Open Educational
                Resources
Lesmateriaal? Open moet het zijn!




Prof. dr. Frederik Questier
Vrije Universiteit Brussel

Seminarie onderwijskunde 5: digitaal leren
Vlaamse Chamilo gebruikersdag
University College Ghent, 25/05/2011
This presentation can be found at
             http://questier.com
http://www.slideshare.net/Frederik_Questier
My background




                         Frederik Questier
Werken met portfolio's          May 2011
04/10/05 | pag. 3                        3
My research interests




Copyleft Frederik Questier, Vrije Universiteit Brussel   4
Research and Innovation Director




                                   Frederik Questier
Werken met portfolio's                    May 2011
04/10/05 | pag. 5                                  5
Our social responsibility:
              how open is the future?
                                    Frederik Questier
Werken met portfolio's                     May 2011
04/10/05 | pag. 6                                   6
Student PIRGs
    (Public Interest Research Groups)

➢   “(US) students spend an average of $900
    a year on textbooks and course materials”

➢   “Textbook prices have increased four times
    the rate of inflation since 1994!”
Student PIRGs
        (Public Interest Research Groups)
➢   “Why are textbooks so expensive?
    ➢   Publishers undermine the used book market.
    ➢   Publishers “bundle” textbooks with extra CDs,
        passcodes and workbooks.
         ➢   More expensive
         ➢   Supplements expire at end of semester
    ➢   Publishers keep faculty in the dark about prices.
         ➢   textbooks market is broken”
Electronic books?

    ➢    Would you buy or advise your students
           ➢    electronic versions of (educational) books
           ➢    if they were 30% cheaper than paper books
           ➢    maybe many books on a good reading device ~ paper?
                              ➢




    ➢    Be aware: often
           ➢    limited to 1 year
                  ➢      no access in the higher years of study
           ➢    limited to buyer
                  ➢      no second hand buying or sale
                  ➢      no library
           ➢    no extensive printing
                                                                  Frederik Questier
Werken met portfolio's                                                   May 2011
04/10/05 | pag. 11                                                              11
Expensive and incompatible




                                                Frederik Questier
Werken met portfolio's                                 May 2011
04/10/05 | pag. 12                                            12
Text To Speech software
                         on e-books
    ➢    Blessing for the blind

    ➢    'Copyright violation' according to
         'Author's Guild' (publishers)

    → TTS disabled in Amazon Kindle 2
       Remote kill flags discovered!




                                              Frederik Questier
Werken met portfolio's                               May 2011
04/10/05 | pag. 13                                          13
DRM:
                                    Digital Rights Management or
                                    Digital Restrictions Management?

    ➢    Restricted
           ➢    export
                  ➢      copying
                  ➢      printing
                  ➢      Text To Speech
           ➢    in time
           ➢    to buyer (no second hand market)
                  ➢      biometric identification
                  ➢      user info “inscribed” in the work (Microsoft Reader)
                  ➢      access info sent back to publisher
           ➢    to certain hardware (e.g. Mac OS X - Apple hardware)
           ➢    to geographic regions
                                                                                Frederik Questier
Werken met portfolio's                                                                 May 2011
04/10/05 | pag. 14                                                                            14
DRM

    ➢    is killing innovation
    ➢    can prevent legal rights such as
           ➢    fair use private copying
           ➢    time shifting
           ➢    lending services (library)
           ➢    2nd hand resale of works
           ➢    donation
           ➢    access for disabled
           ➢    archival
           ➢    public domain
           ➢    …
                                             Frederik Questier
Werken met portfolio's                              May 2011
04/10/05 | pag. 15                                         15
"The most fundamental
  way of helping other
          people,
   is to teach people
how to do things better
 or how to better their
           lives.

       For people
  who use computers,
  this means sharing
       the recipes
    you use on your
        computer,
     in other words
the programs you run."
                          16
Free Software
          (“Open Source Software”)
➢   The freedom to
    ➢   use
    ➢   study
    ➢   distribute
    ➢   improve

        the program

                                     17
Free Software

includes great software like




                               18
19
20
Mass collaboration works amazingly
   for software development...


