SlideShare a Scribd company logo
Subways and Urban Air Pollution
Marco Gonzalez-Navarro, UC-Berkeley
Does the construction of a new subway transportation
system lead to city-wide air quality improvements?
What do we know?
• Positive automobile traffic and air pollution relationship has been well
documented (Chen et al 2016)
• Subways reduce vehicular traffic (Anderson 2014)
• Chen and Whalley (2012) studies subway opening and air quality for a
single city (Taipei)
Subway data
• Average number of stations opened 14
• Daily average ridership 18 months after opening 130,000
• Average city population 4 million
Subway data
Air pollution data
City level air pollution data: Palma, Spain
Research design
• We compare air quality outcomes before to after the subway begins
service in each city to causally estimate the impacts of subways on air
quality
Average effects
Heterogeneous effects by initial air quality
Above median air pollution cities Below median air pollution cities
Coefficient estimate Coefficient estimate
Standarderror
Standarderror
Other dimensions of heterogeneity
• Subways with high levels of ridership reduce pollution more
• New subway openings reduce more pollution than expansions of existing
systems.
Estimated longer term impacts among high pollution cities
-7%
-6%
-5%
-4%
-3%
-2%
-1%
0%
year 1 year 2 year 3 year 4
How much should we value these pollution reductions?
• Take 1: We rely on studies estimating the relationship between pollution
levels and infant mortality (e.g. Arceo, Hanna and Oliva 2016)
• In an average high AOD city, we estimate an improvement of 3.2μg/m3 in
PM10 levels ≈ saving 22.5 infant lives per year ≈ 43 million USD per year.
• Using a 5% discount rate and summing up 5 years of effects means this
health externality is valued at 195 million USD
How much should we value these pollution reductions?
• Take 2: Use the Global Burden of Disease Methodology: Maps between
levels of PM2.5 and mortality risk ratios for all ages.
• In an average high AOD city, we estimate an improvement of 1.7μg/m3 in
PM2.5 levels ≈ saving 500 lives per year ≈ 1 billion USD per year.
• Using a 5% discount rate and summing up 5 years of effects means this
health externality is valued at 4.5 billion USD
Conclusions
• Existing estimate of the effects of particulates on mortality suggest they
are sufficiently harmful that for initially high pollution cities (Above 0.36
AOD ≈ 28μg/m3 PM2.5 annual average) the air quality improvements are
economically important.
• The effects are large enough to justify subsidies for subway construction
and operation.

More Related Content

What's hot

6 ecologies-stockholm
6 ecologies-stockholm6 ecologies-stockholm
6 ecologies-stockholm
Greg Wass
 
Vector 10-10-2016 30
Vector  10-10-2016  30Vector  10-10-2016  30
Vector 10-10-2016 30
Roger Dixon
 
Energy and Transport
Energy and TransportEnergy and Transport
Energy and Transport
Hasan Tufan
 
CreateWV Kamenetz Keynote 2009
CreateWV Kamenetz Keynote 2009CreateWV Kamenetz Keynote 2009
CreateWV Kamenetz Keynote 2009
CreateWV
 
Partnerships to Sustain Cape Town
Partnerships to Sustain Cape TownPartnerships to Sustain Cape Town
Partnerships to Sustain Cape Town
Climate Smart Cape Town
 
The role of the regulator in the transformation of the electricity sector
The role of the regulator in the transformation of the electricity sectorThe role of the regulator in the transformation of the electricity sector
The role of the regulator in the transformation of the electricity sector
SustainableEnergyAut
 
Sustainable Transport: The EMBARQ Footprint
Sustainable Transport: The EMBARQ FootprintSustainable Transport: The EMBARQ Footprint
Sustainable Transport: The EMBARQ Footprint
WRI Ross Center for Sustainable Cities
 
Climate Summit Action Areas Transportation1
Climate Summit Action Areas Transportation1Climate Summit Action Areas Transportation1
Climate Summit Action Areas Transportation1
Dr Lendy Spires
 
2021 GGSD Forum - Session 1: Urban transport and city design
2021 GGSD Forum - Session 1: Urban transport and city design2021 GGSD Forum - Session 1: Urban transport and city design
2021 GGSD Forum - Session 1: Urban transport and city design
OECD Environment
 
Getting next generation mobility technologies on the road
Getting next generation mobility technologies on the roadGetting next generation mobility technologies on the road
Getting next generation mobility technologies on the road
ReedExhibitionsMiddl
 
What it all means: solar regulatory world 101
What it all means: solar regulatory world 101What it all means: solar regulatory world 101
What it all means: solar regulatory world 101
Interstate Renewable Energy Council
 
Sustainable transport - will it ever really count?
Sustainable transport - will it ever really count?Sustainable transport - will it ever really count?
Sustainable transport - will it ever really count?
Institute for Transport Studies (ITS)
 
Hank Courtright, EPRI: Realizing the Potential for Energy Efficiency and Car...
Hank Courtright, EPRI: Realizing the Potential for Energy Efficiency and Car...Hank Courtright, EPRI: Realizing the Potential for Energy Efficiency and Car...
Hank Courtright, EPRI: Realizing the Potential for Energy Efficiency and Car...
Alliance To Save Energy
 
Summer Program on Transportation Statistics, What about the Driver in Driver...
Summer Program on Transportation Statistics, What about the Driver in  Driver...Summer Program on Transportation Statistics, What about the Driver in  Driver...
Summer Program on Transportation Statistics, What about the Driver in Driver...
The Statistical and Applied Mathematical Sciences Institute
 
Julie Roberts_Opportunity Dividend Summit
Julie Roberts_Opportunity Dividend SummitJulie Roberts_Opportunity Dividend Summit
Julie Roberts_Opportunity Dividend Summit
reded2
 
2021 GGSD Forum : High-Level Opening Session
2021 GGSD Forum : High-Level Opening Session2021 GGSD Forum : High-Level Opening Session
2021 GGSD Forum : High-Level Opening Session
OECD Environment
 
