocher en pragmatiste les mondes en train de se défaire
Approcher en pragmatiste les mondes en train de se défaire
 
​Le numérique est notre futur mais quel est notre avenir ? (R)évolution num...
​Le numérique est notre futur  mais quel est notre avenir ?  (R)évolution num...​Le numérique est notre futur  mais quel est notre avenir ?  (R)évolution num...
​Le numérique est notre futur mais quel est notre avenir ? (R)évolution num...
 
Cours sur REST
Cours sur RESTCours sur REST
Cours sur REST
 
Quel avenir pour le Web et le numérique à l’heure de l’Anthropocène ?
Quel avenir pour le Web et le numérique à  l’heure de l’Anthropocène ? Quel avenir pour le Web et le numérique à  l’heure de l’Anthropocène ?
Quel avenir pour le Web et le numérique à l’heure de l’Anthropocène ?
 
Présentation du projet ValueModels (Académie 1 de l'Idex UCA JEDI)
Présentation du projet ValueModels (Académie 1 de l'Idex UCA JEDI)Présentation du projet ValueModels (Académie 1 de l'Idex UCA JEDI)
Présentation du projet ValueModels (Académie 1 de l'Idex UCA JEDI)
 
La question de la durabilité des technologies de calcul et de télécommunication
La question de la durabilité des technologies de calcul et de télécommunicationLa question de la durabilité des technologies de calcul et de télécommunication
La question de la durabilité des technologies de calcul et de télécommunication
 
Le monde devient numérique, a-t-il les moyens de le rester ?
Le monde devient numérique, a-t-il les moyens de le rester ?Le monde devient numérique, a-t-il les moyens de le rester ?
Le monde devient numérique, a-t-il les moyens de le rester ?
 
A quoi peuvent servir les technologies « smart » en regard d’une vision réa...
A quoi peuvent servir les  technologies « smart » en regard  d’une vision réa...A quoi peuvent servir les  technologies « smart » en regard  d’une vision réa...
A quoi peuvent servir les technologies « smart » en regard d’une vision réa...
 
Transition numérique et effondrement écologique : quel monde d'après ?
Transition numérique et effondrement écologique : quel monde d'après ?Transition numérique et effondrement écologique : quel monde d'après ?
Transition numérique et effondrement écologique : quel monde d'après ?
 
Façonner les données. Travail et valeur de l'information
Façonner les données. Travail et valeur de l'informationFaçonner les données. Travail et valeur de l'information
Façonner les données. Travail et valeur de l'information
 
Routines et improvisation, à propos de Computation and Human Experience de Ph...
Routines et improvisation, à propos de Computation and Human Experience de Ph...Routines et improvisation, à propos de Computation and Human Experience de Ph...
Routines et improvisation, à propos de Computation and Human Experience de Ph...
 
The Knowledge ecology: Epistemic Credit and the Technologically Extended Mind
The Knowledge ecology: Epistemic Credit and the Technologically Extended MindThe Knowledge ecology: Epistemic Credit and the Technologically Extended Mind
The Knowledge ecology: Epistemic Credit and the Technologically Extended Mind
 
Thinking with your body and other things
Thinking with your body and other thingsThinking with your body and other things
Thinking with your body and other things
 
Internet et le Web : de nouveaux espaces à cartographier ?
Internet et le Web : de nouveaux espaces à cartographier ? Internet et le Web : de nouveaux espaces à cartographier ?
Internet et le Web : de nouveaux espaces à cartographier ?
 
Artefacts numériques et matérialités
Artefacts numériques et matérialitésArtefacts numériques et matérialités
Artefacts numériques et matérialités
 

Recently uploaded

Girls call Kolkata 👀 XXXXXXXXXXX 👀 Rs.9.5 K Cash Payment With Room Delivery
Girls call Kolkata 👀 XXXXXXXXXXX 👀 Rs.9.5 K Cash Payment With Room Delivery Girls call Kolkata 👀 XXXXXXXXXXX 👀 Rs.9.5 K Cash Payment With Room Delivery
Girls call Kolkata 👀 XXXXXXXXXXX 👀 Rs.9.5 K Cash Payment With Room Delivery
sunilverma7884
 
Data Integration Basics: Merging & Joining Data
Data Integration Basics: Merging & Joining DataData Integration Basics: Merging & Joining Data
Data Integration Basics: Merging & Joining Data
Safe Software
 
