SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 7
© 2004 – 2010
Sherlock Automated Design
Analysis™
© 2004 - 2007© 2004 - 2010
9000 Virginia Manor Rd Ste 290, Beltsville MD 20705 | 301-474-0607 | www.dfrsolutions.com
Model Simplifications for Rapid Assessment of
Interconnects
o Unique scaling challenge of modeling the
robustness of soldered interconnects of
electronics
o Large assembly with thousands of small solder joints
(sub mm)
o Sherlock uses simplified component structures that
approximate the mass and stiffness of the electronic
component without modeling the actual interconnects
© 2004 - 2007© 2004 - 2010
9000 Virginia Manor Rd Ste 290, Beltsville MD 20705 | 301-474-0607 | www.dfrsolutions.com
Model Comparison
o Quarter symmetric model of BGA device under
board bending moment.
o Sherlock uses package dependent board level
strain fatigue models for vibration predictions
© 2004 - 2007© 2004 - 2010
9000 Virginia Manor Rd Ste 290, Beltsville MD 20705 | 301-474-0607 | www.dfrsolutions.com
Models
o Board parameters are identical
o Detailed part includes individual solder joints, die,
substrate and lid
o Simplified part just includes substrate
© 2004 - 2007© 2004 - 2010
9000 Virginia Manor Rd Ste 290, Beltsville MD 20705 | 301-474-0607 | www.dfrsolutions.com
o Identical bending moments applied to board
edges
Displacement Results
≈ 2% Difference
Detailed
0.2618 mm
Simplified
0.2672 mm
© 2004 - 2007© 2004 - 2010
9000 Virginia Manor Rd Ste 290, Beltsville MD 20705 | 301-474-0607 | www.dfrsolutions.com
Principal Board Strains
Simplified
Detailed
Similar corner
PCB strains
© 2004 - 2007© 2004 - 2010
9000 Virginia Manor Rd Ste 290, Beltsville MD 20705 | 301-474-0607 | www.dfrsolutions.com
Discussion
o Based on the board level deflections the
difference between the two models will not have
a significant impact on the dynamic response of
the circuit board.
o Both models generate similar PCB strains

More Related Content

What's hot

Root Cause Analysis of HALT Failures
 Root Cause Analysis of HALT Failures Root Cause Analysis of HALT Failures
Root Cause Analysis of HALT Failures
Cheryl Tulkoff
 

What's hot (16)

MEG-Array® Connector System
MEG-Array® Connector SystemMEG-Array® Connector System
MEG-Array® Connector System
 
UnitedSiC UJN1205K 1200V SiC JFET report published by System Plus Consulting
UnitedSiC UJN1205K 1200V SiC JFET report published by System Plus ConsultingUnitedSiC UJN1205K 1200V SiC JFET report published by System Plus Consulting
UnitedSiC UJN1205K 1200V SiC JFET report published by System Plus Consulting
 
Alternative Methods for Qualifying EEE Parts for CubeSats
Alternative Methods for Qualifying EEE Parts for CubeSatsAlternative Methods for Qualifying EEE Parts for CubeSats
Alternative Methods for Qualifying EEE Parts for CubeSats
 
Axis P1375-E Network Camera
Axis P1375-E Network CameraAxis P1375-E Network Camera
Axis P1375-E Network Camera
 
InvenSense ICM-20789: High Performance 6-Axis Motion Sensor and Pressure Sens...
InvenSense ICM-20789: High Performance 6-Axis Motion Sensor and Pressure Sens...InvenSense ICM-20789: High Performance 6-Axis Motion Sensor and Pressure Sens...
InvenSense ICM-20789: High Performance 6-Axis Motion Sensor and Pressure Sens...
 
Gecko overview PTM
Gecko overview PTMGecko overview PTM
Gecko overview PTM
 
STMicroelectronics MASTERGAN1 Half-Bridge Driver
STMicroelectronics MASTERGAN1 Half-Bridge DriverSTMicroelectronics MASTERGAN1 Half-Bridge Driver
STMicroelectronics MASTERGAN1 Half-Bridge Driver
 
HTC Vive Virtual Reality Head-Mounted Display - teardown reverse costing repo...
HTC Vive Virtual Reality Head-Mounted Display - teardown reverse costing repo...HTC Vive Virtual Reality Head-Mounted Display - teardown reverse costing repo...
HTC Vive Virtual Reality Head-Mounted Display - teardown reverse costing repo...
 
