This document provides guidance for establishing book clubs for English language learners. It discusses defining literacy, student needs and interests, access to texts, and motivation. A needs assessment survey and talking to students to determine interests are recommended. A variety of genres and accessibility of texts levels are important. Successful strategies include partner work, visual aids, modeling, and allowing use of native language. Choosing culturally relevant texts and providing student choice and a comfortable reading environment can boost motivation. Book clubs should include community sharing, reading, writing, discussion, and be fun.
TataKelola dan KamSiber Kecerdasan Buatan v022.pdf
ELL Book Club Strategies
1. Reading & Book Club with
English Language Learners
Ali Cullerton, Ph.D. & Magister Ines Torres de Muñoz
www.bncloja.org
2. Reading for FUN?
Mostly students
learn to read or
read to learn.
Reading for
fun looks
different
throughout
the world.
Less often,
students read
“just for fun.”
3. What do we NEED to know?
• Before we get started:
• Definition of literacy?
• The needs, interests, and language levels
of English language learners?
• Access to text?
• Motivation?
• Timeline?
5. “New & Multi-Modal Literacies”
Smart
Phones
Tablets
Computers
Audio
Books
Social Media
6. Needs Based Analysis/Survey
• Survey your Students: (On a scale from 1-10, with 1= not at all,
5=somewhat accurate, 10=very accurate)
• 1. I read for fun every week.
• 2. I can define my favorite type of literature.
• 3. I have a favorite book.
• 4. I have a favorite author.
• 5. I enjoy reading.
• 6. I do no enjoy reading.
• 7. I have access to books for free.
• 8. My parents and family members enjoy reading.
• 9. I talk to others about my favorite books.
• 10. I am open to reading new things.
7. Talk to your students
• Be clear about YOUR goal. Is it to raise levels, get
kids excited about reading, or teach about a new
topic?
• Students:
• If you could read about anything or anyone what
would it be?
• What is your favorite genre of text?
• How much time could you commit to reading
everyday?
• What are your concerns about participating in a
book club?
8. Model a literacy-rich life
Family life
Classroom Library
Internet
Diverse
Genres
Local
Library
Writing
10. Determine a Timeline & Vision
Is this part of a literacy-based curriculum?
Is this “extra”?
Is this a social club?
Do students get a grade? Scoring tool?
How can you purchase/provide access to these texts?
How much homework will you assign?
Do you re-read as a group? Read alouds?
11. Age & Developmental Needs
Self-motivation,
independent and group
work.
Intermediate learners:
Group reading, choral
reading, partner reading,
group work and
independent work.
Early learners: Read-alouds, repetition,
illustrations, scaffolds, hands-on
activities, reading for “different
purposes,” and review.
12. SuccessfulStrategies withELLs
Speak slowly, listening
centers, read
instructions out loud,
low-stakes writing and
reading.
Games, cooperative
learning,
think/pair/share,
experiential education.
Give examples of
successful projects, use
checks for
understanding, oral
language tools.
Partner work at mixed
levels, groups work,
think-pair-shares,
independent work,
review.
Outlines, advanced
organizer, visual guides,
write key concepts
down.
Model new skills and be
explicit about
acquisition of langauge.
Let students use native
language to support
learning.
Picture glossary, word
walls, vocabulary walls,
visual clues.
Repetition, consistent
use of terms, allow
errors to happen.
http://edutopia-dl-support-strategies-ell.pdf
14. Text Difficulty?
• This all depends on the context and your
objectives.
• Independent Reading: should be right around
your level or below (for struggling readers). For
non-struggling readers, independent reading can
be higher.
• Mediated Reading: Should be at a higher level
(grade level).
15. What is book club?
• Options: Content Area, Literary-Focused Curricula,
Teacher Read Aloud OR Guided Reading.