Bill St Arnaud
Bill St ArnaudBill St Arnaud
Bill St Arnaud
Freedom to Connect
 
DPER’s perspective on the transformation of the electricity sector
DPER’s perspective on the transformation of the electricity sector DPER’s perspective on the transformation of the electricity sector
DPER’s perspective on the transformation of the electricity sector
SustainableEnergyAut
 
Energy-Environment Analysis Framework Iii
Energy-Environment Analysis Framework IiiEnergy-Environment Analysis Framework Iii
Energy-Environment Analysis Framework Iii
gueste4fa13
 

What's hot (19)

6 ecologies-stockholm
6 ecologies-stockholm6 ecologies-stockholm
6 ecologies-stockholm
 
Vector 10-10-2016 30
Vector  10-10-2016  30Vector  10-10-2016  30
Vector 10-10-2016 30
 
Energy and Transport
Energy and TransportEnergy and Transport
Energy and Transport
 
CreateWV Kamenetz Keynote 2009
CreateWV Kamenetz Keynote 2009CreateWV Kamenetz Keynote 2009
CreateWV Kamenetz Keynote 2009
 
Partnerships to Sustain Cape Town
Partnerships to Sustain Cape TownPartnerships to Sustain Cape Town
Partnerships to Sustain Cape Town
 
The role of the regulator in the transformation of the electricity sector
The role of the regulator in the transformation of the electricity sectorThe role of the regulator in the transformation of the electricity sector
The role of the regulator in the transformation of the electricity sector
 
Sustainable Transport: The EMBARQ Footprint
Sustainable Transport: The EMBARQ FootprintSustainable Transport: The EMBARQ Footprint
Sustainable Transport: The EMBARQ Footprint
 
Climate Summit Action Areas Transportation1
Climate Summit Action Areas Transportation1Climate Summit Action Areas Transportation1
Climate Summit Action Areas Transportation1
 
2021 GGSD Forum - Session 1: Urban transport and city design
2021 GGSD Forum - Session 1: Urban transport and city design2021 GGSD Forum - Session 1: Urban transport and city design
2021 GGSD Forum - Session 1: Urban transport and city design
 
Getting next generation mobility technologies on the road
Getting next generation mobility technologies on the roadGetting next generation mobility technologies on the road
Getting next generation mobility technologies on the road
 
What it all means: solar regulatory world 101
What it all means: solar regulatory world 101What it all means: solar regulatory world 101
What it all means: solar regulatory world 101
 
Sustainable transport - will it ever really count?
Sustainable transport - will it ever really count?Sustainable transport - will it ever really count?
Sustainable transport - will it ever really count?
 
Hank Courtright, EPRI: Realizing the Potential for Energy Efficiency and Car...
Hank Courtright, EPRI: Realizing the Potential for Energy Efficiency and Car...Hank Courtright, EPRI: Realizing the Potential for Energy Efficiency and Car...
Hank Courtright, EPRI: Realizing the Potential for Energy Efficiency and Car...
 
Summer Program on Transportation Statistics, What about the Driver in Driver...
Summer Program on Transportation Statistics, What about the Driver in  Driver...Summer Program on Transportation Statistics, What about the Driver in  Driver...
Summer Program on Transportation Statistics, What about the Driver in Driver...
 
Julie Roberts_Opportunity Dividend Summit
Julie Roberts_Opportunity Dividend SummitJulie Roberts_Opportunity Dividend Summit
Julie Roberts_Opportunity Dividend Summit
 
2021 GGSD Forum : High-Level Opening Session
2021 GGSD Forum : High-Level Opening Session2021 GGSD Forum : High-Level Opening Session
2021 GGSD Forum : High-Level Opening Session
 
Bill St Arnaud
Bill St ArnaudBill St Arnaud
Bill St Arnaud
 
DPER’s perspective on the transformation of the electricity sector
DPER’s perspective on the transformation of the electricity sector DPER’s perspective on the transformation of the electricity sector
DPER’s perspective on the transformation of the electricity sector
 
Energy-Environment Analysis Framework Iii
Energy-Environment Analysis Framework IiiEnergy-Environment Analysis Framework Iii
Energy-Environment Analysis Framework Iii
 

Similar to Pathways to Decarbonization & Digital Innovation in Transport: Subways and Urban Air Pollution

Christine McHugh - DMUG 2014
Christine McHugh - DMUG 2014Christine McHugh - DMUG 2014
Christine McHugh - DMUG 2014
IES / IAQM
 
Effects of Air Pollution on Infant and Children Respiratory Mortality in Four...
Effects of Air Pollution on Infant and Children Respiratory Mortality in Four...Effects of Air Pollution on Infant and Children Respiratory Mortality in Four...
Effects of Air Pollution on Infant and Children Respiratory Mortality in Four...
Kinza Irshad
 
BenefitsOfShifFromCarToActiveTransport.pdfTransport Policy.docx
BenefitsOfShifFromCarToActiveTransport.pdfTransport Policy.docxBenefitsOfShifFromCarToActiveTransport.pdfTransport Policy.docx
BenefitsOfShifFromCarToActiveTransport.pdfTransport Policy.docx
AASTHA76
 
Predicting air pollution level
Predicting air pollution levelPredicting air pollution level
Predicting air pollution level
Marwa Tahawi
 
Air Pollution Indices.pptx
Air Pollution Indices.pptxAir Pollution Indices.pptx
Air Pollution Indices.pptx
satyam611442
 
MAJOR-2 (Viva-1).pptx
MAJOR-2 (Viva-1).pptxMAJOR-2 (Viva-1).pptx
MAJOR-2 (Viva-1).pptx
ssuser1fd419
 
the effect of social and economic development on air pollution in indian cities
the effect of social and economic development on air pollution in indian citiesthe effect of social and economic development on air pollution in indian cities
the effect of social and economic development on air pollution in indian cities
Ahammed Aflah E
 