The importance of Quality Assurance for ICT Standardization
The importance of Quality Assurance for ICT StandardizationThe importance of Quality Assurance for ICT Standardization
The importance of Quality Assurance for ICT Standardization
Axel Rennoch
 
Feature sql server terbaru performance.pptx
Feature sql server terbaru performance.pptxFeature sql server terbaru performance.pptx
Feature sql server terbaru performance.pptx
ssuser1915fe1
 
Girls Call Churchgate 9910780858 Provide Best And Top Girl Service And No1 in...
Girls Call Churchgate 9910780858 Provide Best And Top Girl Service And No1 in...Girls Call Churchgate 9910780858 Provide Best And Top Girl Service And No1 in...
Girls Call Churchgate 9910780858 Provide Best And Top Girl Service And No1 in...
maigasapphire
 
BLOCKCHAIN TECHNOLOGY - Advantages and Disadvantages
BLOCKCHAIN TECHNOLOGY - Advantages and DisadvantagesBLOCKCHAIN TECHNOLOGY - Advantages and Disadvantages
BLOCKCHAIN TECHNOLOGY - Advantages and Disadvantages
SAI KAILASH R
 
Dublin_mulesoft_meetup_Mulesoft_Salesforce_Integration (1).pptx
Dublin_mulesoft_meetup_Mulesoft_Salesforce_Integration (1).pptxDublin_mulesoft_meetup_Mulesoft_Salesforce_Integration (1).pptx
Dublin_mulesoft_meetup_Mulesoft_Salesforce_Integration (1).pptx
Kunal Gupta
 
RPA In Healthcare Benefits, Use Case, Trend And Challenges 2024.pptx
RPA In Healthcare Benefits, Use Case, Trend And Challenges 2024.pptxRPA In Healthcare Benefits, Use Case, Trend And Challenges 2024.pptx
RPA In Healthcare Benefits, Use Case, Trend And Challenges 2024.pptx
SynapseIndia
 
Opencast Summit 2024 — Opencast @ University of Münster
Opencast Summit 2024 — Opencast @ University of MünsterOpencast Summit 2024 — Opencast @ University of Münster
Opencast Summit 2024 — Opencast @ University of Münster
Matthias Neugebauer
 
"Mastering Graphic Design: Essential Tips and Tricks for Beginners and Profes...
"Mastering Graphic Design: Essential Tips and Tricks for Beginners and Profes..."Mastering Graphic Design: Essential Tips and Tricks for Beginners and Profes...
"Mastering Graphic Design: Essential Tips and Tricks for Beginners and Profes...
Anant Gupta
 
Recent Advancements in the NIST-JARVIS Infrastructure
Recent Advancements in the NIST-JARVIS InfrastructureRecent Advancements in the NIST-JARVIS Infrastructure
Recent Advancements in the NIST-JARVIS Infrastructure
KAMAL CHOUDHARY
 
High Profile Girls call Service Pune 000XX00000 Provide Best And Top Girl Ser...
High Profile Girls call Service Pune 000XX00000 Provide Best And Top Girl Ser...High Profile Girls call Service Pune 000XX00000 Provide Best And Top Girl Ser...
High Profile Girls call Service Pune 000XX00000 Provide Best And Top Girl Ser...
bhumivarma35300
 
Three New Criminal Laws in India 1 July 2024
Three New Criminal Laws in India 1 July 2024Three New Criminal Laws in India 1 July 2024
Three New Criminal Laws in India 1 July 2024
aakash malhotra
 
leewayhertz.com-AI agents for healthcare Applications benefits and implementa...
leewayhertz.com-AI agents for healthcare Applications benefits and implementa...leewayhertz.com-AI agents for healthcare Applications benefits and implementa...
leewayhertz.com-AI agents for healthcare Applications benefits and implementa...
alexjohnson7307
 
CiscoIconsLibrary cours de réseau VLAN.ppt
CiscoIconsLibrary cours de réseau VLAN.pptCiscoIconsLibrary cours de réseau VLAN.ppt
CiscoIconsLibrary cours de réseau VLAN.ppt
moinahousna
 
Types of Weaving loom machine & it's technology
Types of Weaving loom machine & it's technologyTypes of Weaving loom machine & it's technology
Types of Weaving loom machine & it's technology
ldtexsolbl
 
