Chapter 1
Wewill defined research and scientific
research
Describe the scientific research process
and its steps
Types of research
The need to understand ethical issues
in research
3.
1. Introduction
Researchadvances knowledge and
improves practice
Module intends to give students a
sense of direction in the
implementation of inquiry methods
that value new ways of knowing
4.
1.2 What isResearch?
A systematic process of collecting and
logically analysing data for some purpose
(Creswell 2004, Graziano & Raulin 2008)
Information is collected to increase our
understanding of any subject
Research is a systematic process that can
be conducted by anyone, anywhere and on
anything in nature
This module will explain what scientific
research is
5.
1.3 What isScientific
Research?
It is formal, sequential and not applied in a general
way
The search of knowledge by using recognised methods
in data collection, analysis and interpretation (McMillan
and Schumacher 1998)
Scientific is not similar to science
Scientific refers to an approach of generating
knowledge
Meanwhile science is a body of established knowledge
Research is a methodological study used to prove a
hypothesis or answer a specific question
6.
1.3.1 Characteristics ofScientific
research
Research starts with a question or
problem, it begins with a clear simple
statement of a problem
It deals with the main problem through
appropriate sub-problems
It is guided by the specific hypothesis
It accepts certain critical assumptions
(a position taken for granted)
It requires a systematic approach
7.
1.4 Scientific methodsof solving
a problem
Scientific research method is cyclic
(Neutons and Rubinson 1997). 7 steps of the
research process;
Research problem
The hypothesis
Reviewing literature
The research design
Methods of data collection
Analysing the data
Writing a research report
8.
1.5 Types ofResearch
Applied research:
Research which provides solutions to practical
problems (Graziano & Raulin 2007)
This is people management research e.g. fields
that use scientific knowledge include
management, medicine, engineering, social
work, education etc.
The fields may not themselves be science
Applied research provides a generalised solution
to a general problem e.g. absenteeism,
performance management
9.
Types of Researchcont.
Basic Research
Also known as fundamental research of
pure research is designed to increase
scientific understanding without any
particular practical goals (Graziano and
Raulin 2007)
It starts with a theory, basic principle
or generalization e.g. ‘if you underplay
workers they get demoralised’
10.
1.6 Conceptual Framework
Proposes explanations for potential
relationships
Puts the study in perspective among other
studies
It is used to support studies looking for
relationships between variables e.g.
relationship between employee motivation
and their performance needs a conceptual
framework for the study to fit into existing
11.
1.7 Research Ethics
It refers to code of behaviour expected
It is important when conducting
research on humans it is important to
avoid harm physically, emotionally or
spiritually
The National Research Council of
Zimbabwe has ethical research
principles that govern social research
principles
Different disciplines have their ethics
12.
Assingments 1
A)Discuss the importance of research
in education. 10 marks.
B) Discuss the differences between an
interview and a questioner as research
gathering tools. 10 maks. Due date 25
September 2014.
13.
Chapter 2
Defineresearch problem.
Describe the steps involved in
formulating the research problem.
Evaluation of a researchable problem.
Definition of a hypothesis and its
characteristics
14.
2. STATING THEPROBLEM
STATEMENT
2.1 INTRODUCTION
Problem is stated as a statement or a
question
Steps include formulating the topic,
giving the background to the study,
stating the purpose of the study and
stating the hypothesis or assumptions
15.
2.2 Problem Formulation
Selecting the topic-undertake research in
your area, topic should investigate
something important, give rationale
Developing the topic-it starts broad but
narrow it down still showing detail of
variables to be measured
Characteristics of a good topic-interesting,
researchable
Background to the study- brief history, put
into context
16.
Problem Formulation cont.
The purpose of the study - why
Statement of the problem-what exactly
clearly and concisely
Sub-problems or Sub-questions
Hypothesis-the transformation of the
problem into a statement, provides
framework for data, can be deduced,
can be tested
17.
Check list questionsfor
problem
How significant is the problem?
What are practical benefits ?
How accessible is the information to solve
the problem to the researcher?
How interested are you?