Hemispheric ozone and cooperation - Frank Dentener
Hemispheric ozone and cooperation - Frank DentenerHemispheric ozone and cooperation - Frank Dentener
Hemispheric ozone and cooperation - Frank Dentener
Environmental Protection Agency, Ireland
 
Wang2020
Wang2020Wang2020
Wang2020
SyedAhmedUsman1
 
Presentation IE Raghu Engg College.ppt
Presentation IE Raghu Engg College.pptPresentation IE Raghu Engg College.ppt
Presentation IE Raghu Engg College.ppt
RaghuGhu1
 
Air Pollution Prediction via Differential Evolution Strategies with Random Fo...
Air Pollution Prediction via Differential Evolution Strategies with Random Fo...Air Pollution Prediction via Differential Evolution Strategies with Random Fo...
Air Pollution Prediction via Differential Evolution Strategies with Random Fo...
IRJET Journal
 
Tesfaldet recommendation for prd draft document
Tesfaldet recommendation for prd draft documentTesfaldet recommendation for prd draft document
Tesfaldet recommendation for prd draft document
Tesfaldet Gebregerges
 
Pollution analysis using GIS
Pollution analysis using GISPollution analysis using GIS
Pollution analysis using GIS
Gary Mendonca
 
IRJET - Air Quality Index – A Study to Assess the Air Quality
IRJET - Air Quality Index – A Study to Assess the Air QualityIRJET - Air Quality Index – A Study to Assess the Air Quality
IRJET - Air Quality Index – A Study to Assess the Air Quality
IRJET Journal
 
An Empirical Study of the Environmental Kuznets Curve for Environment Quality...
An Empirical Study of the Environmental Kuznets Curve for Environment Quality...An Empirical Study of the Environmental Kuznets Curve for Environment Quality...
An Empirical Study of the Environmental Kuznets Curve for Environment Quality...
ijceronline
 
Active travel: Benefits and trade-offs - Audrey de Nazelle
Active travel: Benefits and trade-offs - Audrey de NazelleActive travel: Benefits and trade-offs - Audrey de Nazelle
Active travel: Benefits and trade-offs - Audrey de Nazelle
IES / IAQM
 
Quantification of rate of air pollution by means of
Quantification of rate of air pollution by means ofQuantification of rate of air pollution by means of
Quantification of rate of air pollution by means of
IJARBEST JOURNAL
 
Mexico cocontrol final
Mexico cocontrol finalMexico cocontrol final
Mexico cocontrol final
永銓 曠
 
Urban Air Quality Modelling and Simulation: A Case Study of Kolhapur (M.S.), ...
Urban Air Quality Modelling and Simulation: A Case Study of Kolhapur (M.S.), ...Urban Air Quality Modelling and Simulation: A Case Study of Kolhapur (M.S.), ...
Urban Air Quality Modelling and Simulation: A Case Study of Kolhapur (M.S.), ...
IDES Editor
 
Cycling and urban air quality a study of european experiences
Cycling and urban air quality a study of european experiencesCycling and urban air quality a study of european experiences
Cycling and urban air quality a study of european experiences
European Cyclists Federation
 

Similar to Pathways to Decarbonization & Digital Innovation in Transport: Subways and Urban Air Pollution (20)

Christine McHugh - DMUG 2014
Christine McHugh - DMUG 2014Christine McHugh - DMUG 2014
Christine McHugh - DMUG 2014
 
Effects of Air Pollution on Infant and Children Respiratory Mortality in Four...
Effects of Air Pollution on Infant and Children Respiratory Mortality in Four...Effects of Air Pollution on Infant and Children Respiratory Mortality in Four...
Effects of Air Pollution on Infant and Children Respiratory Mortality in Four...
 
BenefitsOfShifFromCarToActiveTransport.pdfTransport Policy.docx
BenefitsOfShifFromCarToActiveTransport.pdfTransport Policy.docxBenefitsOfShifFromCarToActiveTransport.pdfTransport Policy.docx
BenefitsOfShifFromCarToActiveTransport.pdfTransport Policy.docx
 
Predicting air pollution level
Predicting air pollution levelPredicting air pollution level
Predicting air pollution level
 
Air Pollution Indices.pptx
Air Pollution Indices.pptxAir Pollution Indices.pptx
Air Pollution Indices.pptx
 
MAJOR-2 (Viva-1).pptx
MAJOR-2 (Viva-1).pptxMAJOR-2 (Viva-1).pptx
MAJOR-2 (Viva-1).pptx
 
the effect of social and economic development on air pollution in indian cities
the effect of social and economic development on air pollution in indian citiesthe effect of social and economic development on air pollution in indian cities
the effect of social and economic development on air pollution in indian cities
 
Hemispheric ozone and cooperation - Frank Dentener
Hemispheric ozone and cooperation - Frank DentenerHemispheric ozone and cooperation - Frank Dentener
Hemispheric ozone and cooperation - Frank Dentener
 
Wang2020
Wang2020Wang2020
Wang2020
 
Presentation IE Raghu Engg College.ppt
Presentation IE Raghu Engg College.pptPresentation IE Raghu Engg College.ppt
Presentation IE Raghu Engg College.ppt
 
Air Pollution Prediction via Differential Evolution Strategies with Random Fo...
Air Pollution Prediction via Differential Evolution Strategies with Random Fo...Air Pollution Prediction via Differential Evolution Strategies with Random Fo...
Air Pollution Prediction via Differential Evolution Strategies with Random Fo...
 