  What about learning materials?



                                     21
First of all:

    Copyright law
is not really helpful...




                           22
Lady Justice
  has lost her
sense of balance




                   23
Copyright
           th              st
         18 century vs 21 century
➢   “for the encouragement of learning”        ➢   Economic motives

➢   “to promote the progress of science

    and useful arts”

➢   Protection on request of author            ➢   Protection automatically
     ➢   14+14y                                     ➢   Till 70y after death author

     ➢   Protect authors against publishers         ➢   Publishers demand the copyrights

     ➢   If you give copy to every library

➢   Private and non-commercial reproductions
                                               ➢   “Private copiers are pirates”

    allowed
                                               ➢   Protection for DRM
There are nice exceptions
  on reproduction and publication rights
 for educational and scientific purposes


But we need the permission of the authors
     if we want to modify their works
Creative Commons

  ➢    www.creativecommons.org
         Share what you
         want,
         keep what you want




  ➢    6 combinations of
                ➢   Commercial      – no commercial use allowed
                ➢   Modifications   – no modifications allowed
                ➢   Sharealike      – not sharealike
                                                                  Frederik Questier
Werken met portfolio's                                                   May 2011
04/10/05 | pag. 26                                                              26
Creative Commons

    ➢    Movie
           ➢    Wanna work together?
           ➢    http://support.creativecommons.org/videos/#wwt




                                                                 Frederik Questier
Werken met portfolio's                                                  May 2011
04/10/05 | pag. 29                                                             29
Open educational resources
         (OER)
             digitised materials
         offered freely and openly
for educators, students and self-learners
             to use and reuse
   for teaching, learning and research
Why
      OER
          ?
Why Open Course Ware?

    ➢    Why not: should we consider academic knowledge as
         (secret) Intellectual Property?
           ➢    The dark ages of scarcity of information are over!

    ➢    (Peer) recognition
           ➢    for teacher
                  ➢      Whose course is referred to most?
                          ➢   Yours or the one one from your 'competitor'?
           ➢    for university/schools



                                                                             Frederik Questier
Werken met portfolio's                                                              May 2011
04/10/05 | pag. 32                                                                         32
Why Open Course Ware?

    ➢    Increase quality
           ➢    Teachers working together
           ➢    Best course modules are
                  ➢      reused most often
                  ➢      getting most feedback
                  ➢      getting better again

    ➢    Saving time & costs
           ➢    Teachers can start building course from existing material
           ➢    Creation of animated or interactive learning objects is
                often too expensive for development/use by only one
                institution
                                                                  Frederik Questier
Werken met portfolio's                                                   May 2011
04/10/05 | pag. 33                                                              33
UNESCO
                 Believing that OER can
           widen access to quality education,
       particularly when shared by many countries
            and higher education institutions,

               UNESCO champions OER
   as a means of promoting access, equity and quality
in the spirit of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights.
ocw.mit.edu (CCPL)
www.merlot.org
cnx.org




                                   Frederik Questier
Werken met portfolio's                    May 2011
04/10/05 | pag. 39                               39
www.gutenberg.org
 (public domain)
www.flatworldknowledge.com
          (CCPL)
(Firefox) Creative Commons Search
Does your VLE look like this
     to the outside world?




                                    Frederik Questier
Werken met portfolio's                     May 2011
04/10/05 | pag. 47                                47
Closed?
➢   The few good reasons for closing an LMS,
    are probably the reasons why the LMS is
    not dead yet...

    ➢   Copyright exemptions for education
    ➢   Privacy
        ➢   for minors
        ➢   for making mistakes
        ➢   for teachers?
                                               48
But all the rest should be open!