What are the ethical issues?
3.2 Definition ofquantitative
Approach
Is a formal objective, systematic
process in which numerical data are
utilised to obtain information about the
world
It presents results in numbers
It is generalisable,
Deductive i.e. based on reasoning
20.
3.3 Definition ofqualitative
research approach
Broad approach to the study of social
phenomenon
It is naturalistic, interpretive and
increasingly critical
It is subjective, uses words
Based on a world view with the
following beliefs, that there is no single
reality, reality is based on perceptions
that vary with individuals, time, context
and situation
21.
3.3.1 Comparison ofthe features of
Qualitative and Quantitative approaches
Both are systematic in their approach
Both follow a process
Quantitative is objective while qualitative is
subjective
The researcher remains detached while in
other researcher can become involved
Quantitative tests theory the other generates
theory
Results can be generalised in quantitative and
not in qualitative, use of numbers vs words
22.
Types of Variables
Quantitative Variables
Qualitative Variables
NB. Can have the phrases “types of
variables” used synonymous to “types
of data”
23.
(A) Quantitative Variables
Are variables which take numerical
values for which mathematical
operations are possible
Numeric in nature
Express measured characteristics
Convey concepts such as quantity,
amount, and magnitude
Can be in two forms:
(i) Discrete variables and
(ii) Continuous variables
24.
(i) Discrete Variables
Are variables with values that are whole
numbers
They take only a single exact value
They have gaps between each number
where no intermediate values can occur
e.g. No. of visits to a waterhole, no. of
animals/plants etc.
25.
(ii) Continuous Variables
Can take on any numerical value on a
scale
And there exists an infinite number of
values between any two numbers on a
scale
Obtained more precisely
E.g. weight, mass, height, time etc.
26.
(B) Qualitative/Categorical
Variables
Arenon-numeric in nature
Are variables which yield categorical
responses
Express a described characteristic
Use descriptive words/names/labels
Can be in two forms:
(i) Ordinal variables
(ii) Nominal variables
27.
(i) Ordinal Variables
Are ranked or ordered observations
based on whether they are greater than
or less than one another
Ordinal data do not provide
information about how close or distant
observations are from one another
Values/levels can be ranked or ordered
e.g. Occupation
28.
(ii) Nominal Variables
When an observation is simply given a name,
label, or otherwise classified into categories, a
nominal variable is being used
Values/levels can not be ranked or ordered
Nominal variables use numbers to identify
qualitative differences among measurements
NB. These numbers are not in any mathematical
relationship with one another
i.e. no quantitative distinction can be drawn
among them
E.g. gender, marital status, race, ethnicity,
religion
29.
Definition of research
design
Research design refers to the plan and
structure of the investigation used to
obtain evidence to answer research
questions
It describes the procedures for
conducting the study, including when,
from whom and under what conditions
the data will be collected
30.
3.5 QUANTITATIVE RESEARCH
DESIGNS
It is a framework that provides the glue
that holds the research together
It shows how the topic, problem
statement, sample, methods for
collecting data and analysing data work
together to address the central
question
Quantitative designs were initially
developed from research and hard
sciences (Biology, Chemistry and
3.5.1 EXPERIMENTAL
DESIGNS
Experimentsare conducted to predict a
phenomenon
The researcher is able to manipulate what the
subjects experience in an experimental design
Usually there are two groups, one group is
the experiment and the other is the control
Some conditions are imposed on the subjects
which are not imposed on the control e.g.
comparing a trained group versus an
untrained group
33.
True experimental design
The experiment is observed in the laboratory
The researcher exercises a great deal of
control and manipulation
True experimental research can be applied in
management with caution where researcher
studies two groups
Research design aims to investigate the
possible cause effect relationship
Randomization is used, presenting equal
chances
34.
Experimental designs cont.
Pre-test Post-test control group design
Control is not treated but both post-test
results are compared after treatment of
subjects
Post-test only design
Experimental group can only be tested
after treatment e.g. measuring level of
motivation after incentives
35.
