SWOT anlysis of Government, public and private sectors in agricultural communication development
1. SWOT analysis of
government, non
government and private
agencies in agriculture
communication
development
Birat BhandariPrepared by:
2. Contents
Introduction
Role of Governmental agencies
Role of Non Governmental agencies
Role of private agencies
Conclusion
3. Introduction
In context of Nepal agriculture communication is
mainly done by Government agencies (mainly by
DOA, DLS, AICC)
Non government sector (I/NGO) program focus on
agriculture commercialization, agri-market promotion
and technology dissemination (CYMMIT)
Private sectors agro-vets, private firms, individuals
consulting firms are carrying out dissemination of
information
The mode of information follow is use of mass
media, individual and group contact, use of mobile
apps, SMS services, use of social media
4. Governmental agencies in
agricultural communication
development
Extension mainly carried through Department of
Agriculture and Department of Livestock Service
while AICC is responsible for production of mass
media extension contents
Extension programs are managed through 5 regional
directorates, 75 district offices and
agriculture/livestock service centers at sub district
(Ilaka) level
JT/JTA work at Ilaka level and report to DADO or
DLSO now at VDC/Municipality level (new federal
system)
Government agencies play role in communication
5. DOA and DLS in Extension
378 service centers
4-6 service centers per
district
DADO: Subject matter
specialist – protection,
horticulture, extension,
agronomy, planning
Focus on transfer of
technology (plant
protection, disease
control, agri-business,
improved variety use)
999 service centers
9-15 service centers
per district
DLSO: Veterinary
Doctor and Livestock
officer
Extension on best
animal husbandry
practice and treatment
of farm animal
Department of Agriculture Department of Livestock ServiceDepartment of Agriculture Department of Livestock Service
6. Agriculture information and
Communication Centre (AICC)
AICC unit formed in 2000
Objective: Disseminate agricultural
technologies and techniques through mass
media
Produces training/ extension materials• 6 technical
staffs
• 15 min radio
broadcast in
radio Nepal
Radio unit
• 6 technical staff
• Documentaries
/TV program
Video Unit
• 6-10 technical staff
• Bi-monthly
magazine, agri-
diary, agriculture
calendar
• Leaflets, booklets
Publication
unit
7. Strengths and weaknesses
Credibility: Farmers
have great faith
Reliable source of
information
More technical man
power than other
organization
Coverage all over
Nepal up to local level
High budget allocated
for extension
Technical person low per
farmer (1:1333)
Staffs not updated with
new technologies
Poor coordination among
extension worker & farmer
(Focused to reachable
only)
Less number of SMS; 1
specialist per theme per
district
No sufficient infrastructure
Bureaucracy: less
responsible to farmers,
favoritism in reward,
Strengths WeaknessesStrengths Weaknesses
8. Opportunities and threats
I/NGOs working in agriculture
sector: Capacity build up, adding
missing program at community
level
Presence of Cooperative and
groups in community: can be used
for group extension
Advanced communication
technologies can be used for
extension : social media, SMS,
telephone
Local reformation in federal
system: provision of technicians in
each Local levels will create
access of extension
Infrastructure at service center can
be used for extension with repair
Rate of information
demand is increasing
but no of staffs are not
increasing in the same
rate creating huge gap
Rapid technological
advances (technicians
outdated) but
frequency of staff
training is minimal
Opportunities Threats
9. NGO Involvement in
Extension
Three kinds of NGOs operating in Nepal i. INGO ii.
National Level NGO iii. Local NGO
Farmers’ Group formation and mobilization,
cooperative formation and strengthening
Agri-business promotion, technology transfer,
support
Provide training to farmer
10. Cont.…..
Provide advisory services to farmer
Work closely with DADO/DLSO
Publish information materials (Posters,
leaflets, audio and video programs etc)
SMS service, information in website, use of
social media used in communication
11. Awareness of local cultural,
political, economic contexts
Good networking ability and
work closely with rural poor
people
Huge funding and flexibility in
extension program
Have expertise in technical
matter
Have advanced technology
Farmer to farmer contact
(group or individual
Small Coverage area
Choose accessible
location
Limited capacity for
agriculture technology
dissemination
More accountable to
external funding agencies
Strength Weakness
12. Can do partnership with
similar organizations
Local resource
mobilization
Local networking ability
Opportunity to explore
indigenous technology
knowledge (ICIMOD)
Unsustainable
initiatives without
link up with other
agencies
Might not reach poor
people
No regularity in
program
Increased
Opportunity Threats
13. Private Sector Involvement in
Communication
Agro-Vets and farm consultants are engaged in
extension
Supply improved seed, seedlings, saplings, baby
chicks, fingerlings, animal feed, pesticides &
veterinary services
Some Agro-Vets also offer artificial insemination (AI)
on cattle and buffalo
They are more acquainted with farmers problem
14. Easy access to farmer
Provide input in timely
manner
More updated
Provide advisory service
Demand driven extension
services
More effective service
Business motive
service
Expensive (Not afford
by small farmer)
Mostly private sector (
Agro-vet) located in
market area
Strengths Weakness
15. Commercial farming is
being followed in recent
days hence the flow of
farmers to agro-vet is
increasing
Increased credit facility,
hence farmers’ flow is
increasing
Government and NGOs
program focused in
improved farming
Unstable political
changes
Farmers still adopting
conventional farming
practices
Less importance in
crop protection/ animal
health by rural farmers
Opportunities Threats
16. Conclusion
DOA, DLS, AICC are the major government agencies
working in agriculture extension
I/NGOs play important role in agriculture/livestock
development
Agro-vets, private firms, private consultancy services are
working in agriculture extension
Mass media, audio video materials, ICT technologies,
websites, social media, mobile apps are being used by
these sectors in transfer of technology
Every sectors have strength and weaknesses in some
aspects hence there should be close coordination in
order to achieve effective extension through effective
communication
Service centers: 4 in terai and Himalayan districts
6 in hilly districts
Radio program at 6:40
DSTEP: (i) establishment of Community Agricultural Extension Service Centers (CAESC) in each Village Development Committee (VDC);
(ii) strengthening capacity of existing and planned Agriculture and Livestock Service Centers that will provide backstopping services to the CAESCs; and
(iii) promoting a voucher system to empower farmers to access the best available agricultural input and extension service providers.