Samsung LPDDR5 12GB Mobile Memory
Samsung LPDDR5 12GB Mobile MemorySamsung LPDDR5 12GB Mobile Memory
Samsung LPDDR5 12GB Mobile Memory
 
Root Cause Analysis of HALT Failures
 Root Cause Analysis of HALT Failures Root Cause Analysis of HALT Failures
Root Cause Analysis of HALT Failures
 
EZ-Test points PTM
EZ-Test points PTMEZ-Test points PTM
EZ-Test points PTM
 
Prysmian BICON 376 Orion Cable Cleats - Spec Sheet
Prysmian BICON 376 Orion Cable Cleats - Spec SheetPrysmian BICON 376 Orion Cable Cleats - Spec Sheet
Prysmian BICON 376 Orion Cable Cleats - Spec Sheet
 
State of the art of stator winding supports in slot area and winding overhang...
State of the art of stator winding supports in slot area and winding overhang...State of the art of stator winding supports in slot area and winding overhang...
State of the art of stator winding supports in slot area and winding overhang...
 
RELIABLE CABLE INSTALLATIONS FOR INDUSTRIAL ENVIRONMENTS
RELIABLE CABLE INSTALLATIONS FOR INDUSTRIAL ENVIRONMENTS  RELIABLE CABLE INSTALLATIONS FOR INDUSTRIAL ENVIRONMENTS
RELIABLE CABLE INSTALLATIONS FOR INDUSTRIAL ENVIRONMENTS
 
Commscope-Andrew 114EZDM
Commscope-Andrew 114EZDMCommscope-Andrew 114EZDM
Commscope-Andrew 114EZDM
 
Commscope-Andrew CSG78-12B2U
Commscope-Andrew CSG78-12B2UCommscope-Andrew CSG78-12B2U
Commscope-Andrew CSG78-12B2U
 

Similar to Simplified vs. Detailed

Thomson bsa lead_ ball_ screws_catalog
Thomson bsa  lead_ ball_ screws_catalogThomson bsa  lead_ ball_ screws_catalog
Thomson bsa lead_ ball_ screws_catalog
Electromate
 
Servo tek st38st50series_specsheet
Servo tek st38st50series_specsheetServo tek st38st50series_specsheet
Servo tek st38st50series_specsheet
Electromate
 
Thomson bsa lead_and_ball_screws_catalog
Thomson bsa lead_and_ball_screws_catalogThomson bsa lead_and_ball_screws_catalog
Thomson bsa lead_and_ball_screws_catalog
Electromate
 
Physics of Failure Simulation and Modeling Specification Webinar
Physics of Failure Simulation and Modeling Specification WebinarPhysics of Failure Simulation and Modeling Specification Webinar
Physics of Failure Simulation and Modeling Specification Webinar
Ed Dodd
 

Similar to Simplified vs. Detailed (20)

Thomson bsa lead_ ball_ screws_catalog
Thomson bsa  lead_ ball_ screws_catalogThomson bsa  lead_ ball_ screws_catalog
Thomson bsa lead_ ball_ screws_catalog
 
ANALYTICAL STUDY ON MOMENT ROTATION CURVE FOR BEAM- COLUMN STEEL CONNECTION W...
ANALYTICAL STUDY ON MOMENT ROTATION CURVE FOR BEAM- COLUMN STEEL CONNECTION W...ANALYTICAL STUDY ON MOMENT ROTATION CURVE FOR BEAM- COLUMN STEEL CONNECTION W...
ANALYTICAL STUDY ON MOMENT ROTATION CURVE FOR BEAM- COLUMN STEEL CONNECTION W...
 
An Analytical and Experimental Investigation of Shear Connectors in Composite...
An Analytical and Experimental Investigation of Shear Connectors in Composite...An Analytical and Experimental Investigation of Shear Connectors in Composite...
An Analytical and Experimental Investigation of Shear Connectors in Composite...
 