“Deploying Large Language Models on a Raspberry Pi,” a Presentation from Usef...
“Deploying Large Language Models on a Raspberry Pi,” a Presentation from Usef...“Deploying Large Language Models on a Raspberry Pi,” a Presentation from Usef...
“Deploying Large Language Models on a Raspberry Pi,” a Presentation from Usef...
Edge AI and Vision Alliance
 
EuroPython 2024 - Streamlining Testing in a Large Python Codebase
EuroPython 2024 - Streamlining Testing in a Large Python CodebaseEuroPython 2024 - Streamlining Testing in a Large Python Codebase
EuroPython 2024 - Streamlining Testing in a Large Python Codebase
Jimmy Lai
 
find out more about the role of autonomous vehicles in facing global challenges
find out more about the role of autonomous vehicles in facing global challengesfind out more about the role of autonomous vehicles in facing global challenges
find out more about the role of autonomous vehicles in facing global challenges
huseindihon
 
Best Practices for Effectively Running dbt in Airflow.pdf
Best Practices for Effectively Running dbt in Airflow.pdfBest Practices for Effectively Running dbt in Airflow.pdf
Best Practices for Effectively Running dbt in Airflow.pdf
Tatiana Al-Chueyr
 

Recently uploaded (20)

Girls call Kolkata 👀 XXXXXXXXXXX 👀 Rs.9.5 K Cash Payment With Room Delivery
Girls call Kolkata 👀 XXXXXXXXXXX 👀 Rs.9.5 K Cash Payment With Room Delivery Girls call Kolkata 👀 XXXXXXXXXXX 👀 Rs.9.5 K Cash Payment With Room Delivery
Girls call Kolkata 👀 XXXXXXXXXXX 👀 Rs.9.5 K Cash Payment With Room Delivery
 
Data Integration Basics: Merging & Joining Data
Data Integration Basics: Merging & Joining DataData Integration Basics: Merging & Joining Data
Data Integration Basics: Merging & Joining Data
 
The importance of Quality Assurance for ICT Standardization
The importance of Quality Assurance for ICT StandardizationThe importance of Quality Assurance for ICT Standardization
The importance of Quality Assurance for ICT Standardization
 
Feature sql server terbaru performance.pptx
Feature sql server terbaru performance.pptxFeature sql server terbaru performance.pptx
Feature sql server terbaru performance.pptx
 
Girls Call Churchgate 9910780858 Provide Best And Top Girl Service And No1 in...
Girls Call Churchgate 9910780858 Provide Best And Top Girl Service And No1 in...Girls Call Churchgate 9910780858 Provide Best And Top Girl Service And No1 in...
Girls Call Churchgate 9910780858 Provide Best And Top Girl Service And No1 in...
 
BLOCKCHAIN TECHNOLOGY - Advantages and Disadvantages
BLOCKCHAIN TECHNOLOGY - Advantages and DisadvantagesBLOCKCHAIN TECHNOLOGY - Advantages and Disadvantages
BLOCKCHAIN TECHNOLOGY - Advantages and Disadvantages
 
Dublin_mulesoft_meetup_Mulesoft_Salesforce_Integration (1).pptx
Dublin_mulesoft_meetup_Mulesoft_Salesforce_Integration (1).pptxDublin_mulesoft_meetup_Mulesoft_Salesforce_Integration (1).pptx
Dublin_mulesoft_meetup_Mulesoft_Salesforce_Integration (1).pptx
 
RPA In Healthcare Benefits, Use Case, Trend And Challenges 2024.pptx
RPA In Healthcare Benefits, Use Case, Trend And Challenges 2024.pptxRPA In Healthcare Benefits, Use Case, Trend And Challenges 2024.pptx
RPA In Healthcare Benefits, Use Case, Trend And Challenges 2024.pptx
 
Opencast Summit 2024 — Opencast @ University of Münster
Opencast Summit 2024 — Opencast @ University of MünsterOpencast Summit 2024 — Opencast @ University of Münster
Opencast Summit 2024 — Opencast @ University of Münster
 
"Mastering Graphic Design: Essential Tips and Tricks for Beginners and Profes...
"Mastering Graphic Design: Essential Tips and Tricks for Beginners and Profes..."Mastering Graphic Design: Essential Tips and Tricks for Beginners and Profes...
"Mastering Graphic Design: Essential Tips and Tricks for Beginners and Profes...
 