Tesfaldet recommendation for prd draft document
Tesfaldet recommendation for prd draft documentTesfaldet recommendation for prd draft document
Tesfaldet recommendation for prd draft document
 
Pollution analysis using GIS
Pollution analysis using GISPollution analysis using GIS
Pollution analysis using GIS
 
IRJET - Air Quality Index – A Study to Assess the Air Quality
IRJET - Air Quality Index – A Study to Assess the Air QualityIRJET - Air Quality Index – A Study to Assess the Air Quality
IRJET - Air Quality Index – A Study to Assess the Air Quality
 
An Empirical Study of the Environmental Kuznets Curve for Environment Quality...
An Empirical Study of the Environmental Kuznets Curve for Environment Quality...An Empirical Study of the Environmental Kuznets Curve for Environment Quality...
An Empirical Study of the Environmental Kuznets Curve for Environment Quality...
 
Active travel: Benefits and trade-offs - Audrey de Nazelle
Active travel: Benefits and trade-offs - Audrey de NazelleActive travel: Benefits and trade-offs - Audrey de Nazelle
Active travel: Benefits and trade-offs - Audrey de Nazelle
 
Quantification of rate of air pollution by means of
Quantification of rate of air pollution by means ofQuantification of rate of air pollution by means of
Quantification of rate of air pollution by means of
 
Mexico cocontrol final
Mexico cocontrol finalMexico cocontrol final
Mexico cocontrol final
 
Urban Air Quality Modelling and Simulation: A Case Study of Kolhapur (M.S.), ...
Urban Air Quality Modelling and Simulation: A Case Study of Kolhapur (M.S.), ...Urban Air Quality Modelling and Simulation: A Case Study of Kolhapur (M.S.), ...
Urban Air Quality Modelling and Simulation: A Case Study of Kolhapur (M.S.), ...
 
Cycling and urban air quality a study of european experiences
Cycling and urban air quality a study of european experiencesCycling and urban air quality a study of european experiences
Cycling and urban air quality a study of european experiences
 

More from World Bank Infrastructure

Pathways to Decarbonization & Digital Innovation in Transport: Technology and...
Pathways to Decarbonization & Digital Innovation in Transport: Technology and...Pathways to Decarbonization & Digital Innovation in Transport: Technology and...
Pathways to Decarbonization & Digital Innovation in Transport: Technology and...
World Bank Infrastructure
 
Pathways to Decarbonization & Digital Innovation in Transport: Wither Urban T...
Pathways to Decarbonization & Digital Innovation in Transport: Wither Urban T...Pathways to Decarbonization & Digital Innovation in Transport: Wither Urban T...
Pathways to Decarbonization & Digital Innovation in Transport: Wither Urban T...
World Bank Infrastructure
 
Pathways to Decarbonization & Digital Innovation in Transport: The Role of El...
Pathways to Decarbonization & Digital Innovation in Transport: The Role of El...Pathways to Decarbonization & Digital Innovation in Transport: The Role of El...
Pathways to Decarbonization & Digital Innovation in Transport: The Role of El...
World Bank Infrastructure
 
Pathways to Decarbonization & Digital Innovation in Energy: Prospects for Hyd...
Pathways to Decarbonization & Digital Innovation in Energy: Prospects for Hyd...Pathways to Decarbonization & Digital Innovation in Energy: Prospects for Hyd...
Pathways to Decarbonization & Digital Innovation in Energy: Prospects for Hyd...
World Bank Infrastructure
 
Pathways to Decarbonization & Digital Innovation in Energy: Making Better Dec...
Pathways to Decarbonization & Digital Innovation in Energy: Making Better Dec...Pathways to Decarbonization & Digital Innovation in Energy: Making Better Dec...
Pathways to Decarbonization & Digital Innovation in Energy: Making Better Dec...
World Bank Infrastructure
 
Lightning Talk - Transport: Transit Reforms and Ride-Hailing
Lightning Talk - Transport: Transit Reforms and Ride-HailingLightning Talk - Transport: Transit Reforms and Ride-Hailing
Lightning Talk - Transport: Transit Reforms and Ride-Hailing
World Bank Infrastructure
 
Lightning Talk - Transport: Reinventing the Car: Technology vs. Culture
Lightning Talk - Transport: Reinventing the Car: Technology vs. CultureLightning Talk - Transport: Reinventing the Car: Technology vs. Culture
Lightning Talk - Transport: Reinventing the Car: Technology vs. Culture
World Bank Infrastructure
 
Lightning Talk - Transport: Lessons from Vehicle Taxation and Restrictions
Lightning Talk - Transport: Lessons from Vehicle Taxation and RestrictionsLightning Talk - Transport: Lessons from Vehicle Taxation and Restrictions
Lightning Talk - Transport: Lessons from Vehicle Taxation and Restrictions
World Bank Infrastructure
 
Lightning Talk - Transport: Ecological Footprint of Transportation Infrastruc...
Lightning Talk - Transport: Ecological Footprint of Transportation Infrastruc...Lightning Talk - Transport: Ecological Footprint of Transportation Infrastruc...
Lightning Talk - Transport: Ecological Footprint of Transportation Infrastruc...
World Bank Infrastructure
 
Lightning Talk - Transport: Overcoming Deadhead in the Trucking Industry Usin...
Lightning Talk - Transport: Overcoming Deadhead in the Trucking Industry Usin...Lightning Talk - Transport: Overcoming Deadhead in the Trucking Industry Usin...
Lightning Talk - Transport: Overcoming Deadhead in the Trucking Industry Usin...
World Bank Infrastructure
 
Lightning Talk - Transport: Effectiveness of Electric Vehicle Incentives in C...
Lightning Talk - Transport: Effectiveness of Electric Vehicle Incentives in C...Lightning Talk - Transport: Effectiveness of Electric Vehicle Incentives in C...
Lightning Talk - Transport: Effectiveness of Electric Vehicle Incentives in C...
World Bank Infrastructure
 
Lightning Talk - Energy: The Economics of Storage and its Role in the Energy ...
Lightning Talk - Energy: The Economics of Storage and its Role in the Energy ...Lightning Talk - Energy: The Economics of Storage and its Role in the Energy ...
Lightning Talk - Energy: The Economics of Storage and its Role in the Energy ...
World Bank Infrastructure
 