IRJET- Experimental Study on Behaviour of Cold-Formed Steel Castellated Beam
IRJET- Experimental Study on Behaviour of Cold-Formed Steel Castellated BeamIRJET- Experimental Study on Behaviour of Cold-Formed Steel Castellated Beam
IRJET- Experimental Study on Behaviour of Cold-Formed Steel Castellated Beam
 
Servo tek st38st50series_specsheet
Servo tek st38st50series_specsheetServo tek st38st50series_specsheet
Servo tek st38st50series_specsheet
 
Prysmian Bicon Aluminium Claw Cleats - 370 Series Claw Cable Cleat
Prysmian Bicon Aluminium Claw Cleats - 370 Series Claw Cable CleatPrysmian Bicon Aluminium Claw Cleats - 370 Series Claw Cable Cleat
Prysmian Bicon Aluminium Claw Cleats - 370 Series Claw Cable Cleat
 
Prysmian Bicon 370BA07 32-38mm Claw Cable Cleat - Prysmian Bicon Aluminium Ca...
Prysmian Bicon 370BA07 32-38mm Claw Cable Cleat - Prysmian Bicon Aluminium Ca...Prysmian Bicon 370BA07 32-38mm Claw Cable Cleat - Prysmian Bicon Aluminium Ca...
Prysmian Bicon 370BA07 32-38mm Claw Cable Cleat - Prysmian Bicon Aluminium Ca...
 
Prysmian Bicon 370BA04 19-22mm Claw Cable Cleat - Prysmian Bicon Aluminium Ca...
Prysmian Bicon 370BA04 19-22mm Claw Cable Cleat - Prysmian Bicon Aluminium Ca...Prysmian Bicon 370BA04 19-22mm Claw Cable Cleat - Prysmian Bicon Aluminium Ca...
Prysmian Bicon 370BA04 19-22mm Claw Cable Cleat - Prysmian Bicon Aluminium Ca...
 
Prysmian Bicon 370BA05 22-25mm Claw Cable Cleat - Prysmian Bicon Aluminium Ca...
Prysmian Bicon 370BA05 22-25mm Claw Cable Cleat - Prysmian Bicon Aluminium Ca...Prysmian Bicon 370BA05 22-25mm Claw Cable Cleat - Prysmian Bicon Aluminium Ca...
Prysmian Bicon 370BA05 22-25mm Claw Cable Cleat - Prysmian Bicon Aluminium Ca...
 
Prysmian Bicon 370BA06 25-32mm Claw Cable Cleat - Prysmian Bicon Aluminium Ca...
Prysmian Bicon 370BA06 25-32mm Claw Cable Cleat - Prysmian Bicon Aluminium Ca...Prysmian Bicon 370BA06 25-32mm Claw Cable Cleat - Prysmian Bicon Aluminium Ca...
Prysmian Bicon 370BA06 25-32mm Claw Cable Cleat - Prysmian Bicon Aluminium Ca...
 
Prysmian Bicon 370BA03 16-19mm Claw Cable Cleat - Prysmian Bicon Aluminium Ca...
Prysmian Bicon 370BA03 16-19mm Claw Cable Cleat - Prysmian Bicon Aluminium Ca...Prysmian Bicon 370BA03 16-19mm Claw Cable Cleat - Prysmian Bicon Aluminium Ca...
Prysmian Bicon 370BA03 16-19mm Claw Cable Cleat - Prysmian Bicon Aluminium Ca...
 
Prysmian Bicon 370BA02 13-16mm Claw Cable Cleat - Prysmian Bicon Aluminium Ca...
Prysmian Bicon 370BA02 13-16mm Claw Cable Cleat - Prysmian Bicon Aluminium Ca...Prysmian Bicon 370BA02 13-16mm Claw Cable Cleat - Prysmian Bicon Aluminium Ca...
Prysmian Bicon 370BA02 13-16mm Claw Cable Cleat - Prysmian Bicon Aluminium Ca...
 
Prysmian Bicon 370BA09 44-51mm Claw Cable Cleat - Prysmian Bicon Aluminium Ca...
Prysmian Bicon 370BA09 44-51mm Claw Cable Cleat - Prysmian Bicon Aluminium Ca...Prysmian Bicon 370BA09 44-51mm Claw Cable Cleat - Prysmian Bicon Aluminium Ca...
Prysmian Bicon 370BA09 44-51mm Claw Cable Cleat - Prysmian Bicon Aluminium Ca...
 
