This document discusses the ethical dilemmas that can arise regarding medical examinations for seafarers. It notes the conflict between ship safety requirements and seafarers' individual rights. Seafarers must present a valid health certificate to work, but certificates may not always accurately reflect a seafarer's physical and mental fitness. This can put the ship's safety at risk but also threatens the seafarer's employment if issues are later identified. The document explores this dilemma and considers approaches like relying on both medical certificates and seafarer self-declarations of health.