Lightning Talk - Energy: How Much Did Feed-in-Tariffs Cost Ukraine Power Sect...
Lightning Talk - Energy: How Much Did Feed-in-Tariffs Cost Ukraine Power Sect...Lightning Talk - Energy: How Much Did Feed-in-Tariffs Cost Ukraine Power Sect...
Lightning Talk - Energy: How Much Did Feed-in-Tariffs Cost Ukraine Power Sect...
World Bank Infrastructure
 
Lightning Talk - Energy: Green Hydrogen Transport Cost Assessment in the Cont...
Lightning Talk - Energy: Green Hydrogen Transport Cost Assessment in the Cont...Lightning Talk - Energy: Green Hydrogen Transport Cost Assessment in the Cont...
Lightning Talk - Energy: Green Hydrogen Transport Cost Assessment in the Cont...
World Bank Infrastructure
 
Lightning Talk - Energy: How Can Smart-Grids Help for Climate Mitigation?
Lightning Talk - Energy: How Can Smart-Grids Help for Climate Mitigation?Lightning Talk - Energy: How Can Smart-Grids Help for Climate Mitigation?
Lightning Talk - Energy: How Can Smart-Grids Help for Climate Mitigation?
World Bank Infrastructure
 
Lightning Talk - Energy: Decarbonizing India’s Electricity System
Lightning Talk - Energy: Decarbonizing India’s Electricity SystemLightning Talk - Energy: Decarbonizing India’s Electricity System
Lightning Talk - Energy: Decarbonizing India’s Electricity System
World Bank Infrastructure
 
Lightning Talk - Energy: Cost of Transition from The Workers’ Perspective
Lightning Talk - Energy: Cost of Transition from The Workers’ PerspectiveLightning Talk - Energy: Cost of Transition from The Workers’ Perspective
Lightning Talk - Energy: Cost of Transition from The Workers’ Perspective
World Bank Infrastructure
 
Developing Country Case Study: Welfare Effect of Road Congestion Pricing in B...
Developing Country Case Study: Welfare Effect of Road Congestion Pricing in B...Developing Country Case Study: Welfare Effect of Road Congestion Pricing in B...
Developing Country Case Study: Welfare Effect of Road Congestion Pricing in B...
World Bank Infrastructure
 
Using EVs to Provide Ancillary Services: Regulatory Challenges
Using EVs to Provide Ancillary Services: Regulatory ChallengesUsing EVs to Provide Ancillary Services: Regulatory Challenges
Using EVs to Provide Ancillary Services: Regulatory Challenges
World Bank Infrastructure
 
Regulating Transport in the Digitised World: The French Experience
 Regulating Transport in the Digitised World: The French Experience Regulating Transport in the Digitised World: The French Experience
Regulating Transport in the Digitised World: The French Experience
World Bank Infrastructure
 

More from World Bank Infrastructure (20)

Pathways to Decarbonization & Digital Innovation in Transport: Technology and...
Pathways to Decarbonization & Digital Innovation in Transport: Technology and...Pathways to Decarbonization & Digital Innovation in Transport: Technology and...
Pathways to Decarbonization & Digital Innovation in Transport: Technology and...
 
Pathways to Decarbonization & Digital Innovation in Transport: Wither Urban T...
Pathways to Decarbonization & Digital Innovation in Transport: Wither Urban T...Pathways to Decarbonization & Digital Innovation in Transport: Wither Urban T...
Pathways to Decarbonization & Digital Innovation in Transport: Wither Urban T...
 
Pathways to Decarbonization & Digital Innovation in Transport: The Role of El...
Pathways to Decarbonization & Digital Innovation in Transport: The Role of El...Pathways to Decarbonization & Digital Innovation in Transport: The Role of El...
Pathways to Decarbonization & Digital Innovation in Transport: The Role of El...
 
Pathways to Decarbonization & Digital Innovation in Energy: Prospects for Hyd...
Pathways to Decarbonization & Digital Innovation in Energy: Prospects for Hyd...Pathways to Decarbonization & Digital Innovation in Energy: Prospects for Hyd...
Pathways to Decarbonization & Digital Innovation in Energy: Prospects for Hyd...
 
Pathways to Decarbonization & Digital Innovation in Energy: Making Better Dec...
Pathways to Decarbonization & Digital Innovation in Energy: Making Better Dec...Pathways to Decarbonization & Digital Innovation in Energy: Making Better Dec...
Pathways to Decarbonization & Digital Innovation in Energy: Making Better Dec...
 
Lightning Talk - Transport: Transit Reforms and Ride-Hailing
Lightning Talk - Transport: Transit Reforms and Ride-HailingLightning Talk - Transport: Transit Reforms and Ride-Hailing
Lightning Talk - Transport: Transit Reforms and Ride-Hailing
 
Lightning Talk - Transport: Reinventing the Car: Technology vs. Culture
Lightning Talk - Transport: Reinventing the Car: Technology vs. CultureLightning Talk - Transport: Reinventing the Car: Technology vs. Culture
Lightning Talk - Transport: Reinventing the Car: Technology vs. Culture
 
Lightning Talk - Transport: Lessons from Vehicle Taxation and Restrictions
Lightning Talk - Transport: Lessons from Vehicle Taxation and RestrictionsLightning Talk - Transport: Lessons from Vehicle Taxation and Restrictions
Lightning Talk - Transport: Lessons from Vehicle Taxation and Restrictions
 
Lightning Talk - Transport: Ecological Footprint of Transportation Infrastruc...
Lightning Talk - Transport: Ecological Footprint of Transportation Infrastruc...Lightning Talk - Transport: Ecological Footprint of Transportation Infrastruc...
Lightning Talk - Transport: Ecological Footprint of Transportation Infrastruc...
 