3.6 Quasi-Experimental
designs
Areused where manipulation,
randomization and control are lacking
True experimental controls are limited
e.g. use of groups which have evolved
naturally
36.
3.7 Validity inExperiments
Design must be valid for knowledge
generated from experimental research
to be sound
There are two types of validity, Internal
and External
37.
Internal Validity
Thisis the ability to determine if a
causal relationship exists between one
or more independent variables and one
or more dependent variables, i.e. has
treatment caused the change or lack of
change
Examples:
Effects of history, any event that can
alter or affect subjects’ performance,
try to make experiences identical
38.
Internal Validity cont.
Effects of maturation,
Changes which come with age e.g. a new
medication to test depression within 6
months
Effects of testing,
Giving a pre-test and post-test to a group
increases the chances of improvement
if it’s the same test
39.
Internal Validity cont.
Effects of statistical regression
It refers to the tendency for subjects who
score very high or very low to score more
toward the mean on subsequent testing i.e.
regression towards the mean
Effects of instrumentation
If the measuring device changes during the
course of the study, changes in scores
maybe due to the instrument rather than
the treatment
40.
Internal Validity cont.
Effects of selection
Differences in groups prior to the study may
continue throughout the study, therefore
use subject matching or randomization
Effects of experimenter bias
The researcher maybe biased towards the
result they want
Effects of mortality
if subjects drop out or there is mortality
during study
41.
External Validity
DemandCharacteristics
When subjects become aware of the expected result
and exhibit that
Hawthorne Effects
Mere presence of others watching your performance
causes a change in your performance
Order Effects (or Carryover Effects)
Important where multiple treatment is administered
Treatment Interaction Effects
Treatment can affect people differently
depending on their characteristics
42.
3.8 NON EXPERIMENTALDESIGN
Describes something that occurred or
examines relationship between things
without suggesting cause and effect
relationships
There are four types of non
experimental designs, descriptive,
correlation, survey and ex post facto.
43.
Non experimental designs
Descriptive design
Simply describes an existing phenomenon by using
numbers to characterize individuals or a group, there
is no manipulation or treatment
Correlation design
It is a form of descriptive designs. It assesses the
relationship between two or more phenomenon. It
measures the degree of association between
variables. Positive implies high values of both
variables are associated and negative correlation
means high values of one variable are associated to
low values of second variable
44.
Ex Post Facto
Used to explore possible relationships
among variables that cannot be
manipulated by the researcher e.g.
customer care in two or more
supermarkets
Questionnaires and interviews of
employees can be used to understand
their training experiences for customer
care
45.
Survey design
Itis used when the purpose is to describe a
prevailing phenomenon without explaining
casual relationships
The researcher selects a sample of subjects
and administers questionnaires or conducts
interviews to collect data
Surveys can describe attitudes, belief,
opinions or frequency of different factors
Information about a population can be
inferred from responses from a sample
46.
The concept ofpopulation in a
survey design
Population
Larger group to which all the people of interest are
Sample
Is a subset of the population. Sampling saves time,
money and provides valid results if done properly
Sample size
It should take into account type of research,
research hypotheses, financial constraints, the
importance of the results, the number of
variables studied, methodology and degree of
accuracy needed
47.
Types of sampling
In quantitative research there are two types of
sampling i.e. probability sampling and non-
probability
Probability sampling
Probability sampling is where subjects are drawn
from a larger population in such a way that
probability of selecting each member of population
is known. A sample maybe representative of the
population, observations of the probability sample
are used for inferential purpose, inferential or
parametric statistics are used for probability sample
48.
Probability sampling
(a)Convenience sampling
The sample is composed of the subjects that
the researcher conveniently finds available. It
makes also use of volunteers. Technique is
highly biased and maybe suitable where data
collection in not complex and a very low level
of generalisation is envisaged
(b) Quota sampling
Is similar to convenience sampling, subjects are
selected according to their ratio in the pop.
49.