Recent Advancements in the NIST-JARVIS Infrastructure
Recent Advancements in the NIST-JARVIS InfrastructureRecent Advancements in the NIST-JARVIS Infrastructure
Recent Advancements in the NIST-JARVIS Infrastructure
 
High Profile Girls call Service Pune 000XX00000 Provide Best And Top Girl Ser...
High Profile Girls call Service Pune 000XX00000 Provide Best And Top Girl Ser...High Profile Girls call Service Pune 000XX00000 Provide Best And Top Girl Ser...
High Profile Girls call Service Pune 000XX00000 Provide Best And Top Girl Ser...
 
Three New Criminal Laws in India 1 July 2024
Three New Criminal Laws in India 1 July 2024Three New Criminal Laws in India 1 July 2024
Three New Criminal Laws in India 1 July 2024
 
leewayhertz.com-AI agents for healthcare Applications benefits and implementa...
leewayhertz.com-AI agents for healthcare Applications benefits and implementa...leewayhertz.com-AI agents for healthcare Applications benefits and implementa...
leewayhertz.com-AI agents for healthcare Applications benefits and implementa...
 
CiscoIconsLibrary cours de réseau VLAN.ppt
CiscoIconsLibrary cours de réseau VLAN.pptCiscoIconsLibrary cours de réseau VLAN.ppt
CiscoIconsLibrary cours de réseau VLAN.ppt
 
Types of Weaving loom machine & it's technology
Types of Weaving loom machine & it's technologyTypes of Weaving loom machine & it's technology
Types of Weaving loom machine & it's technology
 
“Deploying Large Language Models on a Raspberry Pi,” a Presentation from Usef...
“Deploying Large Language Models on a Raspberry Pi,” a Presentation from Usef...“Deploying Large Language Models on a Raspberry Pi,” a Presentation from Usef...
“Deploying Large Language Models on a Raspberry Pi,” a Presentation from Usef...
 
EuroPython 2024 - Streamlining Testing in a Large Python Codebase
EuroPython 2024 - Streamlining Testing in a Large Python CodebaseEuroPython 2024 - Streamlining Testing in a Large Python Codebase
EuroPython 2024 - Streamlining Testing in a Large Python Codebase
 
find out more about the role of autonomous vehicles in facing global challenges
find out more about the role of autonomous vehicles in facing global challengesfind out more about the role of autonomous vehicles in facing global challenges
find out more about the role of autonomous vehicles in facing global challenges
 
Best Practices for Effectively Running dbt in Airflow.pdf
Best Practices for Effectively Running dbt in Airflow.pdfBest Practices for Effectively Running dbt in Airflow.pdf
Best Practices for Effectively Running dbt in Airflow.pdf
 