Lightning Talk - Transport: Overcoming Deadhead in the Trucking Industry Usin...
Lightning Talk - Transport: Overcoming Deadhead in the Trucking Industry Usin...Lightning Talk - Transport: Overcoming Deadhead in the Trucking Industry Usin...
Lightning Talk - Transport: Overcoming Deadhead in the Trucking Industry Usin...
 
Lightning Talk - Transport: Effectiveness of Electric Vehicle Incentives in C...
Lightning Talk - Transport: Effectiveness of Electric Vehicle Incentives in C...Lightning Talk - Transport: Effectiveness of Electric Vehicle Incentives in C...
Lightning Talk - Transport: Effectiveness of Electric Vehicle Incentives in C...
 
Lightning Talk - Energy: The Economics of Storage and its Role in the Energy ...
Lightning Talk - Energy: The Economics of Storage and its Role in the Energy ...Lightning Talk - Energy: The Economics of Storage and its Role in the Energy ...
Lightning Talk - Energy: The Economics of Storage and its Role in the Energy ...
 
Lightning Talk - Energy: How Much Did Feed-in-Tariffs Cost Ukraine Power Sect...
Lightning Talk - Energy: How Much Did Feed-in-Tariffs Cost Ukraine Power Sect...Lightning Talk - Energy: How Much Did Feed-in-Tariffs Cost Ukraine Power Sect...
Lightning Talk - Energy: How Much Did Feed-in-Tariffs Cost Ukraine Power Sect...
 
Lightning Talk - Energy: Green Hydrogen Transport Cost Assessment in the Cont...
Lightning Talk - Energy: Green Hydrogen Transport Cost Assessment in the Cont...Lightning Talk - Energy: Green Hydrogen Transport Cost Assessment in the Cont...
Lightning Talk - Energy: Green Hydrogen Transport Cost Assessment in the Cont...
 
Lightning Talk - Energy: How Can Smart-Grids Help for Climate Mitigation?
Lightning Talk - Energy: How Can Smart-Grids Help for Climate Mitigation?Lightning Talk - Energy: How Can Smart-Grids Help for Climate Mitigation?
Lightning Talk - Energy: How Can Smart-Grids Help for Climate Mitigation?
 
Lightning Talk - Energy: Decarbonizing India’s Electricity System
Lightning Talk - Energy: Decarbonizing India’s Electricity SystemLightning Talk - Energy: Decarbonizing India’s Electricity System
Lightning Talk - Energy: Decarbonizing India’s Electricity System
 
Lightning Talk - Energy: Cost of Transition from The Workers’ Perspective
Lightning Talk - Energy: Cost of Transition from The Workers’ PerspectiveLightning Talk - Energy: Cost of Transition from The Workers’ Perspective
Lightning Talk - Energy: Cost of Transition from The Workers’ Perspective
 
Developing Country Case Study: Welfare Effect of Road Congestion Pricing in B...
Developing Country Case Study: Welfare Effect of Road Congestion Pricing in B...Developing Country Case Study: Welfare Effect of Road Congestion Pricing in B...
Developing Country Case Study: Welfare Effect of Road Congestion Pricing in B...
 
Using EVs to Provide Ancillary Services: Regulatory Challenges
Using EVs to Provide Ancillary Services: Regulatory ChallengesUsing EVs to Provide Ancillary Services: Regulatory Challenges
Using EVs to Provide Ancillary Services: Regulatory Challenges
 
Regulating Transport in the Digitised World: The French Experience
 Regulating Transport in the Digitised World: The French Experience Regulating Transport in the Digitised World: The French Experience
Regulating Transport in the Digitised World: The French Experience
 

Recently uploaded

PPT Item # 8&9 - Demolition Code Amendments
PPT Item # 8&9 - Demolition Code AmendmentsPPT Item # 8&9 - Demolition Code Amendments
PPT Item # 8&9 - Demolition Code Amendments
ahcitycouncil
 
原版制作(英国Southampton毕业证书)南安普顿大学毕业证录取通知书一模一样
原版制作(英国Southampton毕业证书)南安普顿大学毕业证录取通知书一模一样原版制作(英国Southampton毕业证书)南安普顿大学毕业证录取通知书一模一样
原版制作(英国Southampton毕业证书)南安普顿大学毕业证录取通知书一模一样
3woawyyl
 
A proposed request for information on LIHTC
A proposed request for information on LIHTCA proposed request for information on LIHTC
A proposed request for information on LIHTC
Roger Valdez
 
CBO’s Outlook for U.S. Fertility Rates: 2024 to 2054
CBO’s Outlook for U.S. Fertility Rates: 2024 to 2054CBO’s Outlook for U.S. Fertility Rates: 2024 to 2054
CBO’s Outlook for U.S. Fertility Rates: 2024 to 2054
Congressional Budget Office
 
Combined Illegal, Unregulated and Unreported (IUU) Vessel List.
Combined Illegal, Unregulated and Unreported (IUU) Vessel List.Combined Illegal, Unregulated and Unreported (IUU) Vessel List.
Combined Illegal, Unregulated and Unreported (IUU) Vessel List.
Christina Parmionova
 
Monitoring Health for the SDGs - Global Health Statistics 2024 - WHO
Monitoring Health for the SDGs - Global Health Statistics 2024 - WHOMonitoring Health for the SDGs - Global Health Statistics 2024 - WHO
Monitoring Health for the SDGs - Global Health Statistics 2024 - WHO
Christina Parmionova
 
快速办理(UVM毕业证书)佛蒙特大学毕业证学位证一模一样
快速办理(UVM毕业证书)佛蒙特大学毕业证学位证一模一样快速办理(UVM毕业证书)佛蒙特大学毕业证学位证一模一样
快速办理(UVM毕业证书)佛蒙特大学毕业证学位证一模一样
yemqpj
 
RFP for Reno's Community Assistance Center
RFP for Reno's Community Assistance CenterRFP for Reno's Community Assistance Center
RFP for Reno's Community Assistance Center
This Is Reno
 