Non –probability sampling
Non-probability sampling also called incidental,
accidental sampling, purposive or judgement
sampling, convenience or availability sampling
involves using whatever subject is available to
the researcher e.g. at a conference or meeting
Limitations are:
Sample size is not representative of a larger
population, so generalisation is more restricted
Sample maybe biased. Especially where subject
volunteers.
50.
Techniques for probability
(unbiased)sampling
(a) Simple random sampling
All members of a population have an
equal chance of being chosen e.g.
assigning numbers and then using
random tables, a random sample from
a computer programme or picking
names from a hat, lottery method of
randomization, tossing a coin, throwing
a dice, blind folding
51.
Advantages and limitationsof
randomization
It is objective, it is economic, convenient,
permits the application of statistical devices
and treatments of data, maintains the accuracy
the accuracy in the analysis, it is practical and
gives a representative may be selected
Limitations, sample may fail to be truly
representative, if not done rigorously it may
allow subjectivity, where practical operations
are not favourable the process might be
affected
52.
Techniques for Unbiased
samplingcont.
(b) Systematic sampling
It is similar to simple random sampling
except that the researcher randomly
picks a number then systematically
selects, subjects from a list of names
beginning with the subject assigned the
chosen number. If the number is 6 and
there is need to select a ten percent
sample every tenth subject is selected-
6. 16, 26, 36, and so on.
53.
Techniques for Unbiased
samplingcont.
(c) Stratified sampling
The population is divided into subgroups
or stages on the basis of variable
chosen by the researcher, such as
gender, age or level of education
54.
Techniques for Unbiased
samplingcont.
(d) Cluster sampling
Cluster sampling is similar to stratified random
sampling in that groups of individuals are
identified from the population and subjects
are drawn from these groups. e.g. retail
shops, manufacturing companies, finance
companies can represent group units
Cluster sampling involves two stages, selection
of group units and then of individuals within
groups
55.
Historical method
Historyis the meaningful record of
man’s achievement . It is a truthful
integrated account of the relationship
between persons, events, times and
places (Singh 2006)
Historical approach is an aid in
visualizing society as a dynamic
organism and its structures and
functions as steadily growing and
undergoing change and transformation
56.
Historical research
Itis the application of the scientific
method of inquiry to historical
problems
It involves, identification of the
problem, formulation of the hypothesis,
collection, organisation, validation and
analysis of data; testing the hypothesis;
and writing of the historical account.
Leading to an understanding of the
past and its relevance to the present
57.
Approaches of historicalresearch
Perspective Approach: to study the
events from the past towards present
Retrospective Approach: to study the
events from present and proceed to
past events
58.
Case study method
Case study is both method and tool for
research. Case study leads to very novel idea
and no longer limited to the particular
individual.
Case study is conducted for specific case. It
requires special observation It means the study
is in depth. Depth is to explore all peculiarities of
case.
It is an intensive study of a phenomenon, it
gives
subjective information rather than objective
59.
Case study
Casestudy refers to a study of a unit, it
is a deep study, cumulative study and
can be used for a clinical studies
Case study is a method of exploring
and analysing the life of a social unit-
i.e. a person, a family, institution,
culture group or even an entire
community
60.
Objective s ofcase study
Clinical purpose (dealing with a patient)
Diagnostic purpose (educational
situation to provide the remedial
instruction to poor student)
Fact-finding about psychological or
educational problems
Supplementing other information. It
may be a follow up work.
61.
Three phases ofconducting Case
study
Retrospective phase refers to the past
records of the case which is used in
diagnosing the case
Prospective phase refers to the present
status of the case, which is helpful in
understanding the case
Conspective phase refers to the future
development of the case which is also
employed to examine the effects of the
remediation given to the case
62.
Types of Casestudies
A group or a community –deals with such
elements of community as locations, appearance,
prevailing economic activity, climate and natural
sources, historical development, how people live,
the social structure, goals and life values, an
evaluation of social institutions within a
community that meet the human needs etc.
Casual comparative studies- comparing social
educational background of juvenile groups the
delinquent and non delinquent
63.
Types of Casestudies cont.