                                   49
Open
➢   Open Source
➢   Open Standards
➢   Open Courseware
➢   (OpenID)
    ➢   Sharing students and teachers between VLEs
        ➢   + Portability
    ➢   Enable instutional collaboration
➢   (Open Framework)
    ➢   Sharing apps between VLEs
                                                     50
These generic repositories in
     Chamilo 2.0 are nice




                                     Frederik Questier
Werken met portfolio's                      May 2011
04/10/05 | pag. 51                                 51
Specialized learning object
         repositories are nicer!




S. Ternier et al., Interoperability for Searching Learning Object Repositories: The ProLearn Query
Language, D-Lib Magazine, 2008, Volume 14 Number 1/2, doi:10.1045/january2008-ceri
                                                                                                     52
Let's avoid the
  empty box
    feeling!      53
But content is no longer king!




                                 54
What is good learning?

       Jonassen's Model for
(constructive) learning environments




                                       55
wikibooks.org




                                         Frederik Questier
Werken met portfolio's                          May 2011
04/10/05 | pag. 56                                     56
Example made with my students
  nl.wikibooks.org/wiki/Onderwijstechnologie




                                               Frederik Questier
Werken met portfolio's                                May 2011
04/10/05 | pag. 57                                           57
Student portfolios
           Experiences with
           open publication
   and student defined access control

            Extra motivating

               Copyright!
         Privacy of patients etc

       Student awareness needed!
Block search engines through robots.txt ;)
I'GLO

           Students create

Interaction Generating Learning Objects


           research project
          Artesis Hogeschool
OER Barriers?
➢   Awareness
➢   Teachers attitude
➢   Not enough OER yet
➢   Copyright
➢   Limitations of LMS? (licenses, access control)
➢   Funding
➢   Institutional policy
➢   ?
DARE
                                                         TO SHARE




Copyleft Frederik Questier, Vrije Universiteit Brussel         63
Que
     stio
Tha      ns?
   n ks
       !
Credits
➢   Open Neon light CC by-nc-nd-by by “late night movie” [Mart]
➢   T-Shirt “Best things are life are free” by http://zazzle.com
➢   Lady Justitia CC by-nc-nd By lumierefl (Flickr)
➢   “Sorry. We're closed” CC by-nc by Tommaso Galli
➢   OPEN, CC-by-nc-sa by Tom Magliery
➢   Empty box, CC by-nc-nd by Mike Bitzenhofer
➢   Share matches CC by-nc-nd by Josh Harper
➢   Question mark CC by by Stefan Baudy