State crafting: Changes and challenges for managing the public finances
State crafting: Changes and challenges for managing the public financesState crafting: Changes and challenges for managing the public finances
State crafting: Changes and challenges for managing the public finances
ResolutionFoundation
 
2024: The FAR - Federal Acquisition Regulations, Part 39
2024: The FAR - Federal Acquisition Regulations, Part 392024: The FAR - Federal Acquisition Regulations, Part 39
2024: The FAR - Federal Acquisition Regulations, Part 39
JSchaus & Associates
 
快速办理(Bristol毕业证书)布里斯托大学毕业证Offer一模一样
快速办理(Bristol毕业证书)布里斯托大学毕业证Offer一模一样快速办理(Bristol毕业证书)布里斯托大学毕业证Offer一模一样
快速办理(Bristol毕业证书)布里斯托大学毕业证Offer一模一样
3woawyyl
 
Indira P.S Vs sub Collector Kochi - The settlement register is not a holy cow...
Indira P.S Vs sub Collector Kochi - The settlement register is not a holy cow...Indira P.S Vs sub Collector Kochi - The settlement register is not a holy cow...
Indira P.S Vs sub Collector Kochi - The settlement register is not a holy cow...
Jamesadhikaram land matter consultancy 9447464502
 
快速制作(ocad毕业证书)加拿大安大略艺术设计学院毕业证本科学历雅思成绩单原版一模一样
快速制作(ocad毕业证书)加拿大安大略艺术设计学院毕业证本科学历雅思成绩单原版一模一样快速制作(ocad毕业证书)加拿大安大略艺术设计学院毕业证本科学历雅思成绩单原版一模一样
快速制作(ocad毕业证书)加拿大安大略艺术设计学院毕业证本科学历雅思成绩单原版一模一样
850fcj96
 
Preliminary findings _OECD field visits to ten regions in the TSI EU mining r...
Preliminary findings _OECD field visits to ten regions in the TSI EU mining r...Preliminary findings _OECD field visits to ten regions in the TSI EU mining r...
Preliminary findings _OECD field visits to ten regions in the TSI EU mining r...
OECDregions
 
Donate to charity during this holiday season
Donate to charity during this holiday seasonDonate to charity during this holiday season
Donate to charity during this holiday season
SERUDS INDIA
 
PAS PSDF Mop Up Workshop Presentation 2024 .pptx
PAS PSDF Mop Up Workshop Presentation 2024 .pptxPAS PSDF Mop Up Workshop Presentation 2024 .pptx
PAS PSDF Mop Up Workshop Presentation 2024 .pptx
PAS_Team
 
Bangladesh studies presentation on Liberation War 1971 Indepence-of-Banglades...
Bangladesh studies presentation on Liberation War 1971 Indepence-of-Banglades...Bangladesh studies presentation on Liberation War 1971 Indepence-of-Banglades...
Bangladesh studies presentation on Liberation War 1971 Indepence-of-Banglades...
ssuser05e8f3
 
2024: The FAR - Federal Acquisition Regulations, Part 38
2024: The FAR - Federal Acquisition Regulations, Part 382024: The FAR - Federal Acquisition Regulations, Part 38
2024: The FAR - Federal Acquisition Regulations, Part 38
JSchaus & Associates
 
Invitation Letter for an alumni association
Invitation Letter for an alumni associationInvitation Letter for an alumni association
Invitation Letter for an alumni association
elmerdalida001
 
Researching the client.pptxsxssssssssssssssssssssss
Researching the client.pptxsxssssssssssssssssssssssResearching the client.pptxsxssssssssssssssssssssss
Researching the client.pptxsxssssssssssssssssssssss
DanielOliver74
 

Recently uploaded (20)

PPT Item # 8&9 - Demolition Code Amendments
PPT Item # 8&9 - Demolition Code AmendmentsPPT Item # 8&9 - Demolition Code Amendments
PPT Item # 8&9 - Demolition Code Amendments
 
原版制作(英国Southampton毕业证书)南安普顿大学毕业证录取通知书一模一样
原版制作(英国Southampton毕业证书)南安普顿大学毕业证录取通知书一模一样原版制作(英国Southampton毕业证书)南安普顿大学毕业证录取通知书一模一样
原版制作(英国Southampton毕业证书)南安普顿大学毕业证录取通知书一模一样
 
A proposed request for information on LIHTC
A proposed request for information on LIHTCA proposed request for information on LIHTC
A proposed request for information on LIHTC
 
CBO’s Outlook for U.S. Fertility Rates: 2024 to 2054
CBO’s Outlook for U.S. Fertility Rates: 2024 to 2054CBO’s Outlook for U.S. Fertility Rates: 2024 to 2054
CBO’s Outlook for U.S. Fertility Rates: 2024 to 2054
 
Combined Illegal, Unregulated and Unreported (IUU) Vessel List.
Combined Illegal, Unregulated and Unreported (IUU) Vessel List.Combined Illegal, Unregulated and Unreported (IUU) Vessel List.
Combined Illegal, Unregulated and Unreported (IUU) Vessel List.
 