Activity Analysis-the analysis of the activities or
process that an individual is called upon to
perform
Content or document analysis- usually deals
with the systematic examination of current
records or documents as a source of data
A follow up study-used to investigate the
impact of a certain program or treatment, used
in evaluation
Trend studies-it is longitudinal assessment of
records based on the past and present
64.
Steps of theCase study
A case study must follow steps and
essentially meet the same criteria as do
other research methods
Status of the Situation on Unit of
attention
Collection of data
Diagnosis and identification of casual
factors
Adjustment, Treatment and Therapy
Follow up Programme
4.1 Introduction
Thereare different ways or tools to
collect data i.e.; observations,
questionnaires, interviews, documents,
tests and unobtrusive measures
Commonly used methods are
observations, questionnaires and
interviews
67.
4.2 QUESTIONNAIRES
Questionnaireis commonly used tool in
quantitative research, it is good for
gathering information from groups. e.g. it
can provide information on the levels of
motivation giving information on the
employees knowledge, opinions and
preferences
Questionnaire can elicit reactions, beliefs
and attitudes from subjects. It can
encompass a variety of instruments
68.
Researcher canchoose to construct or
use existing questionnaire
It can be administered by the
researcher, or can be self administered
The questions include open, closed,
sealed and ranked items
69.
4.2.2. Steps toconstruct a
questionnaire
Familiarise yourself with the research
quest, sub questions, aim and objective
Determine the type of information you
want to gather
Decide on the respondents. Knowing
your population helps in determining
the sample size and appropriate
sampling technique
Calculate number of people to be
surveyed and determine number of
70.
The morethe responses the better the result
Create an introduction to your questionnaire,
brief summary on reason of questionnaire
and instructions on how to answer it
Be straight forward and clear, don’t write
questions that can be misinterpreted
Limit the response for each question
Double check for errors, ask someone to
proof read, Pilot the instrument for validity
and reliability
71.
4.2.3 Some thingsto avoid
Avoid complexity
Avoid leading and loaded questions
Avoid ambiguity
Avoid making assumptions
Avoid burden-some questions
72.
4.2.4 Advantages of
questionnaires
Responses are gathered in a standard way
and are more objective than interviews
It is quick to collect information
Information can be collected from a large
sample
Respondents have enough time to consider
their responses carefully
It permits anonymity
It easy to analyse and can be done with
computer software
73.
Questionnaires reducebias. There is no
verbal or visual clues to influence
respondents
There are less intrusive than telephone
or face to face interviews. Respondent
is free to respond at their own time
74.
4.2.5 Disadvantages of
questionnaires
Open ended questions in a
questionnaire can generate large
amounts of data that can take a long
time to process and analyse
Respondents may answer superficially
especially if the questionnaire is too
long
It may be difficult to get good response
often there is no motivation for
respondents
75.
4.3 Interviews
4.3.1Introduction
Interviews are among the most
challenging and most rewarding forms
of measurement. They require a
personal sensitivity and adaptability
and ability to stay within bounds of the
designed schedule/protocol. Can be
used in both quantitative and
qualitative research designs
76.
4.3.2 Definition ofan
interview
It is a purposeful conversation in which
one person asks prepared questions
(interviewer) and another answers
them (respondents/interviewee) Frey
and Oishi (1995)
It is oral, in person administration
It can be used to lead to other
methodologies such as observation and
experiments
77.
4.3.3 Interview structures
Structured Interviews
Nicholas (1991) described them as a
social survey where the range of
possible answers to each question is
known in advance
The questions include open ended and
closed ended
78.
Approach usesprearranged list of
answers
Unstructured Interviews
Informal interview, not structured by a
standard list of questions
Questions are asked in any order
Researcher can probe deeper
Richness of data depends on the
interviewer
79.
Key issues inconducting a
successful interview
Interview structure to be inline with
objective
Use appropriate language
Ensure interviewees confidentiality
Establish a rapport with the
interviewees
80.
Advantages of interviews
Researcher learns things that cannot be
directly observed
Add an inner perspective to outward
behaviour
Allows probing
Increases accuracy of response
Respondents can raise concerns
81.