• Framework:
• Opening Community Share
• Reading Component
• Writing Component
• Discussion Component
• Closing Community Share
* Framework introduced in Book Club Plus text by: Raphael, T. E., Florio-
Ruane, S., George, M., Hasty, N. L., & Highfield, K. (2004)
18. Writing in Book Club
Writing
Objectives in
Book Club
Writing Into Writing Through Writing Out
Raphael, T. E., Florio-Ruane, S., George, M., Hasty, N. L., & Highfield, K. (2004)
19. Book Club: What’s to Say?
Talk
Surface
Knowledge
Text Inquiry
Theme
Inquiry
Reflection
20. Most Importantly: HAVE FUN!
• Share stories.
• Talk about things that are confusing in the text.
• Draw connections (personal, with other texts, with your
environment, with the world, etc.).
• Provide support (Before, During and After Reading).
• Allow time to re-visit, re-read, review.
• Does the book have a movie? Have a movie day!
• How are you going to pick your next book?
21. References
Text:
• Raphael, T. E., Florio-Ruane, S., George, M., Hasty, N. L., & Highfield, K.
(2004). Book Club Plus! A Literacy Framework for the Primary Grades.
Lawrence, MA: Small Planet Communications, Inc.
• Temple, C., Martinez, M., & Yokota, J. (2011). Children’s Books in
Children’s Hands-An Introduction to Their Literature (Fourth ed.).
Boston: Allyn & Bacon.
Online:
• http://edutopia-dl-support-strategies-ell.pdf
• www.alexiscullerton.com
• http://sisaljournal.org/archives/mar11/marland/
• http://www.scholastic.com/teachers/article/success-esl-students
• http://www.readingrockets.org/article/what-does-research-tell-us-
about-teaching-reading-english-language-learners
Editor's Notes
Define how the following topics work their way into a definition of LITERACY:
the emergence of literacy has to take into account broad social, cultural, and historic trends related to the significance and reading and writing for human cognition and communication.
It includes development, social learning, and mediation.
The needs, interests, and language levels of English language learners?
Access to text?
Motivation?
Young learners; Concept books, ABC books, board books,
Not static, can be used in a variety of combinations, depend on decisions about themes, related literature selections, organization, grouping and more…
Opening community share: mini lesson on knowledge appropriate to the age level and theme
Reading Component: teacher led, student led, small groups, individual
Writing component: response logs, respond to what has been read and create new texts
Discussion component: fishbowl, small groups, partners, etc.
Closing community share: linking the reading, writing, and discussion to theme.
1: comprehension instruction should be explicit
2: comprehension strategies must be modeled by more knowledgeable others, including teachers and peers.
3: comprehension strategies must be scaffolded by the teacher until students are able to apply the strategies successfully during independent reading and response to reading.
Students need to know that reading text is a process of making meaning and that good readers use tools and strategies to help them make meaning. Name strategies, so they are easy to recall, describe the benefits.
Talking about it is not enough. Teacher think or talk aloud allows students to see how strategies are applied. Multiple exposure to good modeling is necessary for students to be able to utilize strategies independently.
As strategies are learned, teacher steps back. 4 phases: 1. teacher explicitly states strategy 2. teacher and student work together with QAR, 3. students more independent, partner or group work, 4. student has full responsibility
Background Knowledge:
“What do I already know that helps me step into the world created by this text?” Concepts of print
Making predictions
Using context clues
Making intertextual connections
Developing vocabulary
Text-processing:
“What can I do to make sense of the text as I move through this text world? Sequencing
Visualizing
Identifying Key Events
Making inferences
Understanding literary elements
Using genre knowledge
Using perspective
Using knowledge of text structure
Monitoring strategies:
“How do I know if the meanings I’ve created make sense?”
Evaluating and adjusting predictions
Asking questions
Clarifying
INTO: set the stage; access or highlight relevant background knowledge; raise questions, set purposes, and create guiding questions; foster word consciousness; connect to self and connect self to texts
THROUGH: chart information; identify important information; identify supporting details; identify plot points; explore characters and setting
OUT: Reflect and respond (personal, creative, critical), make text-to-self, text-to-text, and text-to-theme connections; extend text concepts