Open educational resources

  • 1.
    Open Educational Resources Lesmateriaal? Open moet het zijn! Prof. dr. Frederik Questier Vrije Universiteit Brussel Seminarie onderwijskunde 5: digitaal leren Vlaamse Chamilo gebruikersdag University College Ghent, 25/05/2011
  • 2.
    This presentation canbe found at http://questier.com http://www.slideshare.net/Frederik_Questier
  • 3.
    My background Frederik Questier Werken met portfolio's May 2011 04/10/05 | pag. 3 3
  • 4.
    My research interests CopyleftFrederik Questier, Vrije Universiteit Brussel 4
  • 5.
    Research and InnovationDirector Frederik Questier Werken met portfolio's May 2011 04/10/05 | pag. 5 5
  • 6.
    Our social responsibility: how open is the future? Frederik Questier Werken met portfolio's May 2011 04/10/05 | pag. 6 6
  • 7.
    Student PIRGs (Public Interest Research Groups) ➢ “(US) students spend an average of $900 a year on textbooks and course materials” ➢ “Textbook prices have increased four times the rate of inflation since 1994!”
  • 8.
    Student PIRGs (Public Interest Research Groups) ➢ “Why are textbooks so expensive? ➢ Publishers undermine the used book market. ➢ Publishers “bundle” textbooks with extra CDs, passcodes and workbooks. ➢ More expensive ➢ Supplements expire at end of semester ➢ Publishers keep faculty in the dark about prices. ➢ textbooks market is broken”
  • 10.
    Electronic books? ➢ Would you buy or advise your students ➢ electronic versions of (educational) books ➢ if they were 30% cheaper than paper books ➢ maybe many books on a good reading device ~ paper? ➢ ➢ Be aware: often ➢ limited to 1 year ➢ no access in the higher years of study ➢ limited to buyer ➢ no second hand buying or sale ➢ no library ➢ no extensive printing Frederik Questier Werken met portfolio's May 2011 04/10/05 | pag. 11 11
  • 11.
    Expensive and incompatible Frederik Questier Werken met portfolio's May 2011 04/10/05 | pag. 12 12
  • 12.
    Text To Speechsoftware on e-books ➢ Blessing for the blind ➢ 'Copyright violation' according to 'Author's Guild' (publishers) → TTS disabled in Amazon Kindle 2 Remote kill flags discovered! Frederik Questier Werken met portfolio's May 2011 04/10/05 | pag. 13 13
  • 13.
    DRM: Digital Rights Management or Digital Restrictions Management? ➢ Restricted ➢ export ➢ copying ➢ printing ➢ Text To Speech ➢ in time ➢ to buyer (no second hand market) ➢ biometric identification ➢ user info “inscribed” in the work (Microsoft Reader) ➢ access info sent back to publisher ➢ to certain hardware (e.g. Mac OS X - Apple hardware) ➢ to geographic regions Frederik Questier Werken met portfolio's May 2011 04/10/05 | pag. 14 14
  • 14.
    DRM ➢ is killing innovation ➢ can prevent legal rights such as ➢ fair use private copying ➢ time shifting ➢ lending services (library) ➢ 2nd hand resale of works ➢ donation ➢ access for disabled ➢ archival ➢ public domain ➢ … Frederik Questier Werken met portfolio's May 2011 04/10/05 | pag. 15 15
  • 15.
    "The most fundamental way of helping other people, is to teach people how to do things better or how to better their lives. For people who use computers, this means sharing the recipes you use on your computer, in other words the programs you run." 16
  • 16.
    Free Software (“Open Source Software”) ➢ The freedom to ➢ use ➢ study ➢ distribute ➢ improve the program 17
  • 17.
  • 18.
  • 19.
  • 20.
    Mass collaboration worksamazingly for software development... What about learning materials? 21
  • 21.
    First of all: Copyright law is not really helpful... 22
  • 22.
    Lady Justice has lost her sense of balance 23
  • 23.
    Copyright th st 18 century vs 21 century ➢ “for the encouragement of learning” ➢ Economic motives ➢ “to promote the progress of science and useful arts” ➢ Protection on request of author ➢ Protection automatically ➢ 14+14y ➢ Till 70y after death author ➢ Protect authors against publishers ➢ Publishers demand the copyrights ➢ If you give copy to every library ➢ Private and non-commercial reproductions ➢ “Private copiers are pirates” allowed ➢ Protection for DRM
  • 24.
    There are niceexceptions on reproduction and publication rights for educational and scientific purposes But we need the permission of the authors if we want to modify their works
  • 25.