Prysmian Bicon 370BA08 38-44mm Claw Cable Cleat - Prysmian Bicon Aluminium Ca...
Prysmian Bicon 370BA08 38-44mm Claw Cable Cleat - Prysmian Bicon Aluminium Ca...Prysmian Bicon 370BA08 38-44mm Claw Cable Cleat - Prysmian Bicon Aluminium Ca...
Prysmian Bicon 370BA08 38-44mm Claw Cable Cleat - Prysmian Bicon Aluminium Ca...
 
Prysmian Bicon 370BA01 10-13mm Claw Cable Cleat - Prysmian Bicon Aluminium Ca...
Prysmian Bicon 370BA01 10-13mm Claw Cable Cleat - Prysmian Bicon Aluminium Ca...Prysmian Bicon 370BA01 10-13mm Claw Cable Cleat - Prysmian Bicon Aluminium Ca...
Prysmian Bicon 370BA01 10-13mm Claw Cable Cleat - Prysmian Bicon Aluminium Ca...
 
Thomson BSA Lead and Ball Screws
Thomson BSA Lead and Ball ScrewsThomson BSA Lead and Ball Screws
Thomson BSA Lead and Ball Screws
 
Thomson bsa lead_and_ball_screws_catalog
Thomson bsa lead_and_ball_screws_catalogThomson bsa lead_and_ball_screws_catalog
Thomson bsa lead_and_ball_screws_catalog
 
Design Optimization of Connector Secondary Latch to Avoid Failure in Automoti...
Design Optimization of Connector Secondary Latch to Avoid Failure in Automoti...Design Optimization of Connector Secondary Latch to Avoid Failure in Automoti...
Design Optimization of Connector Secondary Latch to Avoid Failure in Automoti...
 
Design of Connections in Tubular Structure
Design of Connections in Tubular StructureDesign of Connections in Tubular Structure
Design of Connections in Tubular Structure
 
Physics of Failure Simulation and Modeling Specification Webinar
Physics of Failure Simulation and Modeling Specification WebinarPhysics of Failure Simulation and Modeling Specification Webinar
Physics of Failure Simulation and Modeling Specification Webinar
 

Simplified vs. Detailed

  • 1. © 2004 – 2010 Sherlock Automated Design Analysis™
  • 2. © 2004 - 2007© 2004 - 2010 9000 Virginia Manor Rd Ste 290, Beltsville MD 20705 | 301-474-0607 | www.dfrsolutions.com Model Simplifications for Rapid Assessment of Interconnects o Unique scaling challenge of modeling the robustness of soldered interconnects of electronics o Large assembly with thousands of small solder joints (sub mm) o Sherlock uses simplified component structures that approximate the mass and stiffness of the electronic component without modeling the actual interconnects
  • 3. © 2004 - 2007© 2004 - 2010 9000 Virginia Manor Rd Ste 290, Beltsville MD 20705 | 301-474-0607 | www.dfrsolutions.com Model Comparison o Quarter symmetric model of BGA device under board bending moment. o Sherlock uses package dependent board level strain fatigue models for vibration predictions
  • 4. © 2004 - 2007© 2004 - 2010 9000 Virginia Manor Rd Ste 290, Beltsville MD 20705 | 301-474-0607 | www.dfrsolutions.com Models o Board parameters are identical o Detailed part includes individual solder joints, die, substrate and lid o Simplified part just includes substrate
  • 5. © 2004 - 2007© 2004 - 2010 9000 Virginia Manor Rd Ste 290, Beltsville MD 20705 | 301-474-0607 | www.dfrsolutions.com o Identical bending moments applied to board edges Displacement Results ≈ 2% Difference Detailed 0.2618 mm Simplified 0.2672 mm
  • 6. © 2004 - 2007© 2004 - 2010 9000 Virginia Manor Rd Ste 290, Beltsville MD 20705 | 301-474-0607 | www.dfrsolutions.com Principal Board Strains Simplified Detailed Similar corner PCB strains
  • 7. © 2004 - 2007© 2004 - 2010 9000 Virginia Manor Rd Ste 290, Beltsville MD 20705 | 301-474-0607 | www.dfrsolutions.com Discussion o Based on the board level deflections the difference between the two models will not have a significant impact on the dynamic response of the circuit board. o Both models generate similar PCB strains