Monitoring Health for the SDGs - Global Health Statistics 2024 - WHO
Monitoring Health for the SDGs - Global Health Statistics 2024 - WHOMonitoring Health for the SDGs - Global Health Statistics 2024 - WHO
Monitoring Health for the SDGs - Global Health Statistics 2024 - WHO
 
快速办理(UVM毕业证书)佛蒙特大学毕业证学位证一模一样
快速办理(UVM毕业证书)佛蒙特大学毕业证学位证一模一样快速办理(UVM毕业证书)佛蒙特大学毕业证学位证一模一样
快速办理(UVM毕业证书)佛蒙特大学毕业证学位证一模一样
 
RFP for Reno's Community Assistance Center
RFP for Reno's Community Assistance CenterRFP for Reno's Community Assistance Center
RFP for Reno's Community Assistance Center
 
State crafting: Changes and challenges for managing the public finances
State crafting: Changes and challenges for managing the public financesState crafting: Changes and challenges for managing the public finances
State crafting: Changes and challenges for managing the public finances
 
2024: The FAR - Federal Acquisition Regulations, Part 39
2024: The FAR - Federal Acquisition Regulations, Part 392024: The FAR - Federal Acquisition Regulations, Part 39
2024: The FAR - Federal Acquisition Regulations, Part 39
 
快速办理(Bristol毕业证书)布里斯托大学毕业证Offer一模一样
快速办理(Bristol毕业证书)布里斯托大学毕业证Offer一模一样快速办理(Bristol毕业证书)布里斯托大学毕业证Offer一模一样
快速办理(Bristol毕业证书)布里斯托大学毕业证Offer一模一样
 
Indira P.S Vs sub Collector Kochi - The settlement register is not a holy cow...
Indira P.S Vs sub Collector Kochi - The settlement register is not a holy cow...Indira P.S Vs sub Collector Kochi - The settlement register is not a holy cow...
Indira P.S Vs sub Collector Kochi - The settlement register is not a holy cow...
 
快速制作(ocad毕业证书)加拿大安大略艺术设计学院毕业证本科学历雅思成绩单原版一模一样
快速制作(ocad毕业证书)加拿大安大略艺术设计学院毕业证本科学历雅思成绩单原版一模一样快速制作(ocad毕业证书)加拿大安大略艺术设计学院毕业证本科学历雅思成绩单原版一模一样
快速制作(ocad毕业证书)加拿大安大略艺术设计学院毕业证本科学历雅思成绩单原版一模一样
 
Preliminary findings _OECD field visits to ten regions in the TSI EU mining r...
Preliminary findings _OECD field visits to ten regions in the TSI EU mining r...Preliminary findings _OECD field visits to ten regions in the TSI EU mining r...
Preliminary findings _OECD field visits to ten regions in the TSI EU mining r...
 
Donate to charity during this holiday season
Donate to charity during this holiday seasonDonate to charity during this holiday season
Donate to charity during this holiday season
 
PAS PSDF Mop Up Workshop Presentation 2024 .pptx
PAS PSDF Mop Up Workshop Presentation 2024 .pptxPAS PSDF Mop Up Workshop Presentation 2024 .pptx
PAS PSDF Mop Up Workshop Presentation 2024 .pptx
 
Bangladesh studies presentation on Liberation War 1971 Indepence-of-Banglades...
Bangladesh studies presentation on Liberation War 1971 Indepence-of-Banglades...Bangladesh studies presentation on Liberation War 1971 Indepence-of-Banglades...
Bangladesh studies presentation on Liberation War 1971 Indepence-of-Banglades...
 
2024: The FAR - Federal Acquisition Regulations, Part 38
2024: The FAR - Federal Acquisition Regulations, Part 382024: The FAR - Federal Acquisition Regulations, Part 38
2024: The FAR - Federal Acquisition Regulations, Part 38
 
Invitation Letter for an alumni association
Invitation Letter for an alumni associationInvitation Letter for an alumni association
Invitation Letter for an alumni association
 
Researching the client.pptxsxssssssssssssssssssssss
Researching the client.pptxsxssssssssssssssssssssssResearching the client.pptxsxssssssssssssssssssssss
Researching the client.pptxsxssssssssssssssssssssss
 

Pathways to Decarbonization & Digital Innovation in Transport: Subways and Urban Air Pollution

  • 1. Subways and Urban Air Pollution Marco Gonzalez-Navarro, UC-Berkeley
  • 2. Does the construction of a new subway transportation system lead to city-wide air quality improvements?
  • 3. What do we know? • Positive automobile traffic and air pollution relationship has been well documented (Chen et al 2016) • Subways reduce vehicular traffic (Anderson 2014) • Chen and Whalley (2012) studies subway opening and air quality for a single city (Taipei)
  • 4. Subway data • Average number of stations opened 14 • Daily average ridership 18 months after opening 130,000 • Average city population 4 million
  • 7. City level air pollution data: Palma, Spain
  • 8. Research design • We compare air quality outcomes before to after the subway begins service in each city to causally estimate the impacts of subways on air quality
  • 10. Heterogeneous effects by initial air quality Above median air pollution cities Below median air pollution cities Coefficient estimate Coefficient estimate Standarderror Standarderror
  • 11. Other dimensions of heterogeneity • Subways with high levels of ridership reduce pollution more • New subway openings reduce more pollution than expansions of existing systems.
  • 12. Estimated longer term impacts among high pollution cities -7% -6% -5% -4% -3% -2% -1% 0% year 1 year 2 year 3 year 4
  • 13. How much should we value these pollution reductions? • Take 1: We rely on studies estimating the relationship between pollution levels and infant mortality (e.g. Arceo, Hanna and Oliva 2016) • In an average high AOD city, we estimate an improvement of 3.2μg/m3 in PM10 levels ≈ saving 22.5 infant lives per year ≈ 43 million USD per year. • Using a 5% discount rate and summing up 5 years of effects means this health externality is valued at 195 million USD
  • 14. How much should we value these pollution reductions? • Take 2: Use the Global Burden of Disease Methodology: Maps between levels of PM2.5 and mortality risk ratios for all ages. • In an average high AOD city, we estimate an improvement of 1.7μg/m3 in PM2.5 levels ≈ saving 500 lives per year ≈ 1 billion USD per year. • Using a 5% discount rate and summing up 5 years of effects means this health externality is valued at 4.5 billion USD
  • 15. Conclusions • Existing estimate of the effects of particulates on mortality suggest they are sufficiently harmful that for initially high pollution cities (Above 0.36 AOD ≈ 28μg/m3 PM2.5 annual average) the air quality improvements are economically important. • The effects are large enough to justify subsidies for subway construction and operation.