The (de)feasibility of smart cities

  • 1. The (de)feasibility of smart cities Alexandre Monnin Origens Medialab / ESC Clermont MSc « Strategy & Design for the Anthropocene »
  • 2. The example of researchers I ONCE ASKED MY FORMER COLLEAGUES AT INRIA WHY THEY WERE WORKING ON SMART CITIES. NO ONE COULD ANSWER THAT QUESTION. NO ONE KNEW WHOSE DEMAND SUCH A RESEARCH PROGRAM WAS ANSWERING (IBM! CISCO!).
  • 3. Solving current issues through technology (and data management) Sevareid’s law (1970): « The chief source of problems is solutions. » • i.e., aiming to solve a problem (making urban areas more « resilient », the environmental crisis, etc.) by aggravating it.
  • 4. Have you solved…? the Jevon’s paradox and the rebound effect (the problem with optimization) the issue of decoupling growth and envrironmental « impact » ? the problem with the so-called dematerialization? the issue with the continuous growth of the environmental impact of digital technologies?
  • 5. References • Magee, Christopher L., et Tessaleno C. Devezas. « A Simple Extension of Dematerialization Theory: Incorporation of Technical Progress and the Rebound Effect ». Technological Forecasting and Social Change 117 (avril 2017): 196-205. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.techfore.2016.12.001. • EEB - The European Environmental Bureau. « Decoupling Debunked – Evidence and Arguments against Green Growth as a Sole Strategy for Sustainability ». Consulté le 6 août 2019. https://eeb.org/library/decoupling-debunked/. • Wiedenhofer, Dominik, Doris Virág, Gerald Kalt, Barbara Plank, Jan Streeck, Melanie Pichler, Andreas Mayer, et al. « A Systematic Review of the Evidence on Decoupling of GDP, Resource Use and GHG Emissions, Part I: Bibliometric and Conceptual Mapping ». Environmental Research Letters 15, no 6 (juin 2020): 063002. https://doi.org/10.1088/1748-9326/ab8429. • Haberl, Helmut, Dominik Wiedenhofer, Doris Virág, Gerald Kalt, Barbara Plank, Paul Brockway, Tomer Fishman, et al. « A Systematic Review of the Evidence on Decoupling of GDP, Resource Use and GHG Emissions, Part II: Synthesizing the Insights ». Environmental Research Letters 15, no 6 (juin 2020): 065003. https://doi.org/10.1088/1748-9326/ab842a.
  • 6. Smart cities are not disruptive solutions but (cybernetic) business as usual
  • 7. "advocates of smartness (…) see opportunities to decentralize agency and intelligence by distributing it among objects, networks, and life forms.“ In Halpern, Orit, Robert Mitchell, et Bernard Dionysius Geoghegan. « The Smartness Mandate: Notes toward a Critique ». Grey Room 68 (septembre 2017): 106-29. https://doi.org/10.1162/GREY_a_00221.
  • 8. « to preach the corporate cosmology » (1976/2008)
  • 9. With smart cities, this cosmology extends to cities themselves, they become firms, have competitors and rely on the same infrastructures as corporations do.
  • 10. Why « solutions » won’t work : adversarial trends The problem with digital technologies is not an accidental but an essential one : - The rebound paradox won’t go away. - « Zombie technologies » (José Halloy) will stay such. - Decoupling is nigh on impossible.
  • 11. About zombie technologies Monnin, Alexandre, José Halloy, et Nicolas Nova. « Au- delà du low tech : technologies zombies, soutenabilité et inventions. Interview croisée de José Halloy et Nicolas Nova par Alexandre Monnin ». In Low tech : face au tout-numérique, se réapproprier les technologies, édité par Isabelle Attard, Emmanuel Charles, Fergus, Alexandre Monnin, Laura Pigeon, Edouard V. Piely, Amélie Polachowska, Caroline Weill, et Mathieu Wostyn, 120-28. Passerelle 21. Paris: ritimo, 2020.
  • 12. Why « solutions » won’t work? • Environmental issues are not merely a byproduct but an integral part of the model… • … i.e., not a « negative externality » but a necessity. • Yet, smart cities (and techno-fixes in general) fit well within the model of global governance of climate issues. • More and more parties are taking up climate issues (cities, corporations, etc.)… • … at their level, without tackling fundamental issues of growth, the extraction and use of fossil fuel, etc.
  • 13. The Climatisation of the World, Stefan Aykut, 2020 “This model is based on so-called "end-of-pipe" measures, i.e. we will try to regulate outputs, and therefore greenhouse gas emissions. International negotiations will therefore mainly concern the distribution of the global effort to reduce emissions. On the other hand, we will not tackle the question of inputs, i.e. the processes that determine the evolution of emissions, such as energy production, industrial development models or the functioning of the world economy. Thirdly, this approach has also fostered the isolation of climate governance on the international scene, by separating it from a whole range of other international arenas and regimes. While the functioning of global energy markets has been identified as one of the "root causes" of the problem, the regulation of these markets is not one of the topics discussed in climate negotiations (Victor, 2011, 19). Other crucial issues are absent from these talks: the regulation of world trade is dealt with within the World Trade Organization or in bilateral negotiations; and the regulation of financial markets is negotiated in confidential arenas such as the Basel Committee on Banking Supervision. These arenas do not take the climate issue into account at all. And vice versa, climate institutions have little or no interest in trade or finance issues. Quite the contrary, since "firewalls" have been established to prevent these regimes from interfering, as noted by politician Elmar Altvater (2007, 37). By excluding these issues from climate governance, important levers for influencing the emissions trajectory have been deprived.”