    Creative Commons ➢ www.creativecommons.org Share what you want, keep what you want ➢ 6 combinations of ➢ Commercial – no commercial use allowed ➢ Modifications – no modifications allowed ➢ Sharealike – not sharealike Frederik Questier Werken met portfolio's May 2011 04/10/05 | pag. 26 26
  • 28.
    Creative Commons ➢ Movie ➢ Wanna work together? ➢ http://support.creativecommons.org/videos/#wwt Frederik Questier Werken met portfolio's May 2011 04/10/05 | pag. 29 29
  • 29.
    Open educational resources (OER) digitised materials offered freely and openly for educators, students and self-learners to use and reuse for teaching, learning and research
  • 30.
    Why OER ?
  • 31.
    Why Open CourseWare? ➢ Why not: should we consider academic knowledge as (secret) Intellectual Property? ➢ The dark ages of scarcity of information are over! ➢ (Peer) recognition ➢ for teacher ➢ Whose course is referred to most? ➢ Yours or the one one from your 'competitor'? ➢ for university/schools Frederik Questier Werken met portfolio's May 2011 04/10/05 | pag. 32 32
  • 32.
    Why Open CourseWare? ➢ Increase quality ➢ Teachers working together ➢ Best course modules are ➢ reused most often ➢ getting most feedback ➢ getting better again ➢ Saving time & costs ➢ Teachers can start building course from existing material ➢ Creation of animated or interactive learning objects is often too expensive for development/use by only one institution Frederik Questier Werken met portfolio's May 2011 04/10/05 | pag. 33 33
  • 33.
    UNESCO Believing that OER can widen access to quality education, particularly when shared by many countries and higher education institutions, UNESCO champions OER as a means of promoting access, equity and quality in the spirit of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights.
  • 35.
  • 36.
  • 37.
    cnx.org Frederik Questier Werken met portfolio's May 2011 04/10/05 | pag. 39 39
  • 40.
  • 41.
  • 42.
  • 45.
    Does your VLElook like this to the outside world? Frederik Questier Werken met portfolio's May 2011 04/10/05 | pag. 47 47
  • 46.
    Closed? ➢ The few good reasons for closing an LMS, are probably the reasons why the LMS is not dead yet... ➢ Copyright exemptions for education ➢ Privacy ➢ for minors ➢ for making mistakes ➢ for teachers? 48
  • 47.
    But all therest should be open! 49
  • 48.
    Open ➢ Open Source ➢ Open Standards ➢ Open Courseware ➢ (OpenID) ➢ Sharing students and teachers between VLEs ➢ + Portability ➢ Enable instutional collaboration ➢ (Open Framework) ➢ Sharing apps between VLEs 50
  • 49.
    These generic repositoriesin Chamilo 2.0 are nice Frederik Questier Werken met portfolio's May 2011 04/10/05 | pag. 51 51
  • 50.
    Specialized learning object repositories are nicer! S. Ternier et al., Interoperability for Searching Learning Object Repositories: The ProLearn Query Language, D-Lib Magazine, 2008, Volume 14 Number 1/2, doi:10.1045/january2008-ceri 52
  • 51.
    Let's avoid the empty box feeling! 53
  • 52.
    But content isno longer king! 54
  • 53.
    What is goodlearning? Jonassen's Model for (constructive) learning environments 55
  • 54.
    wikibooks.org Frederik Questier Werken met portfolio's May 2011 04/10/05 | pag. 56 56
  • 55.
    Example made withmy students nl.wikibooks.org/wiki/Onderwijstechnologie Frederik Questier Werken met portfolio's May 2011 04/10/05 | pag. 57 57
  • 58.
    Student portfolios Experiences with open publication and student defined access control Extra motivating Copyright! Privacy of patients etc Student awareness needed! Block search engines through robots.txt ;)
  • 59.
    I'GLO Students create Interaction Generating Learning Objects research project Artesis Hogeschool
  • 60.
    OER Barriers? ➢ Awareness ➢ Teachers attitude ➢ Not enough OER yet ➢ Copyright ➢ Limitations of LMS? (licenses, access control) ➢ Funding ➢ Institutional policy ➢ ?
  • 61.
    DARE TO SHARE Copyleft Frederik Questier, Vrije Universiteit Brussel 63
  • 62.
    Que stio Tha ns? n ks !
  • 63.
    Credits ➢ Open Neon light CC by-nc-nd-by by “late night movie” [Mart] ➢ T-Shirt “Best things are life are free” by http://zazzle.com ➢ Lady Justitia CC by-nc-nd By lumierefl (Flickr) ➢ “Sorry. We're closed” CC by-nc by Tommaso Galli ➢ OPEN, CC-by-nc-sa by Tom Magliery ➢ Empty box, CC by-nc-nd by Mike Bitzenhofer ➢ Share matches CC by-nc-nd by Josh Harper ➢ Question mark CC by by Stefan Baudy