Disadvantages of interviews
Time consuming
Are expensive in terms of time & money
Information obtained dependent on
interviewer
Interview is subject to interviewer bias
Interviewer is subject to respondent
bias
Questions can be misleading
82.
Glossary of termsused in
quantitative research
Variables
The key to designing any experiment is to look at what
research variables could affect the outcome
There are many types of variables these include the
independent and dependent variables
A variable is any entity that can take on different values.
It is anything that can vary e.g. age, country, company
Variables are not always quantitative or numerical e.g.
variable gender consists of two text values male and
female
Variables are not only things we measure in the
traditional sense
83.
Glossary of termscont.
The treatment or program can be
made up of one or more variables e.g.
the cause can be considered a variable
An educational program can have
varying amounts of time on task,
classroom settings, student-teacher
ratios etc., the program can be
considered a variable that can be made
up of a number of sub-variables.
84.
Glossary of termscont.
Concept of attribute
An attribute is a specific value on a
variable e.g. the variable sex or gender
has two attributes: male and female
Agreement may be defined as having
five attributes 1=strongly disagree;
2=disagree; 3=neutral; 4= agree;
5=strongly agree
85.
Glossary of termscont.
The Independent variable- is the core of
the experiment and is isolated and
manipulated by the researcher. It can be a
treatment or program or cause
The Dependent variable is what is affected
by the independent variable that is your
effects or outcomes. It is the measurable
outcome of this manipulation e.g. when
measuring the effects of a new educational
program
86.
Glossary of termscont.
The educational program is the
independent variable and the measure
of achievement is the dependent
variable
If studying effects of work experience
on college performance, in both groups
student status remains constant, and
work experience varies between the
two groups and is considered a variable
87.
Glossary of termscont.
Every experiment has at least two types of
variables: independent and dependent. The
independent variable is often our input
variable
It is independent of everything that occurs
during the experiment because it does not
change once chosen
In the college performance experiment those
with work experience and those without,
make up the two independent groups
88.
Glossary of termscont.
The dependent variable or outcome
variable, is dependent on our
dependent on our independent variable
or what we start with. College grades is
dependent on work experience
College grades (dependent variable)
can also be dependent also on age (old
vs young students) or sex (men vs
female), these become the independent
variables
89.
3.9 Qualitative Research
Design
Qualitative research designs are less
structured than quantitative designs
The specific procedures are defined during the
research rather than specified ahead of time
Each step depends on prior information
collected during the study
Designs typically investigate behaviour as it
occurs naturally in a natural situation and
there is no manipulation of conditions or
experience
90.
The dataconsists of words in the form
of rich verbal description, rather than
numbers as in quantitative designs
91.
Ethnography and grounded
theory
Ethnographic design
In an ethnographic study the researcher
relies on observation, interviewing and
document analysis, or a combination of
these to provide an in depth understanding
of a cultural group in a natural setting over
a prolonged time (Creswell 1998)
Ethnography focuses on the culture of a
group of people, they can study broadly
defined cultures
92.
One canstudy the culture of owners or
managers of family business in Zim.
The underlying assumption of the
ethnographer is that every human
group eventually evolves a culture that
guides the members’ view of the world
and the way they structure their
experiences
Meaning may be shared and these can
be passed on
93.
Grounded theoryhas been used most often
in studying areas where there has been little
previous research and in gaining new
insights research previously researched
areas. It is inductive
The steps of grounded theory research
occur simultaneously
The researcher will be observing, collecting
data, organizing data and forming theory
from the data at the same time
94.
Data maybe collected by interview,
observation, records or a combination of
these, typically grounded theory research
projects in management tend to have a
sample of 25-50 people
Data collection usually results in large
amount of hand written notes, typed
interview transcripts, or video/audio taped
conversations which needs to be coded and
categorised
95.
The reporttends to be narrative
discussions of the study process and
findings. The outcome of the study is a
theory explaining the phenomenon
under study
96.
Summary
We definedquantitative, qualitative
research approaches
We defined the concept of research
design describing the different research
designs