  • 14. The problem is not the solution: against the pharmakon • The late Bernard Stiegler and the Internation collective wrote about smart cities (Stiegler, Bernard, Collectif Internation, Alain Supiot, & Jean-Marie Le Clezio. Bifurquer: Il n’y a pas d’alternative. Paris: Les Liens Qui Libèrent, 2020, chapter 2). • Against technophobic trends they insisted on the importance of technology, just as Stiegler did for his entire life.
  • 15. • But technology =/= technologies: one can oppose zombie technologies (including smart cities) and yet refuse to embrace a technophobic position.  Technodiversity matters. • The technical system is thought to be disrupting the social, economical, legal, etc. systems. As if it was always in advance. But this time, it’s not in advance but rather out of sync with the current situation.  IoT dates back from the 80s, smart cities appeared in 2005, etc. and we know these perspectives do not fit well with the Anthropocene/impending collapse/ecological meltdown/looming extinction, etc.
  • 16. The smart city is thus a good example of what I call « obsolete futures »
  • 17. The consequences of the Anthropocene • Raymond, Colin, Tom Matthews, et Radley M. Horton. « The Emergence of Heat and Humidity Too Severe for Human Tolerance ». Science Advances 6, no 19 (mai 2020): eaaw1838. https://doi.org/10.1126/sciadv.aaw1838. • Mora, Camilo, Bénédicte Dousset, Iain R. Caldwell, Farrah E. Powell, Rollan C. Geronimo, Coral R. Bielecki, Chelsie W. W. Counsell, et al. « Global Risk of Deadly Heat ». Nature Climate Change 7, no 7 (19 juin 2017): 501-6. https://doi.org/10.1038/nclimate3322. • Steffen, Will, Johan Rockström, Katherine Richardson, Timothy M. Lenton, Carl Folke, Diana Liverman, Colin P. Summerhayes, et al. « Trajectories of the Earth System in the Anthropocene ». Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 115, no 33 (14 août 2018): 8252-59. https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.1810141115.
  • 18. Issues Stiegler takes for granted that smart cities will happen. 01 No attention is given to movements of resistance and tactics deployed to shut down some projects like Quayside in Toronto. 02 From a strategic perspective, no effort is dedicated to synchronizing the scenario of the smart city with what we know about the trajectory of the Earth- system in the Anthropocene. 03
  • 19. Smart cities as “negative commons” “Negative commons refers to “resources”, material or immaterial, “negative” such as waste, nuclear power plants, polluted soil or certain cultural legacies (the right of a colonizer, etc.). The challenge is to take care of them collectively (commoning) if we cannot wipe out these realities. It is therefore an extension of the classical theory of commons, particularly in relation to the “positive” approach of the Commons Pool Resources proposed by Elinor Ostrom, sometimes described as bucolic by Alexandre Monnin. The negative commons approach revolves around two major axes a) giving a negative value to realities that are often considered positive - fossil energy reserves, digital technologies, etc. - and b) giving a negative value to realities that are often considered to be positive. b) the fact of building new institutions likely to allow collectives to democratically reappropriate subjects that have escaped them until now, in particular co-existence with negative commons, more or less at a distance (one can think of the recent measures taken by mayors on the subject of pesticides, but also of the digital tomorrow, based on the same model).” Monnin, Alexandre, et Lionel Maurel. « Glossaire · Politiques des communs ». In Politiques des communs, 2020. https://politiquesdescommuns.cc/glossaire.
  • 21. Two directions • Avoiding innovations to come to existence ; • Dismantling existing technologies, infrastructures, etc. unfit for the time to come. We are helping a City of 100 000+ inhabitants to foreclose some of its infrastructures with democratic “protocols of renunciation” that call for broader transformations.
  • 22. Looking at pressing issues for cities… Food security Rising sea levels Extreme heat Access to water Etc.
  • 23. Smart cities? • Smart cities (« metropoles »)  get rid of the smart element • Smart Cities  how about cities in the Anthropocene? There is an ongoing de-urbanizing movement because cities might not fit well with what we know aout the future? (see Faburel, Guillaume. Les Metropoles Barbares - Poche - Demondialiser la Ville, Desurbaniser la Terre. Le Passager Clandestin, 2019, )
  • 24. • Meanwhile in France a Grenoble, once the place where smart city was first implemented in France, is looking to ban 5G…
  • 25. So… Smart Cities? As jokes they should be ridiculed. As dystopias, they should be seriously fought. As projects, we should use them to learn how to shut down innovations. As realities, we should learn how to inherit them as ruins.